Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Its Not Our Shame, Its Your Shame Says Shenaz Treasurywala To PM Modi
Its Not Our Shame, Its Your Shame Says Shenaz Treasurywala To PM Modi
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
I NDIA O PINES
Search
18.9k
IndiaOpinesisAboutFreedomof
SpeechandTheRightToOpenly
ExpressOne'sOpinions
Contribute
ShareonFacebook
TweetonTwitter
YouMustCheckThemOut
SHARES
ActressShenazTreasurywalahaswrittenanopenlettertoPM
NarendraModi,AmitabhBachchan,SalmanKhan,ShahRukh
Khan,AamirKhan,andAnilAmbaniappealingagainstrapesinIndia.
MostSharedPosts
SelfPublishYourOpinions,Submit
YourLinks
Community
UnderstandingtheUberTaxi
Rapist
Hereistheletter
DearNarendraModi,AmitabhBachchan,SachinTendulkar,
ShahrukhKhan,SalmanKhan,AamirKhanandAnilAmbani,
IamwritingtoYOUspecificallybecauseyouarethemostpowerfuland
influentialMENinourcountry.
IamwritingtoyouasawomanwhogrewupinamiddleclassfamilyinMumbai.
ShwetaBasuPrasadWrites
OpenLettertoMedia,Reveals
Truth
IamwritingtoYOUforHELP!
Myparentsmaynotlikemesayingthis.Iapologizetothemiftheyare
readingbutthisisNOTMYSHAME.ItsTHIERSHAME.
Myfirstexperiencewiththeoppositesex,waswhenIwasjust13andgropedbya
man(neversawhisfacebutwillneverforgethishand)whilewalkinginthe
vegetablemarketwithmymom.Shehadjustgivenmetheworsthaircutandas
anangryteenagerIwasupsetatherandwaslaggingbehindasshewalkedahead.
IstillrememberwhatIwaswearing.Itwasherdress,mustardwithflowersand
littlebowinthefront.HowIhatethatdress!Asif,itwasthedresssfault.
Iwasshockedatfirst.Speechless.Hedisappeared.Ijuststoodthere.Tears
startedpouringoutofmyinnocenteyes.Itoldmymomwhowentmad
screaminginthemarketbutwhoknewwherethatmandisappearedto.Istill
rememberthedirtyfeelingIhadandthenumberoftimesIshoweredinmy
grandmomsbathroomafter.Thatfeelingneverwentaway.
8ReasonsWhyWeLove
BengaliWomen
ReasonsWhyWeLove
PunjabiWomen
Sincethenitwasnonstop.Iwouldtrytoarticulatethistomyparentsandwhile
mymomunderstood,mydadandunclestoldmeIwasimaginingit.Maybethey
justcouldntdealwithit.CANYOU?
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
1/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
WhenIwas15,IstartedgoingbytrainandbustoSt.XaviersCollege.Iwas
gropedandtouchedandfromallanglesandthiswasjusthowIgrewup.NotJust
MebutMOSTINDIANWOMENwhodonthavetheluxuryofcarsanddrivers.
AsateenagerIwoulddreamofandstillsometimesdreamthatIhada
machinegunandcouldkillallthemenwhotriedtogropeme.Avery
disturbingdreamforakid,dontyouthink?
AncientIndiaPreferredDark
Skin,NotFairSkin!
IgotmyfirstassignmentasamodelintheFYJCandIhadtogotoscreentests
straightfromcollege.SoIhadtodressnice,didntmakeitanyeasier.I
specificallyrememberthetimeIwentforanauditioninaredbodysuitanda
blacklongskirtwithslits.ItwasHELL!Ineverworethatagain.Asifitwasthe
dresssfault.
Idevelopedwaystodefendmyself,Ialwayscarriedabaginfrontof
me,myfistwasalwaysclenched,Ialwaysturnedaroundevery20
secondstocheckwhowasbehindmeandafewtimesIslappedmen
whotouchedme,Igotslappedbackmanytimestoo.Sometimessaved
bythepublic,MOSTTIMESNOT.
Mymombeggedmenottopickfightswithmenwhotouchedme,she
wasafraidofacidbeingthrownatmeorthatsomebodysomeday
wouldhurtmebadly.SheisSTILLAFRAIDandtodayshetoldmenot
totakeanUBERtomymeetingtomorrow.Hellya.BANUBER!Make
everyonetakeresponsibilityforthis.
MysistergotintoSophiascollege,wewereallexcited.Shewentbybusbutthe
firstdayshecamehome,shesobbedtraumatized.Amanhadputhishandinher
teeshirtthroughhersleeve,theentirebusride.Shejustfroze.Shewasakidtoo
andwasntequippedtoevenunderstandthis.IwasLIVID.Imsorrysisfor
tellingtheworldthis,pleasedontstopspeakingtome.ITSNOTOurShame.Its
THEIRS!
OneofmyfriendsincollegewasRAPEDonthetrainonherwayhomeinthe
ladiescompartment.Shewassickandwasgoinghomeinthe11:15break.There
wasnobodyinthefirstclasscompartmentgoingbacktoBandraatthattime,it
wasasuperfastmeaningitdidntstopatmoststations.Herapedherandthen
jumpedoffafterusingherscrunchy(hairtie)towipehimself.Shewastheonly
oneonthetrainandhadtolimpherwaybacktoherhomeinBandra,bleeding
profusely.Shewasjust16.Thisshefeltwashershamesoshedidnot
sayanythingtoanyone.
