Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Comment To Formal Offer PDEA
Comment To Formal Offer PDEA
COMMENT/OBJECTIONS
(To the Prosecution’s Formal Offer of Object and Documentary Evidence)
ACCUSED by the undersigned counsel and unto this Honorable Court, most
respectfully comments and/or objects to the admission of the Prosecution’s Formal Offer
of Object Evidence as follows:
“A” Complaint Sheet of Mischelle The Accused objects to the purpose of the
Mateo dated August 7, 2017 offer specifically which is to attest to the
incident pertaining to the commission of the
crime of Robbery and Carnapping by accused
Alejandro, Fabro and Tengay.
Page 1 of 6
speculation inadmissible in evidence.
“B” Complaint Sheet of Jonalyn The Accused objects to the purpose of the
Dalusung dated August 7, offer specifically which is to establish the
2017 presence of the accused at the scene of the
crime.
Page 2 of 6
SHE WAS NOT PRESENT AT THE TIME THE
ALLEGED CRIME WAS COMMITTED.
D Salaysay of Mischelle Mateo & The Accused objects to the purpose of the
Karagdagang Salaysay offer specifically which is to attest to the
incident pertaining to the commission of the
crime of Robbery and Carnapping by accused
Alejandro, Fabro and Tengay.
Page 3 of 6
Salaysay of John Lervie The Accused objects to the purpose of the
G Alamin offer specifically which is to attest to the
incident pertaining to the commission of the
crime of Robbery and Carnapping by accused
Alejandro, Fabro and Tengay.
Page 4 of 6
The Accused objects to the purpose of the
I Salaysay ng Pagtestigo of offer specifically which is to attest to the
Howard Banaag incident pertaining to the commission of the
crime of Carnapping by accused Alejandro,
Fabro and Tengay.
Page 5 of 6
NOPQ Investigation Data Form from
Laguna Prosec Office, Referral IRRELEVANT & SELF SERVING in so far as
for Inquest dated 8/7/17, Accused Alejandro, Tengay and Fabro are
Request for Digital Forensic concerned.
Examination
RTUW Certificate of Live Birth of Inadmissible since the documents were not
Jonalyn Dalusung, , identified by any of the witnesses.
Documents relative to CC
NBo. 30215-17 for Robbery Also IRRELEVANT & SELF SERVING in so
with violence before RTC far as Accused Alejandro, Tengay and Fabro
Calamba. are concerned.
RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Accused most respectfully prays to this Honorable Court that the
foregoing object and documentary exhibits mentioned above be denied admission for
the reasons above stated. The Accused further prays for such other relief as may be
just and equitable under the premises.
Page 6 of 6