Tom Brady Testimony
Tom Brady Testimony
Page 1
1
------------------------------------------------------X
4
5
THOMAS BRADY
6
7
------------------------------------------------------X
APPEAL HEARING
9
10
11
9:28 a.m.
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
BEFORE:
20
21
22
REPORTED BY:
23
24
25
1 of 172 sheets
Page 1 to 1 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 2
1
A P P E A R A N C E S:
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 2 to 2 of 457
2 of 172 sheets
Page 3
1
A P P E A R A N C E S (continued):
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
3 of 172 sheets
(Appearances continued.)
Page 3 to 3 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 4
1
A P P E A R A N C E S (continued):
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 4 to 4 of 457
4 of 172 sheets
Page 5
1
I N D E X
2
3
OPENING STATEMENTS
PAGE
MR. KESSLER
MR. NASH
28
6
7
REPLY
MR. KESSLER
42
9
10
11
E X A M I N A T I O N S
12
13
14
Witness
15
TOM BRADY
16
Direct
Cross
47
100
EDWARD SNYDER
150
194
17
TROY VINCENT
227
18
THEODORE WELLS
261
Redirect
Recross
139
143
251
255
259
321
340
19
20
21
Witness
22
ROBERT CALIGIURI
345
373
402
23
DUANE STEFFEY
411
427
438
24
DANIEL MARLOW
439
448
454
Direct
Cross
Redirect
Recross
408
25
5 of 172 sheets
Page 5 to 5 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 6 of 172
APPEALS HEARING
Page 6
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLERPage 8
1
do today.
9:28 a.m.
10
11
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
the outset.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
best we can.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLERPage 7
2
3
4
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLERPage 9
something.
add?
MR. LEVY: The only thing I want to add is
reporter.
8
9
10
11
12
10
11
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
Commissioner.
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 6 to 9 of 457
6 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 7 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 10
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 12
1
explain that.
10
they said and the team was responsible. But for the
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
big and fat and round to him like he had never felt
18
18
19
19
20
is very important.
20
21
21
22
22
23
first hear from Tom Brady who you said you want to
23
24
24
25
25
9
10
11
11
know what had gone on was the balls had more air put
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
chance to look him in the eye and see what you think
17
18
about that.
18
10
19
about that.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
footballs.
23
24
25
24
25
7 of 172 sheets
Page 10 to 13 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 8 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 14
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 16
1
that shows.
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
produce them.
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
exists today.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
that.
21
13
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
22
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 14 to 17 of 457
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 9 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 18
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 20
1
Mr. Wells.
10
10
11
in place.
11
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
12
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
1
2
this discipline.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
17
22
22
23
23
responsible for.
24
24
25
25
9 of 172 sheets
Page 18 to 21 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 10 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 22
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 24
1
generally aware."
apply to players.
We had another incident a few years ago
2009.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
advantage.
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
1
2
what you will also find out is that in the past, you
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 22 to 25 of 457
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 11 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/KESSLER Page 26
OPENING STATEMENT/NASH Page 28
1
10
10
11
11
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
12
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
proceeding today.
19
23
24
24
25
25
OPENING STATEMENT/NASH
Page 29
and from Ray Rice, in the cases, and I know you are
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
detrimental arose.
18
18
19
19
20
ruled on that.
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
reviewed documents.
24
24
25
25
11 of 172 sheets
Page 26 to 29 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 12 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 30
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 32
1
Agreement.
in the report.
8
9
10
10
11
will see what they have to say. But I will say just
11
say.
12
12
13
13
14
report.
14
15
16
and there has been a lot that has been said about
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
circumstances.
22
23
15
23
24
24
25
25
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 31
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 33
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
the Ideal Gas Law, but what I can say and the
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 30 to 33 of 457
12 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 13 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 34
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 36
1
conduct detrimental.
10
10
11
11
12
the report.
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 35
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 37
the grip.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
13
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
17
13 of 172 sheets
Page 34 to 37 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 14 of 172
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 38
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 40
1
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
game, can consider not just what you just heard from
16
16
17
substantial.
17
18
10
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 39
OPENING STATEMENT/NASHPage 41
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
13
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
been available.
25
20
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 38 to 41 of 457
14 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document
28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 15 of 172
REPLY/KESSLER
Page
42
REPLY/KESSLER
Page 44
1
for Mr. Nash to come and say you should assume that
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
appropriate.
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
conduct.
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
REPLY/KESSLER
Page 43
REPLY/KESSLER
Page 45
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
13
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
15 of 172 sheets
Page 42 to 45 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 16 of 172
REPLY/KESSLER
Page 46
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 48
1
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
win?
A. Four.
Q. Okay. Has anybody won anymore?
A. Same, Montana.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
that information.
18
18
19
doesn't matter.
19
20
20
21
A. I do.
Q. Okay. And could you explain to the
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 47
1
2
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 49
A.
follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
MR. KESSLER:
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
11
12
13
14
University of Michigan.
15
balls in.
16
2000.
17
18
19
20
been the one that I've dealt with that has been
21
15.
22
23
Yes.
24
25
in the NFL?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
10
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
A.
Page 46 to 49 of 457
16 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 17 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 50
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 52
1
10
10
11
11
on right now.
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
Q.
16
17
17
18
18
19
20
21
A.
Q.
20
21
22
23
A.
Q.
A.
19
23
25
Never.
22
24
Never.
24
25
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 51
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 53
for the game, when is the next time you come into
On the field.
3
4
A.
Q.
approved them?
9
10
A.
Q.
No.
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
the ball.
14
14
15
16
17
A.
Q.
15
No.
16
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
quickly.
21
22
23
A.
Q.
A.
21
22
23
24
24
25
25
17 of 172 sheets
Page 50 to 53 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 18 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 54
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 56
1
10
10
11
process.
11
12
13
14
15
16
12
13
different processes?
THE WITNESS: Yeah.
14
15
16
A.
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 55
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 57
the ball, but you didn't like it. Who did you
8
9
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
the water hits the ball, the water will absorb into
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
Is that a fair statement?
Yeah.
Okay. Did some of that intensity get
A.
21
21
22
22
23
said all right, you know, let's go for it. And then
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 54 to 57 of 457
18 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 19 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 58
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 60
1
2
A. Yes.
Q. And so you were telling him make sure the
it 16, right?
5
6
A.
5
6
A. Yes.
Q. Other than that comment, have you ever, after
A.
10
10
11
11
12
13
14
15
12
13
make to them --
A. No.
Q. -- until this happened?
A. No.
14
15
16
16
manager?
17
17
18
18
19
20
21
22
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Zero.
19
20
Zero.
21
22
23
called 16, what did you say to him? How did you
23
24
react to that?
24
25
A.
25
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 59
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 61
10
10
11
11
12
told Dave --
12
13
14
15
16
13
14
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
19 of 172 sheets
Page 58 to 61 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 20 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 62
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 64
1
A. No.
Q. Now, let me now mention, because it came up
report.
preparation of footballs?
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
October 17th. You will see that's the day after the
13
14
14
15
15
A. Yes.
Q. Who were some of the other quarterbacks who
were involved in that?
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
22
a rule change?
20
21
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Now, in this petition, was there any
discussion of the pressure of the balls or inflating
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 63
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 65
A. Yeah.
Q. Now, at this time, when he says, "Tom was
2
3
No.
requirements were?
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A. No.
Q. During the time in 2006, did you have
A. No.
Q. Did you ever learn the 12.5 to 13.5 standard
during that 2006 process?
11
A. No.
Q. Okay. Now, was this rule ultimately
12
10
A. Yes.
Q. And did the Competition Committee adopt this
13
13
14
14
15
that?
15
16
balls?
16
17
18
A. No.
Q. Thank you.
17
A. Yes.
18
19
referees the rule, did you ever tell him you wanted
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
A. No.
Q. Okay. Did you ever tell anyone in the Jets
22
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 62 to 65 of 457
20 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 21 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 66
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 68
A. No.
Q. Did you in any way suggest to him to do
A. No.
Q. Did you even suggest to him anything about
A. No.
Q. What were you talking to Mr. Jastremski about
when you were selecting the balls, if you remember;
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
through.
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
A. No.
Q. Was there any discussion of that rule at that
A.
17
18
time?
A. No.
Q. Now, let me now turn to the AFC Championship
Game against the Colts.
MR. KESSLER: Commissioner, do you think we
A.
19
20
21
22
inclement.
23
24
24
25
will continue.
25
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 67
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 69
6
7
8
9
10
11
A. 7:30, 8:00.
Q. Would it refresh your recollection if I said
it was around 7:00, 6:50, 7:00?
10
weeks of breaking the ball in, that kind of, you can
11
12
12
13
13
14
15
14
15
16
16
17
that time?
17
18
19
20
21
22
A. John.
Q. Anybody else besides Mr. Jastremski or was it
just the two of you?
18
19
20
21
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
21 of 172 sheets
Page 66 to 69 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 22 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 70
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 72
1
Lexol.
4
5
6
4
5
inclement weather?
remember.
10
11
12
11
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
36 hours to go.
18
20
21
22
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
A. On the field.
Q. On the field?
COMMISSIONER GOODELL: Just so I am clear,
for warmup or game?
10
13
19
then?
23
24
25
A. Yes.
Q. In other words, you didn't notice anything
unusual about the balls or your balls felt okay?
A. Yes.
Q. After halftime, did the balls feel any
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 71
1
2
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 73
the game?
A. No.
Q. Now, did you know during the game that the
referees had put more air into the balls to get them
8
9
10
11
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
A. No.
Q. Okay. Mr. Hillebrand had been with you and
A. No.
Q. So could you even tell the difference between
17
A. No.
Q. Now, just to ask, do you recall how you
played in the second half of that game?
18
19
19
20
20
21
first half?
21
22
A. Yes.
Q. During the game, now, when did you next get
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Page 70 to 73 of 457
Yeah.
Was that correct?
What did I do? I don't -Okay. You don't focus on your own
22 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 23 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 74
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 76
1
2
3
4
5
6
Yes, okay.
Mr. Jastremski?
A.
Q.
A.
really well.
Q.
That's sufficient.
A. Yes.
Q. Now, first of all, what was most of those
A.
10
10
11
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
12
13
14
Yeah.
15
16
17
18
A.
19
ridiculous.
20
20
21
21
22
the radio?
22
23
24
25
23
24
25
Q.
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 75
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 77
I spoke to John.
3
4
A.
Q.
A. Yeah.
Q. Why is that? Could you explain to the
Yes.
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
almost -- I think you use the ball for one play and
11
12
13
14
15
15
16
16
Q.
10
14
17
A.
17
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
18
18
19
19
Absolutely.
20
21
of time?
Absolutely.
22
23
20
21
22
23
24
25
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Absolutely.
23 of 172 sheets
24
25
A. Absolutely.
Q. And he had ever done that before for a Super
Bowl?
A.
Page 74 to 77 of 457
No.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 24 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 78
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 80
1
2
3
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
day?
10
10
11
11
12
him?
12
13
A.
Q.
14
15
16
17
Yes.
13
14
A. Absolutely.
Q. Okay.
COMMISSIONER GOODELL: Had John ever been in
it?
THE WITNESS: Up to that point, I have no
idea.
15
A.
Q.
Yes.
16
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
right."
22
23
24
25
23
24
A.
25
A. Home.
Q. Okay. On this particular day, were you
preparing in the quarterback room at that time?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And so, why did you call
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 79
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 81
5
6
Q.
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
A.
Q.
10
11
Yeah.
13
14
15
16
A.
Q.
No.
17
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
24
25
A. No.
Q. Is it possible that something came up about
is he feeling okay because you heard that?
A. Sure, absolutely.
Q. But anything beyond that, do you remember any
conversations about the allegations?
A. I don't remember.
Q. Okay. Now, by the way, there has been some
22
23
Yes.
24
25
McNally?
A.
Q.
16
18
15
17
12
all good."
A.
Q.
A.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 78 to 81 of 457
24 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 25 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 82
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 84
1
2
A. No.
Q. Now, did you know who it was, even, who met
1
2
A. Absolutely.
Q. Have you ever handed signed merchandise to
7
8
A. No.
Q. Okay. Now, in the New England stadium on
7
8
A. Yes.
Q. You just said here, they asked, someone did
it and you gave it to them?
A. Yes.
Q. So there's a statement here in the Wells
10
10
11
various ways?
11
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And do you get to sort of know over
12
13
13
14
14
15
names?
15
12
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
A. Yes.
Q. So is it possible that you actually knew -- I
16
18
A. No.
Q. Now, let me turn now very briefly to the
19
20
21
well past the Super Bowl when you learned from your
17
A. Yes.
Q. And is he somebody you actually sort of knew
22
23
23
24
24
have?
25
A. Yes.
25
A. Yes.
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 83
1
2
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 85
A. No.
Q. Now, there is discussion in the Wells report
decide that?
A. Yes.
Q. Describe for the Commissioner what your
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
A. Absolutely.
Q. Okay. At the time that the request was made,
14
14
okay, you know what e-mails you did and what texts
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
A. Absolutely not.
Q. Okay. Were there any such texts where you
21
21
22
22
23
23
Championship Game?
24
24
25
25
25 of 172 sheets
A. No.
Q. Were there any e-mails like that?
Page 82 to 85 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 26 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 86
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 88
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
A. No.
Q. Now, you were interviewed by Mr. Wells and
1
2
3
A. Yes.
Q. And did they spend a number of hours with
A. Yes.
Q. During that time, did they ever tell you that
if you didn't turn over some texts or e-mails or
A. No.
Q. Did you do anything unusual except your
you?
your phone? When you say "get rid of," does it run
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
out of time?
THE WITNESS: Well, if it -- a new version
A. No.
Q. If you had been informed by them and they
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
15
20
21
22
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Have you ever had anything to hide on
22
23
24
A. No.
Q. Now, Mr. Brady, let me ask you about your
25
25
23
24
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 87
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 89
3
4
5
A. Yes.
Q. So it is essentially costless to you to get
same.
COMMISSIONER GOODELL: Okay.
Q. And, in fact --
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Now, have you had a practice, and tell
10
11
12
all the phone records from the company and that has
13
been submitted.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
14
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And did you do anything unusual here
20
21
A. Yes.
Q. Did you refuse to answer any question that he
22
22
23
23
24
24
A. No.
Q. By the way, did he ever ask you if there were
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 86 to 89 of 457
26 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 27 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 90
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 92
1
that?
A.
you sent.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
A.
Q.
A.
No.
Right.
Q.
A.
10
11
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
12
13
Q.
Yes, please.
13
14
A.
Q.
14
15
15
16
17
process --
Commissioner.
A.
16
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
A.
Yes.
25
25
Q.
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 91
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 93
the guy who swaps them out for me, make sure you get
anybody.
10
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
Now, when it says here that, "Talked to him
No.
Did you even know that, by name or not, did
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
mention you.
15
16
16
A.
Q.
No.
Do you remember saying anything to
A.
No.
Q.
17
And I know these are not your e-mails, but Mr. Nash
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
Q.
23
24
24
25
25
27 of 172 sheets
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Page 90 to 93 of 457
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 28 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 94
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 96
1
3
4
3
4
A. No.
Q. Now, I would like you to look at, on page 86
7
8
9
A. No.
Q. Okay. As you are sitting here today, I am
7
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
pressure of footballs?
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
25
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
14
23
24
your authorization?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
25
good."
Absolutely not.
No.
Are you aware of that?
No.
Do you know that?
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 95
1
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 97
Mr. Jastremski?
4
5
8
9
10
10
11
it.
11
12
A. Yes.
Q. Has anyone in the Patriots organization,
12
A. Absolutely not.
Q. One last question, Mr. Brady. There's a
policy at issue in this case that I will show you.
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
A. No.
Q. Did you understand him to be saying here
17
18
that, well, I did it, but you could have done it?
18
19
19
20
20
it.
21
22
A. No.
Q. What did you understand he was saying here
21
22
23
23
24
yourself"?
24
record.
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
Page 94 to 97 of 457
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 29 of 172
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 98
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 100
1
evidence?
right.
questions.
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY
MR. REISNER:
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
Member Clubs."
14
15
16
A. No.
Q. Okay. Now, if you turn to the section on
15
A. Yes.
Q. And you know that one of the things that the
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
21
22
23
24
20
A. No.
25
DIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 99
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 101
ball deflation?
A. I don't remember.
Q. And do you know whether any search was done
deflation?
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
10
Competitive Rules."
11
A. Yes.
Q. To your knowledge, was it ever sent to you as
a player?
12
15
16
17
18
19
19
20
20
22
23
24
25
14
18
13
17
21
A. Yes.
Q. Tell us what search was conducted for those
21
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
And those were phones that you used, correct?
Yes.
I want to direct your attention to what's in
22
23
24
29 of 172 sheets
25
A. Yes.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 30 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 102
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 104
1
2
3
4
1
2
A. Yes.
Q. And you see there is a reference in
3
4
7
8
9
10
11
A. Yes.
Q. And that refers to the mobile phone devices
that you provided for his review, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And directing your attention to paragraph 4
A. Yes.
Q. Do you know how many text messages you sent
and received during that gap period?
A. I don't.
MR. REISNER: I'm going to ask that NFLPA
Exhibit 1 be placed before Mr. Brady.
10
11
12
12
13
13
Brady 00206.
14
14
15
16
A. Yes.
Q. And directing your attention to the next
15
16
17
18
18
period.
19
19
20
20
21
2014," correct?
21
17
22
23
24
25
A. Yes.
Q. And those were the only two phones that were
provided to the forensic expert, correct?
22
23
24
A. Yes.
25
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 105
forensic consultant?
phone?
A. I gave it to my assistant.
Q. Do you know when you provided it to your
assistant?
A. Yes.
Q. And did you use a cell phone to make calls
A. I have no idea.
Q. And when you provided it to your assistant,
9
10
A. Yes.
Q. And that gap period of November 6, 2014 to
9
10
A. Yes.
Q. Exhibit 96 submitted by the NFL refers --
11
11
12
12
13
A. Yes.
Q. And that gap period also includes the period
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
of footballs, correct?
17
18
19
18
19
A. Yes.
Q. And that gap period also includes a number of
14
20
20
21
correct?
21
phone."
22
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
22
23
Yes.
24
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
A. Yes.
Q. And does that accurately reflect your
practice?
30 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 31 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 106
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 108
1
2
A.
Q.
Yes.
destruction, correct?
A.
Q.
A.
he destroyed it or not.
A. Possibly.
Q. Was that your purpose? Was that your plan
Yes.
phone?
9
10
A.
Q.
10
11
11
12
SIM cards when you get a new phone and "to destroy
12
13
13
14
right?
14
15
16
A.
Q.
A. Yes.
Q. And if you were following your ordinary
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
phone, correct?
20
21
22
23
24
25
A.
Q.
Right.
21
22
occurred, correct?
Yeah.
24
A. Not sure.
Q. Okay. At the interview on March 6th by
25
23
A.
Q.
A. Possibly.
Q. If you were following the practice described
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 109
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
A.
Q.
A.
No.
A.
Q.
A. Yes.
Q. And at that time, were you aware that there
Yes.
on March 6, 2015?
A.
Q.
10
11
11
12
12
phone.
13
14
A.
Q.
Right, correct.
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
correct?
19
A.
20
phone.
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
Q.
31 of 172 sheets
24
25
A.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 32 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 110
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 112
1
by Mr. Wells and his team being told that the Paul,
3
4
3
4
A. Yes.
Q. And that period of February 7 is in that gap
10
11
12
13
13
14
14
15
16
A. Yes.
Q. Do you know whether the materials produced by
12
A. No.
MR. KESSLER: Okay, I will have some
questions on redirect. You don't want to know the
content?
17
18
16
18
20
15
17
19
10
11
A. Right.
Q. So we don't know what the content of those
19
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
A. Correct.
Q. And are you aware if the phone records
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 111
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 113
messages?
4
5
requests?
A. No.
Q. Now, I want to ask you some questions about
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
A. Yes.
Q. You are presently aware that the NFL rules
14
14
15
16
17
Yeah.
18
Number 2 is Jastremski?
19
20
21
season, you were unaware that the NFL rule was that
22
23
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
And when did you become aware of that?
After the Jets game.
So during the period from when you entered
A. I think so.
Q. And in 2006, you were involved in efforts to
32 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 33 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 114
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 116
1
A. Yes.
Q. Around the time that you were involved in
6
7
A.
correct?
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
11
12
A.
10
13
14
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
A.
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 117
with.
after the Jet game and then after this was brought
10
10
11
12
13
14
11
12
13
A.
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
A.
22
23
24
24
25
25
33 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 34 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 118
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 120
A.
3
4
5
6
7
Q.
the ball.
A.
Q.
10
10
11
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
16.
11
12
13
that fair?
A.
Q.
A.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
football.
24
25
Q.
1
2
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 121
A.
ball, correct?
A.
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
15
16
Q.
A.
Q.
13
14
15
16
17
17
18
fair?
18
19
A.
19
20
20
21
21
22
the referees?
22
Q.
23
23
24
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
A. No.
Q. Did you know that the referees checked the
air pressure of the ball in the officials' locker
34 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 35 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 122
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 124
1
room?
A.
were.
report?
6
7
A. No.
Q. And what was your understanding as to how the
10
A.
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
in front of you?
that.
And I think it would be helpful if you had a
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
them.
25
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 125
you didn't know Jim McNally's name, but you knew who
he was, correct?
4
5
6
7
A.
A. No.
Q. And do you know whether in the six months
10
10
11
11
12
practice.
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
A. I wasn't sure.
Q. And did you see in the investigative report,
17
A. Yes.
Q. How many times?
A. I think once or twice.
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
Yes.
22
Championship Game?
23
Yes.
24
25
22
23
24
25
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
35 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 36 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 126
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 128
1
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
A. Yes.
Q. And do you have any reason to believe that's
inaccurate?
A. No.
Q. Do you recall what you discussed during that
13 minutes and four seconds with John Jastremski?
13
A.
14
about.
10
11
12
13
14
A. No.
Q. And do you recall what the two of you
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
22
A. Yes.
Q. And do you have any reason to question the
22
23
23
day.
24
24
21
25
A.
25
No.
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 129
A. 12.
Q. Let me ask you to turn the page.
A. Can I say something else? There was a lot of
So, anyway --
8
9
A. Yes.
Q. And when Mr. Jastremski came to the
10
10
11
him?
11
12
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
12
13
14
15
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
16
A. I have no idea.
Q. Do you ever recall him being in the
17
18
19
A.
20
21
A. Yes.
Q. And if you turn the page to 107, it says,
22
23
23
24
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
Page 126 to 129 of 457
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 37 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 130
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 132
1
2
A.
Q.
Yes.
A.
6
7
8
9
10
11
A.
Q.
about.
Q.
Yes.
A.
10
11
12
12
13
13
A.
Yes.
14
14
Q.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
Q.
A.
No.
Q.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
A.
24
24
25
25
7
8
A.
Q.
No.
10
10
11
11
12
55 seconds."
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
A.
Q.
13
Yes.
14
15
16
A.
Q.
No.
17
18
19
19
20
21
22
23
A.
Q.
20
days.
21
Q.
Yes.
22
23
24
24
25
25
37 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 38 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 134
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 136
1
get a sec."
you?
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
A. Yes.
Q. Do you have any reason to doubt the timing of
the phone calls referenced in the report?
A. No.
Q. Do you recall the substance of either of
10
11
12
him.
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
A. Yes.
Q. Did they raise any concerns for you?
A. About what? About that I was involved? Is
that what I was concerned about?
CROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 137
4
5
6
10
11
12
13
14
10
A. Yes.
Q. And when you saw those text messages in the
report, did they give you any concern?
11
12
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
25
23
24
all?
MR. KESSLER: Wait. After he read the
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
A. Yes.
Q. -- in the report, did they raise any concerns
38 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 39 of 172
CROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 138
REDIRECT/BRADY/KESSLER Page 140
1
9
10
11
A. No.
Q. Okay. Now, then it talks about
10
11
12
12
13
messages, correct?
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
A. Yes.
Q. And when you saw the copies of those text
messages during your interview --
A. Yeah.
Q. -- did they raise any concerns, in your mind,
that something improper was happening?
14
15
16
17
report."
18
19
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
me, so.
24
25
25
A. Yes.
Q. And those are the ones that counsel asked you
to identify, correct?
A. Yes.
1
2
questions on redirect.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY
MR. KESSLER:
6
7
8
9
6
7
A. Absolutely not.
Q. Okay. For all the text messages you've ever
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
A. Yes.
Q. And so, you will see that this says, "Result
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
A. Yes.
Q. And the first one says, "McNally, there are
no text messages between Brady and McNally."
Does that recall with your recollection that
you never texted Mr. McNally for anything?
A. Correct.
Q. In fact, you didn't know him?
A. Correct, well just by face.
39 of 172 sheets
A. No.
Q. Did he ever tell you that anyone else ever
deflated any footballs?
A. Absolutely not.
Q. Did you ever discuss with him any effort to
17
18
20
A. Absolutely not.
Q. What was your main focus from after the AFC
21
22
19
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 40 of 172
REDIRECT/BRADY/KESSLERPage 142
RECROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 144
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Absolutely.
that topic?
4
6
A. Absolutely.
Q. Okay. And was that something you would have
Bowl?
10
11
A. Absolutely.
Q. Now, do you recall that during this period of
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
16
17
18
19
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. How long have you known
15
Coach Belichick?
A. 16 years.
Q. Okay. When he is focused on the Super Bowl,
16
17
18
19
page 105.
20
20
21
21
22
23
22
23
A. No.
Q. Was it unusual for him to get up and have a
24
24
25
Super Bowl?
25
1
2
3
4
5
RECROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 145
A. Yes.
Q. Did Coach Belichick ever tell you that he
A. No.
Q. Anyone else in the Patriots organization ever
A. No.
questions.
10
6
8
10
11
two.
11
12
RECROSS-EXAMINATION BY
12
13
MR. REISNER:
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A. No.
Q. And during the text exchanges referenced
13
14
14
15
15
as well, correct?
16
16
17
17
A. Yes.
Q. And you say that it is possible that you and
18
18
19
Game, correct?
19
20
21
A. Yes.
Q. And during these telephone calls with
20
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
A. Yes.
21
25
40 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 41 of 172
RECROSS/BRADY/REISNER Page 146
RECROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 148
1
essentially --
change?
10
10
11
11
12
stadium on Saturday?
12
13
13
half hour?
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
office?
20
21
22
23
30 minutes.
MR. KESSLER: Let's try a half hour just so
21
22
23
24
24
25
25
RECROSS/BRADY/REISNERPage 149
essentially?
10
10
11
11
his experience with Mr. Brady and what Mr. Brady has
12
you cared about the feel, they knew that from the
12
13
process?
14
15
13
what he told you under oath today and how Mr. Kraft
14
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
essentially?
25
41 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 42 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 150
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 152
1
2
E D W A R D S N Y D E R, called as a witness,
10
10
11
follows:
11
through my consulting.
12
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY
12
13
MR. GREENSPAN:
13
14
Q.
15
record.
16
A.
Q.
A.
17
18
14
15
16
17
18
19
19
20
Yale.
20
21
Q.
A.
22
A.
21
22
23
23
24
24
collected data.
25
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 151
1
2
3
Q.
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 153
A.
Associate Dean.
7
8
9
Q.
A.
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
statistical analyses?
15
Q.
up to about 30.
A.
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
A.
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
involves data.
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
42 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 43 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 154
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 156
1
A.
10
Q.
10
11
11
12
12
13
A.
13
A.
expertise.
A.
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
fired, who gets let go, who gets promoted, who gets
19
20
20
21
A.
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
come up to me.
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 155
Q.
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 157
Thanks.
matter?
A.
statistics.
In the course of making adjustments to the
9
10
11
Q.
10
A.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
analyses.
17
A.
18
18
19
you?
19
20
20
21
21
22
Mr. Commissioner.
22
23
24
23
24
25
43 of 172 sheets
25
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 44 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 158
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 160
1
Q.
10
11
A.
Q.
A.
10
11
uncertainty about.
Q.
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
analysis here.
17
Q.
A.
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
A.
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 159
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 161
analysis.
balls.
back to the raw data was that they then said, well,
10
10
Q.
11
11
12
12
13
13
raw data?
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
threshold.
17
18
18
Q.
A.
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
Table 1.
22
23
A.
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
44 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 45 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 162
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 164
1
7
8
9
A.
10
10
11
to.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
significance."
17
A.
A.
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 163
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 165
A.
psi.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
A.
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
A.
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
45 of 172 sheets
A.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 46 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 166
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 168
A.
it's close.
Q.
A.
10
11
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
difference.
16
Patriots to Colts?
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
25
Q.
23
24
A.
25
Correct.
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 167
1
2
Q.
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 169
to turn to next.
of time?
A.
A.
10
11
12
13
by chance."
Q.
A.
10
11
12
13
change.
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
chance.
22
23
Q.
23
24
24
25
analysis?
25
importance of time.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
46 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 47 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 170
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 172
1
A.
this focus.
of timing at halftime.
5
6
Q.
A.
A.
9
10
11
10
11
12
when the balls are being brought off the field into
12
13
13
14
15
14
15
16
17
18
16
17
18
game?
19
A.
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
24
25
22
23
24
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 171
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 173
at 13.0.
they are wet, and the same thing for the Patriots'
balls, to equilibrate.
10
Q.
A. Nothing.
Q. How do you know?
A. Absolutely nothing. If you look at their
10
11
11
12
12
Nothing, really.
13
14
explanatory variable.
13
14
A.
Q.
15
15
16
16
17
A.
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
left time out of the analysis that they said was the
21
21
most important.
22
22
23
23
24
24
differences work?
25
25
47 of 172 sheets
A.
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 48 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 174
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 176
1
2
A.
10
10
Case Number 2?
A.
11
11
12
your case 1?
12
13
13
A.
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
(indicating), okay.
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 175
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 177
10
10
11
11
12
difference in psi.
12
13
14
15
A.
13
14
15
adjustment?
A.
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
about .7 psi.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
48 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 49 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 178
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 180
1
2
plausible assumptions?
9
10
11
10
A.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
assumptions?
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
see, not to say you know exactly how wet they were,
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
was a greater --
moisture effect.
COMMISSIONER GOODELL: But that's a what-if,
right?
THE WITNESS: Yes, it is a what-if, yes, sir.
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 179
1
2
3
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 181
A. Yes.
Q. What did he say?
A. He said it's definitely the kind of thing
A.
is a moisture effect.
9
10
11
A.
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
variability?
15
16
16
17
work?
17
No statistical -- no statistically
significant difference.
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
level.
23
24
18
24
25
A.
A.
49 of 172 sheets
18
25
Page 178 to 181 of 457
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 50 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 182
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 184
1
significance?
7
8
9
A. No.
Q. Even putting aside the fact that Exponent's
A.
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
A.
12
13
13
14
14
11.32.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
A.
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
"therefore" conclusion.
23
24
25
24
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 183
A.
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 185
variance.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
same thing.
10
11
12
10
11
A.
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
scientific threshold.
23
24
25
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
A.
A.
50 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 51 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 186
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 188
1
2
3
4
A.
you see that in all cases, they are testing for all
possibilities?
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
halftime values.
16
17
18
18
that conclusion?
19
the possibility that the logo gauge was used for the
19
20
pre-game measurements.
20
21
17
21
A.
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
gauge.
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 187
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 189
Championship Game?
4
5
A. Yes.
Q. Let's go to the next slide. And were you
8
9
10
11
A.
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
Ideal Gas Law. I don't think they had the Ideal Gas
15
15
16
results?
16
A.
17
17
18
18
19
are below.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
in the data?
24
25
25
A.
51 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 52 of 172
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 190
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 192
1
first half.
A.
10
11
10
Q.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
A.
15
Q. Other data?
A. I didn't mean "official" in the sense of
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
Q.
19
officiating.
A.
20
20
21
analysis?
21
22
A.
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 191
DIRECT/SNYDER/GREENSPANPage 193
balls.
3
4
5
6
7
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
game data; excuse me; the end of the game data. But
available to it?
either.
10
10
11
11
12
Daniels, I believe.
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
halftime?
16
17
Q.
A.
16
A.
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
52 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 53 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 194
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 196
1
A. I believe so.
Q. And how many times have you worked with the
Analysis Group in the past?
reliable conclusions.
panels.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
15
16
14
15
16
before we do cross?
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY
20
21
MR. REISNER:
21
A. Yes.
Q. That payment is separate and apart from the
22
23
24
25
22
23
24
statistics?
A. No.
25
A. Yes.
Q. Now, before your testimony today, and in
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 195
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 197
A. No.
Q. To your knowledge, is any member of your team
connection with the work that you did, did you read
analysis?
4
5
A. Yes.
Q. And so are you aware that, in addition to the
correct?
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
A. Correct.
Q. Now, you were assisted in your work here by
A. Yes, and as well as by Professor Moore.
Q. And the Analysis Group, that's a consulting
13
14
15
firm, right?
A. Yes.
Q. Very much like Exponent is a consulting firm,
16
17
18
correct?
correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And among those tests were transient
experiments, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. And among those tests were game-day
simulations, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. I want to focus first on your Finding 1. And
19
20
21
presented.
22
A. Yes.
Q. And Exponent frequently works with lawyers
53 of 172 sheets
11
12
10
23
24
25
A. Correct.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 54 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 198
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 200
1
2
3
1
2
A.
A.
difference.
6
7
8
9
A.
8
9
10
10
11
important.
11
12
12
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
13
14
18
13
A.
19
19
20
20
21
22
23
24
25
21
22
A.
23
24
25
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 199
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 201
conduct experiments?
A.
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
model.
13
14
15
16
15
16
17
17
18
work?
18
19
19
A.
20
20
21
Scenario 2.
21
22
know this.
22
23
23
24
24
25
Patriots football."
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
54 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 55 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 202
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 204
1
2
3
4
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A. That's my characterization.
Q. Okay.
A. And I believe -- I believe -- it's a fair
7
8
9
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
by excluding timing.
18
19
included.
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
correct?
22
23
24
25
24
25
A. Yes.
Q. And from reading the Exponent report, you
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 203
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 205
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
to explain everything.
13
14
15
16
17
18
15
16
17
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
that is flawed.
25
55 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 56 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 206
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 208
Q. Can you answer my question without looking at
halftime."
your slides?
10
10
11
11
12
balls?
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
19
20
18
19
20
21
21
22
22
23
explain."
23
24
24
25
25
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 207
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 209
of tampering?
7
8
9
Q. Yes.
A. -- everything.
Q. And so you are not suggesting, Dean Snyder,
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
right?
13
14
experiments?
14
15
16
15
16
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
happen by chance.
21
22
22
23
23
experimental results?
24
of tampering?
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
24
25
A. I don't think.
Q. You don't remember?
56 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 57 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 210
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 212
1
Appendix A, right?
drawing.
10
10
11
11
12
read this.
12
part.
13
14
15
16
17
18
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 211
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 213
6
7
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
results.
22
23
there.
23
24
24
25
25
57 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 58 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 214
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 216
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
A.
Q.
A.
A.
10
10
11
11
12
13
Mr. Anderson --
12
13
14
15
16
A.
Q.
14
15
A.
Q. Yes.
A. -- to get the balls using one of the gauges
16
17
17
18
18
19
account.
19
20
20
Q.
21
21
22
ball 1 --
22
23
A.
Q.
A.
Yes.
23
24
Yes.
25
24
25
Q. 12.17, right?
A. Correct.
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 215
1
2
3
Q.
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 217
A.
differences.
8
9
A.
10
10
11
11
12
Q.
12
13
13
the Patriots say that the psi level that they set
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
A.
Q.
Yes.
17
18
A.
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
or not.
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
your understanding?
A.
A.
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 59 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 218
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 220
1
correct?
A. Correct.
Q. So your analysis basically assumes that the
A. And if they -Q. Can you answer that question "yes" or "no"?
A. No, I can't, because there are two parts to
rules?
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
latter.
14
14
15
15
16
calibrated gauge?
16
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
17
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
the report.
25
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 219
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 221
gauges.
10
10
11
uncertainties.
11
12
12
13
13
14
proceeding or not.
14
15
15
16
16
17
right?
17
18
19
20
21
22
18
19
20
21
22
23
23
24
24
25
conversion.
25
59 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 60 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 222
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 224
1
2
3
Q.
data, correct?
6
7
A.
Q.
Yes.
A.
raw data."
A.
10
11
12
10
Correct.
11
12
A.
Q.
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
statistically significant."
17
18
18
A.
19
19
20
20
21
21
pressures" --
22
22
23
23
24
24
second; yes.
25
25
A.
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 223
1
2
3
4
5
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNERPage 225
A.
Q.
challenging?
A.
10
10
11
11
12
Q.
A.
12
13
13
14
14
15
right?
15
16
17
18
A.
Q.
A.
16
17
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
ignored timing.
23
24
25
24
25
Q.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
your time.
THE WITNESS: Thanks, Mr. Commissioner.
MR. KESSLER: Let me just do some
60 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 61 of 172
CROSS/SNYDER/REISNER Page 226
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 228
1
A. Troy Vincent.
Q. And, Mr. Vincent, what is your current
occupation?
10
10
11
11
Operations?
12
12
13
correct.
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
A. It's fair.
Q. And that would include the referees' testing
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And would you be the most senior person,
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 227
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 229
fair.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
available.
10
10
A. That's correct.
Q. Okay. So let me ask you first, Mr. Vincent,
11
11
how did you first learn that there was any issue or
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
16
17
18
19
15
16
17
18
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
follows:
23
24
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY
24
25
MR. KESSLER:
25
61 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 62 of 172
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 230
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 232
1
2
A. No, sir.
Q. Okay. And what did you do after --
3
4
1
2
3
4
half"?
the game?
game?
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
17
18
A. Yes.
Q. Did officials have instructions prior to this
17
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Okay. Were they asked to record anywhere in
18
16
19
19
20
20
21
21
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Okay. Were there any steps taken to preserve
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 231
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 233
4
5
6
7
A. No, sir.
Q. Do you know if anyone in the NFL Game-Day
A. No, sir.
Q. Okay. How about the timing of when the
see how long the ball was in the room at the time of
10
11
12
13
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
10
11
I hadn't.
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
22
23
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
testing?
A. No, sir.
Q. Okay.
COMMISSIONER GOODELL: Mr. Kessler, just so
I'm clear, are you talking about pre-game?
MR. KESSLER: Yes, I'm talking about pre -about the whole game.
A. Okay.
Q. In fact, let me ask you, prior to this game,
No, sir.
20
21
No, sir.
22
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
62 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 63 of 172
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 234
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 236
1
2
3
4
5
4
5
either, correct?
A. No, sir.
Q. So the only testing the NFL had in place was
11
11
12
matter?
12
13
14
10
13
14
10
15
15
16
16
is that fair?
17
17
18
18
A. My understanding, yes.
Q. Okay. So is it also fair based on your
19
20
21
22
23
19
20
21
22
23
A. No, sir.
Q. Okay. Now we then get to the halftime. You
were present for the halftime testing, correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And is it fair to say you did not tell
24
24
25
25
A. Possibly, yes.
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 235
1
2
3
4
5
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 237
A. No, sir.
Q. And nobody recorded the temperature in the
room at the halftime testing, correct?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Right. You didn't tell anybody to record the
stay in the bag the whole time for both teams and
right?
A. Possible.
Q. And when this testing was done, no one told
halftime, correct?
No, sir.
to record that?
8
9
10
11
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Not to my knowledge.
10
11
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. And the reason for no one doing this is
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
correct?
15
16
17
18
19
20
A. No, sir.
Q. And to your knowledge, it was not recorded
16
anywhere?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Okay. You didn't instruct anyone to indicate
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. Now, let me show you the following,
17
18
19
20
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Now, did Mr. Gardi do this on his own, make
21
21
22
22
23
24
23
24
25
63 of 172 sheets
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 64 of 172
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 238
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 240
1
investigation.
A. Correct.
Q. And, in fact, if you look at the Colts ball
A. Yes.
Q. You will see that three out of the four
10
10
11
11
12
correct?
12
13
14
didn't go to 12.5?
13
14
A. Yes.
Q. But at the time, you didn't know that some of
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. So do you know why Mr. Gardi thought
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
compliance.
19
23
24
25
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, I am going to give you another exhibit,
which is NFL 14. And you will see these are notes,
23
24
25
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 239
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 241
A. Correct.
Q. Now, at the time that you were looking at
5
6
7
8
9
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you signed this as a witness of the
halftime testing; is that correct?
A. That's correct.
Q. Okay. And if you look at the listing of the
A. That's correct.
Q. Is it fair to say, Mr. Vincent, that there
10
10
11
11
12
that correct?
12
13
14
A. That's correct.
Q. Okay. So do you know why Mr. Gardi thought
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
A. No.
Q. Okay. Let me ask you another one. His next
17
18
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Not at all.
You think it was very clear?
I think it was clear.
So do you have any explanation -- is
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
figures?
23
24
25
A. Correct.
Q. Well, let's look at the Colts ball
measurements. If you look at the Colts ball
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
Is he a careful lawyer?
Yes.
If it was so clear, do you have any
64 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 65 of 172
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLER Page 242
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLER Page 244
1
2
Q.
A.
Yes.
Q.
A.
A.
Q.
Q.
Yes.
A.
Yes, sir.
Q.
A.
Yes, sir.
Q.
10
10
11
11
Q.
12
12
A.
13
Q.
13
A.
14
14
15
reason why I'm not going to waste our time and ask
15
16
16
17
17
18
19
20
21
18
19
Q.
A.
access to those.
Q.
20
21
22
22
A.
Yes.
23
23
Q.
24
24
A.
25
25
Q.
yourself?
A.
Q.
A.
Yes, sir.
A.
Q.
Q.
Previous decisions?
A.
Mm-hmm.
matter?
Q.
Of discipline, correct?
A.
10
A.
11
12
13
Yes, sir.
10
11
12
question.
A.
Q.
13
14
14
15
discipline.
15
16
17
18
19
Q.
16
A.
17
18
19
our unit.
Q.
A.
20
20
21
identified here?
21
22
A.
22
23
Q.
23
24
24
25
interviewed?
25
65 of 172 sheets
Q.
A.
Yes, sir.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 66 of 172
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 246
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 248
1
touch?
5
6
7
A.
10
11
8
9
reading of the file. No, this was just -MR. NASH: Objection. Let him finish the
answer, please.
10
out of it."
11
A. Yes.
Q. Did you or anyone in your office conduct any
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
statement?
16
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
18
19
20
No, sir.