HolyCow!MindBlowing
FactsAboutIndia
IndianWomenThatInspire
andMakeUsProud!
ThePowerofWomeninBJP
Government
BUTITISNTHERSHAME,itsTHEIRSHAME.
MymomaccompaniedmetoHyderabadonashootonce.Inchuribazaar,a
cyclistgropedMyMOM.MydearrespectedandlovelyMOM.
INDIANWOMENINSPORT
SorryMom,ITSNOTOurShame,ItsTHEIRSHAME.
WhyamItellingyoumypersonalstory?
WellfirstIwantallwomentoSpeakUp.
LetsmakethisourMOTTO
ItsnotOURSHAME,itsTHEIRSHAME.
DivasofIndianDecor
WhoareTHEY?
THEYARETHEMENINOURCOUNTRY.
NotjusttherapistsandthesexualoffendersandgropersbutalsoourFathers
(sorrydad)andUnclesandBrothersandMOVIESTARSANDCRICKETERS
ANDPOLITICIANSfornotSAVINGUSorPROTECTINGUSbyinsistingand
protestingfortheLAWSTOCHANGEandRapistsandGroperstoBE
PUNISHEDSEVERELY!
Whydoweaswomenhavetofeelsothreatened?WHYhastherebeennosevere
actiontaken?Thishasgoneonforyearsnow.NotjustinDelhibutalloverour
countryandyeseveninBOMBAYORMUMBAIORWhateverthehellyouwant
tocallit!ItsNOTSAFE.NO!
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
RecentComments
PopularDiscussions
POPULAR TOPICS
TRENDINGNARENDRAMODI
JODHAAKBARMAHARANA
PRATAPARVINDKEJRIWAL
2/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
MybiggestfeareversinceIwaskidandeventodaywhenIwalkback
homeatnightfromyogaorwhenItakearickshawfromafriends
homeisbeingRAPED.Istillfeelthatfear.Iamstillamonguard.I
stillfantasizeofhavingthatMACHINEGUN.
Inthepast4yearsIhavebeenlivingandworkinghalfinIndiaandhalfinNew
YorkandletmetellyouIhavewalkedthestreetsofHarlem,theBronxand
Brooklyn(perceivedasthemostdangerousinNYC)at3amafterpartiesinshort
skirtsandfeltsaferthanIfeelinBandraat10pmonaquietroadfullycovered.
WHY??
LetstalkaboutDelhiourCapital.Iwasthere2daysagoandthedayoftherape.I
wantedtogooutandwalkbyIndiaGateandadmireourgreatmonumentsbut
couldI?!Why??
WhatgoodareallyourspeechesintheUSorJapanorAUSTRALIA
NAMO,ifnowomancanwalkfreelyinthestreetseveninbroad
daylightbyherselfintheCAPITALOFOURCOUNTRY.Isntthisa
SHAME?SHAMEONYOUSIR.
RELATIONSHIPSRELIGION
BOLLYWOODWOMEN
JAMMU&KASHMIR
TVSERIALSCRICKET
COMMUNITY
SEARCH
SEARCH
CustomSearch
SOCIAL MEDIA
ThisisourNO1issue.FIXTHISbeforeanythingelse.
ThisisaSHAME.AnditsYOURSHAME.YouarenowRESPONSIBLE
FORUS.
DISCLAIMER
Allviews,includingthoseexpressedinaffiliated
IbegallofyoufinegentlementhatIhaveaddressedtohelpchangetheLAW.
socialmediapagesofthewebsite,arepersonaland
Youarepowerfulmen.Isay,SHAMEandPUNISHTHEGropersandSexual
offendersseverely.KILLTHERAPISTS.
withourfundamentalrighttofreedomof
IwontaskforpubliccastrationwhichiswhatIwantandallthewomenwant
becauseIknowthisisunrealisticandthingsmoveSODAMNSLOWinourFINE
NATION.
anyview.Tocontributepleaseusethislink.
AllIaskforistheDeathPenaltyPlease.NOW!QUICK!
belongtotheirrespectiveownerstheyareused
IfthatstoohardorwilltaketoolongthenatleastLIFEIMPRISONMENT.
claimnoownershiponthem.
belongtothecontributingauthor(s)inaccordance
speechgiventousbyourconstitutionunder
Article19(1a).IndiaOpinesinnowayendorses
Tocontactuspleaseusethislink.Allimages
usedonthissite(barringtheonespurchasedbyus)
havebeencreditedwitha'ImageSource'andduly
forillustrativeandcommentingpurposesandwe
Putthemawayforever.
Whywasthismanwhohadrapedtwicebeforeoutonbail?
Andthengivenadriverslicense?YES,BANUBERTOO.Makeeveryone
responsible.
Imreadytodoanything.ImnotabigenoughcelebbutyouSachin
Tendulkar,AmitabhBachchan,SalmanKhan,SharukhKhan,Aamir
Khan,AnilAmbaniSIRSneedtospeakupasMEN(youarethemen
withthepower)
SAVEUS!
