Investment Management Final Project.
Investment Management Final Project.
INTRODUCTION
INDIAN STOCK MARKET
Introduction Indian Stock Markets is one of the oldest in Asia. Its history dates back to nearly
200 years ago. The earliest records of security dealings in India are meager and obscure. The
East India Company was the dominant institution in those days and business in its loan securities
used to be transacted towards the close of the eighteenth century. By 1830's business on
corporate stocks and shares in Bank and Cotton presses took place in Bombay. Though the
trading list was broader in 1839, there were only half a dozen brokers recognized by banks and
merchants during 1840 and 1850. The 1850's witnessed a rapid development of commercial
enterprise and brokerage business attracted many men into the field and by 1860 the number of
brokers increased into 60. In 1860-61 the American Civil War broke out and cotton supply from
United States to Europe was stopped; thus, the 'Share Mania' in India began. The number of
brokers increased to about 200 to 250. At the end of the American Civil War, the brokers who
thrived out of Civil War in 1874, found a place in a street (now appropriately called as Dalal
Street) where they would conveniently assemble and transact business. In 1887, they formally
established in Bombay, the "Native Share and Stock Brokers' Association, which is alternatively
known as The Stock Exchange". In 1895, the Stock Exchange acquired a premise in the same
street and it was inaugurated in 1899. Thus, the Stock Exchange at Bombay was consolidated.
The Indian stock market has been assigned an important place in financing the Indian corporate
sector. The principal functions of the stock markets are:
enabling mobilizing resources for investment directly from the investors
Providing liquidity for the investors and monitoring.
Disciplining company management.
The two major stock exchanges in India are:-
National Stock Exchange (NSE)
Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE).
National Stock Exchange
With the liberalization of the Indian economy, it was found inevitable to lift the Indian stock
market trading system on par with the international standards. On the basis of the
recommendations of high powered Pherwani Committee. The National Stock Exchange was
incorporated in 1992 by Industrial Development Bank of India, Industrial Credit and Investment
1
Corporation of India, Industrial Finance Corporation of India, all Insurance Corporations,
selected commercial banks and others.
The National Stock Exchange (NSE) is India's leading stock exchange covering various cities
and towns across the country. NSE was set up by leading institutions to provide a modern, fully
automated screen-based trading system with national reach. The Exchange has brought about
unparalleled transparency, speed & efficiency, safety and market integrity. It has set up facilities
that serve as a model for the securities industry in terms of systems, practices and procedures.
2
Delays in communication, late payments and the malpractices prevailing in the
traditional trading mechanism can be done away with greater operational efficiency and
informational transparency in the stock market operations, with the support of total
computerized network.
NSE Nifty
S&P CNX Nifty is a well-diversified 50 stock index accounting for 22 sectors of the economy. It
is used for a variety of purposes such as benchmarking fund portfolios, index based derivatives
and index funds.
NSE came to be owned and managed by India Index Services and Products Ltd. (IISL), which is
a joint venture between NSE and CRISIL. IISL is India's first specialized company focused upon
the index as a core product. IISL have a consulting and licensing agreement with Standard &
Poor's (S&P), who are world leaders in index services. CNX stands for CRISIL NSE Indices.
CNX ensures common branding of indices, to reflect the identities of both the promoters, i.e.
NSE and CRISIL. Thus, 'C' Stands for CRISIL, 'N' stands for NSE and X stands for Exchange or
Index. The S&P prefix belongs to the US-based Standard & Poor's Financial Information
Services.
SENSEX
The Stock Exchange, Mumbai (BSE) in 1986 came out with a stock index that subsequently
became the barometer of the Indian stock market. SENSEX is not only scientifically designed
but also based on globally accepted construction and review methodology. First compiled in
3
1986, SENSEX is a basket of 30 constituent stocks representing a sample of large, liquid and
representative companies. The base year of SENSEX is 1978-79 and the base value is 100. The
index is widely reported in both domestic and international markets through print as well as
electronic media. Due to is wide acceptance amongst the Indian investors; SENSEX is regarded
to be the pulse of the Indian stock market. As the oldest index in the country, it provides the time
series data over a fairly long period of time. Small wonder, the SENSEX has over the years
become one of the most prominent brands in the country. The SENSEX captured all these events
in the most judicial manner. One can identify the booms and busts of the Indian stock market
through SENSEX\
The launch of SENSEX in 1986 was later followed up in January 1989 by introduction of BSE
National Index (Base: 1983-84 = 100). It comprised of 100 stocks listed at five major stock
exchanges.
The values of all BSE indices are updated every 15 seconds during the market hours and
displayed through the BOLT system, BSE website and news wire agencies. All BSE-indices are
reviewed periodically by the index committee of the exchange.
CHAPTER 2
4
OVERVIEW OF THE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK OF THE CAPITAL
MARKET IN INDIA
India has a financial system that is regulated by independent regulators in the sectors of banking,
insurance, capital markets and various service sectors.
The Indian Financial system is regulated by two governing agencies under the Ministry of
Finance. They are
1. Reserve Bank of India The RBI was set up in 1935 and is the central bank of India. It
regulates the financial and banking system. It formulates monetary policies and
prescribes exchange control norms.
2. The Securities Exchange Board of India The Government of India constituted SEBI on
April 12, 1988, as a non-statutory body to promote orderly and healthy development of
the securities market and to provide investor protection.
3. Department of Economic Affairs The capital markets division of the Department of
Economic Affairs regulates capital markets and securities transactions.
The capital markets division has been entrusted with the responsibility of assisting the
Government in framing suitable policies for the orderly growth and development of the
securities markets with the SEBI, RBI and other agencies. It is also responsible for the
functioning of the Unit Trust of India (UTI) and Securities and Exchange Board of India
(SEBI). The principal aspects that are dealt with the capital market division are:
Policy matters relating to the securities market
Policy matters relating to the regulation and development and investor protection
of the securities market and the debt market.
Organizational and operational matters relating to SEBI
The Capital Market is governed by: Securities Contract (Regulation) Act, 1956
Securities Contract (Regulation) Rules, 1957
SEBI Act, 1992
Companies Act 1956
SEBI (Stock Brokers and Sub Brokers) Rules, 1992
Exchange Bye-Laws Rule & Regulations
Self-regulating Role of the Exchange
The exchange functions as a Self-Regulatory Organization with the parameters laid down by the
SCRA, SEBI Act, SEBI Guidelines and Rules, Bye-laws and Regulations of the Exchange. The
Governing Board discharges these functions. The Executive Director has all the powers of the
5
governing board except discharging a member indefinitely or declaring him a defaulter or
expelling him. The Executive Director takes decisions in the areas like surveillance, inspection,
investigation, etc. in an objective manner as per the parameters laid down by the governing board
or the statutory committees like the Disciplinary Action Committee.
2. Intraday
3. Future
4. Forwards
5. Options
6. swaps
Basic Requirement for doing Trading
Trading requires Opening a Demat account. Demat refers to a dematerialized account. You need
to open a Demat account if you want to buy or sell stocks.
So it is just like a bank account where actual money is replaced by shares. We need to approach
the Depository Participants (DP, they are like bank branches), to open Demat account
A depository is a place where the stocks of investors are held in electronic form. The depository
has agents who are called depository participants (DPs).
Think of it like a bank. The head office where all the technology rests and details of all accounts
held is like the depository. And the DPs are the branches that cater to individuals.
There are only two depositories in India
The National Securities Depository Ltd (NSDL)
The Central Depository Services Ltd (CDSL).
6
Capital Market Participants
Banks
Exchanges
Clearing Corporations
Brokers
Custodians
Depositories
Investors
Merchant Bankers
7
CHAPTER 3
Types of Investors
Types of Investors
Institutional Investors- MFs / FI / FIIs / Banks
Retail Investors
Arbitrageurs / Speculators
Hedgers
Day traders/Jobbers
PARAMETERS OF INVESTMENT
The nature of investment differs from individual to individual and is unique to each one because
it depends on various parameters like future financial goals, the present & the future income
model, capacity to bear the risk, the present requirements and lot more. As an investor progresses
on his/her life stage and as his/her financial goals change, so does the unique investor profile.
Economic development of a country depends upon its investment. The emerging economic
environment of competitive markets signifying customers sovereignty has profound
implications for their savings and investment. Investment means persons commitments towards
his future.
INVESTMENT
The word "investment" can be defined in many ways according to different theories and
principles. It is a term that can be used in a number of contexts. However, the different meanings
of "investment" are more alike than dissimilar. Generally, investment is the application of money
for earning more money. Investment also means savings or savings made through delayed
consumption. According to economics, investment is the utilization of resources in order to
increase income or production output in the future.
An amount deposited into a bank or machinery that is purchased in anticipation of earning
income in the long run is both examples of investments. Although there is a general broad
8
definition to the term investment, it carries slightly different meanings to different industrial
sectors.
9
According to economists, investment refers to any physical or tangible asset, for example, a
building or machinery and equipment.
On the other hand, finance professionals define an investment as money utilized for buying
financial assets, for example stocks, bonds, bullion, real properties, and precious items.
According to finance, the practice of investment refers to the buying of a financial product or any
valued item with anticipation that positive returns will be received in the future.
The most important feature of financial investments is that they carry high market liquidity. The
method used for evaluating the value of a financial investment is known as valuation. According
to business theories, investment is that activity in which a manufacturer buys a physical asset, for
example, stock or production equipment, in expectation that this will help the business to prosper
in the long run.
Essentials of Investment
Essentials of investment refer to why investment, or the need for investment, is required. The
investment strategy is a plan, which is created to guide an investor to choose the most
appropriate investment portfolio that will help him achieve his financial goals within a particular
period of time.
An investment strategy usually involves a set of methods, rules, and regulations, and is designed
according to the exchange or compromise of the investor's risks and returns. A number of
investors like to increase their earnings through high-risk investments, whilst others prefer
investing in assets with minimum risk involved. However, the majority of investors choose an
10
investment strategy that lies in the middle. Investment strategies can be broadly categorized into
the following types:
Active strategies: One of the principal active strategies is market timing (an investor is
able to move into the market when it is on the low and sell the stocks when the market is
on the high), which is applied for maximizing yields.
Passive strategies: Frequently implemented for reducing transaction costs.
One of the most popular strategies is the buy and hold, which is basically a long term investment
plan. The idea behind this is that stock markets yield a commendable rate of return in spite of
stages of fluctuation or downfall. Indexing is a strictly passive variable of the buy and hold
strategy and, in this case, an investor purchases a limited number of every share existing in the
stock market index, for example the Standard and Poor 500 Index, or more probably in an index
fund, which is a form of a mutual fund.
Additionally, as the market timing strategy is not applicable for small-scale investors, it is
advisable to apply the buy and hold strategy. In case of real estate investment the retail and
small-scale investors apply the buy and hold strategy, because the holding period is normally
equal to the total span of the mortgage loan.
PRINCIPLES OF INVESTMENT
Five basic principles serve as the foundation for the investment approach. They are as follows:
Focus on the long term
There is substantive empirical evidence to suggest that equities provide the maximum risk
adjusted returns over the long term. In an attempt to take full advantage of this phenomenon,
investments would be made with a long term perspective.
Investments confer proportionate ownership
The approach to valuing a company is similar to making an investment in a business. Therefore,
there is a need to have a comprehensive understanding of how the business operates.
Maintain a margin of safety The benchmark for determining relative attractiveness of stocks
would be the intrinsic value of the business. The Investment Manager would endeavor to
11
purchase stocks that represent a discount to this value, in an effort to preserve capital and
generate superior growth.
Maintain a balanced outlook on the market
The investment portfolio would be regularly monitored to understand the impact of changes in
business and economic trend as well as investor sentiment. While short-term market volatility
would affect valuations of the portfolio, this is not expected to influence the decision to own
fundamentally strong companies.
12
Some Short-term financial options available for investment are:
Broadly speaking, savings bank account, money market/liquid funds and fixed deposits with
banks may be considered as short-term financial investment options.
Savings Bank Account is often the first banking product people use, which offers low interest
(4%-5% p.a.), making them only marginally better than fixed deposits.
Fixed Deposits with Banks are also referred to as term deposits and minimum investment
period for bank FDs is 30 days. Fixed Deposits with banks are for investors with low risk
appetite, and may be considered for 6-12 months investment period as normally interest on less
than 6 months bank FDs is likely to be lower than money market fund returns.
Public Provident Fund: A long term savings instrument with a maturity of 15 years and
interest payable at 8% per annum (nearly) compounded annually. A PPF account can be
opened through a nationalized bank at any time during the year and is open all through
the year for depositing money. Tax benefits can be availed for the amount invested and
interest accrued is tax-free. A withdrawal is permissible every year from the seventh
financial year of the date of opening of the account and the amount of withdrawal will be
limited to 50% of the balance at credit at the end of the 4th year immediately preceding
the year in which the amount is withdrawn or at the end of the preceding year whichever
is lower the amount of loan if any.
13
Company Fixed Deposits: These are short-term (six months) to medium-term (three to
five years) borrowings by companies at a fixed rate of interest which is payable monthly,
quarterly, semi-annually or annually.
They can also be cumulative fixed deposits where the entire principal along with the interest is
paid at the end of the loan period. The rate of interest varies between 6-9% per annum for
company FDs. The interest received is after deduction of taxes
Bonds: It is a fixed income (debt) instrument issued for a period of more than one year
with the purpose of raising capital.
The central or state government, corporations and similar institutions sell bonds. A bond is
generally a promise to repay the principal along with a fixed rate of interest on a specified date,
called the Maturity Date.
Mutual Funds: These are funds operated by an investment company which raises money
from the public and invests in a group of assets (shares, debentures etc.), in accordance
with a stated set of objectives. It is a substitute for those who are unable to invest directly
in equities or debt because of resource, time or knowledge constraints. Benefits include
professional money management, buying in small amounts and diversification. Mutual
fund units are issued and redeemed by the Fund Management Company based on the
fund's net asset value (NAV), which is determined at the end of each trading session.
NAV is calculated as the value of all the shares held by the fund, minus expenses, divided
by the number of units issued.
NOTE: The interest rate changes as per the RBI regulation, so the rates mentioned above
are approximate rate at the time of writing this article.
Equity Investment:
Equity investment refers to the trading of stocks and bonds in the share market. It is also referred
to as the acquisition of equity or ownership participation in the company. An equity investment is
typically an ownership investment, where the investor owns an asset of the company. In this kind
of investment there is always a risk of the investor not earning a specific amount of money.
Equity investment can also be termed as payment to a firm in return for partial ownership of that
firm. An equity investor, in some cases, may assume some management control of the firm and
may also share in future profits.
14
In order to understand equity investment properly, it is necessary to see the technical and
fundamental analysis. The technical analysis of equity investment is primarily the study of price
history of the shares and stock market. A fundamental analysis of equity investment involves the
study of all available information that is relevant to the share market in order to predict the future
trends of the stock market. The annual reports, industry data and study of the economic and
financial environment are also included in the fundamental information of equity investment.
Mutual Funds and Segregated Funds:
Mutual funds or other forms of pooled investment measures are equities held by private
individuals but managed and governed by prominent management firms. These types of financial
holdings allow individual investors to diversify their holdings and avoid potential loss.
Segregated funds, on the other hand, are used by large private investors who wish to hold their
shares directly rather than in a mutual fund.
The prime advantage in investing in a pooled fund is that it gives the individual access to
professional advice through the fund manager. The major disadvantages involved are that the
investors must pay a fee to the fund managers and that the diversification of the fund may not be
appropriate for all investors. In those cases, the investors may over-diversify by holding several
funds, thus reducing the risk.
Mutual funds are supposed to be the best mode of investment in the capital market since
they are very cost beneficial and simple, and do not require an investor to figure out
which securities to invest into. A mutual fund could simply be described as a financial
medium used by a group of investors to increase their money with a predetermined
investment. The responsibility for investing the pooled money into specific investment
channels lies with the fund manager of said mutual fund.
Therefore investment in a mutual fund means that the investor has bought the shares of the
mutual fund and has become a shareholder of that fund. Diversification of investment Investors
are able to purchase securities with much lower trading costs by pooling money together in a
mutual fund rather than try to do it on their own. However the biggest advantage that mutual
funds offer is diversification which allows the investor to spread out his money across a wide
spectrum of investments. Therefore when one investment is not doing well, another may be
15
doing taking off, thereby balancing the risk to profit ratio and considerably covering the overall
investment.
The best form of diversification is to invest in multiple securities rather than in just one security.
Mutual funds are set up with the precise objective of investing in multiple securities that can run
into hundreds. It could take weeks for an investor to investigate on this kind of scale, but with
investment in mutual funds all this could be done in a matter of hours.
DEBENTURES:
In financial context, Debentures are Debt Instruments issued for a long term by governments and
big institutions for rising funds. The Debenture has some resemblances to bonds but the
securitization terms and conditions are different for Debentures compared to a bond.
A Debenture is commonly considered as insecure because there is no pledge or lien on particular
assets. Nevertheless, a Debenture is secured by all the assets which are otherwise not pledged.
If there is a bankruptcy, Debenture holders will be counted as general creditors. The benefit that
the issuer enjoys from issuing a debenture is that they keep particular assets free of
encumbrances so the option is open to issue them for future financing. Usually, Debentures are
freely negotiable debt instruments. The Debenture holder works as a lender to the Debenture
issuer.
In return, the Debenture issuer pays interest to the Debenture holders as it is paid in case of a
loan. In practical application, the difference between a Bond and a Debenture is not always kept.
In some instances, Debentures are also referred to as Bonds and vice-versa.
TYPES OF DEBENTURES
Convertible Debenture
Non-Convertible Debenture
Participative Debenture
Non- Participative Debenture
Redeemable Debenture
Irredeemable Debenture
16
BOND MARKET:
The bond market is a financial market that acts as a platform for the buying and selling of debt
securities. The bond market is a part of the capital market serving platform to collect fund for the
public sector companies, governments, and corporations. There are a number of bond indices that
reflect the performance of a bond market.
The bond market can also be called the debt market, credit market, or fixed income market. The
size of the current international bond market is estimated to be $45 trillion. The major bond
market participants are: governments, institutional investors, traders, and individual investors.
According to the specifications given by the Bond Market Association, there are five types of
bond markets.
They are:
Corporate Bond Market
Municipal Bond Market
Government and Agency Bond Market
Funding Bond Market
Mortgage Backed and Collateralized Debt Obligation Bond Market
Share Market Investment
Shares are purchased and sold on the primary and secondary share markets. To invest in the share
market, investors acquire a call option, which is the right to buy a share, or a put option, which is
the right to sell a share. In general, investors buy put options if they expect prices to rise, and call
options if they expect prices to fall.. The value of a derivative depends on the value of the
underlying asset. The various classifications of derivatives relevant to share market investment
are:
Swap
Futures Contract
Forward Contract
Option Contract
17
A forward contract is agreements between two parties purchase or sell a product in the future, at
a price determined now. This mutual agreement satisfies the profit motive of both the buyer and
seller, and the uncertainties and risks of price fluctuations in the future are aborted. A future
contract is different from a forward contract in the sense that the former requires the presence of
a third party and the commitment for trade is simply notional.
Before a share is chosen for investment, a technical analysis of the share is performed. The price
and volume of a share over a period of time are tracked and then a business plan is constructed.
A fundamental analysis involves a close study of the company associated with the share, and its
performance over time. The fundamental analysis is important for the share market investor.
The price levels of a traded share are as follows:
Opening Price: This is the price at which the market opens. In other words, it is the price of
the first transaction.
Closing Price: This is the price at the time of closing of the market or the price of the last
trade.
Intra-Day High: This denotes the maximum price at which the share was traded in the day.
Intra-Day Low: This is the minimum price at which the share traded in the day.
Debt Investments:
Debt securities (in the form of non-convertible debentures, bonds, secured premium notes, zero
interest bonds, deep discount bonds, floating rate bond / notes, securitized debt, pass through
certificates, asset backed securities, mortgage backed securities and any other domestic fixed
income securities including structured obligations etc.) include, but are not limited to :
Debt obligations of the Government of India, State and local Governments, Government
Agencies and statutory bodies (which may or may not carry a state / central government
guarantee),
Securities that have been guaranteed by Government of India and State Governments,
Securities issued by Corporate Entities (Public / Private sector undertakings),
Securities issued by Public / Private sector banks and development financial institutions.
Money Market Instruments Include
Commercial Papers
18
Commercial bills
Treasury bills
Government securities having an unexpired maturity upto one year
Call or notice money
Certificate of deposit
Permitted securities under a repo / reverse repo agreement
Any other like instruments as may be permitted by RBI / SEBI from time to time Investments
will be made through secondary market purchases, initial public offers, other public offers,
placements and right offers (including renunciation) and negotiated deals. The securities could be
listed, unlisted, privately placed, secured / unsecured, rated / unrated of any maturity.
The AMC retains the flexibility to invest across all the securities / instruments in debt and money
market.
Investment in debt securities will usually be in instruments which have been assessed as "high
investment grade" by at least one credit rating agency authorized to carry out such activity under
the applicable regulations. In case a debt instrument is not rated, prior approval of Board of
Directors and AMC have to be obtained for such an investment. Investment in debt instruments
shall generally have a low risk profile and those in money market instruments shall have an even
lower risk profile. The maturity profile of debt instruments will be selected in accordance with
the AMC's view regarding current market conditions, interest rate outlook etc.
19
CHAPTER 4
DEMONETIZATION EFFECT ON STOCK MARKET
After November 8, 2016, the word demonetization became a household word. In a daring,
unexpected and completely baffling move, PM Narendra Modi announced on November 8, at
8:00 PM that existing high value currency notes of INR 500 and INR 1,000 will no longer be
currency notes. They will be just pieces of paper with no value whatsoever.
Currency note of denomination 500 is just phased out because new design has been
circulated.
Currency note of denomination 1000 has been demonetized because that particular
denomination will no longer exist. Instead, Government of India has circulated a higher
denomination note of INR 2000.
Is it first demonetization in India?
This isnt the only demonetization India has experienced. In the past, demonetization took place
twice. The table below will give a quick overview of the same:
Year of
Currency notes demonetized
demonetization
1946 INR 1,000 and INR 10,000
INR 1,000, INR 5,000 and
1978
INR 10,000
2016 INR 500 and INR 1,000
Reasons for recent demonetization
Now, one of the biggest question is, why did the recent demonetization take place?
20
This recent demonetization had multiple motives behind it. These motives include:
Clampdown on black money and making Indian economy free of black money in future.
Uprooting corruption from Indian economy and making a corruption-free India.
Driving India into becoming a cash-free economy in near future which will prevent
rebirth of black money and corruption.
Ending counterfeit money which supports terrorism and hence, effectively paralysing
cross-border terrorism.
To be honest, the objectives of demonetization are more or less long-term. We still support it
because we needed to start somewhere. However, whats disturbing is that demonetization gave
pain to millions of Indians who are struggling with cash shortage.
With this recent demonetization 86% of cash in circulation suddenly was destroyed. This led to
short term pain for people. Banks were struggling to deal with long queues of people trying to
exchange their old high-value currency notes with newly circulated currency notes. ATMs
remained closed. However, it is not really easy to understand the total economic impact because
of this unexpected policy simply by looking at people and banks and ATMs. A more reliable
indicator of economic impact has always been the stock market trends.
It is a traditional practice to look at the indices of the stock market to understand the overall
economic environment. Persistent and sharp plunges in such indices always indicate that
economic activities are deteriorating.
21
Basically, stock market is considered to be an independent animal and some policy changes
barely impact the indices in the market. However, post demonetization, the scenario was quite
different in the stock market.
Just a week after demonetization, the NSE S&P CNX Nifty (currently known as NSE Nifty 50)
registered a 5.1% drop in daily closing price as opposed to what was there on November 8 (the
day when demonetization was announced). That was the worst close ever since February, 2016.
In case you didnt know, the Nifty 50 is made up of stocks from companies belonging to various
industries. But the pressing concern here is, is there a negative sentiment spreading across all
sectors?
It is pretty depressing and heart breaking to say that yes, the data from NSE or National Stock
Exchange indeed shows a negative sentiment across various sectors. It turns out that the worst hit
sectors have been realty, consumer and automobile.
The table given below shows the differences in price movements for two different periods
before demonetization and after demonetization. Here are some particulars of the table that you
should know before going through the same:
Several indices of National Stock Exchange have been used. These indices include
FMCG, Automobile, Consumption, Banking, Realty etc.
The data comprises of prices for 25 days of trading before demonetization.
The data also comprises of prices for 11 days of trading after demonetization.
Differences
Returns in Returns in in returns
Sectors or %age before %age after (calculated
NSE Indices demonetizatio demonetizatio as
n n percentage
)
Nifty PSE
0.1 0.14 0.24 **
Bank
22
Nifty Private
0.01 0.73 0.74 **
Bank
Nifty Bank 0.01 0.5 0.49 *
Nifty Metal 0.2 0.14 0.34
Nifty Realty 0.2 1.01 0.81 **
Nifty Auto 0.08 1.2 1.12 **
Nifty India
Consumptio 0.1 0.93 0.83 **
n
Nifty FMCG 0.03 0.82 0.90 ***
IMPORTANT
* Denotes statistical significance at 10 %
** Denotes statistical significance at 5 %
*** Denotes statistical significance at 1 %
Returns are calculated as mean returns
Returns
and represented as percentage
The table above clearly shows that the worst hit sectors in India after demonetization have been:
Auto
FMCG
Consumer
Realty
If you swing your eyes to the banking sectors, you will notice that the impact is differential. This
differential impact may require some explanation. So, let us start with the banking sector.
23
If you try to find out the difference between average return of the banking sector in pre and post
demonetization scenarios, you will see that post demonetization returns have been less than that
of pre demonetization by 0.49%.
Does that indicate that demonetization has hit Indian banking sector negatively?
Before answering this question, here are two more questions and their quick answers:
Did deposits increase in banking sector? Yes, they did and there has been a higher deposit
flow into both the savings and current accounts.
Any positive impacts? Yes, interest rates have gone down, which will lead to treasury
gains and stimulate liquidity.
Now, looking at average returns, did demonetization negatively impact banking sector in India?
This is where we need segregation. Indian banks can be divided into Public Sector Banks and
Private Sector Banks.
80% of Jan Dhan Yojana accounts are with Public Sector Banks. This means more money
in form of demonetized currency notes have flowed into these banks.
Government backing is present for these banks. The budget constraints on these banks are
soft. They get financial help from government when times become adverse.
Public banks have 1/4th the profitability of private banks.
The spill over effect from other sectors are usually absorbed by the government,
providing enough cushion for the Public Sector Banks.
PRIVATE SECTOR
24
Private sector banks did take a hit. The returns dropped. The average return after demonetization
for private banks dropped by around 0.74%. But why?
Private banks do not have government backing and hence, not cushioned against hard
times like this.
Different sectors in India are intertwined. This means the negative impact on other
sectors spilled over to the private banks.
Private banks have only 20% of the Jan Dhan Accounts. This means that the inflow of
demonetized cash was very less in these banks compared to that in the public sector banks.
If you compare the two sectors of banking industry, you will see that the gain in public sector is
not enough to offset the loss in the public sector.
In case you did not know, the government actually made it mandatory to disclose PAN details
while making auto purchase except for purchase of two-wheelers.
Also, the luxury car segment has always been an area where unaccounted money had been spent
in big amounts. People used to purchase those cars using cash. Now, with PAN disclosure
becoming mandatory, this segment took a massive hit.
Talking of two wheelers, people can buy that using cash and PAN disclosure is not mandatory
but, with a large chunk of cash taken out of economy, two wheelers segment also took a massive
hit. The whole negative impact shows up through auto index of NSE.
25
another benefit for the realty sector was that tax system was multi-layered. There is service tax,
there is VAT, there is registration charge and then there is stamp duty. Because of all these layers,
the sale price has always been way higher than actual document price for properties.
With demonetization, dumping black money or unaccounted money in real estate sector,
especially into luxury real estate, high-end real estate and resale real estate is not nearly
impossible. This means that the sellers are now under tremendous pressure to sell of the existing
properties. You should know that Indias real sector industry was booming and the supply end of
the sector ballooned up only recently. With too many properties to sell and cash transactions
taking a massive hit, the sellers are now dropping off the prices for offloading the properties.
Prices have already dipped down by about 30% for luxury properties.
Good thing about the real estate sector however is that most of the cash that was invested into the
sector was actually coming from those investors who hoarded black money. That unaccounted
money was invested into the real estate projects with one objective booking profits by raising
prices. With black money taken care of through demonetization, these investors will be wiped
out of the market, providing a much-needed price correction. This will open up legal channels of
financing properties.
1. With shortage of cash in market, the demand has fallen for such goods and services.
2. Consumers are now in a mood of stashing usable cash and spending as less as possible
that is only on goods and services which are considered as necessity. This is further dropping
the demands for premium consumer goods and FMCG products.
Because the consumption sector has taken a hit, the economy as a whole has also taken a hit.
Lack of consumer confidence and propensity to hoard useable cash is actually taking a toll as
being reflected in the respective indices on Nifty.
26
Negative effect of demonetization temporary or permanent?
Try and evaluate the situation on your own. Do you think this negative impact will be permanent
or is it just a temporary impact?
Okay, we will tell you what we think and what experts think.
This impact is temporary. This temporary impact is because of the fact that 86% of countrys
cash was wiped out overnight and this led to severe cash crunch, forcing people to save usable
cash until the Reserve Bank of India pumps in equivalent amount of cash into market.
However, talking of the stock market, the scenario is certainly different. Nifty indices are
showing deflationary pressure but with new cash gradually entering the market, the consumer
demand is gradually increasing and the market is making an upward correction gradually.
For the current scenario, the market has managed to get a 50% correction in terms of price and in
terms of entire movement, a 38% correction has already been registered. Nifty has taken a
support at the level of 8,000. From perspective of traders who trade in the short-term, keeping
stop loss below 8,000 will allow them ample opportunities for quick rally. For those who eye for
long term, this is the right time for portfolio diversification for the long term because prices are
low but they will gain soon as the inflationary pressure comes it after enough new currency notes
have been injected into the market.
Good thing about the stock market is that it is basically a machine which follows a six-monthly
forward discounting. Any event which leads to a negative impact will actually end within one or
at the most two quarters. So, the negative impact and the deflation that is showing up because of
demonetization of high-value currency notes, will eventually fade off.
27
Indian economy is basically cash intensive. From real estate to automobile to FMCG, everything
heavily depended on cash. Demonetization took off 86% of cash circulating in the economy. This
adversely affected all the cash intensive sectors.
The consumer sector (and its subset FMCG sector) contributes to 56% of Indian GDP. Decline in
this sector is definitely going to hit GDP of the nation and slow down the growth because of
deferred purchases.
The good part is that the slowdown is temporary. We dont even have to look into the long term
to say this. In the medium term, government spending is going to increase significantly. This will
produce direct benefits for the economy.
While government can be looked upon as a macro-economic element, we can always look at the
households, which are the micro-economic elements. In case of households, there will be a
switch from physical savings to financial savings, which will in turn, help to boost economic
growth. Government on the other hand will be able to maintain a proper fiscal discipline.
28
CHAPTER 5
CONCLUSION
The negative impact that showed up in stock market after demonetization is gradually
rebounding back to normalcy. Over time, the stock market will improve as consumer demand
rekindles with injection of new cash.
Even if the government decides to cut down on cash supply significantly and push for cashless
economy, situations will improve because government treasury will become plump and
government spending will increase.
How can we say that government treasury will improve by going cashless?
Cashless economy will prevent unaccounted money or black money hoarding. With accounted
money, government revenue will increase through tax collection. Tax has always been one of the
biggest revenue sources for government. This is why government treasury will improve. On top
of that, with decline in use of paper notes, millions of rupees will be saved because of reduced
costs of paper and ink acquisition as well as reduced printing cost and circulation cost.
Coupled with GST, demonetization and cashless reforms will also improve Indias global ranking
in terms of ease of doing business. This will attract new business and FDI (foreign direct
investment). FDI is yet another source for government revenue.
The move of demonetization has been bold and there are some short-term negative impacts.
However, the medium-term and long term benefits can offset these short-term negative impacts
and help India evolve into a corruption-free nation state with greater transparency and public
power. What do you think?
29
CHAPTER 6
BIBLIOGRAPHY
www.pmjandhanyojana.com
WWW.SEBI.GOV.IN
WWW.NSEINDIA.COM
30