Acute Pharyngitis: Robert R. Tanz
Acute Pharyngitis: Robert R. Tanz
Chapter 381
Acute Pharyngitis
Robert R. Tanz
INFECTIOUS ETIOLOGIES
See Table 381-1.
Viruses
In North America and most industrialized countries GAS is the most
important bacterial cause of acute pharyngitis, but viruses predominate
as acute infectious causes of pharyngitis. Viral upper respiratory tract
infections are typically spread by contact with oral or respiratory secre-
tions and occur most commonly in fall, winter, and spring, that is, the
“respiratory season.” Important viruses that cause pharyngitis include
influenza (see Chapter 258), parainfluenza (see Chapter 259), adeno-
viruses (see Chapter 262), coronaviruses (see Chapter 264), enterovi-
ruses (see Chapter 250), rhinoviruses (see Chapter 263), respiratory
2018 Part XIX ◆ Respiratory System
Capillary fragility can cause petechiae distal to a tourniquet or constric- rapid test with a throat culture is recommended. RADTs and throat
tion from clothing, a positive tourniquet test or Rumpel-Leeds phe- culture exhibit spectrum bias: They are more sensitive when the pretest
nomenon. Erythema fades in a few days and when the rash resolves it probability of GAS is high (signs and symptoms are typical of GAS
typically peels like a mild sunburn. Sometimes there is sheet-like des- infection) and less sensitive when the pretest probability is low. Avoid-
quamation around the free margins of the finger nails. Streptococcal ance of testing when patients have signs and symptoms more sugges-
pyrogenic exotoxin A, encoded by the gene spe A, is the exotoxin most tive of a viral infection is recommended.
commonly associated with scarlet fever. Testing for bacteria other than GAS is performed infrequently, and
The M protein is an important GAS virulence factor that facilitates should be reserved for patients with persistent symptoms and symp-
resistance to phagocytosis. The M protein is encoded by the emm gene toms suggestive of a specific non-GAS bacterial pharyngitis, for
and determines the M type (or emm type). Molecular methods have example, when there is concern for gonococcal infection or sexual
identified more than 200 emm genes (emm types). The M protein is abuse. Special culture media and a prolonged incubation are required
immunogenic; an individual can experience multiple episodes of GAS to detect A. haemolyticum. Viral cultures are often unavailable and are
pharyngitis in a lifetime because natural immunity is M type-specific. generally too expensive and slow to be clinically useful. Polymerase
Numerous GAS M types can circulate in a community simultaneously chain reaction is more rapid and multiplex polymerase chain reaction
and they enter and leave communities unpredictably and for unknown testing for respiratory pathogens can identify a variety of viral and
reasons. bacterial agents within a few hours. This may be useful in determining
the isolation needs of hospitalized patients, assisting in patient prog-
DIAGNOSIS nosis, and epidemiology, but in the absence of specific treatment for
The clinical presentations of streptococcal and viral pharyngitis often most viral infections such testing is usually not necessary. A complete
overlap. In particular, the pharyngitis of mononucleosis can be difficult blood cell count showing many atypical lymphocytes and a positive
to distinguish from GAS pharyngitis. Physicians relying solely on clini- mononucleosis slide agglutination test can help to confirm a clinical
cal judgment often overestimate the likelihood of a streptococcal etiol- diagnosis of Epstein-Barr virus infectious mononucleosis.
ogy. Various clinical scoring systems have been described to assist in
identifying patients who are likely to have GAS pharyngitis. Criteria TREATMENT
developed for adults and modified for children by McIsaac give 1 Specific therapy is unavailable for most viral pharyngitis. However,
point for each of the following criteria: history of temperature >38°C nonspecific, symptomatic therapy can be an important part of the
(100.4°F); absence of cough; tender anterior cervical adenopathy; ton- overall treatment plan. An oral antipyretic/analgesic agent (acetamino-
sillar swelling or exudates; and age 3-14 yr. It subtracts a point for age phen or ibuprofen) can relieve fever and sore throat pain. Anesthetic
≥45 yr. At best, a McIsaac score ≥4 is associated with a positive labora- sprays and lozenges (often containing benzocaine, phenol, or menthol)
tory test for GAS in less than 70% of children with pharyngitis (Table can provide local relief in children who are developmentally appropri-
381-2), so it, too, overestimates the likelihood of GAS. Consequently, ate to use them. Systemic corticosteroids are sometimes used in
laboratory testing is essential for accurate diagnosis. Clinical findings children who have evidence of upper airway compromise due to
and/or scoring systems can best be used to assist the clinician in iden- mononucleosis. Although corticosteroids are used fairly commonly in
tifying patients in need of testing. Streptococcal antibody tests are not adults with pharyngitis, large scale studies capable of providing safety
useful in assessing patients with acute pharyngitis. and efficacy data are lacking in children. Corticosteroids cannot be
Throat culture and rapid antigen-detection tests (RADTs) are the recommended for treatment of most pediatric pharyngitis.