PleasedemandtheDeathSentencefortheRapists.
NOBAIL.JustDeath.
SuperstarsIbegyou,pleasetakeastand.UseyourSuperstardomandPowerand
MONEYandsavethewomenofourcountry.SAVEUS!
IurgeyoutoprotestorgoonafastordosomethingDRASTICsopeopletake
notice,thegovernmentwakesupandCHANGEStheLAWsothesemenare
terrifiedtotouchus.
Deathtorapists.Nobail.Justdeath.
ImagineAmitabhBachchanSir,AamirKhan,SalmaanKhan,Sachin
Tendulkar,AnilAmbaniifyouwentonafastorwalkedtothe
RashrtrapatiInDelhi.Ifyou,tookthisstandandmadethisYOURNO
1issue,howmuchchangetherewouldbe?!
Whyshouldweaswomenfeelsounsafeinourmotherland?!
Whyshouldweaswomenbeterrifiedandonguardallthetime.
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
3/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
Whywasthismanoutonbailaftercommittedtworapesalready?
MakeanExampleOfHim.
Anymanwhoeventouchesawomanshouldbeimprisonedforlife.
Bestrict,makeexamplesofthesemen,scarethosewhodaretotouchus.
SCARETHEMBYMAKINGANEXAMPLEOUTOFTHEM.
SAVEUS,Saveyourmother,daughter,sisterplease!
ThisisNOTOURSHAME.
THISISYOURS.
SHAMEONYOU.
DontsleeptillyouSAVEYOURWOMEN!
Withallrespect,
ShenazTreasury
Source
ImageSource
ShareonFacebook
Dec 11, 2014
By EDITORIAL TEAM
TweetonTwitter
in TRENDING
ShareonGoogle
97comments
Addacomment
RiteshThakurArmySchool
NowIamnotagainsther.Groping,molestationistheroot.weallagreetothis.Butifgovernmentmakes
amendmentinlawtopunishmolesters,gropers,rohtakgirlslikeincidentswillonlyincrease.Thisgivethose
criminalmindedgirlsawaytostopaguyandaskhimtogiveherathousandbucksotherwisehewillbetaken
topolice.Also,investigationforallthosecaseswillonlyincreasenumberofcasesandassuchcasearevery
muchinnumber,policewillbedoingonlyonething,monitoringpublicareasandcatchingmolesterswhichwill
affecttheirotherduties.
Butyes,ifpunishingaguytwicedoesn'tstophim,putabulletthroughhisheadnexttimeheiscaught(uber
case).Ifweareseeingcaseslikethis(ubertaxicase),nexttimeonwardsifsomeoneisfoundguiltyofsucha
crime,shoothimintheheadotherwisehe'llbespoilingmorelivesinfuture(wehavelearntthisnowthatdeath
torapeguiltyisamust).
Talkingaboutmolestation,thereisoneandonlyoneway,"toteachyousonswhiletheyaregrowing".
ChangeTHEIRminds,notlaws.
ReplyLike
74FollowPostEditedYesterdayat8:25pm
GandharvMohan
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
Verywellsaidmate!
ReplyLike
423hoursago
RiteshThakurArmySchool
GandharvMohanthanksbrother.
ReplyLike
522hoursago
GurpreetSinghMultani
FollowSalesforce.com,inc.
Agreewithyoubro.Harsherpunishmentsisakneejerkreactionanditisnotalongtermsolution.
TheONLYlongterm(andpainfullyslow)solutionischangeinmindsetofIndians.Everyfamily
needstoteachitssonstorespectwomenandseethemasindividualsratherthanobjectstobe
usedfortheirownpleasure.ThisishowithashappenedintheWestandthisishowit'llhaveto
happenheretoo.
MostEuropeancountriesdonothavedeathpenaltybuttheystillhaveverylowcrimerate.
ReplyLike
220hoursago
View10more
MayankVedAryal
Follow
Well....allmen....howmanymendoyouknow....ItakestandsIhavedonethat....whonoticedorfollowed....
insteadIwasbeatenbypublicforbeingthehero....andthegirlintroublemovedbacksaying...Idintaskhimto
beatthatguy....somissshehnaazIamnotjustifiedbyyouaddressingallmen....andthismorningonlyIwas
travelingandtherewasthiswomenwhowasrubbingherreartomyarmscontinuouslyuntilIgotupandsaid
mamdoyouhaveanyproblem......whatdoyoucallthismenbeinggropedbyawomeninabus....itsjust
individualchangeswillleadustochangesotherwise...staywhereweare...noonhearsno.one....
ReplyLike
16FollowPost23hoursago
GandharvMohan
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
Everyparentsasktheirdaughterstobesafe,nottowearthattypeofclothes,nottogoaloneetc.
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
4/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
Everyparentsasktheirdaughterstobesafe,nottowearthattypeofclothes,nottogoaloneetc.
Why?
Becausetheydonotasktheirsonstorespectothergirls.Parentsneverasktheirboysnottostareatagirlwho
issomeone'sdaughter/sister.
Doesallconditionsappliestogirlsonly?Boysdonothavemoralvalues?Boysdonotneedgoodparenting,
boysdonotneedtobetaughtwhattodoornot?
Iaskyougirls,doyourparentstreatyourbrotherssameastheytreatyou?
Answerisabig"NO".
Andwhenparentsstarttodoit,Ihopenotonlythistypeofcrimeswilldecreasebutgirlswillhaveahealthy
surroundingtolivetheirlifebeingtreatedashumansnotplaythings.
ReplyLike
8FollowPostEdited23hoursago
RizulDewanWorksatStudent
Yobrothyhvetherighttowearanythingoanywearitsuhwhosegonnachangeuaselfndonttouch
thewomenuntillunlesssheallowsuh...
ReplyLike
715hoursago
MohammadYaqoobDirectoratJammu&Kashmir
Asamatteroffact,itisalwaysMaledominatedsocietywithEgo&itisjustlotistalked&promised
esp.inourpoliticaladminstrativesetuppurelyforpoliticalgainsinsupportofourfemalegender
.OtherwiseentirenationalsetupshouldACT&ensureTheirSAFETY&DIGNITYwithoutanylacuna
,delayorexcuse.
ReplyLike
110hoursago
RuchiAroraWorksatGECapitalInternationalServices(GECIS)
Lifeofeverygirlislikethis....whatwebear,wearetoldnottotell....ordiscuss....Thepain,fearandanguish
staysbutnochangetakesplace.It'sawayboysareraised.Theyareallowedtoteasegirls,partyat
night....becausetheyaresafenotknowingtheiractswithothergirls.Somanywomansay"it'sokayformen"but
:why?Youhavewrittenthisletterveryboldly.Howmanyofuscanevenconfess???ButItrulywantachange
forallgirls...Formyfriendsanddaughters.
ReplyLike
6FollowPostYesterdayat4:44pm
JacobEmmanuelMKamladeviGaurduttMittalCollege
Ucan'tremainsilentbectheboyisastrongergeneIbeingmansaythat,relationoranymatterwith
forceisrobbery,andnolawgivesafreewaytorobber.
ReplyLike
GandharvMohan
112hoursago
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
Salutetoyousisterforstandingforacause(y).
AlsoIfeelsorryforyouandyoursister,friendwhogotwhattheydidnotdeserved:(
Itsashameforallmenwhodoitorwatchitdone.
Problemiseveryonewanttograbagirlwhoisnothissister,motherordaughter.Allelsearejustathingto
satisfytheirlust.
IMOtheyarenotrealmen.Theyareworstthandogsandtheyonlydeserveaslowdeath.
ReplyLike
4FollowPost23hoursago
UpasanaMathur
Pleasesir,don'tinsultdogsbysayingthat
ReplyLike
1522hoursago
GandharvMohan
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
UpasanaMathur^^
ReplyLike
122hoursago
JacobEmmanuelMKamladeviGaurduttMittalCollege
Iwouldsayamputethemwhichmakesthemtobesaidasmen
ReplyLike
112hoursago
SumitaChatterjeePatna,India
Breakthespinalcordofsexualoffenders,letthemexperiencethehellandbecomeanexampleforotherswho
areagainstwomen'sdignity.
ReplyLike
4FollowPostYesterdayat4:53pm
JayPrakash TopCommenterWorksatSelfEmployed
Yes!Shootthemalldown,wedontneedthemalepopulation....right.
ReplyLike
KyrieTirzahMedlyn
211hoursago
FollowSr.CustomerserviceprofessionalatAmericanExpress
DeathshouldbethereactiontotheirAction!
ReplyLike
KapilDev
4FollowPostYesterdayat5:55pm
FollowSeniorPartneratKDAggarwal&Associates
IrememberyearsagowhenmydivorcecasewasgoingonandIhadtakenadrinktoomany.myfriendswould
alwaysmakeitsuretodropmepersonallyathome.andoncewhenIwasgoingtosimlainmycarandhad
takenafewdrinkstoomanythepubowneraskedifIneededadriver.Isaidnobutheinsistedandsenda
drivertodropmeatmyhotel.girlsmaybefoolishbutthepubownerandfriendsshouldhavemadesurethat
girlwhowasunabletostandonherlegsissafelyhome.otherwisewhyevenlockhomesandhaveIPCifthere
arenobadpeoplearound.weshouldeducatepeoplenottosteal.askingustolockourhomesorvehiclesis
infringementofourfreedom.
ReplyLike
3FollowPost23hoursago
RabindraBasuSIESCollegeofManagementStudies
HopethisletterreachesNAMOandsuchabilloramendmentorlegislationispassednfasttrackcourtsareset
up.
ReplyLike
3FollowPostYesterdayat4:40pm
HarshaliSatveMumbai,Maharashtra,India
Aboldsteptakenbyaresponsiblecitizen,butawomen1st.......Andnowtheresponsibilitylieswithallthe
biggiesshehasaddressedto,notassuperstarsorinfluentialpeoplebutasresponsiblecitizens!
Stardomandpoweristhemeanstoaccomplishthisverymuchrequiredtaskorinamoreresponsiblewayof
sayingit.....ADUTY!tobecarriedonbythefathers,brothersandhusbandsoutthere!
ReplyLike
2FollowPostYesterdayat3:52pm
JayPrakash TopCommenterWorksatSelfEmployed
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
5/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
JayPrakash TopCommenterWorksatSelfEmployed
Amongst100molestationcases10aresimilartorohtakcase.whenithasbeenproveduwilllight
candlesforthoseinnocent?
ReplyLike
415hoursago
View58more
Facebooksocialplugin
46Comments
IndiaOpines
Login
Share Favorite
SortbyNewest
Jointhediscussion
ArunNair 6hoursago
Ifprovedbeyonddoubt,therapistshouldbecastrated.Ifthereisnolawthenamendthe
lawsofthelandtoprotectourwomen.Molestersshouldbeimprisonedforlife.Ifthe
judiciaryisnotwillingtotakeaction,leaveittothepublictotakeaction.Afterall,ifthelaw
makerscannottakecareofus,wehavetotakecareofourselves.
Reply Share
vicks 6hoursago
Shenaz,thanxforthisheartrenderingletter,allmylifeIhvvotedfrthecongress,butthis
timeIhdvotedfrmodinthepromiseshemade,oftheotherg8peopleumentionIhvhigh
regardnthyaremyrolemodels,Iseriouslyhopewhtthypromissedoruaskthydeleiver,as
afatherof2growingupgirlsmyworstinternalfeariswhtunmanyothershvfaced,plsmr
primeministerdntletusdown.
1
Reply Share
Nz 6hoursago
Itisnotthelackoflawsthatactuallypromotescorruptionbutthelackofwillingnessto
implementthem.Makingmorelawswouldonlyhelpinfalsifyingthecrimes.
Dearwomen,ratherthanwhiningonmen,
makesureureproduceonlygoodmen,
andifyouarenotsureyoucanbringthemupgood,
thendontreproduceatall.
Reply Share
Deeps 6hoursago
Amputationistheonlyprevention!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!thesemonsterscanneverchange......
Reply Share
Deeps 6hoursago
Amputationistheonlyprevention!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!thesemonsterscanchange......
1
Reply Share
Tarun 6hoursago
Ms.Treasury,miserably,failedtonoticethatMANYcases.....whererapecasesare
falsified......whathappenstothem?IamnotagainstdeathpenaltyBUThowaboutlotof
existinglawsbeingmisusedbywomen?e.g.Dowrylaws?Soifawomenlawis
misused.....whoisculprit?womenthemselves?
BUT,nowayimeantosaythatthereshouldnotbeadeathpenaltyforrapist.Butithasto
betakenjudiciously.....notforeachandeverycases.Inthiscase,itwassortofclearthat
driverwasresponsible,sohanghim.........
Meanwhile,tillthelawisnotsostringent.......girls.....becautious.Gosafe.!!!
Reply Share
plaboni 6hoursago
ForallthosemenwhotakeastandagainstwhatSahanazhaswrittenIhaveaquestionfor
you.Whatisyouraccountabilityinprotectingthewomenofourcountry?
Ifashiftinyourthinkingdoesn'ttakeplacethenIndia
isdoomed.
Rapemustbeanonbailableoffence.Exampleshavetobesetsothattheseguysdonot
roamthestreetsfreely.Rapeissocialandemotionalterrorism.
Reply Share
Nz>plaboni 6hoursago
Itisnotlackoflaws,butlackofwillingnesstoimplementthem.
Reply Share
Pallav>plaboni 6hoursago
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
6/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
Pallav>plaboni 6hoursago
Seethevideoofwhatshouldalsobeanonbailableoffence.Whatisyour
accountabilityinprotectingthemenofourcountry?
ThestandisnotagainstwhatSahanazhaswritten.Itsagainstthecollateraldamage
thatitwillentail.
Reply Share
raddhaa 6hoursago
Whatkindofanimalsarethesemen?Dotheynotrealizethattheytoohavetheirown
motherandsisters.Unlessstrictlawsarenottakenagainsttheseterriblementheywill
continuebeingevil.Whyarestrictactionnottakenagainstthemandwhyisthegovernment
notdoinganythingaboutthis?
Reply Share
PallavSaxena>raddhaa 6hoursago
...andwhatkindofanimalarethosewomenwhowouldmisutilizetheselawstoget
theirway?Justlikethosewholedtomisutilizationofantidowrylaw?Thesemen
don'tonlyhavemothersandsisterstheyhavefathers&brothersandsonstoo.Lets
notportraywomendroppingfromheavenandmenfromhell.Lawsneedstobe
draftedonbalanceandtoensurethatnoinnocentispunished.Iamnotagainst
strictactions,Iamsimplyagainststupidsuggestions!
Whyputtingitonthesemen?Whatwerethewomendoingwhentheywereinpower
positions?WhynotwriteittoSoniaforlast10years?
1
Reply Share
PallavSaxena 7hoursago
IndiacameupwithlawtocurbDowry.Astrictoneleadingtoimprisonmentonreporting
alongwithwholefamily.NowSupremeCourthasadvisedagainstitasitwasbeingmis
utilizedbywomenfortheiradvantage.Howwouldthosemencomeoutofsickfeelingof
whattheywentthrough?Thementalagony&pain?Askingforpunishingforgroperscan
againbemisutilizedbywomenlookingforbenefits.Makingsuchstatementswithout
thinkingofwhatitentailsandwhatwouldbetherepercussionsisjustnotgoingtocreate
solution.Itsjustnoise.Therearealreadycaseswherewomenaretakingadvantagesandnot
allofthemarereportedjustlikenotalltherapesarereported.Notallmendeservethe
backlashofwhatafewdid.
IamafatherofagirlandyesIamafraidforwhatwouldhappentoher.IfIhadason,I
wouldhavetaughthimtorespectwomen.ButYes,Iwouldhavebeenafraidforhimtoofor
whatsomegirlcoulddobymisutilizingthelaworpublicsympathywhichwouldnevergo
hiswayirrespectiveofhisdeeds.
Reply Share
anonymous 7hoursago
Deathtorapists.Nobail.Justdeath.
MakeanExampleOfHim.
Anymanwhoeventouchesawomanshouldbeimprisonedforlife.
Bestrict,makeexamplesofthesemen,scarethosewhodaretotouchus.
SCARETHEMBYMAKINGANEXAMPLEOUTOFTHEM.
SAVEUS,Saveyourmother,daughter,sisterplease!
ThisisNOTOURSHAME.
THISISYOURS.
SHAMEONYOU.
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
7/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
DontsleeptillyouSAVEYOURWOMEN!
Whilereadingthis,icouldeasilyrelateitnotjustwithmebutalsoeverywomaniknownear
anddearone's.
ReallyhatsofftoyouShenaz..youareawesome:)
Reply Share
Deeps>anonymous 6hoursago
Shameonuguystowritelikethisforherrecommendations.....thisonlyshowsthe
illiterateandrottenIndianmentality!!!thisisthetruthanducanfeelitonylyifyour
sisterwouldhavebeenopenaboutherencounters.
Reply Share
Deeps>Deeps 6hoursago
MyreplyisforNaveenSharmaandkoko!!!!!ihopeiwasquiteclearand
audible....
Reply Share
NavinSharma 9hoursago
Againapublicitystuntbyastrugglingactressintheindustry.Whatcouldweexpectfrom
thesekindapeoplewhotakeseveryissuestocomeatthelimelightsopeoplecouldgetto
knowthatyestherewasapersonwhousedtobethepartofindustryandnowtheyareout
ofwork.Imeanwhothehellisshetoblamethesepersonalities.Sheisjustpretendingtobe
nestRakhisavant.
Reply Share
lamesharma>NavinSharma 6hoursago
LameSharma,sheisnotblamingthem.....nurcommentinghere,,,,y?Toprovethtu
existonplanetearth
3
Reply Share
mukta>NavinSharma 6hoursago
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
anditsnextnotnest..Lame
Ihavemoretosay....LAMEcontinued
1
Reply Share
NavinSharma 9hoursago
Againapublicitystuntbyastrugglingactressintheindustry.Whatcouldweexpectfrom
thesekindapeoplewhotakeseveryissuestocomeatthelimelightsopeoplecouldgetto
knowthatyestherewasapersonwhousedtobethepartofindustryandnowtheyareout
ofwork.Imeanwhothehellisshetoblamethesepersonalities.Sheisjustpretendingtobe
nestRakhisavant.
Reply Share
venkat 12hoursago
Completelyagree...thereshouldbeamedicaltest...liedetectortest....Onboththeculprit
andthevictim.....immediatepunishmenttobegiveniffoundguilty......nobail......theculprit
shouldbehanged.....
1
Reply Share
koko 16hoursago
Utalkonchannelswithsomuchofenergy..Useittokickoffendersaswell..don'tdepend
onanybody...
Reply Share
shaan>koko 5hoursago
killalloftheminfrontofpublic
Reply Share
SK 17hoursago
Hatsofftoyoushenaz...allthesemenshouldbehangedtilldeath.
4
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel adayago
ThisisthemostidioticletterIhaveread..Thisladysaidnorthingnew.Problemisnotwith
thesystembutitswithupbringing..Nmisseverymanonearthisnotsameihopeyougot
this.APMorsomefewpeoplecannotgotoall65millionmensincountryandaskthemto
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
8/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
this.APMorsomefewpeoplecannotgotoall65millionmensincountryandaskthemto
behave!Ihopeyouhavebraintogetthisthinginmind.Andourtargetshouldbehowto
stoprapefirstlyandthereshouldbeminimumcasesofrape.Thecountryyouaretalking
aboutUSAifseenin%wiserapearemuchmorewhencomparedtoanyothercountry.
AgainIamsayingitsallproblemwithupbringing.Ifthisthingisgoodthentheywillnot
becomecriminalbutnationbuilders.Sostopaccusingallmenoutthereandthiswillonly
makethegoodonesfeelshamenotthebadones.
5
Reply Share
prabiii>BhaveshPatel 13hoursago
Youmustdefinitelybeoneofthosewhogropeduswomen.Beashamedofyourself!
2
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>prabiii 11hoursago
Thisiswhatyourupbringingtoabuseanyoneandforyourkindinfomation.
