JanB's Reviews > My Murder
My Murder
by
by
I was completely invested in this one until the reveal at the end....
Can't say much without spoilers....but it was one of the worst endings I've come across.
FYI: Goodreads lists this as a mystery/thriller, but it is not. I like to check edelweiss for the proper genre, which lists this as women's fiction, which I think is correct.
Now that I've settled down, I'll jot down a few thoughts...
This was such an intriguing premise: the setting is the future, and women whose lives were cut short by a serial murderer are brought back to life through cloning. The women know they are clones and experience short term memory loss, including forgetting their murder. The women meet weekly in a support group.
The story is narrated by Lou (Louise), who is a wife and mother of a 9 mo old daughter. Meanwhile, a video game is produced that makes a game of her murder. While this is gruesome, I think it was meant to portray the public's fascination with true crime.
Lou also bans together with a group of amateur detectives who investigates cold cases. We know from the beginning that her murderer has been caught, but there are questions that arise, and Lou goes in search of answers. We, along with Lou, begin to question just who she can trust.
I really enjoyed the world building, especially the cloning and the emotional effects on the cloned women, as well as the futuristic world. I was invested in finding out just what happened to Lou, and then we come to the end and all questions are answered. Which ruined the entire book for me.
I felt the author jerked the reader around for the entire book only to pull out an ending out of her hat like a magic trick.
Can't say much without spoilers....but it was one of the worst endings I've come across.
FYI: Goodreads lists this as a mystery/thriller, but it is not. I like to check edelweiss for the proper genre, which lists this as women's fiction, which I think is correct.
Now that I've settled down, I'll jot down a few thoughts...
This was such an intriguing premise: the setting is the future, and women whose lives were cut short by a serial murderer are brought back to life through cloning. The women know they are clones and experience short term memory loss, including forgetting their murder. The women meet weekly in a support group.
The story is narrated by Lou (Louise), who is a wife and mother of a 9 mo old daughter. Meanwhile, a video game is produced that makes a game of her murder. While this is gruesome, I think it was meant to portray the public's fascination with true crime.
Lou also bans together with a group of amateur detectives who investigates cold cases. We know from the beginning that her murderer has been caught, but there are questions that arise, and Lou goes in search of answers. We, along with Lou, begin to question just who she can trust.
I really enjoyed the world building, especially the cloning and the emotional effects on the cloned women, as well as the futuristic world. I was invested in finding out just what happened to Lou, and then we come to the end and all questions are answered. Which ruined the entire book for me.
I felt the author jerked the reader around for the entire book only to pull out an ending out of her hat like a magic trick.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
My Murder.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 26, 2023
–
Started Reading
July 26, 2023
– Shelved
July 26, 2023
– Shelved as:
2023-reads
July 26, 2023
– Shelved as:
buddy-read-with-marialyce
July 26, 2023
– Shelved as:
audiobook
July 27, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 73 (73 new)
message 1:
by
Alli
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Jul 27, 2023 05:05PM
Looking forward to your review! I have this one in my queue. ☺️
reply
|
flag
Alli wrote: "Looking forward to your review! I have this one in my queue. ☺️"
I hope you have better luck that I did. I loved it until the reveal
I hope you have better luck that I did. I loved it until the reveal
Cynthia wrote: "Yeah, I was not a fan, either, Jan!"
You said it perfectly Cynthia! The reveal ruined the book
You said it perfectly Cynthia! The reveal ruined the book
Sorry that the ending spoiled this book for you! That’s terrible to read the whole book only to be disappointed by the ending! I hope you next read is a total winner.
Oh my... I want to read this now just to see what the ending is 😃. Edit to add: I just placed a hold and didn't even read what it's about😅
Great review Jan! That really stinks when the ending of a book ruins the whole thing. Hope your next one is awesome!
Carol wrote: "Ugh, a horrible ending is the worst! I hope your next read is a million times better, Jan ❤️🥰!!!!"
Thanks Carol, it really is, after investing so much time, I feel cheated!
Thanks Carol, it really is, after investing so much time, I feel cheated!
Marilyn wrote: "Sorry that the ending spoiled this book for you! That’s terrible to read the whole book only to be disappointed by the ending! I hope you next read is a total winner."
Thanks so much Marilyn! I can usually forgive an ending but this was so egregious I just couldn't
Thanks so much Marilyn! I can usually forgive an ending but this was so egregious I just couldn't
Jayme wrote: "Oh no! It didn’t bother me! Sorry it ruined it for you! 💞"
Thanks Jayme, I'm glad you enjoyed
Thanks Jayme, I'm glad you enjoyed
Tina wrote: "That's really too bad about the ending Jan. Sorry to hear it disappointed you!!"
