John Lamb’s Post

View profile for John Lamb, graphic

Sr. Advisor in Agribusiness, Food Security, Resilience and Food Safety

Do currently available Regenerative Agriculture Certification Schemes address food safety? As far as I can tell after a quick search and review, it seems that none of them do, at least directly, not even pre-farm gate. While recognizing that this is a dynamic field, arguably rapidly gaining momentum, especially as concern over climate change is rising, here are a few tentative observations First, as far as I know there is no official designation or recognition by government or industry of any particular regen ag standards scheme. Second, while some schemes seem to have more adherents than others, and seem to be nearing endorsement by influential sets of market-makers, practitioners, and/or proponents, the forces of competition as well as differences of philosophy, scope, and approach keep the space in flux. Third, while food safety is one of the legitimate concerns for agriculture of any sort, there are many others, including: sustainability, soil health, water use, carbon cycle, biogenic and above ground GHG emissions, animal health, worker health and safety, child labor responsible sourcing, ethical or fair trade, etc. Competing schemes address their own mix of concerns. Fourth, while all of the regen ag schemes give primacy to pre-farmgate practice, some are tentatively trying to move downstream into packing, processing, distribution, and retailing, apparently out of concern that inappropriate conditions or practices that occur during later stages of the supply chain might violate regenerative philosophy and adversely affect resulting products. Fifth, while all regen ag schemes seem to concentrate on practices, some are trying to certify the products themselves, and others are seeking ways to address and measure outcomes. Sixth, all regen ag schemes are driven (or at least affected) by a mix of supply, demand and philosophical factors. Any given scheme may elect to structure itself differently, depending on chosen goals, geographic domain, industry coverage, choice of supply chain stages, financing source and market linkages. So what does this all imply for food safety: (1) sometimes no coverage at all, or at least just partial; (2) apparent need and opportunity for alliances with separate food safety standards and certification bodies, which are far more evolved; (3) need for all leading players to think bigger and act accordingly; (4) apparent need and opportunity for an integrated approach that straddles and interconnects standards that address distinct objective functions; (5) need for further maturation of standard scheme holders, the regulatory environment, and the marketplace. FYI, without any implied endorsement but with due thanks and attribution to "A Greener World", below I insert a URL for a useful table by AGW: https://lnkd.in/eEpptej2 Note the absence of true food safety content among selected leaders in this space!

AGW_Comparison-Table_Institutions-V6-FINAL.pdf

agreenerworld.org

John Lamb

Sr. Advisor in Agribusiness, Food Security, Resilience and Food Safety

7mo

Instructive to examine what the regen ag standard schemes say (or dont say) about food safety, Here is typical example: About Regenified: Regenified is a practice and outcome-based land verification and product certification program that champions regenerative agriculture. Founded by a team of regenerative farming pioneers, experts, and innovators, Regenified promotes practices that enhance biodiversity, soil health, water quality, and nutrient density while aligning with nature. Regenified verifies and certifies farms, ranches, and products that restore ecosystems and regenerate soil, ensuring a sustainable legacy for future generations. Committed to cultivating a regenerative world, Regenified guides farms and brands toward practices that rejuvenate the Earth, support thriving ecosystems, and transform agriculture into a healing force for our planet. Farmers and buyers interested in learning more should visit www.regenified.com

Albert Merkel

Development design adviser

8mo

The big question is, “Do they address the requirement for producing adiquate food production fot the growing world population?”

Margaret Bishop

Adjunct Professor - Strategic Management; Global Business at Parsons School of Design - The New School

8mo

You are always attentive to ah issues, John. Good to have you bringing these issues to the forefront !

Like
Reply
Emmanuel Junior Zuza, Ph.D.

Senior Lecturer/Assistant Professor in Environmental Science & Sustainability || Aflatoxin mgt || SDGs || Geospatial analytics || Climate modelling || Indigenous knowledge || Food systems || Royal Agricultural University

8mo

Jessica Heddenhausen interesting point here.

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics