2024 NCAA Tournament Bracket Watch: What to look for in Saturday’s top-16 reveal

2024 NCAA Tournament Bracket Watch: What to look for in Saturday’s top-16 reveal
By Brian Bennett
Feb 16, 2024

The full NCAA Tournament bracket has been released with UConn leading the way as No. 1 overall

(Editor’s note: This is part of the Bracket Central Series, an inside look at the run-up to the men’s and women’s NCAA Tournaments, along with analysis and picks during the tournaments.)

In 1997, the Fox network began airing a series of TV specials called “Breaking the Magician’s Code: Magic’s Biggest Secrets Finally Revealed,” in which a masked man showed how to pull off such tricks as sawing a woman in half and making an elephant disappear. The show briefly became a minor sensation — it was the ’90s; you had to be there — even though it was all very silly, with fog machines and self-serious music cues.

In the finale of the original series, the masked magician revealed himself as Las Vegas performer Val Valentino. He was immediately sued by other, furious illusionists. (And there are few things funnier than angry magicians.)

We find ourselves thinking about Valentino, both because it’s Valentine’s Day week and because some secrets we care deeply about will soon be exposed to the world. The men’s NCAA Tournament selection committee gathered this week and will release its current top 16 seeds on Saturday at 12:30 p.m. ET on CBS. No, there won’t be as many smoke and mirrors as “Breaking the Magician’s Code,” but if our pal Seth Davis wanted to wear a squid mask while asking committee chair Charles McClelland questions, we’d be here for it.

Advertisement

Get your March Madness printable bracket

The committee might cause some controversy with its choices, especially in a topsy-turvy season like this one. Just look back to last year’s early top 16. You know who wasn’t included as a top-4 seed? UConn, despite being No. 8 in the NET and fifth in KenPom with six Quad 1 wins. The committee would probably like to make that decision go poof.

Still, this reveal — coming three weeks before the committee meets for the real thing — almost always closely aligns with the prestige of Selection Sunday. Per the NCAA, 83 percent of teams included since the bracket preview began have remained among the top four seeds. In each of the last two years, 15 of the early top 16 seeds were still there when the tournament tipped off. Last year, all four of the early No. 1 seeds and three of the No. 2 seeds held on to their status; nine of the top 16 moved two spots or less from the early reveal to the final seed list.

Early Top 16 versus final — 2023
Early Top 16Final Top 16Change
1
Alabama
Alabama
None
2
Houston
Houston
None
3
Purdue
Kansas
minus-1
4
Kansas
Purdue
plus-1
5
Texas
UCLA
minus-1
6
Arizona
Texas
minus-1
7
Baylor
Arizona
minus-2
8
UCLA
Marquette
plus-3
9
Tennessee
Baylor
minus-5
10
Virginia
Gonzaga
minus-6
11
Iowa State
Kansas State
minus-9
12
Kansas State
Xavier
plus-1
13
Indiana
UConn
minus-2
14
Marquette
Tennessee
plus-6
15
Gonzaga
Indiana
plus-5
16
Xavier
Virginia
plus-4

So what should we look for when the committee goes “ta-da” on Saturday? The four No. 1 seeds don’t figure to be jaw-dropping. Purdue, UConn and Houston are locks, while Arizona appears to have control of the final top seed after North Carolina, Tennessee and Kansas all suffered recent losses. There’s minor intrigue on whether the committee prefers Purdue or UConn at No. 1 overall, but the Boilermakers are heading to the Midwest Region and the Huskies to the East regardless, so it’s mostly an honorific.

The No. 2 seed line is where things start to get interesting. We certainly expect to see Tennessee, Marquette and North Carolina there. What about Kansas? The Jayhawks have an enviable portfolio of marquee wins, but they’re also just 7-5 in the Big 12 with metrics that profile more like a No. 3 seed. Could Iowa State (eighth in NET, KenPom and BPI and sixth in SOR) snag a No. 2 seed instead? We’re fascinated to see how the committee sorts out the Big 12, especially given the weak nonconference schedules by many of that league’s teams, including the Cyclones, but Baylor might be the only other Big 12 squad levitating in the top 16.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

CJ Moore's Top 25: UConn towers above the field

We’re always curious to see how each year’s committee weighs results vs. computer rankings. Some of this week’s most interesting calls involve Auburn, a metrics darling that is just 2-4 in Quad 1, and BYU, which is ninth in the NET and 14th in KenPom but just 6-6 in the first two quads. Does the committee trust the computers or see that as sleight of hand? Multiple teams are bunched up around the No. 4 seed line, and which schools get the nod could conjure insight into the committee’s thought process. Can a mid-major like Dayton crack the top 16? How about a Mountain West outfit? Is Wisconsin, with its 11 wins in the first two quads, still top-16 worthy after its recent swoon? And how much will road wins matter, in a season where those have been extremely hard to come by?

We can’t wait to find out. Just remember that whatever the committee decides, this isn’t the final countdown.

Some other notes on this week’s bracket:

• We are beyond excited that The Athletic now has a Bubble Watch and Bracket Watch for women’s college basketball as well. They each debuted this week. Go check those out. Those two features, along with men’s Bubble Watch and this here bit of nonsense will be free and unlocked for the rest of the season, thanks to our Bracket Central partnership with E*TRADE. We did what any sensible person would do with that new sponsorship support: added fancy new arrows to the bracket! The green and red arrows signify a move up or down the seed line from the previous week, while the plus sign indicates a team new to the field (or at least, new from the previous week).

