Margitte's Reviews > Cutting for Stone
Cutting for Stone
by
by
Before you read this book, consider this: the book was printed with an average of 425 words per page for 541 pages in an almost minus zero font size. That jerked my chain a bit, so I did not begin reading this book in quite the right frame of mind.
But who in their right mind would like to put down a book beginning like this:
At first the book did not tickle my cor musculi really, it often rather annoyed the Musculus sphincter ani internus instead! The good thing was that the book distinctly distinguished itself from a romance novel by allocating 109 pages to the birth of the twins instead of to coitus, although it did challenge my knowledge of Latin and anatomy to the extreme. The good thing about romance novels is that they do not use Latin a thousand times to breath, whisper, huff, puff, holler and cry, "I Love You."
This book did not do it either, thank goodness, but I was holding my breath! With the intensity and detail the characters' lives, especially those of the twins, were initially colored in with Latin so lavishly splashed all over it, anything was possible! And everything pointed to a great love story in the making after all!
Yes, I was equally as impressed as I was slightly blowing steam off through my nares by being constantly dropped into the world of Latin by a surgeon (Dr.Thomas Stone) whose work was his life hiding his "social retardiness" - as expressed by his colleagues. I did not want to read a medical journal at all !
The love of Latin genetically moves forward to the next generation. Marion would as a young boy discover the magic:
The surgeon, Dr. Thomas Stone, would have disagreed. He would have insisted on Latin near, or on, any bed! That's all he really understood. And this is where I almost gave up on the book, not because it was not well written - it was in fact brilliantly prosed from the start, but because it seemed as though I needed to order a Latin dictionary first and do at least six years of medical school before I could proceed and I was just not in the mood for it! If the storyline was to be taken away, it could have been a well-texted book on practicing medicine in the tropics.
As a young boy, Marion would receive his first stethoscope from Dr.Gosh. Was there more in this gift than the eyes could see? Was he trying to teach this boy how to find the secrets behind his parents and he and his brother's birth? :
The narrative focuses mostly on the lives of the two twins in their growing up years and which events and people would structure their characters / personalities / destinies. In the end the expression comes to mind: "It is not what happens to you, but how you handle it, that counts."
The tale is an intense, well-researched, well-written novel introducing the fascinating societies of Addis Ababa - Ethopia, Madras - India, New York & Boston in the USA. The book blends African politics, people, compassion, love, fast paced adventure and fiction in such a way that all readers from all walks of life, especially hospital-story junkies, interested in this beautiful but harsh African continent, will find some aspect of the book agreeable and worth reading.
One of my favorite Mark Twain aphorisms is: "I can live for two months on a good compliment."
For me it is not a compliment but strings of words having me wonder around in sheer delirious bliss! Abraham Verghese rooted me to the book with prose like this:
Marion never wanted to sit in the twin-stroller playing with his wooden truck like his brother. Marion wanted an adult view on the world. Rosina had to constantly carry him around.
The epiphany, for me, happened here:
From then on things started to happen rapidly, the drama increased leaving the reader mesmerized and in complete wonder!
The story was brilliantly constructed, although it could have been a 100 pages shorter, in my opinion. There were almost an endless role of "Latinish"-like hospital scenes that leaves the impression of the author expressing opinions through a novel instead of getting his ideas published elsewhere. I was surprised, when thinking back on the role of each person in the narrative, how each one of them made an amazing contribution to the story! The characters was well developed; the denouement at the end of all the elements a huge surprise. The story completes a full unbelievable circle, which really had me sitting back in total amazement. The end left me breathless....and yes speechless...! And when I started recounting all the elements in the book I was amazed at the unusual brilliant tale it was.
A Great read!
But who in their right mind would like to put down a book beginning like this:
"My brother, Shiva, and I came into the world in the late afternoon of the twentieth of September in the year of Grace 1954. We took our first breath in the thin air, 8 000 feet above sea level, of the capital city of Ethiopia, Addis Ababa."The twins, Drs. Marion , and Shiva Praise Stone, were born to a nun, Sister Mary Joseph Praise from the Carmalite Order of Madras, who were sent with Sister Anjali to darkest Africa to serve in hospitals. She would end up at the "Missing"(Mission) hospital of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, via Aden in Yemen, with a dark secret she cold never share.
"Bound by birth, we were driven apart by bitter betrayal. No surgeon can heal the wound that divides two brothers. Where silk and steel fail, story must succeed."
"Sister Mary Joseph was a Malayali Christian. She could trace her faith back to St. Thomas's arrival in India from Damascus in A.D. 52. "Doubting" Thomas built his first churches in Karala well before St. Peter got to Rome."In the first 109 pages the background to the birth is introduced and when the birth finally takes place with high drama, I sighed with relief. Pardon my momental snarkyness, but I almost put down the book and moved on.
