Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Police Brutality CH S 445 Paper
Police Brutality CH S 445 Paper
CH S 445
10 May 2018
It is widely understood that people who are of ethnic minorities such as Latinos or
African American in the United States of America have a history of negative police relations
within their communities. This poor relationship has been worked on through police force by
creating policies that gear police toward more fair treatment of suspects. Despite rules and
policies attempting to regulate fairness, continued difficulty with the ongoing long-standing
perception of mistrust, maltreatment, and fear of the outcome of police interaction continues. The
paper will discuss the abuse against Latinos by the police force and apprise the organizations
There are several issues contributing to the silencing of the Latino voice in the public
debate on police brutality. One of the leaders of the National Council of La Raza (NCLR), Eric
Rodriguez, stressed that the contemporary civil rights organizations, such as Voto Latino, NCLR,
and Black Lives Matter, strive to raise awareness of the police brutality in Latino communities.
Although Latinos account for 17.6% of the American population, they represented 16% of the
police-involved killings, 30% of arrests, and 23% of searches in 2016. However, according to
Rodriguez, state and local agencies' self-report statistics frequently fail to account for the cases
involving victims that are both Latino and Black. There is also a trend to poor coverage of Latino
cases by Latino media outlets and political organizations (Downs). Furthermore, the US Latino
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 2
community lacks consensus as to how it is affected by police violence. Activists often tend to
address the topic solely from the perspective of border violence or undocumented immigrants,
rather than native-born Latinos. In addition, some Latino advocacy organizations, such as the
National Hispanic Leadership Agenda, combining 40 large groups, centered most of their efforts
around the issues of immigration. Such an attitude contributes to the perception of Latinos as a
"single-issue group" (Fountain). To this end, Juan Cartagena, from the Latino Justice civil rights
organization, blamed American Latinos for their inability to generate any significant protest
The above trends can be argued to be largely regressive as compared to some of the early
Latino organizations of the 1930s-1940s. El Congreso del Pueblo de Habla Española particularly
comprised multi-ethnic network of liberal and radical activists who managed to ignite a more
concrete awareness that considered Latinos to be a significant force throughout the nation and
not just an isolated, regional population. Hence, the unity of all Latinos became a central theme
in its political work and outreach (Gutierrez 110-112). El Congreso was distinctly unique from
most other organizations in the Mexican community. Bert Corona, for example, observed that the
new organization, from its inception, made every effort to make no distinctions between
immigrants and those born in the United States stressing "the unity of all the Spanish-speaking,
U.S. citizens or not" (Garcia 112). One of El Congreso's prominent leaders, Luisa Moreno,
understood the need to develop, as Vicki L. Ruiz explains, a "true national conference" and
therefore worked diligently to steer this civil right assembly in that direction (Ruiz 94-97). The
other key leader of the organization included the executive secretary, Josefina Fierro. Through
her tireless dedication and organizational abilities, and that of other activists as well, El Congreso
moved forward on several fronts to particularly bring attention to problems of police brutality
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 3
(Sanchez 249). El Congreso, for example, would help establish the Sleepy Lagoon Defense
youth accused of murder (Healey and Isserman 76). Twenty-two Mexican American youths were
put through trial with an all-white jury and faced many injustices, such as being unable to speak
with counsel or change clothes. LaRue McCormick informed the youths of their legal rights and
found seasoned lawyers to join the defense (Healey and Isserman 68). Carey McWilliams and
Josefina Fierro de Bright gave speeches on the radio and at conferences to gain public attention.
Carey McWilliams headed the SLDC and became the chair of the SLDC after the Sleepy Lagoon
trial.
There are several common patterns in their contemporary reactions to police abuse. First, such
reactions are usually led by small groups of political activists who are not connected to any
nationwide organizations, which contribute to their invisibility in the media. Such activists have
organized numerous campaigns promoting police accountability and are often affected by
African American activism in the similar way some Latino movements were back in the 1960s
(Fountain). For example, in January 2016, in Baltimore, Latino and African American youth
organized a demonstration demanding a police reform. Latino students subsequently called upon
the local school officials to support the Baltimore's immigrant community. Following the
practices, the Latino community met at a public forum emphasizing the absence of Latinos in the
above report and questioning the police's willingness to adopt its recommendations (Fountain).
emphasized the problem of police-community relations at its founding convention and adopted a
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 4
resolution pledging ANMA "to seek discipline of police responsible for acts of brutality." La
Asociación Mexico-Americana (ANMA) was formed in the 1930s and is also known as El
Congreso. Anyway, ANMA cited numerous examples of police overreaction. Among them was
the police beating in October 1949 of nine Mexican-American youngsters arrested for murder.
The nearby Maravilla chapter targeted the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department for its
abusive behavior. In February 1950 officers for the Sheriff's Department arrested fifty Mexican
Americans, including a pregnant woman, who had been attending a baby shower. The charge
was disturbing the peace and possible presence of narcotics, even though no search warrants had
been issued and no neighbors had complained. ANMA accused the officers of using rude and
abusive language and brutal tactics in making the arrests. After an unsuccessful appeal to the Los
Angeles County Board of Supervisors, ANMA publicized the incident and urged others to join
its ranks and help build a mass movement to achieve first-class citizenship (Sanchez 220-221).
However, some of these unfortunate acts of brutality helped ANMA expand. For example, a
branch of ANMA was organized in Sonora, Arizona after a Mexican national was killed by
deputies during a dispute. Additionally, when members of Mine Mill union were beat up,
arrested, and held without bail by deputy sheriffs, it led to creation of the Grant County chapter
of ANMA.
The second pattern in the today's Latino's responses to police abuse is the recognition of
commonality with people of color and African Americans in particular. For instance, in 2016, in
Charlotte, North Carolina, following the police shooting of an unarmed African American man
Keith Lamont Scott, Latinos joined the city protests. The Latino activists specifically emphasized
the similarity of Latino and African American struggle. The above urban revolt, in turn,
contributed to the creation of Charlotte Uprising organization with the purpose of addressing
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 5
police violence against Blacks (Fountain). Similarly, in 2014, in San Francisco, a hunger strike
was launched by five protesters following the police killings of Latino and African American
males. The small group was led by the rapper Equitor and the group refused to eat until either the
Police Chief Greg Suhr or Mayor Ed Lee resigned. It ultimately resulted in the resignation of the
As mentioned, such responses somewhat parallel the Latino movements in the 1960s-
1970s without sharing the latter's radical ideology. For instance, organized in the 1960s, the
Brown Berets had little patience with the continued police harassment and urged a more militant
stance. The goals of the Berets, declared Sanchez, was "to stop discrimination and the many
injustices against our people." That would require major social changes, and "in order to
motivate someone or something towards change, pressure must sometimes be applied." This
option had probably been inspired by similar statements coming from Malcolm X and the Black
Panthers (UCLA Chicano Studies Research Center). Thus, according to Montejano, the Brown
Berets formed as a kind of “community defense group” wing of the Chicano Movement. They
focused on upholding and protecting everyday life practices within the barrio, as opposed to “the
missions or details of building a political party.” In south Texas, the Berets particularly focused
on local issues like police brutality, community drug abuse, and unsafe working conditions
(Montegano 173). These ‘community guards’ operated under an organized system of rules, or
manifestos, that mandated compulsory attendance at meetings, dress codes, daily communication
requirements, prohibitions against alcohol and drugs, and mutual respect (Montegano 178). The
Brown Berets were the first to go to high schools yelling “walk out!” which eventually led to the
East L.A. Walkouts, where thousands of Chicano high school students walked out of schools due
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 6
to frustration of having unequal conditions in Los Angeles School District high schools and
Latino Justice is headquartered in New York. They can also be reached via
latinojustice.org. The organization provides legal assistance to police abuse victims and
encourages those affected by racially-inspired stops and frisks to share their story.
charlotteuprising.com. The organization assists those affected by the Charlotte Uprising events
by providing bail and legal support, as well as free and confidential mental health support.
areas of civil engagement, civil rights, immigration, education, workforce, economy, health and
Voto Latino is a civic media organization that seeks to engage, educate, and empower
Latinos in order to build a stronger and more inclusive democracy. They are headquartered in
The Zoot Suit Riots were a series of violent fights between U.S. servicemen, off-duty
police officers, and civilians against young Latinos, African Americans, and other minority
communities in June 1943. A Zoot Suit was a fashion trend among men where they characterized
by a long loose jacket with padded shoulders and high-waisted tapering trousers. The zoot suit
Latino youths in California were known as "pachucos" and were viewed by whites as street
thugs, gang members, and delinquents because of their flashy clothes and chains. Anyway, the
Zoot Suit Riots began with U.S. servicemen attacking Latinos and stripping them off their suits,
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 7
leaving them injured and almost naked on the sidewalk. The Zoot Suiters symbolized the birth of
a new generation of Mexican American working-class youth and found their sense of identity
through this.
