Fish Farming Aqua PDF
Fish Farming Aqua PDF
Fish Farming Aqua PDF
Practices in Aquaculture
Capacity Building and Policy Development
Edited by
Shiba Shankar Giri
Edited by
Shiba Shankar Giri
Edited by
Shiba Shankar Giri
October 2017
@ 2017 SAARC Agriculture Centre
Published by the SAARC Agriculture Centre (SAC), South Asian Association for
Regional Cooperation, BARC Campus, Farmgate, New Airport Road, Dhaka-1215,
Bangladesh (www.sac.org.bd)
ISBN: 978-984-34-3414-2
Citation:
Giri, S. S. ed., 2017. Best Management Practices in Aquaculture: Capacity Building
and Policy Development. SAARC Agriculture Centre, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 154 p.
This book contains the papers and proceedings of the regional Expert Consultation on Best
Management Practices in Aquaculture: Capacity Building and Policy Development, held at
Goldi Sands Hotel, Negombo, Sri Lanka, from 19-21 September 2017 and jointly organized
by the SAARC Agriculture Centre, and National Aquatic Resources Research and
Development Agency (NARA), Sri Lanka. The experts for country papers presentation were
the representative of their respective governments. The opinions expressed in this publication
are those of the authors and do not imply any opinion whatsoever on the part of SAC,
especially concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or its authorities,
or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
Price
US$ 20 SAARC countries
US$ 80 for other countries
ii
Foreword
Dr. S. M. Bokhtiar
Director
SAARC Agriculture Centre
iii
Contents
FOREWORD iii
COUNTRY PAPERS
v
Chapter 1
1
population to maintain at least current level of per-capita fish consumption
of 19.7kg in 2013 (FAO,2016).
Trade in fish and fishery products is largely demand driven and the
developed world dominates world fishery imports. The fish and products
trades are very often linked to technical regulations and standards that set
out specific characteristics of a product. Lacking of adequate infrastructure,
services, regulatory frameworks, institutional capacity, limited access to
credit and a lack of accurate and reliable market information affect the
quality and safety of fishery products, leading to their loss or difficult y in
marketing.
Table: Top 15 Aquaculture producers in the World in 2014 (production in
thousand tonnes)
Major Aquaculture Total Aquaculture Total Total
Producers in the animals Aquaculture aquaculture
World production plants production
(World position in production (World position
parenthesis) in parenthesis)
China 45469.0 (1) 13362.3 58795.3 (1)
Indonesia 4253.9 (3) 10077.0 14330.9 (2)
India 4881.0 (2) 3.0 4884.0 (3)
Viet Nam 3397.1 (4) 14.3 3411.4 (4)
Philippines 788.8 (11) 1549.6 2337.6 (5)
Bangladesh 1956.9 (5) … 1956.9 (6)
Republic of Korea 480.4 (14) 1087.0 1567.4 (7)
Norway 1332.5 (6) … 1332.5 (8)
Chile 1214.5 (7) 12.8 1227.4 (9)
Egypt 1137.1 (8) … 1137.1 (10)
Japan 657.0 (12) 363.4 1020.4 (11)
Myanmar 962.2 (9) 2.1 964.3 (12)
Thailand 934.8 (10) … 934.8 (13)
Brazil 561.8 (13) 0.7 562.5 (14)
Malaysia 275.7 (15) 245.3 521.0 (15)
Source: FAO 2016
2
remained as the second largest export earnings in Bangladesh, next to
garments, and during 2013-14 the country earned 630.2 million US$. During
2015-16 the export earnings from fisheries and aquaculture was US $ 4.69
billion in India (DAHD, 2017), 253.1 million in Pakistan (during 2014-15),
and 162.8 million US$ in Sri Lanka (in 2015). The transformation of the
fisheries sector from traditional to commercial scale has led to an increase in
fish production in South Asia. The historical scenario of Indian fisheries
reveals a paradigm shift from marine dominated fisheries to a scenario
where inland fisheries has emerged as a major contributor to the overall fish
production in the country. At present inland fisheries has a share of 66.81%
in total fish production of India and aquaculture shares over 63% of total
fish production. In Bangladesh the contribution of Aquaculture is 55.15% of
total fisheries production and is growing at 8.2% annually (APCAS, 2016).
The last 10 years witnessed the tremendous aquaculture growth of 6-8% in
the South Asian region. However, most forms of aquaculture are perceived
to have adverse environmental effects (Tucker et al. 2008a, Klinger and
Naylor 2012).
