Pamantasan NG Cabuyao: College of Business Administration and Accountancy
Pamantasan NG Cabuyao: College of Business Administration and Accountancy
CHAPTER 1
THE PROBLEM STATEMENT
Introduction
Pharmacies tend to be one of the most sought entities of almost everyone. It is
because of the environmental factors, such as pollution and stress, which affect a
person’s health and which makes illness a common enemy to be fought. It is well-
known that being sick requires a lot of money to be spent which is a down side because
not all of the people can afford medicine or go to the doctor. Good thing there exist
pharmacies known as “Generic Drugstores.”
Generic drugstores are very popular nowadays due to the growing demand for
affordable medicine. That is why small-scale drugstores, whether franchised or not,
have sprouted in almost every street corner. Even people who have no background or
that much knowledge in the field of pharmaceutical practice built such stores since they
can just hire the services of a licensed pharmacist. They offer a wide range of
prescription medication and over-the-counter medications at a low price. It has had a
major impact on making medication more affordable.
There is no question that pharmacies could play an even greater role in
providing a wide range of basic healthcare services in a convenient, cost-effective way.
But to reach their full potential to ease the current healthcare crisis, pharmacies will
have to overcome certain barriers. Some of these constraints, such as limits on the level
of service that pharmacies can provide, have been imposed by regulators. Others are
self-imposed and are designed to accommodate physicians and health insurers. In the
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
current reform climate, these barriers are likely to erode, resulting in new opportunities
for the pharmacy to become a critical partner in the restructuring of healthcare.
(Ahlquist, Javanmardian, Kaura, & Bilokrynytskyy, 2010)
Independent pharmacies have long been the backbone of community services
but, like post offices before them, they risk becoming obsolete as more nimble or better
resourced players shape the market and capture its value. (Anscombe & Thomas, 2012)
Profitability
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Porter’s business strategies theory (1985) The business can focus on cost
leadership, differentiation, and focus as strategies to achieve competitiveness.
The cost leadership strategy involves achieving competitiveness through
pursuing the lowest cost of production of a product or service along the value
chain (Porter, 1980). In a pharmacy business, costs can decrease along the value
chain by ordering direct from manufacturers, increasing efficiencies and by
avoiding wastages (Chandra et al., 2013). Zellmer and Walling (2012) proposed
reduction of costs along the value chain delivering low prices on pharmacy
products and better profits. The differentiation strategy involves the creation of
differentiated products, branded and promoted differently (Porter, 1985). Quality
may be used as a tool to provide the differentiation. A pharmacy store leader may
use the strategy to maximum effect and increase profitability. Kamath, Klamath,
Garg, and Prachi (2013) proposed quality pursuit enhanced profitability of any
business. Pharmacies can choose as a strategy, continuous improvement,
leadership, teamwork, and training to enhance differentiation and increase
profitability and sustainability (Brennan, Bosch, Buchan, & Green, 2013). Add
summary to fully conclude the paragraph. The focus strategy involves focusing on
a narrow, defined segment of the market (citation). A pharmacy store leader may
use strategies such as selling generic drugs, over the counter medicines, herbal
remedies and, cosmetic lines to achieve profitability (Shivakumar, Agrawal, &
Gupta, 2013). Such a strategy might involve segmenting the market based on
demographic and economic fundamentals and selling drugs and medicines desired
by the focused and selected segment of the market. I also explored Deming’s
14-step theory (1992) as a conceptual framework for identification of optimal
strategies for profitability of pharmacy stores. The Deming approach to quality
management commonly known as total quality management (TQM) emphasizes
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
1. Confirmation and disconfirmation theory of customer satisfaction
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Conceptual Framework
• The demogra-
• Survey
questionnaire
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
phic profile of
the respondents.
• Competitiveness
of small-scale
• Measurement in
drugstores
the level of
competitiveness
of small-scale
drugstores.
FEEDBACK
disclose the possible result of the studt which are the the level of competitiveness of
selected small-scale drugstores in the City of Cabuyao, Laguna. Lastly, inside the box
at the middle bottom is the feedback loop which transmits the evaluative and corrective
information about the action, event or process. The result depends on the information
collected through self-made questionnaires.
