Coincidence Effect
Coincidence Effect
YOUR PRESENTERS:
Tony Gerard: Tony is a prolific author (Card A-Tack, Magic Behind Bars and more) as
well as a creator of magic effects. He owns the Timid Rabbit Magic and Costume Shop in
Kalamazoo MI. Tony is also responsible for the great stage lighting we enjoy at this con-
vention.
Gene Gordon: Gene is a veteran restaurant performer with over 25 years experience.
He hails from Englewood CO and has appeared 12 times on the Pat Page Workshop!
Allan Kronzek: Allan is the author of three magic-centric books for the public, and
one booklet for magicians— Destiny, Chance and Free Will. Now available as a pdf.
www.allankronzek.com Email Allan for details.
Dave Neighbors: Dave Neighbors lives in Aurora CO. Dave is a prolific creator, most-
ly of coin magic. But Dave also can do some fine work with the pasteboards. Known as the
“Coinjurer”, Dave’s work can be found on his video from A-1 as well as in his many sets of
lecture notes. There’s a new DVD set in the works and possibly a book of Dave’s coin work.
Stay tuned...
Mike Powers: Mike is the author of three books and an instructional video on magic.
His latest effort, Power Plays (2006) was voted book of the year on the Magic Cafe. Mike
writes the Card Corner column in the Linking Ring magazine and is working on book four
for release in 2014.
Maria Schwieter: Maria (who just received news that her vacation time for FFFF
had been rescinded) is a graduate of the Chavez School of Magic under Neil Foster. She is
married to Mike Powers. They reside in La Porte IN.
David Solomon: David collaborated with Simon Aronson on the book Sessions. His
latest books are Solomon’s Mind and The Wisdom of Solomon. David has also created and
produced some fine commercial items like Thoughts Across, Hocus Poker, Printing on De-
mand and others. You can check out his products at: www.davidsolomon.net.
Geoff Williams: Geoff performed close-up in the Tampa Bay Ray’s locker room on
Sunday and openly predicted that they would “crush” their opponents in the game that
day (He figured he’d be long gone before the game ended). The Rays ended up winning 8-
1 and, in a post-game TV interview, the manager Joe Maddon credited Geoff partially for
the win! Ask Geoff for some ideas for the upcoming Powerball Lotto.
2
Geoff Williams: 4-WAY COINCIDENCE
by John Murray
SOURCE: Jerry Mentzer's book Card Cavalcade 3 with variation by Bob Braier.
Published in "The Lecture Your Father Never Gave You" notes by Geoff Williams and
found on the DVD "Miracles For Mortals, Vol. 1" Used with permission(s)
R = Right
L = Left
RH = Right Hand
LH = Left Hand
FD = Face Down
FU = Face Up
EFFECT: The deck is shuffled and a prediction is made. The other three cards matching
the prediction are randomly (and surprisingly) located by several stunned spectators.
SET-UP: None. The deck should be a complete deck (but it isn’t absolutely necessary).
PROCEDURE: Have Spectator #1 shuffle the cards. Spread the deck FU to point out the
fairness of the mix (and note a matching, side-by-side pair). Starting with the rightmost
card of the pair, count to the right using its value (or spell the name, if it's a court card)
and cut the deck as you pick up the spread and square it against the table. If for some rea-
son there isn't a side-by-side pair, encourage others to shuffle the cards.
Example: Let's assume that there are two eights (8H & 8S) side by side in the spread. As
you gather the cards, cut the deck seven cards to the R of them (so they'll lie 8th & 9th
from the bottom of the FD deck). Naturally, if the noted pair was two 4s, you'd cut the
deck exactly three cards to the R of them. If the pair was of queens, cut four cards to the R
(in which case, near the end of the trick, you'd spell "queen" instead of counting).
Back to our example (we're using the eights, remember). Fan the cards facing you. Dis-
place one of the other eights to the top (the L end) of the deck in this manner: Fan the
cards facing you, and pull the 8D out of the fan using your LH. Furrow your brow, look at
Spectator #2 and ask "Where were you born?" No matter how they respond, act as if their
answer has suddenly discouraged you from this first choice of prediction and put the 8D
on the L end of the fan.
3
Picture this design/grid superimposed on the table in front of you:
A B C
D E
Locate the last eight (8C) and place it FD onto the table at position C as a prediction. Close
the fan and hold it FU in dealing (mechanics) grip.
Begin dealing cards into a single, FU pile onto the table at position D and, as you deal past
the 8H/8S pair, instruct Spectator #3 to say "stop" whenever they'd like. When they do,
turn the pile on the table FD and place the balance of the cards in your LH FD at position E.
Magician’s force the E pile on Spectator #4 in this manner: "Which pile shall we work
with?" (I know, the question ends with a preposition. Deal with it.) If they choose the E pile,
turn over its top card (it'll be the 8D). If they choose the D pile, say "Alright, let's see how
we're going to work with that pile" and turn over the top card of the E pile. "An 8 of dia-
monds. That means we'll count down eight cards." Deal 8 cards off the top of the D pile into
a FD pile at the A position. Turn over the 8th card counted (it'll be the 8S) and place it FU
onto the pile at A. Pause to let this coincidence become apparent.
Take top card from D and use it to turn over your prediction at C in such a way that it lands
FU at position B. Let this second coincidence sink in briefly.
"Of course, every deck has FOUR eights." Raise the card in your hand (8H) upward to frame
your face with the final revelation. After a brief pause, place the 8H FU onto the D pile for a
satisfying, symmetrical finish.
NOTES: Award-winning Wisconsin conjuror Bob Braier decided to capitalize on the fact
that a side-by-side pair of cards occurs naturally after almost every standard shuffle. He
also added (among other things) the use of multiple spectators throughout the effect and
the framing of the face when revealing the final card. That Bob is one smart cookie.
4
Dave Neighbors: Marlo’s Double Brainwave Update
By Allan Ackerman and Ed Marlo
EFFECT: Two decks are used—one red and the other blue. The red deck is placed face
down on the table and the blue deck is held face up in the left hand with the Ace of Spades
at the face. The spectator is asked to name any card other than the Ace of Spades. The card
is show to have a red back. The deck in hand is turned over and shown to have blue backs.
The red deck on the table is picked up, spread, and shown to contain one blue card. The
odd card is removed and shown to be the thought-of card.
SLEIGHTS USED: The Vernon two card push-off.
METHOD: Get the blue-backed Ace of Spades on the face of the blue deck. Remove the red-
backed Ace of Spades and place it on the face of the blue-backed deck right next to its du-
plicate. Have the red deck face down on the table in front of you and hold the blue deck face
up in your left hand in a dealing grip. At this point, you are ready to perform. Ask the spec-
tator to name any card in the deck other than the Ace of Spades “since that would be too
easy.” When the spectator names his card, run through the deck and outjog it. Square up
the cards and, as you do, get a little finger break under the top Ace of Spades. Remove the
thought-of card and set it on the face. At this point do the Vernon two-card push-off:
The left second finger moves into the break and pushes
upward on the two cards, causing them to bend concave.
The left thumb is lying in the upper center of the card.
The left thumb and second finger push to the right, caus-
ing the two cards to move as one to the right (figure 1).
The Ace of Spades will remain visible as the face card.
With your right hand, pick up the thought-of card
(double) and turn it face down. Deposit the double card
sidejogged to the right of the face-up Ace of Spades. Its
red back will be dis-
played (figure 2). Next, your right hand picks up the
thought-of card (double) between the thumb and first
finger at the upper right corner. Deal the double card
down with a snap onto the red deck. Turn the deck in
the left hand over, displaying that it has blue backs, and
set it face down on the table. Now execute the following
subtlety. The right hand picks up the red deck and acci-
dentally drops the lower half on the table. The right
hand places the remaining portion of the pack in the left
5
hand, reaches for the tabled cards, and places them on top. You have secretly, but openly,
cut the cards. Spread the deck and show that one blue card is among the red and show it to
be the thought-of card.
CONCLUSIONS: Allan showed this routine to Marlo in the late 1960s and he said it was a
considerable improvement on the routine he had in Ibidem under the same title.
I posted this solution on the Magic Pebble web site and my good friend Tomas Blomberg
responded that Roy Walton had a work out that used a demonstration phase to get into the
set up. See: “Ten Paces To The Right” (The Complete Walton Volume Two, pp. 9-10); or
Kabbala Vol. 1.
Tomas at the same time suggested a way to do the effect without the Head Over Heels
move which he also credited to Walton. So far we have not been able to find that variation,
but I will list the method below.
EFFECT: Magician has a spectator shuffle a deck. The magician looks through the deck to
take two prediction cards out of the deck. The spectator is then shown how to select a card
by cutting and facing the deck. Two cards are selected by two different spectators. The ma-
gician shows that he has predicted the exact mate of the selections.
1. Make sure that you take out the Jokers from the deck and give the deck to the spectator
to shuffle. Take the deck back from the spectator saying that you will make two predictions.
8
2. With the deck face up fan the deck from hand to hand to make two predictions. First cut
the double backed card to the top of the deck. Fan through about a third of the deck, from
the top, looking for a good contrasting pair of cards to predict. Once you have decided on
the pair, down-jog the first card of the pair. For example, if I decide that the cards will be
the Seven of Diamonds and the Three of Clubs, down jog the 7D and look for the 3S as my
first prediction.
3. Take out the 3S placing it face down onto the table as your first prediction.
Now take out the 7H as the second prediction placing it front of the second spectator.
Square the deck into your left hand with the down-jogged card marking off the selections.
4. Turn the deck face down getting a right thumb break above the down-jogged card. Trans-
fer this break to your left little finger holding the deck in dealer’s grip. You are now going to
demonstrate the cutting procedure that you will ask each of the spectators to do to select a
card. With the right hand cut all of the cards above the break, turn them face up and drop
them onto the deck creating a faced deck.
5. Spread the cards from hand to hand stopping where the cards are back to back. This is
the typical Christ Cut position. Point out that the face-down card in the center will be the
selected card. This card in the center is the double-backed card so that you cannot show it.
You must run this double-backer under the face-up spread to perform Simon Aronson’s
Head of Heels move (Try the Impossible), pg. 93. In this case you will insert the double-
backed card under the first two face-down cards in the spread. You must get a left little fin-
ger break under these three cards as you square the deck and hold a space between the
faced packets with your right thumb. Take the top packet and turn it over face down on top
of the deck.
6. Position check: The double backed card is on top of the deck with the two selections face
up under it. The first card will be the Three of Clubs that will be forced. Place the deck on
the table in front of the first spectator and tell him to cut a packet off of the deck and to turn
it face up and place it back on top of the deck as you have instructed them in your demon-
stration. (A lesson learned, I gave the deck to my daughter after the same instructions and
she promptly spread the top cards of the deck now she is a magician’s daughter but maybe
someone else would do the same unfortunate thing) Therefore to prevent showing the true
nature of the deck, place the deck on the table or hold it in your hands and ask the spectator
to cut and turn the packet over.
7. Take the deck from the spectator and spread from hand to hand to take out the face-
down card that has been marked off in the deck. This will be the first spectator’s selection.
Take this card out of the deck and place it face down below your first prediction. The right
hand takes the card off the deck but still has its packet face up in the right hand. The left
hand fans over the next two face-down cards and gets a left little finger break under them
as the right hand squares the face-up packet against the face-down portion. As you square
the deck in the faced position, add the two cards above the break to the face-up cards. Turn
the squared face-up packet face down placing it back on top of the deck. This is Nick Trost’s
9
clever work out from The Card Magic of Nick Trost, OA Clean-Cut Coincidence. Trost lists
the force as The 203rd Force, in Annemann’s Sh-h-h! It’s a Secret (1934) and his addition
from “Double Back Card Force” (Hugard’s Magic Monthly [July, 1944]).
8. The second spectator is asked to carry out the same instructions by cutting off a quarter
or the deck and facing it. Spread the deck and take out the face-down card where the pack-
ets are faced and place it below the second prediction. Turn the face-up packet face down to
once again have a full face-down deck. The double-backed card will be in the deck. You will
now be able to show that each of the selected cards match your predicted card.
9. Basically the effect that I accomplish is the same effect as the Trost effect listed above. I
have added the ability of having a shuffled deck. Trost starts out with the two force cards
already face up under the double-backed card at the top of the deck. Using my demonstra-
tion phase allows me to set up the same position as Trost which I accomplish by using of
Simon Aronson’s “Head Over Heels Move”.
10. Tomas Blomberg suggests the following variation. After the deck is shuffled, with the
faces toward you, move the double-backed card to the third from the top. The two cards
above the double-backer will be the selections. The first prediction will be the top card of
the deck.
11. Perform a demonstration of the Christ cut by turning ¼ of the deck face up. Be careful
when you spread down to where the cards are back to back because the next card will be
face up. Take all of the face-up cards and place them on the bottom of the deck. You are now
in position to ask the first spectator to cut the deck and place the cut off portion on the top
of the deck face up. This will force the top card. Proceed as described in Step 7 and 8 above.
For those of you who do not want to do the Head Over Heels move, this is a very good varia-
tion.
12. I am not sure if the spectator will notice the change of procedure when you first duck
the face-up packet under the deck as opposed to doing the actual cut procedure when you
perform the effect. Remember you place the cut off portion back on the top of the deck. In
any case this is a very efficient way to handle the setup and performance. I thank Tomas for
pointing this out to me and feel that this procedure is his work-out and not Walton’s until
further research tells us whether it is Walton’s procedure. By the way Tomas likes my use of
the Head Over Heels move with the double backed card.
13. I have performed this combination Matcho from a shuffled deck and have received very
good laymen reaction. You can’t ask for much more than that.
10
Maria Schwieter: Time After Time (by Tomas Blomberg)
This very cool coincidence effect is taught on the DVD “21” which features some great magic
from Sweden. The effect is based on Jack Parker’s “The Third Time’s The Charm” (Genii June
2007).
EFFECT: Three spectators locate their own selections in a manner that seems utterly impos-
sible due to the intrinsic randomness of the procedure.
SET-UP: None. The deck can be borrowed deck and shuffled.
Basic principle: Same as that used in the well known Jim Steinmeyer Nine Card Problem.
SELECTION PROCEDURE: The ultimate goal is to end with three approximately equal pack-
ets, one in front of each spectator, with the spectator’s card at the bottom of the face down
packet. You’ll need three spectators. Let’s call A, B and C from left to right.
Tomas uses this very direct and deceptive procedure (See Final Thoughts for an alternate
procedure):
Selection 1: The spectator C (the one on your right) touches a card around fifteen cards
from the bottom of the deck. The Magi catches left 4th finger break UNDER this card.
Selection 2: Spectator B (he middle spectator) touches a card near middle of deck. The Magi
catches break OVER this card with 3rd finger.
Selection 3: The spectator A (on your left) touches a card about 17 cards from top. The Magi
catches a break UNDER this card.
You are holding three breaks. Keep the deck messy and this won’t be obvious.
Control of Selections: Cut at the first break putting selection 3 at bottom of this group. Now
cut at 2nd break and place on tabled portion.
Now riffle down staying ABOVE the last break until you have about 17 cards. Cut these onto
the tabled group. Finally cut at the break but sidejog this group so you can get break. Finally
place the last portion on top.
STATUS CHECK: Selection 3 is on the bottom. Selection 2 is on top of the squared portion.
Selection 1 at the bottom of the sidejogged portion.
Pick up deck obtaining a left 4th finger break at the step point i.e. between selections 2 and 3.
Hand a packet to spectator A (on your left) by dropping the cards below the break onto her
hand (You retain the cards above the break). Ask this spectator to cut some of her cards
back onto your pile, keeping about 17 cards (about a third of the deck). She is then to table
her cards.
STATUS CHECK: Spectator A has her selection on the bottom of her pile. You have two-
11
thirds of the deck with selection 2 on top and selection 1 on the bottom.
Hand your cards to spectator C (right) to hold. Tell spectator B to cut about half the cards
and table them. Spectator C tables the remaining cards.
STATUS CHECK: Each spectator has a packet tabled in front of her that contains her selec-
tion. Selections A and C are on the bottom of the packet while selection B (middle) is on top.
DEMONSTRATION: Pick up spectator B’s pile to demonstrate the procedure. Each spectator
is to think of a number between 10 and 20. They each will deal that many cards to the table
and then drop the remainder on top. If they run out of cards before reaching the number,
they simply stop dealing and wait. Deal a few cards to the table as a demonstration and then
place the rest on top. Now all the selections are at the bottom of their respective piles.
N.B. There should be less than 23 cards in each pile. Have the spectators take cards from
one pile to another to make them approximately equal. You are now ready for the dealing
and swapping procedure.
