Cokaliong Shipping vs. UCPB
Cokaliong Shipping vs. UCPB
After the vessel had passed by the MandaueMactan Bridge, fire ensued in the engine room,
and, despite earnest efforts of the officers and
crew of the vessel, the fire engulfed and
destroyed the entire vessel resulting in the loss of
the vessel and the cargoes therein.
ISSUES:
(1) Is petitioner liable for the loss of the
goods? YES
(2) If it is liable, what is the extent of its
liability? According to what was reflected in
the Bill of Lading
HELD:
(1) Petitioners argument: the cause of the
loss of the goods, subject of this case, was
force majeure. It adds that its exercise of due
diligence was adequately proven by the
findings of the Philippine Coast Guard.
SC:
We
are
not
convinced. The
uncontroverted findings of the Philippine
Coast Guard show that the M/V Tandag sank
due to a fire, which resulted from a crack in
the auxiliary engine fuel oil service tank. The
crack was located on the side of the fuel oil
tank, which had a mere two-inch gap from
the engine room walling, thus precluding
constant inspection and care by the crew