Statement of Hypothesis
Ho: There is no significant relationship between the profitability and customer
satisfaction on the level of competitiveness of selected small scale drugstores
in the City of Cabuyao, Laguna.
• Drugstore owners – this study will give them information regarding small-
scale drugstores’ level of competitiveness in terms of profitability and customer
satisfaction. This study may also give them the idea on how to increase their
business management or strategies in gaining profit.
• Pharmacists – as a practitioner of a profession in line with health services, this
study will be helpful to them by giving them information about a small-scale
pharmacy’s performance
• Accounting and Business Students- As students in line to business, this study
may help them their develop skills, widen their knowledge and give them
deeper understanding about the business’ level of competitiveness that they can
use when they start up their own business.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
• City of Cabuyao – This study will be helpful for future studies as a source of
information relating to drugstore competitiveness. If the result is positive, it
may improve the economic development of the City.
• Future Researchers – this study will be helpful for future studies as a source
of information relating to performance of small-scale businesses. This study
may also give them significant idea on how to measure drugstores competency.
Definition of Terms
Capital - equity interest of the owner in the business that is the difference between
assets and liabilities, also called equity or net worth.
and performance of other firms, sub-sectors or countries in the same market. As good
as or better than others of the same kind: able to compete successfully with others.
Entrepreneur - individual who has the initiative to start an enterprise with its
associated responsibilities, obligations, and risks.
Profitability - ability of a business entity to generate net income and the quality of
affording gain or benefit or profit.
Stock- the goods or merchandise kept on the premises of a business or warehouse and
available for sale or distribution.
Total Quality Management (TQM) - a quality control and managers systems that
demand perfection (zero defects). It is a method by which management and employees
can become involved in the continuous improvement of the production of goods and
services.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
CHAPTER 2
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES
This chapter presents a brief review of literature and studies, both local and
foreign that is related to these studies. It also includes the synthesis it denotes the facts,
concepts, ideas, and knowledge which originally came from the experts and researchers
taken form foreign and local literature and studies that guide the researchers in the
accomplishment of the study. These literatures and studies were carefully scrutinized
after which were believed to be significantly related to the present study.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
important effects (1.) it can lead to gradual increase in the firm’s customer base which
is vital in an era of low sales growth, and (2.) the profits earned from each individual
customer grow the longer the customer remains loyal to the firm. Existing customer
also tend to purchase more than new customers (Rose, 1990). For providing the
customers with greater value and satisfaction than their competitors, firms must be
operationally efficient, cost effective, and quality conscious (Johnson, 1992; Hammer
and Champy, 1993). Customer satisfaction is very important because it will be the basis
to determine whether the firm can provide a good service or not.
satisfy customers' needs, make greater profits than those which fail to understand
and satisfy them (Molina, Consuegra and Esteban, 2009: 260). Kotler and Keller,
2006:16) conceptualize customer satisfaction as an individual’s feeling of pleasure
or disappointment resulting from comparing a product’s perceived performance
(or outcome) in relation to his or her expectations. Customer satisfaction is a
pleasurable fulfillment response while dissatisfaction is an unpleasurable one
(Buttle, 2004:212). Customer satisfaction is based on a customer’s cognitive and
affective evaluation of their personal experience across all service within the
relationship (Vibha, Ravichandran and Jain, 2011: 22).
Gremler and Brown (1997, cited in Lee et al., 2003) argue that customer
satisfaction and service quality are prerequisites of loyalty. Although it plays a role in
maintaining customer loyalty, competitive pricing alone is unlikely to generate loyalty
in the long-term (Schultz & Bailey, 2000; Scott, 2001, cited Lee et al., 2003), and can
have an adverse effect on a firm‟s medium-term and long-term viability (Ernst &
Young, 1996 cited in Lee et al., 2003). Customer satisfaction has been defined in
various ways, but the conceptualization, which appears to have achieved the widest
acceptance, is that satisfaction is a post-choice evaluative judgment of a specific
transaction. Fornell (1992) suggests that satisfaction can be viewed directly as an
overall feeling. Satisfaction is related closely to, but is not the same as, the customer’s
general attitude toward the service. The key to distinguishing satisfaction from attitude
is that satisfaction assessments relate to individual transactions whereas attitudes are
more general (in Bitner, M.J. (1990). Similarly, one interpretation suggests that
satisfaction can be distinguished from perceived quality. Parasuraman, Zeithaml, and
Berry (1998) define “perceived (service) quality” as the consumer’s judgement about
a firm’s overall excellence or superiority. This definition suggests that perceived
quality is similar to an individual’s general attitude toward the firm (Zeithaml, 1988).
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
groups; and sole proprietorships, partnerships and corporations. It has rapidly grown in
terms of number but the systems requirements to make them effective, efficient and
sustainable have lagged behind. BnBs were revived in a Presidential pledge in mid-
2005 and the program has since registered impressive growth, reaching 16,000
pharmacies in 2010, serving about 8 million people. About 62 percent of BnBs serve 2
barangays while 38 percent serve 1 barangay, indicating that program target has been
exceeded by 30 percent. However, their geographic spread remains problematic.
Regions worst served with BnB also tend to be the poorest (ARMM, Soccsksargen, and
Mimaropa). Provinces worst served also tend to be the poorest (Basilan, Sulu, Lanao
del Sur, Tawi-tawi, Compostela Valley, Suquijor, Batanes, and Marinduque). Drug
supply replenishment after the initial stock has run out remains challenging. While
BnBs were conceived as drug revolving funds (DRF), this format has not evolved,
weakening the reflow of funds to buy stocks. Moreover, each BnB has been left to
locate its source of drugs, some buying from costlier private distributors or retailers.
Since the P100 program was initiated, the market for generics drugs in the Philippines
has boomed, with the rapid growth of the private-for-profit The Generics Pharmacy as
well as similar generic compliance-pack initiatives of the private pharmacy chain
Watson (using Pharex products) and Rite-Med branded generics (using Unilab
products). Thus, price comparison of the P100 treatment pack should also be made with
these newer initiatives. The P100 program currently has very few access points, with
only DOH hospitals and some LGU hospitals dispensing them. The drug list is also
very restricted. Expansion of the delivery network and expanding the list are being
contemplated, but stock availability needs to be improved. The P100 pilot project of
Oriental Mindoro indicates that the treatment pack program can be sustainable. Data
for the month of December 2008 alone show that sales at cost was Php 459,170 while
sales at selling price was Php 530,610, yielding a net income of Php 71,440 (or an
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
annualized net income of Php 857,280). While the P100 program can be sustainable, it
requires drug revolving funds (DRF) in health facilities for the program to be truly
institutionalized. Without such DRFs and an accompanying fee-retention policy at the
local level, health staff would not be incentivized to offer P100 treatment packs for
sale. The problem is that not all LGU health facilities have established DRFs, and
revenues for the P100 program are usually plowed back to the local treasury, reducing
the incentive of health staff to collect payments. Despite problems encountered in the
initial phase of the program, the scheme is very innovative and has a large public health
potential, as well as major impact in reducing out-of-pocket household spending on
health especially on drugs dealing with chronic care.
A MeTA study conducted by HAI Global in 2008 showed that BnBs had some
of the highest mark-ups (25-355 percent) even though they are supposed to have a
regulated 30 percent markup. The authors of this study contend that some of the high
mark-ups were a result of the BnB having a minimum selling price of Php 1 per
tablet/capsule – thus the high markups on medicines costing much less than this – and
one BnB increased its price of fast-moving items to recover losses due to expiry of
slow-movers. It must be noted that BnBs have no control over the range of products
initially supplied and cannot return expiring products for a refund (HAI Global, 2008a).