21
22
23
24
overreact.
he warmed?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
17
A. No, sir.
Q. Would you agree with me that if Mr. Rodgers
25
assuming that?
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 247
1
2
3
4
5
A.
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 249
in the report.
A.
misconduct.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
10
11
12
13
14
15
yes.
there has been nothing produced, I don't believe, on
17
18
18
20
21
16
17
19
19
20
21
footballs?
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
66 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 67 of 172
DIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 250
CROSS/VINCENT/NASH Page 252
1
A. Yes.
Q. And you will see that he suspends this
6
7
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, do you know why there was no
6
7
10
10
11
11
13
12
rep.
A. No, sir.
Q. Now, the policy that you cite in your letter,
officials?
THE WITNESS: Two game officials, yes, sir.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And to your observation, were they careful in
doing them?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. If I could ask you to look at NFLPA
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
A. No, sir.
Q. What happened following the issuance of this
letter?
20
21
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
22
CROSS/VINCENT/NASH
1
2
3
4
5
Page 251
CROSS/VINCENT/NASH
A. No.
that?
Page 253
A. Yes.
Q. Was the purpose of the investigation to look
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY
MR. NASH:
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, you were asked a few questions about
9
10
11
12
10
11
A. Yes.
Q. How would you describe the process that took
12
A. Yes, sir.
Q. If I could turn your attention to, I think
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
13
17
18
18
game?
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
game?
17
22
23
24
25
23
24
67 of 172 sheets
25
A. Yes.
Q. Would you say that this accurately describes
A. Yes.
Q. Did you have any information at that time or
do you know of anyone at the NFL who had information
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 68 of 172
CROSS/VINCENT/NASH
Page 254
REDIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 256
1
3
4
5
6
7
A. No, sir.
Q. You were asked about Aaron Rodgers. It's
NFLPA Exhibit 177. Do you have that?
3
4
5
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You were asked about a quote, and I note in
6
7
10
10
11
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes, sir.
Were both teams warned?
Based off the article, yes.
Okay. So if both teams were warned, that
12
13
14
measured it?
14
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you have any information or any evidence
13
16
11
12
15
article.
A. That's correct.
Q. Okay. And so both teams, it would involve
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
not prohibited.
22
23
A. No, sir.
Q. Or at any time, did you have information that
football?
23
24
24
25
25
"warmed" or "warned"?
MR. KESSLER: "Warm."
1
2
3
4
REDIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 257
A. Not at all.
Q. If you had such knowledge and such evidence,
would you have conducted an investigation?
article said.
ball.
article says?
7
8
9
REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY
10
11
11
right?
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
article?
16
17
18
10
17
18
19
MR. KESSLER:
A. Yes.
Q. So it was a very, very cold game. And what
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
23
A. Correct.
Q. And would you agree with me it's a frozen
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Do you think in a frozen game if
24
25
68 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 69 of 172
REDIRECT/VINCENT/KESSLERPage 258
RECROSS/VINCENT/NASH Page 260
1
2
A.
Q.
football.
correct, by you?
6
7
8
9
A.
Q.
A. That's correct.
Q. And it also says in the article that, "The
well."
10
10
11
11
12
all?
12
A. Yes.
Q. And again, did this or any other report that
That's correct.
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
13
14
A.
Q.
18
A.
19
19
20
phonetically]?
20
That's correct.
21
22
23
21
22
A.
Q.
23
24
25
A.
Mm-hmm.
RECROSS/VINCENT/NASH
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
24
25
Page 259
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER
Yes, sir.
T H E O D O R E W E L L S, called as a witness,
Yes.
No, sir.
follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY
MR. KESSLER:
10
A.
Q.
A.
Not to my knowledge.
10
11
No, sir.
12
13
13
14
14
11
12
Page 261
15
RECROSS-EXAMINATION BY
15
16
MR. NASH:
16
17
17
Q.
A.
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
January 21st.
22
23
A.
24
24
25
25
69 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 70 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 262
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 264
1
correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. But you still thought it was appropriate,
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
announced."
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
colleagues."
20
20
21
investigation.
21
22
23
24
25
colleagues.
22
23
24
25
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 263
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 265
Summary.
A. Sure.
Q. And is it fair to say, Mr. Wells, that you
stand by every word written in your report?
final?
correctly, correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So on the very first page 1 in the Executive
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
Championship Game."
17
18
19
20
21
22
18
conducted pursuant."
19
or in writing?
20
A. Yes, sir.
Q. When you wrote this down, this was now when
21
22
23
23
24
correct?
24
25
25
A. Yes.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
70 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 71 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 266
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 268
1
his advice.
of the NFL.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
not independent.
17
18
19
20
21
18
19
20
21
22
22
23
investigation?
23
24
25
24
25
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Were they written?
A. Not to my knowledge, but the truthful answer
is he didn't provide any to me, okay.
A. I believe so.
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 267
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 269
A. I do not.
Q. Do you know what the contents were of his
comments?
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
14
A. Yeah.
Q. -- with respect to the preparation of this
investigative report?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. That is fine.
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
substantive change.
22
22
23
23
24
A. Okay.
Q. -- will you not, then, answer questions about
24
25
25
71 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 72 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 270
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 272
1
2
A.
Q.
Correct.
3
4
5
6
9
10
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
9
10
11
11
12
12
13
A.
14
that.
15
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
To your knowledge, that's the only policy
A.
Q.
That is correct.
Okay. Now, at the time you did this report,
13
14
15
players?
16
16
A.
17
17
Q.
18
18
19
purpose?
19
A.
20
effect.
Q.
Today?
A.
20
A.
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
efficient --
25
I heard today.
Q.
A.
Q.
That is correct.
Now, with respect to your finding that
A.
Page 2?
Q.
A.
Q.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
Sure.
14
13
14
15
Q.
A.
Q.
Second paragraph.
-- it says the following. You say, "Based on
15
16
16
17
anyone else --
17
18
19
A.
Q.
Sure.
18
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
A.
Q.
22
23
24
24
25
25
finding?
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
72 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 73 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 274
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 276
1
A.
inflated?
A.
10
A. That's correct.
Q. Were the balls deflated in the Jets game or
In that particular situation, what they
10
11
11
12
report.
12
13
Q.
13
14
Sure, okay.
15
deflation of balls.
16
14
15
16
A.
Q.
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
A.
21
21
22
22
23
awareness.
23
24
25
24
25
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 275
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 277
Q.
10
11
12
A.
Q.
A.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
No.
10
11
sorry --
12
13
13
14
I cite.
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
73 of 172 sheets
A. Yes.
Q. Now, 13 would be within the legal limit,
right?
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 74 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 278
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 280
A.
Q.
1
2
Yes.
A.
Q.
A.
Yes.
Okay. And how many experts did you consider?
A.
Q.
5
6
preferably physicists.
9
10
A.
Q.
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
believe?
14
15
A.
Q.
Yes.
15
16
16
17
17
18
it?
18
No.
19
next day or the day after in the New York Times that
20
21
22
23
19
20
A.
Q.
21
22
to do this report?
23
24
24
25
25
Q.
A.
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
interesting.
Q.
billed?
A.
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
Q.
15
15
16
16
17
right?
17
18
19
20
21
A.
Q.
I hope so.
18
19
20
21
A.
Q.
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
consulting firm.
22
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
74 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 75 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 282
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 284
1
court-appointed expert.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
resources to do testing.
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
we got to Exponent.
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
the whole?
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
A.
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 283
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 285
watch Exponent.
A. Yes.
Q. And so Paul, Weiss didn't independently make
any scientific testing, statistical conclusions on
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
A. That is correct.
Q. Okay. And is it fair, then, that if for
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
numbers.
20
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
21
75 of 172 sheets
21
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 76 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 286
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 288
1
A.
A.
10
11
12
13
14
10
pressure.
11
A. That's my understanding.
Q. He is not an expert statistician, right?
A. No, but as part of the -- well, I don't know
12
13
14
there.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
testify today.
19
20
21
20
21
statistical expertise?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
22
24
A. No.
Q. That was not why he was hired by you?
A. No, no. That would be totally incorrect.
24
25
25
22
23
23
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 287
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 289
A. Correct.
Q. You came to learn that no one even specified
10
10
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. You came to learn that no one
indicated whether the balls were wet or dry when
they were tested?
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
uncertain?
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
A. That's correct.
Q. Because the recollections were different?
A. That's correct. When I had sufficient --
24
24
25
25
we made a finding --
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
76 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 77 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 290
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 292
1
2
Q.
A.
Right.
was uncertainty.
Q.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And he said his best recollection was that it
was the logo gauge, correct?
10
10
11
A.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
correct?
15
16
A.
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 291
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 293
into the room, that when they came from the cold
10
10
11
11
12.5, 12.6.
12
12
13
Q.
13
14
14
but that's their number. But they are 13. And they
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
uncertain?
18
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
report.
25
19
A.
77 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 78 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 294
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 296
A. That it correct.
Q. So as you are sitting here, you have no idea
Colts said.
The only way Walt Anderson could get to 12.5 for the
another?
A.
11
11
A. Okay.
Q. If their gauges read like the logo gauges
12
12
13
Wilson and may have looked just like the logo gauge,
10
13
Q.
10
14
14
then they might read like the logo gauge if that was
15
15
true?
16
16
A.
17
17
18
18
19
A.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
.4 off.
23
23
24
24
25
25
just what the Patriots saw and what the Colts saw is
reasonable.
gauge he used?
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
11
12
question.
Q.
13
14
shoes, okay.
A.
Q.
A.
Okay.
15
16
17
kind of interesting.
19
20
10
that.
11
Q.
18
19
20
21
21
22
22
23
that?
23
24
A.
Q.
25
That is correct.
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
A. Correct.
Q. The Colts didn't tell you anything about what
gauge he used, correct?
A. Correct.
Q. The only person who told you anything about
which gauge he used is Mr. Anderson?
A. Correct.
Q. Who said his best recollection was it was the
logo gauge, direct?
A.
was mistaken.
A.
A.
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 79 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 298
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 300
1
2
3
4
5
6
been wrong.
2
3
Exhibit 14.
A. -- 56.
Q. Yes.
A. And this is in the report. I just don't
Q. Yes.
A. He wrote that days later because Robyn
10
11
there.
12
260?
13
14
10
11
12
13
14
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
notes are?
18
recollection is correct.
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
A. Page 260.
Q. -- page 260, as you can see, has four and
four. So this would have been at the end of the
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 299
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 301
game?
game.
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
A. Right.
Q. It says, "JJ gauge, red Wilson sticker."
12
13
14
15
16
too.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A. Yes.
Q. Is that true?
A. You know that is true that I told them that,
the finding.
10
11
12
Yes.
13
14
Anderson.
Yeah, Jastremski.
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
Q. 56?
79 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 80 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 302
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 304
Q. Okay. I'm not going to quarrel with you
perfectly-calibrated gauge.
8
9
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And despite that fact, they wrote on that day
8
9
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
13
14
15
documents.
16
report.
17
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 303
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 305
Exponent report.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
declining.
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
information?
18
18
19
19
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
20
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
80 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 81 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 306
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 308
1
2
Q.
A.
do that?
them?
A.
10
A.
10
11
candid.
11
Q.
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
A.
17
18
18
had permission?
19
19
20
20
21
21
A.
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 307
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 309
happened.
4
5
6
7
8
9
Q.
A.
A.
Q.
A.
10
10
11
ahead.
11
12
Q.
12
13
13
14
14
15
that?
15
them.
16
A.
Q.
17
Yes.
16
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
unaccompanied, correct?
21
A. That is correct.
Q. Okay. But you did not interview
22
23
A.
Q.
Correct.
22
23
correct?
24
24
25
inaccurate?
25
81 of 172 sheets
A.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 82 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 310
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 312
1
2
testing.
A. No, sir.
Q. Okay. And would you agree with me that if
role was?
right?
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
A.
Q. Yes.
A. To my knowledge, Mr. Pash had nothing to do
with the testing.
A.
10
11
12
Mr. Ehrlich.
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
18
23
A.
19
23
24
24
25
25
remember when?
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 311
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 313
A.
this investigation?
6
7
8
9
A.
Mr. Brady --
A.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. -- did you ever, yourself, determine whether
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
10
16
A.
Q. Who is he?
A. Mr. Goldberg is a lawyer for the Patriots who
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
25
what happened.
23
24
25
A. No.
Q. Okay. And had you ever done an investigation
previously under the privilege integrity policy?
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
82 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 83 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 314
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLER Page 316
1
2
3
Q.
A.
clear.
Q.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
reliable.
14
14
15
15
16
that, right?
16
17
A.
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
Q.
uncertain, correct?
A.
Sure, yes.
Q.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
the time.
13
A.
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
about not just the science, but the whole case. And
21
inconclusive.
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
83 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 84 of 172
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 318
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 320
1
reasonable.
2
3
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
A.
questions?
Q. 73?
A. Okay. That data we decided not to use. And
10
11
12
13
13
gauges.
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
game.
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
A. That's my recollection.
Q. But you took notes of all that, either you or
your staff, right?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yeah.
They exist, those interview notes?
Yes, sir.
Okay. And they contain a lot of information
DIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 319
CROSS/WELLS/NASH
4
5
6
4
5
13?
A.
Page 321
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
No, sir.
-- in this matter -No, sir.
-- to prepare for this?
Not a bit.
It wasn't just shared with counsel for the
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
A.
17
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
No, sir.
Anyway, those reports exist, correct?
I said that.
And you know that it's been ruled that we
A. I understand that.
18
19
19
20
report says.
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
gauge?
24
25
A.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
84 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 85 of 172
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 322
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 324
2
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And I think you referred to yourself as the
MR. NASH:
ruling.
A.
8
9
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
22
23
21
22
23
24
24
25
investigator?
25
A.
10
10
11
11
evidence.
12
12
13
14
13
14
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is it correct that you were not given any
15
16
16
17
17
18
19
this matter?
15
18
19
20
21
22
23
A. None at all.
Q. Would you have undertaken this role as the
20
A.
21
A. Yes.
Q. Other than what's in the report, did you
22
23
was not aware or did not in any way know about the
24
24
25
25
85 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 86 of 172
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 326
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 328
1
A.
10
10
11
11
12
Q.
by other factors.
So we did all these experiments out in
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
let the air out. And then they did what they called
16
16
17
18
A.
Q.
No, sir.
17
18
Q. Transient?
A. The transient test. And what they did, they
19
19
20
20
Yes.
21
22
23
simulations.
21
22
23
24
25
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Okay.
24
25
CROSS/WELLS/NASH
Page 327
CROSS/WELLS/NASH
Page 329
A.
this.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
rabbit hole.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
measured at halftime."
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
86 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 87 of 172
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 330
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 332
1
2
Q.
A.
Yes.
Q.
A.
communications."
came out, the New York Times and the guy that writes
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
CROSS/WELLS/NASH
Page 331
CROSS/WELLS/NASH
Page 333
it's 001584.
form.
10
Q.
10
11
11
12
12
13
Q.
13
14
14
15
15
16
17
A.
Sure.
16
Q.
A.
Q.
there is an e-mail.
A.
17
18
18
19
Exhibit 61.
19
20
21
A.
Q.
Okay.
20
21
22
22
23
counsel?
23
A.
24
25
decline."
24
25
87 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 88 of 172
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 334
CROSS/WELLS/NASH Page 336
1
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
A.
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
to that.
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
time tell you that they couldn't give you any of the
A.
respect.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
15
A. Right.
Q. Did Mr. Brady or his agents give you any
16
other reason for that, for not giving you the texts?
16
14
17
A.
15
A.
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
interview him.
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
88 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 89 of 172
CROSS/WELLS/NASH
Page 338
REDIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 340
1
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
procedures.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY
20
20
MR. KESSLER:
21
21
22
22
23
forthcoming.
23
24
25
24
25
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And according to the transcript that's
published, you said the following, Mr. Brady, the
Page 339
REDIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 341
phone.
totally cooperative."
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Absolutely, absolutely.
And those are truthful statements, correct?
Yes, sir.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
investigation?
15
A. We did.
Q. Again, did he produce them?
A. No, because we had decided that he wasn't
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
89 of 172 sheets
Q. He also declined?
A. Correct.
Q. To your knowledge, has Mr. Gostkowski been
subject to any discipline for not cooperating with
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 90 of 172
REDIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 342
REDIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 344
1
2
3
your request?
A.
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
the issue.
A. It's true.
Q. How many millions was given to Exponent and
to Dr. Marlow apart from what you were paid in this
10
A.
Marlow.
transcript.
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
and I don't know what you want to do. You are going
20
21
21
proposal --
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
REDIRECT/WELLS/KESSLERPage 343
1
2
3
R O B E R T C A L I G I U R I, called as a
testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY
MR. REISNER:
10
10
record.
11
11
A.
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
you, C-A-L-I-G-I-U-R-I.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
engineering practices.
20
20
21
21
22
23
24
25
22
23
24
record --
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
90 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 91 of 172
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 346
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 348
1
2
3
4
A.
California.
Q.
A.
solving.
Q.
10
10
11
A.
A.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
before.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
expertise.
18
19
20
21
19
20
21
Q.
educational background.
A.
22
22
23
23
24
University.
24
25
Q.
25
A.
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 347
1
2
3
4
5
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 349
A.
Q.
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
Exponent.
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
23
24
25
Q.
A.
91 of 172 sheets
25
Page 346 to 349 of 457
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 92 of 172
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 350
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 352
Q.
your work?
A.
10
10
11
pressure drops.
11
12
13
Yeah.
14
12
13
14
15
Q.
A.
Q.
15
16
16
17
17
analysis.
18
A.
Yes, it does.
18
19
Q.
A.
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 351
1
2
3
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 353
Q.
A.
could.
report.
A.
Q.
A.
8
9
10
Q.
10
football."
11
12
A.
Q.
Yeah.
Can you describe what Figure 20 is.
11
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
football.
16
16
17
18
Q.
20
17
18
19
19
A.
20
21
21
pressure.
22
22
23
24
25
Q.
A.
That's correct.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
23
24
25
Q.
transient experiments?
A.
92 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 93 of 172
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 354
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 356
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Q.
did it and the same way the Colts told us they did
it.
Q.
Yes.
A.
A.
A.
Q.
10
11
A.
12
12
13
13
14
14
Q.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
balls, on average.
21
A.
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
Q.
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 355
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 357
be causing it.
A.
sorts of pressures.
9
10
11
Q.
A.
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
drops.
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
22
Q.
Q.
A.
Yes.
20
Q.
21
record.
22
A.
23
23
24
24
25
25
93 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 94 of 172
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 358
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 360
A. We did look at timing. We very much did so.
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
day simulations.
12
13
13
A.
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 359
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 361
A. That's correct.
Q. And you ran those balls through simulated
A. That's correct.
Q. Now, you were here during the testimony of
8
9
10
11
A. Correct.
Q. And you heard Dean Snyder describe what he
10
A. No.
Q. I want to direct your attention to key
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
A. Correct.
Q. I am referring to Exhibit 191 now. This is
15
16
16
statistically insignificant."
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
20
21
Yes.
22
23
24
Why?
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
94 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 95 of 172
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 362
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 364
1
A.
Q.
Why is it unfounded?
be statistically significant.
A.
10
10
Q.
12.17, right?
11
11
A.
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
and a half and 13, which means, geez, looks like the
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
factors.
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 363
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 365
here.
analyses.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
Q.
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
A.
No.
18
19
Q.
19
And the third one is the same mistake that has been
20
20
21
21
Snyder.
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
95 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 96 of 172
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 366
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 368
1
A.
10
Q.
10
Q.
11
11
12
12
13
13
A.
I sure did.
No.
14
Q.
14
15
A.
Q.
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
A.
21
A.
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 367
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 369
investigation.
10
Q.
10
11
11
12
described, correct?
12
That's correct.
13
14
13
14
A.
Q.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
by Exponent.
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
25
Q.
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 97 of 172
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNER Page 370
DIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNER Page 372
1
8
9
observation?
A.
Q.
balls?
10
10
A.
Yes.
11
11
Q.
12
12
A.
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
and put the pressure on the logo gauge and said what
19
Q.
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
playing field.
22
23
24
25
A.
24
25
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 373
and oranges.
Q.
reached by Exponent?
10
10
A.
No.
MR. REISNER: Nothing further at this time.
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY
MR. KESSLER:
11
11
Q.
12
12
A.
Sorry?
13
13
Q.
14
Q.
14
15
15
A.
"Kala-jerry" [phonetically].
16
16
Q.
"Caligiuri"?
17
17
18
Exponent?
18
A.
Q.
19
20
A.
No.
19
Q.
20
21
21
22
22
23
that report?
23
24
24
25
A.
97 of 172 sheets
25
A.
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 98 of 172
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLER Page 374
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 376
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
A.
11
factor, yes.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Yes.
No.
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
Q. No.
A. I'm sorry; go ahead.
Q. I am asking the following. You have never
15
15
16
16
17
17
A. That's correct.
Q. Okay. So you have to make some assumptions
18
19
A. No.
Q. So you think it's appropriate to take one set
20
20
21
21
A. Correct.
Q. Do you know if Wilson ever issued a version
22
22
23
24
25
18
23
24
25
A.
19
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 377
what the logo gauge was? Did you ever consider that
possibility?
A. Correct.
Q. And for the starting time, you didn't do any
4
5
7
8
9
10
8
9
A.
10
11
11
12
Colts.
12
13
13
A.
A.
same amount?
A.
14
14
15
15
16
16
A.
17
17
are right, they are new. And they all read what the
18
pre-game.
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
fact?
25
A.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
24
25
98 of 172 sheets
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 99 of 172
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLER Page 378
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 380
1
is?
didn't do that.
10
11
12
13
16
17
14
15
16
timing variable?
17
15
11
13
10
12
14
sworn testimony?
18
19
19
20
20
variable improperly?
21
21
22
22
18
23
23
24
24
25
25
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 381
that?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
the reinflation.
No.
10
11
No.
12
13
No.
14
15
A. Yes, I do.
Q. So in the very first one he did where he
16
17
18
19
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
logo gauge?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
20
21
21
22
22
23
your testimony --
23
24
25
24
25
99 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 100 of 172
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLER Page 382
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 384
1
Patriots' balls.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
In the beginning, no, we didn't.
Okay. Are you a football fan?
Yeah.
A. The balls can be in the bag. We actually -Paul, Weiss actually talked to the ball boys that
10
11
11
12
12
13
10
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And tell me what analysis you used
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
19
23
23
24
24
25
25
1
2
3
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 385
transients.
Q. Yes.
A. And you see wet and dry, wet and dry, wet for
10
playing with the ball, can you keep it dry when it's
11
9
10
11
12
Q. Right.
A. -- in the beginning of the measurement cycle.
12
A. No.
Q. Okay. So if the Patriots have those balls
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
24
25
24
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
23
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Sure.
Is it plausible?
Sure.
Okay. And you didn't test for that plausible
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
25
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 101 of 172
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLER Page 386
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 388
1
2
3
4
5
6
experiments, right?
10
10
11
11
12
13
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
no.
16
17
17
environmental factors.
A. Yes.
Q. So the reverse is also true. It's your
18
18
19
19
20
21
A. That's true.
Q. Okay. It's also true the referees weren't
21
22
22
23
23
24
right?
24
20
25
A. No.
25
A. No.
Q. Well, I have to understand this, then. Read
your sentence I'm reading. It says, "For the
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 389
other, correct?
causes," right?
differences in wetness.
9
10
10
11
12
A. We did.
Q. You didn't test if the Patriots' balls were
13
13
14
that.
14
11
12
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
were wetter --
18
Yes.
19
20
means?
21
22
23
19
20
21
22
23
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 102 of 172
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLER Page 390
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 392
A. I believe that's for the non-logo gauge.
Q. Okay. If it was done by the logo gauge -A. No, I'm sorry. That's the logo gauge; I
"average time"? You add all the times and you come
10
10
apologize.
11
12
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. So that would be some of the balls
12
A. Correct.
Q. And you wrote in your report it's uncertain
13
13
14
14
both?
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
20
11
19
20
A. Correct.
Q. And if that was done, then it is your
21
21
22
A. Correct.
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 393
realistic.
A. No.
Q. Now, did you know that the officials felt
10
11
12
13
14
A. Right.
Q. And so you don't think in that environment
10
11
12
13
14
15
15
16
plausible assumption?
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
over there.
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
football.
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 103 of 172
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLER Page 394
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 396
Q. Mr. Caligiuri, one of the things you tested
right?
correct?
A.
A.
10
Q.
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
15
16
17
A.
14
time.
Q.
A.
Q.
15
It is different.
16
17
18
19
19
20
20
22
23
24
25
A.
Q.
22
24
25
21
23
those measurements?
A.
18
21
A.
A.
1
2
3
Q.
A.
Q.
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 397
That's right.
10
11
12
10
A.
Q.
A.
A.
A.
to your question.
11
12
13
14
14
A. Sorry?
Q. Explain what that figure shows as to when you
15
15
13
16
16
A.
17
17
18
18
19
19
rubbing.
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
A.
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 104 of 172
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLER Page 398
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 400
1
question.
pressure?
8
9
A.
before then?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. So if they set their psi at 12.5,
10
10
11
correct?
11
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. So based on your figures, if the
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
12
17
A.
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
saying?
22
23
24
A. Yes.
Q. So in other words, there's a period on your
24
25
25
23
1
2
3
4
CROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 401
A.
after zero.
right?
8
9
10
A.
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
A.
right?
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
correctly earlier?
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 105 of 172
REDIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 402
REDIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 404
1
6
7
happened.
mean?
10
10
11
11
12
13
14
inaccurate?
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
15
16
point.
17
18
glove them.
A. That's correct.
Q. Or an error that you made? Can you explain
what the facts are based on those graphs.
19
20
REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY
20
21
MR. REISNER:
21
19
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
22
REDIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 403
REDIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNERPage 405
transient results.
Colts' balls?
gauge?
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
natural phenomena.
14
15
15
A. That's correct.
Q. And now describe the circumstances with
respect to the logo gauge.
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
of the average --
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 106 of 172
REDIRECT/CALIGIURI/REISNER Page 406
RECROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 408
1
RECROSS-EXAMINATION BY
MR. KESSLER:
halftime?
10
11
12
13
14
10
11
12
13
14
A. Yes.
Q. So now I'm taking away the information given
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
20
21
A. Yes.
Q. In the first half, just on TV, recognizing
22
22
23
23
24
25
24
25
RECROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 409
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
That's right.
And I read it accurately, correct?
You did, and -And those were the results you recorded?
MR. REISNER: Please let him finish.
10
11
A. Yes.
Q. And do you have any understanding with
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
15
A. Pretty frequently.
Q. Do you have any understanding as whether any
14
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
20
19
20
21
21
22
waterlogged?
22
23
23
24
24
25
yes.
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 107 of 172
RECROSS/CALIGIURI/KESSLERPage 410
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNER Page 412
1
2
3
4
1
2
3
7
8
9
10
7
8
9
A. Duane L. Steffey.
Q. And how are you employed?
A. I am a principal scientist and Director of
the Statistical and Data Sciences Group at Exponent.
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
correct?
14
15
16
17
15
16
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
right?
21
22
23
22
23
24
25
24
possible?
25
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNER
4
5
6
Page 411
1
3
associations?
Page 413
about?
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
14
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
18
17
D U A N E S T E F F E Y, called as a witness,
18
level.
19
19
20
20
21
follows:
21
22
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY
22
23
MR. REISNER:
23
24
25
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 108 of 172
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNER Page 414
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNERPage 416
1
A.
set pre-game with both the logo gauge and with the
statistically significant.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Q.
A.
Q.
10
11
12
13
14
Yes.
15
16
Snyder?
A.
Q.
A.
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
21
22
23
A.
Q.
Yes.
A.
Q.
foundation.
20
21
22
23
24
Q.
And why?
24
25
A.
25
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNERPage 417
timing.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
measurements.
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 109 of 172
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNER Page 418
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNERPage 420
1
average drop.
pressure drop.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
Patriots' ball.
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
is inaccurate.
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
you are .04, it's more likely than not, and if you
25
25
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNERPage 421
10
11
Q.
A.
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
position to validate.
15
15
16
are the same, and that the t-test, for example, was
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
probably later.
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 110 of 172
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNER Page 422
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNERPage 424
1
have got a model that has both team effect and gauge
data.
10
Q.
10
11
11
12
12
13
A.
Yes.
13
14
Q.
14
15
15
16
reports?
16
17
A.
Q.
17
And why?
18
A.
Q.
A.
19
wrong.
Yes, please.
20
21
18
19
20
21
22
22
23
23
24
Q.
Please.
24
25
A.
25
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNERPage 425
same order effect that we went back and put into the
sense.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 111 of 172
DIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNER Page 426
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLERPage 428
1
10
11
10
Q.
A.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
appropriate context.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
24
24
25
25
right?
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLERPage 429
A.
using one gauge pre-game and you are using that same
themselves.
Q.
10
Q.
10
11
11
present, correct?
12
12
13
reached by Exponent?
A.
13
No.
14
15
15
16
16
14
A.
Q.
17
and simple.
17
18
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY
18
19
MR. KESSLER:
19
20
Q.
20
A.
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
testimony?
24
25
25
A.
Q.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 112 of 172
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLER Page 430
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLERPage 432
1
2
3
4
5
A. That's correct. And just for -Q. "That's correct" will be good.
A. I am referring to the equation that's about a
third of the way down on Page A3.
inconsistent, right?
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
percent, right?
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
Appendix A, right?
17
18
19
A. That's correct.
Q. Okay, thank you.
20
18
19
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
choice, correct?
24
25
A. That's correct.
Q. Now, it's completely the opposite of
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLERPage 433
correct or not?
A.
that.
7
8
9
7
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
A. Yeah, mm-hmm.
Q. And then you are saying the reason you didn't
13
that.
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
A.
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
not match with all the other studies you did that
24
25
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 113 of 172
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLER Page 434
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLERPage 436
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
A. Yes.
Q. And you talk about the preponderance of
1
2
3
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. Are you familiar with the fact from -how many cases have you testified in?
A. At trial or in depositions?
Q. In any way, trial?
A. Trial, a handful of times; maybe 30
10
depositions.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
experience?
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
1
2
CROSS/STEFFEY/KESSLERPage 437
statistically significant.
And the other thing that is known in general
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
detecting that?
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
variability.
23
23
24
25
24
25
done.
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 114 of 172
REDIRECT/STEFFEY/REISNERPage 438
DIRECT/MARLOW/REISNER Page 440
1
2
REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY
MR. REISNER:
University?
Q.
University.
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
A.
14
14
department chair?
2001 to 2008.
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
expertise?
20
20
21
21
22
22
A.
physicists.
23
23
24
24
25
25
A.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
A.
15
D A N I E L M A R L O W, called as a witness,
15
16
16
would do it myself.
17
17
18
follows:
18
19
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY
19
20
MR. REISNER:
20
21
22
that.
21
Q.
22
record.
23
A.
Q.
A.
24
25
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
A.
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 115 of 172
DIRECT/MARLOW/REISNER Page 442
DIRECT/MARLOW/REISNERPage 444
1
investigation.
4
5
6
Q.
A.
A. Yes.
Q. What is your view?
A. Perfectly good. I was, especially with the
10
10
11
11
12
12
14
14
A. I did.
Q. And did you review carefully both the
15
15
16
13
16
Q.
work.
A.
13
A.
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
this?
21
possible way?
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
A. Yes.
Q. What is your view about their conclusions?
1
2
DIRECT/MARLOW/REISNERPage 445
Q.
A.
A.
important.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Q.
14
15
A.
Q.
18
Yes.
19
20
22
22
25
fully appropriate.
Q.
A. Yes.
Q. Directing your attention to his first key
17
21
24
findings or criticisms?
A.
A. Yes.
Q. Did you hear his description of his three key
16
21
23
Absolutely.
A.
Q.
A.
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 116 of 172
DIRECT/MARLOW/REISNER Page 446
CROSS/MARLOW/KESSLER Page 448
1
A. No.
Q. And have you had an opportunity to review
8
9
10
A.
10
A. Yes.
Q. And after reviewing the commentary on those
A. No.
11
11
12
12
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY
13
13
MR. KESSLER:
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
22
22
A. That's correct.
Q. Will you agree with me that the Exponent
23
Patriots' balls.
23
24
25
that?
24
25
outcome."
4
5
A.
A. No.
Q. Thank you.
10
10
11
detail.
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
20
19
20
21
21
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
22
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 117 of 172
CROSS/MARLOW/KESSLER Page 450
CROSS/MARLOW/KESSLER Page 452
1
decision?
9
10
10
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
That's correct.
In any event, it's not there, correct?
It's not there.
11
11
12
12
13
13
effect, correct?
14
14
15
15
16
balls.
16
17
17
A. That's correct.
Q. Now, you then said even though it's not
19
20
Q. Yes, I do.
A. Good.
Q. There is no timing effect to account -- to
20
21
21
22
22
23
balls, correct?
23
24
25
18
19
24
25
18
A. That's correct.
Q. Okay, good.
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Is "suggestive" a scientific term
five-percent level?
I did.
5
6
7
8
9
10
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
I did.
10
11
Yes.
12
13
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
11
12
13
14
20
20
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
A. Yes.
Q. Was that silly?
A. No, and there is a reason, if you will let me
explain.
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF
Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15
Page 118 of 172
REDIRECT/MARLOW/REISNERPage 454
REDIRECT/MARLOW/REISNERPage 456
1
2
3
4
5
Q. Explain, explain.
COMMISSIONER GOODELL: There is no reason to
point.
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
16
17
18
15
16
17
18
19
19
20
REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY
20
21
MR. REISNER:
21
22
22
23
23
24
24
25
25
participate.
REDIRECT/MARLOW/REISNERPage 457
REDIRECT/MARLOW/REISNERPage 455
Patriots, correct?
