Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Debrahlee Lorenzana - A Hot Case Study
Debrahlee Lorenzana - A Hot Case Study
Debrahlee Lorenzana, 33, has filed a
lawsuit against Citibank claiming she
was the victim of a hostile work
environment simply because of the way
she dressed on the job. Debralee
Lorenzana alleges that she was fired
from her position at Citibank because
she was too good looking, and the
male staff could not handle the
distraction.
She said she felt that way back in
September of 2008 in Citibank's
Chrysler Building branch. But
Lorenzana said it quickly turned in to a
nightmare. She said she was told by her
bosses to tone down her wardrobe. "We don't want you to wear turtlenecks , pencil
skirts and fitted suits or even heels," she said. Lorenzana’s bosses told her that
“as a result of the shape of her figure, such clothes were purportedly ‘too
distracting’ for her male colleagues and supervisors to bear.” She was told
by at least two managers that she needed to stop wearing heels and tailored
clothing that accentuated her curves and other bodily assets.
Lorenzana argued that other women in the same branch wore even shorter skirts
and showed ample cleavage because they were short, overweight, and they didn’t draw
attention. She said her superiors at Citibank said her case was different because
she had a better body than most women. "What they said to me is (other
women's) body types and my body type were different and because of my
body type I drew too much attention," she said.
Lorenzana said she went to human resources, but that infuriated her bosses. She
said they kept harping on her appearance. After finally getting the transfer she
had asked for, she was fired in August of 2009. Poor job performance was the
explanation. A Citibank representative told CBS 2 HD there is a business
appropriate dress code for the company but would not provide details or the
written policy. CBS 2 HD also learned managers have discretion when it comes to
enforcing it.
All Citibank would say about Lorenzana was: "We believe this lawsuit is without
merit. (We) cannot comment more specifically on this litigation, this former
employee's overall performance, or the reasons for her termination." As
Lorenzana sues for lost wages and emotional distress, she hopes to teach Citibank
a lesson: don't desire me, don't discriminate against me. Just let me do my job.
Author's Opinion
1.) I'm not sure if she was fired for being too hot or not,
an arbitrator will decide that (she signed an
arbitration agreement when she was hired, so
there will be no judge or jury).
2.) There are many cases of workplace discrimination,
but financial services is also a very conservative
field. People expect a serious looking
representative when dealing with money.
2.) But I have to wonder: The bosses say you're not
dressing according to the dress code. Debralee
Lorenzana hears "as a result of the shape of her
figure, such clothes were purportedly 'too
distracting' for her male colleagues and supervisors
to bear." They warned her repeatedly. She didn't
alter her behavior.
3.) She calls out her fellow coworkers, saying they are
short and fat and dress much worse. This opinion
about her coworkers certainly doesn't sound like
someone very nice to work with.
4.) "It's so tiring, My entire life, I've been dealing with this" Lorenzana tells the
Village Voice. ". Sounds like an ego trip to me.
6.) It seems both parties are on truth. Yes, the firing of Debra Lee Lorenzana
for her incompetence may mean that she was too hot that no man stands
her fiery figure. You know men in corporate sector are often found with
problems like early ejaculation.
7.) Debralee Lorenzana said in her defense that the kind of background in
which she has been brought up has taught her that women should take
care of themselves and make sure they look their best whenever they go
out, whether to the market or to work.
Questions
Why not just dress down a bit and keep your job ?
Was Debralee dressed too provocative that the men at her job couldn't handle it?
Was Debralee too hot for the job? Or does she just think she was too hot for the job
Complicated issue of the case study
Whether her natural physical appearance was too distracting or her
dressing style made attractive at the workplace? As her lawsuit puts it, her
bosses told her that “as a result of the shape of her figure, such clothes
were purportedly too distracting for her male colleagues and supervisors
to bear.”
Citibank does have a dresscode policy, which says clothing must not be
provocative, but does not go into specifics, and managers have wide
discretion.
OTHER ASPECTS TO FOCUS :
Need to look good or gorgeous at workplace ?
Corporate Dress Code and Dressing sense
Awareness of Work culture and Work environment
Non verbal communication Body language
Gender discrimination issues.
Workplace fairness and equality
Male / Female Coworkers concerns
Professionalism, Workplace Attitude.
This case is prepared by HARISH S, MBA (Marketing) dated 02/07/2010.
Please give your feedback: [email protected]