Congratulations to Allbirds for putting in the effort to lower the environmental impact of their products and publishing some information about their Mo.oNSHOT shoe.
As they said themselves, they will get some criticism about their methodology and claims, and I will make a start. Before doing that, I want to emphasize that by putting in the work and effort and sharing information, they do more than most brands and must be applauded.
Here we go:
1. Marketing claims: “open-source” This one might be on Ecotextile. The information shared on this show is little beyond a basic introduction to materials used and how they account for emissions in production and transportation. Not useful for anyone in the industry, and thus more marketing than “open-source.” Now to the big issue: Calling it “net-zero.” This is utter nonsense (more on that below), and it does more harm than good, as it focuses on one aspect of environmental impact (GHG emissions) and ignores all other factors (e.g. biodiversity, effluents). It promises impact-free consumption.
2. “Net-zero”: Really? There are CO2 emissions associated with materials, production, transportation, and end-of-life. So they use offsets. Strikingly, their “carbon-negative” wool that they use MORE of (more than functionally needed) instead of less since then they can offset emissions that happen elsewhere. So let’s just all wrap our products in massive amounts of that wool, and we all will have carbon-neutral products. They also use bio-based (70%) EVA (again with claims of it being carbon-negative, and which they use to offset emissions). This EVA is based on sugarcane. LCA assessments have shown that bio-based materials do not necessarily have a low environmental impact, so even if we’d accept the carbon calculations, other ecological issues are ignored.
3. Since all products have an environmental impact, some fundamental principles exist to reduce the effects. Just highlighting one of them here for brevity: One fundamental principle is to design for a long lifespan. A shoe with a textile material extending almost to the bottom will get dirty quickly and be hard to clean, shortening its lifespan.
So much more could be said, but that exceeds this space. I just hope brands would stop making these bold claims that need 100 asterisks to come even close to being true.
US footwear brand Allbirds is making available the technology behind what it claims is the world's first net zero shoe freely available to its rivals.
The company has open sourced its toolkit for the M0.0NSHOT shoe - currently a prototype due for commercial launch next spring - by publishing it on its website.
Read more 👉 https://lnkd.in/eRPv3qM9
--
3wNOW you do it 3 months after I retire lol!