Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ENG201 Thill Ch06
ENG201 Thill Ch06
Learning Objectives
AFTER STUDYING THIS CHAPTER, YOU WILL BE ABLE TO
1 Discuss the main tasks involved in completing a business message
2 Explain how to evaluate the elements of your message, and indicate the order
in which to evaluate them
3 Describe four writing techniques you can use to improve the readability of your
messages
4 List nine tips for making your writing clear
5 List four tips for making your message more concise
6 Describe four characteristics of a successful design and explain how four
specific design elements can change a documents appearance
7 Discuss the types of errors to look for when proofreading
Because of permissions issues, some material (e.g., photographs) has been removed from this chapter, though reference to it may
occur in the text. The omitted content was intentionally deleted and is not needed to meet the University's requirements for this
course.
162
Excellence in Business Communication, Sixth Edition, by John V. Thill and Courtland L. Bove. Copyright 2005, 2001 by Bove & Thill LLC. Published by Pearson Prentice Hall, Inc.
On the Job:
COMMUNICATING AT MCDONALDS
163
164
Part II
Once youve completed the first draft of your message, you may be tempted to breathe
a sigh of relief and go on to the next project. Resist the temptation. Professional communicators like David Giarla are aware that the first draft is rarely good enough. In a
first attempt, most writers dont say what they want to sayor dont say it as well as
they could. You owe it to yourself and to your audience to review and refine your messages before sending them. In fact, many writing authorities suggest that you go over a
document several times: one pass for content, organization, style, and tone; one for
readability; and one for clarity and conciseness.
You might wonder whether all this effort to fine-tune a message is worthwhile. But
successful businesspeople care very much about saying precisely the right thing in precisely the right way. Their willingness to go over the same document several times
shows just how important it is to communicate effectively. As Ernest Hemingway once
said, Theres no such thing as writingonly rewriting. Yet, once most businesspeople
have a first draft, they make one of two mistakes: They shuffle words around on the
page rather than actually making improvements, or they think rewriting is too timeconsuming and send the document out the moment that last period hits the page.2
Even after youve fine-tuned your written message, your work is not finished. Look
back at the diagram of the three-step writing process (Figure 41 on page 95). You will
see that completing your message consists of three tasks: revising, producing, and
proofreading your message. Thus, to complete your business message, you must also
check its design and mechanics, as well as distribute it to your audience. Start by evaluating the document as a whole before looking at details. Focusing on the big picture
first is more efficient, since you wont be wasting time perfecting sections that you may
eventually eliminate or change substantially.
When you begin the revision process, youre mainly concerned with content, organization, style, and tone. To evaluate the content, ask yourself these questions:
Is the information accurate?
Is the information relevant to your audience?
Chapter 6
165
Spells out
abbreviated
phrase FG to avoid
confusion
Deletes irrelevant
material to focus
on the main idea
to obtain a corporate discount. We will see to it that your executives are treated
with special courtesy and that they get to use the health club free.
We also have excellent convention facilities and banquet rooms should you
Eliminates
redundancies
Moderates the
excessive enthusiasm
and eliminates words
(such as amenities)
that may be unfamiliar
to reader
Clarifies the
relationships
among ideas
by changing
placement and
combination of
phrases
want to book a convention or meeting here. We hope you and your company will
take advantage of these outstanding world class amenities. Please call me if you
have any questions. I will be happy to answer them.
FIGURE 61
Sample Edited Letter
166
Part II
Once youre satisfied with the content, organization, style, and tone of your message, make a second pass to check its readability. You might even apply a readability
formula to gauge the difficulty of your writing. The most common readability formulas measure the length of words and sentences to give you a rough idea of how
well educated your audience must be to understand your message. Figure 62
shows how one readability formula, the Fog Index, has been applied to an excerpt
from a memo. (For more on this topic, visit www.profusion.com and enter Fog
Index in the search box.) As the calculation shows, anyone who reads at a ninthgrade level should be able to read this passage with ease. For technical documents,
you can aim for an audience that reads at a 12th- to 14th-grade level; for general
business messages, your writing should be geared to readers at the 8th- to 11th-
FIGURE 62
The Fog Index
1. SELECT WRITING SAMPLE
Keep the sample between 100 and 125 words long. (See excerpt.)
EXCERPT
I called Global Corporation to ask when we
will receive copies of its insurance policies
and engineering reports. Cindy Turner of
Global said that they are putting the
documents together and will send them by
Express Mail next week. She told me that
they are late because most of the
information is in the hands of Globals
attorneys in Boston. I asked why it was in
Boston; we had understood that the account
is serviced by the carriers Dallas branch.
Turner explained that the account originally
was sold to Globals Boston division, so all
paperwork stays there. She promised to
phone us when the package is ready
to ship.
Chapter 6
grade level. The Fog Index of popular business publications such as the Wall Street
Journal and Forbes magazine is between 10 and 11.
Readability formulas are easy to apply; many are commonly done by computer.
However, they tend to overvalue condensed prose, and they ignore some important
variables that contribute to reading ease, such as sentence structure, the organization
of ideas, and the appearance of the message on the page.3 Moreover, readability
indexes cant be applied to languages other than English. Counting syllables makes
no sense in other languages. For example, compare the English forklift driver with the
German Gabelstaplerfahrer. Also, Chinese and Japanese characters dont lend themselves to syllable counting at all.4
Of course, most business writers know that busy readers seldom read every word
of a message on their first pass. Instead, they typically skim a message, reading only
certain sections carefully to assess the worthiness of the document. If they determine
that the document contains valuable information or requires a response, they will
read it more carefully when time permits. You can adopt a number of techniques to
make your message easier to skim so that readers can move through the material
more quickly. Varying sentence length, using shorter paragraphs, using lists and bullets instead of narrative, and adding effective headings and subheadings ensure that
your readers will notice key points, even if they do skim messages. These techniques
will also make your message more appealing.
Vary the Sentence Length Variety is the key to making your message interesting and readable. With your words and sentence structure, you create a rhythm
that emphasizes important points, enlivens your writing style, and makes your
information appealing to your reader. Although good business writers use short
sentences most of the time, too many short sentences in a row can make your writing choppy. Conversely, if all your sentences move at the same plodding gait, youre
likely to lull your reader to sleep. So to be interesting, use a variety of both short
and long sentences.
Keep in mind that long sentences are usually harder to understand than short
sentences because they are packed with information that must be absorbed all
at once. Longer sentences are also more difficult to skim. Readers can absorb only a
few words per glance. Thus, the longer your sentence, the greater the possibility that
the reader who skims will not read enough words to process the full meaning.
On the other hand, long sentences are especially well suited for grouping or combining ideas, listing points, and summarizing or previewing information. Mediumlength sentences (those with about 20 words) are useful for showing the relationships
among ideas. Short sentences emphasize important information. Most good business
writing has an average sentence length of 20 words or fewer. (For audiences abroad,
varying sentence length can create translation problems for the reader, so stick to
short sentences in international messages.)5
Keep Paragraphs Short Most business readers are put off by large blocks of text.
Unless you break up your thoughts somehow, youll end up with a three-page paragraph thats guaranteed to intimidate even the most dedicated reader. Short paragraphs (of 100 words or fewer) are easier to read than long ones, and they make your
writing look inviting. Direct-mail letters almost always use very short paragraphs
because the writers know that their letters will be read more carefully that way. Even
in memos, letters, and reports, you may want to emphasize an idea from time to time
by isolating it in a short, forceful paragraph.
As you write your message, try to use a variety of paragraph lengths, but
be careful to use one-sentence paragraphs only occasionally and only for emphasis. When you want to package a big idea in short paragraphs, break the idea
167
168
Part II
Narrative
List
You can separate list items with numbers, letters, or bullets (a general term for
any kind of graphic element that precedes each item). For shorter lists, graphic
elements arent required. However, for longer lists, bullets are preferred over
numbers, unless the sequence of items is important (when the steps in a process
must be completed in a specific order, for example). In the following excerpt, the
three steps need to be performed in the order indicated, and the numbers make
that clear.
Before we bring the day-care issue to a vote, we must gather more
information:
1. Find out how many employees would like on-site day-care
facilities.
2. Determine how much space the day-care center would require.
3. Estimate the cost of converting a conference room for the on-site
facility.
Lists are easier to read if the runovers are indented (aligned with the first word of
the item), as the preceding example demonstrates. You can also indent the entire list.
Furthermore, when using lists, make sure to introduce them clearly so that people
know what theyre about to read. One way to introduce lists is to make them a part of
the introductory sentence.
Chapter 6
169
The board of directors met to discuss the revised annual budget. To keep
expenses in line with declining sales, the directors voted to
Cut everyones salary by 10 percent
Close the employee cafeteria
Reduce travel expenses
If necessary, add further discussion after the lists to complete your thought. Another
way to introduce a list is to use a complete introductory sentence, followed by a colon:
The decline in profits is the result of several factors:
Slower holiday sales
Increased transportation and fuel costs
Higher employee wages
Slower inventory turnover
Regardless of the format you choose, list items should be phrased in parallel form.
For example, if one list item begins with a verb, all list items should begin with a verb.
If one is a noun phrase, all should be noun phrases. Parallel construction shows that
the ideas are related, of similar importance, and on the same level of generality.
Avoid Nonparallel List Items
For additional discussion of parallelism, see Editing for Clarity and Conciseness
later in this chapter.
Add Headings and Subheadings A heading is a brief title that cues readers
about the content of the section that follows. Headings are similar to the subject line
in memos and e-mail correspondence. However, subject lines merely identify the
purpose of the memo or e-mail, whereas headings also advise the reader about the
material included in the paragraph.
Headings serve several important functions:
Organization. Headings show your reader at a glance how the document is organized. They act as labels to group-related paragraphs and organize your material
into short sections.
Attention. Informative, inviting, and in some cases intriguing headings grab
attention, make text easier to read, and help readers find the parts they need to
reador skip.
Connection. Headings and subheadings help readers see the relationship
between subordinate and main ideas. They also visually indicate shifts from one
idea to the next.
170
Part II
Once youve reviewed and revised your message for readability, make sure that your
message is clear. Perhaps a sentence is so cluttered that the reader cant unravel it. Or
perhaps a sentence is so poorly constructed that the reader can interpret it in several
ways. If pronouns or tenses switch midsentence, the reader may lose track of who is
talking or when an event took place. Perhaps sentence B is not a logical sequel to sentence A, or maybe an important word is used incorrectly.6
Ask yourself whether your sentences are easy to decipher. Do your paragraphs
have clear topic sentences? Are the transitions between ideas obvious? Are your statements simple and direct? Remember, a clear sentence is no accident. Few sentences
come out right the first time, or even the third time. See Table 61 for examples of the
following tips:
Break up overly long sentences. Dont connect too many
clauses with and. If you find yourself stuck in a long sentence, youre probably trying to make the sentence do more
than it can reasonably do, such as express two dissimilar
thoughts. You can often clarify your writing style by separating one long sentence into two or more individual sentences.
Even when you sell silly stuff, you want readers to understand
your messages without difficulty. Thats why clear messages
are important to Steve and Sally Colby. From their website at
OfftheDeepEnd.com, the Colbys sell items that run the gamut
from tacky to cheesyincluding flamingo lawn statues and
plastic cockroaches. Their business is innovative, but their
communication is clear.
Table 61
Unacceptable
Preferable
CAMOUFLAGED VERBS
Changing verbs and nouns into
adjectives
Conclude
Discover
Consider
AWKWARD REFERENCES
UNPARALLEL SENTENCES
Using dissimilar construction
for similar ideas
DANGLING MODIFIERS
Placing modifiers close to the
wrong nouns and verbs
SENTENCE STRUCTURE
Separating subject and
predicate
172
Part II
Table 62
ACHIEVING PARALLELISM
Method
Example
Parallel words:
Parallel phrases:
Parallel clauses:
Id like to discuss the issue after Vicki gives her presentation but
before Marvin shows his slides.
Parallel sentences:
Delete unnecessary words and phrases. Avoid words (such as very and rather)
that may act as qualifiers but add nothing new to a sentence.9 Avoid combinations
Table 63
Unacceptable
Preferable
For
If
On
Before
Can
Now
Because
Because
When
About
Absolutely complete
Basic fundamentals
Follows after
Reduce down
Free and clear
Refer back
Repeat again
Collect together
Future plans
Return back
Important essentials
Midway between
End result
Actual truth
Final outcome
Uniquely unusual
Complete
Fundamentals
Follows
Reduce
Free
Refer
Repeat
Collect
Plans
Return
Essentials
Between
Result
Truth
Outcome
Unique
Modern equipment
REDUNDANCIES
Repeating meanings
174
Part II
of words that have more efficient, one-word equivalents. Also, avoid the clutter of
too many or poorly placed relative pronouns (who, that, which). Even articles can
be excessive (mostly too many thes). However, well-placed relative pronouns and
articles prevent confusion.
Shorten long words and phrases. Short words are generally more vivid and easier to read than long ones are. The idea is to use short, simple words, not simple
concepts.10 Plus, by using infinitives in place of some phrases, you not only
shorten your sentences but also make them clearer.
Eliminate redundancies. In some word combinations, the words tend to say the
same thing. For instance, visible to the eye is redundant because visible is
enough; nothing can be visible to the ear.
Recast It is/There are starters. If you start a sentence with an indefinite pronoun (an expletive) such as it or there, odds are that the sentence could be shorter.
As you rewrite, concentrate on how each word contributes to an effective sentence and how that sentence develops a coherent paragraph. As David Giarla cautions, be sure to consider the effect your words will actually have on readers (not just
the effect you plan for them to have). Look for opportunities to make the material
more interesting through the use of strong, lively words and phrases (as discussed in
Chapter 5). For a reminder of the tasks involved in revision, see the Checklist:
Revising Business Messages.
Chapter 6
FIGURE 63
On-Screen Revision Marks
175
176
Part II
means a certain quantity of paper, you simply type quantity AND paper and then
WordHunter searches for every definition in the dictionary that includes those two
terms. In a few seconds, the word ream pops into viewjust the word you were
looking for.
Grammar checkers try to do for your grammar what a spell checker does for your
spelling. The catch is that checking your grammar is much harder than checking
your spelling. A grammar checker must determine whether youre using words correctly and constructing sentences according to the complex rules of composition. But
the program doesnt have a clue about what youre trying to say, so it cant tell
whether youve said it correctly. Even if youve used all the rules correctly, a grammar
checker cant tell whether your document communicates clearly. However, grammar
checkers can perform some helpful review tasks and point out things you should
consider changing, such as passive voice, long sentences, and words that tend to be
misused or overused. Some programs even run readability formulas for you.
By all means, use any software that you find helpful when revising your documents. Just remember that its unwise to rely on grammar checkers or spell checkers
to do all your revision work. What these programs can do is identify mistakes you
may overlook on your own. Its up to you to decide what, if anything, needs to be
done, and its up to you to catch the mistakes that these computer programs cant.11
With the recent advances in computer technology, its becoming easier and easier to
illustrate and enliven your text with full-color pictures, sound recordings, and hypertext links. The software for creating business visuals falls into two basic groups:
Presentation software helps you create overhead transparencies and computerized
slide shows (electronic presentations are discussed in Chapter 13). Graphics software
ranges from products that can create simple diagrams and flowcharts (see Chapter
11) to comprehensive tools geared to artists and graphic designers. You can create
your pictures from scratch, use clip art (collections of uncopyrighted images), or scan
in drawings or photographs.
Adding sound bites to your electronic documents is an exciting new way to get your
message across. Several systems now allow you to record a brief message or other sound
and attach it to particular places in a document. You can also use hypertext markup language (HTML) to insert hyperlinks into your message. Readers can easily jump from
one document to another by clicking on such a link. They can also go directly to a website (provided they have an active Internet hookup). Of course, you must make sure that
the destination file (or the software program used to open that file) is either included
with your electronic document or installed on the recipients computer.
The way you package your ideas has a lot to do with how successful your communication will be. The first thing your readers will notice about your message is its
appearance. If your document looks tired and out of date, it will give that impression
to your readerseven if your ideas are innovative. Good looks can help you get your
message across, especially to busy readers. Consider the memo in Figure 64. The
Chapter 6
177
Adds to a professional
appearance with
colorful letterhead
MEMO
DATE:
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
After doing a little research, Im more convinced than ever that sponsoring a
sporting event would be an excellent way to build awareness of our new
Victorinox line.
Benefits of Sports Sponsorships
The experiences of other companies show that sports sponsorship is
an extremely cost-effective approach to promotion. For example, Volvo found
that it can reach as many people by spending $3 million on tennis tournaments
as it can by spending $25 million on media advertising.
Balances graphics,
text, and color to
create a polished
appearance and to
lend credibility to
your message
Draws attention to
important points with
colorful graphics
Although the mainstream sports currently receive the lions share of corporate dollars, we might achieve more impact with a lesser-known event.
Timberline Company has really scored with its sponsorship of the Iditarod
Dog-Sled Race across Alaska, a contest that appeals to customers for rugged
footwear.
Over the next few days, I plan to do some more research to identify sporting
events that would give us the most exposure among urban professionals with
an active mind-set, who represent our primary market. I plan to pinpoint three
or four possibilities and prepare some preliminary cost estimates for discussion at the Tuesday staff meeting.
FIGURE 64
Effective Document Appearance
bar chart in this memo is centered to give a formal impression, and the color used in
the graphic is balanced by the letterhead logo. Be sure your documents design has
the following characteristics:
Consistency. Throughout a message (and sometimes even from message to message), be consistent in your use of margins, typeface, type size, and spacing (for
example, in paragraph indents, between columns, and around photographs). Also
be consistent when using recurring design elements, such as vertical lines,
columns, and borders.
Balance. To create a pleasing design, balance the space devoted to text, artwork,
and white space.
178
Part II
Restraint. Strive for simplicity in design. Dont clutter your message with too many
design elements, too much highlighting, or too many decorative touches. If you will
be designing a lot of documents that contain a variety of elements, consider taking a
course in page layout, or at least read more about effective design techniques.
Detail. Pay attention to details that affect your design and thus your message. For
instance, headings and subheadings that appear at the bottom of a column or a
page can annoy readers when the promised information doesnt appear until the
next column or page. Also, narrow columns with too much space between words
can be distracting.
To make your message look professional, interesting, and up to date, you can use
a variety of design elements, such as white space, margins and line justification, typefaces, and type styles.
White space is free of text and
artwork.
White Space White space is any space free of text or artwork. It provides visual
contrast for your readers, and perhaps even more important, it gives them a resting
point. White space includes the open area surrounding headings, margin areas, the
vertical space between columns, the space created by ragged line endings, the paragraph indents or extra space between unindented paragraphs, and the horizontal
space between lines of text.
Heading Placement When placing headings and subheadings into your documents,
remember that their purpose is to invite readers to become involved in your message.
Centered heads should contain no more than two lines, since multiple lines will slow
your readers as they search for the beginning of each line. To improve readability,
position your headings flush left (aligned with the left-hand margin). You may even
want to set them in a type size larger than the type used for text and perhaps in a different typeface. Because headings and subheadings clue readers in to the organization
of your messages content, link them as closely as possible to the text they introduce.
You can do so by putting more space above the heading than below it.
Caption Placement Captions are the most widely read part of a document. They tie
photographs and illustrations into the rest of your message. Although usually placed
below the exhibits they describe, captions can also be placed beside or above their
exhibits. Make sure that the width of your captions is pleasing in proportion to the
width of the exhibit, the surrounding white space, and the text.
Margins and Line Justification Margins define the space around your text and
between text columns. Theyre influenced by the way you place lines of type:
Justified (flush on the left and flush on the right). Justified type darkens message appearance (because uniform line lengths lack the white space created by
ragged margins). Justifying tends to make messages look less customized and
more like form letters. Plus, it is often difficult to read because large gaps can
appear between words and more words are hyphenated. Even so, many magazines
and newspapers use it to accommodate more text.
Flush left with a ragged right margin. Flush-left, ragged-right type lightens
your messages appearance. It gives a document an informal, contemporary feeling
of openness. Spacing between words is consistent, and only long words that fall at
the ends of lines are hyphenated.
Centered. Centered type lends a formal tone to your message. However, centering
long blocks of type slows reading because your audience has to search for the
beginning of each line. Avoid centering long passages of text.
Flush right with a ragged left margin. Flush-right, ragged-left type has the
same problems as centered type. Avoid flush-right type for long passages of text.
Chapter 6
179
Table 64
COMMON TYPEFACES
Sample Serif Typeface
Typefaces Typeface refers to the physical design of letters, numbers, and other
text characters. Most computers offer innumerable choices of typefaces, or fonts.
Each typeface influences the tone of your message, making it look authoritative or
friendly, businesslike or casual, classic or modern, and so on. So choose fonts that are
appropriate for your message.
Serif typefaces have small crosslines (called serifs) at the ends of each letter
stroke (see Table 64). Serif faces such as Times Roman (packaged with most laser
printers) are commonly used for text; they can look busy and cluttered when set in
large sizes for headings or other display treatments. Typefaces with rounded serifs can
look friendly; those with squared serifs can look official.
Sans serif typefaces have no crosslines. Faces such as Helvetica and Arial are
ideal for display treatments that use larger type. However, sans serif faces can be difficult to read in long blocks of text. They look best when surrounded by plenty of
white spaceas in headings or in widely spaced lines of text.
Limit the number of typefaces in a single document.12 In general, avoid using
more than two typefaces on a page. Many great-looking documents are based on a
single sans serif typeface for heads and subheads and a second, serif typeface for text
and captions. Using too many typefaces clutters a document and reduces audience
comprehension.
Type Styles Type style refers to any modification that lends contrast or emphasis
to type. Most computers offer boldface, italic, underlining, and other highlighting
and decorative styles. Using boldface type for subheads breaks up long expanses of
text. Just remember that too much boldfacing will darken the appearance of your
message and make it look heavy. You can set isolated words in boldface type in the
middle of a text block to draw more attention to them. If you boldface too many
words, however, you might create a checkerboard appearance in a paragraph.
Use italic type for emphasis. Although italics are sometimes used when irony or
humor is intended, quotation marks are usually best for that purpose. Italics can also
be used to set off a quote and are often used in captions. Boldfaced type and italics are
most effective when reserved for key wordsthose that help readers understand the
main point of the text. A good example of using boldface type effectively is found in
the document-revision tips listed under the heading Editing for Clarity on pages
170172 of this chapter. Here the boldfaced type draws attention to the key tips, followed by a short, regular-typeface explanation of each tip.
As a general rule, avoid using any style that slows your audiences progress
through your message. For instance, using underlining or all-uppercase letters can
interfere with your readers ability to recognize the shapes of words, improperly
placed boldface or too much italicized type can slow down your reader, and shadowed or outlined type can seriously hinder legibility. So use these styles judiciously.
Make sure the size of your type is proportionate to the importance of your message and the space allotted. For most business messages, use a type size of 10 to 12
points (a point is approximately 1/72 of an inch). Resist the temptation to reduce
your type size so that you can squeeze in text. Likewise, avoid enlarging it to fill up
space. Smaller type is hard to read, whereas larger type looks unprofessional and, if
squeezed into a small area, is hard to read and visually claustrophobic.
180
Part II
Most word-processing programs include several elements to help you assemble your
finished pages, combine text and graphics, and create a professional and inviting
appearance. But if you want a first-class report with photos and drawings, consider
desktop publishing (DTP) software, which includes additional specialized tools for
formatting, drawing, design, and layout. Desktop publishing software such as Quark
XPress and Adobe Pagemaker can make it easy for anyone to produce great-looking
documents in two ways:
Adding a first-class finish. You can use DTP to select attractive typefaces, add color
graphics, and turn a plain piece of text into a dazzling and persuasive document.
However, the same technology can turn your document into garish, high-tech rubbish. Knowing how to use technological tools is critical for business communicators.
Managing document style. To maintain consistent style in your document, most
word processors and DTP packages use styles, formatting commands that you can
save and apply as needed. High-end packages collect these commands into style
sheets that save formatting effort, ensure consistency in each section you add to
your report, and ensure a consistent look for all documents created in a department or even in an entire company.
Although spelling, punctuation, and typographical errors seem trivial to some people, most readers view your attention to detail as a sign of your professionalism.
When I get a college rsum and I see a typo on it, I instantly disregard that rsum,
says Adrianne Proeller of Turner Broadcasting System. Whether youre writing a oneparagraph memo or a 500-page report, if you let mechanical errors slip through, your
readers will wonder whether youre unreliable in more important ways.
Proofread your message for correct grammar, usage, and punctuation (for a quick
review, see the Handbook of Grammar, Mechanics, and Usage at the end of this
textbook). Youll also want to be on the lookout for common spelling errors and
typos. Check too for missing material: a missing source note, a missing exhibit, or
even a missing paragraph. Look for design errors; for example, some headings and
text might be in the wrong typeface (Helvetica rather than Times New Roman, or
Arial Black rather than Arial Narrow). One or two special elements may be in the
wrong type style (italic instead of boldface, or underlined instead of italic). Columns
within tables and exhibits on a page might be misaligned. Graphic characters such as
ampersands and percent signs may appear when they should be spelled out, and
numerical symbols might be incorrect. Look for problems in columns of type, such as
extra spacing between lines or between words, crowded type, a short line of type
ending a paragraph at the top of a new page, a heading left hanging at the bottom of
a page, or incorrect hyphenation. (See Sharpening Your Career Skills: How to
Proofread Like a Pro: Tips for Creating the Perfect Document.)
Also, give some attention to your overall format. Have you followed accepted
conventions and company guidelines for laying out the document on the page (margin width, number of columns, running heads)? Have you included all the traditional
elements that belong in documents of the type youre creating? Have you been consistent in handling page numbers, heading styles, exhibit titles, source notes, and
other details? (To resolve questions about format and layout, see Appendix A.)
Chapter 6
181
Mechanics. When looking for errors in spelling, grammar, punctuation, and capitalization, if youre unsure about something,
look it up in a dictionary, a usage book, or another reference.
Accuracy. Double-check the spelling of names and the accuracy of dates, addresses, and all numbers (quantities
ordered, prices, and so on). It would not do to order 500 staplers when you want only 50.
Distance. If you have time, set the document aside and
proofread it the next day.
Vigilance. Avoid reading large amounts of material in one sitting, and try not to proofread when youre tired.
Perceptual tricks. Your brain has been trained to ignore transposed letters, improper capitalization, and misplaced punctuation. Try (1) reading each page from the bottom to the top
(starting at the last word in each line), (2) placing your finger
under each word and reading it silently, (3) making a slit in a
sheet of paper that reveals only one line of type at a time,
and (4) reading the document aloud and pronouncing each
word carefully.
CAREER APPLICATIONS
1. What qualities does a person need to be a good proofreader? Are such qualities inborn, or can they be learned?
2. Proofread the following sentence:
aplication of thse methods in stores in San Deigo nd
Cinncinati have resultted in a 30 drop in roberies an a 50
precent decling in violnce there, acording ot thedevelpers if
the securty sytem, Hanover brothrs, Inc.
Document Makeover
182
Part II
time for each task. Try to stick to your schedule. You want to do your best to create a
perfect document, but you also want to meet your deadline and turn your work in
promptly. As with every task in the writing process, practice helpsyou not only
become more familiar with what errors to look for but also become more skilled in
identifying those errors. Look at the draft in Figure 65. The organization is basically
sound, and the content is more or less satisfactory. However, the overall readability is
poor. The message is filled with awkward language that is wordy and redundant. The
revised letter is much improved.
Once you have revised, produced, and proofread your message, you are ready to
distribute it. For multiple copies of your document, you can print as many as you
like on an inkjet or laser printer, or you can print a single copy and reproduce it
with a photocopier. For high-volume and complex reproduction (involving colors
or photographs, for instance), youll want to take your document to
a print shop, a company that has the special equipment needed for
such jobs.
When you need to send the same document (sales letter, invoice, or
other customer communication) to a large number of people, mail
merge automatically combines a standard version of the document with
a list of names and addresses. It will produce one copy for each person
on your mailing list, saving you the trouble of inserting the name and
address each time. The names and addresses can come from your own
customer databases or from mailing lists you rent from firms that speNOT AVAILABLE FOR
ELECTRONIC VIEWING
cialize in collecting names and addresses.
Similarly, broadcast faxing allows you to enter mailing lists into your
fax machine and transmit your document to the fax machines of all
members on the list. Fax machines are indispensable for international
business, particularly because they overcome the delay problems of regular mail and the time zone problems of trying to contact someone by
telephone.13
Many companies now distribute information on CD-ROM or computer disk rather than on paper. For instance, several of HewlettPackards product catalogs are available either on CD-ROM or in
printed form. CD-ROMs hold a large amount of information, theyre
inexpensive, and their small size saves money in postage and shipping.
Cushcity.com owners Gwen and Willie Richardson are
Of course, one of the most popular methods for distributing docue-tailers who sell Afrocentric books, videos, calendars,
ments is the Internet. Most Internet browser software allows you to
collectibles, toys, and educational items over the
Internet. They also distribute business documents
attach documents of all sizes and types to e-mail messages. If you are
over the Internet, routinely sending e-mail messages
sending multiple documents or long documents over the Internet, you
and attachments of all sizes to employees and often
can use special software to encode or compress your message and
to customers. This method of distribution is popular
reduce the file size so that it can be transmitted faster. Before doing so,
because of the speed. Mrs. Richardson says, We
have a very responsive e-mail system. Customers
however, make sure your recipients have similar software so that they
are especially impressed with the two-hour response
can decode or uncompress the message and convert it back into its
time from Cushcity.
original file format.
Chapter 6
183
FIGURE 65
Poor and Improved Versions Showing Revision
f
ra
In the time since I last wrote you, our new parking lot at the end of Oakcliff
Avenue has been completely finished. I wanted to advise you that were planning a little celebration on August 24, a sort of grand opening of our new parking lot. It would be appreciated if you or others from the commission could
attend. This project seems to have solved the neighborhood parking problems
weve all been experiencing.
Unnecessary clause
So that the impact of the 80 cars parked in that lot will be minimized, we undertook the planting of more than 850 adult plantsall of them native to this area.
This work has been performed exclusively by employee volunteers during their
lunch hours. There was no cost to the taxpayers. While this work is not finished, the lot itself is working well and handling the overflow from our main
lot. Weve essentially moved all the cars associated with this company off
neighborhood streets.
Wordy phrase
Camouflaged verb
Overly enthusiastic
Wordy phrase and negative word
o
si
v
Re
August 7, 2004
Our new parking lot at the end of Oakcliff Avenue has been completed. Were
planning an opening celebration on August 24, and we invite you and others
from the commission to attend. This project has solved the neighborhood
parking situation.
Rewrites section
to avoid indefinite
pronoun starter
Also, to minimize the impact of the 80 cars parked in our new lot, we have
planted more than 850 adult native plants. This work has been performed
exclusively by employee volunteers during their lunch hours at no cost to
neighborhood taxpayers. Although the planting is not quite finished, the lot
itself is effectively handling the overflow from our main lot. Weve essentially
moved all cars associated with Woodward off neighborhood streets.
Moderates enthusiasm
Ends positively
Jeff Singleton
Vice President, Public Relations
Rewrites to avoid
indefinite pronoun
starter
Replaces camouflaged
verb
Removes redundancy
Rewrites to avoid
wordy phrase
184
Part II
On the Job:
SOLVING COMMUNICATION DILEMMAS AT MCDONALDS
As a McDonalds quality control representative, David
Giarla spends his day finding opportunities for improvement: A ceiling tile is stained and needs to be replaced;
a cheeseburger bun is dentedprobably because
someone wrapped it too tightly; a storeroom is messy; a
soft-serve cone is six inches high instead of the recommended three inches. Giarla calls attention to all these
problems. You might expect the restaurant managers
and employees to resent the criticism, but by and large
they welcome his suggestions. Why? Because Giarla
knows how to communicate.
You have recently joined McDonalds as a quality control representative. Like David Giarla, you cover seven or
eight restaurants a day. Most of the managers are cooperative, and most of the restaurants maintain high standards. But over the past few months, youve pointed out a
variety of problems to a particular McDonalds manager.
Youve been friendly, polite, and constructive in your suggestions, but nothing has been done to correct most of
the problems. On your last visit, you warned the manager
that you would have to file a negative report with headquarters if you didnt see some improvement immediately. You have decided to put your suggestions in writing
and give the manager one week to take action. Here is the
first draft of your letter. Using the questions that follow,
analyze it according to the material in this chapter. Be prepared to explain your analysis.
Please correct the problems listed below. I will visit
your facility within the next few days to monitor your
progress. If nothing has been done toward rectifying
these infractions of McDonalds principles of operation, you will be reported to headquarters for noncooperation and unsatisfactory levels of performance.
As you know, I have mentioned these deviations from
acceptable practice on previous visits. You have been
given ample opportunity to comply with my suggestions. Your failure to comply suggests that you lack
the necessary commitment to quality that has long
been the hallmark of McDonalds restaurants.
On two occasions, I have ascertained that you are
using expired ingredients in preparing hamburgers.
On February 14, a package of buns with a freshness
date of January 31 was used in your facility. Also, on
March 2, you were using cheese that had expired by at
least 10 days. McDonalds is committed to freshness.
All our ingredients are freshness dated. Expired ingredients should be disposed of, not used in the preparation of products for sale to the public. For example,
you might contact local charities and offer the expired
items to them free of charge, provided, of course, that
the ingredients do not pose a health hazard (e.g., sour
milk should be thrown out). The Community Resource
Center in your area can be reached by calling
5550909. Although I have warned you before about
using old ingredients, the last time I visited your facility, I found expired ingredients in the storeroom.
Your bathrooms should be refurbished and
cleaned more frequently. The paper towel dispenser
in the mens room was out of towels the last time I
was there, and the faucet on the sink dripped. This
not only runs up your water bill but also creates a bad
impression for the customer. Additionally, your windows need washing. On all my visits, I have noticed
fingerprints on the front door. I have never, in fact,
seen your door anything but dirty. This, too, creates a
negative impression. Similarly, the windows are not as
clean as they might be. Also, please mop the floors
more often. Nobody wants to eat in a dirty restaurant.
The most serious infraction pertains to the appearance of store personnel. Dirty uniforms are unforgivable. Also, employees, particularly those serving the
public, must have clean fingernails and hands. Hair
should be neatly combed, and uniforms should be
carefully pressed. I realize that your restaurant is
located in an economically depressed area, and I am
aware that many of your employees are ethnic minorities from impoverished backgrounds and singleparent families. Perhaps you should hold a class in
basic cleanliness for these people. It is likely that they
have not been taught proper hygiene in their homes.
In addition, please instruct store personnel to
empty the trash more frequently. The bins are constantly overflowing, making it difficult for customers
to dispose of leftover food and rubbish. This is a
problem both indoors and outdoors.
Also bear in mind that all patrons should be served
within a few minutes of their arrival at your place of
business. Waiting in line is annoying, particularly during the busy lunch hour when people are on tight
schedules. Open new lines when you must in order to
accommodate the flow of traffic. In addition, instruct
the order takers and order fillers to work more
rapidly during busy times. Employees should not be
standing around chatting with each other while customers wait in line.
As I mentioned above, I will visit your facility within
a few days to check on your progress toward meeting McDonalds criteria of operation. If no visible
progress has been made, I will have no alternative
other than to report you to top management at
headquarters. If you have any questions or require
clarification on any of these items, please feel free to
contact me. I can be reached by calling 5553549.
1. How would you rate this draft in terms of its content
and organization?
a. Although the style of the letter needs work, the
content and organization are basically okay.
Chapter 6
185
a. If nothing has been done to correct these infractions, you will be reported to headquarters for
noncompliance.
b. If you dont shape up immediately, headquarters
will hear about it.
c. By correcting these problems promptly, you can
avoid being reported to headquarters.
d. You can preserve your unblemished reputation by
acting immediately to bring your facility into compliance with McDonalds principles of operation.
4. Take a look at the third paragraph of the letter. What
is its chief flaw?
a. There is no topic sentence.
b. The topic sentence is too narrow for the ideas
encompassed in the paragraph.
c. The transition from the previous paragraph is poor.
d. The paragraph deals with more than one subject.
e. The topic sentence is not adequately developed
with specific details in subsequent sentences.14
186
Part II
c. Very useful
d. Repeat again
Objective 6.6: Describe four characteristics of a successful
design and explain how four specific design elements can
change a documents appearance.
13. A well-designed document
a. Includes a wide variety of typefaces
b. Balances the space devoted to text, artwork, and white
space
c. Fills as much of the available space as possible with
text and art
d. Does all of the above
14. The best placement for headings longer than two lines is
a. Flush left
b. Centered
c. Flush right
d. Justified
15. Type that is justified is
a. Flush on the left and ragged on the right
b. Flush on the right and ragged on the left
c. Flush on both the left and the right
d. Centered
16. A sans serif typeface would be best for
a. The headings in a report
b. The text of a report
c. Both the headings and the text of a report
d. Things like footnotes and endnotes
Objective 6.7: Discuss the types of errors to look for when
proofreading.
17. When proofreading, you look for errors in
a. Spelling and punctuation
b. Grammar and usage
c. Typography and format
d. All of the above
will be provided. You will need to take everything off the walls too,
and please pack it along with the boxes.
If you have a lot of personal belongings, you should bring
them home with you. Likewise with anything valuable. I do not
mean to infer that items will be stolen, irregardless it is better to be
safe than sorry.
On Monday, we will be unpacking, putting things away, and
then get back to work. The least amount of disruption is anticipated
by us, if everyone does their part. Hopefully, there will be no negative
affects on production schedules, and current deadlines will be met.
Chapter 6
DOCUMENT 6.B
Dear Ms. Giraud:
Enclosed herewith please find the manuscript for your book,
Careers in Woolgathering. After perusing the first two chapters of
your 1,500-page manuscript, I was forced to conclude that the
subject matter, handicrafts and artwork using wool fibers, is not
coincident with the publishing program of Framingham Press,
which to this date has issued only works on business endeavors,
avoiding all other topics completely.
Although our firm is unable to consider your impressive work at
the present time, I have taken the liberty of recording some comments
on some of the pages. I am of the opinion that any feedback that a
writer can obtain from those well versed in the publishing realm can
only serve to improve the writers authorial skills.
In view of the fact that your residence is in the Boston area,
might I suggest that you secure an appointment with someone of
high editorial stature at the Cambridge Heritage Press, which I
believe might have something of an interest in works of the nature
you have produced.
Wishing you the best of luck in your literary endeavors, I
remain.
Arthur J. Cogswell
Editor
187
DOCUMENT 6.C
For delicious, air-popped popcorn, please read the following
instructions: The popper is designed to pop 1/2 cup of popcorn
kernels at one time. Never add more than 1/2 cup. A half cup of corn
will produce three to four quarts of popcorn. More batches may be
made separately after completion of the first batch. Popcorn is
popped by hot air. Oil or shortening is not needed for popping corn.
Add only popcorn kernels to the popping chamber. Standard grades
of popcorn are recommended for use. Premium or gourmet type
popping corns may be used. Ingredients such as oil, shortening,
butter, margarine, or salt should never be added to the popping
chamber. The popper, with popping chute in position, may be
preheated for two minutes before adding the corn. Turn the popper
off before adding the corn. Use electricity safely and wisely. Observe
safety precautions when using the popper. Do not touch the popper
when it is hot. The popper should not be left unattended when it is
plugged into an outlet. Do not use the popper if it or its cord has
been damaged. Do not use the popper if it is not working properly.
Before using the first time, wash the chute and butter/measuring cup
in hot soapy water. Use a dishcloth or sponge. Wipe the outside of
the popper base. Use a damp cloth. Dry the base. Do not immerse
the popper base in water or other liquid. Replace the chute and
butter/measuring cup. The popper is ready to use.
Exercises
For live links to all websites discussed in this chapter, visit this
texts website at www.prenhall.com/thill. Just log on, select
Chapter 6, and click on Student Resources. Locate the page or
the URL related to the material in the text. For Learning More
on the Web exercises, youll also find navigational directions.
Click on the live link to the site.
6.1
6.2
Message Readability: Using Bullets Rewrite the following paragraph using a bulleted list:
6.3
188
6.4
6.5
6.6
6.7
6.8
6.9
Part II
Revising Messages: Conciseness Cross out unnecessary words in the following phrases:
a. Consensus of opinion.
b. New innovations.
c. Long period of time.
d. At a price of $50.
e. Still remains.
Revising Messages: Conciseness Revise the following
sentences, using shorter, simpler words:
a. The antiquated calculator is ineffectual for solving
sophisticated problems.
b. It is imperative that the pay increments be terminated before an inordinate deficit is accumulated.
c. There was unanimity among the executives that Ms.
Jacksons idiosyncrasies were cause for a mandatory
meeting with the companys personnel director.
d. The impending liquidation of the companys
assets was cause for jubilation among the companys competitors.
e. The expectations of the president for a stock dividend were accentuated by the preponderance of
evidence that the company was in good financial
condition.
Revising Messages: Conciseness Use infinitives as substitutes for the overly long phrases in these sentences:
a. For living, I require money.
b. They did not find sufficient evidence for believing in
the future.
c. Bringing about the destruction of a dream is tragic.
Revising Messages: Conciseness Rephrase the following in fewer words:
a. In the near future.
b. In the event that.
c. In order that.
d. For the purpose of.
e. With regard to.
f. It may be that.
g. In very few cases.
h. With reference to.
i. At the present time.
j. There is no doubt that.
Revising Messages: Conciseness Condense these sentences to as few words as possible:
a. We are of the conviction that writing is important.
b. In all probability, were likely to have a price increase.
c. Our goals include making a determination about that
in the near future.
d. When all is said and done at the conclusion of this
experiment, Id like to summarize the final windup.
e. After a trial period of three weeks, during which time
she worked for a total of 15 full working days, we
found her work was sufficiently satisfactory so that we
offered her full-time work.
Revising Messages: Modifiers Remove all the unnecessary modifiers from these sentences:
a. Tremendously high pay increases were given to the
extraordinarily skilled and extremely conscientious
employees.
6.10
6.11
6.12
6.13
Chapter 6
6.14 Revising Messages: Dangling Modifiers Rewrite these
sentences to clarify the dangling modifiers:
a. Running down the railroad tracks in a cloud of
smoke, we watched the countryside glide by.
b. Lying on the shelf, Ruby saw the seashell.
c. Based on the information, I think we should buy the
property.
d. Being cluttered and filthy, Sandy took the whole
afternoon to clean up her desk.
e. After proofreading every word, the memo was ready
to be signed.
6.15 Revising Messages: Noun Sequences Rewrite the following sentences to eliminate the long strings of nouns:
a. The focus of the meeting was a discussion of the bank
interest rate deregulation issue.
b. Following the government task force report recommendations, we are revising our job applicant evaluation procedures.
c. The production department quality assurance program components include employee training, supplier
cooperation, and computerized detection equipment.
d. The supermarket warehouse inventory reduction plan
will be implemented next month.
e. The State University business school graduate placement program is one of the best in the country.
6.16 Revising Messages: Sentence Structure Rearrange the
following sentences to bring the subjects closer to their
verbs:
a. Trudy, when she first saw the bull pawing the
ground, ran.
b. It was Terri who, according to Ted, who is probably
the worst gossip in the office (Tom excepted), mailed
the wrong order.
c. William Oberstreet, in his book Investment Capital
Reconsidered, writes of the mistakes that bankers
through the decades have made.
d. Judy Schimmel, after passing up several sensible
investment opportunities, despite the warnings of her
friends and family, invested her inheritance in a jojoba
plantation.
e. The president of U-Stor-It, which was on the brink of
bankruptcy after the warehouse fire, the worst tragedy
in the history of the company, prepared a press
announcement.
6.17 Revising Messages: Camouflaged Verbs Rewrite each
sentence so that the verbs are no longer camouflaged:
a. Adaptation to the new rules was performed easily by
the employees.
6.18
6.19
6.20
6.21
189
190
Part II
writing skills, and for practice, complete one of the many online
activities provided to reinforce what youve learned. Or select
the Forum to talk about writing. At POWAs website, youll
learn how to improve the final draft of your message.
ACTIVITIES
Go to www.powa.org for advice on organizing ideas, choosing
the best word and appropriate style, and placing each paragraph effectively so that your message achieves its purpose:
1. Why is it better to write out ideas in a rough format and
later reread your message to revise its content? When
revising your message, what questions can you ask about
your writing?
2. Name the four elements of the writing context. Imagine
that youre the reader of your message. What questions
might you ask?
Learn Interactively
INTERACTIVE STUDY GUIDE
Visit the Companion Website at www.prenhall.com/thill. For
Chapter 6, take advantage of the interactive Study Guide to
test your chapter knowledge. Get instant feedback on whether
you need additional studying. Read the Current Events articles
to get the latest on chapter topics, and complete the exercises as
specified by your instructor.
This site offers a variety of additional resources: The
Research Area helps you locate a wealth of information to
use in course assignments. You can even send a message to
online research experts, who will help you find exactly the
information you need. The Study Hall helps you succeed in
this course. Talk in the Hall lets you leave messages and meet
new friends online. If you have a question, you can Ask the
Tutor. And to get a better grade in this course, you can find
more help at Writing Skills, Study Skills, and Study Tips.
PEAK PERFORMANCE GRAMMAR AND MECHANICS
To improve your skill with prepositions and conjunctions, visit
this texts website at www.prenhall.com/thill. Click Peak
Performance Grammar and Mechanics, then click Prepositions,
Conjunctions, and Articles. Take the Pretest to determine
whether you have any weak areas. Review those areas in the
Refresher Course, and take the Follow-Up Test to check your
grasp of prepositions and conjunctions. For advanced practice,
take the Advanced Test. Finally, for additional reinforcement, go
to the Improve Your Grammar, Mechanics, and Usage section
that follows, and complete those exercises.