balls did not start at the same psi level when they
10
11
12
13
14
15
17
18
19
20
22
23
24
25
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
11
12
___________________________
JOSHUA B. EDWARDS, RDR, CRR
13
16
21
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
0
0.3 [1] - 355:18
0.4 [1] - 355:18
00067 [1] - 104:12
001584 [1] - 333:8
00206 [1] - 104:13
004 [1] - 417:16
04 [1] - 420:24
045 [1] - 433:21
05 [12] - 165:8, 165:19,
166:20, 166:24,
175:23, 420:21,
420:22, 424:23,
425:23, 446:17
055 [1] - 433:21
06 [1] - 420:25
067 [1] - 222:5
07 [1] - 179:13
1
1 [34] - 102:5, 104:7,
159:22, 174:4,
174:6, 174:12,
176:13, 180:11,
197:18, 197:22,
198:9, 198:25,
214:2, 214:4, 214:7,
214:11, 214:22,
221:24, 262:25,
263:9, 272:2, 299:9,
327:1, 327:12,
333:23, 361:6,
365:17, 414:16,
415:11, 417:18,
417:24, 420:5,
449:20
1,500 [1] - 338:1
1.1 [1] - 173:2
1/19/2015 [1] - 94:16
10 [4] - 131:2, 172:2,
242:6, 357:17
10.1 [4] - 238:22,
239:11, 239:15,
241:22
10/17 [1] - 92:9
100 [4] - 5:15, 77:12,
77:15, 153:1
10018 [1] - 2:12
10019 [1] - 3:16
101 [1] - 124:23
10154 [3] - 1:16, 2:4,
2:16
10166 [1] - 3:10
119 of 172 sheets
118:14, 119:1,
119:14, 120:20,
121:15, 122:9,
122:22, 122:23,
161:25, 163:7,
184:6, 187:9,
216:17, 216:20,
216:22, 217:14,
218:2, 218:11,
218:20, 238:11,
240:9, 240:14,
293:5, 293:7,
293:11, 293:16,
293:19, 293:25,
294:6, 374:23,
375:17, 378:13,
397:17, 397:20,
398:21, 398:25,
400:10, 400:12
12.6 [9] - 115:25,
116:15, 118:15,
217:14, 218:20,
293:5, 293:7,
293:11, 364:14
12.7 [5] - 114:19,
116:15, 117:9,
120:20, 364:14
12.8 [3] - 114:19,
116:15, 117:9
12.9 [2] - 116:15,
120:20
12.95 [2] - 161:23,
293:13
1285 [1] - 3:16
12:36 [1] - 149:3
12th [4] - 191:7, 192:4,
192:10, 319:22
13 [37] - 12:25, 59:11,
59:25, 62:24, 73:6,
73:19, 94:11,
116:16, 116:21,
118:21, 119:10,
120:20, 126:5,
126:12, 130:22,
134:4, 172:23,
193:17, 193:18,
239:22, 277:20,
277:24, 278:3,
278:12, 278:17,
293:13, 293:14,
293:16, 293:19,
294:1, 294:7, 319:5,
319:10, 319:12,
319:15, 364:16
13.0 [4] - 163:7, 171:3,
171:20, 375:11
13.1 [1] - 293:13
13.5 [6] - 65:8, 113:15,
113:23, 122:23,
218:2, 319:2
Page 1 to 1 of 54
2
2 [28] - 43:5, 111:9,
111:19, 160:13,
176:10, 176:11,
177:23, 180:11,
199:21, 222:13,
273:8, 273:9,
299:24, 316:5,
327:1, 327:16,
361:11, 363:15,
365:18, 367:19,
415:12, 420:11,
420:13, 446:4,
449:21
2.5 [2] - 279:13,
399:17
2.6 [1] - 399:17
20 [5] - 131:9, 131:11,
154:1, 353:10,
400:15
200 [1] - 3:10
2000 [2] - 47:17,
113:20
2001 [1] - 440:13
20036 [3] - 2:21, 3:4,
3:22
2006 [10] - 12:2, 50:10,
64:4, 64:6, 65:3,
65:9, 66:12, 97:19,
113:25, 412:17
2008 [1] - 440:13
2009 [2] - 24:8, 119:22
2010 [1] - 119:22
2013 [1] - 54:24
2014 [17] - 12:13, 52:5,
52:13, 54:24, 99:6,
102:20, 102:21,
103:2, 103:8,
103:10, 104:16,
112:21, 113:20,
124:3, 245:23,
333:23
2014/2015 [1] - 135:8
2015 [30] - 1:10, 6:2,
102:14, 103:2,
103:8, 103:11,
103:12, 104:1,
104:16, 107:2,
107:5, 107:7,
107:10, 109:13,
111:2, 111:11,
111:25, 112:22,
121:2, 125:11,
125:15, 129:16,
131:9, 131:11,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
140:20, 263:11,
263:23, 332:15,
337:5
203 [1] - 64:19
20th [7] - 3:3, 132:1,
132:7, 132:10,
133:11, 141:9,
143:15
21 [1] - 131:25
21st [5] - 133:23,
141:10, 143:15,
261:23, 313:2
22 [5] - 169:23,
172:18, 174:15,
204:18, 223:10
227 [1] - 5:17
23 [5] - 1:10, 6:2,
102:20, 263:11
23rd [2] - 264:12,
264:22
24 [6] - 24:7, 50:5,
69:11, 69:21, 70:23,
131:1
25 [2] - 125:5, 456:21
251 [1] - 5:17
255 [1] - 5:17
256 [3] - 239:3,
258:16, 300:4
259 [1] - 5:17
260 [6] - 298:12,
298:13, 298:23,
298:24, 299:23,
300:4
261 [1] - 5:18
266 [1] - 240:2
28 [10] - 5:5, 109:13,
313:8, 332:15,
382:23, 387:7,
403:17, 403:22,
405:17, 445:4
28th [4] - 84:20,
333:12, 333:19,
337:14
2:00 [1] - 171:5
2:10 [1] - 171:5
2:17 [1] - 194:19
2:28 [1] - 194:19
2:37 [1] - 170:15
2:38 [5] - 170:2, 170:5,
170:10, 171:4,
171:12
2:40 [4] - 170:8,
171:12, 171:16,
172:25
2:50 [1] - 171:5
2nd [2] - 333:17,
335:18
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
4
4 [16] - 102:11, 107:1,
129:11, 175:21,
184:22, 192:5,
226:3, 294:9,
294:11, 296:20,
296:22, 302:24,
316:2, 316:9, 372:15
40 [4] - 50:4, 152:19,
304:17, 399:14
402 [1] - 5:22
408 [1] - 5:22
41 [1] - 353:7
411 [1] - 5:23
42 [3] - 5:8, 226:15,
236:22
427 [1] - 5:23
43 [1] - 205:19
438 [1] - 5:23
439 [1] - 5:24
448 [1] - 5:24
45 [5] - 226:9, 377:15,
378:8, 410:8, 410:19
454 [1] - 5:24
46 [1] - 28:4
47 [2] - 5:15, 134:4
48 [8] - 184:7, 220:17,
291:1, 352:23,
365:25, 372:2, 372:3
48-hour [1] - 70:23
49 [5] - 212:14,
360:11, 430:23,
431:17, 431:18
4:03 [1] - 260:24
4:42 [1] - 236:7
5
5 [8] - 102:20, 103:2,
103:8, 103:11,
104:1, 104:16,
161:11, 408:6
50 [7] - 71:7, 128:8,
220:17, 291:1,
307:13, 309:8,
426:15
538 [1] - 330:7
54 [1] - 388:8
55 [5] - 131:12,
382:23, 392:7,
402:23, 403:25
56 [2] - 299:25, 300:1
58 [1] - 129:24
5:00 [1] - 313:4
5:13 [2] - 132:7,
132:10
5:21 [2] - 129:14,
129:17
5:30 [2] - 130:4, 313:4
5:54 [1] - 345:1
5th [1] - 112:22
6
6 [18] - 101:22, 102:14,
103:2, 103:8,
103:10, 104:15,
106:23, 107:2,
107:5, 107:7,
107:10, 112:21,
162:24, 226:3,
263:23, 350:16,
Page 2 to 2 of 54
355:22, 356:15
6.7 [2] - 222:8, 369:18
600,000 [1] - 342:11
61 [1] - 331:19
62 [6] - 222:19,
224:13, 224:18,
224:19, 225:1
620 [1] - 2:11
64 [2] - 354:12, 355:10
650 [1] - 351:6
66 [1] - 29:22
67 [4] - 184:6, 365:4,
365:8, 365:18
69 [1] - 333:11
6:04 [1] - 345:1
6:50 [1] - 67:8
6th [8] - 40:4, 108:24,
109:25, 110:10,
138:12, 279:10,
336:8, 336:16
7
7 [15] - 5:4, 62:3, 78:6,
111:1, 111:11,
111:25, 112:4,
140:19, 163:11,
163:12, 175:18,
175:21, 177:19,
179:13, 316:5
70 [2] - 333:6, 335:10
71 [5] - 184:6, 364:25,
365:4, 365:6, 365:18
72 [1] - 365:4
725 [1] - 4:4
73 [3] - 24:4, 249:15,
318:11
77 [2] - 91:25, 92:1
79 [1] - 92:1
7:00 [3] - 67:8, 313:3
7:04 [1] - 395:25
7:12 [1] - 395:25
7:24 [1] - 131:19
7:25 [1] - 126:1
7:27 [1] - 133:23
7:30 [2] - 67:6, 130:25
7:38 [1] - 134:5
8
8 [4] - 102:14, 166:7,
208:21, 300:21
86 [5] - 62:4, 94:8,
277:10, 277:15,
277:16
8:00 [1] - 67:6
8:21 [3] - 111:12,
111:25, 140:20
8:27 [1] - 457:5
8:33 [3] - 111:12,
112:1, 140:20
9
9 [1] - 356:24
9,900 [1] - 104:16
90 [1] - 179:13
90017 [1] - 4:4
92.3 [1] - 222:9
95 [1] - 97:18
96 [3] - 105:10, 111:5,
337:4
99 [1] - 104:15
9:28 [2] - 1:11, 6:3
9:51 [2] - 78:8, 126:24
A
a.m [6] - 1:11, 6:3,
100:1, 134:5, 134:6
A2 [1] - 98:22
A3 [8] - 173:11, 198:3,
198:15, 201:15,
202:19, 203:1,
212:13, 430:4
Aaron [2] - 248:3,
254:4
ability [3] - 64:21,
193:6, 316:11
able [23] - 10:14,
13:21, 16:12, 20:5,
20:6, 20:15, 25:25,
53:14, 55:19, 98:9,
112:12, 113:3,
148:3, 173:22,
187:6, 339:6,
417:14, 418:22,
423:4, 423:10,
424:18, 432:7, 432:8
absence [2] - 223:13,
404:2
absolute [1] - 316:16
absolutely [32] 38:21, 50:8, 75:20,
75:22, 75:25, 77:22,
80:9, 81:17, 84:2,
85:12, 85:19, 96:14,
97:1, 97:11, 141:6,
141:15, 141:19,
142:3, 142:6,
142:10, 173:9,
292:6, 296:8,
301:12, 315:13,
329:19, 341:7,
360:8, 368:3,
391:22, 443:16
absorb [1] - 55:17
abstract [1] - 220:22
abundance [1] - 157:7
academic [8] - 16:2,
120 of 172 sheets
151:11, 281:8,
281:23, 282:24,
283:12, 412:12,
440:18
accept [4] - 35:17,
38:7, 178:4, 308:16
accepted [3] - 304:22,
307:2, 371:12
access [6] - 87:2,
107:15, 244:6,
244:18, 321:16,
336:18
accomplished [1] 134:18
according [11] - 40:1,
107:1, 170:25,
177:18, 184:23,
191:9, 216:16,
217:1, 236:5, 257:9,
340:24
account [28] - 173:6,
173:22, 176:9,
202:1, 203:9,
211:14, 212:16,
213:2, 214:19,
215:13, 221:11,
253:1, 327:18,
357:11, 357:15,
358:9, 358:14,
358:17, 362:20,
366:20, 373:25,
384:12, 424:4,
429:13, 450:20,
450:21, 454:23,
455:7
accounted [3] - 19:24,
414:2, 414:4
accounting [2] 408:23, 414:5
accurate [5] - 125:8,
185:1, 217:21,
264:7, 427:4
accurately [8] 105:24, 106:11,
253:20, 255:12,
255:20, 259:19,
409:4, 419:3
accusing [3] - 94:20,
95:6, 144:24
achieve [1] - 432:11
acknowledged [3] 27:5, 176:17, 419:11
acknowledgements
[1] - 22:18
act [2] - 266:22,
324:19
action [4] - 245:19,
245:21, 246:15,
250:8
actions [4] - 154:21,
121 of 172 sheets
177:1, 177:2,
177:15, 178:18,
180:6, 185:13,
185:23, 186:9,
416:20, 416:22,
418:8, 418:15,
418:16, 418:17,
420:5, 420:12,
438:15
adjustments [4] 157:2, 186:14,
216:12, 417:17
administer [1] - 6:23
administrative [1] 345:17
admit [1] - 20:3
admitted [3] - 150:2,
154:18, 434:15
ADOLPHO [1] - 2:6
adopt [3] - 65:14,
176:3, 324:23
adopted [3] - 164:25,
175:25, 181:21
adopting [1] - 285:23
advance [2] - 271:20,
331:25
advanced [1] - 416:21
advantage [1] - 24:16
adverse [1] - 44:12
advice [6] - 15:7,
46:21, 46:22, 85:6,
268:4, 305:8
advise [2] - 27:18,
247:18
advised [2] - 227:2,
304:19
advising [1] - 283:3
advisors [1] - 334:12
advocate [3] - 23:20,
271:20, 323:6
AEI [25] - 188:20,
330:2, 330:18,
365:20, 368:11,
368:12, 368:14,
368:15, 368:23,
369:13, 369:20,
369:25, 370:11,
370:19, 370:24,
371:15, 422:11,
422:21, 422:23,
423:3, 424:15,
426:3, 426:5,
427:10, 448:3
AFC [39] - 33:2, 37:18,
41:7, 66:21, 67:13,
68:15, 68:17, 68:19,
69:20, 76:16, 78:9,
85:22, 94:17, 96:11,
103:11, 103:15,
103:20, 121:1,
Page 3 to 3 of 54
123:1, 124:8,
124:25, 125:2,
141:20, 143:18,
155:8, 189:2, 217:3,
229:13, 229:16,
251:11, 261:17,
263:16, 288:2,
293:8, 304:10,
306:7, 327:18,
334:8, 359:1
Affairs [1] - 2:7
affect [15] - 17:14,
237:14, 269:15,
288:1, 290:12,
361:6, 363:15,
366:11, 371:15,
373:3, 416:12,
422:4, 436:18,
447:23, 448:7
affecting [3] - 357:13,
429:24, 431:10
affects [3] - 13:13,
19:5, 178:19
affirm [2] - 40:24, 41:2
afraid [2] - 43:14,
408:2
afternoon [2] - 146:4,
194:22
afterwards [1] - 43:1
age [2] - 376:25,
379:10
agent [5] - 15:13,
105:11, 332:5,
333:10, 334:13
Agents [1] - 4:3
agents [13] - 14:20,
15:8, 84:22, 86:18,
305:12, 305:15,
312:8, 313:20,
313:21, 314:7,
332:9, 332:10,
335:15
aggressive [1] - 455:5
agitated [1] - 93:1
ago [5] - 24:2, 55:13,
87:8, 117:12, 417:11
agree [38] - 17:3,
23:19, 34:19, 64:17,
97:25, 200:3,
202:16, 202:19,
205:15, 214:20,
220:14, 246:1,
248:17, 257:13,
271:15, 299:3,
312:2, 314:10,
314:17, 315:9,
337:15, 344:24,
373:21, 374:11,
374:17, 384:18,
384:23, 393:5,
393:20, 393:25,
394:10, 427:21,
428:8, 433:4,
441:19, 448:22,
456:6, 456:7
agreed [6] - 30:21,
58:10, 230:19,
343:20, 344:4, 433:7
agreement [13] 28:19, 31:2, 31:8,
31:13, 32:4, 36:8,
344:16, 344:20,
344:22, 373:21,
374:10, 433:9,
456:24
agrees [1] - 447:16
ahead [7] - 159:8,
226:19, 227:19,
298:11, 307:11,
376:13, 404:1
air [24] - 13:11, 59:2,
59:4, 73:5, 94:6,
116:8, 116:9,
121:25, 122:24,
204:22, 248:7,
248:9, 248:18,
254:9, 273:16,
318:24, 318:25,
327:20, 328:15,
351:22, 393:10,
393:22, 404:22,
405:6
AKIN [1] - 2:19
Al [2] - 251:20, 319:25
alike [1] - 218:23
allegation [4] - 75:1,
75:2, 229:12, 230:8
allegations [9] 74:10, 79:2, 81:12,
81:19, 81:24,
130:13, 142:5,
229:24, 322:17
alleged [1] - 91:14
allegedly [2] - 94:15,
249:10
allotment [1] - 226:10
allow [3] - 109:19,
248:9, 279:4
allowed [1] - 242:14
allowing [1] - 378:4
alls [1] - 138:23
almost [9] - 77:10,
77:12, 77:16, 92:22,
103:23, 302:1,
304:17, 316:10,
433:16
alone [2] - 23:24, 32:3
alter [3] - 51:7, 96:12,
421:12
altered [2] - 250:17,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
438:17
alternative [7] - 157:4,
158:3, 158:14,
159:11, 177:20,
180:6, 413:23
alternatives [1] 158:4
amazed [1] - 444:6
American [4] - 195:1,
195:5, 195:8, 412:21
Americas [1] - 3:16
AMOONA [3] - 3:12,
97:15, 98:22
amount [12] - 13:2,
40:9, 52:22, 168:9,
175:10, 342:13,
376:10, 377:8,
383:16, 435:5,
435:20, 435:23
amounts [1] - 279:14
ample [1] - 447:8
amplify [1] - 422:22
amplifying [1] 413:10
AMY [1] - 3:18
analog [2] - 221:14,
221:15
analyses [21] 151:14, 152:1,
153:15, 156:21,
156:22, 157:17,
157:21, 157:22,
157:24, 174:22,
204:3, 204:5, 204:6,
206:15, 206:16,
209:13, 346:14,
363:9, 437:1, 441:8,
441:10
Analysis [2] - 155:14,
412:23
analysis [182] - 15:25,
152:5, 152:7, 153:3,
155:14, 156:2,
156:6, 158:22,
158:23, 159:2,
159:15, 160:17,
160:19, 162:15,
162:20, 162:21,
163:19, 164:2,
164:3, 165:8,
165:10, 165:11,
167:25, 172:5,
172:20, 173:6,
173:13, 173:19,
173:20, 175:6,
175:16, 176:25,
177:7, 177:8,
179:10, 179:16,
179:18, 180:24,
180:25, 181:21,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
182:5, 183:12,
183:21, 183:25,
190:21, 191:18,
195:12, 195:14,
195:21, 196:3,
196:19, 197:3,
197:6, 197:23,
198:2, 198:4,
198:13, 198:20,
199:3, 199:4, 199:6,
200:2, 200:10,
203:5, 203:11,
203:18, 203:20,
204:10, 204:11,
204:13, 205:16,
207:1, 207:14,
207:15, 207:16,
207:19, 207:23,
208:14, 208:18,
210:22, 211:8,
211:13, 211:16,
211:18, 212:16,
213:3, 213:24,
214:17, 215:6,
215:11, 215:12,
215:23, 216:7,
218:5, 219:15,
220:25, 222:4,
223:21, 286:2,
286:8, 296:18,
316:12, 316:15,
317:10, 320:6,
348:2, 349:14,
349:16, 349:17,
352:17, 354:14,
359:18, 360:2,
360:11, 360:15,
360:18, 361:2,
361:22, 362:5,
362:7, 363:3,
363:10, 366:4,
366:25, 367:15,
368:2, 368:5,
368:10, 369:19,
369:20, 371:1,
371:5, 371:6,
371:11, 380:10,
380:24, 382:8,
382:13, 382:19,
383:8, 388:8, 395:5,
395:8, 395:14,
399:15, 400:12,
402:11, 412:25,
413:6, 413:8,
413:12, 413:15,
414:17, 415:2,
417:10, 419:5,
420:14, 421:5,
421:7, 429:24,
431:11, 431:14,
431:23, 432:10,
432:23, 433:3,
434:20, 434:21,
436:14, 438:8,
438:11, 441:15,
443:22, 445:18,
446:1, 447:15,
451:3, 451:17,
454:22, 455:7
analytic [1] - 349:1
analytical [1] - 327:6
analyze [6] - 162:19,
327:12, 349:7,
349:9, 418:25, 429:2
analyzed [4] - 349:20,
354:15, 378:14,
413:20
analyzing [1] - 428:18
Anderson [29] - 34:14,
183:18, 186:6,
186:24, 188:4,
216:13, 241:6,
291:23, 292:1,
293:17, 293:22,
293:23, 294:1,
294:6, 296:21,
297:6, 297:13,
297:21, 301:14,
302:21, 303:7,
304:3, 306:5, 340:7,
359:2, 369:3, 369:9,
376:9, 455:10
Anderson's [1] 303:12
ANDREW [1] - 3:22
Angeles [1] - 4:4
announced [4] 263:11, 264:13,
264:21, 265:2
announcing [1] 261:25
anomalies [2] 413:21, 438:20
anomalous [1] 432:20
answer [41] - 10:4,
10:24, 11:3, 11:7,
89:18, 89:21, 99:19,
162:9, 203:13,
203:16, 208:1,
209:9, 211:24,
217:18, 220:6,
223:17, 246:9,
246:10, 265:12,
265:14, 267:24,
268:14, 268:21,
270:1, 270:20,
285:3, 288:4,
295:16, 311:1,
311:7, 341:3, 380:3,
383:13, 385:25,
Page 4 to 4 of 54
386:5, 397:7,
423:17, 428:13,
434:18, 436:10,
448:16
answered [1] - 341:2
answering [1] - 436:4
answers [2] - 265:10,
322:3
antitrust [3] - 151:21,
152:6, 153:7
Antitrust [1] - 152:4
anxious [1] - 8:11
anyplace [1] - 453:13
anyway [6] - 96:21,
129:9, 321:13,
343:4, 364:18,
384:12
apart [4] - 10:6,
196:21, 342:9,
351:20
apologize [5] - 262:2,
298:8, 392:4,
399:10, 454:6
apparent [1] - 347:5
appeal [4] - 6:12,
32:22, 271:5, 279:3
APPEAL [1] - 1:8
appear [1] - 355:12
appearances [2] 7:11, 12:12
Appearances [2] 2:25, 3:25
appendix [10] 173:10, 201:12,
203:4, 203:12,
211:19, 211:23,
212:4, 212:13,
419:4, 429:7
Appendix [11] 202:20, 202:25,
212:1, 212:2,
428:15, 428:20,
428:23, 430:7,
430:17, 449:9, 450:8
apples [4] - 178:18,
361:21, 372:25
applicability [2] 221:3, 221:4
applicable [4] - 25:24,
219:13, 311:12,
356:19
application [9] 152:7, 152:13,
153:2, 219:16,
220:3, 221:10,
266:14, 288:1, 288:6
applied [8] - 22:3,
22:23, 35:2, 152:1,
158:7, 184:4, 433:6
applies [5] - 26:15,
220:22, 324:22,
325:2, 432:19
apply [11] - 21:22,
24:1, 24:20, 26:1,
26:9, 46:14, 151:13,
187:11, 221:16,
233:17, 275:3
applying [2] - 216:2,
219:24
appointed [3] - 284:1,
348:12, 348:17
appreciable [1] 435:12
appreciate [3] - 148:7,
225:19, 314:21
appreciation [1] 314:19
approach [11] - 42:4,
163:15, 163:18,
163:20, 210:3,
348:20, 367:17,
367:20, 438:15,
442:16, 455:18
approached [3] 287:4, 327:3, 329:3
approaches [1] 418:23
appropriate [11] 21:4, 28:9, 29:5,
40:21, 42:13,
200:25, 264:6,
271:3, 374:19,
428:11, 443:24
appropriately [1] 203:9
appropriateness [10] 361:7, 363:16,
366:12, 371:16,
373:4, 416:13,
443:21, 444:1,
447:24, 448:8
approval [2] - 67:12,
147:6
approve [4] - 50:1,
50:25, 116:21, 147:2
approved [7] - 19:10,
51:8, 51:14, 51:15,
51:20, 56:6, 147:2
approximate [1] 376:25
April [1] - 102:14
arbitrarily [1] - 122:24
arbitrators [1] - 27:3
area [6] - 245:11,
279:11, 285:25,
322:8, 322:20, 347:4
areas [3] - 322:19,
346:16, 440:17
arena [2] - 346:5
arguably [1] - 25:24
151:6
associated [3] 154:24, 252:15,
254:17
associates [1] 284:24
association [4] 195:2, 195:5, 195:8,
412:21
Association [3] - 36:9,
36:10, 322:13
ASSOCIATION [4] 3:3, 3:9, 4:8, 5:13
associations [1] 412:19
assume [25] - 10:11,
10:12, 19:12, 19:13,
22:6, 44:8, 97:25,
148:12, 227:11,
236:8, 242:16,
269:11, 269:22,
293:8, 319:11,
364:5, 365:22,
368:18, 369:11,
376:7, 383:23,
386:3, 386:6,
398:15, 399:6
assumed [3] - 364:25,
371:8, 381:17
assumes [2] - 215:24,
218:5
assuming [15] - 29:4,
44:16, 44:20, 98:6,
171:6, 171:7, 174:7,
188:4, 246:25,
247:1, 372:1, 381:7,
381:9, 405:18,
419:18
assumption [19] 39:20, 171:2,
174:19, 183:17,
183:20, 214:5,
216:6, 221:21,
221:22, 290:24,
384:24, 385:20,
391:16, 391:24,
416:10, 419:14,
419:23, 420:15
assumptions [26] 157:4, 157:23,
158:3, 158:15,
159:11, 160:21,
179:22, 180:2,
180:3, 180:4,
180:14, 186:4,
186:5, 186:23,
188:10, 190:20,
190:22, 191:1,
193:22, 193:24,
214:16, 214:18,
368:8, 376:18,
403:2, 421:13
astounding [1] - 13:2
asymptotes [1] 183:8
AT&T [1] - 139:16
attached [1] - 237:18
attacks [1] - 134:20
attempt [2] - 24:14,
24:15
attempted [1] - 24:10
attend [3] - 47:14,
267:7, 335:4
attendant [5] - 122:5,
123:20, 250:10,
276:13, 276:21
attendants [3] 257:10, 258:10,
260:7
attention [30] 101:21, 102:11,
102:17, 104:10,
106:22, 111:7,
112:20, 129:10,
133:21, 139:10,
158:5, 162:10,
192:10, 200:14,
215:18, 253:12,
298:2, 337:6, 353:7,
355:22, 356:14,
356:24, 361:10,
363:19, 373:2,
402:23, 403:1,
445:16, 446:3,
446:24
attitude [1] - 57:22
attorney [4] - 6:21,
267:16, 268:12,
271:15
Attorney [1] - 152:3
attorney-client [2] 267:16, 268:12
Attorneys [4] - 2:10,
2:20, 3:9, 3:21
attracted [1] - 281:24
attributable [1] 422:9
attributes [1] - 423:3
authority [11] - 15:10,
15:11, 22:22, 35:24,
36:7, 305:16,
305:19, 305:21,
305:25, 311:12,
334:17
authorization [2] 96:11, 96:18
authorize [1] - 96:21
authorized [6] - 11:13,
31:22, 40:23, 96:15,
137:5, 275:4
Page 5 to 5 of 54
B
baby [1] - 160:18
Bachelor [1] - 346:21
backed [1] - 341:16
background [5] 48:11, 322:5,
346:20, 412:8, 413:4
backup [1] - 80:7
backups [1] - 71:4
backwards [1] 173:16
bad [1] - 44:9
bag [9] - 88:14,
236:14, 236:15,
237:2, 384:7, 384:8,
384:13, 384:19,
384:20
bags [2] - 190:4, 237:3
ball [205] - 12:4, 12:20,
16:22, 17:13, 23:22,
36:19, 36:20, 41:8,
41:9, 49:7, 49:25,
50:8, 50:12, 51:25,
52:1, 52:2, 52:8,
52:20, 52:22, 53:5,
53:10, 53:13, 53:15,
53:16, 53:18, 53:25,
54:6, 54:7, 54:9,
55:3, 55:6, 55:17,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
385:10, 386:14,
386:18, 386:22,
386:23, 389:3,
398:14, 400:17,
401:1, 402:2,
405:25, 407:1,
407:4, 407:7, 411:2,
416:6, 418:13,
418:14, 422:3,
428:3, 428:4, 428:5,
431:10, 431:15,
439:8
ball-by-ball [1] - 382:7
ball-to-ball [4] 212:19, 213:6,
213:24, 215:6
balloon [1] - 92:13
balls [469] - 12:16,
12:21, 12:24, 13:7,
13:10, 13:11, 16:13,
16:17, 16:20, 17:8,
17:9, 18:17, 18:23,
18:24, 18:25, 19:3,
19:5, 22:20, 24:11,
26:7, 26:16, 34:3,
34:5, 37:22, 48:15,
48:23, 49:5, 49:11,
49:15, 50:3, 50:4,
50:6, 50:18, 50:22,
50:23, 51:2, 51:24,
52:20, 53:9, 55:22,
56:8, 56:10, 56:24,
56:25, 57:10, 58:4,
58:9, 59:1, 59:2,
59:4, 59:8, 59:10,
59:20, 61:8, 62:23,
63:8, 64:1, 64:25,
65:1, 65:16, 67:12,
67:25, 68:3, 68:9,
68:19, 68:25, 69:5,
69:12, 69:25, 70:15,
70:16, 70:24, 71:7,
71:19, 71:23, 71:24,
72:4, 72:5, 72:11,
72:15, 72:25, 73:5,
74:11, 76:22, 76:25,
77:12, 77:13, 77:16,
82:4, 92:20, 93:10,
94:3, 94:6, 95:15,
113:22, 116:12,
117:7, 118:8,
118:18, 119:1,
119:23, 120:4,
121:15, 122:9,
122:22, 123:14,
144:9, 144:10,
144:14, 146:2,
147:2, 147:24,
148:2, 155:8, 159:4,
159:5, 159:12,
159:16, 160:1,
253:2, 273:17,
275:20, 276:2,
276:7, 276:11,
276:15, 276:24,
277:20, 278:3,
278:12, 285:18,
287:8, 288:19,
288:25, 289:4,
289:5, 289:9,
290:24, 291:4,
291:24, 292:14,
292:19, 293:2,
293:5, 293:7,
293:10, 293:13,
293:19, 293:23,
293:24, 307:14,
307:20, 308:5,
308:9, 308:17,
309:3, 318:14,
318:15, 318:16,
318:18, 318:19,
318:20, 318:22,
318:23, 319:2,
319:14, 328:1,
328:2, 350:8,
350:22, 350:23,
352:23, 354:19,
354:21, 356:5,
356:8, 356:11,
358:7, 358:24,
359:4, 360:9, 362:4,
362:6, 362:10,
362:11, 362:20,
363:22, 364:8,
364:13, 364:15,
365:10, 365:15,
365:24, 367:5,
367:21, 367:22,
367:23, 367:25,
368:4, 368:9,
368:17, 368:18,
369:4, 369:5, 370:1,
370:3, 370:4, 372:9,
373:24, 374:25,
376:1, 378:5,
378:12, 381:7,
381:10, 382:1,
382:2, 382:3, 382:5,
382:14, 382:15,
382:16, 382:20,
382:21, 383:7,
383:18, 383:20,
384:6, 384:8,
384:10, 384:13,
384:19, 384:20,
384:21, 384:24,
384:25, 385:2,
385:13, 385:14,
386:8, 386:15,
387:1, 387:2, 387:3,
387:6, 387:12,
387:13, 387:16,
387:17, 387:20,
388:2, 388:4,
388:10, 388:12,
388:18, 388:19,
389:2, 389:9,
389:13, 389:22,
390:3, 390:4,
390:12, 390:22,
390:24, 391:8,
391:9, 391:25,
396:5, 396:11,
396:13, 398:18,
399:16, 399:18,
399:21, 399:23,
400:5, 400:24,
401:7, 401:8, 401:9,
401:12, 401:13,
401:17, 403:7,
403:8, 406:3, 406:7,
406:16, 407:1,
407:8, 407:12,
407:17, 407:18,
414:2, 414:8,
415:24, 416:2,
416:7, 416:8,
417:21, 417:22,
418:1, 418:2, 418:3,
418:9, 418:11,
422:9, 425:17,
432:4, 442:24,
446:23, 447:1,
447:17, 447:19,
447:21, 449:17,
449:24, 449:25,
450:13, 450:16,
450:23, 455:9
band [6] - 405:4,
405:5, 405:8, 405:9,
409:18, 410:2
bands [2] - 387:7,
409:23
bargaining [6] - 28:19,
31:1, 31:8, 31:13,
32:3, 334:14
base [2] - 201:10,
316:6
baseball [2] - 12:7,
56:23
Based [1] - 273:11
based [78] - 19:17,
28:8, 32:25, 41:23,
41:24, 41:25, 42:1,
42:2, 43:13, 46:21,
79:7, 114:21,
139:16, 163:3,
166:17, 208:17,
209:12, 209:13,
209:19, 209:22,
214:9, 215:15,
220:3, 222:15,
224:1, 224:5, 225:3,
225:9, 226:22,
236:11, 236:18,
242:3, 243:19,
244:19, 246:5,
247:1, 255:13,
256:4, 256:9, 274:4,
274:16, 290:23,
301:12, 303:1,
303:24, 304:12,
308:7, 308:22,
308:23, 319:14,
324:15, 327:8,
327:11, 349:3,
349:5, 352:19,
354:2, 354:6,
354:10, 354:17,
357:24, 358:11,
361:13, 362:5,
362:6, 362:21,
363:4, 391:24,
398:13, 404:17,
410:9, 417:9,
421:13, 435:4,
436:12, 446:5,
447:22, 455:6
bases [1] - 225:12
basic [10] - 33:1, 34:2,
162:22, 167:14,
169:8, 185:22,
201:20, 216:18,
446:12
basis [21] - 8:6, 10:4,
19:16, 20:22, 21:4,
36:23, 37:7, 41:1,
83:14, 127:23,
165:17, 203:22,
218:24, 285:14,
296:5, 334:11,
372:22, 386:9,
387:23, 404:4,
437:13
Basketball [1] 322:17
Bat [1] - 80:2
Bates [3] - 104:12,
222:1, 367:15
bathroom [3] - 34:20,
317:4, 317:6
baton [1] - 150:4
bear [2] - 295:16,
296:9
bearing [1] - 28:14
bears [1] - 279:2
became [6] - 40:4,
117:16, 230:25,
347:5, 413:22,
415:12
Becker [1] - 152:16
125 of 172 sheets
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
274:2, 274:9,
274:17, 275:7,
275:16, 275:22,
275:25, 276:22,
276:24, 293:6,
304:9, 304:17,
305:3, 305:11,
306:4, 310:20,
311:9, 311:13,
312:15, 313:5,
314:2, 314:6,
316:24, 325:22,
326:2, 326:5, 326:7,
326:10, 326:15,
331:15, 332:1,
332:20, 334:21,
335:8, 335:15,
336:12, 336:20,
336:24, 339:3,
340:25, 341:4,
341:20, 396:15,
400:17, 401:4
BRADY [13] - 1:5,
3:21, 4:3, 4:9, 5:15,
401:3, 401:5,
401:18, 401:21,
401:25, 402:6,
402:14, 402:17
Brady's [17] - 26:12,
32:19, 39:6, 39:18,
43:10, 44:2, 44:9,
48:11, 149:19,
271:5, 279:3, 312:8,
313:15, 313:19,
331:22, 333:10,
337:8
brain [3] - 94:20, 95:5,
144:23
brand [4] - 49:9,
68:23, 69:12, 76:13
brand-new [1] - 68:23
breach [2] - 34:21,
234:4
break [34] - 49:10,
49:14, 49:18, 50:10,
52:20, 53:18, 53:19,
54:4, 54:9, 56:21,
66:24, 67:1, 68:23,
69:21, 70:24, 76:15,
77:9, 88:12, 99:22,
99:25, 148:8, 166:1,
194:15, 247:6,
260:22, 260:23,
294:13, 315:14,
317:3, 317:6,
343:20, 395:18,
395:22
breaking [5] - 56:21,
69:10, 76:12, 76:25,
88:18
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
367:19
bump [3] - 168:12,
174:6, 175:20
bunch [4] - 76:21,
219:7, 328:14,
351:12
burden [2] - 31:10,
41:14
BURLING [1] - 2:10
burns [2] - 333:20,
335:11
BURNS [1] - 3:17
bus [1] - 276:20
business [4] - 16:1,
153:4, 153:25, 447:9
Business [1] - 151:5
buy [1] - 301:19
BY [33] - 1:22, 2:4,
2:12, 2:16, 2:22, 3:4,
3:11, 3:17, 3:22, 4:5,
47:9, 100:6, 139:4,
143:12, 150:12,
194:20, 227:24,
251:7, 255:9,
259:15, 261:7,
321:25, 340:19,
345:7, 373:9,
402:20, 408:4,
411:22, 427:18,
438:3, 439:19,
448:12, 454:20
C
C-A-L-I-G-I-U-R-I [1] 345:12
calculate [4] - 420:5,
424:9, 424:11,
424:13
calculated [7] 166:13, 364:11,
365:8, 372:21,
381:23, 418:20,
432:14
calculates [1] - 372:4
calculation [1] 375:13
calculations [5] 365:22, 371:3,
372:1, 375:21,
442:10
calibrated [10] 184:25, 216:20,
218:16, 294:20,
294:24, 302:1,
302:4, 316:10,
353:18, 426:21
calibration [6] 372:16, 372:20,
377:4, 377:6, 377:7,
Page 8 to 8 of 54
378:22
California [2] - 4:4,
346:2
Caligiuri [18] - 345:2,
345:11, 345:13,
354:2, 371:14,
373:13, 373:16,
373:19, 373:20,
396:1, 402:22,
413:11, 416:5,
425:2, 425:20,
426:4, 426:11, 429:9
CALIGIURI [2] - 4:14,
5:22
Callendar [2] - 307:5,
307:12
calm [1] - 251:21
camp [2] - 55:12,
75:16
candid [2] - 306:11,
323:11
candidly [1] - 20:3
cannot [4] - 221:11,
242:10, 357:15,
358:9
capable [1] - 355:7
capacity [1] - 323:7
captures [1] - 445:8
cards [2] - 105:19,
106:12
care [4] - 110:5,
276:16, 284:12,
347:18
cared [1] - 147:12
career [7] - 48:1, 51:4,
51:6, 54:6, 58:1,
119:20, 151:11
careful [4] - 165:15,
241:19, 252:8,
349:24
carefully [4] - 184:23,
263:6, 349:18,
444:14
Carnegie [1] - 412:11
Carolina [2] - 246:13,
259:25
carried [3] - 189:11,
407:4, 419:17
case [44] - 8:16, 11:3,
24:4, 29:18, 36:6,
36:7, 36:18, 44:18,
46:8, 71:4, 97:13,
169:1, 174:4, 174:6,
174:12, 176:8,
178:9, 178:11,
187:25, 200:7,
218:14, 242:5,
242:7, 247:11,
270:4, 290:20,
290:23, 301:17,
303:17, 304:5,
317:20, 317:23,
321:16, 323:20,
342:10, 352:10,
381:1, 383:22,
383:23, 395:11,
417:18, 434:12,
437:8, 441:11
Case [6] - 176:10,
176:11, 221:24,
417:24, 420:5,
420:11
caselaw [1] - 46:21
cases [24] - 27:1, 36:5,
45:23, 154:21,
154:24, 167:7,
174:4, 188:7, 196:5,
196:6, 196:10,
196:14, 208:22,
245:6, 317:14,
322:24, 324:22,
325:2, 381:1, 381:3,
417:17, 433:24,
434:6, 437:1
cash [1] - 136:4
catch [1] - 54:5
caught [2] - 249:2,
324:18
caused [6] - 34:11,
328:5, 328:13,
329:16, 350:25,
355:14
causes [12] - 17:1,
373:23, 388:1,
388:14, 388:21,
389:6, 389:10,
389:24, 390:6,
390:21, 392:20,
408:21
causing [2] - 355:2,
396:6
caution [1] - 157:7
cautious [1] - 435:6
Cave [1] - 80:2
CBA [7] - 9:21, 28:3,
29:1, 29:8, 31:21,
36:1, 40:23
celebrity [1] - 43:11
cell [14] - 87:2, 87:5,
87:10, 87:11, 87:15,
87:17, 87:18, 87:25,
88:4, 89:10, 103:6,
109:19, 305:21,
337:10
centered [1] - 76:24
central [1] - 445:8
CERN [2] - 441:3,
453:2
certain [10] - 22:15,
40:9, 49:5, 104:25,
110:12, 205:10,
214:16, 315:6,
315:12, 436:20
certainly [20] - 15:17,
35:6, 36:22, 39:22,
41:3, 42:9, 99:19,
121:12, 144:12,
194:9, 215:3, 266:5,
272:25, 374:3,
378:24, 407:21,
407:23, 420:22,
437:6
certainty [4] - 40:22,
316:16, 317:16,
317:18
certified [1] - 334:12
Certified [1] - 457:13
certify [1] - 457:8
cetera [1] - 250:24
chain [2] - 18:14,
335:18
chair [4] - 295:17,
440:10, 440:12,
440:14
challenging [2] 222:18, 223:4
championship [4] 13:6, 114:10, 115:5,
115:8
Championship [42] 33:3, 37:18, 41:7,
66:21, 67:13, 68:15,
68:17, 68:19, 69:20,
76:17, 78:10, 85:23,
94:17, 96:11,
103:12, 103:15,
103:20, 121:1,
123:1, 124:8,
124:25, 125:2,
125:22, 141:21,
143:18, 146:1,
155:8, 189:3, 217:4,
229:13, 229:16,
251:11, 261:17,
263:17, 288:3,
293:8, 296:19,
304:11, 306:8,
327:18, 334:8, 359:1
chance [19] - 11:17,
61:23, 76:21, 165:6,
167:10, 167:22,
207:21, 208:24,
208:25, 210:9,
210:16, 222:8,
222:9, 222:10,
287:11, 287:14,
328:3, 328:5, 421:6
change [37] - 9:18,
17:20, 34:2, 46:17,
51:13, 64:4, 64:6,
127 of 172 sheets
275:14, 275:16
cited [5] - 9:23, 15:12,
22:22, 250:19,
311:22
cites [1] - 78:5
citing [1] - 426:8
citizens [1] - 20:24
civil [5] - 31:11,
324:22, 325:3,
433:24, 434:12
claim [8] - 205:17,
285:19, 416:20,
417:5, 418:17,
425:24, 449:7, 450:6
claimed [1] - 418:7
claims [3] - 91:21,
249:20, 445:22
clarification [1] 299:2
clarify [1] - 261:18
clarifying [1] - 264:20
clarity [1] - 290:4
Clark [1] - 152:17
class [2] - 281:9,
444:9
classes [1] - 152:12
clear [44] - 7:6, 11:5,
12:6, 22:12, 26:16,
27:23, 37:15, 41:22,
51:5, 56:17, 61:12,
72:8, 74:20, 96:9,
122:19, 125:20,
137:22, 177:5,
208:4, 221:15,
226:20, 233:14,
241:14, 241:15,
241:21, 242:1,
244:13, 280:7,
289:24, 304:16,
314:6, 314:8, 325:1,
325:10, 326:1,
336:17, 336:20,
348:19, 397:16,
399:9, 421:1, 445:8,
445:25, 446:15
clearer [2] - 413:22,
415:12
clearest [1] - 444:20
clearly [9] - 22:23,
31:2, 34:21, 35:11,
218:21, 271:9,
302:19, 445:2
Clete [2] - 251:24,
407:20
client [14] - 266:11,
266:16, 266:21,
267:15, 267:16,
268:12, 271:12,
271:16, 271:21,
284:8, 323:6,
Page 9 to 9 of 54
333:21, 334:7
clients [1] - 345:23
clock [3] - 415:20,
416:9, 416:11
close [9] - 131:5,
165:19, 165:23,
166:2, 218:15,
280:11, 302:2,
418:23
closed [1] - 395:7
closer [1] - 425:19
closes [1] - 21:10
cloud [2] - 312:20,
339:7
CLR [1] - 1:23
club [11] - 22:11,
22:23, 22:24, 22:25,
23:14, 24:5, 99:7,
120:21, 120:23,
252:21
clubhouse [1] 288:24
clubs [3] - 46:9, 46:16,
250:23
Clubs [1] - 98:14
co [5] - 152:16,
261:16, 261:19,
262:18, 310:3
co-lead [3] - 261:16,
261:19, 310:3
co-taught [1] - 152:16
coach [2] - 53:4,
332:21
Coach [6] - 142:13,
142:17, 143:2,
322:17, 326:6, 326:8
coaches [5] - 22:11,
22:25, 80:6, 99:8,