DEAL AND SWAP: Each spectator is likely thinking of a different number. Be sure that the
audience is aware of this fact. You will now sell the idea that each spectator will deal to her
number in each of the three piles. This is a lie, but the lie will fly! This procedure will involve
some dead time due to the dealing. It’s up to you to keep it moving by turning to the audi-
ence during the dealing and making sure that everyone understands how free and fair eve-
rything is.
DEAL 1: Have each spectator hold her pile and deal singly to the table the number of cards
that they are thinking of (between 10 and 20). Tell the audience that each spectator is mere-
ly thinking of a number. No one can know when they will stop dealing. Once the dealing has
ended, you’ll rearrange the piles using a specific pattern that will return the piles to their
original locations for the 3rd dealing sequence. You will tell everyone that each dealer will
deal their secret number in each of the three piles. This is the big lie but no one will be able
to see that it’s not true.
STEP 1: The spectators have thought of a number between 10 and 20. They each deal that
many cards to the table and drop the remainder on top.
STEP 2 – Pile Switching 1: From the magician’s point of view – switch the two leftmost
packets. Then switch the two rightmost packets. Have each spectator deal her number
again.
Step 3 – Pile switching 2: Switch the two outer packets. Then switch the two rightmost
packets. This sends each spectator’s packet back to her. Finally, each spectator deals her
number again.
Amazingly, each selection will be on top of the pile at the end.
12
FINAL THOUGHTS: An alternate procedure that will end with three piles each containing
a selection at the bottom is this: Control all three selections to the bottom. Now perform
Harry Lorayne’s “HaLo Cut” twice, ending with three approximately equal packets each
with a selection on the bottom. The “HaLo” cut is basically a bottom slip cut. It was origi-
nally published in Rim Shots (1973) and has been re-described in several of Harry’s other
books as well.
13
consists of three mates with the odd colored mate at the bottom of the pile. The deck is
face down with four aces on top.
Cut the deck and hold a break at the cut point in readiness for a Riffle Force*. Execute the
force and thumb off three cards at the force point (three aces). Cut the deck, returning the
fourth ace to the top and table the deck. Say, “We’ll also need a mystery card for later.
Please cut the deck about in half.” After the cut, take the former bottom half and place it
cross-wise onto the former top half (Criss-Cross Force*).
Now have the spectator mix the three selections
(without looking at them!) and place one on top of
each of the three piles of three. The stage is set.
(See figure 1)
Pick up each pile in turn, perform a Double Turno-
ver* and then table the packet. The face up cards
will be a two, a jack and a seven respectively. Sup-
posedly these are the three selections. Say,
“Witness the improbable” as you pick up each
packet in turn, flip it over and perform an Elmsley Count*. During the count, a face down
card shows up second to last. Outjog the face down card as in figure 2. (N.B. This is John
Bannon’s “Discrepancy City” count.) This is a very strong moment since it appears that the
other three cards in the packet are the mates of the selections. After each count, remove
the face down card, replace it face up on top and table
the packet.
Now for the big ending: Say, “That was amazing be-
cause it was highly improbable. Get ready for the im-
possible.” Pick up the upper packet of the two crossed
packets and have the spectator turn over the top card
of the tabled packet. It’s the “mystery card” – an ace. To
end, snap your fingers over each of the tabled packets
and then flip them over. The other three aces have
magically appeared – the impossible!
FINAL THOUGHTS: In Cameron’s original handling, the selections (aces) were placed at
the bottom of the piles which were then Elmsley Counted, seemingly reversing the order.
I prefer to use Dingle’s NoLap Switch* to force the three aces rather than a simple riffle
force. With the NoLap, the selections seem to come from three different places in the deck.
CREDITS: Cameron posted this routine on Lance Pierce’s Magic Pebble forum where it im-
mediately generated significant buzz. Suggestions were made by other members that
14
shaped the routine a bit. Curtis Kam suggested using Bannon’s Discrepancy City Predic-
tion count. Ed Oschmann filled in some details in that regard. Cameron’s inspiration was
an Aldo Colombini effect called “Four-Play.” He also mentions Jack Parker’s “100% Confi-
dence.” Cameron published the routine in an ebook called “Card Trail.” You can find it on
his site at www.cameron-francis.com. The routine was published in my Card Corner col-
umn in the Linking Ring in Sept. 2011.
15