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Women's NCAA Tournament Bracket Watch: Don't count out Duke

• Our last team in the field this week is Villanova, which is sure to raise some eyebrows. The Wildcats are just 13-11 but just look at those wins: North Carolina and Texas Tech on neutral floors, at Creighton and Providence at home. Throw in the fact that Nova has played the 17th-toughest schedule per the NET and ranks 34th in KenPom and 27th in BPI and we think that’s enough to squeak by Seton Hall, whom the Cats just beat by 26 at home, and a Cincinnati squad that didn’t beat a top-140 opponent in nonconference. Someday we’d love the committee to give us all its top at-large teams in the early reveal, which would be much more enlightening than the top 16. Hey, if the College Football Playoff folks could produce a Top 25 for two months straight and then do whatever the heck it wanted in the final poll, why not?

• Questions? Complaints? Gasps of “how did they do that?” amazement? Bring ’em to the comments section and we’ll unmask all our magical secrets.

First Four
Dayton
16
Stetson
16
Grambling
Dayton
10
St. John's
10
Colorado
Dayton
16
Wagner
16
Howard
Dayton
10
Michigan State
10
Florida Atlantic
East Region (Boston)
Brooklyn
1
Connecticut
16
Saint Peter's
Brooklyn
8
Nebraska
9
TCU
Brooklyn
4
Duke
13
Yale
Brooklyn
5
South Carolina
12
UAB
Memphis
3
Baylor
14
Vermont
Memphis
6
Saint Mary's
11
NC State
Charlotte
2
Tennessee
15
Longwood
Charlotte
7
Washington State
10
New Mexico
South Region (Dallas)
Memphis
1
Houston
16
Wagner
Howard
Memphis
8
Dayton
9
Mississippi State
Spokane
4
Kentucky
13
Akron
Spokane
5
Texas Tech
12
McNeese State
Pittsburgh
3
Illinois
14
Oakland
Pittsburgh
6
Clemson
11
Oregon
Indianapolis
2
Marquette
15
Long Beach State
Indianapolis
7
Boise State
10
Michigan State
Florida Atlantic
West Region (Los Angeles)
Charlotte
1
North Carolina
16
Stetson
Grambling
Charlotte
8
Nevada
9
Northwestern
Salt Lake City
4
BYU
13
Charleston
Salt Lake City
5
Alabama
12
Grand Canyon
Omaha
3
Kansas
14
Colgate
Omaha
6
Wisconsin
11
James Madison
Salt Lake City
2
Arizona
15
South Dakota State
Salt Lake City
7
Utah State
10
Texas A&M
Midwest Region (Detroit)
Indianapolis
1
Purdue
16
Montana State
Indianapolis
8
Texas
9
Colorado State
Spokane
4
Auburn
13
Samford
Spokane
5
San Diego State
12
Duquesne
Pittsburgh
3
Creighton
14
Morehead State
Pittsburgh
6
Florida
11
Drake
Omaha
2
Iowa State
15
Western Kentucky
Omaha
7
Gonzaga
10
St. John's
Colorado
First Four OutNext Four OutLast Four InLast Four Byes
Cincinnati
St. John's
Utah
Virginia
Seton Hall
Wake Forest
Nevada
Providence
Gonzaga
James Madison
Ole Miss
Nebraska
Drake
Pitt
Villanova
Butler
Multi-bid conferences
LeagueBids
Big 12
9
SEC
9
Big East
6
Big Ten
6
Mountain West
6
ACC
4
Pac-12
3
Seed list
1
Purdue
AQ
2
UConn
AQ
3
Houston
AQ
4
Arizona
AQ
5
Marquette
6
Tennessee
AQ
7
North Carolina
AQ
8
Kansas
9
Iowa State
10
Baylor
11
Auburn
12
Alabama
13
Illinois
14
Duke
15
Wisconsin
16
San Diego State
AQ
17
Creighton
18
South Carolina
19
BYU
20
Dayton
AQ
21
Clemson
22
Florida Atlantic
AQ
23
Saint Mary's
AQ
24
Utah State
25
Texas Tech
26
Colorado State
27
Kentucky
28
Oklahoma
29
TCU
30
New Mexico
31
Texas
32
Florida
33
Michigan State
34
Northwestern
35
Mississippi State
36
Washington State
37
Boise State
38
Texas A&M
39
Virginia
40
Providence
41
Nebraska
42
Butler
43
Indiana State
AQ
44
Grand Canyon
AQ
45
Nevada
46
Ole Miss
47
Utah
48
Villanova
49
McNeese State
AQ
50
Appalachian State
AQ
51
UC Irvine
AQ
52
Samford
AQ
53
Akron
AQ
54
Yale
AQ
55
La Tech
AQ
56
Morehead State
AQ
57
Vermont
AQ
58
Eastern Washington
AQ
59
UNC Wilmington
AQ
60
Colgate
AQ
61
Oakland
AQ
62
UNC Asheville
AQ
63
South Dakota St
AQ
64
Quinnipiac
AQ
65
Eastern Kentucky
AQ
66
Southern
AQ
67
Merrimack
AQ
68
NC Central
AQ

The Bracket Central series is part of a partnership with E*TRADE.

The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Partners have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.

(Photo of, from left, Auburn’s Johni Broome, Chad Baker-Mazara and Denver Jones: Butch Dill / AP)

Get all-access to exclusive stories.

Subscribe to The Athletic for in-depth coverage of your favorite players, teams, leagues and clubs. Try a week on us.

Brian Bennett

Brian Bennett is a senior editor for The Athletic covering National Basketball Association. He previously wrote about college sports for ESPN.com for nine years and The (Louisville) Courier-Journal for nine years prior to that. Follow Brian on Twitter @GBrianBennett