Quick Screen For Voice
Quick Screen For Voice
Clinical Forum
308 LL , S,PEECH
ANGUAGE
ANGUAGE SPEECH , AND
, AND HEARING
HEARING SERVICES
SERVICES IN S CHOOLS
IN S CHOOLS • Vol. 35 •• 308–319
Vol. 35 • October
• 308–319 • American
2004 © October Speech-Language-Hearing
2004 Association
0161–1461/04/3504–0308
Downloaded From: http://lshss.pubs.asha.org/ by a Northern Illinois University User on 08/20/2016
Terms of Use: http://pubs.asha.org/ss/rights_and_permissions.aspx
pathologies were much more common in males than in Additionally, a checklist of functional indicators of voice
females, with the youngest patients (less than 6 years old) disorders in children and adolescents that could be given to
identified as having the most pathologies. The distribution parents, teachers, or other caregivers may increase their
of pathologies within the races sampled (Caucasian, African attention to potential causes of voice problems and provide
American, and Asian) was similar to that found throughout the SLP with information pertinent to identification. Finally,
the total sample. a brochure with basic information about voice disorders and
Although it has been argued by some that treating voice the need for medical examination may help the SLP
disorders in children is unnecessary or even potentially educate parents. These needs are addressed in the present
harmful (Batza, 1970; Sander, 1989), others have argued document.
for the opposite opinion (Kahane & Mayo, 1989; Miller &
Madison, 1984). Indeed, Andrews (1991) suggested that
unlike some other developmental disorders, maturation
alone does not significantly affect vocal symptoms. QUICK SCREEN FOR VOICE
Habitual patterns of poor voice use do not, as some have
suggested, disappear at puberty. In other words, children do A screening tool entitled Quick Screen for Voice (see
not outgrow voice disorders. Appendix A) was developed by the second author (JS). It
The identification and management of pediatric voice provides more thorough delineation of tasks and measures
disorders is important for the child’s educational and than the more open-ended requests for observation of voice
psychosocial development, as well as physical and emo- quality that are currently available on speech and language
tional health. The underlying cause of any dysphonia must screening tests. The tool may be used for speakers of all
be determined because voice disorders that share the same ages, from preschool through adult.
quality deviations may have vastly different behavioral, Respiration, phonation, resonance, and vocal flexibility
medical, or psychosocial etiologies (see review in Stemple are the hallmarks of healthy and acceptable voice production,
et al., 2000). and all are included in this test. These subsystems of voice
The majority of children with voice problems are production are assessed separately. Lists of perceptual
identified by individuals other than the school SLP (Davis characteristics that are commonly associated with disorders
& Harris, 1992). Typically, the teacher, nurse, or a family of that subsystem are contained in each section. Definitions
member notices that a child has developed an abnormal of each perceptual characteristic are provided in Appendix B.
voice quality and makes the initial contact with the SLP. The protocol is designed to be administered in 5 to 10
These referral sources lack training in making perceptual min. Administration time is reduced when the child’s voice
quality judgments, so they may miss more subtle problems is judged to be normal. When abnormal signs are found in
that need professional attention. Depending on the task, any subsection, the test form provides appropriate language
teachers may or may not be accurate in identifying children for vocal behaviors that the SLP may not observe or
with voice deviations (see review in Davis & Harris, 1992), identify without it. These identifiers can then be used when
and many parents may assume that the child will outgrow reporting findings and generating individualized educational
the disorder. Perceptual voice quality evaluation can be plan (IEP) goals, if a management program is necessary.
difficult even for the SLP (Kreiman, Gerratt, Kempster,
Erman, & Berke, 1993; Kreiman, Gerratt, Precoda, & Directions and Scoring
Berke, 1992), so depending on untrained persons to identify
these children is less than ideal. The Quick Screen for Voice should be administered in a
One common method of identifying childhood communi- quiet area that is free of distractions. The tester should be
cation disorders is through mass screening. Unfortunately, seated close to the individual.
voice has received scant attention in most speech and Perceptual characteristics of the voice are judged by
language screening tools. For example, the Fluharty-2 listening to the individual speak. Therefore, the examiner
Preschool Speech and Language Screening Test (Fluharty, should engage the individual in topics, such as family or
2001) has one line for clinician response to voice quality friends, hobbies or other interests, favorite holidays or
(“sounded normal; recheck may be necessary”). Similarly, vacations, favorite classes in school, and so on. To assist
one line for description of the voice is allotted on the elicitation of spontaneous speech, the individual may be
Speech-Ease Screening Inventory (Pigott et al., 1985). asked to tell a story about pictures that are sufficiently
These conventional one-line summaries fail to address the detailed to allow a 2–3 min description or elicited sample.
voice comprehensively; that is, they do not assess the three Recited passages, counting, or other natural samples of
subsystems of respiration, phonation, and resonance. Voice continuous speech may also be used.
problems are typically reduced to a generic description of The examiner responds to a checklist of observations that
quality deviation and may easily be overlooked because of are made during the spontaneous speech and other voicing
such minimal opportunity for evaluation. tasks. The speaker fails the screening test if one or more
Identification of children with voice disorders could be disorders in production are found in any section. In such
facilitated with several documents. A screening tool cases, the individual would be scheduled to be screened
covering multiple aspects of voice, respiration, and reso- again, have a more comprehensive voice evaluation, or be
nance could replace the more general voice evaluation referred to a physician with a request that the child be
statements that are provided on current screening tools. examined by an otolaryngologist or other specialist.
