The Yellow Wallpaper Discussion Question
The Yellow Wallpaper Discussion Question
The Yellow Wallpaper Discussion Question
Date: ____________
Period: _____
The narrator states, It is a big, airy room, the whole floor nearly, with windows that look all ways, and air and
sunshine galore (648). Why, then, does she find the room oppressive and even sinister? Why does the
narrator tell us the room is a nursery? In what ways does John assault Janes individual autonomy and identity?
3. Examine the extent to which Jane conforms to or subverts the definition of the true woman.
How does her relationship with her brother predispose her to womanhood? Jane describes her husband as
practical in the extreme. He has no patience with faith, an intense horror of superstition, and he scoffs openly
at any talk of things not to be felt and seen and put down in figures (647). Consider this description compared
to the definition of masculinity in the late 1800s.
4. Do you think she loves her husband? Trusts him? Fears him? What effect does his repeated denial that his
wife is sick have upon her? Compare the communication styles of John, Jane and Jennie. It has been pointed out
that instead of fighting back against a silencing patriarch, her husband, Gilmans narrator writes back, at times
using masculine, rational language, just a scientific hypothesis-that perhaps it is the paper(Davison 61). How
would this writing undermine her husband? Does Jane successfully illustrate the irony of her husbands care?
Discuss the ways in which the narrator was gifted with a creative and active imagination. How is the forbidden
writing an outlet? When thwarted, what form does her imagination take?
Identify Johns modes of escape from the situation? Is he blind to his wifes progressive mental deterioration or
does he choose to ignore it? Why? Given that Janes husband is threatened by her use of imagination and does
not seem to value art, can she survive in his world, devoid of self-expression?
5. Discuss the layers of symbolism with which Gilman imbues the wallpaper.
Sprawling flamboyant pattern committing every artistic sin (648).
The color is repellent--- (649).
There is one place where the breadths didnt match, and the eyes go all up and down the line, one a little
higher than another (649).
They connect diagonally, and the sprawling outlines run off in great slanting waves of optic horror (649).
Behind that outside pattern the dim shapes get clearer every day (652).
On a pattern like this, by daylight, there is a lack of sequence, a defiance of law, that is a constant irritant to
a normal mind (653).
At night it becomes bars (653).
But there is something else about the paper---the smell!(654).
I pulled and she shook, I shook and she pulled, and before morning we had peeled off yards of that paper
(655).
Contrast what she sees in the wallpaper in the first part of the story with what she sees later. Explore the
significance of the woman in the wallpaper who is trying to escape. Discuss the bars in the room in comparison
to those she sees as a submerged design in the wallpaper.
6. The narrator states, It must be very humiliating to be caught creeping by daylight. In what way does this
statement symbolize the womans predicament? Janes senseless crawling at the end of the story signifies
freedom, insanity, sanity, or something else?
Why does she remain unnamed until the end of the story?
Of what significance is Johns fainting at the end of the story?
With the changes in treatments available today, could her sanity have been saved? How have attitudes toward
nervous disorders and mental illness changed or remained the same?
7. Would you blame the protagonist as the source of her own troubles?
Or as Barbara A. Suess states in The Writings on the Wall: Symbolic Orders in The Yellow Wallpaper,
would you find, the arrogant abuse of patriarchal authority, as the primary source of the protagonists
ultimately complete inability to separate fantasy from reality (81)?
Or would you agree with Charlotte Perkins Gilman who, according to Cynthia Davis, states that, Womens
economic dependence on men has caused them to become more feminine and less human? (Cynthia Davis,
Love and Economics: Charlotte Perkins Gilman on the Woman Question 243).
8. Charlotte Perkins Gillman wrote three utopian romances, seven novels, seven non-fiction books, some 200
short stories, approximately 500 poems, a handful of plays, hundreds of essays and articles and an
autobiography. From your reading, what skill does she have as a writer of fiction? What demands does she
make on the reader? In the age of realism how is her technique ahead of its time?
In what respects do the narrators experiences in The Yellow Wallpaper reflect the authors own experiences?
What reason did Charlotte Perkins Gilman give for writing The Yellow Wallpaper?
9. Point-of-view has often been considered the technical aspect of fiction which leads the critic most readily
into the problems of meaning of a novel or a short story (G. Hugh Holman, Handbook of Literature 4th edition
344). How is the diary form with a first person narrator used to great advantage in this story? How reliable is
the protagonist/narrator? What other words would you use to characterize her perspective? Nave? Limited?
What else?