Michelle F's Reviews > Strange Practice
Strange Practice (Dr. Greta Helsing, #1)
by
by
Michelle F's review
bookshelves: books-about-books, fantasy, location-literature, mystery, reviewed
Apr 17, 2022
bookshelves: books-about-books, fantasy, location-literature, mystery, reviewed
I tend to associate “beach read” with suspense/thriller novels, and I feel as though I need an equivalent term for the Urban Fantasy genre. I'm taking suggestions! For me they are those books that are exciting and gripping but ultimately ubiquitous. Not bad at all, just utterly forgettable.
With all that preamble, the good news about Strange Practice is that a few things elevated it just out of that category of entertainment for me:
-Greta Helsing is a doctor to the undead. This is a variation of the (fun but) common UF/detective riff that adds a fresh new flavour that I quite liked. I would gladly read a whole series of short novels just about the job itself, even without a dark sinister over-plot.
-Even though this book has a dark sinister over-plot, it seemed to me that Shaw made some effort, within the action, to show me who her characters are when they are at home. I could have done with more of it, but I felt like she worked it in fairly skillfully.
-Greta has potential, I think, but she has not hit her stride yet. Luckily and surprisingly, Strange Practice has an ensemble cast. The shifting points of view add interest and allow for an expanded view of Shaw's worldbuilding...
-...which I thought was pretty great. Digging deeper than your standard vampires, there is a ton of potential with all the creatures and the society that keeps them secret. And even with the vampires the author has created different 'types', which I thought was a nice touch.
Without doubt there are things that didn't impress me. Most frustrating were some unconvincing connecting threads in the story's big mystery. Nothing was polished quite as nicely as it could have been, and as I peruse other reviews I am identifying with much of the criticism.
After a bit of time away from it however, it is the fun stuff that stands out in my memory. That and a few surprising stylistic choices make me want to see how this trilogy plays out.
(still, this is a 'rounded up' rating. It's not quite a solid four stars on its own.)
With all that preamble, the good news about Strange Practice is that a few things elevated it just out of that category of entertainment for me:
-Greta Helsing is a doctor to the undead. This is a variation of the (fun but) common UF/detective riff that adds a fresh new flavour that I quite liked. I would gladly read a whole series of short novels just about the job itself, even without a dark sinister over-plot.
-Even though this book has a dark sinister over-plot, it seemed to me that Shaw made some effort, within the action, to show me who her characters are when they are at home. I could have done with more of it, but I felt like she worked it in fairly skillfully.
-Greta has potential, I think, but she has not hit her stride yet. Luckily and surprisingly, Strange Practice has an ensemble cast. The shifting points of view add interest and allow for an expanded view of Shaw's worldbuilding...
-...which I thought was pretty great. Digging deeper than your standard vampires, there is a ton of potential with all the creatures and the society that keeps them secret. And even with the vampires the author has created different 'types', which I thought was a nice touch.
Without doubt there are things that didn't impress me. Most frustrating were some unconvincing connecting threads in the story's big mystery. Nothing was polished quite as nicely as it could have been, and as I peruse other reviews I am identifying with much of the criticism.
After a bit of time away from it however, it is the fun stuff that stands out in my memory. That and a few surprising stylistic choices make me want to see how this trilogy plays out.
(still, this is a 'rounded up' rating. It's not quite a solid four stars on its own.)
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Strange Practice.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
August 15, 2018
– Shelved
(Kindle Edition)
December, 2021
–
Started Reading
December, 2021
–
Finished Reading
April 17, 2022
– Shelved
Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Margaret M - (too far behind to catch up
(new)
Apr 18, 2022 04:25AM
Excellent review Michelle 🌺
reply
|
flag
Great review Michelle! :) Glad you enjoyed this despite the story not polishing up things the way it should have.
Serge wrote: "Great review Michelle! :) Glad you enjoyed this despite the story not polishing up things the way it should have."
Thanks, Serge! It’s a nice diversion. I will likely check out the rest of the series :)
Thanks, Serge! It’s a nice diversion. I will likely check out the rest of the series :)
Paul wrote: "I reckon "Jaws" would be the best beach read."
Indeed! Then you’ll only need one, because you’ll never want to go back!
Indeed! Then you’ll only need one, because you’ll never want to go back!