LikeIdon'thaveanythinglefttodoonthisearthsoIwouldstockwomen.I
havemuchbetterthingstodoandalsomuchbetterupbringing.Iwouldnot
wastemytimeongirls.
1
Reply Share
Rebecca>BhaveshPatel 17hoursago
Shutthefuckupasshole.Youmustbeoneofthosegropers.Feelingbad'causeshe
toldafuckingtruth?Well,gofuckyourself.
1
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>Rebecca 11hoursago
Thisiswhatyourparentshavetaughtyoutoabuseanyone?
Hopegodblessyou.IdidnotfeelbadoftruthIfeltbadthatjustbecause
yourmovieisgoingtobereleasedtomorrowyouwritealettertomost
influentialpeopleofcountrybutwherewereyouwhenalltoseworstkinda
thingshappendinDelhiinMumbaiinUP.
1
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 21hoursago
TheFatherofournationandtheworldrenownedMahatmaGandhisaid:
Threequartersofthemiseriesandmisunderstandingsintheworldwouldfinishif
peopleweretoputontheshoesoftheiradversariesandunderstoodtheirpointsof
view.
Icannotbelievehowyoucanhavethegalltocallherrecountingofherown
experienceidiotic.Howmanytimeshaveyouwalkedintheshoesofthesewomen
whohavetolivelikepreyinajungle?Youaresoclueless.Letsjusthopeforyoursake
thatyouneverhavetofeellikeprey.
3
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 11hoursago
IdidnotsupportedthatmolestersbutwhatIsaidwasthelawisalready
there.Ifwewouldstartgivingdeathpenaltytoeveryonethensomepeople
fromyourhighsocietywillcallitImmoralprosecutionandwillcallfor
humanrights.Ihopeyouknowthereality.WhatIsaidwaswhycan'twe
teachourchildrenjustastheygrowup.Thisiscalledpreventionisintitbetter
thencrime?
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 11hoursago
Ifyouwouldstartbynotinsultingsomeonemaybesomebodymight
havethepatiencetoreadwhatyouhavetosay.Itdoesn'thelpany
conversationforonesidetostartcallingtheothersideidiotic.
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 9hoursago
CanyoupleasetellwhenIsaidthatthewomeniswrong?Iquestioned
thewaytoputthematter.Ididnotquestionedthetopicandalsonot
herpain.IguessIdidn'tknowhowitfeelsbutIknowitwouldbe
worstofonecanfeel.ButIdontthinkbysayingsomepeople"shame
onyou"woulddoeverything.Lawsaretherebutwhatitwilldoifcase
arenotbeingreported(inmanycases).
1
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 8hoursago
Womenarebroughtuptofeelshamewhentheyareviolatedandyou
callheridioticwithyourfirststatement.
Thenyouaresayingtoher"Ihopeyouhavebraintogetthisthingin
mind"whotalkslikethattoanotherpersoninreallife?
"Sostopaccusingallmenoutthere"doyouevenunderstandwhat
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
9/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
"Sostopaccusingallmenoutthere"doyouevenunderstandwhat
sheisaccusingall"thegoodmen"outthereabout?Sheisaccusing
themofstandingidlybywhilewomenandgirlsareviolateddaily,
probablyhourlyinthecountry.Surelyyouwouldagreethatweshould
feelsomeshamethatsomanywomenandgirlsmaybegetting
violatedbysleazymeninthelandyouaresoproudof.
Nobodyisaccusingyouofbeingsleazy,norissheaskingyoutofight
forherhonorbutatleastdon'ttrashherheartrendingtale.Sheis
boldtofightstereotypesandallyoucanthinkofishowshemight
causegoodmentofeelshame.
1
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 7hoursago
ThatiswhatIwastryingtosaythatfromthestartingitsupbringingof
kidsnotboys.AboyshouldbetaughttogiverespecttoEVERYONE
notonlyparticulartoopp.Sexandalsotogirlstospeakandbegiven
everythingthataboyis.ButcanyoupleasetellmeonethingIamnot
questioningherpainbutIamworriedaboutthetimingtodayher
moviereleasedandIfthisiswayofpublicitythatmostcheapestwayto
doso.Icansayyouonethingthatmyparentsandeldershavealways
taughtmetonottoanyonebeingsuppressedormolested.Andnot
mealmostmywholefamilyandrelativesfollowthis.
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 21hoursago
ThecountriesyoucompareIndiatoatleastattempttoprovideprotectiontotheir
women.
WhatprotectiondoyouclaimIndiaprovidestoourwomenandgirlswhenitlets
rapistsoutonbailtoroamfreeandrapeastheyplease?
2
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 11hoursago
Yehtheyaretryingtobutisthathelping?NoIguessthenumberdoesnotsay
it.YehIknowthereisnotanyprotection.Soforthisyouthinkgovernment
willputapolicemanforeverywomen?Wouldthisbelogic!
Insteadofwritingletterstopeopleoneveofyourmoviereleaseyoushouldgo
tosocietyandaskpeopletoteachtheirchildwhichwillhelpmost.