122:13
coefficient [2] - 425:7,
425:9
cold [8] - 16:18, 23:22,
234:16, 238:15,
257:8, 291:5,
292:19, 314:23
colder [2] - 169:11,
178:16
colleague [3] 155:12, 270:3,
413:11
colleagues [6] 29:21, 89:19, 89:22,
264:19, 264:25,
269:24
collect [5] - 19:12,
151:13, 314:12,
314:15, 323:2
collected [11] 151:22, 151:24,
152:24, 157:14,
189:2, 219:7,
327:12, 350:1,
358:20, 358:21,
380:4
collection [1] - 153:2
collective [8] - 28:19,
31:1, 31:7, 31:13,
32:3, 291:21,
324:14, 334:14
college [2] - 47:14,
53:4
Collider [1] - 441:3
Colts [66] - 66:22,
116:16, 160:15,
160:25, 161:17,
161:23, 168:16,
180:10, 189:25,
200:20, 229:18,
229:23, 230:8,
235:12, 236:3,
236:7, 236:20,
239:19, 239:24,
239:25, 240:4,
240:12, 240:17,
287:9, 293:12,
293:15, 293:21,
294:1, 294:2, 294:4,
294:7, 295:4, 295:7,
295:25, 296:3,
297:9, 310:17,
318:21, 320:4,
350:24, 351:1,
354:23, 356:6,
356:11, 358:15,
364:15, 368:7,
375:12, 376:3,
376:8, 381:17,
382:5, 383:5,
403:19, 403:21,
419:10, 419:15,
420:2, 424:7,
424:13, 437:5,
438:24, 439:1, 439:3
Colts' [110] - 16:19,
18:23, 18:24, 33:5,
144:9, 159:5, 160:3,
160:9, 161:4,
162:23, 163:7,
163:13, 163:17,
164:3, 164:8,
164:10, 164:22,
167:14, 167:16,
167:24, 168:5,
168:18, 169:21,
171:2, 171:5,
171:21, 172:22,
174:8, 174:17,
174:23, 176:14,
176:23, 178:16,
179:7, 181:4,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 10
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 128 of 172
182:11, 182:16,
189:8, 190:24,
191:10, 192:21,
193:4, 197:7,
200:18, 205:5,
206:11, 215:14,
224:9, 224:11,
236:24, 240:9,
240:18, 240:20,
289:4, 318:14,
318:15, 318:19,
318:20, 328:2,
350:23, 354:20,
358:7, 358:24,
362:6, 362:9,
362:11, 364:12,
367:21, 367:22,
367:25, 368:4,
368:9, 368:17,
369:5, 370:3,
373:24, 376:15,
381:7, 381:10,
382:1, 382:2,
382:14, 382:20,
383:7, 383:18,
383:20, 384:25,
386:8, 387:3,
387:13, 387:20,
391:9, 403:8,
409:13, 414:8,
416:1, 417:20,
418:1, 418:2, 418:3,
419:18, 420:2,
423:24, 434:25,
438:17, 442:23,
449:25, 450:15,
450:22
Columbia [12] - 280:9,
280:10, 280:13,
280:14, 280:20,
280:25, 281:1,
281:2, 281:14,
281:22, 282:18,
347:20
Columbia's [2] 280:17, 281:7
column [7] - 160:23,
160:24, 161:1,
161:21, 330:7, 330:8
combination [4] 8:18, 192:7, 194:7,
358:3
combinations [2] 368:24, 369:16
combine [1] - 317:5
comfort [2] - 49:7,
317:10
comfortable [3] 194:10, 316:18,
317:7
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
189:21, 192:11,
194:18, 221:25,
225:19, 226:6,
227:19, 230:3,
230:6, 233:13,
252:2, 256:23,
257:1, 260:20,
277:15, 386:4,
396:7, 397:11,
398:3, 398:6, 399:8,
400:16, 400:20,
400:25, 401:15,
401:19, 401:22,
402:1, 402:12,
402:15, 404:1,
436:9, 439:14,
454:1, 454:4,
454:15, 457:4
Commissioner [54] 2:5, 7:17, 22:14,
25:16, 28:19, 33:9,
40:6, 40:13, 40:20,
42:3, 45:5, 46:7,
48:12, 48:19, 48:23,
52:6, 55:25, 56:3,
62:8, 66:23, 77:1,
77:7, 78:24, 80:1,
83:9, 89:8, 90:16,
91:20, 97:17, 99:8,
99:17, 99:20,
105:12, 111:6,
145:23, 149:8,
155:22, 158:20,
168:11, 194:12,
225:21, 226:16,
228:23, 229:8,
243:17, 309:22,
309:25, 337:5,
343:7, 392:17,
395:16, 456:7,
456:9, 456:20
Commissioner's [3] 171:18, 259:18,
396:9
committee [5] - 65:12,
65:14, 66:5, 97:18,
97:23
common [6] - 165:2,
165:3, 181:10,
181:11, 433:13,
449:1
communicate [2] 133:6, 146:19
communicated [4] 39:11, 125:11,
125:15, 332:2
communicating [2] 62:18, 130:18
Communications [1] 124:25
Page 10 to 10 of 54
communications [13]
- 8:15, 84:19, 90:20,
109:7, 265:11,
266:6, 266:12,
268:11, 276:5,
332:4, 332:19,
332:24, 333:22
community [1] 154:15
company [4] - 89:12,
307:8, 345:20,
345:22
company's [1] 345:18
comparable [2] 44:22, 45:8
compare [4] - 292:23,
374:20, 382:4, 419:8
compared [17] 159:5, 160:24,
161:24, 163:5,
163:9, 172:12,
178:16, 182:11,
185:16, 193:14,
224:7, 234:16,
361:25, 379:10,
382:9, 382:20, 422:1
compares [1] - 372:5
comparing [7] 163:16, 362:18,
372:25, 374:15,
394:4, 403:2, 403:23
comparison [5] 182:22, 183:25,
184:17, 361:21,
419:24
compelled [4] - 8:3,
8:13, 8:24, 10:19
compensated [1] 270:16
compensation [1] 196:22
competition [5] 65:12, 65:14, 66:5,
97:18, 97:23
competitive [6] 24:15, 25:20, 46:15,
250:18, 272:5,
311:22
Competitive [4] 24:24, 98:17, 98:24,
99:10
complained [2] 12:19, 118:21
completely [3] - 11:7,
169:9, 430:25
complex [1] - 427:20
compliance [4] 238:3, 238:10,
240:19, 240:22
Page 11
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 129 of 172
222:18, 223:3,
223:6, 223:22,
225:15, 238:7,
286:1, 309:4,
323:17, 354:11,
362:8, 363:13,
366:9, 369:17,
370:17, 371:25,
388:15, 388:18,
390:21, 392:24,
421:15
conclusions [71] 8:18, 8:19, 8:23,
32:24, 41:23, 66:8,
159:8, 159:9,
165:12, 165:17,
166:4, 167:5, 176:6,
178:8, 181:23,
182:4, 189:1,
190:14, 190:19,
194:8, 201:11,
207:23, 208:14,
209:21, 210:4,
211:17, 222:14,
225:6, 267:4, 268:9,
269:17, 285:6,
285:9, 285:14,
285:15, 304:5,
316:12, 317:24,
317:25, 325:6,
326:14, 331:1,
331:8, 354:3, 354:5,
354:10, 355:9,
355:23, 356:13,
356:16, 356:25,
357:18, 358:11,
361:8, 361:13,
363:17, 366:13,
367:11, 371:17,
373:5, 416:14,
427:12, 444:15,
444:22, 444:25,
445:1, 446:5,
447:25, 448:9
condition [1] - 120:5
conditioner [4] - 53:3,
53:17, 54:9, 55:3
conditions [8] 182:13, 352:22,
353:4, 357:23,
359:5, 366:23,
422:3, 439:8
conduct [31] - 9:6,
9:24, 25:6, 29:3,
29:11, 29:16, 31:14,
31:18, 32:2, 32:8,
32:20, 33:15, 35:24,
36:4, 36:12, 36:13,
38:15, 42:11, 42:18,
42:20, 42:24, 46:14,
201:5, 202:4,
248:13, 263:14,
305:25, 322:7,
326:16
Conduct [3] - 9:22,
22:16, 25:4
conducted [16] 23:13, 29:3, 30:24,
101:10, 157:24,
197:9, 204:15,
209:12, 244:13,
255:3, 263:19,
264:3, 272:3,
309:19, 327:11,
358:23
conducting [6] 264:9, 270:17,
272:9, 322:6,
338:20, 357:1
confer [2] - 6:24,
342:18
conference [3] 142:14, 142:24,
309:17
confession [1] - 95:19
confidential [3] 280:16, 280:23,
344:17
confidentiality [3] 282:23, 344:2, 344:3
confirm [1] - 304:3
confirmed [1] - 306:18
confirming [1] - 334:9
confirms [1] - 332:11
conflating [1] - 32:6
conflict [1] - 323:5
confused [3] - 300:15,
325:15, 402:9
confusion [7] 241:10, 402:24,
403:15, 442:18,
445:23, 449:12,
449:15
connect [1] - 420:22
Connecticut [1] - 3:21
connection [19] 85:22, 104:9,
110:13, 110:17,
196:18, 196:22,
197:1, 197:2,
198:19, 203:4,
261:16, 279:23,
309:22, 310:2,
310:22, 311:4,
312:24, 347:23,
366:18
connects [1] - 154:14
conscious [1] 283:14
consensus [1] -
455:16
conservative [1] 455:18
consider [20] - 31:6,
32:16, 37:13, 38:3,
40:15, 177:20,
180:6, 183:16,
191:3, 207:11,
267:15, 280:2,
330:1, 344:14,
348:11, 366:17,
368:4, 377:1, 377:3,
423:25
consideration [2] 14:2, 416:15
considered [14] 30:3, 30:6, 30:13,
33:11, 33:25, 180:9,
182:21, 192:18,
207:12, 315:18,
333:24, 335:12,
367:8, 374:3
considering [3] 31:25, 32:15, 180:5
consist [1] - 8:12
consisted [1] - 199:2
consistency [5] 27:7, 27:9, 27:12,
46:24, 117:1
consistent [21] 26:24, 27:3, 41:4,
41:13, 44:1, 45:17,
147:24, 157:9,
188:11, 249:11,
294:9, 301:24,
302:24, 370:17,
375:22, 375:23,
403:13, 404:5,
420:8, 426:22,
431:20
consistently [12] 162:4, 186:15,
187:12, 216:2,
220:11, 294:25,
316:8, 355:13,
355:17, 355:21,
367:5, 446:21
consolidate [1] 395:18
constantly [1] - 43:14
constituents [1] 440:25
constituted [1] 155:16
Constitution [1] - 28:5
constrained [1] 386:13
consult [2] - 456:6,
456:23
consultancy [1] Page 11 to 11 of 54
155:18
consultant [2] - 103:4,
283:5
consulted [2] 156:12, 156:14
consulting [8] 152:11, 153:12,
156:19, 195:14,
195:17, 195:20,
281:25, 345:22
consumer [1] - 346:15
contact [8] - 51:2,
90:24, 122:17,
131:5, 131:6,
280:23, 281:16,
313:5
contacted [2] 280:17, 281:12
contacts [2] - 37:20,
91:2
contain [2] - 320:22,
455:22
contained [1] - 330:13
contains [1] - 34:9
contemporaneously
[1] - 306:23
content [11] - 90:18,
107:17, 110:18,
110:22, 112:8,
112:13, 112:17,
338:2, 338:5, 338:7,
338:8
contents [1] - 269:4
context [22] - 8:13,
10:19, 32:16, 39:13,
40:17, 41:6, 41:11,
52:7, 61:23, 62:14,
92:25, 121:5,
121:11, 135:14,
138:21, 163:22,
277:2, 428:11,
434:20, 436:3,
436:23, 438:9
continue [7] - 66:24,
66:25, 181:23,
226:19, 321:22,
402:2, 449:13
continued [5] - 2:25,
3:1, 3:25, 4:1,
181:19
continues [2] 164:13, 164:14
continuing [1] 372:13
continuously [4] 397:18, 398:1,
398:4, 398:5
contract [4] - 28:4,
36:1, 36:3, 334:12
contracts [1] - 90:21
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 12
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 130 of 172
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
215:2, 216:9,
216:25, 217:25,
218:3, 218:4, 220:4,
221:13, 221:17,
221:18, 222:5,
222:11, 224:2,
224:16, 226:13,
228:20, 229:8,
229:9, 234:3, 234:8,
234:21, 234:25,
235:3, 235:7,
235:15, 235:22,
236:8, 236:9,
236:12, 237:15,
238:12, 238:17,
239:4, 239:7, 239:8,
239:12, 239:13,
239:22, 239:23,
240:2, 240:3, 240:9,
240:10, 241:1,
241:2, 241:7, 241:8,
242:7, 245:9,
250:22, 250:25,
251:1, 256:6,
256:13, 256:16,
256:17, 257:5,
257:12, 258:5,
258:13, 258:21,
260:5, 263:7,
263:24, 264:4,
264:7, 269:23,
270:5, 270:8,
271:10, 272:10,
272:11, 273:3,
273:21, 274:18,
274:25, 276:6,
277:3, 277:6,
285:10, 285:11,
285:20, 285:21,
286:9, 286:11,
288:19, 288:25,
289:1, 289:6, 289:7,
289:11, 289:21,
289:23, 290:15,
292:2, 292:5, 292:6,
295:24, 295:25,
296:1, 296:8,
296:25, 297:8,
297:10, 297:11,
297:14, 297:17,
299:18, 300:18,
301:12, 302:7,
303:13, 303:25,
304:5, 306:16,
307:21, 307:22,
307:24, 309:19,
309:20, 309:23,
313:8, 313:9, 315:3,
315:7, 315:13,
319:18, 320:23,
321:13, 323:16,
333:12, 339:13,
340:22, 341:8,
341:12, 341:20,
341:21, 341:23,
342:21, 351:24,
351:25, 359:2,
359:3, 359:7, 359:9,
359:10, 359:13,
359:14, 361:23,
362:12, 364:12,
364:21, 366:8,
367:12, 367:13,
375:3, 376:17,
376:19, 376:20,
378:17, 380:8,
387:4, 390:19,
392:8, 392:10,
392:11, 392:15,
394:15, 395:6,
396:3, 396:13,
396:18, 396:22,
398:11, 398:16,
399:20, 400:23,
404:15, 405:12,
405:13, 406:12,
408:18, 408:21,
409:4, 410:14,
413:25, 414:11,
414:14, 428:8,
428:16, 428:20,
429:1, 429:8,
429:11, 429:25,
430:1, 430:2,
430:18, 430:24,
431:4, 431:16,
432:6, 432:18,
432:25, 433:4,
433:17, 434:3,
434:4, 435:25,
445:1, 448:21,
450:5, 450:23,
450:24, 451:3,
452:8, 452:9,
452:13, 452:14,
455:2, 455:11, 457:9
corrected [2] - 308:15,
447:10
correcting [2] - 157:3,
220:12
correction [4] 187:15, 216:3,
447:13, 447:14
correctly [8] - 159:15,
183:21, 220:10,
241:12, 256:2,
263:7, 373:14,
401:24
correspond [2] 171:20, 417:21
correspondence [1] -
Page 12 to 12 of 54
226:16
Cortez [1] - 24:5
cost [1] - 342:5
costless [1] - 87:4
COUNCIL [4] - 2:15,
2:20, 4:13, 5:20
counsel [20] - 7:5,
11:1, 29:25, 86:19,
104:9, 110:7,
110:13, 110:21,
111:1, 140:10,
140:23, 256:3,
270:18, 321:1,
321:7, 321:11,
331:23, 395:9,
395:12
Counsel [4] - 2:17,
3:5, 3:6, 266:7
counsel's [1] - 410:5
count [3] - 196:5,
196:11, 226:8
counted [1] - 196:16
counterintuitive [1] 360:17
country [1] - 16:3
couple [11] - 124:9,
133:4, 145:24,
222:12, 261:24,
293:25, 318:4,
352:24, 416:24,
418:6, 444:17
course [16] - 9:19,
49:13, 57:7, 57:13,
129:23, 134:22,
152:21, 152:22,
152:25, 153:11,
154:3, 154:17,
156:13, 157:2,
443:15, 454:14
Court [1] - 434:13
court [7] - 6:6, 7:6,
211:6, 284:1, 284:3,
348:12, 348:17
court-appointed [3] 284:1, 348:12,
348:17
cover [3] - 98:10,
98:11, 168:10
covered [4] - 94:9,
94:12, 151:18,
163:23
covering [2] - 91:20,
289:17
covers [1] - 89:9
COVINGTON [1] 2:10
Crawford [1] - 440:3
create [2] - 12:12,
55:18
created [1] - 403:10
Page 13
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 131 of 172
343:8
cross-examining [3] 270:7, 270:22
crossed [1] - 115:9
CRR [2] - 1:23, 457:12
crunching [1] - 185:12
CRUTCHER [1] - 3:20
cubic [1] - 393:22
current [5] - 150:17,
228:4, 261:12,
440:2, 440:7
curve [16] - 171:24,
172:1, 182:19,
182:20, 183:5,
183:7, 352:14,
372:20, 372:21,
382:10, 382:12,
403:5, 404:19,
405:11, 405:20,
409:20
curves [4] - 198:10,
225:4, 417:19, 445:4
custody [1] - 18:14
custom [1] - 105:18
cut [2] - 265:1, 369:23
cycle [1] - 383:12
cycled [1] - 351:5
D
D'Qwell [1] - 191:8
D.C [2] - 2:21, 3:4
daily [1] - 83:14
damp [2] - 407:21,
407:23
Dan [3] - 97:25,
247:18, 439:11
Daniel [3] - 191:11,
192:12, 439:23
DANIEL [3] - 2:22,
4:14, 5:24
Daniels [2] - 191:12,
192:11
Darden [1] - 151:3
dare [1] - 18:3
darn [1] - 303:20
Darrel [1] - 258:19
Data [1] - 412:4
data [173] - 151:13,
151:14, 151:22,
151:24, 151:25,
152:6, 152:7,
152:13, 152:24,
153:2, 153:3,
153:14, 153:20,
153:23, 157:14,
157:15, 158:3,
159:20, 159:25,
160:5, 160:22,
161:7, 161:8,
131 of 172 sheets
161:13, 161:14,
162:5, 162:6, 162:7,
162:10, 166:10,
187:24, 189:2,
190:23, 190:25,
191:2, 191:3,
192:14, 192:18,
192:19, 192:24,
193:7, 193:23,
193:25, 208:14,
209:13, 215:2,
223:14, 224:2,
224:4, 224:14,
225:8, 283:4, 284:5,
289:11, 289:16,
303:23, 314:12,
315:15, 316:17,
318:7, 318:12,
320:9, 327:8,
327:12, 329:21,
337:13, 349:3,
349:7, 349:24,
350:1, 354:14,
354:15, 354:18,
358:20, 358:21,
361:4, 361:25,
362:7, 362:18,
363:5, 367:2, 368:7,
370:18, 372:22,
378:23, 382:11,
382:25, 386:12,
394:22, 403:17,
403:18, 404:5,
404:6, 404:11,
404:18, 413:16,
413:19, 413:20,
413:21, 415:6,
415:11, 415:15,
415:16, 417:3,
418:16, 419:7,
419:15, 419:18,
419:19, 419:25,
420:2, 421:10,
421:12, 421:13,
424:1, 424:6, 424:7,
426:14, 428:18,
429:3, 429:15,
431:22, 431:23,
432:21, 433:14,
435:5, 435:10,
435:13, 435:20,
435:23, 435:24,
435:25, 436:6,
436:7, 436:14,
436:15, 436:17,
436:21, 436:24,
437:9, 438:17,
438:21, 438:25,
439:6, 441:18,
443:14, 443:17,
446:18, 446:20,
446:21, 451:5,
451:6, 451:9,
451:15, 451:23,
452:2, 452:11,
452:25, 453:5,
453:6, 453:7,
454:11, 454:14,
454:23, 455:7,
455:19
date [10] - 40:4, 92:8,
106:25, 107:7,
107:11, 108:17,
302:14, 334:9,
338:4, 456:6
dated [4] - 105:12,
332:15, 333:17,
333:22
dates [2] - 102:13,
102:19
Dave [15] - 59:7,
59:12, 60:15, 61:1,
94:19, 95:4, 119:2,
122:11, 122:16,
144:23, 145:2,
145:6, 238:6, 252:20
DAVID [1] - 3:11
David [1] - 241:25
days [21] - 58:5,
59:13, 59:15, 59:16,
122:5, 123:9, 133:5,
133:13, 133:20,
252:21, 261:24,
282:6, 282:7,
286:25, 300:8,
306:25, 316:4,
316:5, 316:6, 417:10
DC [1] - 3:22
de [1] - 179:22
deal [7] - 45:20, 98:10,
156:23, 269:7,
313:21, 314:7
dealing [3] - 192:6,
262:10, 313:16
dealings [1] - 75:17
deals [1] - 90:22
dealt [3] - 14:9, 49:20,
153:14
dean [10] - 153:25,
154:2, 154:3,
154:12, 171:10,
194:1, 229:2,
363:20, 418:15
Dean [40] - 15:23,
16:1, 150:18,
150:24, 151:3,
151:6, 151:8,
160:13, 188:25,
190:19, 194:22,
194:23, 207:9,
228:25, 290:19,
Page 13 to 13 of 54
326:20, 359:9,
359:11, 361:5,
361:12, 363:15,
364:7, 365:7,
365:20, 366:5,
366:11, 367:14,
375:19, 414:11,
414:16, 416:15,
416:21, 417:6,
417:15, 421:4,
426:10, 438:7,
438:16, 445:11,
447:23
Dear [1] - 333:17
decades [2] - 151:25,
156:16
December [1] - 103:25
decide [7] - 28:8,
40:24, 48:23, 69:17,
85:5, 201:9, 309:8
decided [11] - 68:23,
71:1, 118:4, 128:19,
190:17, 283:1,
292:7, 318:12,
318:13, 341:15,
452:6
deciding [3] - 50:18,
317:10, 456:12
decision [30] - 8:20,
10:13, 14:10, 21:18,
55:10, 85:3, 154:23,
230:16, 237:22,
237:23, 244:8,
303:24, 303:25,
304:13, 304:16,
318:6, 319:22,
324:10, 324:23,
329:23, 335:23,
433:20, 433:23,
436:12, 436:17,
436:18, 452:1,
452:3, 453:18,
456:20
decision-maker [1] 433:23
decisions [6] - 27:19,
245:7, 262:15,
304:19, 317:22,
329:25
deck [5] - 158:18,
197:20, 215:19,
222:2, 222:14
declaration [11] 13:19, 14:8, 15:20,
39:5, 39:17, 40:2,
43:6, 107:1, 149:9,
149:15, 149:16
Declaration [7] - 39:2,
101:23, 106:23,
149:7, 225:24,
226:2, 226:3
declarations [4] 148:24, 149:17,
149:18, 225:25
decline [7] - 305:5,
305:10, 333:25,
334:3, 335:13,
335:23, 336:10
declined [5] - 305:1,
341:19, 341:20,
341:21, 341:22
declining [2] - 305:14,
334:2
decrease [3] - 200:19,
253:1, 327:14
deep [2] - 156:10
defendant [1] - 284:10
defense [3] - 36:21,
236:14, 384:6
definitely [5] - 70:15,
179:3, 183:3, 279:1,
443:12
deflate [12] - 11:12,
16:17, 40:8, 74:11,
75:5, 79:15, 93:25,
94:5, 97:9, 273:24,
274:18, 292:19
deflated [14] - 33:4,
35:9, 35:21, 121:3,
121:8, 141:11,
141:14, 144:9,
164:8, 164:9,
184:13, 276:2, 276:7
Deflategate [3] 261:22, 267:2,
322:11
deflating [5] - 85:17,
85:21, 90:1, 135:2
deflation [31] - 34:4,
34:10, 100:18,
100:24, 101:4,
101:8, 103:16,
112:24, 113:5,
136:4, 140:6, 141:3,
141:17, 142:14,
143:3, 145:4,
145:10, 145:19,
155:7, 181:12,
191:19, 210:8,
243:2, 274:8,
276:15, 277:2,
277:5, 278:17,
304:10, 306:7,
332:20
deflator [3] - 135:9,
136:4, 316:22
Degree [1] - 156:15
degree [9] - 7:22,
149:5, 194:23,
221:7, 317:16,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 14
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 132 of 172
317:18, 346:21,
383:19, 412:9
degrees [13] - 220:17,
257:5, 291:1,
352:23, 364:25,
365:4, 365:18,
365:25, 372:2,
372:3, 412:10
delay [1] - 416:1
delegating [1] - 28:5
delegation [5] - 27:15,
27:21, 28:2, 28:21,
242:10
deliberate [2] - 10:13,
267:8
deliberations [1] 267:9
delivered [8] - 215:25,
216:7, 217:3,
217:11, 217:23,
218:6, 218:10,
364:15
delta [2] - 328:1, 370:6
demand [1] - 305:21
demonstrated [1] 431:20
denial [1] - 40:16
denied [4] - 306:6,
326:2, 326:3, 326:7
departed [1] - 308:3
Department [7] 152:3, 280:10,
280:14, 280:18,
280:21, 281:16,
281:21
department [7] 228:11, 347:11,
440:10, 440:12,
440:14, 440:15,
440:16
departure [1] - 413:13
DePASO [1] - 3:4
dependence [1] 172:7
dependent [6] 169:16, 213:21,
215:4, 352:8, 357:4,
429:25
depositions [2] 434:7, 434:10
derive [1] - 165:12
derived [1] - 243:13
describe [35] - 30:4,
80:1, 83:9, 163:15,
184:2, 186:18,
200:8, 200:12,
211:7, 211:8,
251:13, 251:15,
264:8, 346:19,
347:3, 348:22,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
349:13, 350:19,
353:10, 353:22,
354:5, 354:9,
356:25, 358:10,
359:11, 372:11,
403:4, 403:9,
405:14, 412:7,
412:12, 413:5,
414:13, 441:12,
442:4
described [22] - 54:21,
108:20, 131:16,
137:23, 187:7,
189:25, 193:4,
211:25, 216:5,
237:24, 255:12,
259:19, 267:1,
354:3, 359:12,
367:12, 419:2,
419:3, 438:7,
447:23, 448:4
describes [5] - 37:3,
106:11, 253:20,
350:16, 359:16
describing [1] - 211:9
description [3] 261:18, 367:16,
445:13
designated [1] 441:13
despite [11] - 96:17,
159:6, 211:3,
222:16, 262:17,
264:20, 302:9,
344:8, 361:15,
427:20, 446:6
destination [1] 413:14
destroy [7] - 87:9,
91:6, 105:19,
105:20, 106:11,
106:12, 108:8
destroyed [8] - 39:21,
88:5, 106:17,
106:18, 107:25,
108:2, 108:13, 337:1
destroying [1] - 87:8
destruction [2] 106:4, 108:4
detail [4] - 291:9,
349:14, 444:8,
447:11
details [4] - 33:21,
212:3, 417:12,
418:21
detecting [1] - 435:14
determination [3] 118:1, 118:22,
290:12
determinations [1] -
252:14
determine [21] 112:23, 113:4,
204:21, 205:2,
205:23, 206:8,
206:15, 206:21,
212:18, 213:5,
272:13, 311:11,
314:13, 327:7,
327:13, 346:14,
349:2, 349:8,
349:21, 380:14,
388:1
determined [6] 76:22, 200:21,
223:13, 328:8,
354:24, 362:2
determining [1] 373:22
Detrimental [1] - 25:5
detrimental [21] - 9:7,
9:24, 29:3, 29:4,
29:11, 29:17, 31:14,
32:2, 32:8, 32:20,
33:15, 35:25, 36:4,
36:12, 36:13, 38:15,
42:11, 42:19, 46:14,
326:16
developed [6] 166:14, 183:2,
190:17, 328:19,
328:21, 328:22
developing [2] 153:4, 190:8
development [2] 442:14, 443:3
develops [1] - 154:6
deviation [3] - 405:6,
408:25, 421:8
deviations [2] 404:22, 405:7
device [2] - 105:20,
106:13
devices [2] - 102:5,
102:8
Diego [1] - 412:15
differ [2] - 192:5,
415:7
difference [138] - 13:9,
17:4, 54:19, 73:9,
120:19, 157:19,
158:23, 158:24,
159:7, 160:19,
163:10, 163:19,
163:21, 164:20,
164:24, 165:5,
166:15, 166:16,
166:18, 167:12,
169:20, 173:5,
173:6, 173:10,
Page 14 to 14 of 54
173:13, 173:23,
175:9, 175:12,
175:17, 175:20,
177:18, 177:21,
177:22, 178:7,
179:12, 179:13,
179:14, 179:16,
179:21, 181:17,
181:20, 186:2,
186:3, 197:7,
197:23, 198:4,
198:5, 199:7,
199:20, 200:6,
200:7, 200:18,
200:24, 201:25,
202:5, 203:7,
203:11, 203:21,
204:11, 204:13,
205:4, 205:16,
206:10, 206:17,
207:18, 207:19,
208:18, 213:22,
213:23, 215:5,
215:11, 223:7,
223:20, 224:9,
225:14, 287:7,
327:14, 327:19,
327:25, 328:5,
349:11, 350:10,
354:22, 355:13,
355:25, 356:2,
356:10, 356:23,
357:6, 357:15,
358:9, 358:14,
359:18, 362:21,
363:6, 363:7,
367:17, 367:20,
368:16, 380:9,
414:7, 414:18,
415:8, 416:23,
418:25, 427:1,
427:2, 432:19,
433:21, 435:7,
435:11, 442:23,
445:18, 450:15,
453:16
differences [28] 158:23, 160:14,
160:20, 163:19,
163:24, 167:12,
173:24, 179:16,
205:25, 215:7,
360:22, 363:7,
367:17, 367:20,
380:10, 387:8,
395:5, 396:6,
413:17, 418:25,
419:8, 422:6, 422:9,
426:24, 427:6,
450:22, 453:17
different [52] - 10:8,
Page 15
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 133 of 172
Page 15 to 15 of 54
432:6, 454:22
draft [3] - 267:25,
269:16, 269:24
drafted [1] - 47:16
drafter [1] - 269:23
drafts [3] - 265:5,
265:15, 444:18
draw [10] - 38:22,
44:12, 167:1, 167:4,
178:8, 182:4,
190:14, 209:21,
210:4, 337:6
drawing [1] - 210:6
drawn [1] - 417:13
draws [3] - 222:14,
361:13, 446:4
Drew [1] - 64:11
drew [1] - 159:8
dried [3] - 383:13,
383:16, 383:19
drill [1] - 309:7
driver [1] - 276:21
drop [39] - 162:23,
163:4, 164:15,
167:8, 167:20,
174:24, 200:17,
208:23, 213:22,
287:8, 287:10,
314:13, 314:23,
354:20, 355:25,
358:14, 367:23,
368:17, 370:6,
384:12, 388:2,
388:3, 400:12,
402:9, 414:7, 415:7,
416:23, 416:25,
418:1, 418:5, 420:1,
420:3, 425:11,
425:14, 425:18,
427:5, 427:7, 434:22
dropped [2] - 163:12,
223:21
drops [29] - 157:20,
158:24, 158:25,
163:10, 163:16,
163:21, 166:18,
177:18, 197:7,
197:23, 199:20,
205:4, 206:1,
206:10, 221:12,
349:12, 350:11,
355:14, 356:23,
357:6, 357:11,
357:16, 359:19,
414:18, 419:9,
425:23, 432:20,
445:18
drug [2] - 18:12
dry [32] - 168:25,
171:7, 171:19,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 16
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 134 of 172
171:20, 171:21,
171:25, 179:5,
180:17, 221:1,
233:2, 233:3,
235:21, 237:3,
237:7, 289:9, 367:5,
383:3, 383:4, 383:5,
384:14, 384:15,
384:16, 384:21,
385:6, 385:10,
386:18, 387:6,
407:1, 407:5, 422:9
dryer [7] - 168:19,
168:24, 178:17,
382:15, 383:20,
386:8
dryness [5] - 290:10,
360:22, 362:25,
367:4, 407:13
Duane [3] - 347:8,
411:17, 412:1
DUANE [2] - 4:15,
5:23
Dubin [1] - 333:20
DUBIN [2] - 4:3, 4:5
due [7] - 165:6,
290:13, 314:14,
334:10, 360:25,
361:4, 456:6
Duffner [5] - 156:14,
156:19, 157:8,
178:25, 182:25
duly [7] - 47:6, 150:9,
227:21, 261:4,
345:4, 411:19,
439:16
DUNN [1] - 3:20
duration [1] - 206:4
during [83] - 23:12,
23:18, 37:1, 39:14,
48:1, 50:22, 51:4,
51:5, 56:4, 57:6,
57:13, 57:15, 57:20,
63:4, 63:5, 63:13,
65:3, 65:9, 71:22,
72:11, 73:4, 73:7,
73:12, 74:11, 75:15,
81:7, 86:8, 93:2,
103:7, 104:4,
104:17, 104:20,
107:15, 107:18,
110:4, 110:9,
113:19, 124:3,
126:11, 130:9,
131:3, 132:3,
132:22, 133:2,
133:8, 138:9,
138:11, 138:16,
139:15, 142:11,
143:14, 143:18,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
143:21, 144:16,
144:18, 145:12,
155:8, 190:5, 191:8,
191:22, 230:12,
235:25, 238:2,
245:22, 248:4,
251:10, 263:16,
275:23, 288:2,
319:16, 339:25,
358:2, 359:8, 384:6,
406:16, 407:2,
412:16, 414:11,
440:11, 442:1,
445:10, 450:2,
450:13
duties [3] - 196:23,
276:14, 312:4
duty [3] - 86:17,
271:19, 323:6
dynamic [1] - 428:4
E
e-mail [28] - 14:10,
39:12, 52:8, 90:20,
109:7, 109:17,
144:20, 149:18,
277:7, 277:8, 277:9,
277:17, 280:13,
281:11, 305:23,
306:1, 332:5, 333:9,
333:15, 333:16,
333:20, 333:22,
334:23, 335:18,
337:10, 338:7
e-mailed [1] - 281:2
e-mails [36] - 14:15,
14:23, 14:24, 15:11,
39:8, 43:5, 61:20,
61:25, 62:12, 78:4,
84:23, 85:14, 85:15,
85:25, 86:9, 91:11,
91:17, 91:18, 92:2,
144:16, 305:21,
305:24, 310:13,
310:15, 310:21,
311:3, 311:14,
313:7, 329:9,
332:18, 335:24,
339:12, 339:18,
339:23, 340:2,
341:11
early [12] - 282:6,
286:25, 287:21,
409:21, 409:25,
410:1, 410:5, 410:6,
413:15, 415:3,
434:21
ears [1] - 283:22
earth [1] - 293:18
452:13, 452:24,
453:5
effective [2] - 187:8,
216:22
effectively [1] - 424:17
effects [14] - 159:1,
350:6, 360:7, 361:4,
419:3, 423:9,
423:14, 423:16,
423:18, 423:21,
423:25, 424:4, 424:5
efficient [1] - 270:25
effort [2] - 35:20,
141:16
efforts [6] - 75:5,
93:25, 94:4, 113:25,
114:4, 407:1
Ehrlich [4] - 311:18,
312:12, 335:5, 335:7
Eight [1] - 220:1
eight [11] - 131:1,
159:15, 183:21,
185:18, 187:17,
188:15, 215:21,
363:22, 364:24,
365:15, 447:2
Eighth [2] - 2:11,
21:19
EISENSTEIN [1] - 2:22
either [34] - 26:15,
27:25, 28:7, 35:2,
38:8, 39:21, 41:13,
91:12, 91:21,
115:25, 134:12,
186:6, 193:1, 193:9,
234:8, 254:11,
254:17, 265:18,
280:18, 308:9,
311:17, 320:17,
339:11, 355:15,
358:25, 370:24,
371:7, 395:19,
414:6, 415:25,
422:11, 428:5,
430:12, 439:8
elaborate [2] - 151:17,
158:21
elapse [1] - 418:12
elapsed [1] - 438:19
elected [1] - 412:20
electronic [3] - 84:19,
109:7, 337:13
eleven [24] - 159:15,
160:1, 177:6,
183:22, 188:15,
215:21, 220:1,
222:24, 238:3,
238:9, 238:11,
239:11, 362:10,
363:23, 364:24,
365:15, 389:13,
391:11, 406:2,
412:6, 415:24,
418:9, 423:23, 447:2
eliminate [1] - 395:20
eliminated [1] 175:23
ELIZABETH [1] - 2:23
embodies [1] - 214:5
emphasis [1] - 440:18
emphasized [3] 41:19, 42:17, 164:1
emphasizing [2] 425:21, 426:8
emphatic [2] - 293:4,
293:15
empirical [3] - 151:12,
415:10
employed [5] - 311:3,
345:13, 345:14,
412:2, 439:24
employee [6] - 24:6,
156:16, 246:11,
246:13, 250:3,
259:24
employees [2] - 123:8,
243:2
encounter [1] - 435:7
encourage [1] 335:22
end [35] - 35:15,
40:18, 42:17, 70:7,
111:9, 111:23,
115:2, 115:22,
116:6, 118:9,
164:10, 185:16,
188:16, 192:25,
193:6, 193:7,
211:20, 211:24,
221:6, 226:17,
226:18, 234:7,
276:19, 298:20,
298:25, 299:3,
318:16, 318:20,
321:20, 340:6,
365:9, 370:3,
378:25, 398:10
ended [2] - 70:6,
284:23
Ending [1] - 299:9
endorsement [1] 90:22
ends [1] - 291:2
Enforcement [1] 99:9
enforcement [4] 151:21, 151:25,
152:6, 272:5
engage [1] - 36:12
engaged [17] - 29:3,
Page 17
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 135 of 172
101:22, 148:24,
149:6, 149:24,
150:2, 187:1,
197:19, 219:4,
242:25, 247:1,
254:16, 255:2,
273:12, 274:17,
275:13, 275:16,
276:2, 276:12,
285:18, 289:24,
293:3, 301:12,
316:19, 316:20,
317:9, 317:12,
324:17, 325:5,
325:11, 366:21,
367:7, 369:3,
369:12, 370:1,
385:4, 420:23,
426:8, 434:3,
434:12, 434:16,
435:6, 437:11, 447:8
exacerbated [1] 14:13
exact [8] - 17:7, 17:8,
46:13, 58:17, 235:6,
274:10, 319:7,
415:20
exactly [31] - 14:25,
15:4, 17:10, 18:15,
22:21, 30:25,
100:12, 100:25,
115:14, 118:17,
120:1, 126:13,
130:11, 132:4,
132:23, 134:14,
149:21, 178:20,
207:14, 210:5,
221:2, 223:18,
225:11, 296:4,
376:10, 381:6,
381:23, 399:21,
417:14, 421:25,
438:12
examination [8] 20:11, 20:17,
226:21, 270:17,
343:17, 349:24,
379:5, 453:15
EXAMINATION [23] 47:9, 100:6, 139:4,
143:12, 150:12,
194:20, 227:24,
251:7, 255:9,
259:15, 261:7,
321:25, 340:19,
345:7, 373:9,
402:20, 408:4,
411:22, 427:18,
438:3, 439:19,
448:12, 454:20
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 18
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 136 of 172
399:12, 441:2
experimental [11] 208:16, 209:23,
347:18, 358:11,
358:13, 367:2,
432:3, 440:20,
448:19, 448:24,
449:2
experimentally [3] 347:16, 422:4,
431:20
experimentallyoriented [1] - 347:16
experimentation [6] 413:23, 415:4,
415:13, 417:3,
427:8, 443:15
experiments [46] 197:9, 197:13,
201:5, 202:4,
204:16, 204:17,
204:20, 205:2,
205:22, 205:23,
206:8, 206:21,
209:12, 209:14,
224:16, 225:10,
328:4, 328:11,
349:9, 350:6,
352:18, 353:6,
353:23, 357:1,
357:2, 357:8, 358:6,
358:15, 358:18,
358:19, 358:22,
360:6, 360:17,
363:5, 365:5,
366:19, 367:6,
382:24, 388:5,
415:14, 438:12,
439:4, 441:10,
443:3, 444:1, 444:6
experiments' [1] 454:12
expert [25] - 33:17,
33:20, 33:24, 39:16,
102:1, 102:24,
104:21, 107:14,
148:25, 153:6,
201:20, 283:2,
284:1, 284:3,
284:11, 286:13,
286:15, 291:8,
317:15, 317:17,
348:17, 448:19
expertise [7] - 16:3,
156:11, 286:21,
346:9, 346:18,
347:4, 440:19
experts [14] - 15:24,
33:8, 33:12, 33:23,
270:22, 279:24,
Page 18 to 18 of 54
286:17, 287:24,
291:8, 300:20,
301:8, 302:6,
302:25, 303:9,
315:5, 326:19,
326:22, 327:2,
327:6, 327:10,
329:12, 330:12,
330:23, 331:4,
342:5, 342:8,
342:11, 342:24,
343:4, 343:8,
343:16, 345:14,
345:20, 345:21,
346:25, 347:24,
348:9, 349:15,
350:17, 359:13,
361:8, 361:12,
363:17, 366:13,
366:16, 367:18,
367:21, 368:2,
370:21, 371:17,
371:18, 373:5,
373:6, 402:23,
412:4, 412:5, 413:1,
413:7, 414:14,
416:13, 416:14,
422:12, 427:12,
427:13, 432:22,
433:16, 441:11,
441:24, 442:7,
442:14, 443:4,
443:14, 443:22,
444:2, 444:12,
444:23, 445:25,
446:4, 446:19,
447:25, 448:9,
448:22, 454:13,
455:17
Exponent [7] - 164:13,
187:18, 212:15,
346:3, 366:12,
441:14, 448:8
exponent's [28] 157:10, 160:13,
161:11, 166:4,
166:7, 166:14,
167:11, 169:22,
174:13, 175:6,
175:16, 182:8,
183:21, 183:25,
185:20, 187:7,
188:6, 190:20,
197:22, 215:22,
220:9, 285:13,
342:21, 359:17,
363:23, 414:17,
445:17, 447:2
Exponent's [4] 159:21, 220:2,
364:24, 432:24
Page 19
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 137 of 172
F
face [6] - 22:13, 82:23,
123:4, 139:25,
293:17, 339:1
faced [1] - 187:23
faces [1] - 82:14
facilitate [1] - 262:9
facility [1] - 11:22
facing [1] - 130:14
fact [71] - 11:24, 12:6,
16:22, 22:12, 23:17,
24:12, 24:21, 27:5,
27:24, 28:6, 28:22,
29:7, 29:12, 30:3,
39:14, 39:16, 41:4,
66:15, 79:2, 89:3,
108:13, 114:20,
116:19, 121:3,
139:24, 143:22,
169:1, 182:8,
212:15, 233:20,
238:21, 240:4,
251:2, 255:14,
259:7, 259:8,
276:17, 281:21,
290:16, 300:16,
301:8, 301:11,
302:9, 303:5,
303:12, 306:18,
308:6, 308:16,
315:9, 320:7,
320:10, 324:3,
326:13, 329:22,
137 of 172 sheets
331:24, 335:3,