diagnostic tests for GAS available in routine clinical care. Throat Antibiotic therapy of bacterial pharyngitis depends on the organism
culture remains the “gold standard” for diagnosing streptococcal phar- identified. On the basis of in vitro susceptibility data, oral penicillin is
yngitis. There are both false-negative cultures as a consequence of often suggested for patients with group C streptococcal isolates and
sampling errors or prior antibiotic treatment and false-positive cul- oral erythromycin is recommended for patients with A. haemolyticum,
tures as a consequence of misidentification of other bacteria as GAS. but the clinical benefit of such treatment is uncertain.
Some laboratories prefer nucleic acid testing that is specific for GAS Most untreated episodes of GAS pharyngitis resolve uneventfully
and no longer use culture to confirm the diagnosis. A child who is within 5 days, but early antibiotic therapy hastens clinical recovery by
chronically colonized with GAS (streptococcal carrier) can have a posi- 12-24 hr. The primary benefit and intent of antibiotic treatment is the
tive culture if it is obtained when the child is evaluated for pharyngitis prevention of acute rheumatic fever (ARF); it is highly effective when
that is actually caused by a viral infection. started within 9 days of onset of illness. Antibiotic therapy does not
Streptococcal RADTs detect the group A carbohydrate of GAS. They prevent acute poststreptococcal glomerulonephritis (APSGN). Antibi-
are used by the vast majority of office-based pediatricians. All RADTs otic therapy should not be delayed for children with symptomatic
have very high specificity, generally ≥95%, so when a RADT is positive pharyngitis and a positive GAS RADT or throat culture. Presumptive
it is assumed to be accurate and throat culture is unnecessary. Because antibiotic treatment can be started when there is a clinical diagnosis of
RADTs are generally less sensitive than culture, confirming a negative scarlet fever, a symptomatic child has a household contact with
Table 381-2 Positive Predictive Value of McIsaac Score in Children in Clinical Studies*
McISAAC, 2004 EDMONSON, 2005 TANZ, 2009 FINE, 2012
SCORE (N = 454) (N = 1184) (N = 1848) (N = 64,789)
0 — — 7% 17%
1 — 0.5% 19% 23%
2 20.5% 8.9% 20% 34%
3 27.5% 42.4% 29% 50%
≥4 67.8% 48.2% 49% 68%
GAS prevalence 34% 38% 30% 37%
*One point is given for each of the following criteria: history of temperature >38°C (100.4°F); absence of cough; tender anterior cervical adenopathy; tonsillar swelling
or exudates; and age 3-14 yr. Note that the Centor score lacks only the age criterion. Positive predictive value refers to the proportion of patients with documented
GAS by rapid antigen-detection test and/or throat culture.
2020 Part XIX ◆ Respiratory System
documented streptococcal pharyngitis, or a history of ARF in the episodes of sore throat. Patients with repeated test-positive pharyngitis
patient or a family member, but a diagnostic test should be performed create anxiety among their families and physicians. It is usually unnec-
to confirm the presence of GAS. essary to attempt to eliminate chronic carriage. Instead, evaluation and
A variety of antimicrobial agents are effective for GAS pharyngitis treatment of pharyngitis should be undertaken without regard for
(Table 381-3). Group A streptococci are universally susceptible to peni- chronic carriage, treating test-positive patients in routine fashion and
cillin and all other β-lactam antibiotics. Penicillin is inexpensive, has avoiding antibiotics in patients who have negative tests. Expert opinion
a narrow spectrum of activity, and few adverse effects. Amoxicillin is suggests that eradication might be attempted in select circumstances:
preferred for children because of taste, availability as chewable tablets a community outbreak of ARF or APSGN; personal or family history
and liquid, and convenience of once-daily dosing. The duration of oral of ARF; an outbreak of GAS pharyngitis in a closed or semiclosed
penicillin and amoxicillin therapy is 10 days. A single intramuscular community, nursing home or healthcare facility; repeated episodes of
dose of benzathine penicillin or a benzathine-procaine penicillin G symptomatic GAS pharyngitis in a family with “ping pong” spread
combination is effective and ensures compliance. Follow-up testing for among family members despite adequate therapy; when tonsillectomy
GAS is unnecessary after completion of therapy and is not recom- is being considered because of chronic carriage or recurrent strepto-
mended unless symptoms recur. coccal pharyngitis; and extreme, unmanageable anxiety related to GAS
Patients allergic to penicillin can be treated with a 10-day course of carriage (“streptophobia”) among family members. Clindamycin given
a narrow-spectrum (first-generation) cephalosporin (cephalexin or by mouth for 10 days is effective therapy (20 mg/kg/day divided in 3
cefadroxil) if the previous reaction to penicillin was not an immediate, doses; adult dose 150-450 mg tid). Amoxicillin-clavulanate (40 mg
type I hypersensitivity reaction. Most often, penicillin-allergic patients amoxicillin/kg/day up to 2000 mg amoxicillin/day divided tid for
are treated for 10 days with erythromycin, clarithromycin, or clinda- 10 days) and 4 days of oral rifampin plus either intramuscular benza-
mycin, or for 5 days with azithromycin. thine penicillin given once or oral penicillin given for 10 days have also
The increased use of macrolides and related antibiotics for a variety been used.