The EU survey (2009) of BnBs re-affirmed the HAI study findings, citing operators’
complaints that the 30 percent markup calculation do not seem to have taken into
account the actual transport costs between the supplier and the BnB. The PHOs and
CHDs interviewed as key informants also confirmed these findings. Even as some BnB
outlets outprice their private competitors, the wide variation in BnB prices means that
some of them are really pricing way above the competition. The EU survey gathered
the prices of three prescription drugs and the results are shown in Table 13. For
amoxicillin, although the median price is Php 3.00, 70 percent of the BnBs surveyed
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
sold it at a price higher than Php 3.00; indeed, 10 percent of them sold it as high as Php
7.00 or more. Similar patterns of pricing occurred for cotrimoxazole and metropolol.
To be fair, Gloor (2009) notes that the competition that BnBs/BNBs has brought
to the domestic pharmaceutical market – aside from the MRP/GMAP-mandated price
reduction – has brought down the local prices of drugs. Thus, the prices of innovator
medicines have gone down through their generic counterparts in BnB/BNB, or sold by
the private drugstores throughout the country. It is as if the BnBs/BNBs and private
pharmacies selling generics have brought down the once-dominant sellers of innovator
drugs, causing them to lower their prices dramatically. Now, the table is being turned,
with discounted innovator drugs outpricing the BnB/BNBs. It must be noted at this
point that the period 2009/2010 was marked by high instability in drug prices because
of the combined effect of PDI, the sudden emergence of generic pharmaceutical
franchising5 , and the implementation of the MRP/GMAP. The BnBs’ and BNBs’ role
in increasing the contestability of the local drug market is an important role that the
government plays, even if BnBs/BNBs now have prices that may be a bit higher than
alternative private suppliers. Some quarters fear that if BnBs/BNBs withdraw
completely from supplying the local market, private suppliers may raise their prices
again to “pre-contested” levels. This is a strategic consideration that should be taken
into account about the future of BnBs/BNBs (Picazo, 2012).
The BnBs have had important demonstration effects. Realizing that low-cost
retail of drugs can be profitable (as shown by the best BnBs), for-profit drug franchise
operations have mushroomed quickly, most notably The Generics Pharmacy, the first
generics retail pharmacy to franchise in the Philippines. It is now reputed to have 1,100
franchisees nationwide (as of June 2011) and is the fastest growing drugstore in the
country. For-profit franchise upstarts that followed in its wake include K2 Drugs,
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Pharmaquick 24, Emmaflor, and Johnston Drugs. The Watsons Drugstore chain has
also branched out rapidly, with 247 pharmacies nationwide. The BnB idea itself
branched out to larger Botika ng Bayan (BNB) which operates on the same franchise
format as its private sector 30 counterparts. Despite the still-precarious situation of
BnBs, the Drugstore Association of the Philippines now views them as undue
competition (Picazo, 2012).
The researchers related and differentiated the related literature and studies in
terms of the profitability of small-scale drugstores and customer’s satisfaction. Studies
showed that competition of small-scale drugstores has a negative and positive effect to
their customers.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
CHAPTER 3
Research Design
The researchers utilized a descriptive type of research in evaluating the level of
competitiveness of selected small-scale drugstore in the City of Cabuyao, Laguna in
relation to profitability, financial performance and customer satisfaction from the result
of the test that the proponents conducted. The significant factors affecting the overall
level of competitiveness are defined.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Research Instruments
The data gathering tool in this research in this research is a self structured
survey questionnaire; through this questionnaire the research determined the
competitiveness of small-scale drugstore in relation to profitability and customer
satisfaction.
In preparing the questionnaire, the proponents used books, unpublished thesis,
and other reading materials related to the presented study. The survey type
questionnaire used in conducting this study were formulated with the instruction that
can be easily understood by the respondents. This questionnaire was constructed for
the purpose of knowing the level of competitiveness of selected small-scale drugstore
in the City of Cabuyao, Laguna.
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Validation of Instruments
Prior to the survey, the self-made questionnaires were distributed to the owners
of selected small-scale drugstore as well as the customer to test if the questions are
comprehensible and sensible to be used. Researchers carefully check the research
instrument before it was presented to the respondents. The researcher sought opinion
from their adviser. They conducted survey to gather comments and suggestions that
would be useful in coming up with more effective survey questionnaire.
