Hepatitis B and The Need For A Booster Dose
Hepatitis B and The Need For A Booster Dose
After several decades of vaccination against hepatitis B virus in newborns, infants, adolescents, and adults, the
question remains whether a booster dose is ever needed. Long-term protection is most commonly measured
through 4 methods: the anamnestic response after administration of a booster dose, infection rate in vaccinated
populations, in vitro B and T cell activity testing, and seroepidemiological studies. Long-term protection is
present despite a decrease in anti-hepatitis B surface antibodies over time. The exact mechanism of long-term
protection, however, is not yet fully understood. There is no need for boosters in immunologically potent
persons as long as a full course was adequately administered that respected the recommended timelines, as
evidenced by studies conducted up to 20 years after the original immunization course. However, a booster dose
should be planned for immunocompromised patients, based on serological monitoring.
Over 2 billion people worldwide have been exposed to improvements. Vaccination is an easy and cost-
hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection, and at least 378 mil- effective measure to prevent disease and infection.
lion are chronically infected and are at risk for severe Additionally, vaccination eliminates the incidences
disease and death [1]. Different degrees of endemicity are of persistent HBV infection and chronic liver disease
recognized. If seroprevalence of hepatitis B surface an- and diminishes the pool of chronic carriers, thus
tigen (HBsAg) is .8%, the region is considered to be of limiting transmission of infection to susceptible
high endemicity; if HBsAg seroprevalence is 2%–8%, the contacts [2].
region is considered to be of intermediate endemicity; A complete standard vaccination schedule exists in 3
and if HBsAg seroprevalence is ,2%, the region is doses that are most commonly administered as a 0-, 1-,
considered to be of low endemicity. Hepatitis B is and 6-month schedule. A 3-dose course induces pro-
a bloodborne and sexually transmitted infection. Peri- tective antibody concentrations in .95% of healthy
natal and horizontal transmission is evident in countries infants, children, and adolescents and in .90% of
where the disease is highly endemic and within house- healthy adults [3, 4]. The minimum spacing of doses is 4
holds containing HBsAg carriers, but administering the weeks between doses 1 and 2, 8 weeks between doses 2
vaccine at birth adequately controls perinatal trans- and 3, and 16 weeks between doses 1 and 3 [5]. The
mission. primary hepatitis B immunization series, starting at
Currently, the therapeutic options for treating birth, consists of at least 3 doses of vaccine (1 mono-
chronic HBV infection are difficult to implement and valent at-birth dose followed by 2 monovalent or
are not yet fully effective, leaving room for further combined vaccine doses). Four doses may be given for
programmatic reasons, administered according to the
schedules of national routine immunization programs
Received 28 December 2010; accepted 29 March 2011.
Correspondence: Elke Leuridan, MD, Vaccine and Infectious Disease
[1].
Institute, University of Antwerp, Universiteitsplein 1,Antwerp, B-2610, Belgium The term ‘‘booster’’ refers to a vaccination given some
([email protected]).
time after a primary vaccination series and with the aim
Clinical Infectious Diseases 2011;53(1):68–75
Ó The Author 2011. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Infectious
of providing rapid protective immunity against a sig-
Diseases Society of America. All rights reserved. For Permissions, please e-mail: nificant breakthrough infection (ie, infection resulting
[email protected].
1058-4838/2011/531-0012$14.00
in serological test results positive for HBV and/or clin-
DOI: 10.1093/cid/cir270 ical disease) [1].
Duration of
Year of Vaccinated No. of doses or follow-up, Anamnestic
Reference publication population No. of subjects Country schedule in months years response
[15] 2003 Infants 70 1 41 Samoa 3 doses; 0.1.6 starting at 5 or 9 100% after 5 years,
birth, booster at 5 or 93% after 9 years
9 years
[16] 2004 Infants of carrier 116 UK 3–4 doses, starting at birth 10 86%
mothers
[17] 2004 Infants of carrier 78 1 113 China 4 doses, starting at birth 15 97.3–96.7%
mothers 1 infants
from noncarrier
mothers
[18] 2007 Adolescents 620, 11 lost Italy 3 doses 11 91.7%
anti-HBs
[19] 2005 Adolescents 550 Canada 3 doses 5 99%
[20] 2005 Infants and recruits 1212 children, Italy 3 doses: 3.5.11 months 10 97% children and
446 recruits and 0.1.6 for recruits 96% recruits
[21] 2006 Infants 94 Iran 3 doses starting at birth 10 95.8%
[22] 2007 Adolescents 255 The Gambia 3 doses 15 92.3%
[23] 2007 Infants; recombinant 166 Alaska 3 doses starting at birth 5–7 99%
vaccine
Adolescents; 138 Alaska 3 doses starting at birth 10–15 88%
recombinant vaccine
Adolescents; plasma 74 Alaska 3 doses starting at birth 12–15 71%
derived
[24] 2007 Infants of 37 Alaska 3 doses starting at birth 15 51% after 2 weeks,
carrier mothers 62% after 1 month
[25] 2008 Infants 872 Taiwan 3 doses starting at birth 15–21 70.3%
[26] 2009 Young adults 127 Taiwan 3 doses starting at birth 18–23 75.6% after 1 month;
20% after 1 week
[27] 2009 Children 186 Germany 3 doses 1 1 7–9 98.9%
NOTE. Anti-HBcs, anti-hepatitis B surface antibody.
seroconversion), and in vitro testing for T and B cell activation. boosting illustrate the prolonged duration of protection against
Additionally, seroepidemiological research gives an idea of the hepatitis B, even after the disappearance of vaccine-induced
changes in the carrier rate in vaccinated populations and the serological anti-HBs (Table 1).
impact of immunization programs. Instead of testing 1 month after booster administration, some
The definition of a breakthrough infection with HBV found investigators have been testing immune responses earlier. Fifteen
most often in the literature is an infection characterized by the years after immunization, in Alaskan children who received 3 doses
development of anti-HBc, without clinical features and without starting at birth, only 51% showed an anamnestic response 2
carrier state development. Infection with acquisition of HBsAg, weeks after a 5-lg booster dose, whereas 62% showed a response
a significant breakthrough infection, has been reported in in- after 1 month [24]. Jan et al [26] also measured early anamnestic
fants of carrier mothers, related to the maternal viral load, as responses in Taiwanese students vaccinated at birth, 18–23 years
well as in one HCW [36, 43]. earlier. A low percentage of anamnestic responses were encoun-
tered after 1 week (20.5%). However, titers equaled those in other
Anamnestic Response to Booster Dose as a Way to Demonstrate studies after 1 month (75%), revealing that anamnestic immune
Long-term Protection responses need time. Nevertheless, those who had the earliest
Cohorts of vaccinated people are followed up around the world; anamnestic response in the study of Jan et al [26] were those who
the current longest duration of follow-up is 23 years after pri- ended up with the highest levels of anti-HBs 1–6 months after the
mary vaccination [26, 44]. Regardless of the endemicity in the booster dose. As the incubation time is, on average, 90 days from
country [20, 45] and regardless of natural boosting [17], an- exposure to onset of jaundice and 60 days from exposure to onset
amnestic responses measured shortly after vaccine-induced of abnormal alanine transaminase levels, the stimulation of
Table 2. Data on Studies in Different Populations in Regions With Different Endemicity During the Last Decade, Using Measurement of Hepatitis B Markers as Markers for
d
NOTE. Anti-HBc, anti-hepatitis B core antibody; d, days; HBsAg, hepatitis B surface antigen; HBV, hepatitis B virus; PCR, polymerase chain reaction.