337:11, 374:1,
374:23, 375:24,
375:25, 378:1,
382:14, 384:5,
385:1, 423:3,
424:20, 426:10,
433:15, 434:5,
434:11
fact-finding [4] 27:24, 28:6, 28:22,
29:7
factor [26] - 50:17,
169:19, 207:11,
222:22, 223:9,
243:22, 350:3,
350:25, 364:23,
369:17, 369:21,
369:22, 369:23,
370:14, 372:8,
373:22, 374:2,
374:4, 381:12,
381:16, 415:8,
427:22, 427:23,
428:9, 429:24,
450:21
factors [34] - 16:19,
17:14, 34:4, 48:24,
68:10, 176:3,
190:10, 206:2,
238:16, 253:1,
290:11, 315:6,
327:17, 328:10,
349:10, 350:17,
351:23, 352:3,
352:4, 356:1, 356:9,
356:12, 356:17,
356:19, 358:4,
358:8, 360:20,
360:21, 362:9,
362:22, 362:23,
366:8, 388:7, 428:2
facts [17] - 10:18,
19:25, 28:9, 30:24,
41:17, 267:12,
290:2, 323:2, 323:4,
323:10, 324:7,
375:22, 402:8,
404:17, 404:18
factual [2] - 8:19,
456:16
faculty [1] - 154:16
Fahrenheit [1] 352:23
failed [4] - 207:10,
331:6, 358:13,
372:12
failing [2] - 37:11,
448:15
failure [6] - 14:14,
18:18, 144:11,
144:12, 169:24,
174:15, 202:10,
209:3, 241:23,
328:4, 328:9,
328:19, 346:16,
397:14, 403:6,
403:16
Figure [16] - 169:23,
172:18, 198:9,
204:18, 223:10,
353:10, 353:14,
382:23, 387:7,
397:4, 397:7, 397:9,
397:25, 403:22,
405:17, 445:4
figured [4] - 128:20,
314:24, 314:25,
423:12
figures [5] - 160:16,
163:2, 241:24,
398:13, 403:1
file [1] - 246:6
filed [1] - 6:12
files [1] - 149:20
film [1] - 128:17
final [8] - 67:12, 184:7,
188:25, 252:14,
265:6, 314:9,
413:14, 429:12
finally [8] - 21:6,
27:14, 41:3, 45:19,
258:14, 315:4,
342:4, 423:12
Finally [1] - 335:22
finances [1] - 154:7
financial [1] - 153:20
finder [6] - 301:11,
303:4, 303:12,
324:3, 326:13,
329:22
findings [26] - 10:8,
10:17, 158:4,
158:13, 158:15,
158:19, 158:20,
165:12, 186:11,
188:4, 194:13,
207:20, 269:18,
273:7, 286:6,
326:14, 330:17,
331:1, 359:12,
406:5, 414:13,
424:21, 435:15,
435:18, 445:14,
447:22
Fine [1] - 322:17
fine [12] - 26:11,
26:19, 45:13, 45:15,
72:16, 213:15,
219:8, 242:19,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 20
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 138 of 172
267:21, 284:16,
343:13, 343:14
fined [2] - 45:1, 45:3
fining [1] - 45:10
finish [12] - 202:2,
246:8, 294:16,
383:13, 385:25,
386:4, 391:9,
391:19, 402:12,
402:17, 409:7, 454:1
Finish [1] - 246:10
finishing [2] - 183:4,
401:14
fired [2] - 57:14,
154:19
firm [13] - 155:6,
156:17, 195:15,
195:17, 261:13,
263:13, 268:7,
271:9, 281:25,
283:8, 284:19,
347:14
firms [1] - 195:20
first [145] - 8:8, 10:23,
13:9, 14:16, 18:9,
21:11, 22:2, 23:14,
26:11, 26:13, 26:20,
29:2, 29:6, 33:20,
34:18, 37:19, 39:7,
42:16, 47:1, 47:6,
48:18, 52:16, 57:7,
57:25, 58:15, 69:19,
73:1, 73:10, 73:21,
74:8, 76:7, 79:25,
87:1, 87:16, 98:10,
102:12, 105:16,
118:20, 126:17,
127:22, 128:10,
128:25, 131:1,
138:20, 139:19,
150:9, 151:20,
158:18, 158:22,
159:18, 160:9,
163:23, 168:4,
168:15, 170:16,
176:14, 176:20,
179:15, 182:13,
190:6, 191:9,
191:19, 197:18,
199:5, 199:9,
199:10, 201:3,
201:12, 201:24,
202:9, 224:20,
224:25, 227:21,
229:10, 229:11,
229:14, 229:22,
230:24, 239:3,
242:22, 253:9,
253:15, 255:25,
261:4, 263:9, 264:7,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
265:3, 269:23,
269:24, 272:2,
272:17, 281:9,
282:7, 282:8, 287:5,
287:16, 290:20,
303:14, 308:11,
322:5, 327:23,
328:6, 329:3, 330:5,
331:24, 337:21,
341:19, 343:1,
345:4, 350:20,
350:24, 352:24,
354:13, 359:16,
380:23, 380:25,
381:1, 381:5,
381:15, 389:10,
389:14, 389:17,
396:21, 397:20,
399:5, 401:7,
403:16, 406:21,
406:23, 408:9,
408:17, 411:19,
414:25, 418:12,
421:2, 421:17,
421:19, 423:5,
424:23, 438:22,
439:16, 444:9,
445:16, 446:12,
449:7
first-class [2] - 281:9,
444:9
first-half [1] - 182:13
fit [1] - 387:6
five [27] - 42:14,
55:13, 131:2, 134:6,
149:2, 165:2,
166:20, 181:21,
194:17, 343:20,
344:25, 354:17,
386:8, 395:22,
401:13, 402:17,
418:11, 419:21,
420:7, 420:18,
432:12, 432:14,
432:17, 432:23,
433:12, 433:15,
451:4
five-minute [1] 343:20
five-percent [3] 165:2, 432:17, 451:4
fixed [2] - 19:10, 366:6
flat [3] - 53:15, 182:18,
182:20
flattens [1] - 183:5
flaw [1] - 370:20
flawed [2] - 203:25,
331:6
flaws [1] - 438:15
flexibility [1] - 226:18
141:11, 141:14,
141:17, 143:18,
143:24, 144:7,
147:8, 147:17,
167:9, 167:21,
192:2, 200:20,
208:24, 220:23,
220:25, 222:24,
228:19, 229:12,
230:23, 231:9,
231:25, 234:7,
234:15, 243:3,
245:24, 246:3,
248:21, 249:21,
250:17, 254:20,
255:15, 257:10,
263:16, 273:24,
282:11, 288:2,
327:10, 327:15,
327:20, 349:4,
351:12, 351:18,
351:20, 352:10,
353:3, 356:21,
357:4, 363:8, 372:2,
394:18, 421:20,
443:11
footnote [8] - 211:19,
212:5, 212:6,
212:14, 212:23,
300:17, 318:9,
430:14
Footnote [5] - 212:14,
360:11, 430:23,
431:17, 431:18
footwear [1] - 83:6
forces [2] - 290:14,
314:14
Foreign [1] - 26:3
forensic [10] - 14:9,
15:20, 101:15,
101:17, 102:1,
102:24, 103:4,
104:21, 107:14,
112:5
forensically [1] 149:22
forensics [2] - 101:12
forget [7] - 287:2,
292:13, 293:16,
318:10, 320:11,
442:24, 453:9
form [5] - 243:11,
331:9, 381:4,
429:12, 442:4
formal [1] - 6:7
former [5] - 152:2,
156:15, 236:9,
245:17, 322:13
Formula [2] - 184:2,
184:4
Page 21
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 139 of 172
G
Gabe [1] - 347:19
Gabe's [1] - 281:12
gain [2] - 24:15, 69:9
Galanis [1] - 307:18
game [331] - 12:11,
12:13, 12:14, 13:6,
19:19, 22:9, 22:20,
23:13, 23:25, 24:6,
24:9, 31:15, 31:17,
31:20, 33:17, 35:25,
37:23, 40:15, 48:15,
49:4, 49:11, 49:12,
49:22, 50:3, 51:1,
51:25, 52:5, 52:7,
52:13, 52:15, 52:16,
54:2, 54:16, 54:23,
54:24, 54:25, 55:4,
55:9, 55:14, 55:22,
56:1, 56:2, 56:4,
56:7, 56:24, 57:6,
233:22, 234:5,
234:7, 234:11,
234:13, 234:18,
235:25, 237:25,
238:1, 238:3,
238:21, 239:19,
240:12, 241:5,
246:11, 246:12,
246:17, 246:20,
247:6, 248:4,
248:22, 249:4,
249:5, 249:7,
249:13, 250:5,
252:2, 252:4, 252:5,
253:18, 253:22,
254:18, 254:19,
257:4, 257:8,
257:14, 257:17,
257:23, 259:23,
259:24, 259:25,
272:4, 273:17,
274:18, 276:4,
276:7, 276:11,
276:20, 277:3,
278:8, 282:11,
291:15, 292:18,
298:16, 298:17,
298:20, 299:1,
299:4, 301:1,
307:20, 310:12,
310:16, 318:7,
318:17, 318:20,
328:22, 329:5,
349:19, 352:21,
352:22, 353:12,
354:19, 355:13,
356:20, 357:22,
357:24, 358:7,
358:11, 358:16,
358:18, 358:20,
358:23, 359:6,
363:22, 364:9,
364:17, 365:1,
365:2, 365:14,
365:17, 366:19,
366:24, 368:19,
368:24, 369:10,
370:5, 375:8,
375:13, 375:18,
376:8, 376:9,
376:16, 378:3,
382:17, 384:6,
384:10, 384:11,
388:13, 389:5,
390:5, 394:19,
396:5, 400:18,
401:10, 401:23,
406:16, 406:17,
407:2, 407:6,
407:16, 408:8,
408:13, 409:11,
409:21, 414:3,
414:6, 424:22,
425:19, 427:3,
443:4, 444:2, 447:1,
451:6, 451:9,
451:15, 452:2,
454:23, 455:7,
455:18
Game [47] - 18:6,
24:24, 25:7, 33:3,
37:19, 41:7, 66:22,
67:13, 68:16, 68:17,
68:19, 69:20, 78:10,
85:23, 94:17, 96:12,
99:9, 103:12,
103:15, 103:20,
121:2, 123:1, 124:8,
124:25, 125:2,
125:22, 141:21,
143:19, 146:1,
155:8, 189:3, 217:4,
229:13, 229:16,
231:7, 250:20,
251:11, 261:17,
263:17, 288:3,
293:9, 296:19,
304:11, 306:8,
327:18, 334:8, 359:1
Game-Day [3] - 25:7,
231:7, 250:20
game-day [28] - 123:8,
190:13, 197:15,
199:4, 228:16,
231:2, 310:16,
328:22, 329:5,
349:19, 353:12,
358:7, 358:18,
358:20, 358:23,
366:19, 384:10,
384:11, 388:13,
389:5, 390:5,
401:10, 406:16,
408:13, 409:11,
409:21, 443:4, 444:2
games [13] - 23:18,
48:20, 49:2, 77:3,
122:14, 230:23,
234:2, 249:5,
249:10, 255:5,
377:24, 378:11,
378:14
gaming [1] - 350:21
Ganot [1] - 347:19
gap [11] - 39:18,
103:1, 103:7,
103:10, 103:14,
103:19, 104:4,
107:16, 107:18,
112:4, 112:20
Gardi [8] - 227:17,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 22
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 140 of 172
237:18, 237:21,
239:14, 240:11,
241:11, 241:17,
242:1
Gardi's [1] - 240:25
Garrison [1] - 263:13
GARRISON [1] - 3:15
Gary [1] - 152:16
gas [36] - 16:16, 18:3,
19:24, 33:22,
184:19, 188:16,
189:14, 219:16,
219:21, 219:23,
220:4, 220:14,
220:21, 221:2,
221:11, 231:5,
237:13, 252:25,
280:5, 280:6, 288:1,
288:6, 288:8,
288:13, 290:23,
314:19, 364:19,
365:12, 365:16,
365:23, 365:24,
366:2, 371:25,
375:21, 426:6
Gas [8] - 18:9, 184:2,
184:4, 220:10,
231:9, 372:4,
393:25, 394:5
gatekeeper [1] - 360:3
Gauge [1] - 17:10
gauge [264] - 17:11,
159:12, 161:9,
161:15, 162:2,
163:11, 183:17,
184:21, 184:22,
184:25, 185:1,
185:7, 185:10,
185:13, 185:23,
185:25, 186:1,
186:6, 186:7, 186:8,
186:10, 186:12,
186:13, 186:19,
186:24, 186:25,
187:2, 187:7,
187:11, 188:1,
188:2, 188:13,
189:19, 191:14,
191:23, 214:21,
215:3, 215:20,
216:3, 216:18,
216:19, 216:21,
217:5, 217:6, 217:7,
217:8, 217:16,
217:20, 218:9,
218:10, 218:12,
218:16, 218:24,
219:3, 219:4,
219:24, 221:10,
221:19, 221:21,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
221:22, 232:2,
232:3, 232:5,
232:10, 232:11,
232:14, 232:15,
232:18, 240:23,
240:25, 241:4,
241:7, 259:8,
291:16, 291:17,
291:22, 291:23,
292:5, 292:9, 294:5,
294:8, 294:10,
295:1, 295:5, 295:8,
295:9, 295:22,
295:25, 296:3,
296:4, 296:7,
296:13, 296:14,
296:21, 297:5,
297:7, 297:10,
297:13, 297:16,
297:24, 299:11,
299:16, 299:17,
299:18, 300:10,
301:7, 301:13,
301:21, 301:25,
302:3, 302:4,
302:11, 302:22,
302:24, 303:2,
303:6, 303:13,
306:16, 316:1,
316:4, 316:7, 316:8,
316:9, 319:24,
319:25, 323:25,
352:11, 353:17,
353:18, 355:5,
355:15, 355:17,
363:21, 364:4,
364:5, 364:6,
364:13, 364:17,
365:13, 365:17,
366:15, 366:18,
366:22, 366:23,
366:24, 367:3,
367:8, 368:18,
368:19, 368:25,
369:1, 372:14,
372:16, 372:17,
372:18, 372:19,
374:14, 374:16,
374:20, 374:22,
374:24, 375:2,
375:5, 375:9,
375:10, 375:15,
375:16, 375:17,
376:6, 376:10,
376:15, 376:16,
376:22, 377:1,
377:14, 377:15,
377:18, 377:19,
377:21, 377:24,
377:25, 378:4,
378:7, 378:12,
378:15, 378:20,
378:24, 379:4,
379:5, 379:11,
391:25, 392:1,
392:2, 392:3, 392:5,
392:10, 392:13,
392:17, 397:22,
403:1, 403:2,
403:12, 403:17,
404:6, 404:8, 404:9,
404:11, 405:1,
405:2, 405:12,
405:15, 405:19,
408:7, 408:8,
408:20, 410:4,
414:3, 414:4, 414:5,
414:6, 419:6,
421:19, 423:14,
423:16, 423:18,
423:21, 423:22,
424:3, 424:5,
424:10, 424:11,
424:12, 424:13,
424:22, 426:1,
426:14, 426:17,
426:20, 426:21,
426:22, 426:25,
427:3, 427:4, 427:7,
446:25, 447:8,
447:9, 447:12,
447:14
gauged [3] - 293:23,
293:24, 455:11
gauges [81] - 161:3,
163:4, 184:20,
187:20, 189:10,
189:20, 189:22,
189:24, 192:1,
200:23, 216:15,
218:13, 218:18,
218:21, 219:5,
219:6, 219:7, 219:8,
221:17, 231:24,
231:25, 232:3,
232:4, 232:7, 232:8,
232:22, 232:24,
240:13, 240:16,
240:18, 240:21,
240:24, 282:5,
282:8, 296:11,
296:12, 296:19,
300:25, 301:19,
301:23, 315:23,
315:25, 316:1,
316:11, 320:1,
320:9, 320:13,
350:1, 355:4, 355:6,
355:7, 355:12,
369:9, 376:25,
377:4, 377:7,
377:16, 377:20,
Page 22 to 22 of 54
378:17, 378:21,
378:22, 378:25,
379:2, 379:16,
379:17, 379:18,
379:19, 379:21,
380:4, 380:6,
413:24, 415:25,
426:12, 426:15
gee [2] - 15:6, 438:23
geez [1] - 364:16
General [5] - 3:5, 3:6,
152:3, 229:17, 266:7
general [16] - 9:13,
21:25, 22:11, 49:2,
99:7, 157:11,
157:13, 158:8,
209:17, 209:18,
314:18, 428:21,
433:9, 434:18,
435:2, 436:6
generally [28] - 9:1,
9:9, 9:11, 9:16,
13:14, 19:14, 21:12,
22:5, 22:6, 23:21,
27:2, 30:12, 42:24,
43:2, 75:17, 177:13,
234:2, 236:15,
243:1, 246:2,
248:20, 249:10,
250:9, 251:15,
257:15, 273:14,
274:2, 435:20
generated [5] - 203:2,
204:17, 209:13,
352:15, 432:3
gentlemen [1] - 274:7
gently [1] - 120:24
George [1] - 150:25
GIBSON [1] - 3:20
given [47] - 9:4, 20:10,
22:12, 22:13, 22:15,
22:16, 22:17, 22:19,
25:18, 28:15, 30:19,
51:12, 98:12, 108:1,
152:18, 156:24,
156:25, 158:11,
159:13, 174:21,
183:20, 206:2,
206:4, 220:8,
231:18, 250:23,
250:24, 251:3,
272:14, 272:18,
273:2, 296:12,
304:21, 305:9,
313:9, 313:10,
313:17, 313:23,
321:21, 323:16,
342:8, 348:7,
399:24, 400:3,
400:5, 408:16, 413:4
Page 23
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 141 of 172
117:22, 117:25,
122:19, 124:18,
125:20, 128:1,
133:10, 133:16,
136:13, 136:19,
137:11, 137:14,
137:16, 145:24,
146:4, 146:7,
146:10, 146:14,
146:16, 146:18,
146:22, 146:25,
147:5, 147:10,
147:15, 147:23,
148:4, 148:6,
148:10, 148:14,
148:18, 149:1,
155:17, 155:23,
156:4, 168:7,
168:14, 168:23,
170:9, 170:14,
170:17, 170:22,
177:5, 178:1, 180:1,
180:11, 180:13,
180:17, 180:20,
189:21, 192:11,
194:18, 221:25,
225:19, 226:6,
227:19, 230:3,
230:6, 233:13,
252:2, 256:23,
257:1, 260:20,
277:15, 386:4,
396:7, 397:11,
398:3, 398:6, 399:8,
400:16, 400:20,
400:25, 401:15,
401:19, 401:22,
402:1, 402:12,
402:15, 404:1,
436:9, 439:14,
454:1, 454:4,
454:15, 457:4
Gostkowski [4] 121:6, 335:7,
341:11, 341:24
Government [2] - 2:7,
347:17
grab [4] - 49:25,
306:1, 382:8, 382:9
gradient [1] - 393:16
gradients [1] - 393:12
graduate [1] - 210:25
graduates [1] - 281:7
grant [1] - 226:17
granted [1] - 226:25
graph [4] - 174:14,
405:16, 410:9,
410:12
graphs [3] - 380:21,
404:17, 445:6
117:7, 120:3,
312:17, 312:18,
330:6
guys [5] - 135:15,
146:10, 146:18,
148:12, 265:22
gym [1] - 294:21
H
Hadron [1] - 441:3
half [56] - 13:9, 13:10,
57:8, 59:11, 59:25,
73:1, 73:10, 73:11,
73:15, 73:19, 73:21,
74:4, 111:20,
111:21, 118:21,
118:22, 118:23,
119:11, 126:17,
148:13, 148:20,
168:12, 168:14,
168:24, 170:16,
175:5, 177:1, 177:2,
177:21, 179:6,
182:13, 190:6,
191:9, 229:16,
230:4, 239:21,
239:22, 309:2,
319:16, 350:24,
364:16, 369:24,
375:10, 375:11,
378:9, 390:15,
390:17, 397:23,
399:12, 399:24,
406:21, 406:23,
419:22
halftime [117] - 13:12,
33:2, 72:25, 73:6,
159:5, 159:25,
160:7, 163:25,
168:3, 168:6, 170:5,
172:6, 176:13,
180:8, 181:5, 181:6,
184:1, 185:9,
185:24, 186:16,
187:12, 187:21,
192:25, 193:4,
193:15, 193:17,
193:23, 199:23,
200:21, 200:23,
204:22, 205:3,
206:6, 206:9,
211:15, 215:14,
216:3, 221:6,
221:12, 222:15,
222:23, 222:25,
224:5, 224:6,
224:14, 225:8,
230:12, 233:22,
234:3, 234:20,
234:21, 234:25,
Page 23 to 23 of 54
245:16, 338:24,
379:17, 391:18,
410:22, 453:6
Hargrove [2] - 45:3,
45:9
Hargrove's [1] - 45:7
Harvard [2] - 269:9,
269:10
Harvard-trained [2] 269:9, 269:10
hasty [1] - 181:11
hated [1] - 55:24
HAUER [1] - 2:19
head [3] - 22:11, 99:8,
229:2
heading [1] - 129:11
headquarters [1] 346:1
heads [2] - 94:23, 95:8
heads-up [2] - 94:23,
95:8
health [1] - 346:5
hear [25] - 8:11, 10:23,
10:24, 11:20, 12:15,
14:16, 20:19, 20:20,
28:24, 30:5, 32:10,
32:12, 37:9, 37:16,
38:4, 39:15, 43:10,
87:23, 100:10,
100:13, 180:1,
211:11, 331:12,
445:13, 456:11
heard [26] - 6:15, 7:24,
30:2, 30:4, 35:1,
35:18, 37:5, 40:15,
74:17, 74:21, 74:25,
81:16, 136:15,
200:4, 229:23,
231:5, 231:11,
269:7, 272:19,
272:23, 315:5,
330:1, 359:11,
369:17, 414:13,
455:20
Hearing [1] - 457:5
hearing [13] - 6:13,
6:14, 28:13, 28:25,
110:9, 110:17,
117:12, 121:11,
150:1, 270:17,
272:18, 456:7,
456:18
HEARING [1] - 1:8
heat [2] - 19:3, 23:18
heated [3] - 23:12,
257:24, 291:7
heaters [2] - 257:10,
257:14
Heather [1] - 226:11
HEATHER [1] - 3:5
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 24
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 142 of 172
101:15, 156:22,
261:15, 261:25,
266:24, 270:18,
283:2, 283:4,
283:24, 286:23,
287:18, 323:7
hiring [1] - 284:3
historically [3] 114:17, 114:19,
117:19
history [11] - 20:24,
25:8, 25:10, 44:21,
45:13, 45:16, 46:9,
46:12, 46:13,
119:20, 378:14
hits [1] - 55:17
hmm [4] - 237:20,
245:8, 258:25,
431:12
hold [5] - 46:9,
120:24, 277:14,
412:9, 412:21
holding [1] - 46:16
hole [1] - 329:14
holes [1] - 219:2
home [5] - 80:20,
80:21, 128:18,
133:7, 133:19
honest [2] - 20:4,
75:18
honestly [1] - 11:16
honesty [1] - 149:14
hope [5] - 14:1, 263:5,
279:18, 280:12,
448:16
hopeful [1] - 336:3
hopefully [1] - 6:17
hoping [1] - 155:24
horizontal [1] - 170:1
host [1] - 74:24
hot [3] - 16:18, 291:6,
314:22
hotel [1] - 238:1
hour [12] - 20:10,
131:24, 148:13,
148:20, 226:9,
226:17, 226:18,
227:1, 227:6, 313:1,
343:5, 402:4
hours [15] - 67:11,
67:14, 68:24, 70:18,
86:5, 126:17,
226:14, 233:24,
352:24, 400:18,
401:1, 401:16,
401:23, 402:4, 402:5
hours' [1] - 226:9
house [2] - 294:12,
294:19
housekeeping [1] -
225:23
HR [1] - 154:13
huge [4] - 19:1, 192:5,
339:16, 433:21
human [5] - 34:6,
34:7, 34:11, 34:22,
209:2
hundreds [8] - 54:8,
294:11, 301:19,
302:1, 316:2, 355:5,
377:15, 378:16
Hunter [1] - 322:14
hurt [5] - 304:20,
304:24, 338:16,
339:3, 339:4
hydrometer [1] 386:15
hypotheses [1] 178:5
I
idea [21] - 13:6, 35:8,
38:7, 56:11, 75:9,
80:14, 104:24,
105:5, 122:2,
127:17, 164:12,
167:14, 167:15,
178:12, 181:9,
189:8, 189:9, 241:4,
296:2, 318:19, 368:3
ideal [36] - 16:16,
18:3, 19:23, 33:22,
184:19, 188:16,
189:14, 219:16,
219:21, 219:22,
220:3, 220:14,
220:21, 221:2,
221:11, 231:5,
237:13, 252:25,
280:5, 280:6, 288:1,
288:6, 288:8,
288:13, 290:23,
314:19, 364:19,
365:12, 365:16,
365:23, 366:2,
371:25, 375:21,
426:6
Ideal [7] - 18:9, 184:1,
184:4, 220:10,
231:9, 372:4, 394:5
ideas [2] - 283:19,
329:7
identified [17] 100:19, 140:12,
141:9, 157:13,
157:16, 157:21,
157:22, 163:24,
184:11, 243:21,
358:3, 358:25,
Page 24 to 24 of 54
361:12, 363:20,
413:23, 414:16,
416:15
identifies [2] - 199:19,
203:1
identify [9] - 7:5,
140:24, 153:12,
163:4, 163:10,
207:10, 226:1,
327:16, 437:10
ignore [1] - 36:23
ignored [1] - 223:23
ignores [5] - 197:24,
359:19, 414:19,
445:19, 447:15
III [1] - 2:6
ill [1] - 304:19
ill-advised [1] 304:19
illegal [1] - 378:5
illustrates [1] - 45:10
imaginable [1] - 21:3
imagine [1] - 161:19
immediate [1] 154:15
immediately [10] 103:15, 172:9,
172:11, 174:8,
230:10, 247:6,
262:5, 391:15,
408:19, 416:1
impact [16] - 19:1,
175:13, 182:24,
187:15, 204:21,
231:8, 269:17,
282:10, 285:25,
288:9, 290:18,
314:20, 350:21,
351:8, 356:16, 428:3
impacts [1] - 328:20
implausible [2] - 38:6
implicate [1] - 334:15
implicit [1] - 419:14
implied [1] - 416:19
importance [7] 160:16, 169:4,
169:25, 172:5,
175:24, 176:5, 439:5
important [41] - 7:21,
10:20, 12:23, 21:16,
21:17, 30:15, 31:14,
50:8, 50:9, 120:16,
158:2, 168:8, 169:7,
170:22, 173:21,
190:18, 191:21,
191:24, 198:11,
200:2, 200:4,
213:17, 221:20,
248:25, 334:4,
341:16, 341:18,
348:18, 360:18,
373:22, 396:24,
415:5, 416:24,
420:19, 427:22,
427:23, 428:6,
428:9, 436:22,
443:9, 443:13
importantly [3] 29:24, 31:5, 32:9
impose [4] - 243:8,
243:14, 312:4,
416:10
imposed [8] - 7:23,
15:18, 23:16, 42:12,
45:18, 45:25,
243:16, 326:15
imposing [4] - 27:25,
417:17, 419:23,
420:14
impossible [2] - 55:7,
120:19
impressed [1] - 444:7
impromptu [2] 190:9, 194:5
improper [5] - 28:2,
137:1, 138:1,
138:19, 159:9
improperly [5] 222:14, 361:13,
380:20, 381:19,
446:4
IN [1] - 1:3
inaccurate [5] 123:23, 126:9,
307:25, 404:14,
418:18
inappropriate [3] 10:16, 223:22,
273:15
inch [1] - 113:23
incident [9] - 23:10,
24:2, 41:15, 44:23,
245:23, 247:4,
255:12, 259:22,
260:13
incidentally [1] 128:24
incidents [3] - 48:16,
249:18, 253:9
inclement [4] - 55:9,
68:22, 69:17, 70:5
inclined [1] - 226:16
include [22] - 110:17,
110:22, 159:1,
179:19, 198:15,
198:22, 199:8,
201:13, 202:11,
203:21, 210:18,
210:20, 228:15,
228:18, 238:18,
Page 25
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 143 of 172
325:25, 425:3,
451:24, 452:6,
452:7, 452:12,
454:24
included [17] - 179:18,
191:17, 198:16,
202:14, 202:20,
202:24, 204:1,
204:19, 207:1,
243:22, 369:20,
369:22, 441:21,
449:8, 454:24,
454:25, 455:16
includes [6] - 32:25,
103:11, 103:14,
103:19, 103:23,
104:14
including [10] - 30:1,
36:6, 42:8, 141:8,
166:6, 313:15,
326:4, 354:7,
357:25, 413:24
inclusion [2] - 438:6,
450:11
inconclusive [1] 315:21
inconsequential [2] 115:1, 116:17
inconsistency [3] 187:6, 219:24,
431:19
inconsistent [3] 147:16, 221:19,
432:1
incorporate [1] 211:13
Incorporated [1] 345:14
incorporated [3] 213:4, 213:12,
367:11
incorporating [1] 212:17
incorrect [2] - 202:7,
286:24
incorrectly [1] 161:18
increase [3] - 291:7,
360:25, 425:15
increasing [2] - 366:4,
394:13
increments [1] - 214:5
incriminating [3] 14:22, 14:24, 149:19
indeed [1] - 157:8
independence [4] 262:4, 322:3,
348:13, 348:15
independent [21] 27:24, 29:9, 30:19,
143 of 172 sheets
202:13, 252:23,
261:20, 262:8,
262:12, 264:18,
264:24, 266:11,
266:17, 267:1,
267:3, 270:12,
271:9, 286:7,
322:24, 323:8,
323:10, 348:17
independently [4] 8:20, 156:3, 285:8,
311:15
index [1] - 98:18
Indianapolis [2] 229:18, 299:17
indicate [7] - 13:23,
63:13, 96:3, 219:5,
235:20, 392:19,
397:9
indicated [11] - 8:10,
225:23, 226:23,
289:9, 309:16,
370:1, 374:12,
396:10, 403:6,
416:5, 456:14
indicates [2] - 204:12,
315:5
indicating [7] - 53:9,
171:7, 174:18,
184:12, 386:17,
386:22, 451:22
indicating) [7] - 25:17,
161:1, 171:23,
172:1, 175:10,
182:17, 182:19
indication [4] 260:14, 369:8,
383:22, 435:20
indications [2] 369:10, 391:17
individual [1] - 362:20
individuals [2] 156:8, 309:13
industrial [1] - 151:10
industries [4] 151:18, 152:8,
152:10, 153:14
infant [1] - 153:18
infer [2] - 66:9, 66:15
inference [2] - 38:22,
44:12
inflate [1] - 119:8
inflated [19] - 18:23,
18:25, 35:14, 58:9,
59:9, 113:14,
113:22, 114:8,
116:5, 118:9, 119:9,
119:24, 119:25,
122:9, 177:7,
193:17, 238:21,
254:25, 276:8
inflating [3] - 64:25,
65:4, 135:1
inflation [31] - 35:2,
35:7, 50:16, 50:21,
51:13, 51:15, 66:12,
73:10, 97:22,
100:18, 100:23,
101:3, 101:7,
113:11, 114:12,
114:15, 119:17,
119:19, 119:21,
124:2, 136:3,
143:17, 143:23,
253:2, 254:19,
276:10, 276:14,
277:4, 332:20,
351:9, 360:22
influence [2] - 349:11,
350:4
inform [1] - 256:21
information [34] 19:13, 38:19, 38:23,
39:9, 43:16, 48:17,
89:9, 90:25, 91:8,
94:19, 155:21,
243:14, 253:24,
253:25, 254:11,
254:16, 254:23,
299:24, 305:17,
315:11, 320:22,
332:16, 333:3,
334:3, 334:19,
337:7, 337:11,
352:21, 357:24,
392:23, 393:3,
408:9, 408:16, 437:6
informed [2] - 86:16,
122:8
initial [8] - 27:25,
144:8, 184:6,
291:15, 347:6,
380:14, 399:13,
413:14
inquire [1] - 164:13
inserted [3] - 160:14,
351:13, 353:14
insertion [2] - 350:7
insertions [2] - 351:9,
351:16
inside [14] - 230:18,
231:16, 234:17,
288:24, 351:1,
351:13, 351:22,
353:14, 354:1,
356:10, 382:5,
393:10, 393:22,
397:23
insight [1] - 183:1
insights [2] - 153:4,
Page 25 to 25 of 54
182:12
insignificant [7] 179:20, 361:16,
430:22, 431:3,
431:15, 446:7, 453:9
insistent [1] - 364:15
inspected [1] - 239:20
instead [4] - 45:25,
176:25, 188:9,
211:20
instinctively [1] 433:6
Institute [2] - 353:19,
412:22
institution [2] - 154:4,
154:9
instruct [3] - 118:25,
235:14, 235:20
instructed [2] - 23:14,
233:7
instruction [3] 121:18, 121:21,
231:18
instructions [4] 96:10, 232:13,
323:17, 348:7
instrument [1] 353:14
integrity [18] - 22:8,
22:19, 23:25, 25:20,
29:22, 31:15, 31:17,
31:20, 35:25, 40:14,
46:15, 149:14,
154:9, 228:12,
250:18, 272:4,
311:22, 311:25
Integrity [3] - 98:17,
98:24, 99:9
intend [2] - 7:13, 8:1
intending [2] - 209:4,
209:5
intense [1] - 57:15
intensity [1] - 57:19
intensive [1] - 442:2
intention [2] - 360:3,
442:19
interact [1] - 441:23
interactions [2] 440:25, 442:5
intercepted [2] 191:8, 320:3
interest [4] - 156:1,
271:20, 344:11,
344:12
interested [2] - 6:13,
7:25
interesting [7] - 24:21,
25:19, 155:20,
212:11, 279:7,
295:18, 360:14
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 26
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 144 of 172
307:23, 308:8
intriguing [1] - 189:4
introduce [1] - 421:7
introduced [1] 455:10
introduction [1] 438:6
intuition [2] - 189:6,
189:11
invalidate [1] - 286:2
investigate [2] 258:4, 324:6
investigated [2] 24:19, 249:9
investigation [67] 23:13, 23:23, 29:18,
30:19, 30:21, 30:23,
37:1, 37:11, 45:1,
45:5, 87:24, 141:4,
169:17, 200:25,
237:23, 238:5,
247:3, 248:14,
250:8, 252:23,
253:5, 254:10,
255:3, 258:8,
258:11, 262:3,
262:12, 262:16,
262:21, 263:14,
263:18, 264:3,
264:8, 264:10,
266:2, 266:23,
267:1, 267:3,
267:11, 270:12,
272:3, 272:10,
310:22, 311:5,
311:17, 311:21,
311:24, 322:11,
322:12, 322:15,
324:16, 327:7,
327:12, 336:1,
339:4, 339:15,
347:7, 348:18,
349:2, 349:6, 355:1,
367:9, 413:3,
413:13, 415:3,
417:1, 442:3
investigations [4] 322:6, 322:9, 322:21
investigative [7] 100:16, 100:22,
109:5, 123:17,
123:18, 264:17,
267:19
investigator [11] 29:9, 29:20, 261:16,
261:19, 261:20,
262:8, 262:13,
310:3, 322:25,
323:8, 323:20
investigators [4] 06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
344:1, 366:16,
398:4, 456:12
issued [11] - 8:16,
263:23, 264:21,
265:18, 268:1,
272:25, 302:6,
302:14, 330:13,
330:18, 376:21
issues [15] - 6:17,
27:13, 29:2, 31:16,
145:4, 145:10,
216:10, 242:10,
261:16, 262:9,
332:22, 334:14,
334:15, 340:9,
456:15
Item [1] - 357:17
itself [13] - 32:24,
37:14, 149:8, 221:3,
247:11, 266:3,
267:11, 288:7,
301:6, 357:11,
357:14, 358:8,
435:22
IX [4] - 300:22, 326:22,
326:23, 327:5
J
jackson [1] - 191:8
James [1] - 192:12
January [30] - 103:12,
103:25, 121:2,
125:1, 125:4,
125:11, 125:15,
126:1, 126:18,
127:3, 129:16,
130:4, 131:9,
131:11, 132:1,
132:7, 132:10,
133:23, 141:9,
141:10, 143:15,
144:22, 145:13,
261:23, 263:11,
264:12, 264:22,
306:24, 313:2
Jastremski [114] 12:20, 12:23, 12:24,
34:25, 37:21, 43:25,
44:5, 49:17, 50:22,
51:18, 53:21, 57:20,
58:3, 58:8, 60:7,
60:19, 60:21, 61:10,
62:12, 63:3, 67:19,
67:23, 68:8, 70:2,
71:15, 75:4, 75:11,
76:5, 76:9, 77:20,
78:8, 78:18, 79:20,
81:1, 92:4, 92:8,
92:12, 92:15, 92:18,
Page 26 to 26 of 54
Page 27
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 145 of 172
347:13
jointly [1] - 262:7
joke [1] - 121:5
JONATHAN [1] - 3:12
Jones [1] - 36:6
Jonny [2] - 78:19,
78:25
JOSHUA [3] - 1:23,
457:7, 457:12
JR [1] - 4:10
Jr [4] - 47:13, 102:6,
261:11, 263:12
judge [6] - 284:2,
303:5, 303:10,
317:21, 324:3, 324:4
Judge [4] - 21:18,
36:6, 45:24, 46:5
judgment [20] - 14:3,
29:1, 29:10, 31:7,
31:8, 31:24, 32:3,
32:8, 38:13, 40:19,
40:20, 40:24, 42:4,
42:5, 296:8, 309:14,
317:8, 317:19,
324:14
judgments [1] 194:11
jump [1] - 169:22
juncture [1] - 281:18
June [5] - 1:10, 6:2,
105:12, 139:8, 337:5
juries [1] - 317:12
jurisdiction [1] 228:20
jurors [2] - 317:19,
329:24
jury [3] - 317:14,
324:8, 325:4
Justice's [1] - 152:4
K
K-balls [1] - 24:11
kala [1] - 373:15
kala-jerry [1] - 373:15
Karp [2] - 324:12,
329:22
keep [20] - 148:11,
154:8, 165:22,
165:23, 232:22,
260:21, 303:20,
318:25, 383:14,
384:14, 384:15,
384:16, 385:6,
385:10, 407:1,
407:5, 416:25,
427:16, 432:2,
437:24
keeping [4] - 226:8,
226:15, 340:10,
145 of 172 sheets
340:11
keeps [3] - 179:5,
232:23, 232:24
Kensil [1] - 229:20
kept [4] - 42:17,
236:15, 320:15,
339:7
KESSLER [110] - 3:11,
5:4, 5:8, 7:10, 7:14,
7:16, 7:19, 42:14,
47:3, 47:10, 48:10,
52:6, 52:25, 62:8,
65:20, 65:22, 66:4,
66:23, 89:8, 91:19,
97:14, 97:16, 98:5,
98:20, 99:16,
111:20, 112:10,
112:15, 112:19,
124:20, 135:25,
136:7, 136:11,
139:2, 139:5, 139:7,
143:8, 145:22,
148:5, 148:8,
148:11, 148:20,
148:23, 149:5,
150:3, 194:15,
225:22, 226:7,
226:20, 227:9,
227:17, 227:25,
233:15, 242:13,
242:19, 247:16,
247:21, 249:16,
251:5, 255:8,
255:10, 256:25,
257:2, 259:13,
260:18, 260:21,
260:25, 261:8,
266:9, 266:20,
271:7, 277:16,
279:1, 294:17,
298:8, 318:4,
321:18, 340:18,
340:20, 342:15,
342:18, 342:23,
343:3, 343:15,
343:21, 343:24,
344:19, 344:23,
373:10, 386:1,
392:16, 395:16,
400:19, 400:22,
401:4, 402:8, 408:2,
408:5, 411:13,
427:16, 427:19,
437:23, 439:10,
448:13, 453:25,
454:17, 455:24,
456:3, 456:13, 457:2
Kessler [37] - 29:7,
30:4, 32:6, 32:10,
32:14, 34:1, 34:8,
L
lab [1] - 282:21
Labor [2] - 2:7, 2:17
laces [1] - 56:22
lack [4] - 15:15, 44:16,
44:20, 223:24
laid [1] - 445:3
language [3] - 135:17,
172:4, 205:9
Large [2] - 441:1,
441:2
large [8] - 39:18,
152:10, 191:1,
349:5, 393:12,
436:16, 443:1,
449:16
larger [3] - 404:12,
418:4, 420:12
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 28
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 146 of 172
85:7, 110:17,
195:22, 195:24,
270:11, 305:12
layers [1] - 22:2
LCD [2] - 153:19,
196:7
lead [9] - 6:25, 182:13,
183:5, 261:16,
261:19, 283:2,
310:3, 413:3, 451:23
Lead [1] - 3:15
leading [2] - 15:24,
103:20
leads [3] - 194:7,
208:6, 392:24
LEAGUE [6] - 1:1, 2:3,
2:15, 2:20, 3:3, 3:9
League [27] - 1:14,
9:18, 11:13, 13:1,
18:2, 21:3, 23:13,
25:17, 25:22, 28:6,
28:7, 36:9, 46:6,
64:13, 65:22,
113:20, 190:17,
228:7, 236:5, 236:8,
249:24, 251:25,
257:21, 314:11,
364:9, 376:2, 377:4
League's [1] - 46:9
leak [2] - 350:8,
351:17
leakage [1] - 351:22
leaked [1] - 281:22
leaking [1] - 351:14
leaks [3] - 282:25,
283:13, 283:14
learn [14] - 18:1, 65:8,
74:12, 114:14,
229:11, 272:17,
287:24, 288:17,
288:23, 289:2,
289:8, 290:11,
290:14, 437:20
learned [9] - 58:3,
58:8, 63:21, 82:19,
84:21, 114:20,
117:11, 288:21,
288:22
learning [2] - 224:15,
225:9
least [22] - 14:4,
21:19, 28:9, 73:17,
114:6, 196:14,
199:2, 226:17,
227:1, 227:5,
240:19, 240:21,
242:1, 243:1,
248:19, 256:15,
273:14, 280:21,
344:9, 400:25,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
418:11, 421:21
leather [11] - 12:9,
53:3, 53:6, 53:8,
53:17, 55:2, 56:20,
56:22, 57:1, 57:2,
57:3
leave [6] - 72:2,
168:25, 213:15,
381:21, 452:1,
456:22
leaves [1] - 190:9
led [2] - 47:25, 161:1
left [13] - 153:7,
160:24, 173:20,
198:17, 202:15,
229:20, 230:11,
309:11, 348:20,
401:9, 401:14,
401:19, 403:22
left-hand [2] - 160:24,
403:22
legal [9] - 21:7, 21:10,
28:10, 46:20,
277:24, 278:4,
420:22, 424:25,
456:14
legally [1] - 46:18
lend [1] - 181:9
length [1] - 212:4
less [16] - 64:1, 68:3,
119:25, 126:4,
132:19, 182:20,
183:5, 391:19,
405:23, 410:7,
410:11, 420:25,
435:24, 436:6,
437:9, 442:1
letter [32] - 6:15,
14:14, 27:23, 39:3,
105:11, 105:17,
106:10, 108:21,
111:5, 111:7,
111:17, 114:22,
139:8, 237:18,
238:20, 240:23,
240:25, 242:3,
242:4, 242:6,
244:20, 250:13,
250:14, 252:13,
252:19, 252:20,
330:14, 332:14,
337:5, 337:7
letters [1] - 430:10
level [52] - 34:4, 35:7,
50:16, 50:21, 51:13,
51:15, 63:20, 66:12,