310 LANGUAGE, SPEECH, AND HEARING SERVICES IN SCHOOLS • Vol. 35 • 308–319 • October 2004
312 LANGUAGE, SPEECH, AND HEARING SERVICES IN SCHOOLS • Vol. 35 • 308–319 • October 2004
Name: _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Directions: The Quick Screen for Voice should be conducted in a quiet area. Elicit verbal activities, such as spontaneous conversation,
picture description, imitated sentences, recited passages, counting, and other natural samples of voice and speech, or perform the tasks
requested. The screening test is failed if one or more disorders in production are found in any area, indicating that a more thorough
evaluation is needed.
Mark all observations that apply, as the individual produces connected speech:
Respiration
_____ Inhalatory stridor or expiratory wheeze _____ Limited breath support for speech
_____ Infrequent breaths; talking too long on one breath _____ Reduced loudness or vocal weakness
Phonation
Resonance
_____ Hyponasality (observed during humming, nasal _____ Nasal turbulence or audible nasal emission (observed
consonant contexts: Mommy makes me muffins; during pressure consonant contexts: Counting from
Man on the moon; Many men make money, etc.). 60 to 69; Popeye plays baseball; Give Kate the cake;
_____ Consistent mouth breathing Buy Bobby a puppy, Take a ticket to Daddy, etc.).
_____ Hypernasality (observed during vowel and oral consonants) _____ Juvenile resonance characteristics
Model the series of nonverbal tasks that are described on the test form. Multiple trials are allowed. Visual cues such as hand gestures,
moving a toy car across the table (for maximum phonation time) or up and down a hill (for pitch range), etc. may be used to supplement the
auditory model.
1. Habitual pitch and loudness task: “Count from 1 to 10. Repeat, but stop at ‘three’ and hold out the /i:/.”
314 LANGUAGE, SPEECH, AND HEARING SERVICES IN SCHOOLS • Vol. 35 • 308–319 • October 2004
Note. MPT values are related to age and height; multiple attempts also influence results.
*Data summarized from Kent, Kent, & Rosenbek (1987)
3. Pitch range task: “Make your voice go from low to high like this (demonstrate upward pitch glide on the word ‘whoop’). Now go
down from your highest to low (demonstrate rapid downward pitch glide like a bomb falling).” Or, model and elicit a fire siren
sound.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
From Quick Screen for Voice by L. Lee, J. C. Stemple, & L. Glaze, in press, Gainesville, FL: Communicare Publishing.
Copyright 2003 by Communicare. Reprinted with permission.
Respiration Resonance
Inhalatory stridor or expiratory wheeze: Sound heard on inhalation Hyponasality: Reduction in nasal resonance during the production
or exhalation, indicating an obstruction at some point in the airway of nasal consonants /m, n, N/, reflecting blockage in the nasophar-
that creates airflow turbulence ynx or the entrance to the nasal cavity
Limited breath support for speech: Failure to create a sufficient Consistent mouth breathing: Open-mouth posture; the need to
amount of air to support connected utterances; frequent need to breathe through the mouth because of possible nasal airway
replenish the breath supply; typically, failure to inspire beyond the obstruction
tidal breathing range
Nasal turbulence or audible nasal emission: Also called nasal
Infrequent breaths; talking too long on one breath: Failure to rustle, nasal turbulence is frication heard as air pressure is forced
replenish breath often, or failing to take sufficient breaths so that through a partially opened velopharyngeal valve; audible nasal
utterances extend beyond end-tidal breathing into the expiratory emission, also called nasal air escape, is inappropriate airflow
reserve through the nose during speech, typically occurring on high
pressure consonants because of velopharyngeal dysfunction; either
Reduced loudness or vocal weakness: Soft voice, or one that characteristic may be a consonant-specific learned behavior
sounds fatigued, possibly due to diminished respiratory support
Hypernasality: Sound entering the nasal cavity during production
of vowels or liquid consonants due to velopharyngeal dysfunction,
Phonation resulting in excessive acoustic nasal resonance
Rough or hoarse quality: Quality deviation of the voice reflecting Juvenile resonance characteristics: Child-like quality to the voice;
aperiodic vibration of the vocal folds during phonation often accompanied by high pitch and abnormal tongue posture,
giving the voice an immature sound, usually seen in teenage girls
Breathy quality: Quality deviation of the voice reflecting a larger and women
than normal glottal opening, allowing excessive airflow through the
vocal folds during phonation
Nonverbal Vocal Range and Flexibility
Vocal strain and effort: Tension, strain, and/or effort needed to
speak; this may include difficulty initiating or maintaining Habitual pitch and loudness task: Relative to the speaker’s age and
phonation, and may also include supporting evidence of visible sex, the appropriateness of pitch or loudness during a sustained
neck or jaw tension vowel is noted
Aphonia: Absence of voicing, which may be intermittent or Maximum phonation time task: The length of maximum phonation
constant; may occur as voice “cutting out” or whisper, and can be time is noted; norms are provided by age category to help the
accompanied by apparent strain, tension, or effort examiner decide whether or not MPT is within normal limits
Persistent glottal fry: Rough, low-pitched, tense voice quality that Pitch range task: Ability to vary the pitch of the voice, and the
often occurs at the end of sentences, reflecting tightly approxi- presence of voice breaks during the gliding activity, are noted; the
mated vocal folds with flaccid edges vibrating at a low fundamen- pitch range increases with age from approximately one-half octave
tal frequency for preschool children to over two octaves for adults
From Quick Screen for Voice by L. Lee, J. C. Stemple, & L. Glaze, in press, Gainesville, FL: Communicare Publishing.