Reply Share
KapilDev adayago
IrememberyearsagowhenmydivorcecasewasgoingonandIhadtakena
drinktoomany.myfriendswouldalwaysmakeitsuretodropme
personallyathome.andoncewhenIwasgoingtosimlainmycarandhad
takenafewdrinkstoomanythepubowneraskedifIneededadriver.I
saidnobutheinsistedandsendadrivertodropmeatmyhotel.girls
maybefoolishbutthepubownerandfriendsshouldhavemadesurethat
girlwhowasunabletostandonherlegsissafelyhome.otherwisewhy
evenlockhomesandhaveIPCiftherearenobadpeoplearound.we
shouldeducatepeoplenottosteal.askingustolockourhomesor
vehiclesisinfringementofourfreedom.
Reply Share
shilpa adayago
Itsoootrueeeitssrealityywomenfacethisnjstcryhelplesslyybuttnowweshouldtakeestep
forourselfinstedofcryinggweshouldstronglyyfaceethem....nooneecanhelpifweourself
notputsteppforwardd...
Reply Share
MeghanaApte adayago
Notimpressed.ThoughitisatruthShenazTreasurywala,youaretroubledbysomeother
peopleandyouareholdingwrongpersonsresponsibleforcontrollingit.
Youmustbeaware,thatthisisnotthefirstyearofsuchincidences,thenwhydidyounot
say,"Shameonyou"forallthepreviousgovernmentswhoseapathybroughtdownthe
moralityofIndians?Theearliergovernmentneverallowedamendmentsinthelawsjust
becauseitwillhurtcertaincastes.Aretheynottobemoreshamefultobringourcountryto
thisstage?
WhyareyounottalkinganythingabouttheillfamousIndiannewsmedia,whoactually
earn,outofsuchincidences?Themedialikesandyesenjoysthedetailingoftherapeand
harassmenttowardswomensogaudilythatinsteadoffeelingguilty,themenbecome
curiousabouttheact.
Infactyougotcouragetowritethisopenlynowbecauseyounowfeelthatyessome
changeispossible.SoitisthefaithinModiandthelikesyouhavementioned,causingyou
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
10/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
changeispossible.SoitisthefaithinModiandthelikesyouhavementioned,causingyou
toexpectsomethinggoodtohappen.
2
Reply Share
StupidMeghanaApte>MeghanaApte adayago
Areyounuts?Doyouevengetthemeaningofherletter?Theletterisnottothegovt,
youmyopic.....itisforalltheinfluentialmeninIndiawhoarelookeduponthe
KhansofBollywood,theBigB,thegodofcricketSachin,thecorporategiantand
socialactivistAmbani,......Don'tpoliticizethings....Stupid!
11
Reply Share
StupidMeghanaApte>StupidMeghanaApte adayago
Andofcourse,thePMModi
Reply Share
chiragshah>MeghanaApte adayago
.......................Whenapersondoesn'tspeakwewillcomplainabouttheirobedience
andfear....Whenapersonspeaks,wewillaskthem,"Whydidn'tyoudoit
earlier?"....Peoplehavethistendencytoalwayscriticizeinsteadoflookingatthings
asastepintherightdirection.YoubasicallyreflectthetypicalIndianmentalityand
it'spathetic.Also,sheisspeakingonaparticulartopicsowhywouldshebringthe
mediaintothisletter?Whywouldshesay"Shameonyou"tothegovernmentwhen
she'stalkingabouttheoverallenvironmentandmentalityofsociety?Whyshouldshe
unnecessarilyconvolutetheentireletterwhenit'sbettertostayfocusedonactual
pointthatsheismaking........Youareonepatheticandsadindividual...Seriously.
Peoplelikeyouareholdingthiscountrydown.
2
Reply Share
anonymous adayago
whenyoureadthecommentsgivenonthisarticle,yourealisewhyourcountryisinthis
state.allthemenhaveattheendofithavesaiditisthewomen'sfault.Andwewonderwhy
thingsaren'tchanging....
3
Reply Share
AnonymousIndian>anonymous adayago
DontKillthePersonresponsibleforit.Killthediseasesocalledthemindsetand
attitudesofthepeoplewhocommittosuchacts.killingarapistdoesnotmakesure
thecountryissafer,therearemostcasesofincestrapeswhichdonotcometo
limelightduetofamilyhonouryetthevictimbecomesmentallyunstable...............
itsbetterwenwecomeupwiththeIDEAtochangepeopleandrealisethepreyed
womenissomeoneelsesister,mother,orbetterhalf......................justhinkwether
heisahumanoramundanebeast.....................
Reply Share
me>anonymous adayago
True
Reply Share
Oneofu>me adayago
Iagree...Killthecausenottheperson...Bloodythecauseishangingwiththe
man..Chopoffhispartandlethimlive.
Itstimewhenpeopleshouldunderstandwhatrespecteveryindividual
deserves.Yiseveryonearguingwitheachother.Bettertakeapledgetohelp
andsupportotherpeople.Thisletteris.Surelyanoutburstofagirlsemotion..
Everygirldreamsofcarryingagunandkillingsuchpeopleonspot.Thatis
thefearmenhaveimplantedinwomen.Hightimepeopleworkontheir
mentalityandbecomemorehuman.
Subscribe
Reply Share
AddDisqustoyoursite
Privacy
INDIA OPINES
India Opines 2014
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
11/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
12/12