Levi S Personal Pair Jeans A
Levi S Personal Pair Jeans A
12/98
In 1995, womens jeans was a $2 billion fashion category in the US and growing fast.
Levi-Strauss was the market leader, but its traditional dominant position was under heavy attack.
Standard Levis womens jeans, sold in 51 size combinations (waist and inseam), had been the
industry leading product for decades, but fashion was now taking over the category. Market
research showed that only 24 percent of women were fully satisfied with their purchase of
standard jeans at about $50 per pair.
Fashion in jeans meant more styles, more colors, and better fit. All of these combined
to create a level of product line complexity that was a nightmare for manufacturing-oriented,
push-based companies like Strauss. By 1995, Strauss operated 19 Original Levis retail stores
across the country (2,000 to 3,000 square foot mall stores) to put them in closer touch with the
ultimate customers. But this channel was a very small part of their overall $6 Billion sales which
were still primarily to distributors and/or independent retailers. Exhibit 1 shows Levis financial
footprint.
CO
PY
This case was written by Professors Lawrence Carr, William Lawler and John Shank of the F.W. Olin Graduate School of
Business at Babson College., as a basis for class discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling
of an administrative situation . It is based on publicly available information.
Copyright 1997 by Lawrence Carr , William Lawler, and John Shank and licensed for publication to Harvard Business
School Publishing. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, call (800) 545-7685 or write Harvard
Business School Publishing, Boston, MA 02163. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval
system, used in a spreadsheet, or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying,
recording, or otherwise without the permission of copyright holders.
BAB020
possible by a partnership with Custom Clothing Technology Corp. (CCTC), a small Newton,
MA-based software firm specializing in client/server applications linking point of sale custom
fitting programs directly with single ply cutting programs in apparel factories. The new process
operated as follows:
1.
The Personal Pair kiosk was a separate booth in the retail store,
staffed by specially-trained sales clerks and equipped with touch
screen PCs.
3.
2.
Within one or two tries, the customer was wearing the best available
prototype. Then the sales clerk used the tape again to determine the
exact measurements for the customer (4224 possible combinations)
and to note the length required (inseam).
5.
The sales clerk entered the 4 final measurements in the touch screen and
recorded the order. Initially, the system was available only for the Levis 512
style, but 5 color choices were offered in both tapered and boot cut legs.
6.
The customer paid for the jeans and chose either Fed Ex delivery (a $5
extra charge, per pair) or store pick up. Delivery was promised in not
more than three weeks.
7.
4.
CO
Each Personal Pair customer order was transmitted by modem from the kiosk to CCTC
where it was logged and immediately retransmitted directly to a Levis factory in Mountain City,
TN where each pair of jeans was individually cut. In the regular supply chain, patterns were cut
from rolls of denim in stacks 60 layers thick.
PY
After cutting, each pair was hand-sewn, inspected and individually packed for shipment.
Jeans were normally sewn one pair at a time, but there was high WIP at each process stage and
several pairs were made in sequence to minimize change-over time.
Each Personal Pair garment included a sewn-in bar code unique to the customer for
easy re-ordering at the store where the bar code was on file in the kiosk.
Exhibit 3 is a summary of the normal supply chain for jeans sold through the Original
Levis Store distribution channel. The exhibit includes some additional information about
inventories, property and equipment investment, and uncertainties across the chain.
BAB020
Assignment Questions
1. Profitability, for any business can be thought of in terms of the basic Return
on Invested Capital (ROIC) equation:
Revenue - Cost
Profitability =
Working Capital + Property & Equip.
Profit
Investment
Calculate the pretax ROIC for Levi Strauss for both channels shown in Exhibit
2. So what?
2. What impact will the Personal Pair system have on the value chain shown
in Exhibit 3? Be careful to consider how each element of the chain will be
affected, if at all.
3. How would you price the Personal Pair jeans (versus $50 for standard, offthe-shelf jeans)? Would you lower the price, since the customer must wait up
to three weeks for delivery? Would you raise the price, since the fit will be
much better?
4. In general, how will Personal Pair change the various elements of the
financial footprint? Is the overall result a higher or lower ROIC?
5. What is your advice to management regarding the Personal Pair
experiment?
CO
Further expansion?
Extend to other products?
Changes to the system?
Overall evaluation?
PY
3
BAB020
Exhibit 1
LEVI STRAUSS
Taxable
Income
15.0%
x
Tax Rate
40.0%
Net
Income
9.0%
Operating
Profit
15.0%
+/Other
Items
0.0%
Gross Margin
40.0%
S,G & A Exp
25.0%
ROIC
23.4%
ROE
x
38.6%
Investment
Turnover
2.60
Fixed Asset
Turnover
5.33
Working Cap
Turnover
4.60
A/R Collection
Days
51
Inventory
Days
77
Inventory
Turnover
4.73
Payables
Days
27
CO
Financial
Leverage
1.65
Days' Sales
in Cash
30
PY
4
BAB020
Exhibit 2
Profitability Analysis of Womens Jeans
D
O
Operations, per pair
Gross Revenue
Less Markdowns
OLS
Channel
Estimate
$35
(3)
$50
(5)
32
45
Net Revenue
Costs
Cotton
Mfg. Conversion
Distribution
Total COGS
Gross Margin
SG &A
Wholesale
Channel
Estimate
$6 13%
$4
(1)
6
4
7
5
1
0
$13
$12
(1)
7
0
11
5
2
9
20
$38
PY
1.
13%
CO
Distribution PP&E
Retail Store
Total Investment
$4
5
Given
5
High labor content since all jeans hand sewn
1
Large, wholly-owned distribution network
10
20
25 56%
3
19
41%
5
5
9
19
13
2
9
BAB021
LEVI STRAUSS
Exhibit 3
Production
Factory
Warehousing
Design
Research
INVENTORY
Lead-time
Uncertainty
R. M.
Inventory
~15 days
PY
FIXED ASSETS
INVENTORY
VARIETY
Cycle-time
Uncertainty
and
Variation
Demand
Uncertainty
and
Variation
WIP
F.G.
CO
Macro
Demand
Uncertainty
Inventory
~15 days
Heavy Eqp.
Cutting (60 ply)
Sewing
Handling
Packing &
Shipping
Shipping
by Truck
Fleet &
Common
Carrier
Raw
Material
Logistics
Production
Planning
Distrib.
Warehouses
Market
Research
Schedule
Uncertainty
and
Variation
Inventory
~50 days
Demand
Forecasting
Hub &
Spoke
Demand
Uncertainty
and
Variation
Ship to
Retail
Stores
Truck
Fleet
Schedule
Variation
F.G.
Inventory
~100 days
Retail
Outlets
Vehicles
Investment
Real Estate
Investment
Vehicles
Investment
THE
CUSTOMER
Customer
Satisfaction Level?
F.G.
Inventory
~60 days
54% of customers
generate 90% of
sales
Working
Capital
Investment
500 to 1,000
SKU's per
store, based on
local patterns
20,000 SKU's
Sales &
Promotions
Micro
Demand
Uncertainty
Likelihood of Repeat
Purchase?
76% of women
customers not
fully satisfied with
the purchase