Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sir Philip Sidney's Remark On His Contemporaries
Sir Philip Sidney's Remark On His Contemporaries
) English Literature
Since, we have already discussed first three sections of this critical essay before; I shall
deal with the fourth section here.
Philip Sidney had eventually earned the repute of a practical critic. He not only put
forward his conception of an ideal poetry; indeed he pushed criticism to the practical use.
He weighed the works of writers who wrote in his lifetime and those before him as well.
In deliberating his thoughts on contemporary literature, I would first perceive the method
he had used and then with the defects and suggestions which he had pointed out in regard
to the literature of that age.
Method of Criticism
Sidney approached the literature available in his times in the following steps:
Find out the faults in literary work, its genre, form, content etc.
(Tragedy, Comedy, Lyrical poetry, diction & style)
Put forth suggestions for the possible improvement in that literary genre.
Pass judgment whether a work is good, bad, better, best or worst.
(Based on its conformity to classical models & sincerity of purpose)
Sidney started finding faults with the drama, as it was the emerging genre until then.
He laid stress on unities to be observed and dignity of each genre to be kept in mind.
It seemed absurd to him to show Asia, Africa & America all on the same stage. Or in
some cases, showing battle fields, gardens, caves etc in one place within just time span of
less than two hours was strongly disliked by him. He was of the opinion that what can not
be showed, must be told. He did not appreciate blending comic and serious incidents
together and considered it an abuse. He dealt with the two major kinds of dramas viz.
Tragedy and Comedy separately. About tragedy he stated;
ℑ Tragedy should be subject to laws of poetry and not history. Dramatist must
transform his material to obtain tragic effects.
[email protected]
http://www.altaftheredmax.spaces.live.com
Altaf Ahmed Sheikh 2 M.A (Hons.) English Literature
ℑ Plot in tragedy should open at some significant incidence which brings the
reader to the heart of happenings at once without detouring of any sort.
ℑ Chronology of events may be altered at will of writer and/or some fresh
incidents and situations may be invented.
ℑ If an incidence is hard to be represented, it must be reported.
ℑ Only tragedy he admires is “Gorbuduc” by Seneca.
[email protected]
http://www.altaftheredmax.spaces.live.com
Altaf Ahmed Sheikh 3 M.A (Hons.) English Literature
“Marry they that delight in poetry itself should seek to know what they do, how they do,
and especially look themselves in an unflattering glass of reaction, if they inclinable unto
it. For poetry must not be drawn by ears; it must be gently led, or rather it must lead;
which was partly the cause that made the ancient-learned affirm it was a divine gift.”
[email protected]
http://www.altaftheredmax.spaces.live.com