Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nikko Hotel Manila Garden and Ruby Lim vs. Roberto Reyes G. R. No. 154259 February 28, 2005 Chico - Nazario, J.
Nikko Hotel Manila Garden and Ruby Lim vs. Roberto Reyes G. R. No. 154259 February 28, 2005 Chico - Nazario, J.
Roberto Reyes
FACTS:
On October 13, 1994, while Roberto Reyes was having coffee at the lobby of Hotel
Nikko, he was invited by his friend of several years, Mrs. Filart to join her in a party at the
hotel’s penthouse for the manager’s birthday celebration. Lining up at the buffet table, Roberto
Reyes was stopped by Ruby Lim, Executive Secretary, claiming he was not invited in a
manner that was embarrassing Roberto Reyes. Mrs. Filart completely ignored the cries for
help of Roberto Reyes who was being escorted out of the party by a policeman. Roberto
Reyes claimed one million pesos moral and exemplary damages and two hundred thousand
Ruby Lim admitted that she asked Roberto Reyes to leave the party but not in the
manner that Roberto Reyes painted in his testimonies. One of her functions included
organizing the birthday party of the hotel's former General Manager, Mr. Tsuruoka. The year
1994 was no different. For Mr. Tsuruoka's party, Ms. Lim generated an exclusive guest list and
extended invitations accordingly. The guest list was limited to approximately sixty of Mr.
Tsuruoka's closest friends and some hotel employees and that Mr. Reyes was not one of those
invited.
Mrs. Filart also testified that she did not invite Roberto Reyes to the party. Roberto
Reyes volunteered to carry the basket of fruits intended for the birthday celebrant as he was
ISSUES:
Whether or not Ruby Lim acted abusively in asking Roberto Reyes, a.k.a. "Amay
Bisaya," to leave the party where he was not invited by the celebrant thereof thereby becoming
RULING:
The Court found more credible the lower court’s findings of facts. There was no proof of
motive on the part of Ms. Lim to humiliate Mr. Reyes and to expose him to ridicule and shame.
Mr. Reyes’ version of the story was unsupported, failing to present any witness to back his
story. Ms. Lim, not having abused her right to ask Mr. Reyes to leave the party to which he was
not invited, cannot be made liable for damages under Articles 19 and 21 of the Civil Code.
Necessarily, neither can her employer, Hotel Nikko, be held liable as its liability springs from
When a right is exercised in a manner which does not conform with the norms enshrined in
Article 19 and results in damage to another, a legal wrong is thereby committed for which the
wrongdoer must be responsible. Article 21 states that any person who willfully causes loss or
injury to another in a manner that is contrary to morals, good customs or public policy shall
The maxim “Volenti Non Fit Injuria” (self-inflicted injury) was upheld by the Court, that is, to
which a person assents is not esteemed in law as injury, that consent to injury precludes the
recovery of damages by one who has knowingly and voluntarily exposed himself to danger.