U.S. patent 7272021: Power converter with isolated and regulated stages. Granted to Schlecht et. al. (2 total) on 2007-09-18 (filed 2006-04-20) and assigned to SynQor, Inc.. Currently involved in at least 1 patent litigation: Vicor Corporation v. Synqor, Inc. (Massachusetts). See http://news.priorsmart.com for more info.
Original Title
Power converter with isolated and regulated stages (US patent 7272021)
U.S. patent 7272021: Power converter with isolated and regulated stages. Granted to Schlecht et. al. (2 total) on 2007-09-18 (filed 2006-04-20) and assigned to SynQor, Inc.. Currently involved in at least 1 patent litigation: Vicor Corporation v. Synqor, Inc. (Massachusetts). See http://news.priorsmart.com for more info.
U.S. patent 7272021: Power converter with isolated and regulated stages. Granted to Schlecht et. al. (2 total) on 2007-09-18 (filed 2006-04-20) and assigned to SynQor, Inc.. Currently involved in at least 1 patent litigation: Vicor Corporation v. Synqor, Inc. (Massachusetts). See http://news.priorsmart.com for more info.
c2) United States Patent
(sy
as),
By)
ay
2
6)
()
@
oy
(32)
Schlecht et al.
POWER CONVERTER WITH ISOLATED
AND REGULATED STAGI
Inventors: Martin F, Schlecht, Lexington, MA
(US); Richard W. Farrington, Heath
TX (US)
Assignee: SynQor, Inc. Boxborough, MA (US)
Notice: Subject w any diselime, the tem of this
patent is extended or adjusted under 35
USC, 1540) by 0 days.
This patent is subject to a terminal dis-
claimer.
Appl. No. 11/407,699
Filed: Apr. 20, 2006
Prior Publication Data
US 200610262575 AI Nov. 23, 2006
Related US.
CContinuation-in-part of application No. 10729430,
filed on Dec. 5, 2003, now Pa, No. 7.050.309, which
is » continuation-in-part of application No. 108
314, filed on Mar. 29, 2004, now Pat. No, 7.072.190,
Which is a continuation af application No. 10355,
4457 filed on Feb. 5, 2003, now Pat, No, 6,731,520,
‘which is a division of application No, 091817,867,
filed on Oot. 13,1999, now Pat, No, 6,222,742, which
is division of epplication No. 091012,475, fled oa
Jan, 23, 1996, now Pat. No, 5,999,417, which is a
‘ontiauation of application No, 091821, 655, filed on
Mar. 29, 2001, now Pat, No. 6,594,159
Application Data
Provisional application No, 60/431,673, filed on Dee.
6, 2002 provisional application No, 609036,245, filed
on Jan, 24, 1997
Int. cl.
HORM 3335 (2000601)
us.Cl 363/17, 3697
USO
107272021
US 7,272,021 B2
*Sep. 18, 2007
(10) Patent No.:
(45) Date of Paten
(58) Field of Classification Search seas,
363/18, 20, 21.01, 95, 97,125, 131,17
‘See application file for complete search history.
66) References Cited
US, PATENT DOCUMEN:
BOORL A S9T2 Pasa
{Continued
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
sio90 BL 7993
i sivas a2 2002
» 06315263 AL
Wo WORKOOS4 AL 111988
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Movons . Haachitaba, otal, A High-Eiincy 1.5 RW, 390-50
V Talbidge Converter Operted at 100% Dury-Rato IEEE,
1992, pp. 723730.
(Continued)
Primary Examiner
(74) Atormes, Agent, oF Firm
Reynokds, PC
Adolf Berhane
Hamilton, Brook, Smith &
on
Ina power converte, the duty eyele ofa primary winding
circuit causes near continuous flow of power through the
Primary and secondary winding circuits during normal
‘operation, By providing no regulation during noanal opera-
tion, a very eficent circuit is obtained with a synchronous
reclfier in the secondary operating at all times. However,
during certain conditions such as start up or a shoet-cecut,
the duty cycle of the primary may be reduced 10 cause
freewheeling periods, nomally on-regulating isolation
stage may be followed by plural non-solating regulation
stages. To simplify the gate crive, the synchronous rectifiers
‘may be allowed t0 tur off for a portion ofthe eyele when
the duty eyce is reduced. filter inductance of the second:
ary wining citcut is sulicent to minimize ripple during
formal operation, but allows large siple when the duty
cele is reduce. By accepting large ripple during other than
normal operation, a smaller fier inductance ean be vse.
