Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pineda V Lantin
Pineda V Lantin
LANTIN
Nov. 30, 1962|REGALA, J. | INJUNCTION AS PROVISIONAL
REMEDY
Digester: Africa, Mabel
SUMMARY: Minority stockholders of Bacolod Murcia Milling filed
a complaint with the SEC against the said company and its
president, Araneta. The SEC Commissioner Pineda ordered the
investigation of the case. Araneta and Bacolod Murcia moved to
quash and discontinue the proceedings and investigation due to an
alleged lack of jurisdiction of the SEC (due to non-promulgation of
SECs rules). The SEC Comm denied the motion. Hence, Araneta
and Bacolod Murcia filed a Special Civil Action for Injunction
before the CFI. The SEC Comm and the investigators moved to
dismiss the special civil action on the ground of impropriety, since
the CFI has no jurisdiction over SEC orders. CFI Judge Lantin
denied. The SEC filed with the SEC a petition for certiorari
attributing grave abuse of discretion on the part of Judge Lantin.
The SC agreed with the SEC. The CFI has no jurisdiction over the
case of prohibition because the same is lodged EXCLUSIVELY with
the SC.
DOCTRINE: Under the ROC, the CFI has no jurisdiction to grant
injunctive reliefs against the SEC. That power is lodged
EXCLUSIVELY with the SC.
1. Sec. 1, Rule 43 within 30 days from notice of an order or
decision issued by the Public Service Commission or the SEC, any
party aggrieved may file with the SC a petition for review
2. Sec. 35, Commonwealth Act 83 (creating and setting forth the
powers of the SEC) Any person aggrieved by an order issued by
the Commission... may obtain a review of such order in the SC
The above provisions are very clear. Whenever a party is aggrieved
by or disagrees with an order or ruling of the SEC, his remedy is to
come to the SC on petition for review. He is not permitted to seek
relief from courts of general jurisdiction.
FACTS:
The fact that the order is interlocutory does not mean such
cannot be appealed in such a manner, as appeal may be had if
the appeal is grounded upon lack of jurisdiction.