Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Developing Political Competence
Developing Political Competence
219224
0737-1209/01/$15.00
Blackwell Science, Inc.
Developing Political
Competence: A Comparative
Study Across Disciplines
Joanne W. Rains, D.N.S., R.N., and Paul BartonKriese, Ph.D.
219
community advocacy. Though useful, this professional orientation isnt all that is needed to help student nurses
or novice practitioners find links between the personal,
political, and professional. Understanding political influence in the context of citizenship is also helpful.
The expression of citizenship is unique to each political
culture, but it involves the five following attributes: a sense
of identity (national or multinational), an enjoyment of
rights and benefits, the fulfillment of obligations and duties,
accepting the responsibility to be interested and engaged
in public affairs, and an acceptance of basic values held
by most of society (Cogan, 1998). Citizenship involves
a reciprocal relationship between the individual and the
collective that is neither passive nor pessimistic.
Citizenship within the United States currently faces several severe threats. Braungart and Braungart (1998) cited
problems such as increasing pluralism and diversity, which
threaten our unified sense of identity. Low voter turn-out
and declining loyalty to political parties suggest a disaffected citizenry. Lastly, a willingness to serve and sacrifice
for the whole contradicts the American culture of individualism and materialism. Images of rugged individualism and
pulling yourself up by your own bootstraps pervade the
culture. Skepticism toward government and any consolidation of power can be seen as both an American strength
and a flaw.
Nurses are called to the American political table in the
context of this political culture and these challenges to
citizenship. Certainly, nurses as citizens have, to some
extent, shaped political attitudes and acquired knowledge
through primary and secondary school, family experiences,
media exposure, and community life. But how do undergraduate nursing education and professional socialization
contribute to the development of competencies to effectively influence policy and politics? What is the student
journey toward political competence or active citizenship?
On what sources do they base their opinions about public
policy? How do they live their beliefs as citizens and as
a professionals? Does the nursing student experience differ
from that of students in other disciplines? In an attempt
to begin to address these questions, we conducted a small
exploratory study comparing undergraduate nursing and
political science students on their political beliefs and
behaviors.
METHODOLOGY
This cross-sectional comparative study was conducted at
a small regional university campus in the Midwest. Clearance was obtained by the schools Institutional Review
Board. A convenience sample was drawn from two populations of college students: senior-level baccalaureate nursing
students (N 9) and senior-level political science students