Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Borland-Clifford House Nomination
Borland-Clifford House Nomination
1. Name
historic
2. Location
street & number 339 Ralston for publication
3. Classification
Category Ownership Status Present Use
district public X occupied agriculture museum
X building(s) X private unoccupied commercial park
structure both work in progress educational -X_ private residence
site Public Acquisition Accessible entertainment religious
object n/a in process x yes: restricted government scientific
being considered yes: unrestricted industrial transportation
no military other:
4. Owner of Property
name 0. S. Clifford
street & number 339 Ralston
city, town
Reno state
Nevada
cl . I 11,1,11 I , I i I , , I D ___ I I I I I
El l I I I , I I i I I . I . I l i I J_I I I
G , I I I , I , , I I i I i I. , , I I I J_I
Verbal boundary description and justification; Washoe Go. Assessor's Parcel #.Q7-274-12
The parcel is 71.66' X 187'. The house stands on the South 71.66* of the
original lots 8 & 9 of block 27^, book 7- -Parcels were subdivided to provide
street frontage for houses along Ralston prior to the construction of this
List all states and counties for properties overlapping state or county boundaries
state code
n/a county
n/a code
n/a
n/a n/a
state code county code
title date
FHR-8-300A
(11/78)
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
HERITAGE CONSERVATION AND RECREATION SERVICE
Clifford House
CONTINUATION SHEET 1 ITEM NUMBER 10 PAGE One
1. Name of Property______________________________________________________
historic name:___Borland-Clifford House__________________________________________
other names/site number: previously listed as Clifford House_____________________ _________
2. Location
street & number 339 Ralston Avenue not for publication
city or town ___Reno________ vicinity
state ______Nevada_______ code NV county Washoe code 031 zip code 89503
In my opinion, the property __ meets does not meet the National Register criteria. (__ See continuation sheet for additional comments.)
other (explain):
5. Classification_____________________________________
Ownership of Property (Check as many boxes as apply)
x private
_ public-local
_ public-State
_ public-Federal
Number of Resources within Property (Do not include previously listed resources in the count.)
Contributing Noncontributing
1 _buildings
_ _ sites
_ _ structures
_ _ objects
_1_ _L Total
Name Of related multiple property listing (Enter "N/A" if property is not part of a multiple property listing.)
6. Function or Use___________________________
Historic Functions (Enter categories from instructions)
Cat: domestic_____ Sub: residence__________
7. Description
Architectural Classification (Enter categories from instructions)
Mid-Nineteenth Century: Gothic Revival_______
Narrative Description (Describe the historic and current condition of the property on one or more continuation sheets.) See continuation sheets.
Form NPS Form 10-900 (Rev. 10-90} OMB No. 1024-0018
USDI/NPS NRHP Registration
Page 3
8. Statement of Significance_____________________________________________
Applicable National Register Criteria (Mark "x" in one or more boxes for the criteria qualifying the property for National Register listing)
x A Property is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history.
_ B Property is associated with the lives of persons significant in our past.
x C Property embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction or represents the
work of a master, or possesses high artistic values, or represents a significant and distinguishable
entity whose components lack individual distinction.
_ D Property has yielded, or is likely to yield information important in prehistory or history.
Narrative Statement of Significance (Explain the significance of the property on one or more continuation sheets.) See continuation sheets.
Verbal Boundary Description (Describe the boundaries of the property on a continuation sheet.)
Boundary Justification (Explain why the boundaries were selected on a continuation sheet.)
Additional Documentation
Submit the following items with the completed form:
Continuation Sheets
Maps
A USGS map (7.5 or 15 minute series) indicating the property's location.
A sketch map for historic districts and properties having large acreage or numerous
resources.
Photographs
Representative black and white photographs of the property.
Additional items (Check with the SHPO or FPO for any additional items)
Property Owner________________________________________________
(Complete this item at the request of the SHPO or FPO.)
Paperwork Reduction Act Statement: This information is being collected for applications to the National Register of Historic Places to nominate properties
for listing or determine eligibility for listing, to list properties, and to amend existing listings. Response to this request is required to obtain a benefit in
accordance with the National Historic Preservation Act, as amended (16 U.S.C. 470 et seq.).
Estimated Burden Statement: Public reporting burden for this form is estimated to average 18.1 hours per response including the time for reviewing
instructions, gathering and maintaining data, and completing and reviewing the form. Direct comments regarding this burden estimate or any aspect of this
form to the Chief, Administrative Services Division, National Park Service, P.O. Box 37127, Washington, DC 20013-7127; and the Office of Management and
Budget, Paperwork Reductions Project (1024-0018), Washington, DC 20503.