Luis Rodriguez from Moore, Oklahoma died in the early morning hours of February 15,
2014 in fault of police force. The reason for why police got involved and cause this situation to
occur is because someone called about a "fight" occurring outside the Warren theater. The
"fight" was between Rodriguez's wife, Nair, and their 19-year-old daughter when Nair slapped
their daughter for her behavior of being disrespectful and deceitful. When the police arrived, they
arrested Rodriguez as he was trying to go after his wife to comfort her and when the police
arrested him they tackled him on the floor. When he was being pushed down to the ground,
Rodriguez told the police officers he couldn't breathe but they ignored his warnings. After this,
Nair started recording with her phone and moments later the paramedics arrived and Rodriguez
was no longer breathing and died. Two months later, Rodriguez's death was ruled a homicide
during an attempted restraint by law enforcement. Homicide is a medical term that does not
denote wrongdoing or criminal intent. As a result, the Cleveland County District attorney cleared
Another example of a Latino police brutality case occurred in March 2018 when ten
police officers from the San Francisco Police Department shot 19-year-old male, Jesus Adolfo
Delgado, ninety-nine times. The incident occurred when two people alerted the police of robbery
at gunpoint by the occupants of a black Honda Civic. In a video, it shows Jesus Adolfo Delgado
jumping into the trunk of a black car. 19-year-old male, Victor Navarro-Flores, was in the driver
seat and 18-year-old female, Cristina Juarez, was in the passenger seat. Officers pulled up to the
black car because the vehicle matched the car description and ordered Victor out of the car and
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 8
detained him while Cristina remained inside the vehicle. Officers then noticed Delgado in the
trunk. With the trunk being half-way open, the officers yelled at him several commands in
English and then Spanish and when Delgado refused to comply, officers discharged a bean bag
round at him. Moments later Delgado allegedly fired a gun from the inside of the trunk and as a
result, the ten police officers fired at Delgado ninety-nine times, twenty-five bullets of which hit
Delgado. Later, the San Francisco Police Department recovered a 9mm handgun from the
Honda's trunk. Later it was revealed that it is believed that Jesus Delgado hid in the trunk
Conclusions
Overall, the contemporary US Latino generation, though critical of the conditions of the
Latino community in the United States, believes in the principles of American democracy and
articulates the language of Americanism paralleling the early Latino reformist movements.
Beginning in the 1930s and stretching into the 1950s, El Congreso, ANMA and others worked to
eradicate the ills affecting Mexican Americans and Mexican nationals, calling for reform rather
than revolution, and fighting to secure the rights guaranteed to Mexicans under the Constitution.
Despite this fundamental difference with the later Chicano Generation, one cannot disregard the
precedent that these groups established for the insurgency of the 1960s and 1970s.
Reflection
People who are from ethnic minorities, which are known to experience being racially
often have their own family histories of racial segregation and problems in the United States.
They believe that the police treated them unfairly especially when compared to how white people
were treated. However, often studies on the police are limited due to resource complications and
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 9
the police surely do not report on themselves. The national surveys leave out significant
members of the population, whereby the end result appears that people felt the police were fair.
purports to be responsive to, and representative of, the citizenry. When there is an outcry for
accountable policing and responsive policy, and the police respond with militarized gear
designed to handle an 'enemy,' this is indicative of a larger problem which merely influences
institutions like policing. The problem being protested in the first place is that police cannot be
trusted with their guns, so a response where they are more fully armed is categorically deaf and
blind. A better community representation on police forces in the way of gender, ethnicity, and
religion is a reputable institutional reform, but itself cannot do much to alleviate police bias.
Getting police of minority ethnicity on the force may not go far enough. At the same time, after
an instance of police brutality has already occurred, it is obviously too late to prevent it from
happening; however, aftermath of these incidences, and how they are handled may help prevent
future instances. To this end, Latino civil rights organizations may be effective in both helping
the victims of police abuse and organizing joint community actions to amend policies and ensure
Works Cited
Dillon, Jay. “Medical Examiner Rules Luis Rodriguez's Death a Homicide.” KOKH, 2
Downs, Kenya. "Why aren’t More People Talking About Latinos Killed by Police?" PBS,
Fountain, Aaron. "How African American Activists are Influencing Latinos." Black
Garcia, Mario T. Memories of Chicano History: The Life and Narrative of Bert Corona,
Gutierrez, David G. Walls and Mirrors: Mexican Americans, Mexican Immigrants, and
Healey, Dorothy and Maurice Isserman. Dorothy Healey Remembers: A Life in the
History.com Staff. “Zoot Suit Riots.” History.com, A&E Television Networks, 2017,
www.history.com/topics/zoot-suit-riots
KTVU, Unknown. “Family of 19-Year-Old Killed by SFPD Last Month Meets with
month-meets-with-da
Rafieha, Sanchez, Vela, Salvador 11
Montegano, David. Quixote's Soldiers: A Local History of the Chicano Movement, 1966-
Ruiz, Vicki L. From Out of the Shadows: Mexican Women in Twentieth Century
Ideology, and Identity, 1930-1960, edited by Mario T. Garcia, Yale University Press, 1989, pp.
214-262.
UCLA Chicano Studies Research Center. "Panel: 'The Birth of a New Symbol' - The
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOrz_nuCpE0