Mark Ritson’s Post

View profile for Mark Ritson, graphic

Founder @ Marketing Week Mini MBA

Cannes, LGBTQ+ advertising, and a more complex, nuanced approach to brand purpose….this weeks column.

Diversity doesn’t harm your ads, which is reason enough to do it

Diversity doesn’t harm your ads, which is reason enough to do it

marketingweek.com

Yisrael Segall

Founder of MediaSync | Demand Generation | Content Strategy | Growth Marketing | Marketing Strategist | Deep Marketing Generalist and Fractional CMO

1mo

you say why not. But why yes? If it doesn't change the situation, and buyer situations are the same, why not spend the effort on 91% of the population who are the bigger and stronger market than then 9%.

you just spreading gay propaganda, you force it

You weren't paying attention while I was talking about my collection of 3D-printed toasters! 😱

Like
Reply
Andrew Simmons

End-to-End Brand Experience Lead - International

1mo

It always surprises me how difficult people still find this conversation 🤯

Julia Kinner

Growth Strategy & Execution | D2C Products and Services | Marketing Consultant | Fractional CMO | Interim Management | Top 1% Upwork Consultant | Available for Projects ✅

1mo

I guess the question is if you want to "do" purpose for the purpose of purpose and accept that it has zero effect OR you prefer to allocate resources on something that is commercially oriented . For me it's the latter.

Yeah, but no. Performative diversity is bollocks, just like performative anything is. It’s a quick sugar hit. But the idea that talking to communities who feel excluded from your category narrative isn’t valuable is nonsense. We live in a world where category after category is static and involved in expensive share wars. So what happens if you bring in people who otherwise feel excluded? They feel it’s too macho? Too girly? It doesn’t work for people who are differently abled? Older people feel estranged? Take your pick. Inclusivity is an engine of growth, and should be an engine of innovation. Invite more people to your category and your brand. Make them feel welcome and able to buy.

Kerry Collinge

Uncensored CMO Podcast MD | Commercial Director a.p.e I MiniMBA | ThePowerMBA/ Co-Author of Pivot and Grow I Board Advisor I Mentor

1mo

Mark thank you 🙏 and also to note, the System1 Ad Ratings data shows there is a significant uplift in effectiveness amongst the representated audience…. So no negative effect, uplift in both feeling seen and effectiveness and you lose a few bigots too which is great

Asad Dhunna

Founder & CEO of The Unmistakables

1mo

Finally - some robust analysis that moves us beyond slapping a rainbow on it and goes into the precarious position marketers sit in today. I would be curious to see the same analysis run on when an advert's protagonist in the UK is someone who is non-white, as the current sentiment seems to be that what's on-screen has become 'too diverse', which is of course code for 'too Brown / Black'. This is a direct result of challenging conversations between clients and agencies about casting decisions, which is always too late in the game for robust decision-making. But until then, thanks Mark, Tamara and Andrew for a proper analysis of inclusion. Great to see.

Interesting musings as ever from the always readable Mark Ritson. We have finally evolved the idea of 'brand purpose' from being something that actively boosts a brand's performance - hence the cynical tendency for brands to jump on the bandwagon of progressive causes. Expressing your support for a progressive cause shouldn't be a commercial decision - it won't drive sales, despite self-serving research studies proclaiming that Gen-whatever will only buy brands that have a purpose. Equally, as Ritson explains, it won't affect sales. Brands are products of the societies in which they operate, and we are fortunate to live in a world (at least in the UK) in which 'progressive' attitudes towards gender, sexuality, race, human and animal rights, environmental issues etc. are widely shared. Brand owners should express their support for causes if they genuinely believe that it is the right thing to do, for their employees, customers and wider society.

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics