29) Chua Vs Mesina
29) Chua Vs Mesina
18. Mrs. Mesina died in the early part of 1991. Transfer of title
was never effected. The Melencio property was being offered
for sale to the public.
19. The spouses and Hsia filed on Aug 24, 1992 a complaint
against Atty Mesina and his two siblings before the RTC of
Nueva Ecija for Declaration of Nullity of Sale and
Reconveyance of Real Property.
20. At the time of the filing of this administrative complaint in
1998, the civil case against the Mesina siblings was still
pending.
21. By Resolution of July 13, 1998, the Court directed Atty
Mesina to file Comment on the complaint within 10 days.
22. By Resolution of Dec 2, 1998, the Court required Atty.
Mesina to comment on the complaint, noting that the complaint
sent to him at his office in Bel-Air on July 13, 1998 was
returned unserved with the notation, Moved. The Court
however considered the Jul 13 Resolution served on Atty
law; that he intended to defraud not only a private party but the
government is aggravating.
b. convincing complainants to execute a simulated Deed of
Absolute Sale wherein thay made it appear that complaintsnts
reconveyed the Melencio property to his mother, he committed
dishonesty.
c. inveigling his own clients into turning over to him the
owners copy of his mothers title upon misrepresentation that
he would, in 4 months, have a deed of sale executed by his
mother in favor of complainants, he likewise committed
dishonesty.
4. In Nakpil vs Valdez, As a rule, a lawyer is not barred from
dealing with his client but the business transaction must be
characterized with utmost honesty and good faith. The
measure of good faith which an attorney is required to exercise
in his dealings with his client is a much higher standard that is
required in business dealings where the parties trade at arms
length.
5. In fine, the Respondent violated his oath of office and more
specifically, the following canons of the Code of Professional
Responsibility:
CANON 1. A LAWYER SHALL UPHOLD THE
CONSTITUTION, OBEY THE LAWS OF THE LAND AND
PROMOTE RESPECT FOR LAW AND LEGAL
PROCESSES.
Rule 1.01. - A lawyer shall not engage in unlawful, dishonest,
immoral or deceitful conduct.Rule 1.02. - A lawyer shall not
counsel or abet activities aimed at defiance of the law or at
lessening confidence in the legal system.
copy to the clerk of court, with proof of failure of both personal service and service by mail.
The service is complete at the time of such delivery. (6a)