"To her parents' chagrin, my mother became a Carmalite none,abandoning the ancient Syrian Christian tradition of St. Thomas to embrace (in her parents view) this Johnny-come-lately, pope-worshipping sect... It was a good thing her parents didn't know that she was also a nurse, which to them would mean that she soiled her hands like an untouchable."
At first the book did not tickle my cor musculi really, it often rather annoyed the Musculus sphincter ani internus instead! The good thing was that the book distinctly distinguished itself from a romance novel by allocating 109 pages to the birth of the twins instead of to coitus, although it did challenge my knowledge of Latin and anatomy to the extreme. The good thing about romance novels is that they do not use Latin a thousand times to breath, whisper, huff, puff, holler and cry, "I Love You."
This book did not do it either, thank goodness, but I was holding my breath! With the intensity and detail the characters' lives, especially those of the twins, were initially colored in with Latin so lavishly splashed all over it, anything was possible! And everything pointed to a great love story in the making after all!
Yes, I was equally as impressed as I was slightly blowing steam off through my nares by being constantly dropped into the world of Latin by a surgeon (Dr.Thomas Stone) whose work was his life hiding his "social retardiness" - as expressed by his colleagues. I did not want to read a medical journal at all !
The love of Latin genetically moves forward to the next generation. Marion would as a young boy discover the magic:
"I loved those Latin words for their dignity, their foreigness and that my tongue had to wrap around them. I felt that in learning the special language of a scholarly order, I was amassing a kind of force. This was the poor and noble side of the world, uncorrupted by secrets and trickery."Dr. Gosh was of the opinion that the language of love and medicine was the same "Take off your shirt. Open your mouth. Take a deep breath.".
The surgeon, Dr. Thomas Stone, would have disagreed. He would have insisted on Latin near, or on, any bed! That's all he really understood. And this is where I almost gave up on the book, not because it was not well written - it was in fact brilliantly prosed from the start, but because it seemed as though I needed to order a Latin dictionary first and do at least six years of medical school before I could proceed and I was just not in the mood for it! If the storyline was to be taken away, it could have been a well-texted book on practicing medicine in the tropics.
As a young boy, Marion would receive his first stethoscope from Dr.Gosh. Was there more in this gift than the eyes could see? Was he trying to teach this boy how to find the secrets behind his parents and he and his brother's birth? :
"He invited me into a world that was not secret, but it was well hidden. You needed a guide. You had to know what to look for, but also how to look. You had to exert yourself to see this world. But if you did, if you had that kind of curiosity, if you had an innate interest in the welfare of your fellow human beings, and if you went through that door, a strange thing happened: you left your petty troubles on the threshold. It could be addictive."It is exactly the reason why I just could not put the bloody book down, for, believe me, bloody it was! Buckets full of it!
The narrative focuses mostly on the lives of the two twins in their growing up years and which events and people would structure their characters / personalities / destinies. In the end the expression comes to mind: "It is not what happens to you, but how you handle it, that counts."
The tale is an intense, well-researched, well-written novel introducing the fascinating societies of Addis Ababa - Ethopia, Madras - India, New York & Boston in the USA. The book blends African politics, people, compassion, love, fast paced adventure and fiction in such a way that all readers from all walks of life, especially hospital-story junkies, interested in this beautiful but harsh African continent, will find some aspect of the book agreeable and worth reading.
One of my favorite Mark Twain aphorisms is: "I can live for two months on a good compliment."
For me it is not a compliment but strings of words having me wonder around in sheer delirious bliss! Abraham Verghese rooted me to the book with prose like this:
"There was three spaced knocks on the door of Matron's office. "Come in," Matron said,and with those words Missing was on a course different than anyone could have imagined. It was at the start of the rainy season, when Addis was stunned into wet submission."There are sweet anecdotal moments such as this: Dr. Marion Praise Stone, the narrator, recounts a moment in their childhood:
"In our household, you had to dive into the din and push to the front if you wanted to be heard. The foghorn voice was Ghosh's, echoing and tailing off into laughter. Hema was the songbird, but when provoked her voice was as sharp as Saladin's scimitar,which, according to my Richard the Lion Hearted and the Crusades, could divide a silk scarf allowed to float down onto the blade's edge. Almaz, our cook, may have been silent on the outside, but her lips moved constantly, whether in prayer or song,no one knew. Rosina took silence as a personal offense, and spoke into empty rooms and chattered into cupboards. Genet, almost six years old of age, was showing signs of taking after her mother, telling herself stories about herself in a singsong voice, creating her own mythology."Initially there is a deceitful tranquility present in the rhythm of the prose. The author used an ingenious method to pacify the reader while having an addictive mixture of tension and drama bubbling and boiling underneath.