ABSTRACT
48 Claims, 8 Drawing SheetsUS 7,272,021 B2
Page 2
US, PATENT DOCUMENTS
443841 A 4984 Robin tal
AS86LID A, 6 Suton
4788450 A LL988 Wagner
AT6M A LLIORK Schlecht a
4812672 A M4989 Cowan ea
SOIV9S4 A $1991 Bourges ta.
S512 A, Fisher etal
527856 A, Loftus, Je
S30R138 A, Rooman
S3038 A. ‘hina a
S306a12 A Barge
Sa5M A, Coke a
551092 A, Goebel
a Kikinis etal
a Roman
a Uilestate
a Rooman
a Warn etl
a ‘Yamashita a
S771160 A, Seong
S774350 4, Noto
S870299 A, Rozman
SHM05 A, Loftus, Jeet
Ss80.949 A, Melhem ea.
Sos9a70 A Pa
59994417 A. Schlecht
6016258 A, Shin ta
6.046920 A, aha eta
6.6594 A. Hastings etal
088.329 A, Libary a
6252781 BI 62001 Rinne ea
6487093 BI 11/2002 Vogman
6504267 BI 1.2009 Giannopoulos
6552917 BI 42003 Bouillon
6 700,365 B2 42001 Isham ta
6788 BI 4.2004 Chen ea
6.735004 B2 $2004 Stigrvald et
6853568 B2_ 22005 Li eta
71050300 B2* $2006 Farington 3617
797190 B2 12006 Sebleht
2080174822 AL 92003 Xu etal.
2o0sosTi77 AL 32008 “Tita
20060209872 AL 92006 Schlecht
20060285368 AL 122006 Schlecht
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
-Mcen, Loveday Haacitaba, “The Design of Front-End DC-DC
Converters of Distributed Power Supply Systems with Improved
ficiency and Stability Thesis, Masschusts Isitte of Tech-
ology, Sep. 192, pp. L184
Casey, Leo Francis, “Celt Design For 1-10 MHZ DC-DC Con.
‘vasion.” MIT Doctoral Thesis, 8h. 1989, pp. 1-216
Toten, Andeew. "A 250° W High Density Poin-fLoad Con.
ater” MIT Masior of Science Thasis, Sep. 1989, pp. 1-117
‘Moan, Bijan, MOSFET Synchronous Rector Achieve 90%
ciency Pat Land Pat I, PCIM, Tan 1991, pp 10:13 & $8461
(Cobos A. ot al, "Resonant Resut Forward Topologies for Low
‘Ovuput Volage On Board Converters” IEEE, 195, pp. 703-708.
“abl, WA, eal, "A MOSFET Resonant Synchronous Resor
Foy High-Frequeney DC DC Converters" Procelingsof he Power
lecwones Specialists Conference, San Antonio, TX, Jun 1-18,
1990, pp 769.779.
Wiogmin, HLLN, al, “A Dual Active Bridge SMPS Using
Synchronous Rests.” HEPC May 1990 Proeadings, pp. 336+
346
Shoyama, Mash, & al,
‘Magntzing Cumese of Transformer st Push-Pull Cea
si
“Zax Notage Switch Pash-Pall DC-
229.
