Steven Biersteker’s Post

View profile for Steven Biersteker, graphic

Architect sharing insights about carbon + architecture.

I've worked with a lot of engineers. The bad ones: - Assume coordination will just happen - Give no warning of major design updates - Copy-paste systems from their last project - Show no initiative The good ones: - Provide proactive solutions - Flag potential coordination issues - Suggest better ways of doing things - Show initiative Engineers are critical to the design of buildings, and we architects NEED you to be proactive experts in your field. Of course, architecture is much more complex than a good vs bad comparison, but these are critical factors in selecting an engineer to work with. _______________________ If you like my content give me a follow and hit the bell. I post Monday - Saturday @ 6:15am PST. #architecture #design #engineering

Jonathan Smart

Principal Owner JBS Structural Drafting LTD, Vancouver

1y

Oh boy you opened a can of worms 🤣 As someone in the BIM profession I can say this comment raises a red flag. Coordination is a two way street. Do you have regular coordination meetings with all parties Do you use issue tracking software Do you have a CDE So far my experience working in Canada is non of the above, with the exception of the larger international firms that have global standards in place. Canada has been very slow to adopt BIM and as a result there are very few BIM coordinators with real experience so the guys/gals doing the modeling lack the experience to pick up a lot of the coordination issues. Just my two cents

Sam Bernstel, PE, CxA

Commissioning Agent at Enviros

1y

This list is unnecessarily complicated. You can drop the initiative comments. That’s not specific to engineers. That’s every denomination. The rest can be simplified down to: Bad ones: - don’t communicate Good ones: - communicate Full stop

Kevin Lawson, PE

Providing automated engineering for architects and engineers.

1y

Weird. I've worked with a lot of architects and: The bad ones: - Assume coordination will just happen - Give no warning of major design updates - Copy-paste systems from their last project - Show no initiative The good ones: - Provide proactive solutions - Flag potential coordination issues - Suggest better ways of doing things - Show initiative

Travis W.

Mass Timber DfMA | ARKHOUSE Design

1y

Not sure why Steven Biersteker is catching so much flak in the comments. I appreciate the post. Took it as a helpful and professional perspective / reminder for engineers and engineering-adjacent individuals. Common sense, really - in a good way. We all need to be reminded more than taught. Keep em coming, Steven. I guess some people take issue that he specified engineers? Of course all this applies to architects the other way around also. It makes sense he'd speak to it from this side of the interaction. That's his experience. If I want to hear about bad architects I'll ask... well I was going to say engineers, but I swear everybody loves to pick on architects (myself included) 🤣

Brett Little

Empowering people to make homes better

1y

I get the same issue from architects to be sure

Tim Kiepe

Engineering Specialist

1y

Glad to see that you and your firm are changing the AEC industry from the Architectural level. I would love to see one of your models as it is properly populated with the correct wall families that match your wall section and details for all parameters needed to run accurate HVAC load calculations.

David Frost

The Best Home Inspector in Toronto *

1y

I agree with you 100% Steven ! As an Engineer, I would say what separates GOOD / BAD Architects is a good Architect will consider what their design would be like to live with and maintain for the long term, whereas a bad Architect not give any consideration to the occupants and the long term maintenance of their design…

Rob Jennings

Founder & Director REJEN Architects Architect/Conservation Architect/RIAI/RIBA

1y

Click-bait comment perhaps on co-professionals when same could be said in reverse? There are good and less good on all sides but not sure admonishing engineers from the pulpit helps Steven.

James Koch

Structural Engineer at Fast + Epp | Designing ambitious structures

1y

In the end the best results tend to occur in my experience when there is a dialog i.e. effective and proactive communication between architects and engineers to solve the design problems encountered along the planning journey.

Matthew Houston

Senior Mechanical Designer and Process Innovation Lead

1y

Develop a relationship with the "pretty good" engineers. Tell them your needs, work on solutions together. You'll find, I believe, that in the long run you'll both find more work, and make a much higher quality product at the end of the day.

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics