Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sudan
Sudan
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiffs,
)
)
v.
)
)
ALCON ENTERTAINMENT, LLC,
)
IMAGINE ENTERTAINMENT, LLC,
)
GOOD LIE PRODUCTIONS LLC,
)
BLACK LABEL MEDIA, LLC, RELIANCE )
BIG ENTERTAINMENT (US), INC.,
)
OUTLAW PRODUCTIONS, DEBORAH
)
JELIN NEWMYER, as executrix of the
)
Estate of Robert Newmyer, JEFFREY
)
SILVER, and MARGARET NAGLE,
)
)
Defendants.
)
COMPLAINT
COME NOW Plaintiffs Foundation for Lost Boys and Girls of Sudan, Inc.
(the Foundation) and Nathaniel Chol Nyok, Bol Deng Bol, Gam Day Awino,
Emmanuel Gai Solomon, Stephen Akech Kuol, Luka Thiik Yai, Gabriel Gai
Magok, Makur Makuei Abiar, James Chier Malual, Andrew Majok Marier, Angelo
Agany Akot, Moses Matur Chol, James Chol Achiber, Marol Deng Deu, Kuir
Garang Marier, John Nuai Wour, Jacob Aweng Deu, John Garang Dau, Abraham
Chier Arop, Ngor Kur Monyol, Peter Malou Jok, Deng Manyang Riak, Santino
Achiek Ayol, Dau Goi Leek, Ernest Akuei Madut, James Ajang Yai, Jacob Nyang
Alier, Gabriel Garang Thuch, Jacob Akol Kuany, Jacob Deng Mach, Victor Duang
Deng, Abraham Chol Machol, Abraham Laat Deng, John Manyok Anyieth, David
Deng Anyieth, John Mading Jok, Abraham Garang Majak, Santino Dut
Monynhial, Abraham Bol Kuany, Peter Kuol Mading, Deng Machot Deng, Marko
Aguer Ayii, Mayom Lat Mawut, Simon Ayuel Deng, William Lual Deng,
Philemon Juac Gor, Peter M. Adol, James Bol Maliet, Abraham Majok Deng,
Abraham Yel Nhial, Sarah Abiei Solomon, and Abraham Mach Nyok (collectively,
the Contributing Lost Boys or the refugees), and file this Complaint against
Defendants Alcon Entertainment, LLC (Alcon), Imagine Entertainment, LLC
(Imagine), Good Lie Productions, LLC (GLP), Black Label Media, LLC
(Black Label Media), Reliance Big Entertainment (US), Inc. (Reliance),
Outlaw Productions, Deborah Jelin Newmyer as executrix of the Estate of Robert
Newmyer (the Estate), Jeffrey Silver (Silver), and Margaret Nagle (Nagle,
collectively, Defendants), as follows.
INTRODUCTION
1.
genocide to produce the recently released film The Good Lie. The Good Lie is an
A-list production by Academy Award winning producer Ron Howard starring
Academy Award winner Reese Witherspoon. The refugees partnered with
Defendants to create The Good Lies script, in part, based upon their promise that a
non-profit foundation organized and run by the refugees would be the sole
beneficiary of any fundraising efforts associated with The Good Lie. It was
expected that The Good Lie would increase public awareness of the plight of
Sudanese refugees and lead to multiple ongoing and continuous fundraising
opportunities to help this worthy cause. The Foundation was formed to use the
proceeds of the movies fundraising efforts to fund schools and other philanthropic
causes in South Sudan. However, neither the refugees nor their Foundation have
been compensated in any fashion for sharing their traumatic personal stories and
assisting with the creation of the script for The Good Lie. When confronted during
a videotaped meeting on April 15, 2013, Molly Smith, of Black Label Media, LLC,
said, The most important thing that was said here today was you asked a question,
Do you feel you should be compensated for your story? And, the answer I can
say, because its my company and my studio, is absolutely. Defendants have
broken their promises to these refugees.
PARTIES, JURISDICTION, AND VENUE
2.
3.
Georgia.
4.
of business in California. Alcon may be served with a copy of the summons and
complaint in this action at the office of its registered agent, Corporation Service
Company, 2711 Centerville Road, Suite 400, Wilmington, Delaware 19808.
5.
principal place of business in California. Black Label may be served with a copy of
the summons and complaint in this action at the office of its registered agent,
in Delaware. Reliance may be served with a copy of the summons and complaint in
this action at the office of its registered agent, Paracorp Incorporated, 2140 S.
Dupont Highway, Camden, Delaware 19934.
9.
California. Silber may be served with a copy of the summons and complaint in this
matter at Outlaw Productions principal place of business located at 11054
Cashmere Street, Los Angeles, California 90049.
11.
of the state of California. The Estate may be served with a copy of the summons
and complaint in this action at 11054 Cashmere Street, Los Angeles, California
90049.
12.
This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to
This Court also has subject matter jurisdiction over this action
pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1331, 1338(a), and 1338(b) because this action arises
under the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. 101, et seq.
15.
pursuant to the provisions of Georgias Long-Arm Statute, O.C.G.A. 9-10-91(1)(3), and because each Defendant has established sufficient minimum contacts
within the State of Georgia such that maintenance of the suit does not violate due
process protections. The contracts at issue in this matter were made in Georgia, the
interviews at issue in this matter occurred in Georgia, and the movie The Good Lie
was filmed in Georgia and included some of the Plaintiffs as extra actors.
16.
28 U.S.C. 1391(b)(2)-(3).
FACTS
The History of Lost Boys of Sudan
17.
nations located on the African continent just south of Egypt. Both share a
tumultuous history, including two recent civil wars spanning thirty-eight of the last
fifty-nine years.
18.
administered as separate provinces of the same colony from 1899 until 1946 when
the British integrated the two areas.
19.
the nation remained far from unified as religion, culture, industry, politics, and
language continued to divide the northern and southern regions.
20.
The First Sudanese Civil War, between the north and south, began in
1955 and continued through 1972. The treaty that ended the First Sudanese Civil
War in 1972 failed to completely dispel the religious and ethnic tensions that had
originally caused it.
21.
Northern Sudanese enlisted the help of Muslim militia from Darfur in jihad against
the Southern Sudanese, who were predominantly Christian or followed ancient
beliefs.
23.
The Darfurians raided villages for cattle and goods. They enslaved the Southern
Sudanese women and girls. They slaughtered Southern Sudanese men and boys.
24.
villages. When militiamen raided these villages, they targeted grass-roofed huts
with fires that easily spread from hut to hut. As a result, villagers were forced out
of their burning village and into the militias trap. Females were captured, raped,
and enslaved. Males were slaughtered.
25.
were targeted for killing by the militia, the Southern Sudanese told their boys to
flee the village at the first signs of an attack while the adult men sacrificed
themselves to allow their families to escape. Boys escaped to the surrounding bush,
only to watch their village burn and families die.
26.
The traumatized boys fled from the genocidal attackers coming from
Darfur. Along the way, many boys, and occasionally girls, joined together in the
wilderness. Together, some of the boys overcame their trauma, starvation,
dehydration, and frequent animal attacks.
27.
boys, some only ten or eleven years old, became the group elders. Children as
young as seven or eight years old were parents to the younger boys. When
weakness or exhaustion overtook the youngest children, the older boys picked
them up and carried them.
28.
Many did not survive the dangers of the African wilderness. Many
boys died from starvation, disease, attacks from wild animals and enemy militias.
The fallen were buried by their young friends.
29.
Many of the boys walked for months until they reached refugee camps
in neighboring Ethiopia, where they remained for about four years. However, after
civil war broke out in Ethiopia, the boys left the refugee camps and again began
walking back through a war-torn Southern Sudan towards the Kakuma Refugee
Camp in Kenya.
30.
Aid workers named the boys the Lost Boys of Sudan after the
fictional lost boys in Peter Pan. Most of the Lost Boys are orphans from the
10
the genocide and fighting during the Second Sudanese Civil War, and millions,
including thousands of Lost Boys, were displaced.
32.
Thousands of Lost Boys and Lost Girls of Sudan were granted entry
into the United States via a lottery system. After they arrived in the United States,
the penniless orphans created communities, educated themselves, found
employment, and tried to achieve the American Dream.
33.
While many of the Lost Boys and Girls have permanently settled in
the United States, they continue to help their homeland through charitable
donations and humanitarian aid and support. Others are returning to South Sudan
to help rebuild their war-torn country.
34.
Atlanta, Georgia and works to improve conditions in South Sudan by, among other
things, fostering education in South Sudan.
11
While the Lost Boys share a common background, each Lost Boy has
his own story of the trials faced during his journey stories filled with the sorrow
of loss, the power of friendship, and the will to survive.
36.
In 2002, Lost Boys Gam Day Awino, Gabriel Gai Magok, Nathaniel
Chol Nyok, and three others were hired to work on the movie Tears of the Sun
starring Bruce Willis. After filming Tears of the Sun in Hawaii, Mr. Awino,
Mr. Magok, and Mr. Nyok traveled through Los Angeles, California where they
were introduced to Robert a/k/a Bobby Newmyer (Newmyer), a film producer
and partner at Outlaw Productions.
37.
Newmyer asked Mr. Awino, Mr. Magok, and Mr. Nyok where they
were from and how they arrived in Atlanta. Mr. Awino, Mr. Magok, and Mr. Nyok
told Newmyer about some of their experiences in South Sudan and how they
arrived in Atlanta as refugees. When Newmyer said, We can make this into a
movie, Mr. Awino, Mr. Magok, and Mr. Nyok told Newmyer to contact Mary
Williams, founder of the Lost Boys Foundation1 (LBF). Newmyer agreed to
travel to Atlanta, Georgia to meet with members of the Lost Boys community.
1
The Lost Boys Foundation was a 501(c)(3) organization established in 2001. This
foundation is not affiliated with the plaintiff Foundation.
12
38.
include Boardwalk Empire, to write the script incorporating the Lost Boys stories.
39.
While some common elements of the Lost Boys story were publically
available, Newmyer and Nagle wanted to create a movie with real, personal and
emotional details otherwise unavailable to the public at large. Newmyer and Nagle
needed the details from the Lost Boys personal stories and permission to use those
details in a screenplay and subsequent film.
40.
Mr. Awino was initially not invited to the meeting, but he attended
anyway. The interview process had already just begun when Mr. Awino arrived.
Mr. Awino interrupted and asked to speak. He asked Nagle and Newmyer what the
arrangements were for compensating the Contributing Lost Boys for their
assistance in creating the script for a movie. Mr. Awino insisted that the interviews
cease until an agreement could be reached.
42.
The other Contributing Lost Boys agreed that they would not continue
13
43.
At that point, Newmyer and Nagle left the room to discuss the
demand for compensation. Upon their return, they offered to pay the Contributing
Lost Boys $55,000 immediately and that they would not allow the script to be used
for a film unless and until the Contributing Lost Boys consented after reaching an
agreement as to compensation with the future filmmakers/studios.
44.
Newmyer and Nagle further promised that they would facilitate using
the telling of the Contributing Lost Boys stories as a catalyst to raise funds for a
new foundation to be organized and operated by the Contributing Lost Boys, i.e.,
the Foundation.
45.
Boys, prior to the continuation of the interviews, that the proceeds of any
fundraising efforts associated with the script and the movie would be contributed
solely to a non-profit foundation organized and operated by the Contributing Lost
Boys.
46.
At the time, the parties did not know if, how, or when the movie
would be produced. Newmyer and Nagle explained that it was impossible to agree
on the ultimate compensation from the profits of the movie unless and until the
details of the movies production were known. Newmyer indicated that he likewise
14
did not know his own compensation details at this stage because the script was still
being written and they had not shopped the concept to any studios.
47.
It was further explained and understood that just as a movie could not
be produced from the script without the consent of Newmyer and Nagle, that a
movie would not be produced from the script without the consent of the
Contributing Lost Boys.
48.
charitable donations and funds raised from the script and movie would be directed
solely to a non-profit foundation organized and operated by the Contributing Lost
Boys.
49.
The Contributing Lost Boys accepted this offer and fully performed
their end of the bargain by continuing the interviews and assisting with the creation
of the script.
50.
Contributing Lost Boys to create the script and to sell the script to a studio to
produce a movie from the script (the Joint Venture).
51.
terms governing the Joint Venture: (1) the Contributing Lost Boys would share
their life stories with Nagle and Newmyer via a series of interviews; (2) Nagle
15
would use the Contributing Lost Boys stories and interviews to create a
screenplay about the Lost Boys of Sudan; (3) Outlaw Productions, Newmyer, and
Nagle would pay the Contributing Lost Boys $55,000 for their life stories; (4) no
film would be produced from the screenplay unless and until the Contributing Lost
Boys consented after agreeing on the compensation arrangement with the
producers/studios; and (5) 100% of all charitable donations and funds raised from
the script and movie would be directed solely to a non-profit foundation organized
and operated by the Contributing Lost Boys (the Joint Venture Agreement).
52.
script with studios, producers, and/or filmmakers after the script was completed.
The Contributing Lost Boys agreed to create a committee to negotiate their
compensation if and when the screenplay was made into a film.
53.
501(c)(3) foundation upon release of the movie to receive and administer 100% of
all charitable donations and funds raised from the script and movie if and when the
screenplay was made into a film.
54.
all payments to the Contributing Lost Boys, and charitable funds raised, pursuant
to the Joint Venture and Joint Venture Agreement would go directly to a non-profit
16
foundation founded, owned, operated, and managed by the Contributing Lost Boys
for charitable works in South Sudan.
55.
agreed with the Contributing Lost Boys that any charitable fundraising associated
with the film would not be directed to any third party charities, regardless of their
purported or actual devotion to or track record with South Sudanese humanitarian
efforts. It was very important to the Contributing Lost Boys that they be able to
direct and control the use of funds derived from their life stories and contributions
to the script.
57.
Contributing Lost Boys during their trip to Atlanta in 2003 (the Interviews).
Each of the Interviews was recorded by audio or video recording. Newmyer and/or
Nagle retained the audio and video recordings of the Interviews.
17
58.
Newmyer spoke to other Sudanese refugees, or did other research for the script,
they did not make similar, or any, promises of compensation and exclusive
fundraising rights with respect to a movie to any other person, organization, or
foundation.
59.
contact some of the Contributing Lost Boys to obtain additional details about their
life stories.
61.
For example, Newmyer spoke with Gam Awino three times after the
initial interviews. Mr. Awino escaped with a few other Lost Boys, but the
Darfurians came upon them in the Sudanese bush. One of Mr. Awinos friends lied
to the would-be-captors and said he was alone to save Mr. Awino and the other
friends. Indeed, upon information and belief, the title for the film The Good Lie
refers to this lie that saved Mr. Awinos life. On a second occasion, Newmyer
contacted Mr. Awino to learn more about his hospitalization. Newmyer and Nagle
incorporated these details into the Screenplay.
18
62.
The parties met several times to discuss the logistics of the Joint
Chairman of the Lost Boys National Foundation, and, in 2005, was designated as
the Contributing Lost Boys representative to discuss with Newmyer and Nagle the
amount of compensation necessary to obtain their consent to produce a film from
the Screenplay and the details of the films fundraising efforts on behalf of the
Foundation.
64.
Although the parties did not agree on a dollar amount for selling the
script or making the movie during their discussions in 2003, 2004, and 2005,
Newmyer and Nagle reiterated their commitment to the Joint Venture Agreement
and insisted that the Contributing Lost Boys would be paid an agreed upon amount
before the movie was produced. They further promised that 100% of all charitable
19
fundraising, foundation seed money, and positive publicity to the South Sudanese
cause would be directed exclusively to the Foundation.
65.
discussing promotion of the script with the Estate, Mike Glassman, Newmyers
assistant, and Nagle, but these discussions were not fruitful.
The Screenplay is tabled until 2013
67.
68.
the same project. Outlaw Productions and Nagle knew that they needed more
producers or a larger production company to make the Screenplay into a feature
film.
69.
20
Agreement, but the Contributing Lost Boys were never compensated for their
original contributions to the Screenplay.
70.
Paramount had not obtained any rights from the Contributing Lost
Boys and therefore had no right to produce a movie from the Screenplay.
72.
Media, and GLP then acquired Outlaw Productions and Nagles limited rights in
the Screenplay in conjunction with Reliance and Imagine. No one purchased, or
had, any right to produce a movie from the Screenplay without the Contributing
Lost Boys consent.
73.
Upon
information
and
belief,
Reliance,
Imagine,
Alcon
Entertainment, Black Label and GLP (the Production Team) were aware of and
assumed the responsibilities and obligations under the Joint Venture Agreement
during the various transfers of ownership and production interests in the
Screenplay.
74.
21
75.
film lab in which a team of producers, actors, and directors worked with Nagle to
revise the Screenplay.
76.
Upon information and belief, the Production Team began filming The
Team wanted to film an authentic movie. The Production Team contacted the
International Rescue Committee (IRC) to solicit Lost Boys living in metroAtlanta to work as extras in the Movie.
78.
and South Sudanese, and asked him to help recruit Lost Boys as extras for the
Movie and offered to pay each extra $200 to $250 per day. Mr. Solomon agreed
and recruited many extras for the Movie and put them in touch with the films
producers.
79.
Mr. Solomon later learned that the producers reneged on the promised
payment amount and had offered only $8.00 to $10.00 per hour to the Lost Boys to
be extras. Many Lost Boys work in low-income positions, and the promise of
earning $8.00 to $10.00 per hour as an extra was an attractive offer.
22
80.
Mr. Solomon discovered this bait and switch and forced the Movies
producers to pay the originally offered $200 to $250 per day before the Lost Boys
would perform as extras.
81.
The Lost Boys working on the Movie soon recognized Nagles script,
now entitled The Good Lie, and brought the script to the Contributing Lost Boys.
82.
After reading the script, the Contributing Lost Boys discovered that it
was the same story Nagle had written years earlier using their life stories. The
Contributing Lost Boys were shocked that their story was being produced because
they trusted Nagle to keep her promise and comply with the terms of the Joint
Venture Agreement.
83.
Neither Nagle nor anyone else contacted the Contributing Lost Boys
Falardeau and producers Molly Smith of Black Label Media and Karen Sherwood
of Imagine Entertainment.
85.
On April 15, 2013, Ms. Smith and Ms. Sherwood, on behalf of the
Production Team, met with representatives for the Contributing Lost Boys and the
23
Foundation. During the videotaped meeting, Ms. Smith and Ms. Sherwood
confirmed that the screenplay for The Good Lie was a revised version of the
Screenplay and included the Contributing Lost Boys life stories. Ms. Sherwood
told the Lost Boys, Margaret [Nagle] told me at that conference it was agreed that
a scholarship donation would be made from the film to the Lost Boys.
86.
Ms. Smith further said, If the movie ever got made, in the budget of
the film, a portion of that would go to a scholarship fund. Which, and just speaking
from our profession, is a very unusual thing because that never happens on a film.
But, because of the message of the film, it was very important, and we would like
to honor that.
87.
During the meeting, Ms. Smith addressed the Contributing Lost Boys
concerns and said, The most important thing that was said here today was you
asked a question, Do you feel we should be compensated for your story? And,
the answer I can say, because its my company and my studio, is absolutely.
88.
At the end of the April 15, 2013 meeting, Ms. Smith and
Ms. Sherwood acknowledged their assumption and adoption of the Joint Venture
Agreement, agreed to compensate the Contributing Lost Boys for their contribution
to The Good Lie by making a donation to the Contributing Lost Boys Foundation,
and agreed to further negotiate in good faith the exact dollar amount for the
24
Upon information and belief, the Production Team knew that Nagle,
Newmyer, and Outlaw Productions did not have the right to unilaterally sell or
license the Screenplay.
The Production Team does not Negotiate in Good Faith
90.
A few weeks after the April meeting, Ms. Smith called Moses Matur
Chol and offered $1,000,000 to satisfy and comply with the Joint Venture
Agreement. Mr. Chol indicated that he did not have authority to accept or reject the
offer and that he would respond after consulting with the other Contributing Lost
Boys and the Foundation.
91.
On May 16, 2013, counsel for Alcon, Black Label Media and Good
Lie Productions rejected the Foundations efforts to negotiate stating, Our clients
have never agreed to pay any law firm, Lost Boy, or organization for Black Label
Medias own copyrighted work.
25
93.
The Foundation wrote counsel for Alcon, Black Label Media and
On July 26, 2013, counsel for Alcon, Black Label Media and Good
Lie Productions denied the Foundations request to mediate, denied the existence
of any agreement with the Contributing Lost Boys or the Foundation, and denied
that Ms. Smith acknowledged that The Good Lie used the Contributing Lost Boys
life stories.
95.
Venture Agreement, each of the Contributing Lost Boys irrevocably assigned all
intellectual property rights in his story and his claims against the Defendants to the
Foundation.
The Movie is Released and Includes Many of Plaintiffs Stories
96.
97.
Although the trailer is just over two minutes in length, the Movie clips
Contributing Lost Boys, noted that the first scene of the attack on the village with
boys on the trees came directly from his story. In his interview, Nagle asked what
he was doing on the day the fighting began. Mr. Nyok answered, We boys were
26
doing different things fishing, playing games, on trees eating fruits while the rest
looked after the cows. The scene shown in the Movies trailer copies Mr. Nyoks
story.
99.
Nagle took their jokes and casual conversations and used them in her script. When
Nagle was at the LBFs Center in Atlanta, Mr. Nyok showed Nagle the great white
cow he was molding and suggested that Nagle could be nicknamed Yaardit,
meaning great white cow in Dinka. The trailer shows a similar scene in which
Jerimiah, played by Ger Duany, gives Carrie Davis, played by Reese Witherspoon,
the nickname Yaardit.
100. After the release of the movie, the Contributing Lost Boys recognized
numerous more stories, anecdotes, plot devices, character traits, etc. taken from the
stories they told Nagle and Newmyer.
101. For example, Plaintiff Abraham Chier Arop emigrated to Atlanta in
2001 and met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following
story:
Shortly after Sadiq Al Mahdi became the Prime Minister of
Sudan, the government forces came out to my village of Pariang.
They burnt down the village, killed women, children and elderly. I
27
was able to escape. On my way eastward I met other boys who were
displayed from their villages. We walked together for several days.
About a week or two we arrived at Nasir, a town on Sobat River
which was also attacked and destroyed by the government forces. The
town was literally a ghost town; there were dead children, women and
men on the grounds and vultures were circling over the town. We
could not stand the stench of unburied, decaying bodies. The movie
shows these same scenes in the first ten minutes of the film.
Seeing dead children, who were about my age, on the ground, I
started breaking down. I was scared, and at the same time confused by
the government forces indiscriminate killing of my people. I could
not understand why we were being targeted because of our, faith in
Jesus Christ and African heritage. We did not bother Arabs because of
their heritage and faith in Islam. This shared sentiment is
demonstrated in the movie when children are left parentless after
Jinjaweeds on horse backs and helicopter gunship indiscriminately
massacred the villages, children and elderly. Orphaned children
expressed their frustrations in song, as they walked towards Ethiopia.
28
102. For example, Plaintiff Peter Malou Jok emigrated to Atlanta in 2001
and met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following story:
I had seen cars and trucks at both Pinyidu and Kakuma refugee
camps; which would bring UNHCR (United Nations High
Commissioner Refugees) workers and food and clothing to the camps.
However, I had never seen huge number of cars until I came to
Atlanta. I had seen huge herds of Dinka cows, though. I was able to
swing by several cows without being hurt or getting scared. But,
swinging around speeding cars was a different story all together. One
day, my roommates- David Geu, Abraham Majak and I went to
Thriftown, a grocery store in Clarkston to buy some food and phone
cards. Standing from our English Oaks Apt, you would see Thriftown,
but the round trip took us 2 hours. As we tried to cross road, the cars
would honk, BEEP, BEEP! We were confused and scared. The traffic
light did not mean anything to us. Not knowing better, we thought our
cowboy ways would serve us well. But we soon realized we were not
in our villages anymore and were not dealing with cows. Almost this
exact scene was duplicated in the script and movie when Paul (a
character played by Emmanuel Jal) absentmindedly crossed a very
29
congested road and almost got hit. Paul thought he was still in the
Dinka village
103. For example, Plaintiff Stephen Akech Kuol emigrated to Atlanta in
2001 and met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following
story:
I was privileged to star in Tears of the Sun and to meet with
Late Bobby Newmyer in LA. Here is my contribution to the script: I
was shot by government forces in the leg when they attacked my
village in 1987. I was about 7 years old. One of the boys from my
village, who saw me on the ground, picked me up and ran with me. I
could not walk, my leg was totally broken. I told Deng Ayuen, the boy
from my village, to leave me, but he insisted he would carry me until
we find some help. After several weeks, we both arrived at a Refugee
Camp where I was amputated. I was given crutches to get around. Life
became so different; I could not play soccer any more. I could not
participate in a lot of things my friends were part of. But, I
appreciated being alive regardless of my limitation. Some of my
playmates did not make it out of my village; they were killed. My
story was used in the movie when boys from various villages
30
31
32
movie when the caseworker picked up the boys at the airport and told
them she would work with them in finding jobs. My story was also
used in the script and movie when boys were given a crash course on
how to present themselves at job interviews while they were at the
ranch.
We arrived at Jubilee Partners in the evening. We could see
animals by the car headlights. I turned to our caseworker and asked if
there were lions. The caseworker laughed, but when he realized I was
scared he reassured me that there were no lions. Lion had once
attacked and ate my friend, Deng Wel in my presence. So, wherever I
see huge trees, I ask to make sure that there are no lions. My story was
used in the script and movie when Paul asked if there were lions at the
ranch.
Shortly after I arrived here, I was hired by Kroger as a Courtesy
Clerk; my duties included helping customers, running register,
stocking shelves and cleaning and throwing out stale food. I enjoyed
every role that my job entailed, but one thing. Throwing out food was
making me sick; just few months ago I barely had anything to eat in
the Refugee camp. As I would throw out this so called stale food, I
33
would remember all my friends whom I left in the camp in Kenya and
have nothing to eat; and I would break down. However, my bitterness
was replaced by a joy when I discovered an African American single
woman with her son who would come and ask me for stale food. I
would give them cake, vegetables and fruits that were meant for
dumpster. Every time this woman and her son would receive food,
they would beam while thanking me profusely. It was not long before
I was upset again. One evening, while I was giving out food to the
single woman with her son, the store manager saw me and came
running. She took the food from this woman and threw it in to a
dumpster and summoned me to her office. Seeing tears dropping
down from this poor womans cheeks, I became angry and grabbed
the manager by collar of her shirt. With my heavily accented English,
I demanded why she was being mean; I asked her if she would do the
same to a white woman. The manager kept quiet and asked me to
follow her to the office. At that point, I told her she was not my boss
anymore since I was quitting. This incidence was my first encounter
with coldhearted American, who would not sympathize with needy.
The image of an American until that day was that one of
34
35
36
days become weeks and weeks become months and before we knew it
we were welcome by light skinned people who spoke strange
language; later to be known as Ethiopians. While on this journey,
many young children including myself became sick from mosquito
bites, hunger and long distant walk. Not knowing what to do my
cousin Anguk injected us with cow medicines which he brought from
the village. Some of us positively responded to the medicine and
became better; some unfortunately died. My story was used in the
script and movie when Daniel becomes sick.
Just few days before we arrived in Ethiopia, we ran out of water
and became thirsty. We dug out roots of trees we could lay our hands
on; and chew them to quench our thirst. When I saw my cousin Anguk
urinating, I ran with my gourd to collect his urine and drank it. The
urine was bitter, but I did not want to die. Other boys followed my
idea and started drinking urine from those who had water and could
urinate. I could not imagine water I had taken for granted was so
precious! My story was used in the script and movie when the boys
drank urine.
37
106. For example, Plaintiff Awino Gam emigrated to Atlanta in 2001 and
met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following story:
I was privileged to star in Tears of the Sun and to meet with
Late Bobby Newmyer in LA. Here is my contribution to the script:
One day my friends Mawei, Deng, and Wel- and I were playing
Adaw (a traditional sport which resembles baseball, but we use
rounded wood instead of ball and sticks instead of bats) at the village
outskirt. The village was hidden from our view by tall tropical
grasses, but we could hear people talking and women pounding grains
on mortars and pestle. My team with Mawei was winning, I was
overjoyed. At the peak of our game, we heard some gun shots coming
from our village and commotion of fleeing villagers. Deng who was
the oldest boy told us to hide among tall grass. Before he hid himself,
the Arab soldiers caught up with him. They asked Deng of
whereabouts of everybody and he told them he did not know. The
soldiers took him away and we remained hiding. Dengs lie saved us.
Mawei, Dengs younger brother was heartbroken and he cried so hard
that we joined him. Deng was a good friend and brother to Mawei;
both brothers were very close. Mawei, Wel and I decided to run
38
eastward for safety. We walked for two days before seeing huge
number of boys from other villages crossing the river. We joined them
and walked together until we arrived in Ethiopia. I took it as my
responsibility to look out for Mawei whose older brother lied to save
from us. He became my younger brother instead of a friend. We
would cook and eat together. Hard life of refugee camp made us to be
closer. I even made a promise to Mawei that I would die for him. My
story was used in the script and movie when a boy surrendered to
Arab soldiers and motioned the other boys to keep quiet.
In 1991 while being chased out of Ethiopia at gun point, young
Mawei and I came to the border of Sudan and Ethiopia. The trees and
grass were tall; you could not see beyond 10 feet ahead. Out of this
grass jumped huge brown male lion and grabbed Mawei by left leg
and tried to pull in to the bushes. At first I was scared and wanted to
run then I remembered the promise I made to Mawei and how his
brother lied to save my life. At that point I mustered all the courage I
had and came charging at the lion with my hands rolled in to fists. The
lion let go of Mawei and confronted me instead. The lion tore off a
flesh on arm and knocked me down ready to finish me. However, the
39
boys who had heard Mawei crying for help came to my rescue me.
Today when I see the scar, I remember my promise to Mawei. Mawei
and I came to the US together and became roommates. My story was
used in the script and movie when Paul narrated how he got the scar
on his arms to his coworkers.
107. For example, Plaintiff Abraham Chol Machol emigrated to Atlanta in
2001 and met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following
story:
The process of resettlement to US- which involved series of
interviews with various sub agencies of INS (Immigration and
Naturalization Services) and medical screening was long and
unstructured. We had to stop going to school because interview
notices were posted on the board which was located few miles away
from our camp. So, we had to frequent the board to see if our names
were posted for interviews or flight. The visits to the notice board
were both exciting and discouraging depending on whether your name
was posted or not . After making several of these discouraging visits
to the notice board, I became totally hopeless of possibility of flying
out of this godforsaken camp. I had concluded either my case had
40
41
42
Malual Mayom Ruai. Up on hearing my name this nice mans face lit
up and before I knew he ordered his people to ferry me across the
river on their boat. He later told me he was my relative and that he
commended me for stating my full name. Once on the safe side of
Gilo River, I thanked my father for taking time to teach me my
genealogy; for a simple lesson which I took for granted saved. Right
then, I promised to teach my genealogy to my children if I had any in
future. My story was used in the script and movie when the boys
would recite their ancestors names.
109. For example, Plaintiff Andrew Majok Marier emigrated to Atlanta in
2001 and met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following
story:
I am a Deputy Chairperson of the Lost Boys and Girls of
Georgia. Here is the story that I contributed: Looking back to the
episodes of Gilo River, one would not help it but laugh of miracles
that happened. While on the safe side of the river, I would watch boys
going down in to the bottom of the river. I would see dead bodies
floating on the river, and people crying with help. But, then I saw my
friend Mawet, who was stranded on the other side of the river,
43
44
45
him a sick which he would use to scare away hyenas which come to
attack him. After my brother gave him the stick, we took off with the
baby. My story was used in the script and movie when a wounded old
man asked the boys to give him stick, to take the child and to run
towards Kenya.
112. For example, Plaintiff Simon Deng emigrated to Atlanta in 2001 and
met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following story:
Upon arriving in Atlanta on May 2nd, 2001, we were taken to
Jubilee Partners. During our three-month stay at Jubilee Partners we
were trained on how to turn on and off light switch, an experience
which fascinated us ; in the camp we would use a can lamp to see at
night, there were no electric light . We also attended ESOL and life
skill classes. My story was used in the script and movie when the
caseworker in the apartment gave the boys a crash course on how to
turn the light on and off.
113. For example, Plaintiff Agany Akot emigrated to Atlanta in 2001 and
met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following story:
When I was in Gokrial village, I was a goat herder. It was not
easy job. Sometimes, the goats would stray in to other peoples farms
46
and eat the crops; and the farmers would come out and beat us up. So,
to avoid getting beaten we decided to hold hands to barricade goats
from destroying peoples farms. Handholding became part of us. In
the wilderness on our way to Ethiopia, we would hold hands together
to ensure we stay together. We continued to hold hands until
American friend told us it was considered gay-like behavior. I miss it!
My story was used in the script and movie when boys would sleep
holding hands; and at the ranch when the boys asked to visit the cows.
114. For example, Plaintiff Luka Thiik emigrated to Atlanta in 2001 and
met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following story:
Upon boarding plane in Nairobi, Kenya I was so happy. I knew
I was finally going to America after long wait and anxiousness. It
was an opportunity of life time! But, my happiness was short lived by
sickness on the plane. Plane foods, chicken, broccoli, butter, were
strange. Nothing resembled our meal of corns and beans. I decided
not to eat, but the hunger became so unbearable that I asked flight
attendant to give me something to eat. She came back with chicken,
broccoli and butter. I started with butter, but it tasted salty and
greasy; I put it down. I ate some chicken and broccoli. None tasted
47
like food. No sooner did I finish eating this strange food, than I
became sick. I went to the restroom and threw up and all over the
sudden I became unconscious. I stumbled back to my seat and
remained unconscious for the remaining part of the trip. Upon
landing at JFK airport was I rushed to the hospital where I was
hooked to drip for 8 hours. My other friends were sick too, but less
serious than I. My story was used in the script and movie when Paul
ate butter and Jeremiah got sick on the ride to their apartment.
115. For example, Plaintiff Madau Goi emigrated to Atlanta in 2001 and
met with Nagle and Newmyer in 2003 in Atlanta and told the following story:
One day in Duke in 1987, while playing soccer with friends the
Arab soldiers sneaked on us. One of the men I believe their
commanding officer asked us to stop playing and to listen. We
stopped and gathered to listen; it was too late for us to run so we
complied. He said the country was under attack from SPLA rebels and
that It was a duty of every citizen to defend the country. And he
singled me out since I was the tallest and most muscular boy. In my
heart, I knew the rebels were not bad people; they were members of
our communities who had rebelled against the government for the
48
49
50
51
to
be
used
in
screenplay
written
by
Nagle
and
Outlaw
52
122. The Contributing Lost Boys performed pursuant to the terms of the
Joint Venture Agreement by participating in the Interviews with Nagle.
123. The Screenplay created pursuant to the terms of the Joint Venture
Agreement was made into a film, to wit, The Good Lie, which was released on
October 3, 2014.
124. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver breached the Joint
Venture Agreement governing the Joint Venture because they marketed, sold, and
allowed the Screenplay to be made into a film without the Contributing Lost Boys
knowledge or consent.
125. The Contributing Lost Boys assigned all of their rights to bring claims
against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver to the Foundation.
126. Furthermore, the Foundation is an intended third-party beneficiary to
the Joint Venture Agreement.
127. As a result of Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silvers
breach of contract, the Foundation has been damaged in an amount to be proven at
trial.
128. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver have acted in bad
faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Foundation unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow the Foundation to recover its reasonable
53
54
132. The Contributing Lost Boys, Nagel and Newmyer agreed that the
Screenplay would be property of the Joint Venture.
133. Works by multiple authors are considered a joint work when the
contributions are inseparable rather than interdependent. [I]f author Bs
contribution when combined with author As contribution results in recasting,
transforming or adapting As contribution, then the two contributions may be said
to be inseparable. If the process is simply one of assembling into a collective whole
As and Bs respective contributions, without thereby recasting As contribution,
then the two contributions may be said to be interdependent. M.G.B. Homes, Inc.
v. Ameron Homes, Inc., 903 F.2d 1486, 1493 (11th Cir. 1990) (quoting 1 Melville
B. Nimmer & David Nimmer, Nimmer on Copyright 6.04 at 6-11 (1989)).
134. The Contributing Lost Boys, Nagle, Newmyer, and Outlaw
Productions agreed to make individualized contributions to the Interviews.
135. Their contributions merged into inseparable parts of a unitary whole
(the Interviews), as Nagle and Newmyers contributions (the questions and the
phrasing of such questions) when combined with The Contributing Lost Boys
contribution (the answers to the questions) resulted in recasting The Contributing
Lost Boys contribution.
136. The Interviews constitute a joint work pursuant to 17 U.S.C. 101.
55
56
57
153. Nagle created a derivative work from the Interviews, to wit the
screenplay for The Good Lie2, which included the Contributing Lost Boys
individualized contributions.
154. As joint authors, the Contributing Lost Boys have rights including, but
not limited to, the right to reproduce, prepare derivative works, distribute, perform,
and display the Interviews; the right to participate in negotiations of exclusive
licenses for the publication of the Interviews; and the right to receive royalties and
profits from the exploitation of the Interviews.
155. However, joint authors do not have an unfettered license to use
original material provided by other joint authors without consent.
156. Even though Nagle, Newmyer, and Outlaw Productions own a
copyright in the Screenplay, that copyright is limited: the copyright in the
derivative work extends only to the material contributed by the author of such
work, as distinguished from the preexisting material employed in the work, and
does not imply any exclusive right in the preexisting material. 17 U.S.C. 103.
The copyright in such work is independent of, and does not affect or enlarge the
scope, duration, ownership, or subsistence of, any copyright protection in the
preexisting material. 17 U.S.C. 103
2
Black Label Media registered a copyright for the motion picture The Good Lie on
or about October 10, 2014.
58
59
without the permission of the owner of the original work copyright prevents
unauthorized copying or other infringing use of the underlying work or any part of
that work contained in the derivative product so long as the underlying work itself
remains copyrighted).
159.
Nagle, Newmyer, and Outlaw Productions permission to use the Interviews for
future derivative works other than the Screenplay, such as a movie, the Court looks
to the parties contract. See 1 NIMMER, supra, 3.04 (The rights between the
underlying copyright owner and derivative owner should be determined by the
contract between them.).
160. The Joint Venture Agreement contains no language granting Nagle or
Outlaw Productions any copyright in the Contributing Lost Boys originals stories
or granting Nagle or Outlaw Productions a license to use the underlying material
from the Interviews to make a movie. To the contrary, the Joint Venture
Agreement expressly provided that no film would be produced from the
Screenplay unless and until the Contributing Lost Boys consented.
161. The Contributing Lost Boys have assigned all of their rights in the
Interviews, and any derivatives thereof, to the Foundation.
60
61
expenses of litigation; and affording all further relief the Court deems just and
appropriate.
COUNT III: INJUNCTIVE RELIEF AND SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE
Against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver
165. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 148 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
166. The Contributing Lost Boys, Nagle, Newmyer, and Outlaw
Productions are co-owners of the copyright in the Interviews and in the Screenplay.
167. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, Newmyer, and the Contributing Lost
Boys share the exclusive rights granted works under 17 U.S.C. 103, 106.
168. Nagle created a derivative work from the Interviews and Screenplay,
to wit the script for The Good Lie, which included the Contributing Lost Boys
individualized contributions.
169. The Contributing Lost Boys have assigned all of their rights in the
Interviews, the Screenplay, and any derivatives thereof, to the Foundation.
170. Any court having jurisdiction of a civil action arising under this title
may . . . grant temporary and final injunctions on such terms as it may deem
reasonable to prevent or restrain infringement of a copyright. 17 U.S.C. 502(a).
62
63
copies of the Screenplay and the Interviews allowing the Foundation to apply for
copyright registrations.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs request this Court issue an injunction prohibiting
Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver from registering a copyright of
the screenplay for The Good Lie without giving credit to the Contributing Lost
Boys as co-authors or obtaining permission from the Foundation; requiring Nagle,
Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Nagle to provide the Foundation with copies of
the Interviews; requiring Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver to
provide the Foundation with a copy of the Screenplay; requiring Nagle, Outlaw
Productions, the Estate, and Silver to pay Plaintiffs attorneys fees, costs, and
expenses of litigation; and affording all further relief the Court deems just and
appropriate.
COUNT IV: BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY
Against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver
176. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 116 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
177. Plaintiffs and Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver
entered a joint venture when they combined their labor and property in a joint
64
undertaking for profit with rights of mutual control, namely through creation of the
Screenplay from the Interviews. Kissun v. Humana, Inc., 267 Ga. 419, 420 (1997)
(citing Boatman v. George Hyman Constr. Co., 157 Ga. App. 120, 123 (276 S.E.2d
272) (1981)).
178. Under Georgia law, a joint venture is governed by the same rules as a
partnership. Therefore, Plaintiffs are owed the same duties as if Plaintiffs and
Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver had entered a common law
partnership. Vitner v. Funk, 182 Ga. App. 39, 42 (1987) (applying partnership rules
of formation to a joint enterprise); see Murphey, Taylor & Ellis v. Williams, 223
Ga. 99, 102-103 (1967) (applying partnership agency principles to a joint venture).
179. Therefore, Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver owe the
highest fiduciary duty of loyalty to the Plaintiffs. These fiduciary duties forbid
joint adventurers from (i) wasting business assets, (ii) engaging in self-dealing of
any kind to the detriment of the joint venture or any joint adventurer, (iii) usurping
joint venture opportunities for ones own benefit; or (iv) appropriating the assets
and property of the business to the exclusion of the other joint adventurers. See
Vinter, 182 Ga. App. at 42 (stating that the distinction between a joint venture and
partnership is not crucial and the same general rules apply).
65
180. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver breached their
fiduciary duties to Plaintiffs by, inter alia, (i) failing to properly account for
profits; (ii) depriving Plaintiffs of a corporate opportunity for the joint venture,
namely participation in the creation of the Movie; and (iii) appropriating the assets
and property of the business, the Screenplay, to the exclusion of the Contributing
Lost Boys.
181. By virtue of Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silvers
breach of fiduciary duties, the Plaintiffs are entitled to damages in an amount to be
proven with certainty at trial.
182. As partners in Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver are liable for
all of Outlaw Productions obligations pursuant to Cal. Corp. Code. 16306.
183. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver have acted in bad
faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Plaintiffs unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow the Plaintiffs to recover their reasonable
expenses and attorneys fees pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
184. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silvers violations of their
fiduciary duties to the Plaintiffs constituted willful misconduct, malice, fraud,
wantonness, oppression, or that entire want of care which would raise a presumption
66
67
187. Under Georgia law, a joint venture is governed by the same rules as a
partnership. Therefore, Plaintiffs are owed the same duties as if Plaintiffs and
Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver had entered a common law
partnership. Vitner v. Funk, 182 Ga. App. 39, 42 (1987) (applying partnership rules
of formation to a joint enterprise); see Murphey, Taylor & Ellis v. Williams, 223
Ga. 99, 102-103 (1967) (applying partnership agency principles to a joint venture).
188. As such, Plaintiffs have been wrongfully excluded from the joint
venture business by Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver, the joint
adventurers, within the meaning of O.C.G.A. 14-8-22(1); see Vinter, 182 Ga.
App. at 42 (stating that the distinction between a joint venture and partnership is
not crucial and the same general rules apply).
189. Pursuant to O.C.G.A. 14-8-8, the Joint Venture owns all rights in
the Screenplay.
190. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver sold the Screenplay
without the Contributing Lost Boys knowledge or consent and without accounting
to the Contributing Lost Boys for profits earned from the unauthorized sale.
191. Plaintiffs are entitled to a formal accounting as to joint venture affairs
pursuant to O.C.G.A. 14-8-22.
68
192. As partners in Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver are liable for
all of Outlaw Productions obligations pursuant to Cal. Corp. Code. 16306.
193. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver have acted in bad
faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused Plaintiffs unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow Plaintiffs to recover their reasonable expenses
and attorneys fees pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs request the Court order a formal accounting as to
partnership affairs pursuant to O.C.G.A. 14-8-22, and award Plaintiffs their
reasonable expenses and attorneys fees pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11, and for
such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.
COUNT VI: CONVERSION OF PLAINTIFFS IDEAS
Against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver
194. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 116 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
195. A conversion of idea claim in Georgia exists when a defendant
wrongfully uses an idea shared by the plaintiff without permission or
compensation.
69
196. To state a claim for conversion of idea, (1) the idea must be novel; (2)
the disclosure of the idea must be made in confidence; (3) the idea must be adopted
and made use of by the defendant; and (4) the idea must be sufficiently concrete in
its development to be usable. See Wilson v. Barton & Ludwig, Inc., 163 Ga. App.
721, 723 (1982). See also Ctr. for Transp. & the Env't, Inc. v. Georgia Aquarium,
Inc., 2006 WL 278389, at *3 (N.D. Ga. Feb. 1, 2006).
197. The Contributing Lost Boys shared novel ideas, the specific details of
their life stories, with Defendants Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and
Silver.
198. The Contributing Lost Boys shared the ideas with Defendants Nagle,
Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver in confidence and with the
understanding that the Contributing Lost Boys and the Foundation would receive
some compensation for disclosure of the ideas.
199. Defendants Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver used the
ideas to create the screenplay for The Good Lie.
200. The Contributing Lost Boys assigned all of their rights to bring claims
against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver to the Foundation.
201. As a result of Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silvers
conversion, the Foundation has been damaged in an amount to be proven at trial.
70
202. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver have acted in bad
faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Foundation unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow the Foundation to recover its reasonable
attorneys fees and expenses incurred in bringing this action pursuant to
O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
203. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silvers actions were
committed maliciously, intentionally and with a willful and conscious disregard of
the Contributing Lost Boys rights, making an award of punitive damages
appropriate in order to punish and deter Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and
Silver s from engaging in the conduct alleged.
WHEREFORE, the Foundation requests this Court issue a judgment for
damages in an amount to be proven at trial against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the
Estate and Silver for their conversion; punitive damages in an amount to be
determined by the enlightened conscience of an impartial jury; requiring Nagle,
Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver to pay the Foundations attorneys fees,
costs, and expenses of litigation; and affording all further relief the Court deems
just and appropriate.
71
Imagine,
Reliance,
Black
Label
Media,
and
GLP
72
208. In the April 15, 2013 meeting, the Contributing Lost Boys reiterated
the exclusive ownership of their original stories, and the Production Team agreed
to compensate the Contributing Lost Boys for their original stories.
209. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP are third party
beneficiaries of the Joint Venture Agreement.
210. Oral contracts are binding in Georgia. O.C.G.A. 13-1-5(b).
211. Contracts to negotiate are binding in Georgia. The Eleventh Circuit
has held, In addition, as we understand the law, the parties to a contract can agree
to bind themselves by that contract to negotiate in good faith and to work out
within an agreed frameworksome terms that remain open. Of course, Georgia
law imposes an implied duty of good faith and fair dealing for all parties in
contracts. The parties made an enforceable contract although it remained executory
in part. Bommer v. Reynolds, 465 F. Appx 876, 879-80 (11th Cir. 2012).
212. The Contributing Lost Boys performed pursuant to the terms of the
Joint Venture Agreement by participating in the Interviews with Nagle.
213. The Foundation performed pursuant to the terms of the Joint Venture
Agreement by making efforts to negotiate in good faith, including, but not limited
to, requesting mediation with Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, and GLP.
73
214. The Screenplay was made into the Movie, to wit, The Good Lie,
which is scheduled for theatrical release on October 3, 2014.
215. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP breached their
agreements to the Contributing Lost Boys and to the Foundation because they
produced the Movie from the script the Contributing Lost Boys helped create
without their consent and without negotiating in good faith the terms of a
compensatory donation to the Foundation and because all charitable donations and
funds raised from the script and movie were directed to a non-profit foundation
other than one organized and operated by the Contributing Lost Boys.
216. The Contributing Lost Boys assigned all of their rights to bring
contractual and other claims against Alcon, Imagine, Reliance, Black Label Media
and GLP to the Foundation.
217. Furthermore, the Foundation is an intended third-party beneficiary to
the Joint Venture Agreement.
218. As a result of Alcon, Imagine, Black Label Media, Reliance and
GLPs breach of contract, the Foundation has been damaged in an amount to be
determined at trial.
219. Alcon, Imagine, Black Label Media, Reliance and GLP have acted in
bad faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Foundation
74
75
76
77
78
79
238. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLPs breach of
the Joint Venture Agreement is not the result of an honest mistake, bad judgment
or negligence, but rather a conscious, selfish, and deliberate act, which unfairly
frustrates the agreed common purpose and disappoints the reasonable expectations
of Plaintiffs, depriving Plaintiffs of the benefits of the Joint Venture Agreement.
239. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP have acted in
bad faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused Plaintiffs unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow Plaintiffs to recover their reasonable attorneys
fees and expenses incurred in bringing this action pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment against Alcon, Reliance, Black
Label Media, Imagine and GLP in an amount to be proven at trial, post-judgment
interest as allowed by law, their reasonable expenses and attorneys fees incurred
in bringing this action, together with all costs, pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11, and
such other and further relief as this Court deems just and proper.
ALTERNATE COUNT XI: UNJUST ENRICHMENT
Against Alcon, Reliance, Imagine, Black Label Media and GLP
240. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 116 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
80
241. The elements of an unjust enrichment claim are: (1) the plaintiff
conferred a benefit on the defendant, and (2) equity requires the defendant to
compensate the plaintiff. See Chem-Nuclear Sys., Inc. v. Arivec Chemicals, Inc.,
978 F. Supp. 1105, 1110 (N.D. Ga. 1997).
242. The theory of unjust enrichment applies when there is no legal
contract and when there has been a benefit conferred which would result in an
unjust enrichment unless compensated. Cochran v. Ogletree, 244 Ga. App. 537,
538 (2000).
243. The Contributing Lost Boys participated in the Interviews with Nagle.
Nagle took the Contributing Lost Boys personal stories and used them to create
the script for The Good Lie.
244. As producers, Alcon, Reliance, Imagine, Black Label Media and GLP
will earn substantial revenues from The Good Lie.
245. At least a portion of revenue Alcon, Reliance, Imagine, Black Label
Media and GLP earn for The Good Lie is directly attributable to the Contributing
Lost Boys assistance with the script.
246. In the April 15, 2013 meeting, the Contributing Lost Boys reiterated
the exclusive ownership of their original stories, and the Production Team agreed
to compensate the Contributing Lost Boys for their original stories.
81
82
O.C.G.A. 13-6-11, and such other and further relief as this Court deems just and
proper.
ALTERNATE COUNT XII: UNJUST ENRICHMENT
Against Nagel, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver
251. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 116 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
252. The elements of an unjust enrichment claim are: (1) the plaintiff
conferred a benefit on the defendant, and (2) equity requires the defendant to
compensate the plaintiff. See Chem-Nuclear Sys., Inc. v. Arivec Chemicals, Inc.,
978 F. Supp. 1105, 1110 (N.D. Ga. 1997).
253. The theory of unjust enrichment applies when there is no legal
contract and when there has been a benefit conferred which would result in an
unjust enrichment unless compensated. Cochran v. Ogletree, 244 Ga. App. 537,
538 (2000).
254. The Contributing Lost Boys participated in the Interviews with Nagle.
Nagle took the Contributing Lost Boys personal stories and used them to create
the script for The Good Lie.
83
255. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver have earned and
will earn substantial revenues from The Good Lie.
256. At least a portion of revenue Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate,
and Silver have earned and will earn for The Good Lie is directly attributable to the
Contributing Lost Boys assistance with the script.
257. The Contributing Lost Boys have not been compensated for their
assistance with the script.
258. Equity requires that Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver
compensate the Contributing Lost Boys for their assistance with The Good Lie.
259. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver have acted in bad
faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Contributing Lost Boys
unnecessary trouble and expense so as to allow the Contributing Lost Boys to
recover their reasonable attorneys fees and expenses incurred in bringing this
action pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
WHEREFORE, the Contributing Lost Boys demand judgment against
Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver in an amount to be proven at
trial, post-judgment interest as allowed by law, their reasonable expenses and
attorneys fees incurred in bringing this action, together with all costs, pursuant to
84
O.C.G.A. 13-6-11, and such other and further relief as this Court deems just and
proper.
ALTERNATE COUNT XIII: QUANTUM MERUIT
Against Alcon, Reliance, Imagine, Black Label Media, and GLP
260. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 116 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
261. The elements of a claim for quantum meruit are: (1) Plaintiffs
performance of services valuable to Defendant;
85
264. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP have not paid
the Contributing Lost Boys for their contributions to The Good Lie or their
participation in the Interviews. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and
GLPs receipt of the Contributing Lost Boys services without payment is unjust.
265. Nagle and Outlaw Productions told the Contributing Lost Boys that
they would be compensated for participation in the Interviews, and Alcon,
Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP assumed Nagle and Outlaw
Productions obligations to pay the Contributing Lost Boys.
266. When confronted during a videotaped meeting on April 15, 2013,
Molly Smith, of Black Label Media, LLC, said, The most important thing that
was said here today was you asked a question, Do you feel we should be
compensated for your story? And, the answer I can say, because its my company
and my studio, is absolutely.
267. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP have acted in
bad faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Contributing Lost
Boys unnecessary trouble and expense so as to allow the Contributing Lost Boys to
recover their reasonable attorneys fees and expenses incurred in bringing this
action pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
86
87
88
O.C.G.A. 13-6-11, and such other and further relief as this Court deems just and
proper.
ALTERNATE COUNT XV: PROMISSORY ESTOPPEL
Against Alcon, Reliance, Imagine, Black Label Media, and GLP
276. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 116 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
277. In the April 15, 2013 meeting, the Contributing Lost Boys reiterated
the exclusive ownership of their original stories, and the Production Team agreed
to compensate the Contributing Lost Boys for their original stories.
278. When confronted during a videotaped meeting on April 15, 2013,
Molly Smith, of Black Label Media, LLC, said, The most important thing that
was said here today was you asked a question, Do you feel we should be
compensated for your story? And, the answer I can say, because its my company
and my studio, is absolutely.
279. Pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-3-44(a), A promise which the promisor
should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance on the part of the
promisee or a third person and which does induce such action or forbearance is
89
90
284. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP made certain
promises to the Plaintiffs, to wit, promising to negotiate the amount of payment for
the Contributing Lost Boys life stories.
285. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP should have
known that Plaintiffs would rely on such promises.
286. Plaintiffs relied on such promises to their detriment.
287. Injustice can only be avoided by enforcement of the promise.
288. Alcon, Reliance, Black Label Media, Imagine and GLP have acted in
bad faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused Plaintiffs unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow Plaintiffs to recover their reasonable attorneys
fees and expenses incurred in bringing this action pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment against Alcon, Reliance, Black
Label Media, Imagine and GLP in an amount to be proven at trial, post-judgment
interest as allowed by law, their reasonable expenses and attorneys fees incurred
in bringing this action, together with all costs, pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11, and
such other and further relief as this Court deems just and proper.
91
92
293. [T]he fact that [a promise] is performable in the future does not
preclude the application of promissory estoppel. Hendon Props., LLC v. Cinema
Dev., LLC, 275 Ga. App. 434, 440 (2005).
294. Promissory estoppel cannot be applied unless the promisee
reasonably relied on the promise. Poindexter v. Am. Bd. of Surgery, Inc., 911 F.
Supp. 1510, 1523 (N.D. Ga. 1994) (citing Fidelity & Deposit Co. v. West Point
Constr. Co., 178 Ga. App. 578, 580 (1986)).
295. Nagle and Outlaw Productions promised the Contributing Lost Boys
that the Screenplay would not be made into a movie without their consent.
296. Nagle and Outlaw Productions should have known that the
Contributing Lost Boys would rely on such promises.
297. The Contributing Lost Boys relied on such promises to their
detriment.
298. Injustice can only be avoided by enforcement of the promise.
299. As partners in Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver are liable for
all of Outlaw Productions obligations pursuant to Cal. Corp. Code. 16306.
300. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver have acted in bad
faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Foundation unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow the Foundation to recover its reasonable
93
attorneys fees and expenses incurred in bringing this action pursuant to O.C.G.A.
13-6-11.
WHEREFORE, the Foundation demands judgment against Nagle, Outlaw
Productions, the Estate, and Silver in an amount to be proven at trial, postjudgment interest as allowed by law, its reasonable expenses and attorneys fees
incurred in bringing this action, together with all costs, pursuant to O.C.G.A. 136-11, and such other and further relief as this Court deems just and proper.
COUNT XVII: FRAUDULENT INDUCEMENT
Against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver
301. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 116 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
302. In Georgia, the elements of fraudulent inducement are:
a.
b.
Scienter;
c.
from acting;
d.
e.
Damages.
94
See Worsham v. Provident Companies, Inc., 249 F. Supp. 2d 1325, 1331 (N.D. Ga.
2002); Denim N. Am. Holdings, LLC v. Swift Textiles, LLC, 816 F. Supp. 2d 1308,
1320 (M.D. Ga. 2011).
303. Although actionable fraud cannot be based on statements and
promises as to future events, there is an exception to this proposition, which is that
fraud may be predicated on a promise made with a present intention not to
perform. Kirkland v. Pioneer Mach., Inc., 243 Ga. App. 694, 695 (2000).
304. Nagle and Outlaw Productions made a false representation of existing
material facts to the Contributing Lost Boys that no film would be produced from
the Screenplay unless and until the Contributing Lost Boys consented after
agreeing on the compensation arrangement with the producers/studios.
305. The Contributing Lost Boys justifiably relied upon Nagle and Outlaw
Productions promise and subsequently participated in the Interviews.
306. At the time of the misrepresentation, the Nagle and Outlaw
Productions had the intention not to perform the promised act. Nagle and Outlaw
Productions intended to deceive the Contributing Lost Boys.
307. The Contributing Lost Boys have suffered damage proximately
caused by Nagle and Outlaw Productions fraud.
95
308. As partners in Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver are liable
jointly and severally for all obligations of the partnership pursuant to Cal. Corp.
Code 16306.
309. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silver have acted in bad
faith, have been stubbornly litigious, and have caused the Foundation unnecessary
trouble and expense so as to allow the Contributing Lost Boys to recover their
reasonable attorneys fees and expenses incurred in bringing this action pursuant to
O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
310. Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate, and Silvers actions
constituted willful misconduct, malice, fraud, wantonness, oppression, or that
entire want of care which would raise a presumption of conscious indifference to
consequences so as to authorize an award of punitive damages in order to deter
such willful misconduct.
WHEREFORE, the Contributing Lost Boys request that this Court issue a
judgment against Nagle, Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver for damages in
an amount to be proven at trial for their promissory fraud and for punitive damages
in an amount determined by the enlightened conscious of the jury; requiring Nagle,
Outlaw Productions, the Estate and Silver to pay the Contributing Lost Boys
96
attorneys fees, costs, and expenses of litigation; and affording all further relief the
Court deems just and appropriate.
COUNT XVIII: FRAUDULENT INDUCEMENT
Against Alcon, Imagine, Reliance, Black Label Media and GLP
311. Plaintiffs reallege and restate the allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 74 of this complaint against Defendants with the same force and effect as
if they had been fully restated.
312. In Georgia, the elements of fraudulent inducement are:
a.
b.
Scienter;
c.
from acting;
d.
e.
Damages.
See Worsham v. Provident Companies, Inc., 249 F. Supp. 2d 1325, 1331 (N.D. Ga.
2002); Denim N. Am. Holdings, LLC v. Swift Textiles, LLC, 816 F. Supp. 2d 1308,
1320 (M.D. Ga. 2011).
313. Although actionable fraud cannot be based on statements and
promises as to future events, there is an exception to this proposition, which is that
97
98
Contributing Lost Boys and the Foundation to recover their reasonable attorneys
fees and expenses incurred in bringing this action pursuant to O.C.G.A. 13-6-11.
319. Alcon, Imagine, Black Label Media, Reliance and GLPs actions
constituted willful misconduct, malice, fraud, wantonness, oppression, or that
entire want of care which would raise a presumption of conscious indifference to
consequences so as to authorize an award of punitive damages in order to deter
such willful misconduct.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs request this Court issue a judgment against Alcon,
Imagine, Black Label Media, Reliance and GLP for their promissory fraud and for
punitive damages in an amount determined by the enlightened conscious of the
jury; requiring Alcon, Imagine, Black Label Media, Reliance and GLP to pay the
Plaintiffs attorneys fees, costs, and expenses of litigation; and affording all
further relief the Court deems just and appropriate.
Respectfully submitted,
This 19th day of February, 2015.
/s/ Jason W. Graham
Jason W. Graham
Ga. Bar No. 304595
[email protected]
Raegan M. King
Ga. Bar No. 812035
[email protected]
T. Brandon Welch
99
100
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE
This is to certify that the foregoing document has been prepared in Times
New Roman, 14-point font in accordance with LR 5.1 and LR 7.1(d).
Respectfully submitted,
This 19th day of February, 2015.
/s/ Jason W. Graham
Jason W. Graham
Ga. Bar No. 304595
[email protected]
Raegan M. King
Ga. Bar No. 812035
[email protected]
T. Brandon Welch
Ga. Bar No. 152409
[email protected]
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Graham & Jensen, LLP
17 Executive Park Drive, Suite 115
Atlanta, Georgia 30329
Phone: (404) 842-9380
Fax: (678) 904-3110
101