Copyright 2003 by Communicare. Reprinted with permission.
316 LANGUAGE, SPEECH, AND HEARING SERVICES IN SCHOOLS • Vol. 35 • 308–319 • October 2004
From Functional Indicators of Voice Disorders in Children and Adolescents by L. Lee, J. C. Stemple, & L. Glaze, in press, Gainesville FL,
Communicare Publishing. Copyright 2003 by Communicare. Reprinted with permission.
Your child has been identified as having a voice disorder, meaning How Might a Voice Disorder
that his/her voice sounds different from that of other children of
the same age and sex. The purpose of this pamphlet is to provide Affect a Child’s Education?
you with information about the cause, diagnosis, and management
of voice disorders. The effects of a voice disorder may decrease the child’s ability to
interact effectively in the classroom setting. Speech may be
difficult to hear or understand, and the child may be less likely to
How Is Voice Produced? participate in daily educational activities, such as volunteering
answers or reading aloud. A childhood voice disorder may also
Figure 1 contains the primary structures in the vocal tract. The decrease the potential for developing a normal adult voice.
larynx is a system of cartilages, muscles, and ligaments in the
neck (pharynx). It sits on top of trachea, the passageway to the
lungs. The passageway to the stomach is behind the larynx and What Are Common Causes
trachea. The larynx is covered when we swallow, so food does not of a Voice Disorder?
enter the trachea.
Laryngeal pathologies are changes in the larynx and vocal folds
The larynx contains thin membranes, called vocal folds. The vocal that are associated with voice disorders. Many factors contribute to
folds sit in an open position during breathing. When a person the development of laryngeal pathologies, including voice misuse,
wants to speak, muscles close the folds, and air from the lungs medical problems, and personality-related issues. Each of these
causes them to vibrate. The sound the vocal folds make then is described below.
resonates through the mouth (or nose, for some sounds) and speech
is created. The combination of breathing, vibrating the vocal folds, Voice Misuse
and shaping or resonating the vibration creates the distinct sound The majority of laryngeal pathologies are due to the way a child
you recognize as your child’s voice. A problem with any part of misuses the voice. Children often engage in loud talking, scream-
the voicing process may lead to a voice disorder. ing, or shouting, such as at sports events. They may enjoy making
vocal noises during play, imitating motorcycles, action figures or
monsters. Habits such as these may harm young voices. Excessive
coughing or throat clearing may also damage the vocal folds.
Figure 1. The vocal tract. Sometimes children learn to speak in an incorrect manner, such as
using a very low pitch level. Or, the child may be so eager to
communicate that he/she does not pause for enough breaths to
support the voice.
The examples presented are habits that may cause irritation to the
vocal folds. Constant irritation may lead to vocal fold changes,
such as swelling (edema), redness, or callous-like growths called
vocal nodules.
Medical Causes
Some children develop voice disorders because of a medical
problem. An infant may be born with structural defects of the
larynx. Neurologic problems, such as vocal fold paralysis, can occur.
Chronic upper respiratory or other viral infections, allergies, and
gastrointestinal disorders are other examples of medical problems
that may lead to laryngeal pathologies. The larynx may be damaged
during an accident or surgery. Finally, some medications have side
effects that may contribute to changes in vocal fold vibration.
318 LANGUAGE, SPEECH, AND HEARING SERVICES IN SCHOOLS • Vol. 35 • 308–319 • October 2004
From Your Child’s Voice by L. Lee, J. C. Stemple, & L. Glaze, in press, Gainesville FL: Communicare Publishing.
Copyright 2003 by Communicare. Reprinted with permission.