Thanks so much Tina!
Thanks so much Tina!
Jenna wrote: "Oh my... I want to read this now just to see what the ending is 😃. Edit to add: I just placed a hold and didn't even read what it's about😅"
haha....I'd love to discuss that ending with you lol. Apparently I'm an outlier...no big surprise!
haha....I'd love to discuss that ending with you lol. Apparently I'm an outlier...no big surprise!
JaymeO wrote: "Lol Jan! I loved the ending! Totally unexpected! Sorry it didn’t work for you!"
It was definitely unexpected, but not in a good way for me, lol
I'm glad you enjoyed it!
It was definitely unexpected, but not in a good way for me, lol
I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Suzy wrote: "Great review Jan! That really stinks when the ending of a book ruins the whole thing. Hope your next one is awesome!"
Luckily it wasn't an overly long book 😉
Thanks Suzy!
Luckily it wasn't an overly long book 😉
Thanks Suzy!
Holly wrote: "Well, one of the worst endings ever is pretty bad! 😂"
it obviously annoyed the heck out of me 😂
it obviously annoyed the heck out of me 😂
I’m so glad I didn’t put this book on hold at the library. That’s one less book I need to worry about. Lol!!
I was surprised by the ending in that I just didn't think it would go that way. It's hard to talk about the book without spoiling things though. 🤐
Oh, no Jan. After investing in a book only to go off the cliff at the end. Avoiding this one for sure. ;)
message 31:
by
Bec (becbingesbooks) - sorry, behind with lots of catching up to do
(new)
Rachel wrote: "I’m so glad I didn’t put this book on hold at the library. That’s one less book I need to worry about. Lol!!"
haha, happy to help Rachel! I was expecting a mystery/thriller and it was not.
haha, happy to help Rachel! I was expecting a mystery/thriller and it was not.
MarilynW wrote: "I was surprised by the ending in that I just didn't think it would go that way. It's hard to talk about the book without spoiling things though. 🤐"
there's no way we could have predicted it because there were zero bread crumbs! Ugh, so annoying, lol
there's no way we could have predicted it because there were zero bread crumbs! Ugh, so annoying, lol
Linda wrote: "Oh, no Jan. After investing in a book only to go off the cliff at the end. Avoiding this one for sure. ;)"
It definitely nose-dived off that cliff lol.
Thanks Linda!
It definitely nose-dived off that cliff lol.
Thanks Linda!
Julie wrote: "I hate it when that happens! Very frustrating. I hope your next book makes up for it 💖"
Thanks so much Julie!
Thanks so much Julie!
Margaret M - wrote: "Thanks for the honesty as always Jan 💖 I hope you enjoy your next one more"
Thanks Margaret!
Thanks Margaret!
Bec (becbingesbooks) wrote: "Oh I'm so intrigued about that ending and what made it so bad!!!! Think I'll pass"
haha...and I'd love to vent about it!
haha...and I'd love to vent about it!
Alli wrote: "I have this one in my queue but maybe I’ll skip it. Great review, Jan!"
just don't go in expecting a typical mystery/thriller and be prepared for an ending that is just strange to say the least. lol
Thanks Alli!
just don't go in expecting a typical mystery/thriller and be prepared for an ending that is just strange to say the least. lol
Thanks Alli!
Karen wrote: "Thank you Jan. I had so much trouble with this book, too! Wonderful honest review!"
I loved your last line in your review....we still have a mystery to unravel...oh yes we do! A few breadcrumbs would have been nice, as would categorizing this into the proper genre!
Thanks Karen
I loved your last line in your review....we still have a mystery to unravel...oh yes we do! A few breadcrumbs would have been nice, as would categorizing this into the proper genre!
Thanks Karen
Wow, sorry to hear that happened Jan. Reminds me of the movie The Departed....loved it until the ending where it took a turn that I felt they didn't know what else to do and that I wasted a few hours of my life I could have been reading a book. Ha! On to better reads for you!
PorshaJo wrote: "Wow, sorry to hear that happened Jan. Reminds me of the movie The Departed....loved it until the ending where it took a turn that I felt they didn't know what else to do and that I wasted a few hou..."
YES!! I wasn't a fan of that movie either lol
Thanks PorshaJo!
YES!! I wasn't a fan of that movie either lol
Thanks PorshaJo!
I am curious about this one but I'll lower my expectations. Thank you for clarifying the genre! Great review!
OMG I'm reading this now (off and on)...I can't really make up my mind whether I like or not...it isn't what I expected. Maybe I should have read more reviews like your first!