The questionnaire was validated by the researcher adviser, panelist and
statistician.
4 Agree Competitive
3 Undecided Moderate Competitive
2 Disagree Less Competitive
1 Strongly Disagree Not Competitive
4 Seldom
3 Often
2 Sometimes
1 Always
𝒇
𝑷= × 𝟏𝟎𝟎
𝑵
𝑓 × 𝑖
×= ∑
𝑁
10 n= 1
𝑓: Frequency
N: The number of sampling
∑: The summation notation
3. Pearsons or Product Moment Correlation Coefficient – is used to determine the
significant relationship between the level of competitiveness of selected small-scale
drugstore in terms of profitabilty, financial performance and customer satisfaction.
𝑛 ∑ 𝑥𝑦 − (∑ 𝑥)(∑ 𝑦)
𝑟=
√𝑛(∑ 𝑥 2 ) − (∑ 𝑥)2 − √𝑛(∑ 𝑦 2 )(∑ 𝑦)2
Where: r: Pearsons Correlation Coefficient
x: values in first set of data
y: Values in second set of data
N: Total number of values
∑: The summation notation
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
References
Ahlquist G., Javanmardian M., Kaura A., & Bilokrynytskyy I. (2010). The Pharmacy
Solution An Expanding Role for Pharmacies in Healthcare Delivery [PDF flie].
United States of America: Booz & Company. Retrieved from
https://www.strategyand.pwc.com/media/file/The_Pharmacy_Solution.pdf
Ball, Douglas and KlaraTisocki (2009). Public Procurement Prices of Medicines in the
Philippines. Health Action International. www.haiweb.org
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Brennan, S. E., Bosch, M., Buchan, H., & Green, S. E. (2013). Measuring team
factors thought to influence the success of quality improvement in primary
care: A systematic review of instruments. Implementation Science, 8, 20.
doi:10.1186/1748-5908-8-20
Chandra, H., Rinkoo, A. V., Verma, J. K., Verma, S., Kapoor, R., & Sharma,
R. K. (2013). Supply chain management with cost-containment & financial
sustainability in a tertiary care hospital. Journal of Health and Human
Services Administration, 36(1), 3-23. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com/docview/1369309658?Accountid=14872
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Kamath, B. G., Klamath, V., Garg, A., & Prachi, P. (2013). TQM implementation,
performance, and firm profitability: a causal approach. International Journal
of Accounting and Business Management, 1. Retrieved from
http://www.ftms.edu.my/ascent2014/BM/1.pdf
Milagrosa, A. (2014). Micro and Small Enterprise Upgrading in the Philippines [PDF
flie]. Philippines: Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik gGmbH.
Retrieved from
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
Picazo R. (2012). Review of the Cheaper Medicines Program of the Philippines [PDF
flie]. Philippines: Philippine Institute for Development Studies. Retrieved from
https://dirp4.pids.gov.ph/ris/dps/pidsdps1213.pdf
Whelan, B. (2013). A Framework for Sustianable, Competitive Advantage for the Irish
Pharmaceutical Industry
A Thesis
Presented to the Faculty of College of
Business Administration and Accountancy
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
City of Cabuyao, Laguna
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
Bachelor of Science In Accountancy
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TITLE PAGE ……………………………………………………….
CERTIFICATION AND APPROVAL
SHEET………….……………….
CERTIFICATION OF ORIGINALITY
………………………………....
CERTIFICATEOF RECOMMENDATION
……………………………..
EDITOR’S CERTIFICATE
……………………………………………….
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
………………………………………………. .
DEDICATION
……………………………………………………………..
ABSTRACT
…………………………………………………………………
TABLE OF CONTENTS
…………………………………………………..
LIST OF TABLES
………………………………………………………….
LIST OF FIGURES
………..……………………………………………...
Pamantasan ng Cabuyao
College of Business Administration And Accountancy
BIBLIOGRAPHY