Marion never wanted to sit in the twin-stroller playing with his wooden truck like his brother. Marion wanted an adult view on the world. Rosina had to constantly carry him around.
The epiphany, for me, happened here:
P.184: "...the kitchen was alive. Steam rises in plumes as Almaz clangs lids on and off the pots. The silver weight on the pressure cooker jiggles and whistles. Almaze's sure hands chop onions, tomatoes, and fresh coriander, making hillocks that dwarf the tiny mounds of ginger and garlic. ... A mad alchemist she throws a pinch of this, a fistful of that, then wets her fingers and flings that moisture into the mortar. She pounds with the pestle, the wet, crunchy thunk thunk soon changes to the sound of stone on stone.This scene above acted as a metaphor for this book: so seemingly uncomplicated, innocent and serene on the surface, but exploding with energy under the lid! What was hidden in the mixture would ultimately add meaning and definition, like exquisite aromas from a pot-pourri of herbs and spices to the people's lives. The experience will be hot and penetrating; sweet and scrumptious, heavy and often "indigestably" cruel.
...Mustard seeds explode in the hot oil. She holds a lid over the pan to fend off the missiles. Rat-a-tat! like hail on the tin roof. She adds the cumin seeds, which sizzles, darken and crackle. A dry, fragrant smoke chases out the mustard scent. Only then are the onions added, handfuls of them, and now the sound is that of life being spawned in a primordial fire.
Rosina abruptly hands me over to Almaz... I whimper on Almaz's shoulder, perilously close to the bubbling cauldrons. Almaz puts down the laddle and shifts me to her hip. Reaching into her blouse, grunting with effort, she fishes out her breast.
"Here it is," she says, putting it in my hands for safekeeping...Almaz, who hardly speaks, resumes stirring, humming a tune. It is as if the breast no more belongs to her than does the laddle."
From then on things started to happen rapidly, the drama increased leaving the reader mesmerized and in complete wonder!
The story was brilliantly constructed, although it could have been a 100 pages shorter, in my opinion. There were almost an endless role of "Latinish"-like hospital scenes that leaves the impression of the author expressing opinions through a novel instead of getting his ideas published elsewhere. I was surprised, when thinking back on the role of each person in the narrative, how each one of them made an amazing contribution to the story! The characters was well developed; the denouement at the end of all the elements a huge surprise. The story completes a full unbelievable circle, which really had me sitting back in total amazement. The end left me breathless....and yes speechless...! And when I started recounting all the elements in the book I was amazed at the unusual brilliant tale it was.
A Great read!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Cutting for Stone.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 2, 2013
– Shelved
July 10, 2013
–
Started Reading
July 12, 2013
–
23.04%
"Well, happy yeeehaaa, the birth of the twins is finally over. It took 109 pages and the sun to shed some light on the very moment.....I am trying my best, so stay tuned!"
page
129
July 13, 2013
–
Finished Reading
July 14, 2013
– Shelved as:
africa
July 14, 2013
– Shelved as:
african-authors
July 14, 2013
– Shelved as:
fiction
September 17, 2013
– Shelved as:
reviewed
Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Julia
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 10, 2013 09:21AM
oh, my husband is busy reading it. he says it's very good, but upsetting. he put it down the other night and grabbed a more positive book. he said he can't go to sleep with that picture in his mind. can't wait to read it. getting khaled hosseini's new book on friday, so will have to read that one first before i tackle this one.
reply
|
flag
I make sure I have humorous books stacked up beside my bed when I 'do' these kind of books otherwise I will go insane! In fact I am playing on Goodreads, organizing my books instead of reading right now. lol.
i don't read reviews before i've read the book, so i will read it later. my husband still reading this one. i'm still busy with a book - khaled is waiting patiently. only then will abraham be in my hands.
Margitte, your review has whetted my appetite for this book! But I must admit all those Latin words sound scary!!! ;)
Awww do not worry, Adite, there are a few million readers, including moi, who survived it nicely :-)
Margitte wrote: "Awww do not worry, Adite, there are a few million readers, including moi, who survived it nicely :-)"
LOL. Thank god words can't kill you!
LOL. Thank god words can't kill you!
To Tanya & Adite: I enjoyed the life story, the cultural input, the biographical part, community stories, but the hospital parts, which was in my humble opinion just too much - detail upon detail upon detail of various sorts of operations, became the gory, tedious part.
