Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Therapeutic Effectiveness of Toric Implantable Collamer Lens in Treating Ultrahigh Myopic Astigmatism
Therapeutic Effectiveness of Toric Implantable Collamer Lens in Treating Ultrahigh Myopic Astigmatism
www.biomedres.info
Abstract
With a rapid increase in the prevalence of Ultra-High Myopic Astigmatism (UHMA), especially in the
youth, there have been many studies on visual correction. In our study, we investigated the clinical value
of the Toric Implantable Collamer Lens (TICL) in UHMA. We conducted a retrospective study between
2011 and 2013. TICL implantation was performed on fifteen UHMA patients (30 eyes), and all these
patients were regularly followed up for 12 months. The preoperative and postoperative data, including
Uncorrected Visual Acuity (UCVA), Best Corrected Visual Acuity (BCVA), Intraocular Pressure (IOP),
and corneal endothelial counts, were all analysed using the paired-sample t-test. The 12-month spherical
mirror (SPH) of the surgical eye was -0.25~+0.25 D, and the Cylinder mirror (CYL) was 0~-0.50 D.
Twenty patients exhibited an increase in UCVA by one level in comparison to the preoperative BCVA,
amounting to a 66.7% increase; 20.0% of patients exhibited an increase in UCVA by two levels. A
comparison between the preoperative and postoperative IOP showed no statistically significant
difference. No difference was also found in mean corneal endothelial counts before and after the
operation. A decrease in visual acuity was observed in one eye at the 3rd-month of review; this was
corrected by TICL position adjustment. Precisely measuring the preoperative parameters, selecting the
appropriate TICL, more thoroughly aspirating sodium hyaluronate intraoperatively, and maintaining a
stable IOP were important for maintaining the effectiveness, safety and stability of TICL in treating
UHMA.
this was repeated three times. Oxybuprocaine hydrochloride Long-distance UCVA, slit-lamp microscopy, IOP by non-
eye drops were applied 30 min before the surgery with one contact tonometer (NT-510, DINEK), corneal endothelial cell
drop every 5 min for three or four times. The 0º and 180º of the inspection, chamber angle inspection by UBM, refraction
eye were positioned around the corneal limbus 5 min before status, mydriatic TICL vault, axial position, and lens were all
the surgery with a marker pen under a slit lamp microscope. tabulated.
Lastly, the TICL axis was adjusted during surgery when
necessary. Statistical analysis
The comparisons between the preoperative and postoperative
Determination of IOL degrees
inspection results were performed using SPSS17.0 statistical
TICL (collagen-copolymer material, STAAR collamer) used in software; all data before and after the surgery were analysed
the surgery can be folded into dual-concave one-piece shapes; using the paired t-test, with P<0.05 considered as a statistically
four models (M115, 120, 125, and 130) were manufactured by significant difference.
STAAR (Swiss). The calculation software provided by STAAR
was used to adjust the diameter, refraction degree, and Results
astigmatic degree of TICL after referring to the anterior
chamber depth, WTW, and other parameters measured before Surgical results
the surgery. Furthermore, angle rotations along the horizontal
axis and its schematic diagrams were also calculated to select The patients’ UCVAs before and after the surgery within
the appropriate TICL. different equivalent SPH ranges were shown in Table 1.
Equivalent SPH (-8.0~-21.0 D) were divided into -17.0~-16.75
Surgical procedures D, -12.0~-16.75 D and -8.0~-11.75 D, respectively. In -17.0
D~-16.75 D, the preoperative BCVA was 0.25~0.5; in -12.0
All the surgeries were performed by the same skilled surgeon: D~-16.75 D, the preoperative BCVA was 0.5~0.8; in -8.0
the surgical eye was focally disinfected, regularly paved the D~-11.75 D, the preoperative BCVA was more than 1.0. We
towels, and TICL installation parameters re-checked. A 3.2 observed changes in vision, during D1, W1, M1, M3 and M12
mm incision and an auxiliary incision at the 12:00 position was after the surgery. Twenty eyes had preoperative UCVA<0.1
made along the temporal transparent corneal edge. Sodium (20/30); 10 eyes were within the range of 0.1 to 0.3 (10/30).
hyaluronate was injected into the anterior chamber, and one On postoperative D1, 5 eyes had UCVA ≤ 0.5 (5/30), while 25
disposable pusher was used to inject TICL into the anterior eyes had UCVA ≥ 0.5 (25/30). One week after the surgery, 2
chamber through the main incision. After the TICL was eyes had UCVA ≤ 0.5 (2/30), while 28 eyes had UCVA ≥ 0.5
naturally spread out, the microscopic re-positioning hook was (28/30). One month after the surgery, 28 eyes had UCVA ≥ 0.5
used to place the four loops of TICL between the iris and lens, (28/30), and this was kept stable from M3~M12. Twelve
and fixed afterward inside the ciliary groove. The TICL was months after the surgery, 20 eyes had UCVA ≥ 0.5, accounting
finely adjusted, kept in the center of the lens, and then rotated for 83.3% (20/30), and six eyes had UCVA ≥ 1.0, accounting
to the corneal edge marker with reference to its unique for 20% (6/30). The preoperative and postoperative (M12) IOP,
diamond logo. The sodium hyaluronate of the anterior chamber corneal endothelial count, SPH, and CYL are shown in Table
was flushed with Advanced Medical Optics (AMO) 2. In M12, SPH was within -0.25~+0.25 (mean ± standard
phacoemulsification instrument I/A. The anteroposterior deviation: 0.21 ± 0.11D); CYL was within 0 to 0.50 (mean ±
balance of TICL was adjusted afterward, and the incision standard deviation: 0.19 ± 0.08 D). Twenty eyes exhibited an
completely closed. TobraDex eye drops and ointment were increase in UCVA by one level compared with the preoperative
applied to the surgical eye for 1 w. BCVA, accounting for 66.7%. 20.0% increase in UCVA by two
levels. A comparison between preoperative and postoperative
Postoperative follow-up SPH showed a statistically significant difference (t=105.36,
All the patients were followed up regularly for 12 months. The P<0.01); in addition, the comparison of preoperative and
patients were followed up in the following order: postoperative postoperative CYL also showed a statistically significant
day 1 (D1), day 2 (D2), day 3 (D3), week 1 (W1), month 1 difference (t=3.89, P<0.01).
(M1), month 3 (M3), month 6 (M6), and month 12 (M12).
Table 1. Comparison of preoperative and postoperative UCVA within different equivalent SPH ranges.
Equivalent SPH Preoperative BCVA Postoperative D1 Postoperative W1 Postoperative M1 Postoperative M3 Postoperative M12
(D)
-17.0~21.0 0.25~0.5 10 9 2 3 2
-12.0~16.75 0.5~0.8 15 15 22 21 22
-8.0~11.75 ≥ 1.0 5 6 6 6 6
Table 2. Comparison of the mean values before and after the surgery (x̄ ± s).
Corneal endothelium count (cells/mm2) 2840.75 ± 83.04 2837.75 ± 82.95 0.15 0.88
performed on the surgical eye, which penetrated the iris root at endothelial cells decreased slightly in comparison with the
the 10:00 and 2:00 positions around the iris to form the preoperative endothelial cell count, the difference was not
undercut hole (with a diameter at least 0.6 mm). Even if the statistically significant (P=0.88>0.05).
TICL optical zone caused a pupillary block, the outflow of
During the follow-up assessments, one patient complained of a
aqueous humor would not be affected, thus ultimately avoiding
decline in the visual acuity in his right eye in the third month
the pupillary block that causes an increase in IOP. The period
of regular review. Mydriatic inspection revealed that the right
of routine postoperative local application of TobraDex eye
TICL vault and position were imbalanced, with the refraction
drops and ointment did not exceed one week in order to avoid
being +1.25/-3.50 × 145º. This indicated that the right TICL
the high IOP caused by long-term local hormone usage. The
rotated 45º. After rotation and readjustment of the right TICL,
patients had no postoperative ocular hypertension during the
the postoperative visual acuity was restored to 0.8. The rest of
follow up.
the patients did not complain of rotational displacement of
Generally, patients with high myopia may also show TICL. UBM was performed to check the TICL and chamber
astigmatism. As a result, these patients may not benefit from angle, which revealed that the TICL vault and position were
the correction effects of frame glasses. Because the frame imbalanced, with uneven gaps between its four loops and the
glasses are some distance away from the cornea, the objects chamber angle. This was considered to be caused by an
refracted by the lens would be shrunk by various degrees when inclination during TICL implantation that led to TICL rotation,
projected onto the retina. As narrowing of the magnification is which was followed by significant astigmatism and decreased
positively correlated with the lens degrees, the zoom-out times vision. After re-adjusting the TICL position, this patient’s
of objects in ultra-high myopia would be large. This in turn astigmatism and visual acuity were corrected. The rest of the
made it difficult for the glasses-corrected visual acuity to reach patients showed uniform TICL vaults and stable balance in the
BCVA. When TICL is implanted into the eye, it would be close routine postoperative reviews. The optical part was parallel and
to the node of the refractive system, so that the changes in the equivalent to the corneal plane. UBM inspection revealed that
object magnification ratio would be extremely small, which the TICL’s loops uniformly contacted with the chamber angle,
would reduce the aberrations, and magnify the objects, with no compression or bending, and that the gaps were
subsequently improving the patients’ visual quality [20]. uniform, indicating that the TICLs implanted were suitable for
Compared with frame glasses, the postoperative UCVA after the patient’s ciliary groove’s diameter. Consequently, we
the TICL implantation could be increased by one or two levels believe that accurately measuring the anterior chamber depth
compared to the preoperative BCVA. The follow-up and WTW is critical in ensuring postoperative stability of
assessments in this study showed that 20 patients exhibited TICL implantation. When measuring WTW preoperatively,
UCVA increase by one level compared to the preoperative UBM inspection should be performed simultaneously, and it
BCVA, accounting for 66.7%, with 20.0% showing an increase should always be performed by the same surgeon to guarantee
of two levels over the baseline. This indicates that the TICL the identity, continuity, and precise measurement for the
implantation had good effects. objective selection of IOL with the right diameter. Accurately
determination of the IOL diameter was important for achieving
Cataracts have been reported to be complications of TICL
postoperative stability of TICL implantation. When necessary,
implantation in studies in China and abroad [21-23]. With the
however, a panoramic UBM could be performed to directly
constant improvements in TICL materials, however, the
measure the distance between the two ciliary grooves, which
procedure has become safer and with fewer side effects. TICL
would make the implantation even more accurate and reliable.
is made of Collamer material, which adds collagen into silica
gel. As a result, the material is more hydrophilic and lighter, In light of these findings, we suggest that precise measurement
with more elasticity, and is closer to the physiological state. and objective selection of IOLs with a suitable diameter should
After folding, it could be injected through the 3.2 mm corneal be performed to ensure the safety and effectiveness of TICL
limbal incision, and then fixed behind the iris’s ciliary groove. implantation in treating UHMA and restoring the patient’s
This would form an ideal optical zone equivalent to the corneal visual acuity. We summarized “seven preconditions,” or “seven
plane with long-term rotational stability. TICL could also be goals” for treatment success: select the appropriate patient
used to correct astigmatism and limit the off-axis incident light. (good condition); reserve the right lens (good measurement);
The incidence of glare and halos would be less, thereby prepare fully (good peri-iris incision); install the lens smoothly
allowing normal functions of the iris to be maintained. Its (good preview); perform skilled specification (good practice);
optical unit exhibits a convex shape, and the unit is far away handle the emergency properly (good IOP); and perform close
from both the corneal endothelium and lens. The unit only postoperative observation (good postoperative observation).
contacts the peripheral zones of the iris and the front surface of All of these steps must be followed to ensure surgical quality.
the lens. The TICL optical part, thus, is in a state of We believe that ICL and TICL implantation had significant
suspension, which reduces damage to the corneal endothelial effects on ultra-high myopia, and the indications might be
cells, and reduces mechanical injury from the TICL on the appropriately extended to moderate and high myopia. TICL
anterior capsule of the lens. All the operations were performed could be used not only for artificial lens implantation for
by an experienced surgeon. The operations were gentle enough hyperopia and cataracts, but also for the treatment of post-
to avoid surgically induced lens damage as well as the excimer laser residual refraction [24] and stable keratoconus
occurrence of cataracts. Though the average number of corneal [25]. The present study, however, only sampled UHMA
patients. Moreover, the patient amount was relatively small, patients with high myopia. J Cataract Refract Surg 2015;
and the postoperative follow-up only lasted 12 months. This 41: 1810-1819.
condition required further observation for assessment of its 10. Hashem AN, El Danasoury AM, Anwar HM. Axis
long-term effects. alignment and rotational stability after implantation of the
toric implantable collamer lens for myopic astigumtism. J
Conclusion Refract Surg 2009; 25: 939-943.
11. Elies D, Alonso T, Puig J, Gris O, Güell JL, Coret A.
In conclusion, lens refraction correction surgery is the
Visian toric implantable collamer lens for correction of
preferred option for high myopia, especially ultra-high myopia.
compound myopic astigmatism. J Refract Surg 2010; 26:
Our study confirmed that TICL implantation would lead to
251-258.
significant vision improvement. With negative vacuum
aspiration of sodium hyaluronate during the operation and two 12. Alfonso JF, Lisa C, Fernandez-Vega Cueto L, Fernandes P,
holes at the iris root to avoid aqueous humor block, no Gonzalez-Meijome JM, Montes Mico R. Comparison of
postoperative ocular hypertension was recorded in any patient visual and refractive results of toric implantable collamer
within twelve months of follow-up. lens with bioptics for myopic astigmatism. Graefes Arch
Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2013; 251: 967-975.
Conflict of Interest 13. Lee JK, Chuck RS, Park CY. Femtosecond laser refractive
surgery: small-incision lenticule extraction vs. femtosecond
All authors have no conflict of interest regarding this paper. laser-assisted LASIK. Curr Opin Ophthalmol 2015; 26:
260-264.
References 14. Kamiya K, Igarashi A, Shimizu K, Matsumura K, Komatsu
M. Visual performance after posterior chamber phakic
1. Matamoros E, Ingrand P, Pelen F, Bentaleb Y, Weber M,
intraocular lens implantation and wave front guided laser in
Korobelnik JF, Souied E, Leveziel N. Prevalence of myopia
situ keratomileusis for low to moderate myopia. Am J
in france: a cross-sectional analysis. Medicine (Baltimore)
Ophthalmol 2012; 153: 1178-1186.
2015; 94: 1976.
15. Barsam A, Allan BD. Excimer laser refractive surgery
2. Hejcmanova M, Horackova M, Vlkova E. Effect of
versus phakic intraocular lenses for the correction of
refraction procedures LASIK on various ocular functions
moderate to high myopia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev
(initial results). Cesk Slov Oftalmol 2005; 61: 205-212.
2014; 6: 007679.
3. Huang H, Yang J, Bao H, Chen S, Xia B, Zou J.
16. Shah R, Shah S, Sengupta S. Results of small incision
Retrospective analysis of changes in the anterior corneal
lenticule extraction: All-in-one femtosecond laser refractive
surface after Q value guided LASIK and LASEK in high
surgery. J Cataract Refract Surg 2011; 37: 127-137.
myopic astigmatism for 3 years. BMC Ophthalmol 2012;
12: 15. 17. Bühren J, Kohnen T. Factors affecting the change in lower-
order and higher-order aberrations after wavefront-guided
4. Balañá M, Ruiz-Moreno JM, Roura M. National study to
laster in situ keratomileusis for myopia with the Zyoptix
assess the costs of patients with high myopia with and
3.1 system. J Cataract Refract Surg 2006; 32: 1166-1174.
without choroidal neovascularisation. Value Health 2015;
18: 419. 18. Bamashmus MA, Al-Arabi AH, Alawad MA. Visual
outcomes and patient satisfaction after implantable
5. Gaucher D, Chartier C, Cohen SY, Malecaze F, Souied EH,
collamer lens and toric implantable collamer lens correction
Weber M, Leveziel N. High myopic patients: a survey of
for moderate to high myopia and myopic astigmatism.
their history, feelings, beliefs and needs. J Fr Ophtalmol
Saudi Med J 2013; 34: 913-919.
2016; 39: 12-19.
19. Assetto V, Benedetti S, Pesando P. Collamer intraocular
6. Li YT, Xie MK, Wu J. Association between ocular axial
contact lens to correct high myopia. J Cataract Refract Surg
length-related genes and high myopia in a Han Chinese
2006; 22: 551-556.
population. Ophthalmologica 2016; 235: 57-60.
20. Yu A, Wang Q, Xue A, Zhu S, Wang S, Chen Y, Sun J.
7. Hansen RS, Lyhne N, Grauslund J, Grønbech KT,
Comparison of contrast sensitivity after angle-supported,
Vestergaard AH. Four-year to seven-year outcomes of
iris-fixated and posterior chamber phakic intraocular lens
advanced surface ablation with excimer laser for high
implantation for high myopia. Ophthalmologica 2008; 222:
myopia. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2015; 253:
53-57.
1027-1033.
21. Hsuan JD, Caesar RH, Rosen PH, Rosen ES, Gore CL.
8. Ahmad MA, Edrees MH, Jafarzadehpur E. Relationship
Correction of pseudophakic anisometropia with the Staar
between corneal thickness, corneal curvature, and
collamer implantable contact lens. J Cataract Refract Surg
intraocular pressure before and after laser treatment for
2002; 28: 44-49.
simple myopia. Eye Sci 2014; 29: 70-73.
22. Sanders DR, Vukich JA. Comparison of implantable
9. Schallhorn SC, Venter JA, Hannan SJ, Hettinger KA.
contact lens and laser assisted in situ keratomileusis for
Outcomes of wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis
moderate to high myopia. Cornea 2003; 22: 324-331.
using a new-generation Hartmann-Shack aberrometer in
23. Liu TX, Luo X. Stability of axis and patient satisfaction the correction of high myopic astigmatism in eyes with
after toric implantable collamer lens implantation for keratoconus. J Refract Surg 2008; 24: 840-842.
myopic astigmatism. Pak J Med Sci 2013; 29: 1371-1374.
24. Kojima T, Horai R, Hara S, Nakamura H, Nakamura T, *Correspondence to
Satoh Y, Ichikawa K. Correction of residual refractive error
Jinqiang Yu
in pseudophakic eyes with the use of a secondary
piggyback toriclmplantable Collamer Lens. J Refract Surg Department of Ophthalmology
2010; 26: 766-769.
Renmin Hospital, Hubei University of Medicine
25. Kamiya K, Shimizu K, Ando W, Asato Y, Fujisawa T.
Phakic toric Implantable Collamer Lens implantation for PR China