Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mil STD 401B PDF
Mil STD 401B PDF
com
MI L-STD-401B
26 September
1967
SUPERSEDIN G
MI L-STD-401A
15 JUNE
1956
MILITARY
SANDWICH
STANDARD
CONSTRUCTIONS
MIL-STD-401B
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE
Waahlngton, D. C. 20301
Sandwich Constructions
MIL-STD-401B
and Agencies
2. Recommended corrections,
additions, or deletions should be addressed to the
Commander, Navai Air Systems Command, (Code 52021), Waehiogtoq
D. C. 20360.
ii
..
MIL-STD-401B
CONTENTS
@
Paregraph
1.
1.1
2.
3.
3.1
3.1.1
3.1.2
3.1.3
3.1.4
3.1.5
3.1.6
3.1.7
3.1.7.1
3.1.7.2
4.
4.1
4.1.1
4.1.2
4.1.2.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
5.
5.1
5.1.1
5.1.2
5.1.3
5.1.4
5.1.5
5.1.6
5.1.7
5.1.8
5.2
5.2.1
5.2.2
5.2.3
5.2.4
5.2.5
5.2.6
5.3
5.4
SCOPE
Scope
REFERENCED DOCUMENTS
DEFINITIONS
General
Sandwich
Core
Facing
Flstwise
Edgewise
Isotropic
Orthotropic
Orthotropic facing directions
Orthotropic core directions
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Selection of test samples
Design data
Quaiity assurance provisions
Sampling for the various inspections,
examinations aad tests
Test conditions
Test apparatus
Report of test results
Designation of units of measurement
DETAIL TEST METHODS
Core Test Methods
Core Density and Specific Gravity
Core Moisture Sorption
Core Thermai Conductivity
Core Compression
Core Shear
Core Tension
Core Water Migration
Core Delamination of Honeycomb Core
Sandwich test methods
Sandwich Compression
Sandwich Shear
sandwich Tension
Sandwich Flexure
Sandwich Thermal Conductivity
Sandwich Peel
Fatigue Tests
Creep Characteristics
iii
Page
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
4
5
5
8
6
6
6
7
7
9
12
12
13
14
14
15
15
16
19
19
22
22
MIL-STD-401B
FIGURES
Figure 1.
2.
Page
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
iv
MIL-STD-401B
1.
SCOPE
-.
This standard covers the general requirements and
1.1
methods for testing sandwich core materials and for testing sandwich construction
of the types used primarily in aircraft structures.
This standard does nnt include
test methods applicable only to a specific product; such test methnds are included
in the detailed specifications
for the product.
2.
REFERENCED
2.1
tations forbids
DOCUMENTS ~/
invi-
I
I
I
MIL-STD-105
Sempling Procedures
and Tsbles
Inspection by Attributes.
for
(Copies of standards required by suppliers in connection with specific procurement functions should be obtained from the procuring activity or as directed by
the contracting officer.)
2.2
Other publications. l_/ The folloviing documents form apart of
Unless otherwise indicated. the issue
this stsndard to the extent specified herein.
in effect on date of invitation for bids or request for proposal shell apply.
American
I
I
1
I
ASTM C 177
ASTM C 236
ASTM C 271
ASTM C 272
MIL-STD-401B
Anerican
(Continued)
ASTM C 273
ASTM C 297
ASTM C 363
ASTM C 364
ASTM C 365
ASTM C 393
ASTM C 394
&STM D 1761
DEFINITIONS
General.
The following terms are used throughout this standard
3.1
and their interpretation shall be eonstrued in accordance with the following defiottione.
Sandwich. A laminar construction, consisting of thin facings bonded to a rel3.1.1
atively thfck lightweight core, res@ting in a rigid and lightweight panel. In this standard, bonded
means jofned by welding, brazing or adhesive.
Core.
A lightweight natural, synthetic, or fabricated material
3.1.2
bonded between the facings of sandwich construction in order to separate the facings and
to supper+ them against &ckling under stress.
3.1.3
of a sandwich.
F-.
One of the two outer layers which have been bonded to the core
MIL-STD-401B
Edgewise.
Describes the supplication of forces
3.1.5
parallel and actually in the plane of a sheet of ssndwfch.
in directions
Isotropic.
Describes
3.1.6
the ssme properties in SU directions.
or cores,
3.1.7
having different
materisl,
either facings
having
Orthotropic.
Describes material, either facings or cores,
strength end elastic properties in different directions.
W!
L direction
direction
Parallel
to grain
Tangential to shnusl
growth rings
Honeycomb
Parsllel
flutes
to core
Parallel to core
ribbons
Perpendicular
ribbons
Cellular
ParsJlel to slab
or core thickness
ParsJlel to direction
of foaming
Perpendicular to
direction of foaming
Plastic
These directions
4.
are ftiher
of Figore
to core
1.
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
MIL-STD-401B
Quali@
assurance
provisions.
4.1.2.1
Ssmuling for the various inspections,
examinations and tests.
Where the inspection lot consists of a number of supposedly identical items, the
previsions of MIL-STD-105 apply and should be referenced.
The inspection level and
Acceptable Quality Level (AQL) to he used will depend upon the expense and importance
of the tests involved.
If the inspection lot is of such a nature that MIL-STD-105
should not be used, then
not less than five, (5) specimens of a given type shall be tested for lot acceptance,
with a clew statement of what shall constitute acceptance or rejection of the lot.
When @mpriate,
variables
Test conditions.
The conditions of test depend on the purpese of
4.2
the particular tests under consideration and should be stipulated in the procurement
Specifictilon for the material.
Normal or rnnm temperature tests shall be conducted
at 73 *2 F (23 +1 C) and 50 *4 percent relative humidity.
If the physical properties
of the materials being teeted are affected by moisture, the test specimens shall be
brought to constant weight before testing, preferably in a conditioning chamber with
The tests shall preferably be made in a room
temperature aad hmnidity control.
under the same conditions.
This would provide specimens having a uniform moisture
content, and changes in moisture content would not occur during test.
Test SPparatus.
4.3
Apparatus for performing specific tests je descrtbed
in the detailed test method and special apparatus for certain materials is described
General requirements presented here
in procurement specifications for the,materi~.
Measuring
equipment for. determining specimen
shall be met by apparatus for any tests.
dimensions ,and wei@s
shall not be in error by more thn *1/2 percent. The testing maehine
4,
MIL-STD-401B
on the previoue
conditioning
of test specimens
end
The report shall include a description of the testing machine and testing apparatus
used to measure deformations or deflections.
The report shall include a brief description of testing procedures
and shsfl give
detailed descriptions and discussion
of procedures which differ from those prescribed in this Standard.
Test results shall be presented in concise form including tables of dst~ diagrams
end graphs, where necessary,
end descriptions of test failures, including photogrsphe, if neceseary.
*
MIL-STD-401B
5.
5.1.1
Gravity.
5.1.1.1
=.
The method describes
the apparent density and specific gravity of cores
5.1.1.2
Test specimens.
The test specimens may be any convenient size
or shape of core material that can be accurately measured.
The number of test
specimens shall be determined in accordance with 4.1.
The test conditions shafl conform to 4.2.
accuracy
percent.
Test precedure.
The test specimens shell be weighed to an
5.1.1.3
of *O. 5 percent and the dimensions measured within an accuracy of *O. 5
Calculations.
The following
5.1.1.4
the core density in pounds per cubic foot:
Density
(lb/ft3)
Specific
5.1.2
=m
= 1728%
= 3.81 ~
= 62.4 ~
Vol (fts )
vol (in. )
vol (in. 3 )
vol (cm3 )
Apparent Specific
5.1.1.5
the test report
foot.
formuias
Gravity = ens~~
as follows:
.
lb/ft 3
~
Report.
In addition to the genersl report requirements of 4.4,
shall give the individual and average core deneity in pounds per cubic
Core Moisture
(ASTM C 272)
Sorption.
-.
This method describes a teat procedure
5.1.2.1
the sorption of water by core materials when immersed.
for determining
Test specimen.
The test specimen shall, be 3 inches square and
5.1.2.2
The thickness of the specimen sIMJI
1/2 inch thick (75 mm by 75 mm by 12 mm).
be in the same direction as the core thickness when used in sandwich construction.
The
test specimens shall be machined, sawed, or sheared from the core samples so as to
have smooth surfaces which are free from cracks.
The number of test specimens shaU
be determined in accordance with 4.1.
Specimens shall be conditioned in accordance with
4.2.
MIL-STD-401B
Test procedure.
The conditioned specimens shall be weighed
5.1.2.3
to an sccuracy of fO. 5 percent, and then completely immersed to a depth of 1 to 2
inches (25 to 50 mm) in distilled water, maintained at a temperature of 73 *2 F
(23 *1 C). Specimeae which float shall be held under water by a loose net or screen,
weighted just enough to submerge the specimens.
The specimens shsfl be removed
from the water and weighed after increasing periods of immersion so as to determine
Upon removel of specimens from
the moisture sorption - time curve for 60 days.
the water, one at a time, sll surface water shall be wiped off with a dry cloth aad
For cores that tend to trap water in surface
the specimen weighed immediately.
poree or core cells, the specimen should be dipped in absolute alcohol, dried quickly
in a gentle current of warm air, snd weighed immediately.
If a core material is
known or suspected to contain any appreciable amounts of wster-soluble
ingredients,
the epecimens of this core shall be reconditioned at 50 *4 percent relative humidity
st 73 +2 F (23 +1 C) to obtain the amount of dissolved material,
ss determined
by difference in weight of originally conditioned and reconditioned specimens.
Report.
In addition tothe general
5.1.2.4
the test report shall include:
(a)
report requirements
es a graph of percent
5.1.3
5.1.4
of 4.4,
water
as per-
5.1.4.1
x.
This method of test describes a procedure for determining
compressive
properties of sandwich cores and esndwich constructions.
Deformation
data can be obtained; S@ from a complete load-deformation
curve, it is possible
to compute the compressive
stress at proportional limit load, ultimate compressive
strength, and modulue of ele@ici@
of the core.
Core properties are usually required, for design purposes, in a direction nnrmaf to
the plaoe of facinge as the core would be plsced in a sandwich constructio~
and the
test procedure pertains to compression
in this direction in particular,
but also can
be applied to determining compression
properties in other directions.
5.1.4.2
Test specimens.
Flstwise
7
compression
specimens
shsll be of
MIL-STD-401B
core or of sandwich and shall have a minimum 2- by 2-inch %- bv 5-cm) cross section.
The
height of the specimens shall be not greater than 8 inchss (20 cm) nor less tnan 1/2
inch (12 mm). Edgewise compression
specimens of core (not sandwich) shall be at
least 2 inches by 3/8 inch (5- by l-cm) in cross section and shall be not greater in
height than 4 times the smallest cross-sectional
dimension.
The dimensions of the
specimens shall be measured to an accuracy of at least O. 5 percent.
The number of
specimens shall be determined in accordance with 4.1.
The specimens shall be conditioned in accordance with requirements of 4.2.
*
5.1.4.3
Specimen preparation.
Care shall be taken to prepare the test
specimens so that the loaded ends will be parallel to each other and perpendicular
to the sides of the specimen.
In order to avoid local crushing at the ends of some
cores in flatwise compression,
particularly honeycomb aud gridded cores, it is
desirable to reiuforce the ends with a suitable material.
The ends may be cast in a
molding material, such as plaster of Paris or cast resin, or they may be dipped in a
thin layer, of resin (epoxy resin has been found to be satisfactory)
and cured at room
temperature or slightly elevated temperature.
The resin-dipping procedure results
in leaving openings at the ends of the cells of the specimen, thus allowing circulation
of exposure media if such exposures are to be made. It has been found that a resin
dip, as shallow as 1/16 inch (2 mm), will provide adequate support for many types of
cores so as to prevent localized end failures.
5.1.4.4
Test procedure.
The load shall be applied to the specimen through
a spherical loading block, preferably of the suspended, self-aligning
type. Care shall
be taken so that the block shall apply load as uniformly as possible over the entire
The load shall be applied at a constant rate of moveloading surface of the specimen.
ment of the movable head of the testing machine (Note 1) and at such a rate that the
maximum load (Note 2) will occur between 3 and 6 minutes.
Note 1:
A suggested
per minute.
is O. 3 percent
of core height,
Note 2:
Data for stress- strain curves may be taken. For determining strains, deformations
shall be measured to at least the nearest O. 0001 inch (O. 002 mm) by means of a compressometer,
having a gage length not exceeding 2/3 of the height of the specimen.
The
compressometer
shall measure average deformations (measurements
can be taken on
two opposite sides of the specimen and averaged) over the central portion of the height
8
I
I
MIL-STD-401B
of the epecimeo.
The compressometer
shall he light in weight, require a minimum
force to operate, and shall be attached in such a way that it will not damage or stiffen
the specimen, thus preducing incorrect results.
Increments in load should be
chosen so that at le&at 12 readhgs of deformation are taken to proportion~
limit.
A Martens mirror-type
of strain gage, a Tuckerman strain gage, or a microformed
type, with autographic recorder,
have heen found to work satisfactorily
for most
cores.
For honeycomb cores having cells smaller than 1/2 inch (12 mm), it has
been found that properties of specimens 1/2 inch (12 mm) in height are no different
than for specimens 4 or 8 inches (10 or 20 cm) long; thus, a long specimen can be
tested using a long gage length and, in genersl, a more practical,
simpler test
will result than if short l/2-inch
(12-mm) specimens are tested.
For extremely
soft cores, it has been found necessary to measure strains with Filar microscopes,
focused on points of fine needles inserted in the core.
Bonded electric resistance
strain gages are usually not considered satisfactory for soft cores because of the
stiffness of the gage. The reinforcing effect of bonding these gages to some cores
leads to large errors in actual strain measurement.
Note:
5.1.4.5
-.
In addition to the general
the test repnrt shall include:
report
requirements
of 4.4,
(a) Description of specimen ends including details of procedures ueed to obtain these end conditions.
or load-deformation
diagrams, if deforma(b) Stress-strain
tions were measured; and these data should be analyzed
to give the core modulus of elasticity and stress at
proportional limit.
(c)
5.1.5
she=
5.1.5.1
properties
Compressive
strength values,
Core Shear.
(ASTM C 273)
w.
This method of teat describes a procedure for determining
of sandwich cores or of composite sandwich construction.
Tlie
I MIL-STD-401B
core or sandwich specimen is bonded between thick steel plates which sre displaced,
relative to each other, during testing, thus placing, the bonded specimen in shear.
Deformation data can be obtained and, from a complete load-deformation
curve, it is
possible to compute the shear stress at proportional limit load, shear strength, and
ahear modulus.
Shear properties,
usually required for design purposes, are those associated with
shear distortion of planes parallel to the edge plane of a sandwich.
This test is designed
to apply, in particular,
to core thus oriented, and then the test determines shear strength
parallel to the plane of the sandwich and shear modulus associated with diatertion in a
plane normal to sandwich facinga.
The method may be used to determine shear properties
in other directions.
Example:
5.1.5.2
Test specimens.
Shear specimens shall be of core or of sandwich
and shall preferably be 2 inches by 1/2 inch by 6 inches (50 by 12 by 150 mm) in size.
If a different size is to he tested, the widtl shall be not less than twice the thickness,
and the length shall be not less than 12 times the thickness.
The dimensions of the
specimens shall be measured to an accuracy of at leaat O. 5 percent.
The number of
specimens shall be determined in accordance with 4.1.
The test specimens shall be
conditioned as described in 4.2.
5.1.5.3
Specimen preparation.
Figure 2 showa apparatua for applying
tensile loads or compressive
loads to produce ahear in the specimen.
Care should
be tsken to prepare the test specimen so that the surfaces to be hended will be plane
and parallel to each other.
The loading plates shall be bonded to the specimen with
a fairly rigid adhesive (epoxide resin adheaive or phenol-vinyl-polymers
have been
found to be suitable for bonding the loading plates). Care shall be taken not to crush
the core when the plates are being bonded to it. The plates shall be properly positioned
on the core ao that the line of action of tbe testing force shall pass as closely as possible
through diagonally opposite corners of the specimen.
The thickness of the loading plates
may be varied with the strength of the specimen.
It haa been found that loading plates
having a stiffness not less than 600,000 pound-inches 2 per inch of width per inch of core
thickness (2. 67 MN-cm2
per cm of width per cm of core thickness) have performed
satisfactorily.
5.1.5.4
Test procedure.
The load shall be applied to the ends of the loading
plates in tension or compression,
through a universal joint or a spherical bearing block, so
as to distribute the load uniformly. across the width of the specimen and along a line extending from diagonally opposite corners of the specimen.
The load shall be armlied
throuph
..
continuous motion of the movable head of the testing machine, at a rate such that failure
will occur in not less than 3 and not more than 6 minutes.
10
MIL-STD-401B
Note:
Calculations.
Shear stresses
f~ = :b
where
f~ = shear stress
P = applied load
o = specimen length
b = specimen width
where
&
W = ~
r,
t=
specimen
(P r) curve
to the other
thickness.
11
MIL-STD-401B
Gc =
where Gc =
G =
Gf =
tc =
d =
tcG
tc
G
d [- G(--T)
5.1.5.6
-.
teet report shail include:
(a) Description
report requirements
of bonding process
of 4.4,
the
diagrams, if deformations
were measured aad these data should be anslyzed to give the
core shear moduius and stress at proportional limit.
(c)
5.1.6
Shear strength,
individual values,
and aversges.
Core Tension.
5.1.6.1
-.
This test method is the ssme as for Sandwich Tension (see
5.2. 3). Tension teats are usually made on sandwich and the load is applied in a direction
normal tn the facings of the sandwich, to test tbe facing-to-core
bond as well as tbe core.
If core specimens are to be tested, it is permissible to bond the loading cubes directly
to the core, and thus determine strength of the bond or the tensile strength of the core,
whichever is the weaker.
*
5.1.7
5.1.7.1
!&?&
This test sh~l determine the rate Of water migr~iOn intO
The specimen shall be a saodwich at
the core of a sandwich with a punctured facing.
least 5 by 5 inches (12 by 12 cm) in cross section.
The facings shsll be of impervious
material snd shall be bonded to the core with a water-resistant
adhesive.
~:
The adhesive shall be applied so that fairly heavy fillets form between the core cell wall
ends sad the facings, thus assuring a water-tight joint between the facings and core.
A
hole, opposite one centraily located core cell, shall be drilled through tbe upper facing.
A suitable connection shall be provided,
The hole sl@l lead directly into only one cell.
such a
of
MIL-STD-401B
hydrostatic pressure.
The primary cell shall be filled with distilled water, measuring
the amount of water required or the increase in weight of the sandwich specimen.
The
primary cell shall then be connected to a distilled water source under a constant head of
3 feet (1 m). The amount of water, transfixed during a 24-hour period, shall be determined by weighing the specimen or by measuring the amount transfused.
Note:
by
The atmospheric conditions under which the tests are conducted shall be reported.
It is recommended that the tests be conducted at 73 *2 o F (23 ~l C), 50 ~4 percent
relative humidity, and specimens be conditioned to constant weight under those conThe water migration shall be computed as being the cells
ditions before testing.
filled in the 24-hour period.
This can be obtained by dividing the amount of transfused water by the amount necessary to fiIl one ceII.
5.1.8
5.1.8.1
the delamination
5.1.8.2
Node Delamination
(.4STM c 363)
of Honeycomb
Core.
=.
This method of test describes a procedure for determining
strength (node-to-node
bond strength) of honeycomb core.
Test apparatus.
(a) Tension testing device, capable of slow, uniform
head motion, that will indicate load at failure to within 1 percent accuracy.
type or clamping
(see Figure 8)
type, multi-pin
Test specimens.
The specimen of honeycomb core shall be 5
5.1. 8.3
*1/16 by 10 tl/2 inches (12 by 25 cm) long, with a test section, outside the grips,
of 8 fO. 5 inches, and with the width parallel to the node-to-node
bond area.
The
thickness of the core slice, if poasib~e, shall be 0.500 *O. 005 or 0.625 *O. 005 inch.
Specimens shall be conditioned in accordance with 4.2.
In the event that a clamping type of grip is te be used instead of a multiple pin
type, the specimen ends can be reinforced against crushing by filling with plaster
or reinforcing with a dip coating of resin.
5.1.8.4
Test procedure.
Apply tensile load ao as to produce a constant
rate of grip separation, and reach maximum load in 3 to 6 minutes.
Failure in the
grips shall not be considered s satisfactory test.
13
MIL-STD-401B
5.1.8.5
Calculation.
The delamination
strength) shall be calculated by the formula:
strength
(node-to-node
bond
F=&
where:
5.1.8.6
-t.
In addition te the delamination
include the general repert requirements of 4.4.
5.2
5.2.1
Sandwich Compression.
sandwich is performed
as described
5.2.1.1
-.
The Edgewise Compression Sandwich test covers a
procedure for determining compressive
properties of sandwich constructions in a
direction parallel tc the plane of a sheet of sandwich.
The edgewise compressive
strength of short specimens of sandwich provides a basis for judging the load-carrying capacity of the sandwich in terms of developed facing stresses as compared to the
yfeld stress of the facings.
The sandwich column, no matter how short, is usually
This failure manifeats itself by wrinkling of the
subject to a buckling type of failure.
facing, shear crimping, dimpling of facings or general buckling, in which caae, the
core deforms to the wavy shape of the facings; by dimpling of the facings inte the cell
of honeycomb-like
cores; or by hending of the sandwich resulting in crimping near the
enda, due to core shear failure or perhapa failure of tbe core-to-facing
bond (see
Figure 7).
5.2.1.2
Test specimens.
Edgewise compression
specimens of sandwich
construction shall be at leaat 2 inches wide (5 cm), but not less than twice the sandwich thickness, nor leas than the width of two complete core cells.
The unsupported
apacimen length (dimension parallel to direction of applied load) shall be not greater
than eight times the sandwich thickness.
Care shall be taken in preparing the test specimens to insure smooth end surfaces,
free of burrs.
The ends shall be parallel to each other (WARNING-Wed,
flat ends are essential for preventing localized end failures at low loads) end at ri~t
The dimeneiona of tbe specimens shall be
anglea to the length of the specimens.
measured to at least the nearest O. 5 percent.
14
shall be determined
shall be conditioned
in accordance
ss described
with 4.1.
in 4.2.
Sandwich Shear.
-.
This test method is the same as for Core .%ear (5.1. 5).
5.2.2.1
The core shear testing piocedure includes suggestions and computations rektive to
determining shear properties of sandwich ss well as core.
5.2.3
Sandwich Tension.
(ASTM C 297)
m.
This teat method covers the precedure for
5.2.3.1
strength in tension, flatwise (load applied normal to s~dwich facings)
The test is performed
the facing-to-core
bond of ,msembly ssodwich.
bon&d between heavy metsl loading blocks, which are pulled apart in
15
determining the
of the core, or of
on specimens,
a testing machine.
MII.rsTD-4olB
5.2.3.2
Test specimens.
Flatwise tensile specimens shall be the thickness of the sandwich and not less than 1 square inch (25 by 25 mm) in cross section;
for open-celled
cores, having cells larger thsn 3/8 inch (1 cm), the area shsll be a
minimum of 4 square inches.
The dimensions of the test specimens shall be measured to
at least O. 5 percent accuracy.
The number of teat specimens shall be w required in
4.1.
The specimens shall be conditioned in accordance with 4.2.
5.2.3.3
Specimen preparation.
Loading blocks shall be bonded to the
facings of the test specimen by a method which shall not appreciably, affect the existing bond between facings and core.
The bonding pressure shall be less than the
origimd pressure used to bond the facings to the core, and the assembly temperature
shall be room temperature,
or it shall be at leaat 50 F (28 C) lower thW the
temperature at which the sandwich was originally bonded.
(Epoxide resin adhesives
have been found useful for bonding the Iotilng blocks at room temperature or at
slightly elevated temperature. )
Test procedure.
The specimen, with bonded Ioadlng blocks, shall
5.2.3.4
be pl=ed in a eelf- aligning loading fixture which shall not apply eccentric loads.
A
satisfactory type of apparatus is shown in Figure 4. The load shall be applied w a
constant rate of movement of the movable head of the testing machine; and at such
a rate that the maximum load will occur in not less than 3 or not more than 6 minutes.
A head movement of 6 percent of specimen thickness per minute is suggested as a
guide in obtaining the proper testing machine speed.
Report.
5.2.3.5
report shall include:
(a) Description
(b)
5.2.4
Tensile
of bonding process
strength values;
requirements
of 4.4,
the test
individual
and averages.
Sandwich Flexure.
(ASTM C 393)
-.
This test method pertains to the bending of sandwich so
5.2.4.1
that the applied moments produce curvature of the plane of a sheet of sandwich construction.
The usual procedure applies shear, as well as bendhg moment, on the
sandwich.
The test can produce failure in the sandwich by shearing the. core, by
shearing the bond between the core and facings, by direct compression
or tension
failure of the facings, or by localized wrinkling of thin ftiings at load points or
reactions.
Thus the test specimen must be carefully desigped so that the property
Long spans produce Idgh facing stresses so
sought is actually the one obtained.
that core failures or bond failures would not be expected.
Short spans tend to
produce core shear or bond failures, provided the facings are thick enough to
carry the stresses produced by bending moments and also the local stresses x the :.
load points.
Stress concentrations
at load points can be reduced by ueing 2-~int
16
MI L- STD-401B
Test specimen.
The test specimen shsil be rectangukr
in cross
5.2.4.2
section.
The facings shall be of the same thickness and the same material.
The
depth of the specimen shall be equal to the thickness of the sandwich construction,
Snd the Width shsll be not less than twice the total thickness, not less than 3 times
the dimensions of a core cell, nor greater than 1/2 the span length. The specimen
length shall be equaJ to the span length plus 2 inches (5 cm) or plus 1/2 the sandwich
The dimensions of the test specimens shail be
thickness, whichever is the gre~er.
The number of test specimens shall be
measured to at least O. 5 percent accuracy.
se required in 4.1.
The specimens shall be conditioned in accordance with 4.2.
I
I
I
I
I
I
5.2.4. 2.1
so as to determine
I
I
shall be constmcted
1
I
Specimen construction.
The test specimen
the properties to be measured.
(a)
I
I
loading rather than a single central load point. If deflection readings are taken on a
short specimen,
it is possible to obtain an approximate value of the core shear modulus. If bending stiffness of the sandwich is not known or cannot be computed, it is
Tbe following
possible to obtain bending stiffness by testing a 10USflexure specimen.
testing procedures can be used to obtain approximate values of core shear modulus
and strength, but the test method of 5. 2.2 is more accurate.
Approximate value of
facing properties can also be obtained; however, test methods for determining properties of the facing materiel will give more accurate results.
Test procedure.
Loads shall be applied to the specimen at two
5.2.4.3
quarter-span points through round steel bars or steel pipesl having a diameter not less
than one-half and not more than one and one-half times the sandwich thickness (see
apparatus in Figure 5). The bars or pipes shall be circular in cross section to within
one percent of their diameter; they shall be straight to within O. 5 percent of their length.
If, after a trial te@, it is -found that locil failures occur under load pointe, it will be
17
MI L- STD-401B
permissible to place thin narrow plstee at theee p,oints to prevent such failure.
load shall be applied, preferably,
through a constant rate of movement of the
movable head of the testing mexhine, and at such a rate that the maximum load
will occur in not less than 3 and not more than 6 minutes.
The
Ps
s = (d+tc)b
where S = core shear stress
Ps = totaf force, applied at 2 points located a distance of oS/4 from
each reaction
OS= span length
d = total sandwich thickness
tc = core thickness
b = sandwich width
The average facing stresses are given by the formula (for thick facinge the stress
will be slightly greater at the surface than the average stress):
P~ o~
F 4t(d+tc)b
where F = facing stress
PB= total force, applied at 2 points located
each reaction
a~= span length
t = facing thickness
d = totaf sandwich thickness
tc = core thickness
b = sandwich width
The core shear modulus is given by the formula
G=
a distance
frnm
P3 0, tc
2wS (d+tc)zb I (
18
of se/4
llP~a,3
768w, Db )
MIL-STD-401B
where
D,
E(d3-tc3)
12L )
E = modulus of elasticity
L = O. 91 for isotropic
of facings
facings
facings.
If II is unknown and cannot be computed aa above, the aandivich can be tested for
OS, and on a short span,
deflections on a long span,
OS, (See5. 2.4.2 for determining spana), and then G and D determined from the following:
Note:
A lthaugh one-third span two point loading and single point loading are
used by Industry they are not recommended for Quality Assurance testing
since their resultant values diverge from the norm established by quarterspan two point loading.
5.2.4.5
-.
In addition to the general report requirements of 4.4, the
teat report shall include maximum facing and core shear stresaea, load-deflection
diagrams,
core shear modulus, and sandwich stiffness as obtained from the particular teata performed.
5.2.5
Note:
5.2.6
Sandwich Thermal
(ASTM C 236)
Conductivity.
5.2. 6.1
-.
This method of test is intended for determining tbe comparative
peel resistance of adhesive bonds between facings and Coi es of sandwich constructions,
19
MIL-STD-401B
when tested under specified test condltons. The method is most applicable when
the facings being peeled are relatively thin. The ,peeling torque calculated from
this test includes both the forces required to peel the adhesive bond, end to bend
the facing.
*
Test appsratus.
The peel test apparatus shall consist of a
5.2.6.2
flanged drum, flexible loading straps or cables, andsuitable clamps for holding the
test specimen.
The apparatus shown in Figure 6hasbeenfound
to be satisfactory.
The outside radius of the drum shail be 2.000 +0. 005 inches (50.80 *O. 05 mm).
The rsdiusof the flange, including one half of thethickness
of theloachngstrspsor
c~les,
shall be 0.500 +0.005 inch (12.70 +0.05 mm) larger than the rachusof the
drum. This O. 500*0.005
inch (12.70 *0.05 mm) distance isthe effective torque
arm of the apparatus.
Asuitable topclamp (Clamp A), for use inloachg
the specimen, and a drum clamp (Clamp B) shall be used to initially hold the facings tangent
to the face of the drum, similar to those shown in Figure 6. The drum shall be
balanced about its exisbythe
use of aweight placed diametrically
opposite Clamp B,
tocompensate
for the weight ofth@ clamp.
The drum and fiangewith C1smp B and
its compensating weight shall not weigh more than 8 pounds (3.63 kg), a lighter
weight being preferable to facilitate handling of the apparatus.
Note:
Test specimen.
For evaluation of adhesives in sandwich con5.2.6.3
structions the test specimen shall coaform to the general form and dimensions of
Thelength of the speoimen shall be at least 10
the specimen shown in Figure6.
inches (25 cm).
Thickness ofcore
is not important, except in the sense that the
sandwich specimen shell not bend while the facing is being peeled.
Forcomparstive evaluation of adhesives in bonding metal-faced
sandtich constructions,
afacingof
2024-T3 clad aiuminum alloy 0.020 inch (0.5 mm) thick, and score
1/2 inch (12. 7 mm) thick haa been found to be suitable.
These specimens maybe
At least 6 specimens,
two or more
cut from larger bonded panels if desired.
from each of 3 bonded panels, shall be tested for each adhesive sample.
Note:
An initial force, equal to that obtained in calibration of the apparatus for load to
overcome the resisting torque of the drum, shall be applied by loadlng the apparatus
in tension.
The specimen is then ready for testing.
The peel of at least 6 inches (15 cm) of the facing of the sandwich panel, shall then
be made by the loading of the apparatus in tension, at a testing machine head speed
of 1.00 fO. 01 inch (2. 5 +0. 025 cm) per minute. It is preferred that an autograph
recording of the force versus head movement, or force versus distance peeled, be
made during the peel test. If autographic equipment is not available, average forces
cm be obtained by recording those at fixed increments of time after the start of the
test. The load may be recorded 15 seconds after the start of the test and et each 5This will permit calculating an average load over 5 inches (13 cm)
eecond interval.
of peeling, as deecribed in 5.2.6.6.
Computation.
The average peeling force required to peel the facing
5.2.6.6
shall be taken from the autographic curve for the peeling of the sandwich specimens
between 1 and 6 inches (2. 5 and 15 cm), or as the average of load readings taken at
the fixed time increments during this part of the test. The average peeling tnrque
per unit epecimen width for peeling the strip of facing shall be calculated aa
follows:
T=
Torque arm
Width of specimen
(Average
peeling force
minus force
to overcome
resisting
torque of drum)
The maximum peeling force obtained during the test shail also be recorded,
and the
maximmn peeling torque shall be c slculated in accordance with the above formula.
Note:
21
5.2.6.7
I@@.
In addition to the general
the test report shall include the following:
(a) Number of specimens
report requirements
of 4.4,
tested.
torque of the
(d) Average and maximum peeling torque values per unit specimen width for each specimen,
and average values for each
group of specimens.
(e)
Type of failure,
(f)
Approximate
peeling.
after
22
MIL-STD-401B
Data reported shall includecreep rate beyond the initial deformation or &flection
as obtained by dividing the creep by the time pertod between defoliation
or deflection
readings in hours or days; load sustained and expreesed as a percent of static con-
if failure occurred.
Preparing activity:
Navy - AS
Custodians:
Army - ME
Navy - AS
Air Force -11
Review:
Army4
MR, EL
Navy - AS
Air Force -11,
84
User:
Amny - MI, ME, AV
Navy - SH
23
MIL-STD-401B
GRAIN Jw
DIRECTION
24
MIL-STD-401B
A
o
UPPER FITTfNCi
PLANE IN WHICH
THE LOAD AC~
SANDWICH CORE
MATERIAL
-L
LOADING PL4TES
- LOWER FITTING
COMPRESSION LOAD
TENS1ON LOAD
Figure 2.
25
MIL-STD-401B
Figure
3.
Compression
test apparatus
showing an adjustable
supporting
MIL-STD-401B
Figure
4,
.,
----
MIL-sTD-4olf?
Fipure
5.
Apparatus
.,
--
-..5..--.....-
for conducting
flexure
28
test of sandwich
construction.
MIL-STD-401B
1
A
CLAMP A_
CLAMP A
TX
I
.E...
3.00+0.01
riPLUS
0.500*O.005
(rO)
couNTERWEIGHT
-.
CLAMP B
.-
CLAMP
.:?
...
l-~
~sTRA p
f!
NOTE
ALL DIMENSIONS IN INCHES
2. NOT COMPLETELY DIMENSIONED
3. ri= RAD OF DRUM
4. ro= RAD TO MID-DEPTH OF STRAP
._
. . ---
1.
SECTION A-A
Figure 6.
Type ofapparatussuitable
formaking sandwichpeeltest.
29
MI L-STD-401B
b
,
t+++
A.
tttt
GENERAL
BUCKLING
B. SHEAR CRIMPING
++++
SEPARATION
FROM
CORE
HONEYCOMB
CORE
C.
CORE
CRUSHING
++++
tttt
DIMPLING
OF FACINGS
D.
Figure
7.
++++
WRINKLING OF FACINGS
30
MILSTD-401B
r
o
!4!2:
;--g-j
0.500
0.625
-------------
+0.
+0.
~
,------------
CORE LOADING PI
Figure
* u. s.
.OVERNMENT
,!+l.,l
!-4.
OF,
8.
ICE-,3
Apparatus
.7:
,0,.220.371
31
tests.
SPECIFICLT!G::ANALYSIS SHEET
FormApproved
BudgetDureauNo. IIg-Ro04
IwxucrIcNs
outby perymncleitherGovernment
or contractor,
involved
in theuse of the specTni. she. t is to be filled
f?c~tiop
;. p,t:zrermntof product:forult+mat?use by theDepartment
of Defense.Thissheet,s prov~dedf.: obw,th
f
nx?,ng.nrorn.
t,oaonthe.s. of thisspec.
f>cat,
on wh~chw1l n-,s.re
thatsuitableproduct.c,..be procured
~nm.m
.IX,.T,:
.f ,delayand a~ the leastc st. Commentsand the ?et.rnof ChlsformWI1l be appreciated.
Fold.r
.Ct.YXtY(.s indicated
on r..etsehc,e.f).
,nescm reverses,de,stapleL corner,an2 sendt. prep.r~n~
PECIFICATIGN
RGAN!LArl
.. b.itt.
r)
CllY
)NiRACTNO,
&TER 1AL
PROCURED
~
HAS
ANY
UNDER
n,nEcT
PART
OF
C. N7RACT
SPEC I F I CATION
A.
CIVE
B.
RECOMMENDATIONS
sTATE
00LLAR AMOUNT
s
60 VERNMENT
THE
AND
CREATED
SU8CONTR4CT
PROBLEMS
OR REOU I RED
INTERPRETATION
IN
PROCUREMENT
uSE?
ANO WORDING.
FOR CORRECTING
THE DEFICIENCIES.
.,
. -COAOSENTS
ON
ANY
IS TNE SPECIFICATIONRESTRICTIVE?
~
NO
Ir
YES-,
UBAIi TTED
,,s
. . . ..
pepera,
BY
(Printed
. .. . .
), Jy6,1Vm
ot:.c
to fora
or typed
IN
datum
ondploce
n.ae
REPLACES
WHAT WAY?
end
DATE
activity)
NAVSNIPS
FORM
4863.
.
VU+IC41
.-------I s 0U50LL1L
. ----
.-...