of infections, especially the azalide, azithromycin, is associated with
increased rates of resistance to these drugs among GAS in many coun- RECURRENT PHARYNGITIS
tries. Approximately 5% of GAS in the United States and more than True recurrent GAS pharyngitis can occur for several reasons: reinfec-
10% in Canada are macrolide-resistant (macrolide resistance includes tion with the same M type if type-specific antibody has not developed;
azalide resistance), but there is considerable local variation in both poor compliance with oral antibiotic therapy; macrolide resistance if a
countries. Some macrolide-resistant GAS isolates are also resistant to macrolide was used for treatment; and infection with a new M type.
clindamycin. Although not a major hindrance for treatment of phar- Unfortunately, determining the GAS M type in an acute infection is
yngitis, clindamycin resistance may be important in management of not available to the clinician. Treatment with intramuscular benzathine
invasive GAS infections. Use of these antibiotics should be restricted penicillin eliminates nonadherence to therapy. Apparent recurrences
to patients who cannot safely receive a β–lactam drug for GAS phar- can represent pharyngitis of another cause in the presence of strepto-
yngitis. Tetracyclines, fluoroquinolones, or sulfonamides should not be coccal carriage. Chronic GAS carriage is particularly likely if the
used to treat GAS pharyngitis. illnesses are mild and otherwise atypical for GAS pharyngitis.
Undocumented histories of recurrent pharyngitis are an inadequate basis
CHRONIC GROUP for recommending tonsillectomy.
A STREPTOCOCCUS CARRIERS Tonsillectomy may lower the incidence of pharyngitis for 1-2 yr
Patients who continue to harbor GAS in the pharynx despite appropri- among children with frequent episodes of documented pharyngitis (≥7
ate antibiotic therapy are streptococcal carriers. They have little or no episodes in the previous year or ≥5 in each of the preceding 2 yr, or ≥3
evidence of an immune response to the organism. The pathogenesis of in each of the previous 3 yr). However, the frequency of pharyngitis
chronic carriage is not known. Carriage generally poses little risk to (GAS and non-GAS) generally declines over time. By 2 yr posttonsil-
patients and their contacts, but it can confound testing in subsequent lectomy the incidence of pharyngitis in severely affected children is
similar among those who have tonsillectomy and those who do not.
Few children are so severely affected and the limited clinical benefit of
tonsillectomy for most must be balanced against the risks of anesthesia
and surgery.
Recurrent GAS pharyngitis is rarely, if ever, a sign of an immune
disorder. However, recurrent pharyngitis can be part of a recurrent
fever or autoinflammatory syndrome such as PFAPA syndrome. Pro-
longed pharyngitis (>1 wk) can occur in infectious mononucleosis and
Lemierre syndrome, but it also suggests the possibility of another dis-
order such as neutropenia, a recurrent fever syndrome, or an autoim-
mune disease such as systemic lupus or inflammatory bowel disease.
In such instances, pharyngitis would be one of a number of clinical
findings that together should suggest the underlying diagnosis.
PREVENTION
A variety of GAS vaccines are being developed. A recombinant multi-
valent M-type vaccine uses the terminal portions of various M proteins
to take advantage of their immunogenicity. Other vaccines are based
on more conserved GAS epitopes in order to avoid the necessity of
matching the vaccine with the M types prevalent in a community or
target population. None of the investigational GAS vaccines are near
licensing for use. Antimicrobial prophylaxis with daily oral penicillin
prevents recurrent GAS infections but is recommended only to prevent
recurrences of ARF.
Bibliography Little P, Stuary B, Hobbs FDR, et al: Predictors of suppurative complications for
American Academy of Pediatrics: Group A Streptococcal Infections. In Pickering acute sore throat in primary care prospective clinical cohort study, BMJ
LK, Baker CJ, Kimberlin DW, et al, editors: Red Book: 2012 Report of the 347:f6867, 2013.
