Andrew Smith's Reviews > Sea of Tranquility

Sea of Tranquility by Emily St. John Mandel
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5885760
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: science-fiction, netgalley, time-travel

In the author’s last novel The Glass Hotel we were introduced to Vincent and her half-brother Paul and we learned of a link to a Ponzi Scheme which was to have tragic consequences. Well, we are to meet them again here. It’s not clear to what extent their back story is a pivotal element but this is one of the quirky and interesting things about Mandel’s books: she sets about things in a slightly different way to other writers I’ve come across, teasing and surprising in equal measure.

In addition to the continuing discoveries regarding Vincent and Paul we are also taken back in time to a Vancouver forest and forward to time to when lunar colonies are in place. Each segment offers up sight of a slightly puzzling event. How are these individual moments in time linked, and is there a broader significance? It’s clear from the far future view that pandemics and global warming have, to some extent, driven development and exploration. There’s a lot at play here and we haven’t even gotten to the time travel element yet.

If the first half of the book is a slow scene setter then the second half offers much more in terms of both pace and discovery. Aficionados of time travel tales will spot some of the usual tropes, but (as a reader of many such tales) I believe there’s definitely something new here, a different puzzle to solve. Mandel eschews the need for detailed breakdowns of how it’s all done, preferring instead to focus on the bigger picture and on the plight of the characters she’s introduced us to. I found this approach refreshing, I must admit. It’s a relatively short book, coming in at under three hundred pages, but there’s a good deal packed in.

If I have a grumble, it’s that I’d have liked some of the characters to have been fleshed out a little more and I thought some of the transitions in the second half of the book felt a little rushed - for instance, at one point a major character takes a controversial and determining action, seemingly without any forethought. But these are minor quibbles as I believe that once again Mandel has produced a thoughtful and compulsively readable story, one that certainly ticked a lot of boxes for me.

As a final thought, if you haven’t read The Glass Hotel don’t worry, this one works just fine as a stand-alone piece.

My thanks to Pan Macmillan, Picador for providing a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
147 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Sea of Tranquility.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 25, 2022 – Started Reading
February 25, 2022 – Shelved
February 25, 2022 – Shelved as: science-fiction
February 25, 2022 – Shelved as: netgalley
February 28, 2022 – Shelved as: time-travel
March 3, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jeanne Can’t wait to see what you think.


message 2: by Andrew (last edited Feb 25, 2022 07:25AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Andrew Smith Jeanne wrote: "Can’t wait to see what you think."

Jeanne - I’ve just started it today, but I’m loving it already. I’ve just recognised a character (Vincent) from her last book The Glass Hotel, and it that book I recognised a couple of characters from another of her books, Station Eleven. Mandel does like to tease with these carry over characters. I’m not big into blurbs (I avoid them most of the time) so I don’t know if Vincent is going to be a significant character here. Intriguing…


message 3: by Carol (new)

Carol I hope you are liking this novel, Andrew. I loved The Glass Hotel..


Andrew Smith Carol wrote: "I hope you are liking this novel, Andrew. I loved The Glass Hotel.."

Carol - I loved that one too. And it seems there is some crossover as there is certainly another view in the early part of this book of a thread covered in The Glass Hotel. It’s started really well.


message 5: by Bill (new)

Bill Thanks, Andrew for your nice review. I will definitely get this one.


Andrew Smith Bill wrote: "Thanks, Andrew for your nice review. I will definitely get this one."

Many thanks, Bill. I really hope you enjoy it 👍


message 7: by Andrew (last edited Mar 04, 2022 02:00PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Andrew Smith Elyse wrote: "Good review Andrew -- I hope I don't get confused -- I'm already forgetting some of her last book --should I do a quick skim-read?
I like Emily S. John Mandel -- (not a book I haven't read of hers)..."


Elyse - I found the first half a little too slow and the second half a little too fast. But I still admire Emily’s ability to tell a story. Like you, I’ve read all of her books - I don’t see this as her best (always Station Eleven for me) or her worst (definitely the Lola Quartet, the only one I wasn’t too keen on).

I hadn’t realised carry over characters would appear (though she also pulled this trick in The Glass House, albeit with non consequential characters from Station Eleven). She drops a big clue re Vincent in this one - you wouldn’t miss it - and at that point I went back and re-read my review and a couple of others just to refresh my memory of who she was. But in truth, although reminding yourself who she and Paul are might marginally enrich your reading experience, I do think it will be marginal. This book works perfectly well if you’ve never come across them before.

It’s a clever book and I do love time travel stories, which helps. But are some characters a little sketchy? Are some obstacles deliberately overlooked? Maybe. Probably. I look forward to your thoughts on it :))

Haven’t read any Tana French - I should probably look her up xo


message 8: by JanB (new) - added it

JanB The Glass Hotel was in my top favorites and this is on my list. But I decided to borrow it from the library instead of requesting an ARC, as her books are hit or miss for me. I appreciate your thoughts. Great review Andrew!


Andrew Smith Thanks, Jan :))

I’ll be interested to hear what you think
of this one. It’s different again, as is her tendency. But she’s such a great storyteller most of her books really work for me.


Lisa (NY) Excellent review - I'm a big fan of Mandel and look forward to this.


Andrew Smith Lisa wrote: "Excellent review - I'm a big fan of Mandel and look forward to this."

Thanks, Lisa. I’m a big fan too and eagerly await anything she releases. I do love the fact that she’s able to write different types of story. Very clever.


Richard (on hiatus) Interesting review Andrew ……… loved The Glass Hotel and looking forward to this one :)


Andrew Smith Richard (on hiatus) wrote: "Interesting review Andrew ……… loved The Glass Hotel and looking forward to this one :)"

Richard - I look forward to your thoughts on this one. I’m not sure it’s her best but even when she’s not on top form I still feel that Mandel remains in to top quartile of writers today.


message 14: by Fran (new)

Fran Wonderful review, Andrew. Glad you enjoyed! 👍


Andrew Smith Fran wrote: "Wonderful review, Andrew. Glad you enjoyed! 👍"

Many thanks, Fran 😁


Andrew Smith Beth wrote: "Should I read Station Eleven and Glass Hotel first, or does each book stand alone? Not really a series, right?"

Beth - yes, definitely not a series & these books can be read in any order. The reference to characters from Station Eleven in Glass Hotel are hard to spot (I missed them and had to have them pointed out by another reader). It’s just a quirky thing she did. The repeat characters in this one from Glass Hotel are to some extent a small expansion on their story, but it won’t matter which order you read these books. Enjoy!


message 17: by L.A. (new) - added it

L.A. Excellent review, Andrew!


Andrew Smith Many thanks, L.A. 🙏


Vincent Raimondi what do you think of the book?? do you recommend?


Andrew Smith Vincent wrote: "what do you think of the book?? do you recommend?"

Vincent - I liked the book. I really enjoy reading pretty much anything this author writes, I find her interesting and I think she’s a great storyteller. This might not be her very best book, but it’s still pretty good, in my view.


Lisa (NY) Wonderful review - just finished and found it quite satisfying.


Andrew Smith Lisa - Many thanks and glad you enjoyed it. I always look forward so much to any new novel released by Emily M.


message 23: by Brian (new) - added it

Brian Deegan I have this on my list, glad to hear I don't need to read The glass hotel first :)


Andrew Smith You'll be fine reading this one as a standalone, Brian. Hope you enjoy it! 📖


back to top