67:24, 68:6, 113:11,
114:8, 114:12,
114:15, 115:13,
116:5, 116:11,
118:5, 118:8,
119:17, 119:19,
119:21, 124:2,
151:23, 151:24,
153:1, 165:2, 171:6,
171:7, 171:23,
179:23, 193:14,
217:2, 217:10,
217:13, 348:12,
348:15, 382:21,
382:22, 413:18,
420:7, 420:17,
420:18, 432:12,
432:17, 432:24,
433:2, 434:14,
444:8, 446:17,
451:4, 455:9
levels [10] - 58:17,
143:17, 143:24,
145:19, 204:22,
215:14, 324:24,
324:25, 356:19,
426:23
LEVY [41] - 2:12, 7:4,
7:12, 7:15, 47:1,
62:7, 100:2, 112:18,
148:15, 149:4,
150:1, 203:17,
226:14, 227:5,
227:15, 242:18,
260:19, 268:13,
271:6, 271:24,
279:4, 294:16,
295:11, 318:2,
321:22, 340:15,
342:17, 343:14,
343:20, 343:23,
344:16, 344:25,
380:3, 385:25,
395:24, 411:16,
449:13, 456:2,
456:4, 456:21, 457:3
Levy [2] - 6:16, 6:22
levy [5] - 11:2, 21:6,
46:20, 99:18, 225:23
Lexol [13] - 55:2, 55:5,
55:15, 68:25, 69:8,
69:9, 69:12, 69:25,
70:3, 70:16, 76:17,
76:21
liability [1] - 325:9
liable [1] - 9:17
lie [1] - 278:7
lied [1] - 278:9
life [3] - 14:6, 43:11,
377:25
light [3] - 45:16,
342:19, 343:5
lighter [2] - 294:23,
405:4
Page 28 to 28 of 54
Page 29
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 147 of 172
301:13, 301:21,
301:25, 302:22,
302:24, 303:1,
303:6, 303:13,
316:1, 316:8, 316:9,
323:25, 355:4,
355:5, 355:11,
355:17, 363:21,
364:4, 364:5, 364:6,
364:13, 364:17,
365:13, 365:17,
366:15, 366:17,
366:22, 366:23,
366:24, 367:3,
367:7, 368:18,
368:19, 368:25,
369:1, 369:4, 369:5,
372:14, 372:18,
372:21, 375:1,
375:5, 375:6,
375:17, 376:6,
376:22, 377:1,
377:13, 377:19,
377:20, 377:21,
377:24, 377:25,
378:4, 378:7,
378:12, 378:23,
379:4, 379:11,
392:1, 392:2, 392:3,
392:5, 392:10,
392:16, 403:1,
403:2, 403:12,
403:17, 404:6,
404:7, 404:9,
404:11, 404:25,
405:2, 405:12,
405:15, 405:19,
408:7, 408:8,
408:20, 410:4,
414:3, 414:4, 419:6,
421:18, 421:19,
424:11, 424:13,
424:22, 426:1,
426:17, 426:20,
446:25, 447:7,
447:9, 447:12,
447:14
logs [2] - 43:20,
149:23
long-time [1] - 155:12
long-winded [1] 284:16
loo [1] - 258:19
look [152] - 6:14, 8:21,
11:17, 15:6, 15:10,
20:5, 20:6, 20:20,
29:15, 33:18, 39:16,
46:22, 62:2, 62:4,
71:4, 78:3, 78:5,
86:17, 91:18, 91:24,
454:11, 454:14
look-see [1] - 287:16
looked [55] - 15:20,
23:8, 25:22, 61:8,
115:11, 159:3,
200:9, 240:16,
245:6, 245:16,
249:19, 287:7,
296:13, 306:21,
312:5, 312:7,
316:19, 317:11,
328:6, 328:22,
329:23, 354:15,
357:7, 360:8,
362:17, 362:18,
365:1, 365:2, 365:6,
367:3, 368:5, 368:6,
369:6, 370:10,
370:12, 376:15,
379:17, 379:19,
382:1, 388:6, 396:4,
413:19, 415:16,
417:2, 418:19,
421:10, 434:23,
438:22, 439:5,
441:13, 444:18,
446:19, 446:21
looking [42] - 62:1,
67:3, 163:2, 208:1,
222:13, 223:14,
241:3, 247:11,
253:16, 258:18,
275:13, 281:4,
287:6, 287:13,
287:17, 321:8,
338:6, 338:8,
338:25, 346:14,
349:23, 360:6,
362:19, 363:5,
363:11, 379:21,
380:5, 410:2,
410:12, 415:6,
417:19, 419:5,
423:21, 425:10,
426:24, 427:2,
434:22, 439:6,
442:20, 443:6,
444:20, 452:11
looks [5] - 175:9,
287:8, 364:16,
410:9, 417:24
loosely [2] - 120:13,
120:17
LORIN [1] - 3:17
Lorin [2] - 119:20,
270:4
Los [1] - 4:4
lose [2] - 74:2, 234:15
loss [1] - 351:6
lost [1] - 224:7
Page 29 to 29 of 54
M
machine [2] - 304:24,
351:5
MacKinnon [11] 330:14, 365:20,
371:21, 372:7,
372:24, 373:2,
373:3, 422:11,
426:6, 427:11, 448:3
MacKinnon's [1] 330:4
magnitude [7] 199:23, 200:19,
327:19, 354:22,
357:6, 435:12,
438:13
mail [28] - 14:10,
39:12, 52:8, 90:20,
109:7, 109:17,
144:20, 149:18,
277:7, 277:8, 277:9,
277:17, 280:13,
281:11, 305:23,
306:1, 332:5, 333:9,
333:15, 333:16,
333:20, 333:22,
334:23, 335:18,
337:10, 338:7
mailed [1] - 281:2
mails [36] - 14:15,
14:23, 14:24, 15:11,
39:8, 43:5, 61:20,
61:25, 62:12, 78:4,
84:23, 85:14, 85:15,
85:25, 86:9, 91:11,
91:17, 91:18, 92:2,
144:16, 305:21,
305:24, 310:13,
310:15, 310:21,
311:3, 311:14,
313:7, 329:9,
332:18, 335:24,
339:12, 339:18,
339:23, 340:2,
341:11
main [10] - 8:9, 128:9,
141:20, 205:1,
205:22, 206:20,
418:7, 419:4, 426:2,
442:2
Maine [1] - 188:24
maintain [1] - 407:13
maintained [2] 297:23, 297:25
major [4] - 153:9,
157:16, 157:21,
219:10
maker [1] - 433:23
malfunction [1] 355:15
man [1] - 284:25
manage [1] - 154:23
management [1] 150:19
Management [2] 15:24, 150:18
MANAGEMENT [4] 2:15, 2:20, 4:13,
5:20
Manager [2] - 155:13,
229:18
manager [3] - 59:7,
60:16, 69:4
managers [4] - 22:11,
53:24, 99:7, 147:6
MANARA [1] - 2:16
manifest [1] - 435:22
manner [4] - 31:1,
39:24, 250:11,
251:21
Manning [1] - 66:3
Manual [2] - 98:13,
250:20
manual [5] - 69:7,
250:21, 250:23,
250:24, 251:3
manually [1] - 54:7
manufacturer [1] 426:17
map [1] - 355:21
March [22] - 40:4,
102:14, 102:20,
103:2, 103:8,
103:11, 104:1,
104:16, 107:2,
107:5, 107:7,
107:10, 108:24,
109:25, 110:10,
112:22, 138:12,
333:17, 335:18,
335:19, 336:8,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 30
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 148 of 172
336:16
margin [2] - 436:20,
436:21
margins [1] - 165:20
marked [1] - 359:1
MARLOW [2] - 4:14,
5:24
Marlow [30] - 33:23,
227:17, 281:17,
281:20, 282:17,
282:20, 283:5,
283:15, 285:4,
285:20, 286:20,
286:25, 287:18,
287:22, 287:25,
329:12, 330:12,
330:22, 331:4,
342:9, 342:12,
342:13, 342:25,
343:10, 343:19,
433:7, 439:11,
439:23, 440:17,
454:22
Marlow's [2] - 286:10,
347:23
Maryman [8] - 39:2,
43:6, 101:23, 102:1,
106:23, 149:17,
225:25, 226:3
masked [1] - 361:3
masking [1] - 360:23
master [35] - 184:25,
185:1, 185:7,
185:10, 185:13,
185:23, 185:25,
186:1, 186:8, 187:7,
187:11, 216:2,
218:15, 219:24,
221:19, 302:3,
353:17, 372:16,
372:17, 372:19,
374:14, 374:16,
374:20, 374:21,
374:24, 375:2,
375:5, 375:9,
375:10, 375:15,
375:16, 377:15,
377:18, 426:21
Master's [5] - 152:23,
153:1, 156:15,
346:22, 412:10
Master's-level [1] 153:1
match [7] - 43:24,
44:5, 44:6, 329:18,
423:13, 431:22,
431:24
Material [1] - 346:23
material [7] - 44:3,
332:23, 335:24,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
336:3, 346:17,
347:19, 356:20
materials [6] - 110:12,
110:16, 110:20,
332:7, 346:11,
351:21
math [9] - 184:18,
184:19, 188:23,
219:18, 219:19,
219:20, 219:22,
220:9, 220:11
Mathematical [1] 412:22
mathematical [3] 185:11, 288:11,
364:20
MATTER [1] - 1:3
matter [33] - 10:25,
17:21, 28:20, 31:18,
40:12, 45:8, 46:19,
51:22, 86:18,
149:14, 155:2,
155:4, 181:14,
182:4, 234:12,
243:9, 258:4,
266:16, 266:21,
279:23, 312:24,
321:3, 323:14,
325:19, 332:25,
344:2, 347:1,
365:14, 413:1,
433:17, 433:18,
456:12
matters [8] - 18:22,
18:25, 46:18, 46:24,
201:9, 201:19,
334:15, 440:25
McNally [56] - 34:13,
34:17, 34:19, 34:25,
44:1, 44:3, 81:22,
81:25, 82:19, 83:2,
83:5, 84:14, 84:16,
92:7, 93:6, 95:14,
96:4, 123:19, 124:1,
129:12, 130:20,
130:24, 131:6,
134:25, 135:7,
137:19, 139:19,
139:20, 139:22,
140:2, 140:7,
273:15, 274:3,
274:5, 275:17,
275:24, 275:25,
276:13, 276:14,
276:19, 276:22,
276:25, 306:6,
307:13, 307:20,
308:4, 308:8,
308:16, 310:20,
316:21, 316:25,
325:24, 326:3,
333:1, 337:20,
456:11
McNally's [5] - 38:9,
44:4, 92:6, 123:2,
276:16
McPhee [3] - 3:5,
311:17, 312:11
mean [60] - 15:5, 54:8,
57:21, 61:3, 61:25,
75:12, 78:17, 87:23,
91:6, 96:19, 128:8,
140:3, 145:5,
157:11, 164:5,
164:6, 178:1, 178:3,
183:3, 185:4,
186:21, 190:24,
192:8, 192:15,
200:4, 201:7,
240:17, 256:11,
266:16, 267:2,
275:22, 276:1,
277:1, 291:21,
296:16, 314:7,
315:14, 324:18,
326:1, 338:3,
360:14, 362:2,
380:21, 389:17,
390:7, 396:7,
400:20, 401:21,
404:3, 422:22,
423:20, 432:19,
434:22, 436:11,
440:22, 445:6,
447:12, 451:16,
454:7, 454:9
meaning [1] - 262:14
meaningful [1] - 415:9
means [22] - 16:17,
18:18, 216:17,
218:9, 220:3, 222:7,
224:3, 325:5, 352:7,
361:23, 364:16,
389:8, 389:12,
389:17, 389:18,
389:20, 389:21,
390:7, 390:23,
393:12, 408:22,
410:18
meant [6] - 115:8,
238:10, 260:7,
324:4, 396:17, 407:7
measure [28] - 159:12,
184:10, 189:7,
214:2, 214:6,
214:10, 215:20,
220:16, 241:5,
292:16, 292:17,
318:18, 328:13,
363:21, 393:14,
Page 30 to 30 of 54
393:17, 394:2,
394:6, 394:7, 399:5,
406:2, 411:2, 427:1,
427:5, 428:4,
432:10, 433:15,
447:1
measured [84] - 62:23,
160:1, 160:2, 160:4,
160:9, 160:10,
161:3, 161:4, 168:4,
168:5, 168:21,
168:22, 172:9,
172:11, 172:13,
174:8, 174:20,
174:25, 175:2,
176:14, 182:16,
182:18, 189:8,
189:16, 191:9,
191:11, 191:13,
192:21, 192:22,
200:21, 214:4,
221:5, 222:24,
238:11, 254:14,
254:21, 290:24,
293:24, 314:21,
318:15, 318:19,
318:21, 327:21,
349:12, 351:21,
353:2, 353:18,
353:20, 354:24,
356:23, 360:10,
362:10, 363:12,
365:3, 369:4, 370:2,
370:3, 382:2,
388:11, 388:18,
388:20, 389:2,
389:13, 389:22,
390:3, 390:22,
393:6, 397:20,
415:23, 415:24,
416:2, 416:8,
417:21, 417:23,
418:1, 418:4, 418:9,
421:21, 422:5,
449:24, 449:25
measurement [41] 161:17, 164:22,
175:4, 176:2,
176:22, 176:23,
180:10, 184:13,
187:2, 191:25,
192:6, 205:24,
206:22, 212:10,
213:19, 213:25,
216:9, 251:16,
366:1, 366:7, 375:8,
383:12, 387:15,
396:21, 397:10,
398:20, 404:20,
405:22, 411:1,
416:3, 418:12,
418:13, 421:18,
426:9, 426:11,
427:7, 428:6,
434:25, 437:21,
447:20
measurements [97] 159:4, 160:7, 161:9,
161:24, 169:20,
174:23, 181:4,
181:9, 184:1, 185:9,
186:20, 187:12,
189:18, 190:12,
190:14, 191:23,
192:4, 193:11,
193:12, 193:13,
193:18, 199:23,
204:22, 205:3,
206:4, 206:9,
207:11, 211:15,
212:20, 213:1,
213:7, 216:3,
221:13, 222:16,
222:23, 224:5,
224:6, 224:11,
225:2, 239:25,
240:1, 240:5,
251:23, 252:6,
290:13, 292:22,
295:3, 318:7,
328:20, 349:19,
358:5, 358:7,
361:14, 361:24,
364:6, 368:24,
368:25, 369:10,
372:5, 372:17,
375:14, 376:24,
391:19, 391:24,
394:17, 394:20,
394:24, 397:1,
397:3, 397:15,
403:21, 405:18,
408:10, 408:17,
409:14, 409:15,
415:18, 415:20,
417:5, 418:10,
421:24, 423:22,
423:23, 423:24,
424:8, 426:23,
426:25, 437:13,
438:20, 438:24,
438:25, 441:17,
443:7, 446:6,
449:22, 450:14,
454:12
measures [3] 186:13, 217:21,
239:16
measuring [8] - 189:9,
355:7, 386:15,
390:24, 393:9,
397:17, 416:6, 450:3
Page 31
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 149 of 172
100:23, 101:3,
101:7, 101:11,
101:16, 103:7,
104:3, 104:17,
107:17, 109:1,
109:5, 109:15,
110:2, 110:7, 110:8,
110:18, 110:22,
111:3, 112:1, 112:9,
112:13, 112:23,
112:24, 113:4,
113:5, 125:6,
126:19, 126:23,
127:4, 129:17,
130:3, 132:8, 132:9,
134:24, 135:4,
135:12, 135:15,
135:18, 136:3,
136:17, 137:23,
138:4, 138:6, 138:9,
138:13, 138:16,
139:12, 139:15,
139:20, 140:11,
140:19, 141:5,
141:7, 144:17,
310:14, 310:16,
310:21, 311:4,
311:14, 313:7,
317:2, 317:7,
332:18, 335:24,
337:19, 337:23
messed [1] - 350:2
met [9] - 82:2, 117:20,
118:1, 239:20,
240:12, 282:1,
282:2, 282:16,
434:13
methodology [3] 220:9, 348:20,
381:20
methods [1] - 356:4
Miami [3] - 311:16,
311:20, 322:10
Michael [1] - 155:11
Michigan [2] - 47:15,
151:5
middle [4] - 111:8,
131:18, 325:1, 369:9
might [25] - 20:14,
84:23, 142:4, 144:2,
183:13, 208:6,
262:22, 283:12,
296:14, 308:17,
312:4, 314:20,
317:4, 320:4,
327:18, 328:4,
329:7, 329:16,
336:13, 357:5,
366:18, 387:24,
392:7, 439:2, 455:19
389:3, 389:14,
389:17, 389:23,
390:4, 390:13,
390:16, 390:17,
391:20, 395:22,
399:2, 399:14,
400:15, 405:23,
406:11, 406:12,
408:11, 408:18,
409:9, 410:1,
418:11, 421:21
mischaracterizes [1] 415:1
mischaracterizing [3]
- 255:22, 255:23,
266:19
misconduct [2] 247:9, 322:18
misdemeanor [1] 151:23
misidentified [1] 423:6
misinterpretation [1] 426:5
misread [1] - 264:11
misses [1] - 446:11
missing [3] - 19:20,
299:18, 430:7
misstatement [1] 390:1
mistake [8] - 185:22,
221:19, 285:25,
365:19, 372:1,
422:25, 423:2,
423:13
mistaken [1] - 297:18
mistakes [2] - 423:3,
444:19
mitt [1] - 56:23
mixed [4] - 371:6,
371:10, 419:3, 423:9
mixup [1] - 306:19
mobile [2] - 102:5,
102:8
mode [2] - 371:6,
371:10
model [65] - 166:14,
166:15, 166:18,
198:14, 198:16,
198:18, 198:19,
198:21, 201:2,
201:11, 201:14,
201:17, 202:10,
202:11, 202:13,
202:15, 202:19,
202:22, 203:1,
203:6, 204:14,
210:19, 210:20,
210:24, 212:3,
212:17, 213:5,
213:13, 328:19,
328:21, 328:22,
329:1, 360:13,
414:4, 419:4, 423:7,
423:8, 423:9, 424:3,
425:1, 425:5,
425:10, 425:12,
428:15, 428:17,
428:19, 428:22,
428:24, 429:5,
429:6, 429:10,
429:13, 429:19,
430:6, 442:15,
443:22, 449:8,
450:4, 450:8, 450:12
models [2] - 151:14,
349:20
moisten [2] - 53:16,
120:6
moisture [8] - 171:19,
174:9, 178:19,
178:22, 178:24,
179:8, 180:19, 190:2
moment [8] - 44:17,
138:25, 153:24,
221:23, 289:16,
350:12, 366:16,
399:7
money [4] - 287:15,
329:15, 342:6
monitor [1] - 393:22
monitored [2] 352:13
Monitoring [1] - 398:6
monitoring [4] 352:8, 397:25, 398:9
Montana [1] - 48:9
month [2] - 68:19,
88:21
months [4] - 103:20,
125:10, 125:14,
125:21
Moore [4] - 155:11,
155:25, 156:7,
195:13
more-than-adequate
[1] - 41:1
morning [24] - 6:5,
6:8, 6:11, 6:16, 6:23,
7:16, 7:18, 47:11,
74:13, 74:14, 78:8,
92:9, 92:21, 100:8,
100:9, 126:1,
126:18, 126:24,
131:19, 132:1,
133:23, 134:3,
144:22, 261:9
most [47] - 16:2, 19:7,
20:23, 31:5, 32:8,
39:9, 64:13, 76:7,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 32
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 150 of 172
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
143:13, 145:21,
145:22, 148:5,
148:8, 148:11,
148:15, 148:17,
148:20, 148:22,
148:23, 149:4,
149:5, 150:1, 150:3,
150:6, 150:13,
192:13, 194:14,
194:15, 194:17,
194:21, 198:23,
203:15, 203:17,
222:1, 225:17,
225:18, 225:22,
226:7, 226:14,
226:20, 227:5,
227:9, 227:15,
227:17, 227:25,
233:15, 242:13,
242:18, 242:19,
243:11, 246:8,
247:16, 247:19,
247:21, 249:16,
251:5, 251:8, 255:7,
255:8, 255:10,
255:23, 256:25,
257:2, 259:13,
259:14, 259:16,
260:17, 260:18,
260:19, 260:21,
260:25, 261:8,
265:9, 265:20,
265:23, 266:9,
266:18, 266:20,
268:5, 268:13,
271:1, 271:6, 271:7,
271:22, 271:24,
277:16, 278:23,
279:1, 279:2, 279:4,
294:16, 294:17,
294:18, 295:11,
295:19, 298:7,
298:8, 298:10,
318:2, 318:4,
321:18, 321:22,
321:24, 322:1,
340:15, 340:17,
340:18, 340:20,
342:15, 342:17,
342:18, 342:22,
342:23, 343:2,
343:3, 343:13,
343:14, 343:15,
343:20, 343:21,
343:23, 343:24,
344:16, 344:18,
344:19, 344:22,
344:23, 344:25,
345:2, 345:8, 373:8,
373:10, 380:2,
380:3, 385:25,
386:1, 392:16,
395:16, 395:24,
400:19, 400:22,
401:3, 401:4, 401:5,
401:18, 401:21,
401:25, 402:6,
402:8, 402:14,
402:17, 402:19,
402:21, 408:1,
408:2, 408:5, 409:7,
409:12, 409:16,
411:13, 411:15,
411:16, 411:17,
411:23, 427:15,
427:16, 427:19,
436:8, 437:23,
438:1, 438:4, 439:9,
439:10, 439:11,
439:13, 439:20,
448:11, 448:13,
449:13, 450:9,
453:25, 454:17,
454:19, 454:21,
455:23, 455:24,
456:2, 456:3, 456:4,
456:13, 456:21,
457:1, 457:2, 457:3
MS [1] - 198:25
multidisciplinary [1] 413:4
multiple [10] - 54:21,
89:14, 188:19,
231:24, 232:3,
351:16, 423:8, 429:3
multiples [1] - 379:2
multivariable [2] 370:25, 371:5
Murphy [1] - 152:17
must [6] - 92:17,
275:19, 275:25,
276:25, 316:25,
334:10
mutual [1] - 55:10
N
N.W [2] - 2:21, 3:21
name [15] - 47:12,
81:24, 82:24, 84:5,
93:8, 123:2, 150:14,
150:16, 228:1,
261:10, 281:12,
345:9, 373:14,
411:24, 439:21
named [2] - 84:15,
307:5
names [1] - 82:15
narrowly [1] - 335:25
Nash [13] - 42:16,
42:21, 44:8, 44:13,
Page 32 to 32 of 54
Page 33
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 151 of 172
345:5, 411:20,
439:17, 457:8
new [30] - 7:22, 9:19,
40:3, 45:24, 46:17,
49:9, 53:18, 68:23,
69:12, 69:21, 70:15,
70:24, 76:13, 88:11,
88:19, 105:19,
106:8, 106:12,
106:25, 108:17,
218:21, 219:5,
219:7, 219:8,
255:21, 377:17,
378:17, 379:5,
379:7, 401:6
NEW [1] - 1:24
news [1] - 142:14
next [59] - 12:22, 51:1,
58:2, 58:5, 61:18,
71:22, 72:5, 79:18,
92:13, 102:17,
127:4, 131:2, 131:8,
134:23, 148:22,
150:6, 159:19,
160:12, 161:10,
162:12, 163:14,
166:3, 169:2, 169:3,
174:2, 174:10,
175:13, 176:24,
177:3, 181:13,
183:24, 184:15,
187:5, 187:14,
226:4, 239:18,
248:1, 258:23,
260:25, 279:22,
280:19, 281:2,
281:3, 282:16,
293:22, 333:5,
334:4, 334:5, 336:6,
342:17, 343:15,
351:8, 351:17,
355:3, 385:24,
409:12, 411:16,
428:14, 451:1
NFL [94] - 2:10, 4:8,
4:13, 5:13, 5:20, 9:5,
14:4, 18:4, 20:12,
20:24, 21:1, 22:3,
24:4, 25:10, 28:5,
40:13, 46:6, 47:16,
47:21, 48:20, 58:18,
62:3, 65:12, 66:11,
77:4, 87:13, 87:15,
87:18, 99:18,
104:12, 105:10,
111:5, 113:10,
113:13, 113:21,
114:5, 139:6,
191:11, 218:1,
226:8, 231:7, 234:2,
234:10, 237:23,
238:25, 248:21,
249:15, 253:25,
258:14, 261:21,
261:24, 263:11,
263:15, 264:1,
264:12, 265:3,
266:8, 266:11,
266:15, 266:21,
266:25, 267:15,
270:7, 270:17,
270:18, 271:11,
271:12, 271:16,
279:16, 298:2,
309:18, 310:14,
311:2, 311:3, 321:1,
321:8, 321:11,
322:10, 324:16,
324:23, 325:13,
331:18, 337:4,
339:13, 339:14,
343:25, 344:3,
344:7, 344:14,
344:23, 376:22,
376:24, 378:11
NFL's [2] - 10:25,
45:10
NFLPA [24] - 7:20,
62:3, 64:18, 78:6,
101:22, 104:6,
104:12, 106:23,
150:6, 226:2, 226:3,
237:17, 242:5,
248:2, 252:11,
253:13, 254:5,
255:11, 300:20,
334:12, 334:13,
335:6, 359:16
nice [1] - 333:18
nickname [1] - 92:6
night [9] - 67:5, 67:9,
71:6, 71:11, 71:12,
71:13, 92:16, 93:5,
306:24
nine [3] - 131:11,
152:15, 152:25
nine-year [2] - 152:15,
152:25
Nobel [3] - 152:16,
188:21, 330:15
nobody [5] - 16:12,
235:2, 235:9, 291:3,
320:4
noise [1] - 413:17
nominal [1] - 426:23
non [76] - 17:11,
161:25, 184:22,
185:2, 186:7, 186:9,
186:12, 186:24,
188:1, 217:8,
221:10, 221:17,
221:22, 232:11,
232:15, 241:7,
291:17, 291:22,
293:1, 294:8, 295:5,
296:4, 301:7,
301:13, 301:21,
301:25, 303:1,
303:6, 316:9,
323:25, 355:5,
355:11, 356:12,
364:4, 365:13,
366:15, 366:17,
366:22, 366:24,
367:3, 367:7,
368:19, 369:1,
369:5, 375:1, 375:6,
377:21, 378:23,
379:4, 392:1, 392:5,
392:10, 392:16,
403:1, 403:12,
403:17, 404:6,
404:7, 404:9,
404:11, 404:25,
405:2, 405:12,
408:7, 408:8,
408:20, 410:4,
414:4, 419:6,
421:19, 426:17,
435:4, 435:15,
447:7, 447:9, 447:14
non-factors [1] 356:12
non-logo [73] - 17:11,
161:25, 184:22,
185:2, 186:7, 186:9,
186:12, 186:24,
188:1, 217:8,
221:10, 221:17,
221:22, 232:11,
232:15, 241:7,
291:17, 291:22,
293:1, 294:8, 295:5,
296:4, 301:7,
301:13, 301:21,
301:25, 303:1,
303:6, 316:9,
323:25, 355:5,
355:11, 364:4,
365:13, 366:15,
366:17, 366:22,
366:24, 367:3,
367:7, 368:19,
369:1, 369:5, 375:1,
375:6, 377:21,
378:23, 379:4,
392:1, 392:5,
392:10, 392:16,
403:1, 403:12,
403:17, 404:6,
404:7, 404:9,
Page 33 to 33 of 54
404:11, 404:25,
405:2, 405:12,
408:7, 408:8,
408:20, 410:4,
414:4, 419:6,
421:19, 426:17,
447:7, 447:9, 447:14
non-significance [2] 435:4, 435:15
none [18] - 12:3,
13:12, 16:4, 18:19,
44:1, 90:8, 136:5,
144:8, 174:21,
239:11, 239:15,
240:18, 240:19,
321:9, 323:18,
356:8, 356:18,
451:24
nonscientific [1] 16:15
nonsignificant [2] 425:22, 425:25
normal [8] - 77:14,
83:13, 88:4, 98:5,
108:10, 123:11,
255:4, 284:7
normally [5] - 68:13,
72:2, 72:22, 80:18,
88:8
Northwestern [1] 155:12
Notary [8] - 47:6,
150:9, 227:21,
261:4, 345:4,
411:19, 439:16,
457:7
NOTARY [1] - 1:24
note [16] - 8:13, 8:24,
11:5, 21:9, 21:10,
27:14, 27:21, 28:12,
97:17, 160:20,
226:7, 237:7, 242:9,
254:7, 334:6, 337:10
noted [3] - 76:2,
226:15, 327:5
notes [15] - 8:21,
79:19, 238:25,
244:14, 258:15,
259:1, 298:14,
298:18, 299:3,
299:20, 320:17,
320:20, 321:10,
395:18, 457:10
noteworthy [1] 152:14
nothing [28] - 9:12,
13:8, 15:5, 26:15,
42:25, 85:2, 97:21,
139:1, 145:21,
145:22, 171:13,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 34
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 152 of 172
415:12, 446:4
numbers [18] 161:20, 161:21,
163:11, 219:20,
241:10, 241:12,
283:20, 283:21,
287:6, 287:8,
287:13, 287:17,
320:12, 329:18,
364:22, 365:7,
371:2, 438:18
Numbers [1] - 104:12
Numeral [1] - 124:24
numeral [1] - 327:5
numerical [1] - 418:2
numerous [3] - 37:25,
76:14, 378:11
NW [1] - 3:3
O
oath [6] - 11:11,
149:13, 255:20,
379:20, 379:25,
385:15
object [4] - 265:9,
266:5, 266:18, 268:5
objection [10] - 8:7,
136:7, 150:1,
243:11, 246:8,
255:23, 265:12,
271:22, 278:23,
380:2
Objection [2] - 436:8,
450:9
objections [1] - 7:9
objective [3] - 284:13,
323:11, 348:16
objectivity [1] 348:17
obligated [1] - 334:12
obligation [1] - 15:18
observation [5] 252:8, 271:8,
287:23, 370:8, 447:4
observations [15] 191:2, 224:12,
225:7, 251:22,
274:5, 287:1, 350:4,
368:15, 390:10,
407:17, 422:15,
437:5, 437:8,
437:15, 439:7
observe [1] - 146:11
observed [13] 174:22, 205:4,
205:25, 206:11,
212:18, 213:6,
221:12, 270:6,
294:3, 355:25,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
413:17, 431:21,
442:8
observing [1] - 119:23
obtained [1] - 225:9
obvious [1] - 415:17
Obviously [1] - 437:4
obviously [20] - 6:20,
6:23, 7:1, 14:6,
20:23, 28:20, 31:21,
58:25, 61:24, 76:10,
79:1, 90:19, 95:10,
123:11, 135:18,
137:18, 152:20,
416:7, 444:19,
447:12
occupation [2] 228:5, 261:12
occur [1] - 406:19
occurred [20] - 10:9,
32:20, 108:22,
111:12, 167:9,
167:21, 206:5,
208:24, 208:25,
210:15, 357:24,
358:1, 385:5, 385:7,
393:4, 408:10,
408:18, 408:19,
409:9
occurs [1] - 174:20
October [5] - 52:5,
52:12, 62:11, 62:13,
70:13
OF [3] - 1:3, 1:24
offense [7] - 26:11,
26:13, 26:20,
236:13, 384:17,
385:2, 385:9
offer [2] - 182:12,
190:15
offered [1] - 98:6
office [10] - 128:19,
133:11, 146:20,
146:21, 146:23,
247:7, 247:14,
248:13, 333:20,
345:25
official [9] - 192:12,
192:15, 236:6,
241:5, 319:13,
319:23, 388:12,
389:4, 390:5
Official [3] - 160:2,
160:3, 191:11
officially [1] - 412:17
officials [29] - 35:10,
60:3, 61:7, 160:4,
161:2, 161:19,
189:5, 190:7,
191:22, 192:20,
222:25, 229:7,
230:15, 230:22,
232:13, 248:9,
249:2, 251:19,
251:25, 252:3,
252:4, 252:5, 254:9,
254:13, 254:20,
310:14, 391:7,
407:16, 415:24
officials' [5] - 121:25,
122:5, 123:20,
358:2, 406:8
officiating [2] 192:16, 229:2
often [1] - 88:8
oily [1] - 55:7
old [10] - 45:25, 46:2,
53:4, 55:12, 56:25,
69:3, 128:6, 379:8,
379:16, 380:6
older [6] - 219:4,
219:5, 296:12,
379:18, 379:21,
380:5
once [15] - 50:25,
52:1, 116:13,
125:19, 125:21,
148:1, 171:15,
172:13, 177:14,
252:20, 332:8,
401:19, 441:25
one [208] - 6:10, 8:13,
12:11, 13:3, 14:4,
15:13, 15:24, 16:2,
16:19, 18:21, 18:22,
20:23, 21:11, 21:16,
22:3, 22:18, 25:13,
26:17, 30:15, 41:17,
42:1, 42:16, 45:15,
49:11, 49:20, 52:3,
52:9, 54:7, 54:23,
56:7, 56:15, 60:21,
64:5, 66:7, 75:15,
77:10, 80:7, 84:14,
91:7, 91:20, 93:18,
93:19, 94:9, 94:10,
94:12, 94:14, 97:12,
100:15, 100:21,
101:2, 124:16,
126:4, 129:8, 130:5,
130:13, 135:10,
135:17, 138:25,
139:19, 143:10,
144:15, 144:17,
144:23, 152:14,
153:9, 153:22,
157:18, 160:20,
161:6, 161:16,
162:1, 171:20,
180:7, 180:9, 186:4,
188:4, 189:4, 195:6,
Page 34 to 34 of 54
196:9, 209:9,
216:15, 218:17,
220:9, 223:5, 226:9,
229:6, 230:16,
232:2, 232:3, 232:5,
237:6, 237:8,
237:11, 238:21,
239:18, 240:13,
240:15, 240:21,
240:23, 240:25,
241:23, 243:22,
246:19, 246:20,
247:25, 249:14,
249:18, 251:17,
251:25, 253:9,
255:18, 256:12,
256:15, 258:18,
260:16, 264:9,
269:23, 270:10,
271:13, 272:16,
273:1, 274:1,
275:15, 283:22,
288:18, 288:23,
289:2, 289:8,
290:16, 291:11,
294:20, 294:24,
296:5, 298:7,
299:22, 301:13,
301:18, 304:18,
307:9, 315:1,
315:19, 316:14,
317:15, 322:6,
323:4, 325:1, 330:7,
335:11, 338:2,
343:21, 343:24,
349:7, 350:20,
352:5, 352:15,
361:19, 365:19,
367:14, 368:14,
369:15, 370:24,
371:24, 374:19,
376:23, 378:20,
378:23, 379:1,
380:25, 381:2,
381:5, 381:9,
381:11, 381:15,
385:24, 386:22,
387:3, 387:25,
390:15, 395:14,
396:1, 397:6,
416:19, 416:25,
421:7, 421:19,
426:14, 426:18,
427:3, 428:20,
428:24, 429:5,
429:10, 430:16,
432:2, 433:11,
436:24, 437:2,
437:12, 437:15,
437:20, 438:1,
441:12, 445:7, 451:1
Page 35
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 153 of 172
344:23, 369:21,
397:21, 407:13,
415:21, 415:23,
416:3, 416:7,
419:12, 425:3,
425:4, 425:9,
425:12, 425:13,
425:20, 425:22,
429:21, 431:15,
438:7
orderly [2] - 251:14,
251:17
ordinarily [1] - 25:3
ordinary [1] - 108:15
organization [5] 63:24, 97:7, 143:5,
151:10
organize [1] - 161:8
organized [3] 157:14, 161:14,
162:5
oriented [2] - 49:24,
347:16
original [9] - 18:7,
68:20, 70:12,
151:24, 152:6,
210:18, 210:20,
210:24, 337:13
originally [2] - 395:4,
415:3
otherwise [2] 265:11, 315:12
ought [1] - 305:25
ourselves [1] - 348:11
outcome [12] - 186:3,
215:22, 220:2,
220:3, 222:10,
284:12, 363:23,
364:25, 365:10,
365:11, 365:16,
447:3
outdoor [1] - 447:20
outer [1] - 409:23
outfit [1] - 281:9
outraged [1] - 280:21
outset [2] - 8:14,
348:6
outside [12] - 28:6,
164:8, 164:9, 221:6,
234:16, 292:15,
292:19, 307:9,
307:18, 309:1,
322:20, 369:13
outstanding [1] 109:4
overall [8] - 41:17,
162:16, 286:1,
395:15, 396:16,
402:11, 404:22,
405:17
153 of 172 sheets
P
p-factor [1] - 369:17
p-value [17] - 166:6,
166:23, 168:13,
177:12, 177:14,
177:23, 177:24,
179:9, 179:11,
222:5, 222:7,
418:20, 419:20,
420:4, 420:15,
424:23, 425:23
p-value's [2] - 166:13,
420:12
p-values [6] - 166:19,
381:24, 417:15,
418:24, 419:13,
432:14
p.m [15] - 111:12,
111:25, 112:1,
149:3, 194:19,
260:24, 345:1,
395:25, 457:5
packers [4] - 248:5,
254:12, 254:18,
254:24
page [93] - 26:2, 62:4,
78:5, 91:25, 94:8,
94:13, 105:16,
111:7, 111:8,
111:16, 111:17,
115:18, 124:23,
125:24, 126:15,
127:1, 127:2, 129:4,
129:10, 129:14,
129:21, 130:19,
131:8, 131:18,
132:6, 132:17,
132:18, 133:22,
139:10, 144:19,
162:14, 200:15,
201:12, 205:19,
208:19, 208:21,
222:1, 222:13,
222:19, 224:13,
224:18, 224:19,
224:23, 225:1,
238:20, 239:3,
240:2, 258:16,
259:3, 262:25,
263:9, 264:7, 272:2,
273:8, 273:9,
277:10, 286:3,
287:3, 298:12,
298:22, 298:23,
298:24, 300:19,
300:21, 318:10,
326:23, 326:25,
327:4, 330:14,
333:7, 333:13,
333:14, 337:25,
350:15, 350:16,
353:7, 354:12,
355:10, 367:15,
382:23, 388:8,
392:7, 397:11,
402:23, 403:25,
408:6
PAGE [1] - 5:3
Page [2] - 212:13,
430:4
pages [4] - 104:15,
299:5, 320:24, 338:1
paid [7] - 158:5,
278:21, 278:25,
279:5, 279:6,
279:14, 342:9
pair [1] - 62:11
pairs [1] - 225:2
Panda [3] - 62:12,
62:16, 277:19
panel [1] - 88:16
panels [1] - 196:8
panthers [2] - 246:13,
259:25
paper [7] - 59:9,
59:20, 59:24, 119:4,
153:17, 153:18,
264:21
paperwork [2] Page 35 to 35 of 54
247:12, 247:13
paragraph [31] - 28:3,
36:2, 102:5, 102:11,
102:18, 107:1,
111:10, 111:23,
200:16, 205:20,
224:20, 225:1,
242:21, 242:22,
242:23, 263:10,
273:10, 300:23,
327:1, 327:4,
327:22, 334:4,
334:5, 334:19,
337:9, 348:25,
355:11, 355:22,
356:15, 356:24,
357:17
parameters [4] 184:5, 205:10,
362:16, 362:17
pardon [2] - 144:17,
144:21
Park [5] - 1:15, 2:3,
2:15, 3:10, 346:1
parroted [1] - 280:6
parse [2] - 41:19,
41:21
Part [1] - 449:20
part [40] - 15:8, 34:7,
50:10, 82:10,
118:15, 138:3,
138:6, 151:20,
152:8, 152:10,
174:14, 182:18,
182:20, 200:2,
212:12, 218:14,
219:1, 219:15,
286:14, 286:18,
315:23, 320:6,
347:7, 352:1, 362:8,
384:11, 395:14,
396:10, 396:14,
396:15, 396:24,
403:9, 417:1,
421:16, 423:5,
426:4, 431:5, 442:2,
449:21, 455:3
part-time [1] - 82:10
partially [1] - 206:24
participate [3] 237:22, 452:2,
456:25
participated [3] 10:15, 273:23, 287:1
particle [5] - 440:20,
440:23, 448:19,
448:24, 449:3
particular [28] - 30:9,
30:20, 49:23, 54:23,
55:8, 80:22, 88:12,
114:25, 115:23,
116:23, 129:7,
133:4, 147:20,
211:19, 218:22,
228:24, 230:14,
242:23, 243:20,
245:11, 259:25,
276:9, 284:9,
323:17, 346:9,
401:5, 440:18,
449:11
particularly [10] 6:13, 8:11, 12:10,
16:3, 158:1, 191:20,
327:13, 334:14,
345:24, 346:15
parties [2] - 98:7,
456:5
partly [3] - 57:9,
194:4, 194:5
partner [1] - 261:13
partners [1] - 324:13
parts [2] - 41:19,
220:7
PASH [1] - 2:5
Pash [21] - 261:20,
262:3, 262:5, 262:7,
263:15, 264:2,
264:10, 265:1,
265:5, 266:1, 266:7,
267:6, 267:7,
267:10, 267:25,
268:7, 268:16,
269:8, 269:14,
310:2, 310:8
Pash's [3] - 265:25,
266:12, 269:14
pass [1] - 150:4
passed [1] - 370:4
passer [1] - 135:3
passing [1] - 73:18
past [10] - 23:7, 60:22,
77:18, 84:21, 196:3,
196:12, 210:25,
249:20, 334:8,
376:22
path [1] - 165:21
patience [1] - 457:3
Patrick [1] - 47:13
Patriots [131] - 24:7,
29:25, 31:18, 33:3,
47:19, 47:23, 48:1,
51:6, 51:12, 51:18,
60:8, 61:7, 63:24,
74:10, 75:2, 82:5,
97:7, 118:25,
121:13, 121:21,
122:4, 129:1, 143:5,
144:9, 145:9,
160:15, 160:22,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 36
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 154 of 172
161:15, 168:16,
176:19, 180:10,
189:25, 199:25,
200:20, 215:25,
216:8, 217:2,
217:10, 217:13,
217:23, 218:6,
221:12, 222:23,
229:12, 236:1,
236:6, 236:19,
238:2, 243:2, 248:5,
252:15, 252:16,
262:10, 263:16,
269:19, 273:14,
273:17, 293:4,
293:8, 293:9,
293:16, 293:20,
293:24, 294:2,
294:3, 294:7, 295:4,
295:8, 295:22,
296:3, 297:3, 297:5,
300:9, 307:8,
307:19, 310:23,
313:14, 314:4,
314:24, 320:8,
327:10, 329:6,
329:7, 330:13,
332:3, 332:6, 332:8,
332:12, 340:12,
349:5, 354:19,
354:23, 356:5,
356:11, 358:5,
358:15, 362:11,
364:8, 364:14,
368:7, 376:1, 376:4,
376:8, 383:4, 383:6,
383:15, 385:1,
385:13, 386:9,
388:9, 389:1,
396:10, 396:18,
398:14, 399:16,
399:17, 403:18,
403:21, 419:9,
419:15, 419:24,
420:1, 424:7,
424:10, 424:12,
432:21, 438:24,
450:22, 455:2
Patriots' [140] - 11:22,
16:20, 18:24, 34:3,
144:10, 155:7,
159:4, 159:12,
159:16, 160:1,
160:9, 161:4,
162:22, 163:7,
163:12, 163:17,
164:4, 164:7, 167:9,
167:20, 168:4,
168:21, 169:20,
171:8, 171:25,
174:9, 174:25,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
175:2, 176:13,
176:15, 176:22,
178:15, 181:5,
181:7, 182:11,
183:14, 183:15,
183:22, 184:1,
185:15, 185:18,
187:17, 189:7,
192:22, 193:11,
193:13, 197:8,
200:16, 205:5,
206:11, 208:23,
215:15, 215:20,
216:20, 217:15,
218:24, 219:3,
222:24, 225:2,
235:13, 236:23,
239:10, 240:17,
253:2, 287:8, 289:5,
290:13, 318:22,
318:23, 319:14,
328:1, 350:22,
358:24, 362:4,
363:22, 365:10,
367:23, 368:18,
369:4, 370:1,
373:24, 376:16,
382:3, 382:15,
382:16, 382:21,
384:24, 387:2,
387:12, 387:17,
388:2, 388:4,
388:10, 388:18,