‘ino, Li. et al "Sof Swichel PWM. DCIDC Converter With
‘Syachronous Retr” IEEE 196, pp. 476-484
‘Blanchard, Richard, ets, “The Dsigh ofa High Eicione, Low
‘Voltage Power Supply Using MOSFET Synchronous Resifcation
snl Cusent Mode Contol IEEE, 1988 p. 385-361
Sitar, fone Dan, tal, “High Eiciency DC-DC Convent." EEE,
1904p. 638-644,
Harpur, DJ, tal, "Contoled Synchronous Rest,” HEPC May
1988 Proceedings, pp. 165172
Acker, Brin, etal. “Currea-Contoled Synchronous Recifica-
tion” IEEE 1994, pp. 185-191
‘Mura, Naoki al ~A High Eceny 30-W Board Mousted
Power Suply Mole IEEE 1991, pp. 122
(Casey, Lan Fe al, "A High Freqeney, Low Volume, Ponto
Load Power Supply for Disibuted Power Systems” IEEE L087,
pp. 489-450,
Schlecht, Marin F., “Research Rests frm the Sty of A High
[ciency Highly Manuactunble DC-DC Convert” unpub
lished pp. 1-32,
‘Gachora, Jon Moun, “Design ofa FourPhase Switched High
ciency Power Supply.” MIT Master of Engineering. Thess,
1994, op. 166
[Blanchard Reta, "MOSFETs Move n On Low Voge Reat-
‘eation” Oficial Procedigs of the Ninth Intersil PCY "84
Confrence, Ot 2-31, 1984, pp. 213-222
Garcia, Oca, "Zero Voge Switching In The PW Hal Beige
‘Topology With Complementary Cont And Synchronous Retil-
cation,” Reson ofthe Amn Power Electronics Specialist Com
Terence, Pes, lana, Ju, 12-15, 1995, vl 1, No. CONF 26 un
12,1995, IEEE, pp. 286-291.
“ZeroVolage Switching Realized by
at
* cited by examinerU.S. Patent Sep. 18, 2007 Sheet 1 of 8 US 7,272,021 B2
oO
g 3
Zz
Z
FIG. 1
S <
2 w
8
Q
v ~ 9
7 2US 7,272,021 B2
Sheet 2 of 8
Sep. 18, 2007
USS. Patent
é OldUS 7,272,021 B2
Sheet 3 of 8
Sep. 18, 2007
USS. Patent
€ OldUS 7,272,021 B2
Sheet 4 of 8
Sep. 18, 2007
USS. Patent
INIT ND
acl
‘ano
7 gino 30]
v LN0S TTT} v1no a4! vg 2 aaUA
aca diNoo
corn PLL
awoo:
| SPs |S
cod ote Oh
‘¥}e0|29}
| jous: anol _
'so0a “NN ’s008 NN NA
NIH
oh nor NiH| oa xe or
aan)
an TO} 008: Leto:
+NIA|
pes b-oorrt
0017
rolls
gona TinUS 7,272,021 B2
Sheet 5 of 8
Sep. 18, 2007
USS. Patent
ar ols
“On
[b-Loze
|t-oozr
+0A
SOVLS LNdiNOUS 7,272,021 B2
Sheet 6 of 8
Sep. 18, 2007
USS. Patent
HELO 8clO
: 1 SauA
doo! v-301N LeleUS 7,272,021 B2
Sheet 7 of 8
Sep. 18, 2007
USS. Patent
-OA
ar ‘ola
|b-bozr
|-oozr
+0A
Lunoulo
dwv1o
BOVLS LNdLNOU.S. Patent Sep. 18, 2007 Sheet 8 of 8 US 7,272,021 B2
501 503
bv
12v
Isolation + Regulation
503
Regulation
503
(
1.8v
Regulation
FIG. 5US 7,272,021 B2
1
POWER CONVERTER WITH ISOLATED
"AND REGULATED STAGES
RELATED APPLICATIONS
‘This application is Continuation-i-Part of US. appl
cation Set No. 10/729,430, filed on Dee. 5, 2003 now US.
Pat, No, 7.050.309, which claims the benefit of U.S, Provi-
sional Application No. 60/431,673, fled Dee. 6, 2002 and a
Continuationin-Partt U.S. application Ser. No. 10812,
314, fled Mar. 29, 2004 now U.S. Pat, No. 7,072,190, whieh
is a comtinvation of application Ser, No, 10/389,457, fled
Feb. 5, 2003 now US. Pat. No. 6,731,520, which is a
continuation of application Ser. No. 09/831,685, fled Ma
29, 2001, now US. Pa. No. 6,594,159, which isa divisional
‘of application Se. No. 09/417,867, filed Oct. 13, 1999, now
US. Pat, No, 6,222,742, which is a divisional of Ser. No.
