Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3.2 Subsidies PDF
3.2 Subsidies PDF
higher tax incidence. With elastic supply, consumers example, to students, to low-income consumers for
have the higher tax incidence. If schedules are the purchase of goods and services such as housing,
inelastic, the opposite holds, so that more of the tax or to firms needing assistance), the provision of
burden falls on the same side. With inelastic demand, goods and services by the government at below-
most of the tax burden is on consumers; with inelastic market prices; tax relief (i.e. paying lower or no
supply, most of the tax burden is on producers. taxes); and others.
Examining Figures 4.6 and 4.7 will enable you to In this section, we will consider only subsidies
confirm that these results hold. consisting of cash payments by the government to
In general, the tax burden falls proportionately firms. Such payments are usually a fixed amount per
more on the group whose activities are less unit of output, and are therefore specific subsidies.
responsive to price changes: on consumers whose
purchases are not very responsive to price increases Subsidies and the allocation of resources
(inelastic demand), and on producers whose Subsidies, like taxes, have the effect of changing
sales are not very responsive to price increases the allocation of resources because they affect
(inelastic supply). The low responsiveness (low price relative prices, thus changing the signals and
elasticities) means that as price increases due to incentives prices convey. A subsidy granted to a
the imposition of the tax, consumers or producers firm (or group of firms) has the effect of increasing
do not change their buying and selling activities the price received by producers, causing them
substantially, and so as a result must bear a relatively to produce more, and lowering the price paid by
larger portion of the tax burden. consumers, causing them to buy more. Therefore,
the allocation of resources changes and results in
greater production and consumption than in the
free market.
Test your understanding 4.3 As with indirect taxes, we are interested in seeing
1 What determines whether the incidence of whether the granting of a subsidy improves or
an indirect tax falls mainly on consumers or worsens the allocation of resources. Here, too, the
mainly on producers? answer depends on the degree of allocative efficiency
in the market before the subsidy. In an economy
2 Using diagrams, show how the incidence of an
where resources are allocated efficiently, a subsidy
ad valorem tax will be shared between consumers
introduces allocative inefficiency and welfare losses.
and producers in the case of (a) elastic demand,
This will be the topic of this section. But if the
and (b) inelastic demand. What conclusions
economy begins with allocative inefficiency (due to
can you draw about relative tax burdens and
market imperfections), then a subsidy can work to
price elasticities of demand?
improve the allocation of resources if it is designed
3 Using diagrams, show how the incidence of an to correct the source of the inefficiency. This will be
ad valorem tax will be shared between consumers examined in Chapter 5.
and producers in the case of (a) elastic supply,
and (b) inelastic supply. What conclusions can
you draw about relative tax burdens and price
Why governments grant subsidies
elasticities of supply?
Explain why governments provide subsidies, and describe
examples of subsidies.
82 Section 1: Microeconomics
the price paid by the consumer, Pc, plus the subsidy Whatever the case, the impact on the government’s
per unit of output. budget is negative.
The market outcomes due to the subsidy are the
following: Workers
As output expands from Q* to Qsb, firms are
• equilibrium quantity produced and consumed
likely to hire more workers to produce the extra
increases from Q* to Qsb
output, therefore workers who find new jobs are
• the equilibrium price falls from P* to Pc; this is the better off.
price paid by consumers
• the price received by producers increases from Society as a whole
P* to Pp Society as a whole is worse off because there is an
• the amount of the subsidy is given by (Pp − Pc) × overallocation of resources to the production of the
Qsb, or the amount of subsidy per unit multiplied by good; Qsb > Q*.
the number of units sold; this is the entire shaded
area, and represents government spending to Foreign producers
provide the subsidy If the subsidy is granted on exports (goods sold to
other countries), it lowers price and increases the
• there is an overallocation of resources to the
quantity of exports. While this is positive for domestic
production of the good: Qsb is greater than the free
producers, it is negative for the producers of other
market quantity, Q*.
countries who may be unable to compete with the
lower price of the subsidised goods. (This topic will be
Consequences of subsidies for various discussed in Chapter 17.)
stakeholders