Committee on Infectious Diseases, ed 29, Elk Grove Village, IL, 2012, American McIsaac WJ, Kellner JD, Aufricht P, et al: Empirical validation of guidelines for
Academy of Pediatrics, pp 668–680. the management of pharyngitis in children and adults, JAMA 291:1587–1595,
Burton MJ, Glasziou PP: Tonsillectomy or adeno-tonsillectomy versus non-surgical 2004.
treatment for chronic/recurrent acute tonsillitis (review), Cochrane Database Sys Mullarkey C: Soothing a sore throat: the efficacy and safety of steroids in acute
Rev 1:CD001802, 2009. pharyngitis, Ir J Med Sci 180:837–840, 2011.
Centor RM: Expand the pharyngitis paradigm for adolescents and young adults, Paradise JL, Bluestone CD, Bachman RZ, et al: Efficacy of tonsillectomy for
Ann Intern Med 151:812–815, 2009. recurrent throat infection in severely affected children: Results of parallel
Centor RM: When should patients seek care for sore throat?, Ann Intern Med randomized and nonrandomized clinical trials, N Engl J Med 310:674–683,
159:636–637, 2013. 1984.
Clegg HW, Ryan AG, Dallas SD, et al: Treatment of streptococcal pharyngitis with Park SY, Gerber MA, Tanz RR, et al: Clinicians’ management of children and
once daily compared with twice daily amoxicillin: A non-inferiority trial, adolescents with acute pharyngitis, Pediatrics 117:1871–1878, 2006.
Pediatr Infect Dis J 25:761–767, 2006. Pichichero ME, Casey JR: Systematic review of factors contributing to penicillin
Edmonson MB, Farwell KR: Relationship between the clinical likelihood of group treatment failure in Streptococcus pyogenes pharyngitis, Otolaryngol Head Neck
A streptococcal pharyngitis and the sensitivity of a rapid antigen-detection test Surg 137(6):851–857, 2007.
in a pediatric practice, Pediatrics 115:280–285, 2005. Shaikh N, Swaminathan N, Hooper EG: Accuracy and precision of the signs and
Fine AM, Nizet V, Mandl KD: Large-scale validation of the Centor and McIsaac symptoms of streptococcal pharyngitis in children: a systematic review, J Pediatr
scores to predict group A streptococcal pharyngitis, Arch Intern Med 160:487–493, 2012.
172:847–852, 2012. Shulman ST, Bisno AL, Clegg HW, et al: Clinical practice guideline for the
Fine AM, Nizet V, Mandl KD: Participatory medicine: a home score for diagnosis and management of group A streptococcal pharyngitis: 2012 update
streptococcal pharyngitis enabled by real-time biosurveillance, Ann Intern Med by the Infectious Diseases Society of America, Clin Infect Dis 55(10):e86–e102,
159:577–583, 2013. 2012.
Gerber MA, Baltimore RS, Eaton CB, et al: Prevention of acute rheumatic fever Tanz RR, Gerber MA, Kabat W, et al: Performance of a rapid antigen-detection test
and diagnosis and treatment of acute streptococcal pharyngitis (American and throat culture in community pediatric offices: Implications for management
Heart Association Scientific Statement), Circulation 119:1541–1551, 2009. of pharyngitis, Pediatrics 123:437–444, 2009.
Hersh AL, Jackson MA, Hicks LA: Principles of judicious antibiotic prescribing for Tanz RR, Shulman ST, Shortridge VD, et al: U.S. community-based surveillance of
upper respiratory tract infections in pediatrics, Pediatrics 132:1146–1154, 2013. macrolide-resistant pharyngeal group A streptococci during three respiratory
Kuppalli K, Livorsi D, Talati NJ, et al: Lemierre’s syndrome due to Fusobacterium disease seasons, Clin Infect Dis 39:1794–1801, 2004.
necrophorum, Lancet Infect Dis 12:808–815, 2012. Tanz RR, Shulman ST: Chronic pharyngeal carriage of group A streptococci,
Lennon DR, Farrell E, Martin DR, et al: Once-daily amoxicillin vs twice-daily Pediatr Infect Dis J 26:175–176, 2007.
penicillin V in group A β-haemolytic streptococcal pharyngitis, Arch Dis Child Van Driesl ML, De Sutter AIM, Keber N, et al: Different antibiotic treatments for
93:474–478, 2008. group A streptococcal pharyngitis, Cochrane Database Syst Rev (4):CD004406,
Little P, Hobbs FDR, Moore M, et al: Clinical score and rapid antigen detection 2013.
test to guide antibiotic use for sore throats: randomized controlled trial of Wessels MR: Streptococcal pharyngitis, N Engl J Med 364:648–655, 2011.
PRISM (primary care streptococcal management), BMJ 347:F5806, 2013.