NPS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
Section 8: Significance
The subject property was listed in the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) as the Clifford House
on March 7, 1983. At that time the property was listed under Criterion C, for architecture at the local level
of significance.
This amendment is to add Criterion A in the area of Community Planning and Development, to
modify the property's name to reflect the original owner's construction of the residence, and to
change the period of significance to 1875-1958, also to reflect recent research on the property that
shows an earlier construction date than that proposed in the original 1982 nomination (listed on
March 7,1983) of the Clifford House at 339 Ralston Street in Re no, Nevada. In addition, included
here is updated historical information on the neighborhood in which the Borland-Clifford House is
located, Reno's Western Addition.
The Borland-Clifford house had important beginnings in the fall of 1875 since it was one of the first houses
built in Reno's new Western Addition. Since that time, the neighborhood surrounding it has gone through
several transformations. Early in the neighborhood's development, the Lincoln Highway transected the
Western Addition beginning in 1913, leading the way for U.S. Highway 40 and the need for motels,
restaurants, and auto stations. Located within the Western Addition, the Whitaker School (for girls) was
the first school in 1876 to bring education to Reno's western edge, and many followed. A small Catholic
hospital, established in 1907, has expanded through the years, and now covers much of the addition. The
year 1931 forever changed Reno when the state legislature legalized gaming and reduced the legal
residency requirements to file for divorce to six weeks. Many Reno neighborhood homes became boarding
houses for "temporary residents," the divorce-seekers. Other original homes vanished making way for a
more modern bungalow style homes. As gaming increased and moved west casino owners destroyed many
homes in order to make room for large buildings and parking lots. Remarkably, through all these changes,
the Borland-Clifford house has remained a private single-family home. It is significant at the local level in
the areas of Architecture (Criterion C), and Community Planning and Development (Criterion A).
The Western Addition's history began even before Reno's birth. On July 1, 1862, President Lincoln signed
the first Pacific Railroad Act, which stated, "That there be, every alternate section of public land,
designated by odd numbers, to the amount of five alternate sections per mile on each side of said railroad,
on the line thereof, and within the limits often miles on each side of said road, not sold, reserved, or
otherwise disposed of by the United States." The future site of Reno lay right in the middle of odd
numbered Section 11, Township 19N, Range 19E. The railroad acquired the entire section except one
NPS Form 10-900-a 0MB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
small portion. The only inhabitant living within Section 11 (640 acres) was Myron C. Lake. A year earlier,
Lake purchased a bridge and hotel on the main wagon road from California to Virginia City, Nevada.
By the spring of 1868, the Central Pacific Railroad approached the Truckee Meadows. Lake sold Charles
Crocker 160 acres within Section 11 for $200. Being on the road to Virginia City, Crocker decided this
would be a good location for a depot and town. On May 8, 1868, Reno was bom during a public auction
when Crocker sold town lots to regain the money he spent purchasing the property.
As Reno's population grew, individuals purchased lots and subdivided them into additions. Some of
Nevada's earliest businessmen, real estate magnate M.C. Lake, University of Nevada founder J.N. Evans,
surveyor and Nevada-California-Oregon RR president AJ. Hatch, and banker H.G. Marsh, all bought large
parcels for development that later became additions to Reno. On September 21, 1874, the Central Pacific
Railroad deeded the northwest quarter (160 acres) of Section 11 to Contract and Finance, a financial
company owned by the CPRR. This became the Western Addition, basically bound by Chestnut (now
Arlington) to the east, Vine Street to the west, 9th Street along the north and the railroad tracks along #rd
Street, to the south.
Two weeks after Contract and Finance subdivided the new Western Addition, John S. Shoemaker became
the first landowner there when he purchased lots 6, 7, 8 and 9 of Block 2 for $500 in October, 1874. He
quickly subdivided lots 8 and 9 and changed them into eastward-facing properties oriented toward Ralston
Street. Shoemaker built his south-facing house on lots 6 and 7. On July 28, 1875, James H. Borland
purchased Shoemaker's lots 8 and 9 for $600. Two days later, he sold one portion of those to A. C.
Hobart for $300. Hobart retained the property until January 4, 1876, when he sold it to Charles T. Bender
for the same amount he paid. On July 29, 1875, H.W. Higgins purchased the third portion. Borland
quickly began construction on the southern end of lots 8 and 9.