The rest was really really great! I think they should have split the story or edited out a lot of the hospital stuff. But there were other reviewers who thought THAT was the best part, so I guess it is a matter of preference and interest.
The rest was really really great! I think they should have split the story or edited out a lot of the hospital stuff. But there were other reviewers who thought THAT was the best part, so I guess it is a matter of preference and interest.
This is terrific, Margitte! You got so much out of this book and presented it to us in all its glory. Sounds like the Latin was a chore to get through, but I figure that Verghese, with a medical degree of his own, was either showing off his scholarly attainment or had forgotten how foreign it all must sound to everyone else.
If this is a representative sample of your reviews, I'm sure I'll be liking many more in the future. You write very clearly and convincingly.
If this is a representative sample of your reviews, I'm sure I'll be liking many more in the future. You write very clearly and convincingly.
Thank you so very much Steve! Yes Verghese is a professor in medicine.
I am looking forward to all your comments on my other books as well. And I will hop over to your book shelves soon as possible. Cannot wait to read yours.
I am looking forward to all your comments on my other books as well. And I will hop over to your book shelves soon as possible. Cannot wait to read yours.
my husband is almost finished with this one. he continually said it is a very difficult read and he gives up very easily if a book doesn't grip him. he is almost at the end ... so it's a good sign ... ;)
Julia wrote: "my husband is almost finished with this one. he continually said it is a very difficult read and he gives up very easily if a book doesn't grip him. he is almost at the end ... so it's a good sign ..."
It is indeed. The story is written in such a way that it forces the reader to read till the end for this surprising finale. Very well planned. Amazing. Let me know what he thought of it.
It is indeed. The story is written in such a way that it forces the reader to read till the end for this surprising finale. Very well planned. Amazing. Let me know what he thought of it.
Hmmm. I'll leave this one to read when I've got plenty of time. Took it with on holiday but never got to it and probably just as well as my holiday mush brain wouldn't have coped with all that Latin and my ADD patience wouldn't have survived a book that's about 100 pages too long. Still ... when I'm in the right mood this will be one to pick up.
Julia wrote: "he he judy, you sound like my husband. ;)"
Your hubby sounds like a great person!! (hee hee!!) :)
Your hubby sounds like a great person!! (hee hee!!) :)
Judy wrote: "Julia wrote: "he he judy, you sound like my husband. ;)"
Your hubby sounds like a great person!! (hee hee!!) :)"
;)
Your hubby sounds like a great person!! (hee hee!!) :)"
;)
Judy wrote: "Hmmm. I'll leave this one to read when I've got plenty of time. Took it with on holiday but never got to it and probably just as well as my holiday mush brain wouldn't have coped with all that Lati..."
Welcome back Judy and thanks for dropping by to comment! I actually started our making fun of the Latin, it did not really bother me too much. I just assumed they were busy with something dangerous when I did not understand what they were talking about. lolol. But it was actually not too bad.
Welcome back Judy and thanks for dropping by to comment! I actually started our making fun of the Latin, it did not really bother me too much. I just assumed they were busy with something dangerous when I did not understand what they were talking about. lolol. But it was actually not too bad.
Still Margitte, for now, I think I'll move a couple of other books to a higher place in that teetering TBR pile of mine...:) Have a great reading weekend!
Judy wrote: "Still Margitte, for now, I think I'll move a couple of other books to a higher place in that teetering TBR pile of mine...:) Have a great reading weekend!"
Join the club, lolol. I have a pile of books waiting and life is interfering way too much ! Enjoy your weekend!
Join the club, lolol. I have a pile of books waiting and life is interfering way too much ! Enjoy your weekend!
Margitte wrote: " Join the club, lolol. I hav...Enjoy your weekend"
You too! I hope to get my holiday book reviews up this weekend (I got chance to read a book a day - what a pleasure!) :)
You too! I hope to get my holiday book reviews up this weekend (I got chance to read a book a day - what a pleasure!) :)
Glad to bump into this review today, Margitte. This book has been in my radar for a long time and I don't know why I keep putting it off. You dissect themes, characters, backdrop and the profound, almost scientific, research in medicine the author must have amalgamated to write this epic with objectivity and clinical eye. Will have to get to it soon. Thanks for the great review.
What an amazing review Margitte! Unsure how I missed it up until this point but I sure am glad it was found.
Dolors wrote: "Glad to bump into this review today, Margitte. This book has been in my radar for a long time and I don't know why I keep putting it off. You dissect themes, characters, backdrop and the profound, ..."
This book grips the soul of the reader and hold it to the very end. I hope you can find time for it, Dolors. Thanks for stopping by. Always great to read your comments.
