Nancy's Reviews > Wild: From Lost to Found on the Pacific Crest Trail

Wild by Cheryl Strayed
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1882126
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: bio-memoir

In some reviews, Strayed has been criticized for a number of things. Unpreparedness for the Pacific Crest Trail, risky decisions and miscalculations, as well as reckless living - poor choices in coping with a broken life. Her real father was unstable, abusive and essentially absent. Her mother was quirky. She couldn't provide the basic material comforts of the middle class. On the other hand, her unconventional behaviors are exactly what gave Cheryl her independent, survivor spirit. Her mother died in her mid-forties and the threads of what little family Cheryl had disintegrated. Married to a perfectly good man, but wed very young, in her grief, she eventually resorted to heroine abuse and promiscuity.

I think those readers are missing the point. This is not a how-to book. Although there are some brief informative sections about the history and development of the PCT, as well as fleeting references to equipment. It is not a back to nature book. She writes picturesque but unsentimental descriptions. It is not a self-help book. She's not espousing any means to self discovery. It is a eloquent story of how one rather mixed up young woman used this journey. Alone, she is able to dig deep into her past and her fears. There comes a point in everyone's life when we have to forgive our own mistakes and accept how they define us. The struggles along the trail gave her the strength and clarity to face who she really is and what she is capable of. It resonated with me. After having taken a road trip in the mid 70's, from Minneapolis, to Whitehorse Yukon Territories, back through Edmonton, across the Rockies to Vancouver and down Route 1 to San Diego before going home. The experiences most definitely frame who I am.
345 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Wild.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 19, 2012 – Started Reading
December 19, 2012 – Shelved
December 19, 2012 –
11.0%
December 28, 2012 –
35.0%
December 31, 2012 –
43.0%
January 4, 2013 –
56.0%
January 5, 2013 –
81.0%
January 6, 2013 – Shelved as: bio-memoir
January 6, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Michael Nice review. Like your capture of of the "what" for the book: "It is a eloquent story of how one rather mixed up young woman used this journey. Alone, she is able to dig deep into her past and her fears."

To me, that sounds a lot like Matthiessen's The Snow Leopard in which his exterior journey in the Himalayas served as a means for an interior journey. I like the approach of aligning the two worlds.


message 2: by Sheila (new) - added it

Sheila Great review, Nancy. This one is on my mental to-read list.


Nancy Thanks Michael and Sheila. It was worth my time.


Amanda Thank you! Some of the criticism about this book really bothers me. Cheryl clearly admits that her life is spinning out of control.


Nancy Totally agree Amanda. I get frustrated with critiques of memoirs that seem to negate the persons story for judgments sake.


Casey, with a book Yes! You took the words out of my mouth.


Zeep92 So true, I don't fully understand the logic behind giving a book a bad review because you don't understand or agree with the life choices of the author!


message 8: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Thomas such angry people!


Chantal So thankful to read your review. This is not a hiking book. It is about self-discovery and redemption.


Nancy Chantal wrote: "So thankful to read your review. This is not a hiking book. It is about self-discovery and redemption." Indeed! I don't understand judgmental reviews in regards to someone's personal journey!


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Thanks for your review. I think people need to give her a break! I made a lot of mistakes in my 20s and I wasn't grieving a mother who died too young. You'd think people would be more understanding, but whatever. I really liked the book.


Nancy Thanks Lisa - totally agree! I thought the movie was pretty good too. You can never condense a book into 2-2.5 hours, but I enjoyed it.


Jenny I loved the authors honesty and vulnerability.Maybe I liked it because I identified with her and maybe others don't because they have never been on a similar spiritual quest. I don't know. Its like some of the reviews of eat pray love - which i also enjoyed.


Nancy Thanks for the "like" Jenny. I also enjoyed Eat Pray Love and really liked the movie. I know the author generated some controversy, but that's another case where I don't really care and won't judge. I would love to learn better meditation practices but slowing down my brain is indeed a challenge!!


Susan Yes! I'm not even finished with the book yet, but I was curious as to what others thought, and dismayed to find scathing and negative reviews. I think her writing is compelling - straightforward and engaging. She seems very transparent about who she was/is and her experiences, not hyperbolic (which is my personal irritant). You're exactly right about what this book is and isn't, and for what it is, at this point I'd give it 5 stars. I'll wait til I finish though :)


message 16: by Nancy (last edited Apr 21, 2017 02:38PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nancy Susan wrote: "Yes! I'm not even finished with the book yet, but I was curious as to what others thought, and dismayed to find scathing and negative reviews. I think her writing is compelling - straightforward an..."

I'm so glad you're enjoying it Susan. You can't fault her writing, so why would any want to rip apart her honesty and as you said - transparency? I'm not one to judge other people that way. She understands the mistakes she made, but she also had incredible coping skills. And if one follows anything about the woman she has become - it is a remarkable transformation.


message 17: by S. (new) - rated it 5 stars

S. Roit I know it's an older review but so agree. It's not a how to. It's raw and real, a personal journey.


Nancy Thank you Sherry.


Evelyn Cheryl's transparency made the book for me. I was at a place in life where I felt completely fucked up. Like I hadn't done anything right. And at least once a chapter I would think to myself "well at least I haven't done heroin!" or "If Cheryl could handle her crazy fucked up baggage, then I can handle mine." I won't say it absolutely changed my life, but I came out of the book with some perspective.


Nancy I'm kicking myself because Stayed was in town giving a talk and had I known I would have tried to get out of a conflict. I would have loved to have heard her speak.


message 21: by Grace (new) - added it

Grace P I completely agree. Thank you for this. I didn't read reviews before the book, and am shocked to find so many negative reviews on here. I don't understand people's useless judgments of her -- she was in her early 20s, traumatized, and freely admits that she *also* doesn't think she did anything perfectly, or even well. What is the point of the judgment? She lost absolutely everything in her life. She had nowhere to turn. Realistically, if she had faced someone judging her choices back then, that only would have hindered her. Learn how to love, people, or don't read memoirs.


Nancy Well said Grace. I think people who sometimes are critical of her missteps and journey just do it for reasons of their own personal power. And you’re right. Judgment wouldn’t have helped. We are all flawed human beings. Love your final statement!!


message 23: by Miriam (new)

Miriam Holder Agree with Nancy. Excellent book.


message 24: by Byron (new) - added it

Byron I disagree. It is a self-help book. She’s describing her experience, her journey, and how the PCT trail helped her overcome her fears and figure out her life. It’s as self-help as they come.


Allie Riley Excellent review!


Nancy Allie wrote: "Excellent review!"Thank you Alie!


back to top