Melissa (Trying to Catch Up)'s Reviews > We Used to Live Here

We Used to Live Here by Marcus Kliewer
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
721595
's review

it was ok

I don’t feel like I read the same book as everyone else. Reminded me so much of how I felt reading House of Leaves.

This book had such an intriguing premise and I was really intrigued to see what might be happening. And for the first half, I was captivated and reading quickly. Eve and her partner Charlie flip houses and they have purchased an older property. They have recently moved in and when Charlie is out running an errand, Eve answers a knock at the door. Thomas, his wife, and their three children stand there. Thomas says he used to live in the house as a child and wants to know if he can show his family around as they are on their way to move across the country. Reluctantly, Eve allows them in, and what happens next gets more and more bizarre and frightening.

I don't mind horror fiction, but I want it to at least make a semblance of sense. There are some intriguing documents scattered throughout and I kept waiting for it all to come together. For me, it really didn't. It just kept getting stranger and stranger after the first half, and it never coalesced to make a coherent narrative for me.

This is definitely a creepy book with a very unsettling vibe throughout. I see that it's being made into a movie and I definitely got an American Horror story feel, so hopefully it will translate well to the screen.

This is billed as being like Parasite, and while I loved that move, this book is nothing like it. That movie made sense to me and this book just did not. I wanted my questions answered in a satisfactory way and they weren't. I was left with too many threads and not enough explanations.

Overall, this wasn't a very successful book for me, but it has a high average rating and lots of people loved it, so it may appeal to you, especially if you were a fan of House of Leaves.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
281 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read We Used to Live Here.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 7, 2024 – Shelved
February 7, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
June 20, 2024 – Started Reading
June 22, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 88 (88 new)


Katie T Funny, reminded me of HoL too, which I loved despite the insane format. I was thinking how nice it was to listen to via audio and not be reading upside down footnotes 😂. Sorry this one was a failure for you though!!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Katie T wrote: "Funny, reminded me of HoL too, which I loved despite the insane format. I was thinking how nice it was to listen to via audio and not be reading upside down footnotes 😂. Sorry this one was a failur..."

I just expected more from it. I wanted it to come together in a cohesive way. I do agree that it would have been better for me either as an audiobook or as a printed copy.


message 3: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim Novak (The Reading Rx) HoL is one of my favorite books ever and probably why I enjoyed this one so much!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Kim wrote: "HoL is one of my favorite books ever and probably why I enjoyed this one so much!"

Probably so! I thought that one was way too weird as well.


message 5: by Matthew (new) - added it

Matthew Dafoe O M G I have been SOOOO excited for this but now you mention house of leaves..... (go see my review.....) i am now nervous!!!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Matthew wrote: "O M G I have been SOOOO excited for this but now you mention house of leaves..... (go see my review.....) i am now nervous!!!"

Maybe you will like this. It isn't quite so confusing.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Matthew wrote: "O M G I have been SOOOO excited for this but now you mention house of leaves..... (go see my review.....) i am now nervous!!!"

Okay I take that back, I just looked at your House of Leaves review...I'm pretty sure you won't like this one either.


Debra Sorry this didn't work for you, Melissa! I hope your current book is a winner.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Debra wrote: "Sorry this didn't work for you, Melissa! I hope your current book is a winner."

Thanks Debra!


NZLisaM I felt about the same as you. I’ve been curious about House of Leaves for years, but if it’s anything like this think I’m inclined to skip it.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) NZLisaM wrote: "I felt about the same as you. I’ve been curious about House of Leaves for years, but if it’s anything like this think I’m inclined to skip it."

It's even weirder because it's written in such a strange way with words circling the page upside down, etc.


message 12: by Jayme (new)

Jayme I read an excerpt and decided to skip it! Glad I did-great review!


Kristy Riley It truly was soooo confusing. I feel like we need a prequel and sequel because I really have no idea how everything meshes together


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Jayme wrote: "I read an excerpt and decided to skip it! Glad I did-great review!"

I wish I would have, but I had major FOMO


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Kristy wrote: "It truly was soooo confusing. I feel like we need a prequel and sequel because I really have no idea how everything meshes together"

I could get behind that!


message 16: by Rosh (new)

Rosh Dang! I might just skip the book and jump straight to the Netflix adaptation. Thanks for the honest review, Melissa!


Nancy (playing catch-up) Terrific review, Melissa!


message 18: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha I liked the premise but a need a book to make sense even if it is horror. Fab review, Melissa.


Stacey 100% agreed with you on this, I felt the same way I did at the end of Lost.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Rosh (is rushing to catch up after the break!) wrote: "Dang! I might just skip the book and jump straight to the Netflix adaptation. Thanks for the honest review, Melissa!"

I'm very curious as to how they will play it.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Nancy (playing catch-up) wrote: "Terrific review, Melissa!"