388:19, 389:2,
389:9, 389:22,
390:2, 390:22,
391:25, 396:2,
396:4, 398:18,
403:7, 404:20,
406:3, 406:7,
408:10, 408:17,
409:14, 409:20,
409:23, 414:8,
415:24, 417:22,
418:9, 418:13,
418:14, 418:16,
419:19, 421:18,
421:20, 421:24,
423:23, 434:24,
438:19, 438:21,
438:25, 439:7,
442:23, 446:23,
447:1, 449:17,
449:24, 450:13,
450:15, 455:8
pattern [2] - 87:1,
431:21
patterns [1] - 86:25
Paul [37] - 100:16,
100:22, 109:4,
110:1, 113:1, 113:6,
123:18, 138:11,
155:15, 261:13,
262:14, 263:13,
263:14, 264:17,
264:23, 267:5,
268:7, 270:15,
271:9, 278:21,
280:11, 280:20,
284:18, 285:8,
300:24, 307:17,
315:6, 327:5, 347:6,
348:8, 348:23,
357:25, 384:9,
406:5, 407:4, 408:9,
408:17
PAUL [1] - 3:15
pause [2] - 157:25,
224:23
pay [2] - 162:10, 192:9
payment [2] - 196:18,
196:21
pays [1] - 266:25
peace [1] - 330:15
pedantic [1] - 446:10
penalties [1] - 151:23
penalty [3] - 15:16,
23:15, 28:8
pending [1] - 344:16
people [77] - 15:20,
16:2, 16:4, 22:24,
23:1, 25:3, 25:5,
61:21, 80:3, 80:4,
82:9, 82:10, 82:20,
83:11, 83:23, 84:4,
89:6, 123:10, 154:4,
154:11, 154:14,
154:17, 155:15,
155:17, 188:19,
190:13, 191:25,
194:11, 200:3,
209:3, 210:11,
227:1, 243:24,
244:7, 244:25,
252:5, 276:20,
281:21, 282:13,
289:15, 292:13,
294:12, 302:25,
303:21, 304:4,
306:4, 306:13,
308:22, 309:1,
310:11, 310:23,
311:18, 314:21,
315:14, 324:19,
325:12, 325:14,
330:23, 331:4,
337:19, 337:22,
338:20, 340:6,
342:21, 342:24,
343:4, 343:8,
343:16, 347:2,
Page 36 to 36 of 54
347:22, 350:9,
376:8, 437:12,
445:5, 446:2, 456:21
people's [3] - 90:25,
196:9, 196:10
per [2] - 113:23, 441:7
percent [31] - 165:2,
166:21, 179:13,
181:21, 222:8,
222:9, 307:13,
309:8, 354:17,
369:18, 369:24,
375:10, 375:20,
386:8, 386:9,
419:21, 419:22,
420:6, 420:7,
420:16, 420:17,
420:18, 432:12,
432:13, 432:15,
432:17, 432:23,
433:12, 433:15,
451:4
perfect [1] - 294:21
perfectly [4] - 302:1,
302:4, 316:10, 444:5
perfectly-calibrated
[1] - 302:4
perform [4] - 50:14,
336:2, 349:9, 352:1
performed [11] 158:9, 158:10,
198:2, 198:7,
215:16, 224:16,
349:14, 368:2,
412:25, 413:7,
413:14
perhaps [2] - 145:22,
325:9
period [48] - 13:25,
39:14, 39:19, 77:20,
79:20, 89:10, 103:8,
103:10, 103:14,
103:19, 104:4,
104:18, 104:20,
107:16, 107:18,
112:4, 112:5,
112:21, 113:19,
139:16, 142:11,
142:12, 144:17,
144:18, 152:15,
152:25, 168:8,
170:8, 179:5,
215:13, 236:2,
366:7, 372:4, 377:9,
379:3, 383:15,
387:15, 392:6,
392:9, 398:24,
398:25, 400:2,
400:7, 408:11,
409:10, 440:11,
450:3
periodically [1] 87:10
permeability [2] 351:18, 351:21
permissible [3] 115:22, 118:9,
121:12
permission [5] 308:11, 308:18,
308:23, 309:6,
309:12
permitted [1] - 335:4
person [28] - 9:14,
9:15, 14:9, 20:4,
24:18, 24:23, 29:14,
29:21, 37:21, 82:4,
82:5, 84:1, 130:17,
144:7, 154:5,
154:13, 161:20,
188:17, 228:22,
285:1, 297:12,
303:20, 307:9,
309:9, 309:10,
334:7, 338:18
personal [9] - 14:6,
25:6, 109:19,
228:20, 274:5,
287:1, 323:3, 324:7,
324:15
Personal [2] - 9:22,
22:16
personally [4] - 124:1,
137:3, 243:23,
246:24
personnel [3] - 22:24,
118:25, 121:14
perusing) [1] - 287:3
Peterson [2] - 21:18,
45:24
petition [5] - 64:16,
64:19, 64:20, 64:24,
65:20
Peyton [3] - 64:11,
66:1, 66:2
Ph.D [9] - 151:20,
188:22, 284:24,
286:18, 346:22,
347:9, 347:15,
347:19, 412:10
pharmaceuticals [1] 153:17
phenomena [2] 403:14, 404:13
philosophy [1] 445:25
phone [96] - 37:20,
39:18, 40:3, 40:4,
42:1, 43:8, 43:20,
43:21, 44:10, 44:24,
Page 37
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 155 of 172
363:5, 363:11,
375:22, 375:23,
388:6, 425:7,
425:16, 431:21
physically [2] - 82:5,
392:23
physicist [2] - 284:24,
330:16
physicists [4] - 280:8,
283:10, 284:20,
440:21
physics [10] - 33:24,
188:22, 281:5,
286:11, 440:16,
440:23, 440:24,
448:20, 448:24,
449:3
Physics [8] - 280:10,
280:14, 280:18,
280:20, 281:16,
281:21, 439:25,
440:4
pick [12] - 51:24, 52:1,
114:25, 115:10,
115:12, 115:21,
116:1, 116:12,
118:12, 386:7,
386:10
picked [14] - 71:24,
114:16, 114:24,
115:23, 118:13,
118:14, 148:2,
384:22, 386:10,
400:17, 400:23,
400:24, 401:8
picking [3] - 94:19,
95:5, 144:23
picture [2] - 351:3,
353:13
piece [3] - 59:9,
264:21, 444:9
pieces [2] - 275:15,
349:6
Pierre [1] - 155:13
pin [1] - 186:17
pissed [3] - 57:8, 57:9,
57:22
place [13] - 18:11,
162:15, 211:4,
230:19, 234:10,
248:4, 251:14,
252:23, 256:21,
276:5, 288:12,
399:1, 443:18
placed [2] - 104:7,
105:13
places [1] - 239:2
plain [1] - 452:22
plainly [1] - 40:23
plaintiff [1] - 284:9
26:22
playing [11] - 52:3,
54:5, 117:1, 137:7,
170:16, 218:1,
229:21, 282:11,
372:23, 384:20,
385:10
plenty [3] - 170:24,
171:1, 171:4
plot [1] - 405:17
plotted [1] - 387:7
plug [1] - 364:19
plugging [1] - 219:20
plural [1] - 255:15
point [72] - 8:13, 10:1,
10:19, 28:21, 29:6,
30:15, 33:13, 34:1,
35:23, 37:13, 38:16,
38:20, 41:17, 42:25,
75:15, 80:13, 84:14,
107:22, 109:8,
114:17, 121:17,
129:2, 149:5,
157:25, 158:1,
162:1, 163:23,
164:1, 169:9,
169:18, 169:19,
174:20, 186:22,
190:2, 200:10,
204:10, 213:18,
219:10, 221:8,
242:12, 291:13,
313:16, 319:3,
320:3, 321:19,
343:19, 367:19,
378:23, 396:25,
399:5, 400:21,
402:16, 413:13,
415:11, 415:12,
415:25, 416:19,
420:19, 421:25,
424:18, 442:18,
442:25, 445:24,
446:11, 446:12,
446:13, 449:6,
449:12, 449:15,
453:19, 454:8, 456:1
pointed [6] - 340:4,
367:7, 425:2,
426:11, 432:9, 447:6
pointing [3] - 348:3,
366:21, 431:18
points [12] - 30:12,
33:10, 34:1, 42:16,
66:7, 178:14,
289:17, 303:23,
373:21, 374:10,
416:24, 426:2
policies [5] - 9:19,
21:21, 22:3, 22:15,
22:18
Policies [2] - 25:17,
25:23
Policy [10] - 2:7, 9:15,
9:22, 21:1, 22:16,
24:24, 25:5, 98:13,
98:24, 99:9
policy [46] - 9:3, 9:8,
9:21, 9:23, 22:8,
22:9, 22:19, 22:20,
22:22, 23:3, 23:25,
24:20, 24:24, 25:12,
25:13, 25:15, 26:2,
26:14, 26:15, 26:17,
26:18, 26:22, 44:19,
45:21, 45:25, 46:2,
46:15, 46:17, 86:13,
97:13, 98:13, 153:4,
250:13, 250:16,
250:19, 272:4,
272:8, 272:14,
273:1, 311:12,
311:21, 311:25,
312:3
ponder [1] - 445:5
pooled [1] - 419:17
population [2] 437:19, 437:20
portion [3] - 104:11,
212:18, 213:5
portions [1] - 209:20
posed [1] - 11:8
position [10] - 9:3,
150:17, 150:21,
217:15, 284:9,
312:15, 338:13,
339:5, 421:14, 440:7
positions [2] - 412:12,
440:8
positive [2] - 18:16,
425:10
positively [1] - 154:20
possession [2] 236:2, 377:22
possibilities [6] 188:8, 369:6, 369:7,
392:21, 393:1, 393:2
possibility [12] 186:19, 187:3,
192:25, 366:17,
366:20, 377:2,
385:4, 389:14,
409:24, 414:2,
414:6, 423:25
possible [27] - 49:10,
81:15, 82:17,
103:16, 120:17,
143:25, 144:4,
145:17, 237:5,
266:13, 297:17,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 38
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 156 of 172
297:20, 314:20,
344:15, 368:23,
370:14, 384:14,
384:15, 385:6,
391:21, 392:19,
407:5, 408:20,
410:13, 410:24,
413:6, 444:21
possibly [12] - 26:1,
26:9, 59:1, 107:9,
107:21, 108:5,
108:19, 144:13,
229:8, 236:25,
395:19, 395:20
post [22] - 28:13,
192:21, 193:11,
193:14, 193:18,
193:25, 248:22,
249:4, 249:7,
249:13, 298:16,
318:7, 394:19,
451:6, 451:9,
451:15, 452:2,
454:23, 455:7,
455:18, 456:7,
456:18
post-game [18] 192:21, 193:11,
193:14, 193:18,
193:25, 248:22,
249:4, 249:7,
249:13, 298:16,
318:7, 451:6, 451:9,
451:15, 452:2,
454:23, 455:7,
455:18
post-hearing [3] 28:13, 456:7, 456:18
post-time [1] - 394:19
potential [10] - 29:16,
155:7, 191:25,
238:4, 349:10,
355:24, 365:6,
404:13, 421:8,
451:18
potentially [3] 233:25, 403:13,
443:8
pounding [3] - 282:12,
328:12, 329:10
pounds [5] - 113:15,
113:23, 294:22,
294:25, 351:6
power [1] - 435:9
PowerPoint [2] 330:20, 417:10
practical [2] - 221:4,
433:23
practice [26] - 43:10,
43:18, 45:10, 53:25,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
425:19, 427:3
preceded [1] - 442:9
precedent [4] - 9:4,
9:24, 21:13, 43:2
precise [2] - 288:18,
334:10
precisely [1] - 106:2
preclude [1] - 363:10
predecessors [1] 29:13
predicted [4] - 187:18,
358:6, 362:24,
365:11
prediction [1] - 188:17
predictions [1] - 394:1
predicts [1] - 288:9
predominant [1] 325:3
preface [1] - 156:20
prefer [2] - 116:4,
373:17
preferably [1] - 280:8
preference [5] 119:13, 119:14,
122:8, 124:2, 148:17
preferred [7] - 114:12,
114:15, 115:13,
118:5, 118:7,
119:17, 166:11
prefers [1] - 35:14
prejudice [1] - 268:13
prejudicial [1] - 455:1
preliminary [1] - 417:9
premises [2] - 43:3,
232:9
prep [2] - 24:10, 250:4
preparation [10] 64:7, 69:5, 70:17,
81:4, 142:21,
267:18, 396:11,
396:16, 396:23,
400:4
preparations [2] 356:4, 401:10
prepare [8] - 12:3,
64:21, 65:15, 77:2,
80:19, 80:20, 321:5,
396:13
prepared [16] - 11:2,
54:23, 60:24, 117:7,
144:7, 146:2,
264:16, 265:4,
268:8, 268:9,
269:24, 356:4,
356:8, 371:20,
399:22, 444:11
preparing [5] - 71:19,
80:18, 80:23,
250:10, 321:9
preponderance [5] Page 38 to 38 of 54
324:17, 325:4,
420:23, 434:2,
434:12
prepping [1] - 49:21
presence [1] - 251:10
present [16] - 7:21,
10:22, 31:4, 45:8,
150:5, 169:17,
206:3, 234:21,
327:17, 333:23,
343:8, 359:6,
424:21, 429:6,
429:11, 430:5
presented [15] - 8:9,
65:12, 66:4, 197:21,
268:15, 285:6,
374:12, 380:10,
392:21, 404:11,
428:16, 428:19,
428:24, 429:1,
444:20
presently [1] - 113:13
presents [1] - 264:17
preserve [1] - 232:21
preserving [1] 228:12
President [10] - 2:6,
2:7, 24:12, 24:22,
25:1, 25:6, 228:6,
228:9, 249:24,
263:15
president [4] - 246:7,
345:16, 345:17,
347:14
presidents [1] - 99:7
press [9] - 142:24,
261:25, 262:17,
264:1, 264:21,
309:17, 340:22,
341:17, 342:2
pressure [150] - 12:4,
12:11, 12:16, 13:2,
13:5, 16:20, 16:21,
16:22, 18:8, 18:18,
19:6, 60:8, 60:25,
63:5, 63:14, 64:25,
67:24, 68:6, 96:13,
114:18, 115:1,
115:13, 116:5,
116:8, 116:9,
116:14, 118:5,
118:8, 121:25,
141:4, 157:20,
158:24, 158:25,
162:23, 163:16,
166:18, 167:8,
167:20, 169:16,
171:15, 172:8,
172:10, 172:13,
197:7, 197:23,
199:20, 199:24,
200:17, 200:19,
204:22, 205:4,
206:1, 206:10,
208:23, 212:19,
213:6, 213:22,
215:24, 221:12,
222:15, 223:1,
230:23, 233:4,
234:16, 248:21,
250:17, 288:10,
291:6, 292:17,
314:14, 327:14,
327:20, 349:11,
350:11, 350:25,
351:7, 351:15,
352:13, 352:16,
353:18, 353:19,
353:21, 353:25,
354:20, 354:23,
355:14, 355:25,
356:10, 356:21,
356:23, 357:6,
357:10, 357:11,
357:15, 358:14,
359:18, 360:7,
360:23, 360:25,
361:14, 363:8,
364:8, 364:20,
366:3, 368:17,
370:5, 370:6,
370:13, 372:18,
380:13, 382:6,
384:12, 388:3,
394:13, 396:6,
397:17, 397:22,
397:24, 398:7,
398:9, 398:15,
398:20, 399:13,
399:14, 399:16,
399:18, 414:7,
414:18, 415:7,
416:23, 416:25,
418:1, 418:5, 422:5,
422:7, 425:10,
425:11, 425:14,
425:18, 426:23,
427:5, 427:6, 428:3,
431:11, 432:4,
432:19, 434:22,
445:18, 446:6,
447:17
pressures [14] - 13:7,
224:21, 225:1,
239:10, 353:2,
355:8, 357:13,
362:21, 374:14,
374:15, 374:16,
374:20, 374:21,
455:14
presumably [1] -
Page 39
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 157 of 172
399:24
presume [3] - 161:9,
161:24, 401:17
presumed [1] - 163:6
pretty [16] - 49:8,
52:19, 127:14,
347:25, 348:10,
348:24, 354:12,
356:15, 377:10,
379:17, 407:14,
410:22, 426:20,
427:4, 435:21,
446:14
previous [5] - 69:4,
150:23, 245:6,
245:7, 245:14
previously [10] 15:25, 92:10, 120:4,
151:4, 153:6,
211:25, 311:25,
332:6, 359:1, 413:10
Princeton [8] - 33:24,
281:16, 282:19,
282:21, 439:25,
440:2, 440:5, 440:8
principal [5] - 270:3,
270:11, 345:16,
347:3, 412:3
Principal [1] - 155:13
principle [4] - 21:16,
21:17, 158:8, 438:5
principles [2] - 157:6,
157:9
Prioleau [5] - 160:3,
240:6, 258:19,
259:8, 292:22
privacy [1] - 283:13
private [4] - 43:16,
90:25, 152:5, 322:22
privilege [11] - 266:14,
267:7, 267:16,
268:3, 268:12,
268:14, 269:13,
270:21, 271:4,
278:23, 311:25
privileged [6] - 265:7,
265:10, 266:6,
266:13, 270:1, 279:1
privy [1] - 138:7
Prize [2] - 152:16,
188:21
prize [1] - 330:15
probability [4] 209:22, 369:23,
409:24, 435:13
probable [11] - 10:8,
10:15, 31:23, 38:11,
273:13, 274:16,
303:6, 317:11,
324:19, 325:5, 325:7
157 of 172 sheets
344:5
proposed [2] - 334:11,
456:6
proposition [1] 434:19
prose [1] - 430:12
protecting [1] - 40:14
protocol [17] - 34:13,
34:21, 57:11, 167:3,
190:8, 190:9, 192:8,
192:20, 194:5,
233:24, 234:13,
255:5, 308:4, 309:7,
309:12, 317:3, 317:6
protocols [7] - 119:6,
165:15, 190:16,
193:12, 314:11,
314:15
prove [2] - 316:15,
446:17
provide [23] - 10:4,
14:17, 15:9, 15:14,
30:1, 36:21, 36:22,
37:2, 38:19, 38:23,
43:19, 105:7,
107:20, 107:24,
109:10, 121:21,
268:17, 268:22,
268:23, 286:20,
315:11, 327:6, 349:1
provided [22] - 15:19,
38:1, 38:2, 39:13,
43:19, 101:17,
102:9, 102:24,
103:3, 104:20,
105:3, 105:6, 108:7,
108:12, 110:13,
158:12, 182:15,
337:8, 339:13,
339:16, 357:24,
408:9
provides [2] - 41:1,
159:14
providing [2] - 14:15,
109:11
proving [1] - 201:18
proximity [1] - 280:11
proxy [2] - 416:4,
416:9
psi [54] - 58:14, 58:17,
63:5, 63:14, 63:20,
73:6, 97:22, 114:8,
115:7, 140:7, 163:7,
163:8, 163:11,
163:12, 169:12,
171:10, 171:20,
173:2, 174:17,
175:12, 175:20,
175:21, 177:19,
177:22, 184:6,
192:2, 192:5,
215:14, 216:1,
216:8, 217:2,
217:10, 217:13,
218:2, 238:22,
292:24, 353:20,
355:18, 367:23,
372:15, 375:11,
375:17, 375:20,
376:1, 396:21,
397:17, 397:23,
400:10, 417:23,
417:24, 422:5, 455:9
psi's [2] - 65:5, 163:25
psychological [1] 116:25
public [11] - 7:24,
11:6, 35:13, 119:22,
121:2, 153:4, 244:9,
247:23, 264:14,
302:18, 344:11
PUBLIC [1] - 1:24
Public [8] - 47:6,
150:9, 227:21,
261:4, 345:5,
411:19, 439:16,
457:7
publically [2] - 114:7,
263:11
publication [1] 153:18
publicity [1] - 280:5
published [4] 280:23, 340:25,
368:12, 370:18
pulled [1] - 382:11
pumped [3] - 318:24,
319:4, 319:12
punish [1] - 19:11
punished [4] - 9:14,
9:16, 9:25, 45:22
punishment [2] - 46:4,
336:21
puny [2] - 164:21,
193:5
purely [2] - 32:23,
415:10
purported [1] - 421:4
purporting [1] 424:21
purpose [12] - 81:8,
105:7, 108:6, 153:3,
156:19, 204:20,
206:7, 253:5,
270:19, 353:22,
415:1, 443:23
purposefully [1] 325:8
purposely [1] - 35:9
purposes [2] - 108:4,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 40
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 158 of 172
267:16
pursuant [3] - 263:19,
272:3, 272:10
pursue [2] - 395:13,
452:24
push [2] - 248:7,
249:1
pushing [1] - 248:18
put [64] - 13:11, 13:22,
14:8, 21:7, 30:8,
42:8, 73:5, 83:18,
115:24, 120:5,
122:22, 122:23,
161:21, 163:22,
171:18, 186:17,
192:1, 210:23,
215:9, 246:17,
246:20, 248:8,
257:24, 265:3,
273:19, 276:19,
306:22, 319:1,
338:17, 339:4,
341:2, 349:20,
352:11, 352:23,
360:12, 372:18,
375:20, 380:12,
380:18, 380:19,
380:24, 381:1,
381:3, 381:9,
381:16, 391:22,
393:13, 397:22,
407:8, 411:7, 425:4,
425:12, 425:13,
428:10, 429:12,
429:13, 429:16,
429:18, 430:20,
431:14, 436:3,
437:11, 443:23,
445:24
puts [1] - 409:23
putting [7] - 26:4,
38:11, 69:12, 76:21,
182:8, 230:15, 381:6
puzzled [1] - 39:4
Pye [1] - 347:13
Q
QB [1] - 127:6
qualify [2] - 337:17,
433:19
quality [1] - 154:8
quantified [1] - 357:3
quarrel [1] - 304:1
quarreling [4] - 219:9,
219:22, 219:23,
308:19
quarter [6] - 230:5,
230:6, 230:8, 236:1,
236:22, 382:17
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
R
rabbit [2] - 219:2,
329:14
race [1] - 284:4
radar [1] - 115:6
radio [4] - 74:13,
74:22, 74:25, 78:10
rained [2] - 70:8,
76:19
raining [1] - 406:22
rainy [2] - 236:15,
384:6
raise [5] - 135:23,
136:22, 136:25,
137:25, 138:18
raised [10] - 34:2,
42:16, 73:19,
103:16, 143:17,
143:23, 144:2,
145:19, 190:2,
329:13
raises [1] - 28:2
ran [6] - 202:23,
203:2, 349:23,
359:4, 367:1, 382:25
randomly [2] - 118:12,
119:16
range [17] - 115:22,
116:6, 118:9,
121:12, 152:10,
153:16, 177:10,
177:24, 185:16,
185:17, 206:2,
279:13, 355:21,
357:22, 365:2,
365:6, 365:9
ranges [4] - 169:16,
177:11, 362:23,
387:6
rapid [1] - 350:7
rate [1] - 351:17
rather [4] - 128:21,
188:9, 395:22,
Page 40 to 40 of 54
456:15
rating [1] - 135:3
raw [12] - 159:20,
161:7, 161:13,
223:14, 224:1,
224:4, 224:14,
225:8, 287:6,
287:13, 287:17,
289:16
Ray [1] - 27:1
RDR [2] - 1:23, 457:12
re [1] - 417:2
re-looked [1] - 417:2
reach [13] - 165:12,
181:23, 182:5,
185:15, 190:19,
207:23, 208:14,
215:23, 225:15,
285:5, 309:4,
323:17, 354:3
reached [25] - 66:8,
182:22, 188:14,
207:19, 211:17,
280:9, 280:20,
280:22, 315:22,
315:23, 317:24,
347:13, 354:6,
354:10, 358:11,
361:8, 363:17,
366:13, 371:17,
373:6, 416:14,
427:13, 444:23,
447:25, 448:9
reaching [2] - 194:11,
317:8
react [8] - 56:13,
58:15, 58:24,
220:25, 248:23,
249:1, 249:3, 249:6
reacted [1] - 72:20
reaction [15] - 51:17,
52:11, 74:16,
359:20, 359:23,
361:17, 363:24,
368:20, 370:7,
370:22, 414:20,
445:20, 446:8,
447:4, 447:5
reactions [2] - 371:22,
422:14
read [49] - 41:10, 96:6,
114:5, 123:25,
135:25, 136:9,
136:14, 149:9,
173:15, 184:21,
197:1, 201:7,
201:11, 201:23,
202:6, 202:8,
208:17, 210:12,
215:8, 218:15,
219:5, 243:23,
244:9, 244:15,
244:16, 244:23,
244:24, 270:13,
294:10, 296:3,
296:11, 296:14,
316:5, 316:6,
348:25, 355:17,
357:20, 370:11,
377:17, 388:24,
409:4, 409:12,
410:4, 426:13,
426:14, 426:18,
426:19
reader [1] - 264:22
readers [2] - 325:8,
430:11
Reading [3] - 172:8,
356:18, 357:22
reading [26] - 27:23,
114:6, 186:21,
189:23, 204:12,
204:25, 205:6,
206:13, 207:6,
208:20, 210:7,
211:3, 218:19,
224:25, 244:20,
245:4, 246:6,
248:22, 295:2,
364:13, 374:24,
388:25, 390:1,
408:6, 409:13
readings [7] - 184:24,
185:1, 185:2, 185:8,
185:10, 185:24,
237:14
reads [14] - 162:3,
162:4, 184:21,
200:16, 216:21,
294:9, 294:11,
294:20, 294:22,
302:19, 316:2,
327:5, 334:6, 377:14
ready [6] - 7:10,
128:16, 128:18,
130:14, 313:2,
373:11
real [6] - 152:10,
211:6, 337:25,
340:8, 433:19,
433:23
real-world [1] - 433:23
realistic [5] - 206:3,
391:1, 408:12,
409:10, 409:22
realities [1] - 363:12
realize [1] - 164:21
realized [1] - 443:7
really [57] - 9:20,
12:16, 20:22, 37:19,
Page 41
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 159 of 172
281:5
reconcile [1] - 358:4
reconsider [4] 335:23, 336:4,
336:7, 339:8
reconsidered [1] 336:9
reconstructing [1] 450:2
record [44] - 6:7, 6:10,
7:6, 21:9, 35:13,
42:8, 47:12, 97:24,
98:21, 149:4,
150:15, 189:17,
189:18, 192:2,
215:9, 216:17,
226:8, 228:2,
231:16, 232:17,
233:3, 233:8,
234:24, 235:5,
235:11, 235:14,
237:9, 261:10,
271:8, 311:7,
318:25, 338:19,
340:6, 340:10,
340:11, 343:22,
343:25, 345:10,
357:21, 411:25,
413:21, 415:17,
439:22, 456:17
record-keeping [2] 340:10, 340:11
recorded [12] - 18:20,
191:23, 235:2,
235:9, 235:17,
288:18, 288:23,
375:14, 409:6,
413:20, 415:23,
429:15
recording [1] - 231:23
records [14] - 39:19,
43:22, 44:10, 76:1,
89:12, 104:8,
104:15, 110:25,
139:16, 140:13,
313:7, 319:1,
331:15, 340:5
recreate [1] - 352:21
RECROSS [3] 143:12, 259:15,
408:4
Recross [2] - 5:14,
5:21
RECROSSEXAMINATION [3] 143:12, 259:15,
408:4
recruited [1] - 347:8
recuse [1] - 8:4
red [4] - 299:11,
Page 41 to 41 of 54
333:11, 397:6
referenced [8] 111:14, 132:22,
134:10, 134:13,
134:24, 135:6,
145:12, 203:4
references [1] 130:23
referred [13] - 69:3,
100:18, 100:23,
126:23, 157:18,
166:13, 173:16,
211:18, 211:23,
324:2, 352:7,
371:20, 426:10
referring [20] - 78:23,
95:2, 101:7, 105:18,
112:1, 112:24,
113:5, 133:22,
135:1, 136:3,
197:19, 198:19,
202:20, 205:21,
247:10, 359:15,
404:24, 430:3,
440:15
refers [11] - 102:8,
102:12, 102:18,
105:10, 132:9,
135:8, 259:5, 259:7,
259:11, 260:4,
409:16
reflect [3] - 105:24,
140:14, 427:7
reflected [3] - 140:16,
198:9, 215:2
refresh [4] - 67:7,
201:1, 225:5, 253:16
refs [4] - 92:21,
121:14, 216:8, 308:9
refusal [3] - 11:8,
38:18, 304:13
refuse [2] - 89:21,
341:3
refused [1] - 44:25
refusing [1] - 45:4
regard [2] - 417:9,
426:6
regarding [19] - 8:7,
11:22, 26:21, 29:1,
31:13, 48:12, 64:6,
66:11, 99:8, 114:1,
114:5, 123:14,
234:7, 247:4,
248:21, 249:20,
250:14, 337:8,
371:25
regardless [5] - 66:14,
200:22, 332:25,
333:1, 333:2
register [1] - 378:22
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 42
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 160 of 172
248:3, 250:19,
260:12, 262:16,
262:23, 262:25,
263:4, 263:23,
264:23, 265:4,
265:5, 265:15,
265:17, 266:3,
267:4, 267:19,
268:1, 268:8,
269:10, 269:16,
269:23, 270:13,
272:2, 272:12,
272:25, 273:9,
273:22, 274:1,
274:4, 274:12,
274:21, 275:21,
276:18, 277:10,
278:22, 279:10,
285:16, 290:7,
291:10, 291:25,
293:18, 294:15,
300:3, 300:17,
300:20, 301:6,
301:8, 302:6, 302:7,
302:14, 302:16,
302:19, 303:8,
303:9, 308:12,
308:13, 308:20,
309:17, 315:5,
316:14, 318:9,
319:4, 319:8, 319:9,
319:10, 319:19,
319:20, 320:2,
320:23, 324:10,
324:11, 325:21,
325:25, 326:11,
326:22, 330:2,
330:4, 330:5, 330:9,
330:18, 330:19,
331:2, 340:22,
341:1, 350:13,
350:16, 353:8,
354:12, 359:13,
360:12, 368:11,
368:12, 368:14,
368:23, 369:25,
370:12, 370:18,
370:19, 370:25,
371:15, 371:20,
371:23, 373:3,
374:2, 374:6,
391:22, 392:12,
392:22, 397:7,
402:23, 409:1,
411:7, 411:12,
421:25, 422:21,
422:23, 423:5,
423:12, 426:3,
426:5, 427:9,
427:10, 428:1,
429:7, 442:7,
Page 43
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 161 of 172
444:11, 444:15,
444:16, 444:23,
445:3, 448:3,
448:23, 450:1,
451:13, 451:17,
451:18, 454:24,
454:25, 455:1,
455:16
REPORTED [1] - 1:22
reported [10] - 92:6,
198:3, 224:12,
411:3, 411:5,
417:15, 418:23,
419:13, 420:12,
427:9
Reporter [2] - 457:13,
457:13
reporter [2] - 6:6, 7:7
reporting [2] - 166:8,
166:12
reports [17] - 243:24,
244:7, 244:14,
320:14, 320:15,
321:1, 321:13,
321:16, 330:22,
330:24, 330:25,
331:5, 331:6, 411:4,
422:16, 448:3, 448:7
represent [9] - 62:15,
92:5, 107:10, 154:3,
236:5, 247:21,
284:8, 323:6, 333:6
representation [2] 287:22, 323:9
representative [2] 245:18, 393:18
representatives [2] 313:6, 336:24
represented [5] 110:20, 267:4,
271:11, 314:2, 314:4
representing [2] 270:7, 270:16
represents [2] - 256:4,
256:5
reproduce [2] - 371:9,
423:6
reputation [1] 312:18
request [29] - 84:23,
85:2, 85:8, 85:13,
87:24, 109:4, 109:8,
109:14, 109:17,
110:8, 261:22,
305:11, 311:8,
313:18, 331:22,
333:11, 333:21,
333:24, 335:11,
335:12, 335:20,
335:23, 335:25,
161 of 172 sheets
336:4, 336:11,
336:17, 337:13,
342:1, 410:5
requested [4] 149:21, 304:14,
336:2, 339:11
requesting [1] 333:21
requests [7] - 101:2,
113:1, 113:7, 313:6,
331:14, 332:2,
337:12
require [3] - 113:14,
218:2, 311:13
required [3] - 149:6,
233:21, 367:22
requirement [1] 239:21
requirements [3] 65:6, 239:20, 240:12
requires [1] - 438:6
research [2] - 440:18,
441:1
researcher [3] - 17:2,
158:2, 186:22
resend [1] - 341:17
reserve [1] - 20:11
reset [1] - 91:7
resist [2] - 219:12,
455:24
resolve [1] - 302:17
resolving [1] - 456:12
resources [3] - 282:3,
282:14, 283:9
respect [68] - 8:25,
18:17, 20:7, 44:14,
45:6, 100:11,
113:10, 179:12,
223:25, 233:1,
242:23, 250:17,
261:19, 261:21,
262:15, 267:2,
267:9, 267:18,
269:18, 273:4,
273:7, 273:19,
311:8, 314:6,
318:22, 322:13,
322:16, 326:4,
330:21, 334:10,
337:3, 341:10,
348:9, 353:6,
355:24, 356:1,
356:16, 356:25,
359:13, 361:5,
361:7, 363:14,
363:16, 366:11,
367:14, 367:19,
368:1, 368:14,
371:16, 372:8,
373:4, 380:8, 404:7,
405:12, 405:15,
406:15, 406:25,
407:12, 408:7,
412:24, 416:12,
422:12, 441:9,
443:20, 447:24,
448:7, 449:6
respected [3] - 16:2,
280:10, 330:7
respectful [1] - 305:5
respectfully [6] 305:4, 305:5,
305:10, 333:24,
335:13, 336:9
respects [1] - 414:25
respond [5] - 42:15,
86:10, 334:21,
335:19, 438:10
responded [1] - 85:3
response [16] - 6:12,
42:25, 335:10,
341:19, 359:20,
359:23, 361:17,
363:24, 368:20,
370:7, 370:22,
414:20, 426:3,
445:20, 446:8, 447:5
responses [3] 371:21, 404:10,
422:14
responsibilities [7] 123:5, 123:14,
137:20, 154:1,
154:2, 154:12, 228:9
responsibility [6] 31:22, 145:3, 145:8,
154:10, 228:11,
413:3
responsible [15] 10:10, 11:21, 21:23,
40:14, 46:9, 46:16,
49:21, 69:5, 134:20,
154:4, 154:7, 202:5,
228:23, 229:6,
345:18
responsive [4] 112:25, 113:6,
304:14, 336:3
rest [2] - 24:18, 454:12
restriction [1] - 211:2
Result [1] - 139:14
result [18] - 17:14,
17:20, 17:24, 18:19,
168:22, 176:5,
193:20, 201:10,
202:13, 202:17,
203:3, 210:9,
287:11, 317:4,
403:10, 411:3,
445:9, 446:12
Page 43 to 43 of 54
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 44
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 162 of 172
312:21, 332:18,
333:2, 333:22,
337:22
searches [2] - 336:2,
337:18
season [11] - 24:18,
76:11, 77:4, 113:21,
124:3, 129:8, 133:2,
133:9, 135:8,
245:23, 401:8
season's [1] - 334:8
seasons [1] - 47:20
seated [1] - 270:4
Seattle [1] - 128:17
sec [2] - 129:18, 134:1
second [53] - 13:10,
14:13, 16:4, 16:11,
22:7, 29:4, 33:19,
73:11, 73:15, 73:18,
74:4, 102:18, 126:2,
130:5, 130:14,
131:20, 139:11,
149:16, 164:1,
168:5, 169:18,
176:8, 176:15,
179:24, 200:15,
205:21, 224:24,
226:12, 229:16,
230:3, 230:5, 230:6,
230:8, 236:1,
236:22, 238:20,
263:10, 273:10,
300:20, 300:23,
319:16, 332:22,
337:9, 349:25,
352:18, 374:11,
381:9, 382:16,
397:6, 400:6,
432:10, 438:14,
449:6
second-team [1] 332:22
second-to-last [1] 200:15
secondarily [1] 319:21
secondly [2] - 159:3,
223:8
seconds [23] - 125:5,
126:5, 126:12,
129:22, 129:24,
130:22, 131:1,
131:2, 131:12,
131:25, 132:20,
134:5, 134:6,
236:20, 236:22,
390:14, 410:8,
410:16, 410:19,
411:1, 411:11,
418:10
Page 45
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 163 of 172
344:13, 344:23,
351:6, 351:14,
352:15, 353:13,
353:16, 355:7,
360:3, 360:24,
361:1, 367:2,
373:20, 381:2,
383:3, 396:5,
397:25, 408:14,
410:23, 414:7,
415:17, 420:9,
421:11, 442:11,
449:17, 449:18,
449:19, 452:23,
453:4, 453:6, 454:9,
456:23
seeing [9] - 88:14,
253:14, 253:15,
265:18, 328:12,
328:13, 356:2,
415:9, 422:6
seeking [1] - 110:2
select [4] - 50:4, 50:5,
72:23, 77:13
selected [2] - 67:15,
155:18
selecting [2] - 50:23,
68:9
selection [2] - 67:16,
67:23
selects [1] - 48:20
send [1] - 103:7
sending [1] - 78:18
Senior [3] - 2:7, 2:17,
151:5
senior [2] - 228:22,
229:6
sense [19] - 57:1,
73:12, 191:25,
192:15, 192:20,
275:13, 288:7,
360:4, 364:22,
366:5, 369:8, 370:9,
370:24, 417:5,
425:8, 425:16,
441:18, 442:11,
457:1
sensitive [2] - 291:12,
334:13
sent [30] - 64:16,
91:12, 92:2, 92:3,
99:6, 99:13, 100:17,
104:3, 104:17,
107:18, 109:1,
109:8, 125:25,
129:14, 132:9,
134:25, 138:6,
141:8, 144:20,
144:21, 237:19,
242:7, 252:20,
280:13, 329:12,
332:13, 333:20,
334:23, 337:5, 338:7
sentence [19] 205:21, 224:20,
224:25, 239:19,
264:11, 264:12,
264:15, 264:16,
265:3, 331:25,
356:15, 388:25,
408:22, 408:23,
409:1, 409:12,
409:16, 410:4
sentences [1] - 183:4
separate [3] - 196:21,
211:18, 300:21
separately [4] - 197:8,
282:3, 419:6, 419:7
September [1] 333:23
sequence [12] - 160:6,
160:7, 168:2, 168:3,
168:6, 176:11,
176:13, 177:21,
180:7, 187:21,
417:4, 421:24
sequences [2] 177:11, 180:8
sequencing [2] 190:25, 206:4
sequential [2] 327:23, 439:6
sequentially [1] 438:21
series [4] - 197:9,
350:6, 357:2, 388:4
serious [6] - 28:21,
40:12, 42:11, 45:11,
249:3
served [3] - 153:6,
167:24, 348:13
service [1] - 107:23
services [1] - 307:8
set [57] - 12:25, 58:18,
79:14, 92:7, 114:17,
114:19, 114:22,
115:19, 116:2,
116:14, 116:20,
117:6, 117:11,
117:19, 118:17,
118:23, 119:1,
119:10, 121:14,
178:3, 189:24,
192:17, 205:13,
217:13, 223:19,
228:24, 231:13,
239:20, 265:2,
293:4, 293:9, 303:7,
303:16, 332:18,
337:12, 341:1,
Page 45 to 45 of 54
352:18, 353:11,
355:10, 361:25,
369:15, 371:22,
374:19, 374:21,
378:8, 399:16,
400:10, 414:3,
436:14, 436:15,
437:9, 444:15,
444:23, 450:8,
453:1, 453:16
set-up [1] - 353:11
sets [9] - 189:10,
193:1, 332:14,
435:24, 435:25,
436:6, 436:7,
436:24, 446:21
setting [4] - 194:4,
283:12, 293:10,
398:14
seven [9] - 134:6,
177:2, 177:21,
179:6, 196:4,
196:12, 196:14,
229:15, 257:5
seven-and-a-halfminute [1] - 177:2
several [3] - 172:14,
239:2, 414:25
sexting [1] - 44:24
sexual [1] - 322:18
shape [1] - 331:8
share [1] - 443:14
shared [3] - 320:25,
321:7, 321:10
sheet [3] - 59:20,
59:24, 119:4
shift [4] - 179:19,
417:21, 454:8, 454:9
shifting [1] - 438:18
shock [1] - 280:17
shocked [1] - 285:1
shoes [3] - 83:11,
84:13, 295:14
short [4] - 148:11,
162:9, 228:23,
427:16
show [32] - 15:4,
36:16, 41:14, 43:20,
43:22, 43:23, 44:10,
61:8, 61:18, 63:18,
74:13, 74:24, 97:13,
111:1, 111:10,
111:24, 122:12,
122:20, 140:13,
140:19, 198:10,
199:13, 201:16,
226:18, 237:16,
277:9, 299:5, 308:1,
308:15, 331:6,
424:21
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 46
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 164 of 172
370:21, 403:4,
403:10, 412:25,
413:6, 413:8,
417:16, 420:20,
421:5, 432:11,
432:24, 434:14,
435:4, 435:15,
435:18, 435:19,
438:8, 442:15,
443:1, 443:18,
443:21
significant [78] - 17:4,
17:24, 52:22, 54:10,
122:24, 159:7,
162:18, 162:21,
164:3, 164:15,
165:13, 166:19,
166:22, 167:4,
167:6, 168:8,
175:19, 178:7,
179:20, 181:17,
182:1, 182:9,
186:11, 199:12,
199:14, 199:17,
199:22, 200:22,
201:10, 201:25,
202:11, 202:13,
202:17, 203:3,
203:23, 205:18,
210:4, 222:17,
223:7, 224:8,
225:13, 327:16,
327:25, 345:24,
354:25, 360:5,
360:16, 362:3,
367:24, 368:16,
374:2, 374:3, 374:5,
395:6, 402:10,
411:8, 414:9, 420:7,
420:17, 425:5,
425:6, 429:14,
431:2, 431:10,
431:25, 432:16,
434:23, 435:1,
436:13, 436:15,
439:2, 446:13,
451:2, 451:25,
452:12, 452:16,
453:13, 453:18
significantly [3] 172:12, 395:19,
401:17
silly [4] - 453:10,
453:11, 453:14,
453:22
SIM [2] - 105:19,
106:12
similar [4] - 41:15,
41:16, 42:19, 283:25
similarly [2] - 420:11,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
422:17
simple [3] - 16:19,
423:17, 427:17
simpler [2] - 419:5,
442:16
simply [10] - 16:9,
19:2, 38:6, 46:18,
158:16, 203:19,
225:8, 380:24,
427:7, 448:16
simulate [3] - 352:20,
358:16, 406:18
simulated [2] 352:25, 359:4
simulation [3] 384:11, 444:6,
446:20
simulations [11] 197:16, 199:4,
328:23, 358:12,
358:13, 358:21,