(09/012.475, fled Jan. 23, 1998, now US. Pat. No. 5,999,
AIT, whic claims the benefit of US. Provisional Applica.
tion 60(036,245 fil Jan, 24, 1997. The entre teachings of
the above applications are incoxpornted herein by reference
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
‘This invention pertains to switching power converters. A ™
specific example of a power converter is a DC-DC power
supply that draws 100 watts of power from a 48 volt DC
source and convents it 0 a5 volt DC output to drive logic
circuitry. The seminal valves and ranges of the input and
‘output voliges, as well as the maximum power handling
capability of the converter, depend on the application,
Tris common today for switching power supplies to have
a switching frequency of 100 kHz or higher, Such a high
switching frequency permits the capacitors, inductors, and
‘runsfomier: in the converter to be physically small. The
reduction inthe overall volume of the converter that results
is desirable to the uses of such supplies
Aooiher important attbute of a power supply is its
eficiency. The higher the elicieney, the less heat that is
dissipated within the supply, and the less design effort,
volume, weight, and cost that must be devoted to remove
thisheat. A higher efficiency is therefore also desirable othe
users of these supplies
A significant faction ofthe energy dissipated in a power
supply is due to the on-state (or conduction) loss of the
diodes used, paricuary if the load and/or source voltages
are low (eg. 33, 5, of 12 vols). In onder to reduce this,
conduction lss, the diodes are sometimes replaced with
‘wansistors whose on-state voltages are auch smaller. These
‘eansistors, called synchronous rectfes, are typically power
MOSFETs for converters switching in the 100 kHz and
higher range.
‘The use of trasisiors as synchronous wetter in high
switching frequency converters presents sever technical
challenges. One isthe need w provide properly timed dives.
tothe contol terminals ofthese transistors, This tasks made
‘more complicated when the converter provides electrical
isolation between is input and outpat because the synchro
‘ous reife drives ae thea isolated fom the dees ofthe 6
sain, primary side transistors. Another challenge i the peed
to minimize losses during the switch transitions of the
synchronous rectifiers. An important portion ofthese switch
ing losses is due to the aced to charge and discharge the
parasitic capacitances ofthe transistors, the parasitic induc> 6S
tances of interconnections, and the leakage inductance of
transformer windings.
2
‘SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In certain embodiments of the invention, a power con-
verter system comprises a normally non-reguating isolation
sage and a plurality of non-isoatng regulation stages, each
receiving the output ofthe isolation stage and regulating a
regulation stage output. The aoa-regulating isolation stage
‘may comprise a primary winding circuit and a secondary
‘winding creit coupled wo the primary winding circuit, The
secondary Winding circuit comprises 4 secondary tan
former winding in series with controllod rectifier having @
paral uncontrolled reetifie.A contra ert eontols duty
cyele ofthe primary’ winding ctcit, the duy cycle causing,
substantially uninterrupted contol of power through the
Primary and secondary winding circuits during normal
operation,
The duty cycle ofthe primary winding circuit may be
reduced to cause freewheeling periods in other than normal
‘operation. Duty eyele might be reduced during the startup or
to limit curent and may be a function of sensed current,
The primary winding creuit may include a single primary
winding, and the secondary winding circuit may include
plural secondary windings coupled to the single primary
‘winding. The primary winding may ben a fll ridge circuit.
having a capacitor in series with the primary winding. In one
‘implementation ofthe fll bridge circuit, during freewheel.
‘ng, only v0 top FETS or two bottom FETS are turned off
contol signal ofthe controlled rectifier may be derived
from a waveform of the secondary winding circuit. The
secondary winding etcut may include a filter indvtor and
hhave a capacita coupled across its output,
The isolation stage may be a step down stage. For
example, it may provide an output of about 12 vols from a
DC power source that provides a voltage varying over the
range of 36-75 volts. The regulation stages may be down,
converters to provide outputs of voltage levels to drive logic
circuitry. A regulation stage ouipat may, for example, be 5
vols or less, such as 3.3 volts,
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The foregoing and other objects, features and advantages
of the invention will be apparent fom the following more
particular description of prefered embodiments of the
jventioa, as illustrated in the accompanying drawings ia
which like reference characters refer to the same parts
‘throughout the different views, The drawings are not noc:
cesarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon illus-
‘rating the principles of the invention.