This book grips the soul of the reader and hold it to the very end. I hope you can find time for it, Dolors. Thanks for stopping by. Always great to read your comments.
Arah-Lynda wrote: "What an amazing review Margitte! Unsure how I missed it up until this point but I sure am glad it was found."
Ah Arah-Lynda, thank you so much for your kind comment. Great to see you!
Ah Arah-Lynda, thank you so much for your kind comment. Great to see you!
Sue wrote: "this has long been on my WTR list."
Thanks, Sue. It's a long read but worth it in the end.
Thanks, Sue. It's a long read but worth it in the end.
What a magnificent, wonderfully written review, Margitte. "Musculus sphincter ani internus" made me howl. First I didn't want to read this book, and by the end, you seduced me into it. Thanks.
Betsy wrote: "What a magnificent, wonderfully written review, Margitte. "Musculus sphincter ani internus" made me howl. First I didn't want to read this book, and by the end, you seduced me into it. Thanks."
Thanks Betsy. You make my day. Well yes, as far as the Latin is concerned, I discovered the magic of the language as a result of this book :-))
Thanks Betsy. You make my day. Well yes, as far as the Latin is concerned, I discovered the magic of the language as a result of this book :-))
Loved your review --- actually better than the book.
Verghese is a bit of a local celebrity as he was teaching (maybe still is) at Stanford, so lots of people had read it. It was a bookclub pick of our several years ago. I'm not sure if I was disappointed because I had such high expectations or it was just a timing issue. I was going through cancer treatment at the time and it was just too much medical stuff and too many unlikable characters.
I did think it was well-researched and I enjoyed the background on Ethiopia (a country I don't know much about). In my review, I did comment that I thought the pacing was a bit off and it could have used a bit more editing.
Verghese is a bit of a local celebrity as he was teaching (maybe still is) at Stanford, so lots of people had read it. It was a bookclub pick of our several years ago. I'm not sure if I was disappointed because I had such high expectations or it was just a timing issue. I was going through cancer treatment at the time and it was just too much medical stuff and too many unlikable characters.
I did think it was well-researched and I enjoyed the background on Ethiopia (a country I don't know much about). In my review, I did comment that I thought the pacing was a bit off and it could have used a bit more editing.
JoLene wrote: "Loved your review --- actually better than the book...."
Thanks, Jolene. Your summary of the book is very good and I agree with you. Large parts of the story were too graphic for me. It was a tough call not to put it down. And yes, it could have lost quite a few pages as a result, I would say.
Thanks, Jolene. Your summary of the book is very good and I agree with you. Large parts of the story were too graphic for me. It was a tough call not to put it down. And yes, it could have lost quite a few pages as a result, I would say.
I love this review, Margitte. It makes me regret that I couldn't make it through the Latin and finish the story.
Carol wrote: "I love this review, Margitte. It makes me regret that I couldn't make it through the Latin and finish the story."
Thanks Carol. We have to be in the right frame of mind to start a book. Sometimes it works for us on a second try, right?
Thanks Carol. We have to be in the right frame of mind to start a book. Sometimes it works for us on a second try, right?
Angela M wrote: "Great review . I loved this one too ."
Thanks, Angela. Will you write a review for it?
Thanks, Angela. Will you write a review for it?
Magitte , I won't be writing a review since its been quite a while since I read the book . I read it before I was writing reviews on a regular basis like I do now.
Angela M wrote: "Magitte , I won't be writing a review since its been quite a while since I read the book . I read it before I was writing reviews on a regular basis like I do now."
Ah okay. I did the same.
Ah okay. I did the same.
Brilliant review, thankfully I had a digital copy so I ddint have to slog through small typeset like you did. This book will stay with me for a long time
Sonja wrote: "Brilliant review, thankfully I had a digital copy so I ddint have to slog through small typeset like you did. This book will stay with me for a long time"
Thanks, Sonja. This was an amazing book, right? It made such a lasting impression.
Thanks, Sonja. This was an amazing book, right? It made such a lasting impression.
Emer wrote: "Sold!!! I love the passages you have quoted Margitte and even though my knowledge of Latin is limited at best I somehow feel that will add to the book. There is a great power in reading something t..."
I'm still recommending this book to all and sunder, Emer. In the meantime I acquired it in epub format and plan to read it again. The prose was just beautiful.
I'm still recommending this book to all and sunder, Emer. In the meantime I acquired it in epub format and plan to read it again. The prose was just beautiful.
Beautiful review, Margitte! Cutting for Stone is a favorite of mine. We read this in bookclub a few years ago and everyone loved it.