Maceda vs. ERB
Maceda vs. ERB
Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence > Year 1990 > December 1990 Decisions > [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 :
December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD
(ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJANDRO B. AFURONG; REX V. TANTIONGCO; and OSCAR E. ALA, in their
collective official capacities as Chairman and Members of the Board (ERB), respectively; CATALINO MACARAIG, in
his quadruple official capacities as Executive Secretary, Chairman of Philippine National Oil Company; Office of
Custom Search the Energy Affairs, and with MANUEL ESTRELLA, in their respective official capacities as Chairman and President
of the Petron Corporation; PILIPINAS SHELL PETROLEUM CORPORATION; with CESAR BUENAVENTURA and REY
Search
GAMBOA as chairman and President, respectively; CALTEX PHILIPPINES with FRANCIS ABLAN, President and
Chief Executive Officer; and the Presidents of Philippine Petroleum Dealer's Association, Caltex Dealer's Co.,
Petron Dealer's Asso., Shell Dealer's Asso. of the Phil., Liquefied Petroleum Gas Institute of the Phils., any and all
concerned gasoline and petrol dealers or stations; and such other persons, officials, and parties, acting for and
on their behalf; or in representation of and/or under their authority, Respondents. [G.R. Nos. 95119-21 :
ChanRobles On-Line Bar Review December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 OLIVER O. LOZANO, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB),
PILIPINAS SHELL PETROLEUM CORPORATION, CALTEX (PHIL.), INC., and PETRON CORPORATION, Respondents.:
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 1/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
EN BANC
[G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.]
192 SCRA 363
SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD
(ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJANDRO B. AFURONG; REX V.
TANTIONGCO; and OSCAR E. ALA, in their collective official capacities as
Chairman and Members of the Board (ERB), respectively; CATALINO
MACARAIG, in his quadruple official capacities as Executive Secretary,
Chairman of Philippine National Oil Company; Office of the Energy Affairs, and
with MANUEL ESTRELLA, in their respective official capacities as Chairman
and President of the Petron Corporation; PILIPINAS SHELL PETROLEUM
CORPORATION; with CESAR BUENAVENTURA and REY GAMBOA as chairman
and President, respectively; CALTEX PHILIPPINES with FRANCIS ABLAN,
President and Chief Executive Officer; and the Presidents of Philippine
Petroleum Dealer's Association, Caltex Dealer's Co., Petron Dealer's Asso.,
Shell Dealer's Asso. of the Phil., Liquefied Petroleum Gas Institute of the
Phils., any and all concerned gasoline and petrol dealers or stations; and such
other persons, officials, and parties, acting for and on their behalf; or in
representation of and/or under their authority, Respondents.
[G.R. Nos. 95119-21 : December 18, 1990.]
DebtKollect Company, Inc.
192 SCRA 363
OLIVER O. LOZANO, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB),
PILIPINAS SHELL PETROLEUM CORPORATION, CALTEX (PHIL.), INC., and
PETRON CORPORATION, Respondents.
DECISION
SARMIENTO, J.:
The petitioners pray for injunctive relief, to stop the Energy Regulatory Board (Board
hereinafter) from implementing its Order, dated September 21, 1990, mandating a
provisional increase in the prices of petroleum and petroleum products, as follows:
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 2/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
On September 21, 1990, the Board, in a joint (on three applications) Order granted
provisional relief as follows:
WHEREFORE, considering the foregoing, and pursuant to Section 8 of Executive Order
No. 172, this Board hereby grants herein applicants' prayer for provisional relief and,
accordingly, authorizes said applicants a weighted average provisional increase of ONE
PESO AND FORTY-TWO CENTAVOS (P1.42) per liter in the wholesale posted prices of
their various petroleum products enumerated below, refined and/or marketed by them
locally. 3
December-1990 Jurisprudence
The petitioners submit that the above Order had been issued with grave abuse of
discretion, tantamount to lack of jurisdiction, and correctible by Certiorari.
[G.R. No. 32945 : December 3, 1990.] MARIANO T. The petitioner, Senator Ernesto Maceda, 4 also submits that the same was issued
NASSER, Petitioner, vs. THE COURT OF APPEALS,
HON. MALCOLM SARMIENTO, in his capacity as
without proper notice and hearing in violation of Section 3, paragraph (e), of Executive
Presiding Judge, Court of First Instance of Pampanga, Order No. 172; that the Board, in decreeing an increase, had created a new source for
Branch I, AURORA RIVERA CANLAS, PATERNO R. the Oil Price Stabilization Fund (OPSF), or otherwise that it had levied a tax, a power
CANLAS, and TOMAS CENTILLAS, Respondents. [G.R.