FIG. 1 shows a fall-bridge, single-ransforme, voltage
fed isolation stage that incomporates concepts of the “417
patent
FIG. illustrates the adliion ofa capacitor to the primary
winding of FIG. 1.
IG. 3illstates the addition of an output filter indvetor
to the cirevitof FIG. 2.
FIGS. 4A-4C show a contro circuit for the circuits of
FIGS. 13 and embodying the present invention, and FIG.
4D shows an allemative to the circuit of FIG. 4B.
FIG, § shows an Intermediate Bus Architecture (IBA)
‘implementation ofthe invention.US 7,272,021 B2
3
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE
INVENTION
A description of prefered embodiments ofthe invention
follows
FIG. 1 shows a full-bridge, single-tansformer, voltae
fed isolation stage that incorporates synchronous rectifiea-
tion and the concepts ofthe “417 patent. The operation of
this isolation stage is as follows. For the first half of the
cyele, MOSFETs 101 and 103 are tumed on while MOS-
FETs 102 and 104 are let off and the vokage Vis applied
positively (according to the “dot” convention) across the
{ransfomer’s primary winding 107. This voltage, modified
by the transfonmer’stumsrato, appears across the second
ary windings with the appropriate polarity. Power ows into
the transformer’s primary winding, and out of the first
secondary winding 108 tothe output. The volage at Node B
is approximately twice the output voltage, and it eauses the
MOSFET synchronous rettier 105 10 be turned on. The
voltage at Node Ais therefore slightly below ground, which
ceases the MOSFET synchronous rectifier 106 to be turned
off These states ofthe rectifier switches are consistent with,
the power flowing out ofthe frst sscondary winding,
‘During the second half of the eyele, MOSFETS 102 and
104 are tumed on while MOSFETs 191 and 103 ae eft off,
and the voltage Vis applied neyatively across the trans
former's primary ‘Winding. This negative polarity causes
MOSFET 106 10 be tured oa, MOSFET 105 to be tumed
‘off, and power to flow into the primary winding and cut of
the second secondary winding 109 to the output across
capacitor 10,
‘The secondary windings are not tightly coupled to each
other, as indicaed withthe parasitic inductances 113 and
114, to achieve the advantages discussed inthe "417 patent
A similar setup was shown inthe topology of FIG. 9 ofthe
“417 patent since it also used a single wansloeme.
Care must be taken in this isolation stage topology to
ingore thatthe magnetizing inductance of the transformer
does not saturate One way to do this isto place a large
capacitor 218 in series with the primary winding a show
in FIG. 2. This capacitor will assume a de voltage across it
that counters any imbalance there may bein the positive and
negative volt-seconds of the waveforms ereated by Mi
FETs 101-104. Altemativey, several well-known tech
niques to sense the magnetizing inductor’sewrent could be
sed to modify the durations of the first and second halves
of the eee
‘The filters atthe output ofthe isolation stages in the “417
patent are composed of one of more cepaciive and inductive
lements. When the isolation stage is voltage-fe, it may be
desirable to have the output itr bepin with an indctoe 316,
as shown in FIG. 3. One benefit this approach provides is
that the voltage-fed isolation stages can now be operated
with a variable duty eyele control strategy to provide a
sofestart capability orto limit curent ow ina shortciecuit
condition. These functions could be provided by the regu
lation stages in the topologies depicted in the 417 patent,
but if the isolation stage is not combined diretly with a
regulation stage in a single product, then it may be desirable
to include these functional capabilities in the isolation stage,
as well
‘Under variable duty eyele contol, the pereentage of the
coveral eycle (the duty cycle) that MOSFETS 101 and 103
(or MOSFETS 102 and 104) conduct is reduced from the
50% value described shove, For the remaining, freewheeling
fraction of the half-eyele, ether all of the primary-side
[MOSFFTS are tured of, or at east the two top MOSFETS
x“
4
101 and 104 or the two bottom MOSFETs 102 and 108 are
tured off. During the freewiheTing part of the evel, both
diodes 111 and 112 conduct the cunteat Bowing through
indvctor 316, and the voltage across the transformer wind
ings is approximately oro As is well know, this additional
portion ofthe eyele penis the ouput voltage to be less than
‘Vo divided by the rrinsformer’s tms-rati. How much less