358:23, 366:19,
406:17, 443:4, 444:2
simultaneously [3] 131:5, 134:16
single [1] - 372:16
sit [5] - 309:24,
310:25, 317:19,
335:9, 339:17
sitting [6] - 96:8, 97:2,
229:20, 296:2,
395:22, 399:19
situation [10] - 45:9,
49:2, 49:14, 149:12,
194:12, 229:22,
260:10, 276:9,
435:8, 437:18
situations [2] - 36:8,
435:16
six [10] - 48:4, 55:13,
125:10, 125:14,
125:21, 131:24,
229:15, 365:9,
401:13, 419:21
six-minute-and-21second [1] - 132:3
sizes [2] - 435:17,
439:3
skeptic [1] - 441:13
slices [1] - 153:21
slickers [2] - 407:8,
407:9
Slide [2] - 172:2,
172:16
slide [25] - 158:18,
159:19, 160:12,
161:10, 162:12,
162:25, 163:14,
164:14, 166:3,
169:3, 174:2,
174:10, 174:11,
174:13, 175:13,
176:24, 177:3,
181:13, 183:24,
184:15, 185:17,
187:5, 187:14,
199:19
slides [8] - 199:15,
199:16, 207:25,
208:2, 208:7,
208:10, 417:10,
417:16
slight [1] - 404:20
slowly [2] - 164:6,
292:21
small [13] - 176:1,
229:21, 285:25,
435:16, 435:20,
435:24, 436:6,
436:14, 436:15,
437:4, 439:3, 447:13
smaller [4] - 166:23,
166:24, 436:21,
451:23
smallest [2] - 436:24,
437:2
smart [1] - 90:20
Snyder [47] - 15:22,
17:16, 148:25,
150:5, 150:7,
150:16, 151:8,
160:14, 171:10,
188:25, 190:19,
194:1, 194:22,
194:23, 207:9,
222:19, 270:8,
290:19, 326:20,
328:25, 330:20,
352:14, 359:9,
359:11, 361:12,
363:15, 363:20,
364:7, 365:7,
365:21, 366:5,
366:11, 374:12,
375:19, 380:9,
380:19, 414:17,
416:16, 416:21,
417:6, 417:15,
421:4, 426:10,
438:7, 438:16,
445:11, 447:23
SNYDER [2] - 4:9,
5:16
Snyder's [5] - 361:5,
367:14, 414:11,
418:15, 432:6
so-called [8] - 17:10,
177:17, 184:25,
203:2, 213:19,
213:21, 316:1,
Page 46 to 46 of 54
355:17
soaked [1] - 407:24
social [2] - 43:15,
165:3
Society [2] - 210:25,
412:23
soft [5] - 56:18, 57:1,
57:2, 59:4
soften [1] - 12:8
softer [2] - 56:22,
56:23
softness [1] - 56:20
SOKOLY [1] - 3:12
solely [2] - 198:1,
244:20
solid [1] - 442:12
solve [1] - 345:23
solving [2] - 346:6,
346:8
someone [17] - 28:6,
28:8, 74:9, 77:19,
83:17, 83:23, 84:7,
84:12, 92:4, 113:2,
191:10, 249:10,
257:24, 307:4,
319:9, 350:21,
396:12
sometime [1] - 58:7
sometimes [16] - 18:1,
53:10, 54:3, 71:20,
83:18, 88:16, 120:5,
196:6, 231:24,
315:14, 377:23,
377:24, 407:8,
441:25, 442:1, 453:7
somewhat [3] - 93:1,
281:24, 435:6
somewhere [7] - 81:6,
91:1, 232:22,
279:11, 279:12,
286:8, 323:5
soon [1] - 390:24
sooner [3] - 408:11,
408:18, 409:9
sorry [38] - 42:21,
45:4, 63:24, 71:10,
94:10, 94:12,
112:19, 121:7,
170:9, 193:13,
202:3, 204:3,
207:17, 224:22,
229:1, 242:22,
244:12, 244:17,
252:2, 265:2,
277:11, 277:18,
298:8, 298:11,
318:5, 373:12,
376:4, 376:13,
388:19, 392:3,
397:12, 397:13,
399:10, 402:13,
454:6, 455:22
sort [15] - 50:2, 82:13,
82:22, 153:13,
154:5, 158:19,
160:18, 165:22,
168:12, 169:23,
216:18, 220:21,
353:2, 356:12,
382:24
sorts [4] - 329:7,
350:9, 355:8, 360:6
sound [2] - 182:4,
406:12
sounds [2] - 33:7,
67:10
source [3] - 84:11,
285:18, 285:21
sources [2] - 218:22,
297:4
speaking [3] - 6:9,
7:5, 442:24
speaks [4] - 120:2,
129:12, 149:7, 210:8
special [1] - 80:3
specialty [2] - 151:10,
286:10
specific [14] - 23:17,
35:19, 51:11, 86:12,
153:13, 191:6,
273:5, 274:14,
295:20, 295:21,
337:12, 362:7,
397:5, 397:6
Specifically [1] 172:10
specifically [14] 26:10, 46:8, 51:10,
104:11, 147:8,
172:8, 327:10,
360:12, 370:10,
370:14, 379:18,
379:21, 380:5,
380:17
specifics [4] - 53:2,
191:7, 304:6, 304:7
specified [2] - 289:2,
289:3
specifying [1] 240:15
speculate [5] 135:16, 135:21,
137:9, 138:2, 138:23
speculation [1] 181:2
speculative [1] - 32:23
speech [1] - 294:14
speed [1] - 54:10
spell [1] - 345:11
spend [7] - 20:8, 21:8,
Page 47
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 165 of 172
264:14, 271:8,
275:24, 278:13,
304:22, 306:22,
315:17, 334:1,
337:15, 391:23,
432:18, 436:3
STATEMENTS [1] 5:3
statements [8] - 7:24,
11:6, 35:15, 119:22,
121:3, 337:2, 341:6,
341:8
states [6] - 105:17,
134:2, 213:9,
213:10, 258:16,
380:23
States [3] - 324:23,
325:4, 347:17
stating [3] - 201:18,
225:6, 275:6
stationed [1] - 307:18
Statistical [1] - 412:4
statistical [136] 15:25, 151:13,
151:15, 151:16,
152:1, 152:7, 153:3,
153:15, 156:9,
156:22, 157:16,
157:21, 158:9,
163:20, 164:16,
164:19, 165:1,
165:7, 165:16,
165:18, 166:4,
166:9, 166:14,
166:15, 166:17,
167:2, 173:19,
175:14, 175:22,
175:25, 176:4,
176:6, 177:14,
180:24, 181:14,
181:16, 182:3,
182:5, 187:22,
194:3, 195:1, 195:5,
195:8, 197:6,
197:22, 198:2,
198:4, 198:13,
198:20, 199:3,
200:9, 201:3,
201:17, 203:5,
203:18, 207:16,
207:22, 208:5,
208:13, 211:12,
212:16, 213:3,
213:4, 213:13,
222:3, 223:13,
223:19, 223:25,
285:5, 285:9,
286:21, 286:25,
287:12, 328:7,
329:3, 349:8,
Page 47 to 47 of 54
349:16, 349:17,
349:20, 354:8,
354:14, 354:18,
359:17, 360:2,
360:11, 360:15,
361:2, 361:22,
362:7, 363:3,
363:10, 366:25,
367:17, 367:20,
368:1, 368:5,
368:10, 370:20,
371:7, 395:14,
412:18, 412:21,
412:25, 413:6,
413:8, 413:12,
414:17, 415:1,
420:20, 421:5,
423:7, 424:2,
428:15, 428:19,
429:23, 432:11,
432:12, 432:24,
433:3, 433:16,
434:14, 435:3,
436:25, 438:5,
438:8, 439:2, 441:7,
442:14, 443:1,
443:21, 445:17,
449:8, 450:4, 450:7,
450:11, 450:12
statistically [53] 17:3, 17:23, 159:7,
164:15, 165:13,
166:19, 166:22,
167:4, 175:19,
179:20, 181:16,
182:1, 182:9, 194:6,
200:22, 201:24,
202:10, 202:12,
202:17, 203:3,
203:23, 205:18,
210:3, 222:17,
223:7, 224:8,
225:13, 327:15,
327:25, 354:25,
360:5, 361:16,
362:3, 367:24,
368:16, 371:12,
395:6, 414:9, 420:6,
420:16, 425:5,
425:6, 430:22,
431:3, 434:23,
435:1, 446:7,
446:13, 451:2,
451:25, 452:12,
452:16, 453:18
statisticallyaccepted [1] 371:12
statistician [7] 187:23, 286:13,
286:16, 330:16,
347:9, 437:15,
452:20
statisticians [6] 283:11, 284:19,
330:8, 381:22,
424:16, 435:7
statistics [22] - 16:3,
73:17, 74:1, 152:13,
157:1, 157:3,
194:24, 201:21,
211:1, 236:6, 236:8,
286:17, 287:19,
287:23, 347:7,
347:10, 348:2,
412:10, 423:2,
441:5, 441:7
Statistics [2] - 412:15,
412:23
stay [5] - 88:25,
128:19, 237:2,
335:18, 365:25
stayed [1] - 133:19
staying [1] - 366:15
steel [1] - 153:17
Steffey [8] - 347:8,
411:17, 412:1,
412:7, 414:10,
427:21, 438:1
STEFFEY [2] - 4:15,
5:23
stenographic [1] 457:10
step [3] - 160:18,
165:16, 276:11
STEPHEN [1] - 4:5
stepped [3] - 88:13,
88:15, 230:10
steps [5] - 54:21,
158:6, 190:11,
230:15, 232:21
Steroid [1] - 9:14
steroids [2] - 9:12,
9:15
Steve [2] - 101:13,
331:25
sticker [1] - 299:11
sticking [1] - 328:14
Stickum [1] - 26:4
still [17] - 20:16,
45:14, 76:11, 96:1,
97:3, 116:16,
129:16, 264:6,
302:10, 343:18,
390:18, 401:8,
401:11, 401:14,
402:4, 410:20,
436:15
Still [1] - 78:20
stimulate [1] - 353:4
stimulations [1] -
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 48
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 166 of 172
329:5
stock [1] - 153:20
stood [1] - 307:9
stop [6] - 151:15,
176:7, 181:18,
271:1, 333:4, 350:12
stopped [1] - 400:1
story [2] - 291:2,
420:10
straight [1] - 134:3
strategy [1] - 154:6
STRAUSS [1] - 2:19
STRAWN [1] - 3:8
street [1] - 128:9
Street [2] - 3:3, 4:4
stress [6] - 92:17,
93:14, 275:20,
275:25, 276:25,
317:1
strike [6] - 211:5,
211:6, 219:12,
295:7, 296:17, 297:3
striking [2] - 181:19,
192:8
strong [3] - 172:7,
435:21
struck [1] - 446:20
structure [3] - 221:18,
428:21, 429:2
structured [6] 201:23, 428:24,
429:5, 429:6,
429:10, 430:6
student [1] - 211:1
students [3] - 152:23,
154:15, 282:22
studied [11] - 151:21,
152:9, 167:8, 201:4,
208:11, 208:22,
210:17, 218:14,
337:17, 426:12,
426:15
studies [8] - 152:5,
165:14, 329:4,
329:6, 431:24,
433:17, 440:23,
440:24
study [13] - 16:5,
151:13, 152:13,
200:11, 201:2,
210:16, 373:3,
380:15, 413:15,
434:15, 434:21,
441:6, 451:11
studying [3] - 163:22,
442:10, 442:25
stuff [6] - 124:19,
128:18, 306:23,
313:19, 338:25,
353:3
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
164:9
suspend [1] - 20:22
suspended [4] 24:17, 25:11, 45:3,
249:9
suspenders [1] 283:8
suspending [1] 45:11
suspends [1] - 250:2
suspension [4] - 36:3,
36:14, 45:7, 45:17
sustained [2] - 271:6,
271:24
swapped [1] - 407:12
swaps [1] - 91:4
swear [1] - 261:2
sweatshirts [1] 407:9
switch [2] - 190:23,
190:24
switched [4] - 161:2,
161:22, 369:3, 369:9
switching [1] - 413:24
sworn [8] - 47:6,
150:9, 227:21,
261:4, 345:4, 380:1,
411:19, 439:16
symbols [1] - 430:13
synch [1] - 446:16
Syracuse [1] - 322:15
system [1] - 28:10
T
t-test [2] - 419:8,
419:16
Tab [1] - 198:25
Table [10] - 159:22,
160:13, 161:11,
166:7, 173:11,
198:3, 198:15,
201:15, 208:21,
225:3
table [8] - 159:21,
162:24, 163:1,
166:7, 166:12,
169:22, 212:8,
369:14
tack [1] - 53:7
tackiness [1] - 55:19
tackled [1] - 426:4
Tagliabue [2] - 45:5,
46:7
tailored [1] - 335:25
takeaway [2] - 179:15,
194:2
talent [1] - 284:23
talks [5] - 22:20,
140:9, 238:20,
314:25, 397:4
tamper [1] - 147:22
tampered [5] - 16:13,
18:19, 254:13,
319:16, 320:5
tampering [18] 16:24, 193:1,
207:24, 208:15,
209:2, 209:7, 209:8,
209:12, 209:22,
210:10, 249:20,
314:15, 316:17,
327:9, 329:17,
329:20, 349:4
tape [3] - 303:19,
303:22
task [1] - 30:19
tasked [3] - 33:18,
145:3, 145:8
taught [2] - 152:12,
152:16
teacher [1] - 188:24
teaching [2] - 151:7,
152:20
Team [1] - 307:7
team [63] - 10:7,
10:10, 11:9, 16:4,
17:16, 21:2, 22:17,
23:20, 47:18, 56:14,
75:14, 86:3, 100:16,
100:22, 101:12,
101:15, 101:17,
107:8, 107:12,
108:25, 109:5,
110:1, 110:2,
138:11, 155:11,
155:16, 158:13,
173:22, 174:5,
195:4, 195:7,
236:12, 245:24,
255:18, 256:16,
262:13, 264:17,
267:5, 268:24,
284:25, 286:8,
286:18, 291:21,
307:6, 324:10,
324:13, 331:14,
332:22, 334:25,
341:4, 346:25,
347:4, 348:8, 378:8,
406:6, 413:4,
416:21, 417:6,
423:25, 424:3,
424:4, 438:16
teams [22] - 152:23,
206:1, 237:2,
255:14, 256:5,
256:8, 256:10,
256:11, 256:14,
256:18, 256:21,
Page 49
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 167 of 172
258:7, 259:21,
260:3, 260:4,
296:19, 327:15,
327:20, 355:14,
376:22, 376:24,
408:13
tech [1] - 197:20
technical [8] - 183:8,
345:23, 348:21,
417:12, 418:21,
430:11, 430:15,
446:11
techniques [1] - 449:1
Ted [7] - 11:7, 14:25,
15:22, 20:4, 100:12,
118:2, 261:1
telephone [14] - 112:6,
124:7, 125:4,
125:16, 129:24,
130:10, 130:24,
131:4, 131:10,
134:13, 143:14,
143:21, 145:14,
149:23
Telephone [1] - 130:3
telephoned [1] - 262:5
telephones [3] 43:12, 102:2, 149:22
television [2] 406:18, 406:19
temperature [38] 17:12, 18:21, 34:2,
120:11, 169:15,
184:5, 184:7, 192:2,
220:18, 221:5,
231:16, 231:19,
234:24, 235:2,
237:13, 288:9,
288:24, 290:8,
353:25, 364:25,
365:2, 366:6, 372:2,
393:5, 393:7, 393:8,
393:12, 393:15,
394:2, 394:4, 394:5,
394:6, 394:7,
394:11, 394:12,
394:18
temperatures [4] 189:18, 352:12,
353:1
temptation [1] 455:25
ten [12] - 77:16, 99:25,
150:23, 236:20,
386:9, 399:2, 399:4,
420:16, 420:17,
432:12, 432:15,
433:11
tendency [1] - 184:20
term [11] - 183:7,
167 of 172 sheets
183:8, 207:17,
425:7, 425:20,
429:13, 429:20,
429:22, 452:19,
452:21, 452:22
terms [56] - 13:25,
25:2, 26:22, 27:12,
38:13, 39:18, 73:11,
87:22, 92:1, 151:17,
152:8, 156:10,
157:6, 157:11,
157:13, 158:8,
164:18, 172:5,
172:25, 177:14,
185:4, 186:23,
251:15, 260:3,
270:21, 272:22,
276:12, 283:2,
284:14, 296:7,
296:18, 301:10,
304:14, 308:21,
310:24, 315:2,
315:16, 322:19,
323:8, 324:24,
325:6, 332:18,
333:2, 337:22,
337:23, 338:16,
339:19, 339:21,
339:24, 340:9,
341:3, 346:10,
378:22, 428:1,
428:21
tertiary [1] - 329:4
test [40] - 17:17,
178:4, 178:10,
185:4, 198:9, 207:4,
215:10, 229:7,
231:25, 232:5,
232:15, 233:8,
233:24, 282:7,
301:24, 319:14,
328:18, 342:5,
351:2, 351:11,
351:19, 377:12,
377:13, 378:25,
380:14, 383:24,
385:19, 385:20,
385:23, 386:2,
386:19, 387:10,
387:12, 387:21,
387:22, 387:23,
419:8, 419:16,
419:22, 449:11
tested [53] - 16:22,
17:8, 17:9, 17:13,
18:15, 18:24, 93:11,
93:19, 97:10,
203:10, 220:16,
220:17, 233:4,
233:21, 235:6,
235:12, 235:22,
Page 49 to 49 of 54
231:9, 231:17,
232:19, 233:7,
233:10, 234:3,
234:6, 234:10,
234:11, 234:21,
234:25, 235:3,
237:6, 239:1, 239:7,
249:5, 282:4,
282:14, 282:19,
283:9, 283:18,
285:5, 285:9,
291:15, 298:16,
309:19, 310:1,
310:6, 310:9,
339:20, 339:21,
339:25, 340:3,
349:14, 351:4,
352:1, 352:6, 352:7,
354:2, 354:7,
355:16, 362:15,
375:14, 377:20,
378:19, 392:25,
396:17, 399:18,
406:7, 407:16
Tests [1] - 258:19
tests [16] - 18:16,
197:9, 197:12,
197:15, 198:7,
258:17, 282:20,
283:3, 290:9, 302:2,
302:23, 303:1,
352:5, 376:11,
427:12
text [104] - 37:20,
39:11, 39:19, 40:8,
42:1, 43:20, 43:22,
43:24, 44:7, 76:4,
78:7, 78:14, 78:18,
92:7, 95:20, 100:11,
100:17, 100:23,
101:3, 101:7,
101:11, 101:16,
103:7, 104:3,
104:15, 104:17,
107:17, 109:1,
109:5, 109:14,
110:2, 110:7, 110:8,
110:18, 110:22,
111:2, 111:11,
111:24, 112:1,
112:9, 112:13,
125:12, 125:25,
126:19, 126:23,
127:3, 127:5,
128:21, 129:15,
129:17, 131:18,
132:8, 132:9,
132:15, 133:22,
134:24, 135:4,
135:6, 135:12,
135:15, 135:18,
136:3, 136:17,
137:22, 138:3,
138:5, 138:9,
138:12, 138:15,
139:12, 139:15,
139:20, 140:11,
140:15, 140:19,
141:2, 141:5, 141:7,
144:17, 144:21,
145:12, 275:16,
277:8, 277:10,
277:18, 310:13,
310:16, 310:21,
311:4, 311:14,
313:7, 316:23,
317:2, 317:6,
332:17, 333:22,
335:24, 337:19,
337:23, 338:1,
338:3, 338:5
texted [1] - 139:22
texts [34] - 14:10,
14:15, 14:22, 14:24,
34:23, 38:25, 39:10,
39:14, 43:8, 43:25,
44:4, 44:5, 44:6,
44:9, 44:10, 44:11,
61:21, 78:4, 79:14,
84:23, 85:14, 85:15,
85:20, 86:9, 89:25,
91:11, 92:2, 95:2,
315:1, 331:15,
335:16, 337:1,
339:12, 341:11
THE [106] - 1:3, 1:24,
49:17, 53:1, 54:14,
54:17, 54:22, 56:2,
56:11, 59:15, 59:18,
60:17, 60:20, 60:23,
61:1, 61:14, 61:17,
66:1, 66:3, 67:2,
68:17, 69:15, 69:18,
69:23, 70:6, 70:21,
70:25, 71:3, 71:10,
71:13, 72:10, 74:23,
80:13, 80:17, 88:11,
88:22, 88:25, 89:4,
89:16, 99:23,
105:15, 109:23,
117:5, 117:8,
117:10, 117:15,
117:18, 117:24,
118:3, 122:21,
124:17, 125:23,
127:25, 128:4,
133:12, 133:18,
136:10, 137:13,
137:15, 137:18,
146:3, 146:6, 146:9,
146:13, 146:15,
146:17, 146:21,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 50
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 168 of 172
146:24, 147:4,
147:9, 147:14,
147:18, 148:1,
155:20, 155:25,
156:6, 168:10,
168:17, 168:25,
170:11, 170:16,
170:19, 170:24,
177:9, 178:3, 180:4,
180:12, 180:15,
180:18, 180:22,
189:22, 225:21,
230:5, 252:4,
265:22, 271:25,
298:9, 318:5,
397:12, 398:5,
398:8, 403:25,
409:13, 409:19,
439:12, 449:14
theirs [1] - 423:4
themselves [7] - 7:6,
217:2, 338:21,
355:4, 385:5, 429:4,
449:23
THEODORE [2] - 4:10,
5:18
Theodore [2] - 261:11,
263:12
theoretical [3] - 221:3,
286:11, 288:8
theory [6] - 164:2,
167:14, 250:9,
424:2, 431:21,
441:19
therefore [10] - 23:3,
46:10, 182:2,
182:23, 200:24,
208:6, 266:12,
267:22, 354:25,
356:22
Therefore [2] - 205:22,
222:20
thermo [1] - 393:13
thermodynamics [1] 169:8
thesis [3] - 151:21,
284:6, 284:10
they've [5] - 22:19,
33:25, 158:12,
213:11, 315:5
thick [3] - 98:9,
269:10, 337:25
thinking [8] - 81:4,
128:20, 237:12,
245:17, 366:6,
420:19, 423:16,
441:20
third [12] - 130:2,
134:3, 178:9,
178:11, 205:21,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
242:21, 242:22,
333:7, 350:5,
365:19, 381:11,
430:4
THOMAS [2] - 1:5, 4:9
Thomas [2] - 47:13,
102:6
thorough [2] - 29:19,
31:1
thousands [1] 320:24
thousandth [1] 353:20
Three [1] - 166:11
three [59] - 22:2,
49:18, 54:3, 59:16,
67:14, 70:19, 75:12,
88:15, 111:2,
111:11, 111:24,
117:12, 129:23,
130:2, 132:19,
140:19, 152:5,
158:18, 158:20,
168:12, 168:14,
168:24, 174:3,
175:5, 177:1,
187:18, 191:14,
191:23, 192:4,
199:2, 240:8,
240:13, 292:11,
294:22, 294:25,
297:4, 303:23,
319:23, 320:11,
324:25, 330:14,
330:21, 359:12,
366:8, 376:7,
378:20, 379:2,
380:6, 381:1, 381:3,
381:12, 400:17,
400:25, 401:22,
414:13, 416:9,
417:17, 421:21,
445:13
three-and-a-half [3] 168:14, 168:24,
175:5
three-and-a-halfminute [1] - 177:1
three-page [1] 330:14
three-years' [1] 379:2
threshold [15] 159:17, 165:8,
165:9, 165:20,
168:13, 183:13,
183:15, 183:23,
184:12, 185:19,
187:18, 220:8,
433:3, 433:5, 433:13
Page 50 to 50 of 54
381:9, 381:16,
399:23, 414:19,
415:5, 415:13,
415:14, 416:22,
417:7, 418:8,
418:15, 418:17,
420:9, 422:2, 422:8,
427:22, 428:6,
428:9, 429:8, 429:9,
429:14, 430:8,
430:13, 430:16,
430:21, 431:1,
431:9, 431:14,
431:25, 438:7,
438:13, 438:15,
439:5, 439:8,
445:19, 445:22,
449:8, 449:12,
449:17, 450:7,
450:20
tiny [6] - 404:21,
404:23, 404:25,
408:24, 447:10,
447:14
tipped [1] - 276:20
tips [1] - 276:19
title [3] - 98:13,
345:15, 440:2
today [36] - 8:2, 8:10,
10:22, 15:2, 25:1,
28:23, 30:2, 30:5,
30:9, 31:4, 33:8,
35:6, 38:5, 39:15,
42:6, 96:8, 149:13,
157:19, 196:25,
272:17, 272:21,
272:23, 272:24,
279:15, 279:20,
286:19, 290:17,
321:8, 344:7,
355:19, 364:7,
369:18, 417:13,
455:20, 456:17
together [9] - 8:17,
61:4, 156:5, 263:14,
264:10, 276:18,
276:19, 317:12,
389:19
Tom [28] - 6:12, 6:13,
7:19, 10:23, 10:24,
11:9, 11:11, 13:23,
14:4, 14:6, 14:16,
42:10, 47:3, 52:23,
60:14, 61:6, 63:2,
94:10, 111:20,
128:1, 148:6, 152:4,
273:13, 275:6,
275:17, 275:22,
314:2, 332:1
TOM [4] - 3:4, 3:21,
4:3, 5:15
Tom's [4] - 13:24,
92:12, 119:13, 332:3
ton [3] - 329:15, 342:5
tongue [1] - 164:18
took [46] - 53:22,
69:24, 70:2, 71:25,
114:18, 156:24,
173:25, 211:20,
212:15, 214:10,
214:15, 214:18,
215:1, 215:13,
246:11, 246:14,
248:4, 251:13,
260:1, 276:5,
292:23, 307:13,
314:22, 320:17,
330:17, 349:18,
351:5, 351:12,
351:20, 352:10,
352:11, 372:17,
380:24, 381:25,
382:8, 396:21,
397:15, 397:22,
406:2, 406:6,
411:11, 412:9,
442:5, 442:16,
454:23
tool [1] - 371:12
tools [1] - 371:7
top [15] - 34:23, 99:1,
99:3, 99:5, 127:2,
132:18, 152:18,
162:13, 169:9,
171:20, 172:19,
174:14, 258:23,
299:8, 353:13
topic [2] - 144:3,
447:18
topics [3] - 100:19,
112:25, 113:6
torrential [1] - 55:1
total [3] - 125:5,
125:6, 131:11
totalities [1] - 392:22
totality [5] - 41:24,
316:19, 316:20,
317:9, 393:3
totally [7] - 264:11,
286:24, 296:24,
303:24, 317:5,
341:5, 359:24
touch [3] - 12:1,
88:16, 246:4
touchdown [2] 73:18, 166:1
touched [1] - 337:21
tough [1] - 147:10
toward [4] - 105:17,
111:9, 111:23,
Page 51
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 169 of 172
115:21
towards [2] - 366:21,
367:7
track [3] - 128:22,
190:5, 226:15
tracked [1] - 190:3
traction [1] - 53:12
traditional [1] - 281:24
traffic [2] - 52:8,
251:20
trained [3] - 192:1,
269:9, 269:10
training [3] - 55:12,
75:16, 122:15
transcribed [1] 161:18
transcript [4] - 340:24,
344:6, 344:10,
344:17
transcription [1] 457:9
transient [53] 172:20, 197:12,
198:6, 198:9,
198:10, 199:3,
204:16, 204:17,
204:20, 205:1,
205:22, 205:23,
206:8, 206:16,
206:21, 215:12,
220:24, 224:15,
225:4, 225:10,
328:17, 328:18,
352:6, 352:7,
352:16, 353:6,
353:11, 353:23,
357:1, 357:2, 358:6,
358:19, 358:22,
366:19, 370:12,
372:4, 382:24,
383:15, 403:3,
403:5, 403:17,
403:18, 404:6,
404:19, 405:11,
405:20, 409:20,
417:19, 438:11,
443:3, 443:8, 444:1,
445:4
transients [1] - 383:1
transition [3] - 171:24,
174:14, 175:6
translated [1] - 375:1
translation [2] - 375:5,
375:9
transparency [1] 344:12
transparent [2] 302:20, 418:21
treated [2] - 249:19,
435:16
169 of 172 sheets
130:23, 133:13,
133:19, 134:13,
134:15, 134:23,
135:15, 138:5,
142:12, 143:11,
149:16, 149:22,
151:25, 152:21,
159:8, 160:4, 161:2,
161:19, 163:11,
176:18, 176:20,
178:13, 180:8,
184:20, 186:4,
186:5, 187:25,
189:10, 191:7,
220:7, 223:5,
225:25, 226:9,
226:14, 227:10,
227:15, 232:4,
232:6, 232:8,
233:24, 240:16,
240:24, 251:24,
252:2, 252:4, 252:5,
258:17, 274:7,
276:20, 281:18,
293:15, 293:25,
294:19, 300:25,
306:8, 309:13,
320:1, 327:15,
327:20, 332:16,
333:3, 349:5, 349:8,
352:5, 362:2, 363:8,
369:7, 369:13,
369:15, 369:24,
374:25, 377:20,
378:20, 388:11,
388:20, 389:3,
389:14, 389:17,
389:23, 390:4,
390:13, 390:16,
390:17, 390:18,
391:20, 401:16,
402:4, 402:5,
404:21, 405:7,
405:23, 406:11,
406:12, 408:11,
408:18, 408:25,
409:9, 415:24,
415:25, 416:9,
418:22, 419:1,
419:8, 420:6,
424:14, 437:12,
437:15, 438:10,
456:23
two-hours' [1] - 226:9
two-month [1] - 68:19
two-sample [1] 419:8
two-sigma [1] 408:25
two-week [3] - 77:20,
79:20, 142:12
Tygon [1] - 353:16
type [9] - 9:6, 15:18,
45:12, 151:17,
151:18, 151:19,
262:9, 267:25, 438:6
types [5] - 231:25,
232:6, 232:8,
305:16, 346:7
typically [7] - 49:13,
55:14, 133:8, 234:4,
234:6, 437:16
U
U.S [1] - 152:3
Ugh...Tom [1] - 62:21
ultimate [2] - 32:7,
301:10
ultimately [13] - 12:22,
34:19, 51:25, 64:15,
65:11, 116:1,
120:12, 148:2,
283:1, 301:6,
302:15, 316:17,
423:10
unable [1] - 371:3
unaccompanied [1] 307:21
unanimous [1] 324:11
unapproved [2] 24:10, 250:4
unaware [1] - 113:21
uncertain [6] - 289:6,
289:20, 291:18,
315:7, 343:11,
392:12
uncertainties [5] 187:23, 219:11,
445:2, 445:9, 451:19
uncertainty [28] 160:11, 176:18,
176:19, 176:20,
176:21, 183:20,
187:20, 187:21,
214:12, 290:3,
290:5, 290:7, 290:8,
290:9, 290:10,
291:14, 300:25,
301:16, 301:18,
302:10, 302:12,
302:17, 303:4,
419:25, 437:17,
451:20, 451:21,
451:22
under [64] - 9:7, 9:14,
11:11, 22:22, 25:4,
26:10, 26:14, 26:23,
27:10, 27:11, 27:12,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 52
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 170 of 172
222:21, 223:8
Uniform [2] - 26:3,
26:6
uniform [2] - 228:14,
393:17
uniforms [1] - 25:14
unimportant [1] 211:3
Union [6] - 245:17,
305:6, 335:2, 335:4,
335:9, 344:6
unit [1] - 243:18
United [3] - 324:22,
325:4, 347:17
University [15] 47:15, 150:23,
151:1, 151:3, 151:4,
155:12, 280:9,
322:15, 346:24,
347:15, 347:20,
412:11, 412:15,
440:1, 440:9
unknown [3] - 17:19,
17:20, 315:6
unknowns [8] - 16:10,
17:6, 17:15, 17:21,
287:25, 315:10,
315:17, 315:20
unless [8] - 7:11,
21:19, 166:1,
266:14, 275:1,
275:8, 298:6, 393:21
unlike [1] - 377:10
unlikely [6] - 167:9,
208:24, 208:25,
210:15, 243:3,
377:11
unprecedented [2] 130:17, 132:24
unquestioned [1] 29:21
unrealistic [6] - 94:22,
95:7, 95:12, 95:23,
95:25, 145:1
unreliable [2] - 286:5,
317:22
unreported [3] 211:21, 212:5, 212:7
unscientifically [1] 193:5
unusual [5] - 13:8,
72:15, 87:21, 88:3,
142:23
unweighted [1] 423:19
up [93] - 6:9, 16:25,
19:4, 19:5, 19:6,
28:25, 31:5, 36:19,
41:9, 43:24, 44:5,
44:6, 45:2, 50:3,
V
valid [1] - 438:8
validate [2] - 358:19,
421:14
valuable [1] - 42:15
value [24] - 166:6,
166:23, 168:13,
177:12, 177:14,
Page 52 to 52 of 54
177:23, 177:24,
179:9, 179:11,
181:10, 181:11,
187:8, 187:13,
216:4, 216:22,
222:5, 222:7, 418:2,
418:20, 419:20,
420:4, 420:15,
424:23, 425:23
value's [2] - 166:13,
420:12
values [16] - 149:14,
163:5, 163:6, 163:9,
166:19, 174:24,
186:1, 186:15,
186:16, 381:24,
403:20, 417:15,
418:23, 418:24,
419:13, 432:14
variability [45] 180:24, 181:15,
182:10, 222:15,
222:16, 222:23,
223:14, 224:1,
224:13, 225:7,
361:3, 361:14,
361:15, 361:23,
362:6, 362:18,
362:23, 363:1,
383:25, 387:9,
417:1, 419:15,
419:24, 419:25,
420:2, 429:23,
432:10, 434:24,
437:18, 437:19,
437:22, 438:22,
438:23, 446:5,
446:7, 446:22,
449:16, 449:19,
451:3, 451:25,
454:11, 454:22,
455:6, 455:13
variable [28] - 173:14,
201:13, 206:25,
213:20, 213:21,
215:4, 362:5, 365:1,
380:11, 380:16,
380:19, 380:20,
380:25, 419:19,
429:8, 429:9,
429:25, 430:8,
430:16, 430:21,
431:2, 431:3,
431:10, 431:16,
438:7, 439:1, 450:7
variables [4] - 173:12,
198:16, 202:14,
210:19
variance [9] - 181:8,
182:14, 182:21,
182:25, 183:6,
224:7, 224:10,
419:17, 451:23
variances [2] - 159:6,
420:15
variants [1] - 181:3
variation [12] - 159:3,
205:24, 205:25,
206:22, 212:19,
213:6, 213:24,
222:9, 361:24,
362:19, 368:6, 421:7
variations [2] 169:15, 362:1
variety [3] - 17:13,
345:22, 346:15
various [13] - 27:6,
41:19, 52:7, 76:4,
82:11, 206:5,
298:15, 306:12,
351:21, 352:10,
352:12, 358:1
vary [3] - 17:18, 17:19,
428:2
veering [1] - 355:20
verbally [1] - 265:18
verdict [1] - 324:9
verifying [1] - 358:22
version [5] - 88:11,
88:19, 197:20,
376:21, 430:9
versus [13] - 19:21,
73:10, 217:8,
240:23, 241:1,
319:15, 323:25,
364:4, 365:18,
368:17, 382:21,
422:9, 447:7
VI [1] - 124:24
Vice [10] - 2:6, 2:7,
24:12, 24:22, 25:1,
25:6, 228:6, 228:9,
249:24, 263:15
vice [4] - 246:7,
345:16, 345:17,
347:14
victory [1] - 424:24
videotape [1] - 352:19
view [21] - 19:9, 19:15,
95:19, 154:5, 188:2,
191:19, 201:19,
210:2, 249:8,
273:12, 284:2,
322:23, 378:13,
416:12, 443:20,
443:25, 444:4,
444:22, 444:25,
454:25, 455:6
viewed [4] - 24:15,
271:11, 276:12,
Page 53
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 171 of 172
304:20
viewing [1] - 348:16
views [9] - 190:15,
287:19, 361:6,
363:15, 366:11,
371:16, 373:4,
447:23, 448:7
vigorously [1] 396:12
Vikings [9] - 23:10,
23:12, 246:14,
253:10, 253:17,
253:21, 254:2,
259:17, 260:13
Vikings' [1] - 36:18
VINCENT [2] - 4:10,
5:17
Vincent [19] - 8:17,
14:14, 19:18, 20:1,
25:2, 27:25, 28:7,
28:8, 226:4, 227:13,
228:1, 228:3, 228:4,
229:10, 241:9,
249:18, 251:9,
310:10, 310:14
Vincent's [1] - 27:16
violate [1] - 248:20
violated [2] - 20:25,
252:16
violating [1] - 86:12
violation [8] - 32:19,
33:16, 35:11, 36:16,
218:7, 234:1, 234:5,
245:15
violations [7] - 24:25,
45:12, 228:14,
245:10, 269:19
Violations [1] - 26:7
violence [1] - 46:3
Virginia [1] - 151:3
virtually [2] - 152:9,
153:21
vitamins [1] - 153:21
void [1] - 425:24
W
wait [1] - 135:25
waive [1] - 265:13
waiver [1] - 270:2
waives [1] - 267:6
waiving [4] - 8:6,
267:12, 269:13,
270:21
walk [7] - 83:19,
128:8, 146:11,
158:19, 163:1,
169:23, 307:20
walked [3] - 305:10,
308:10, 309:8
171 of 172 sheets
362:25, 367:4,
381:11, 382:21,
383:6, 383:25,
386:15, 387:8,
387:9, 406:15,
407:18
wetted [2] - 383:16,
383:18
wetter [7] - 178:16,
236:23, 384:25,
385:15, 387:13,
387:18, 407:19
whack [1] - 295:9
WHARTON [1] - 3:15
Wharton [1] - 263:13
what-if [2] - 180:20,
180:22
whereas [3] - 181:20,
335:5, 370:2
white [1] - 420:21
whole [19] - 17:13,
43:3, 51:4, 51:5,
89:10, 220:20,
233:16, 233:17,
237:2, 284:21,
288:12, 298:9,
298:15, 317:20,
329:24, 336:11,
350:5, 396:23,
420:10
wholly [1] - 10:6
wide [4] - 152:10,
153:16, 345:22,
346:14
wife [1] - 43:16
wildly [1] - 393:16
willing [6] - 11:7,
99:19, 225:12,
225:15, 226:18,
290:3
Wilson [4] - 296:13,
299:11, 376:21,
377:3
win [2] - 48:6, 74:2
winded [1] - 284:16
window [9] - 392:17,
404:12, 404:23,
404:25, 405:19,
405:21, 405:23,
408:12, 409:10
winner [3] - 152:16,
188:21, 330:15
WINSTON [1] - 3:8
wishy [2] - 324:20,
324:21
wishy-washy [2] 324:20, 324:21
withdrawn [1] 138:10
withheld [2] - 14:23,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
Page 54
Case 1:15-cv-05916-RMB-JCF Document 28-230 Filed 08/04/15 Page 172 of 172
15:5
WITNESS [104] 49:17, 53:1, 54:14,
54:17, 54:22, 56:2,
56:11, 59:15, 59:18,
60:17, 60:20, 60:23,
61:1, 61:14, 61:17,
66:1, 66:3, 67:2,
68:17, 69:15, 69:18,
69:23, 70:6, 70:21,
70:25, 71:3, 71:10,
71:13, 72:10, 74:23,
80:13, 80:17, 88:11,
88:22, 88:25, 89:4,
89:16, 99:23,
105:15, 109:23,
117:5, 117:8,
117:10, 117:15,
117:18, 117:24,
118:3, 122:21,
124:17, 125:23,
127:25, 128:4,
133:12, 133:18,
136:10, 137:13,
137:15, 137:18,
146:3, 146:6, 146:9,
146:13, 146:15,
146:17, 146:21,
146:24, 147:4,
147:9, 147:14,
147:18, 148:1,
155:20, 155:25,
156:6, 168:10,
168:17, 168:25,
170:11, 170:16,
170:19, 170:24,
177:9, 178:3, 180:4,
180:12, 180:15,
180:18, 180:22,
189:22, 225:21,
230:5, 252:4,
265:22, 271:25,
298:9, 318:5,
397:12, 398:5,
398:8, 403:25,
409:13, 409:19,
439:12, 449:14
witness [32] - 29:15,
47:2, 47:5, 100:2,
136:8, 139:7,
148:22, 150:7,
150:8, 153:6,
198:23, 226:4,
227:20, 239:6,
260:23, 260:25,
261:2, 261:3, 267:7,
279:20, 292:9,
292:10, 341:16,
341:18, 342:17,
345:4, 411:16,
411:18, 439:13,
06/25/2015 03:43:11 PM
439:15, 454:5,
454:18
Witness [2] - 5:14,
5:21
witnesses [21] - 8:22,
20:12, 20:14, 20:15,
29:22, 30:10, 38:2,
226:24, 227:7,
227:10, 227:16,
289:13, 289:18,
292:11, 293:15,
297:19, 302:21,
314:18, 325:18,
325:22, 326:9
WITNESSES [4] - 4:8,
4:13, 5:13, 5:20
won [1] - 48:8
word [12] - 42:17,
44:22, 263:4, 274:8,
274:20, 308:19,
312:21, 312:22,
328:16, 339:9,
452:16, 452:17
words [18] - 17:21,
43:10, 61:9, 66:9,
72:14, 87:23, 96:20,
208:22, 262:19,
274:10, 285:17,
303:8, 324:19,
343:10, 380:23,
398:24, 399:5,
447:19
wordsmithing [1] 269:12
wore [1] - 400:13
works [6] - 12:8,
195:21, 195:24,
302:1, 302:2, 345:22
world [9] - 15:25,
43:14, 201:18,
282:25, 284:7,
330:8, 411:8,
428:16, 433:23
worn [1] - 400:14
worried [1] - 85:16
worries [2] - 94:24,
95:9
worse [1] - 43:12
worth [5] - 349:23,
395:21, 415:9,
425:21, 426:7
wow [1] - 192:23
write [10] - 94:24,
231:19, 312:15,
313:23, 313:24,
318:8, 335:19,
340:8, 391:4, 411:10
writes [7] - 62:20,
78:20, 79:11, 92:11,
92:15, 299:24, 330:6
X
XI [2] - 350:15
Y
Yale [6] - 15:23,
150:18, 150:20,
150:21, 150:22,
196:23
year [12] - 22:14,
23:10, 47:16, 54:25,
71:16, 129:6, 129:8,
152:15, 152:25,
153:9, 261:17,
378:20
years [32] - 24:2,
43:18, 49:19, 69:15,
70:20, 75:12, 75:13,
75:19, 82:14,
116:13, 121:1,
129:1, 142:18,
150:22, 150:23,
153:8, 154:1, 156:7,
196:5, 196:12,
196:14, 236:11,
304:17, 378:20,
378:21, 378:25,
380:6, 412:6,
412:14, 412:16,
440:6
years' [1] - 379:2
Yee [10] - 105:11,
111:6, 139:8,
Page 54 to 54 of 54
312:21, 313:24,
333:9, 333:16,
336:18, 337:6, 338:9
YEE [2] - 4:3, 4:5
Yee's [1] - 108:21
yesterday [2] - 27:24,
275:19
yield [2] - 220:15,
222:4
yields [1] - 403:12
York [30] - 1:16, 2:4,
2:11, 2:12, 2:16,
3:10, 3:16, 6:1, 24:3,
47:7, 61:13, 150:10,
227:22, 261:5,
280:19, 280:24,
330:6, 330:19,
345:5, 411:20,
439:17, 457:8
YORK [1] - 1:24
young [1] - 284:25
yourself [11] - 8:4,
27:6, 27:8, 94:22,
95:13, 95:24, 96:1,
145:1, 245:1,
311:11, 324:2
yourselves [1] - 8:22
Z
zealously [3] - 271:20,
323:6, 323:9
zero [8] - 58:19, 58:21,
170:14, 170:17,
173:1, 389:22,
397:23, 399:3