No. 32946. December 3, 1990.] MARIANO T. NASSER,
vested in the legislature, and/or that it had "re-collected", by an act of taxation, ad
Petitioner, vs. THE COURT OF APPEALS, PATERNO R. valorem taxes on oil which Republic Act No. 6965 had abolished.
CANLAS, AURORA RIVERA-CANLAS, TOMAS
CENTILLAS and THE CHIEF OF POLICE OF SAN The petitioner, Atty. Oliver Lozano, 5 likewise argues that the Board's Order was issued
ISIDRO, DAVAO ORIENTAL, Respondents. without notice and hearing, and hence, without due process of law.
[G.R. No. 39430 : December 3, 1990.] FRANCISCO The intervenor, the Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (TUPAS/FSM)-
MANLAPAZ, DELFIN SANGCAP, DOMINGO SANGCAP,
PEDRO CUNANAN, FAUSTO DE LA PENA and
W.F.T.U., 6 argues on the other hand, that the increase cannot be allowed since the
HONORATA DE LA PENA, Petitioners, vs. HON. COURT respondents oil companies had not exhausted their existing oil stock which they had
OF APPEALS, HON. JUDGE LORENZO R. MOSQUEDA, bought at old prices and that they cannot be allowed to charge new rates for stock
HON. JUDGE VIRGILIO CANIVEL, TEODORO RIVERA,
PABLO RIVERA, RENATO RIVERA and BONIFACIO
purchased at such lower rates.
RIVERA, Respondents.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 3/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
The Court set the cases (in G.R. Nos. 95203-05) for hearing on October 25, 1990, in
[G.R. No. 55466 : December 3, 1990.] MANILA
SURETY & FIDELITY CO., INC., Petitioner, vs. COURT
which Senator Maceda and his counsel, Atty. Alexander Padilla, argued. The Solicitor
OF APPEALS and WILLIAM H. QUASHA, Respondents. General, on behalf of the Board, also presented his arguments, together with Board
Commissioner Rex Tantiangco. Attys. Federico Alikpala, Jr. and Joselia Poblador
[G.R. No. 78778 : December 3, 1990.] 191 SCRA
814 LEONIDA CORONADO, FELIX BUENO, MELANIA
represented the oil firms (Petron and Caltex, respectively).
RETIZOS, BERNARDINO BUENASEDA and JOVITA
MONTEFALCON, Petitioners, vs. THE COURT OF
The parties were thereafter required to submit their memorandums after which, the
APPEALS and JUANA BUENO ALBOVIAS, Respondents. Court considered the cases submitted for resolution.
[G.R. No. 79560 : December 3, 1990.] 191 SCRA On November 20, 1990, the Court ordered these cases consolidated.
823 ANDRES E. DITAN, Petitioner, vs. PHILIPPINE
OVERSEAS EMPLOYMENT ADMINISTRATION On November 27, 1990, we gave due course to both petitions.
ADMINISTRATOR, NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
COMMISSION, ASIAWORLD RECRUITMENT, INC., The Court finds no merit in these petitions.
AND/OR INTRACO SALES CORPORATION,
Respondents. Senator Maceda and Atty. Lozano, in questioning the lack of a hearing, have
overlooked the provisions of Section 8 of Executive Order No. 172, which we quote:
[G.R. No. 80904 : December 3, 1990.] 191 SCRA
830 BALTAZAR, PEDRO, URSULA, and DOMINGO, all "SECTION 8. Authority to Grant Provisional Relief . — The Board may, upon the filing of
surnamed PANTIG, Petitioners, vs. VENANCIO
BALTAZAR, Respondent.
an application, petition or complaint or at any stage thereafter and without prior
hearing, on the basis of supporting papers duly verified or authenticated, grant
[G.R. No. 82115 : December 3, 1990.] 191 SCRA provisional relief on motion of a party in the case or on its own initiative, without
836 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee,
vs. ROMEO ORTIZ y BALLARES, Accused-Appellant. prejudice to a final decision after hearing, should the Board find that the pleadings,
together with such affidavits, documents and other evidence which may be submitted
[G.R. No. 84884 : December 3, 1990.] EULALIO M. in support of the motion, substantially support the provisional order: Provided, That
RUIZ and ILUMINADA RUIZ, Petitioners, vs. HON.
DOROTEO N. CANEBA, THE CITY SHERIFF OF MANILA
the Board shall immediately schedule and conduct a hearing thereon within thirty (30)
AND/OR HIS DEPUTIES, ZENAIDA SANGALANG and days thereafter, upon publication and notice to all affected parties. : nad
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 6/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
GERMOGENES GINGCO, HONORIO DETOITO, ELIGIO determines policy, and ultimately, by the electorate, that stands to be better for it or
MENDOZA, RUBEN QUITORIANO, LEON DELA CRUZ,
PACITO SALES, ANTONIO CEMANES, IRENEO
worse off, either in the short or long run.
LUBUGIN, FORTUNATO MATO, ROMEO MERIC,
ALBERTO GALLO, MELCHOR SALGADO, SIMEON
At this point, the Court shares the indignation of the people over the conspiracy of
QUIJANO, ANTONIO CARAAN, CARLITO GUZMAN, events and regrets its own powerlessness, if by this Decision it has been powerless.
ALBERTO SALMON, FELIMON TAN, FERNANDO The constitutional scheme of things has simply left it with no choice.
FAUSTINO, CONRADO DAVID, REYNALDO NOLASCO,
ANTONIO NIETO, JAIME CAMACHO, ALBERTO In fine, we find no grave abuse of discretion committed by the respondent Board in
PANGLAO, ROSAURO GANAC, ALFREDO ARCABIO,
PEDRO MANASALA, VICENTE BELARMINO, ROMULO
issuing its questioned Order.
SIOCO, SEVERINO ATIENZA, JR., RUFO ABALOS,
JESUS POSADA, ALBINO BACARRO, ERNESTO DAJAY,
WHEREFORE, these petitions are DISMISSED. No costs.
WILFREDO VILLALON, CELESTINO BACARRO, MANUEL
TOLENTINO, ERNESTO ANTONIO, OSCAR ABUNDIO,
SO ORDERED.
ZOSIMO IJARES, RUBEN ARISTORENAS, GAUDENCIO
CASTILLO, DOMINGO DELA TORRE, DANILO
Narvasa, Gutierrez, Jr ., Cruz, Gancayco, Bidin, Griño Aquino, Medialdea and
RONCADA, RAFEL PUPA, ALFONSO SAPINORO, Regalado, JJ., concur.
LUISITO JACRIQUE, MARCELINO BESA, ANSELMO
DATELES, ALBERTO PALCULAN, BIENVENIDO Fernan, C.J., Melencio-Herrera and Padilla, JJ., no part.
FUENSALIDA AND JOSE ORZAL, Petitioners, vs. THE
HON. AMADO G. INCIONG in his capacity as Deputy Feliciano, J., is on leave.
Minister of Labor; NLRC Commissioners DIEGO
ATIENZA, CLETO VILLATUYA and GERONIMO
QUADRA; ATLANTIC CONTAINER CORPORATION;
INLAND INDUSTRIES, INC., LAZARO ARRIOLA, Separate Opinions
BIENVENIDO KATALBAS, AURORA JEREZA, GOSHI DE
YULO AND PAZ YULO AND ROBERTO JACINTO, PARAS, J., dissenting:
Respondents.
I dissent.
[G.R. No. 55361 : December 10, 1990.] 192 SCRA
163 SPOUSES TEOFILO ERCILLO and TERESITA In fixing the oil prices complained of, the Energy Regulatory Board (ERB) gravely
ERCILLO, Petitioners, vs. COURT OF APPEALS and abused its discretion —
SPOUSES LUTGARDA CIFRA and BENJAMIN CIFRA,
SR., represented by their son and attorney-in-fact, (1) in approving the prices without due process of law, and
BENJAMIN CIFRA, JR., and HON. JOSE P. CASTRO,
Respondents. (2) in exercising the taxing power in gross violation of the 1987 Constitution which
[G.R. No. 55613 : December 10, 1990.] 192 SCRA
vests such power only in Congress. : nad
[G.R. No. 79962 : December 10, 1990.] 192 SCRA 7. Nos. 78888-90, 79501-03, 79590-92, June 23, 1988, 162 SCRA 521.
209 LUCIO R. CRUZ, Petitioner, vs. COURT OF
APPEALS AND CONRADO Q. SALONGA, Respondents.
8. Supra, at 535.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 8/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
[G.R. Nos. 84132-33 : December 10, 1990.] 192 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
SCRA 257 NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANY AND
NEW AGRIX, INC., Petitioners, vs. PHILIPPINE
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
VETERANS BANK, THE EX-OFFICIO SHERIFF and 2013 2014 2015 2016
GODOFREDO QUILING, in his capacity as Deputy
Sheriff of Calamba, Laguna, Respondents.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 9/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
Economic and Development Authority, Regional Office
No. VIII and Member of the Board; HON. SEDFREY A.
ORDO�EZ, Secretary of Justice and Chairman of the
Review Committee under Executive Order No. 17; and
DR. CRES V. CHAN-GONZAGA, Respondents.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 10/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
MAXIMA FRANCISCO and FRANCISCO FRANCISCO,
Respondents.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 11/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
CONGSIGNA, REYMUNDO CUADRA, EUFRONIO
CUBERO, BIENVENIDO CURAYAG, RUDICASTRO
CURAYAG, JOVENCIO DARAY, DAVID DE LEON,
NELSON ECHIN, ROLANDO ESCATRON, BERTINO
ESPINOLA, CRESENCIO FRANCIS, MATEO FRIAS,
RODOLFO FUENTES, BENEDICTO GALLOGO, HERMANO
GALOPE, JORGE GALVE, ERNESTO GONABO, VIRGILIO
GRUMO, JEMELITO GUBAL, RICARDO GUILLEN,
GENEROSO HERNANDEZ, JR., NELSON JABAY, EMILIO
JACINTO, EMELIANO JALA, JR., IGNACIO JURALBAR,
ALFREDO LOMOLJO, CELESTINO LOMOLJO, EDUARDO
LOPEZ, LUCIO LOPIO, SAMUEL LOREDO, NORBERTO
LORIA, MARCOS LOSIS, MARIO LUENGAS, NICOLAS
MAGHINAY, ROGELIO MATILDO, FLORANTE MIRANDA,
ANACLETO MONTON, NARCISO MONTON, ERNESTO
OROZCO, CHARLITO ORQUITA, MERLCHOR PANTO,
CASIMIRO PEREGRINO, EDUARDO PLAZA, NELSON
PLAZA, PAQUITO PLAZA, PEDRO PLAZA, FREDIOMIO
QUI�ONES, PEPE RAMIREZ, JOEL REMEDIO,
EDUARDO REVELLEZA, GERALDO ROSIL, JR.,
TEMESTOCLES RUBENAL, REMEGIO SABUSIDO, ROGER
SOTES, BELTRANO SULLANO, JAIME SULLANO, ERNIE
TACUGDOY, WENIFREDO TOCMO, SR., PAQUITO
TRUGILLO, ANIOLITO URBIZTONDO, ROMARICO
URIARTE DARIO ORQUIZA, BERTINO VALLEJO,
FRANCISCO VEGA, CRESENCIO YPARRAGUIRRE, RUDY
YPARUAGUIRRI and EDUARDO SACRAGON, SR.,
Petitioners, vs. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
COMMISSION, (Fifth Division), SURIGAO
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION (SUDECOR) and RET.
GEN. REYNALDO G. DILAN, Vice President for Field
Operations & Administration, Respondents.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 12/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
[G.R. No. 82002 : December 20, 1990.] 192 SCRA
478 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee,
vs. FRANCISCO DE GUZMAN y DE DIOS, Accused-
Appellant.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 13/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 14/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
Appellee, vs. BENJAMIN HERICO, Defendant-
Appellant.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 15/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
[G.R. No. 88336 : December 26, 1990.] 192 SCRA
743 REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, Petitioner, vs.
THE HONORABLE SANDIGANBAYAN (FIRST
DIVISION), Respondents.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 16/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 17/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
G.R. Nos. 84132-33 December 10, 1990 -
NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, ET AL. v.
PHILIPPINE VETERANS BANK, ET AL.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 18/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 19/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
DEVT. COMPANY WORKERS
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 20/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
G.R. No. 55466 December 3, 1990 - MANILA
SURETY & FIDELITY CO., INC. v. COURT OF APPEALS,
ET AL.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 21/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
G.R. No. 30616 December 10, 1990 - EUFRACIO D.
ROJAS v. CONSTANCIO B. MAGLANA
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 22/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
G.R. No. 31688 December 17, 1990 - DIRECTOR OF
LANDS, ET AL. v. JUAN P. AQUINO, ET AL.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 23/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
G.R. No. 81835 December 20, 1990 - ROMEO J.
ORDOÑEZ v. ALFREDO J. GUSTILO, ET AL.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 24/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 25/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 26/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
G.R. No. 55613 December 10, 1990 - ERNESTO
DICHOSO v. COURT OF APPEALS, ET AL.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 27/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
TRUSTEES, ET AL.
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 28/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 29/30
8/18/2018 [G.R. Nos. 95203-05 : December 18, 1990.] 192 SCRA 363 SENATOR ERNESTO MACEDA, Petitioner, vs. ENERGY REGULATORY BOARD (ERB); MARCELO N. FERNANDO, ALEJAN…
G.R. No. 46210 December 26, 1990 - RICARDO
VILLAFLOR v. COURT OF APPEALS, ET AL.
Copyright © 1998 - 2018 ChanRobles Publishing Company | Disclaimer | E-mail Restrictions ChanRobles™ Virtual Law Library™ | chanrobles.com™ RED
http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1990decemberdecisions.php?id=50 30/30