From the beginning, businesses shared land next to prominent houses. Brick and wood yards, an invalid's
home, livery stables, and churches all found early homes in the Western Addition. The first large non-
residential purchase went to Bishop O.M. Whitaker in April 1876. With the help of several influential
Reno investors, the Bishop purchased Western Addition's Block 14 in its entirety. He soon began
construction of his Episcopal school for girls. This elaborate structure was three stories high and cost
$27,000. That October, Principal Miss Kate Sill opened the school to forty-five young scholars. The
Whitaker School may have been the first school in the Western Addition, but many followed.
Aside from Bishop Whitaker's School, the Western Addition housed one other parochial school. In 1877,
three Dominican sisters arrived in Reno and built an elaborate academy on Lake Street near the Catholic
Church, but by 1892, financial debt forced the church to close the school. That same year, Father Micheal
NFS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
Kiely asked Sister Antoine and Sister Vincent to open a smaller, more practical school. With Bishop
Manogue's blessing, they purchased Lots 11 and 12 in Block C of the Conner's Survey, in the northwest
quadrant of the Western Addition, for $900. Here they built a small two-room schoolhouse. Within two
years, their needs grew and two more classrooms plus an upstairs living quarters for boarders was added.
In May 1894, Father Francis Reynolds began construction of a two-story brick building. As the school
grew, so did the building. By the turn of the century, it was a three-story building with rooms for more
than a dozen boarders. In 1903, Father Thomas Tubman became priest of the Reno Parish. He did not
believe education was the concern of the church, and was opposed to the sisters' school. In early 1907,
Sisters Vincent and Bertrand went to Ireland to recruit postulants for their convent. When they returned
that September, they found Father Tubman had converted their school into a hospital.
By the turn of the century, Reno was in dire need of a hospital. There were twenty-one physicians in
Reno, most of whom worked as general practitioners. Several attempts at establishing hospitals were
made, including one at the old Whitaker School and another on Ralston Heights just north of the Western
Addition. It was not until 1908 when Sisters Hospital began operation, that a medical facility was
successful. In 1912, the hospital built a wing next to the old Convent School, and in 1931, St. Mary's
Hospital expanded across the street to its present location. The hospital and other health care facilities
soon encompassed most of Conner's Survey. The most relevant event to this amendment at St. Mary's
Hospital occurred on December 30, 1963 with the birth of Tamera Buzick. If it were not for that, this
amendment would not exist.
By 1879, Reno's population had outgrown the small frame schoolhouse at the northwest corner of Front
and Sierra. When the trustees for Reno School District No. 10 began searching for a suitable location for
their new school, they found the Western Addition to be a prime location. That March the trustees
purchased an unnumbered block which lay just west of Reno's block A and on the eastern edge of the
addition on West Street between Fourth and Fifth streets. Central School was a two-story high large brick
building with mansard roof surmounted by a tower. Its eight classrooms housed grammar school students
on the lower floor and high school students on the second floor. This building serviced Western Addition
children's needs until 1911 when trustees deemed it unsafe. Students moved into the old Whitaker School
while the district built two new schools. The magnificent Reno High School soon occupied the grounds of
the old Central School. A new grammar school also found a home in the Western Addition. Despite the
dangers of a creek crossing the property and its location near the largest livery in Reno, School District
trustees began construction on Fifth Street between Bell and Washington. They named the school after a
long-time Reno educator, Mary S. Doten.
From 1875 to 1907 when OJ. Clifford purchased the home at 339 Ralston, the Western Addition
continued to grow as a residential neighborhood. Over two hundred homes were located in the
NPS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
subdivision. The addition represented almost every imaginable frontier and urban occupation. According
to city directories, professions included bartenders, stock raisers, shoemakers, a dress maker, several
carpenters, two paving labors, a hotel keeper, a bank teller, a dentist, several teachers, a freight agent, a
telegraph operator, two house painters, a railroad foreman, a horseshoer, a surveyor, a sheepherder, two
cops, teamsters, a blacksmith, several bookkeepers and clerks, and many day laborers comprised the
notable mix of professions. The more memorable families included stock raiser and hotelier George
Mapes, bank teller Charles Bender, Cattle Inspector Solomon Hilp, and bartender Spiro Francovich. It
would take some of these families generations to become well-known in the Reno community, but at the
turn of the twentieth century, they all lived productive lives in the Western Addition.
Like the Borland home, many nineteenth-century homes became rentals and boarding houses. The
Western Addition was conveniently located near downtown Reno making it ideal for people working in the
city. Borland's neighbor J. S. Shoemaker sold his home to Elda Orr, wife of early settler and developer of
Reno's first irrigation ditch, John Orr, on October 23, 1897. Mrs. Orr apparently wanted to convert the
home to an income-producing rental property. She subdivided Shoemaker's two remaining lots, rotated
the original home so it faced Ralston Street, and built another home between that house and Borland's.
