Professional Documents
Culture Documents
People of The Philippine Islands Vs
People of The Philippine Islands Vs
G.R.
HELD: No.
PERFECTO
No.
L-18463,
ENDENCIA V. DAVID
93 Phil. 699 Political Law The Judiciary Te
Legislature Separation of Powers
Statutory Construction Who May Interpret Laws
Saturnino David, the then Collector of Internal
Revenue, ordered the taxing of Justice Pastor
Endencias and Justice Fernando Jugos (and other
judges) salary pursuant to Sec. 13 of Republic
Act No. 590 which provides that
No salary wherever received by any public officer
of the Republic of the Philippines shall be
considered
as
exempt
from
the income
tax, payment of which is hereby declared
not to be a diminution of his compensation
fixed by the Constitution or by law.
The judges however argued that under the case
of Perfecto vs Meer, judges are exempt from
taxation this is also in observance of the
doctrine of separation of powers, i.e., the
executive, to which the Internal Revenue reports,
is separate from the judiciary; that under the
Constitution, the judiciary is independent and
the salaries of judges may not be diminished by
the other branches of government; that taxing
theirsalaries is already a diminution of their
benefits/salaries (see
Section
9,
Art.
VIII,
Constitution).
The Solicitor General, arguing in behalf of the CIR,
states that the decision in Perfecto vs Meer was
rendered ineffective when Congress enacted
Republic Act No. 590.
ISSUE: Whether or not Sec 13 of RA 590 is
constitutional.
HELD: No. The said provision is a violation of the
separation of powers. Only courts have the power
to interpret laws. Congress makes laws but courts
interpret them. In Sec. 13, R.A. 590, Congress is
already encroaching upon the functions of the
courts when it inserted the phrase: payment of
Issue:
1. w/n the provisions of the Constitution,
particularly Article XII Section 10, are selfexecuting.
2. w/n the 51% share is part of the national
patrimony.
Held:
A provision which is complete in itself and
becomes
operative
without
the
aid
of
supplementary or enabling legislation, or that
which supplies sufficient rule by means of which
the right it grants may be enjoyed or protected, is
self-executing. Thus a constitutional provision is
self-executing if the nature and extent of the right
conferred and the liability imposed are fixed by
the constitution itself, so that they can be
determined by an examination and construction
of its terms, and there is no language indicating
that the subject is referred to the legislature for
action.
The rule is that a self-executing provision of the
constitution does not necessarily exhaust
legislative power on the subject, but any
legislation must be in harmony with the
constitution, further the exercise of constitutional
right and make it more available. Subsequent
legislation however does not necessarily mean
that the subject constitutional provision is not, by
itself, fully enforceable. Hence, unless it is
expressly provided that a legislative act is
necessary to enforce a constitutional mandate,
the presumption now is that all provisions of the
constitution
are
self-executing.
If
the
constitutional provisions are treated as requiring
legislation
instead
of
self-executing,
the
legislature would have the power to ignore and
practically
nullify
the
mandate
of
the
fundamental law. In fine, Section 10, second
paragraph, Art. XII of the 1987 Constitution is a
mandatory, positive command which is complete
in itself and which needs no further guidelines or
implementing laws or rules for its enforcement.
From its very words the provision does not require
any legislation to put it in operation.
In its plain and ordinary meaning, the term
patrimony pertains to heritage. When the
Constitution speaks of national patrimony, it
refers not only to the natural resources of the
Philippines, as the Constitution could have very
well used the term natural resources, but also to
the cultural heritage of the Filipinos. It also refers
to Filipinos intelligence in arts, sciences and
letters. In the present case, Manila Hotel has
become a landmark, a living testimonial of