Thanks Nancy!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Srivalli wrote: "I liked the premise but a need a book to make sense even if it is horror. Fab review, Melissa."
I agree Srivalli!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Stacey wrote: "100% agreed with you on this, I felt the same way I did at the end of Lost."

I agree that the end of Lost was a letdown, but I could puzzle it together mostly. This one not so much.


Presley Summers Too many plot holes. This book left me confused. I agree!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Presley wrote: "Too many plot holes. This book left me confused. I agree!"
So totally confusing!


Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - so very behind! You are right on the money as always, Melissa! I'm so relieved to read you felt this way too...I kept wanting it to make more sense than it did. Haven't read House of Leaves, but I have a feeling based on this one that I maybe should skip that too...excellent review!


Brittany Completely agree. There were so many intriguing premises introduced and I was waiting and hoping for them to be explained. It felt like a really intelligent set up was thrown away.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Brittany wrote: "Completely agree. There were so many intriguing premises introduced and I was waiting and hoping for them to be explained. It felt like a really intelligent set up was thrown away."

Yes, that's exactly it.


Bedtime Booknerd ok im so glad i am bot alone with this pov…i heard that this is a scary book but like you said theres a creepy feeling but it never really scared me lol enjoyed it nontheless


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Bedtime Booknerd wrote: "ok im so glad i am bot alone with this pov…i heard that this is a scary book but like you said theres a creepy feeling but it never really scared me lol enjoyed it nontheless"

It was definitely creepy


message 31: by Nora (new) - added it

Nora Currie So sorry that this book didn’t turn out to be scary and that it’s just creepy instead. Hope your next book is five ⭐️!


Kelli Wilson Great honest review Melissa. I very much enjoyed this book. But appreciate how it didn't provide you the same experience. I hope your next read is enjoyable!


Kelli Wilson "House of Leaves". Is it the one by Mark Danielewski?


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Nora wrote: "So sorry that this book didn’t turn out to be scary and that it’s just creepy instead. Hope your next book is five ⭐️!"

Thanks Nora!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Kelli wrote: ""House of Leaves". Is it the one by Mark Danielewski?"

Thanks and yes, that one.


message 36: by Jess (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jess I was unsure about the end but I was invested the entire time.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Jess wrote: "I was unsure about the end but I was invested the entire time."

I was very invested...until it just went weird


message 38: by Judy (new) - rated it 1 star

Judy Confusing and overrated IMHO.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Judy wrote: "Confusing and overrated IMHO."

Yes, I was very confused.


Julie M I came to the reviews specifically to see if anyone else got the House of Leaves vibe as well. I really enjoyed your review Melissa thank you for posting. I feel the exact same way you do.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Julie wrote: "I came to the reviews specifically to see if anyone else got the House of Leaves vibe as well. I really enjoyed your review Melissa thank you for posting. I feel the exact same way you do."

I'm glad to see that some people feel similarly!


Ebony | whatebonyreads I totally agree with this review. The book started out so strong and fell flat in the middle never to rise again. It should’ve given us a slight explanation as to what was going on. It dragged on way too long for me. I listened to the audiobook and struggled not to DNF with 2hrs left. I heard it’s supposed to be a trilogy…..O can’t say I’m excited to read those.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Ebony | whatebonyreads wrote: "I totally agree with this review. The book started out so strong and fell flat in the middle never to rise again. It should’ve given us a slight explanation as to what was going on. It dragged on w..."

Really? I will not be reading any more in the trilogy unless things really get cleared up. Maybe I'll wait until they are all out to see.


Nikki Lee Omg!! Melissa, I couldn’t AGREE MORE! Seriously! I was literally irritated that nothing was ever explained. We are never given a reason for all the creepy happenings. There is absolutely no closure no clues … nada! I don’t understand the hype at all!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Nikki wrote: "Omg!! Melissa, I couldn’t AGREE MORE! Seriously! I was literally irritated that nothing was ever explained. We are never given a reason for all the creepy happenings. There is absolutely no closure..."

I needed an explanation instead of more weirdness.


Sherrie I just finished and am more confused than anything! I didn’t find this scary, just weird.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Sherrie wrote: "I just finished and am more confused than anything! I didn’t find this scary, just weird."

Agreed, weird


Georgina Totally agree with your review. Enjoyed almost exactly the first half and then it switched. Couldn’t wait to finish it and move on.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Georgina wrote: "Totally agree with your review. Enjoyed almost exactly the first half and then it switched. Couldn’t wait to finish it and move on."

Yes, so true.


Lindsey This is how I felt about it too. I loved the first 1/3 - so unsettling and creepy and fun - but then I felt like the rest was just every horror trope rolled out with no cohesive plot. Nothing tied together.


« previous 1
back to top