Both Orr houses became rentals. On the other side of 339 Ralston, the Bender home also lost its status as
a single residence. Charles Bender died June 28, 1915 and his widow sold the house to Luella Chessman
on May 17, 1919, who in turn began taking in boarders. A year later on June 12, 1920, Luella sold the
property to Mary Ramsey who then converted the home into the Ralston Apartments.
The Western Addition's transportation connection dates back to its birth along the Central Pacific
Railroad. However, it took Henry Ford's mass production of the automobile to change the neighborhood.
With America's newfound desire to travel, better roads became a necessity. In September 1913, the
Lincoln Highway Association announced their transcontinental highway route. Reno it es were delighted to
find they were to be included. Lincoln Highway travelers entered Reno from either the east or the west
by way of Fourth Street. Being at the base of the Sierra Nevada, Reno became a prime resting location.
Once tourists entered town, they took several routes to reach desired hotels, motels, restaurants and auto
station. Many travelers went directly through the Western Addition. By 1922, traffic increased along
Fourth Street when the new Victory Highway divided the Western Addition. In 1926, Fourth Street
became federal Highway US 40. Motels, restaurants and auto stations replaced many original homes. In
1938, the Higgins home at 361 Ralston fell to Manford JB Gas Co. and became 500 W. Fourth Street.
This left only three original homes on Shoemaker's 1875 subdivision within the Western Addition.
In 1931, the Nevada Legislature reduced the residency period for divorce to six weeks. The Western
Addition became a perfect waiting location for temporary residents in Reno. It was still a quaint
neighborhood, and it conveniently located near restaurants, theaters, the library, gaming establishments,
NPS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
(Section 8 continued)
and most importantly the Washoe County courthouse. During the 1931 -1934 period, six residences on the
300 block on Ralston Street were listed in divorce court documents as addresses for the temporary
"residents" (Harmon 2000). Renters such as these helped the addition survive the trying times of the
Depression. Shoemaker's old house, the Orrs' new house, as well as the Bender and Higgins homes all
benefited from the divorce trade. The Borland-Clifford home does not appear to have been modified for
boarders, and does not appear in newspaper ads of the day as a rental for divorce-seekers.
It took over thirty years for legalized casino gaming to make its appearance in the Western Addition,
through changes in zoning laws. In 1965, Peter Cladianos Jr. purchased the 79-unit Sands Motel on
Arlington Street, and began expanded the hotel immediately. By 1969, the Sands Motor Inn was large
enough to qualify for an unlimited gambling license. In May 1978, the Cladianos family began construction
of a thirteen-story tower directly across the street from the Clifford home. Today the Sands Regency
occupies an entire block that was once home to a dozen nineteenth-century houses. For instance, the
Francovich home at 328 Ralston was saved from demolition when it was moved to its present location at
557 Washington Street. The Sundowner, the Gold Dust West, and the Reef casinos followed the Sands in
taking entire blocks to build casinos that forever altered a once vital residential neighborhood in the Reno
downtown "core."
Reno is no longer a bustling nineteenth-century railroad town. The Western Addition's picturesque
gardens and chestnut trees are all gone. The charismatic neighborhood where Guy Borland and Oscar
Clifford once played as boys has vanished. The quiet carriage ride from the railroad to Whitaker's School
is now a fast-paced drive from the now below-grade railroad trench through downtown to Interstate 80
(which now covers the northern section of the Western Addition). Growth and development may have
changed Reno's environment, but under the shadow of the Sands Regency Hotel exists a small reminder of
Reno's western heritage. Through it all, James Borland's little gothic house has remained a family home
filled with children's laughter. Currently the property owner rents the house to single families.
In the entire 160 acres that originally made up the Western Addition, only a few pre-1900 homes remain
intact. Even fewer have remained private residences. Urban growth in the areas of transportation,
education, health care, the divorce trade, and gaming have changed the feeling of the once-elite
neighborhood known as the Western Addition.
James Howatt Borland was born in Pennsylvania in 1849 to Scottish immigrants John and Jean Borland.
In 1856, his family traveled by sea to California where they quickly settled in Placerville. Here James'
NFS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
father made the transition from coal miner to gold miner. James did not follow his father's career choice,
however. James moved frequently and worked clerk type jobs for various companies. In 1871, he
temporarily lived in Reno where he worked as a clerk for merchants Manning and Duck. He also spent
time in Rye Patch, Nevada where his father ran a hotel on the Southern Pacific RR line with the help of his
wife and his two sons Robert and Alexander. James then moved to San Francisco where he met and
married Mary Ella Millett in October 1873. At the end of August 1874, Mary Ella gave birth to son Guy
Howatt Borland in San Francisco. That October, they returned to Reno where James purchased lots 8 and
9 in the Western Addition on July 28, 1875. By early September, their new gothic home was ready for
occupancy (the home appears on the first Sanborn Fire Insurance Map completed for the City of Reno, in
1885). They lived in the home less than five years, and in 1880, the Borland family returned to Rye Patch
where they lived with James' parents and he worked as a telegraph operator. In 1897, James accepted a
job with the Internal Revenue Service in San Francisco. In 1904, He became general manager of the San
Francisco-based United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company of Baltimore, Maryland. He retained this
position until his death on May 26, 1919.
From 1880 until the turn of the century, the Borland's little gothic home was rented to tenants. One
renting family was Virginia & Truckee RR conductor P. F. Verrrill, his wife Sarah, and their daughter
Florence. Mary Jepson, a Danish housekeeper lived in the home with them. Another renter was Harold
Clausen's family. Clausen was part owner of Block and Clausen's Washoe Saloon and Lunch Counter on
Commercial Row in downtown Reno. On March 21, 1902, James Borland sold the house to Mrs. Augusta
Rosenthal. She also used the home as a rental until she sold it to Mrs. O.J. Clifford on July 31, 1907. The
Cliffords owned the home until 199L
Oscar Jed Clifford was born in Holly, Michigan to Michiganders William and Sarah Clifford on October
16, 1860. When O.J. was fifteen years old, the family moved to Austin, Nevada where his father worked
at the local grocery store during the gold rush days there. Oscar J. married Austin native Lucy Criscenzo
on July 9, 1889. Lucy was the second of four children born to emigrants Sam and Eliza Criscenzo; her
father was a barkeep in Austin. After marriage, O.J. edited and published the Reese River Reveille and
established a pharmacy business in Austin. On June 26, 1896, Lucy gave birth to their only child Oscar S.
Clifford. On March 28, 1901, O.J. received his license to practice pharmacy in Washoe County, Nevada.
In 1903, the family moved to Sparks, and three years later, they moved to Reno where O.J. became a
partner of the Dalton, Clifford and Wilson drug store on First and Virginia Streets. He worked there until
his retirement in 1920. For a time, both Lucy's father and O.J.'s mother lived at the family home on
Ralston Street. O.J. died of a stroke on April 31, 1932. Lucy lived in the home until August 28, 1945.
Oscar S. graduated from University of Nevada in 1918. In 1955, he married a woman named Beth
(maiden name unknown), and the two continued living at 339 Ralston. Oscar worked several jobs during
his life including sales for the Sierra Pacific Power Company. He died February 15, 1945. Beth sold the
house in 1991.
NFS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
(Section 8 continued)
Integrity
According to the Washoe County Assessor's Office, Mr. Hong V. Nguyen purchased the home at 339
Ralston Street in 1995, and currently owns it as a rental property. Recent modifications to the residence
are minimal, at most, or undetectable. Although the surrounding streets continue to experience growth and
change, this portion of Ralston Street, specifically the Borland-Clifford House at 339 Ralston, maintains
integrity in terms of location, design, materials, workmanship and association.
Boghosian, Paula
1982 Historical Preservation and Archaeology Inventory Form: Clifford House. On file at State Historic
Preservation Office, Carson City.
Downing, AJ.
1873 Cottage residences. J. Wiley & Son, New York.
Franzwa, Gregory M.
2004 The Lincoln Highway-Nevada, The Patrice Press, Tucson.
2000 Nystrom Guest House, National Register of Historic Places registration form. On file at State
Historic Preservation Office, Carson City.
NPS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018 (8-86)
Kling, Dwayne
1999 The Rise of the Biggest Little City, An encyclopedic history ofReno Gaming 1931-1981.
University of Nevada Press, Reno.
Polk, R.L.
1900-1945 Folk's Reno, Sparks and Washoe County Directory. R.L. Polk and Company, San
Francisco.
1897-1919 Folk's San Francisco City Directory. R.L. Polk and Company, San Francisco.
Townley, John M.
1883 Tough Little Town on the Truckee: Reno 1868-1900, Great Basin Studies Center, Reno.
(Section 9, continued)