At present the major concerns of South Asian seafood export market are the
strict enforcement of quality standards by the US and the EU,
implementation of Codex Standards, HACCP regulations, social and
economic issues. In South Asia aquaculture is a highly disorganized activity.
Aquaculture, like other kinds of agriculture, is conducted on a variety of
scales, and production methods vary greatly. As aquaculture is growing
rapidly conflicts with other resource users are also increasing. The conflicts
mostly involve environmental and social issues, poor planning and bad
management which have negatively impacted aquaculture. Prospects for
increasing fisheries production through aquaculture can be enhanced
through efficient, environmentally responsible and standardized production
techniques. In addition to improving performance, aquaculture would
benefit from programs to improve its image with environmental advocacy
groups, human rights organizations, and consumers (Boyd and Clay, 1998).
Obviously, achievement of these objectives will require a great effort in
research and development, extension, and public education and cooperation
among many organizations with different and sometimes conflicting
interests. Therefore, to improve the environmental and social performance
of South Asian aquaculture the best short-term approach is to develop Best
Management Practices (BMPs) for voluntary adoption by the aquaculture
industry and to follow the FAO Code of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries
(FAO, 1997). The governance of fisheries and aquaculture should be greatly
influenced by the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, the
3
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and the Paris Agreement of the
Conference of the Parties (COP21) of the United Nations Framework
Convention on Climate Change (FAO, 2016). Best management practices
(BMPs) are increasingly regarded as meaningful goals in the overall
reduction of cumulative impacts of agriculture (Clay, 2009). Much activity
has been initiated globally on BMPs for improving environmental and social
responsibility in aquaculture, but even more remains to be done if BMPs are
to be effective for the intended purpose. BMP can encompass a wide variety
of issues to include environmental impact assessment of various kinds of
aquaculture in different countries, development of BMPs from existing data
and from results of new studies, verification of BMPs, and efforts to enhance
the implementation of BMPs.
Social issues
The social issues related to aquaculture are conflicts over use of land, water
and
other natural resources. In South Asia many landless people live near the
coast and depend upon fishing and harvest of other coastal resources for
their living. Many times the big investors obtain the land through financial
4
or political influences. Local people sometimes are unable to develop small
aquaculture projects in prime areas because the land is occupied by big
companies. These people have sometimes been forced from coastal land by
aquaculture developers.
Local people often develop small aquaculture farms in coastal areas without
adequate technical knowledge and capital, and without proper permission
from the government. Such projects sometimes lead to environmental
damage, and they often are abandoned within a few years.
5
and Bangladesh. Also, the technological advancements need to be
transferred to small and marginal farmers with in a country to make
aquaculture economically self-sufficient sector of food production.
Diversification of Aquaculture: So far only few candidate species are being
aquacultured in the SAARC Region. Standardization of technologies for
seed production for other many indigenous as well as exogenous finfish and
shellfish and culture of sea weeds are other possibility of aquaculture
diversification. Also, the diversification of aquaculture systems, cage
culture, pen culture, raceway, flow-through, RAS can be new initiatives in
aquaculture. Farm mechanization, pond automation, information and
communication technology (ICT) through web service is identified as key
areas to reduce the input cost, crop losses and to harvest healthy crops from
the aquaculture ponds.
Genetically improved aquatic species: So far only a few genetically
improved aquatic species have been brought into commercial aquaculture
operations. But, the know-how to develop genetically modified fish is
spreading. These genetically improved organisms (GMOs) should satisfy
the desires of both the producers and the consumer. R&D efforts on Jayanthi
Rohu have yielded fruitful results and introduction of GIFT Tilapia in India
has opened up new vistas for genetically improved species.
Public-Private Partnerships: Another important aspect about the positive
impact of aquaculture is the Public-Private Partnerships which can be seen
in many areas of infrastructure development such as market facilities, cold
storages, processing sector etc.
Aquaculture insurance: In view of the severe natural calamities and disease
out breaks, aqua farmers are incurring huge losses. Introduction of
Aquaculture insurance to all fish and shrimp ponds can encourage farmers
for aquaculture.
Investments: Generally, there is low participation of private investors in the
sub-sector due to various constraints in the procedures, lack of incentives,
short term licenses with lengthy procedure for application dealing with
several line agencies which cause he investigators discouraged.
De-silting and de-weeding of creeks, dredging of sea mouths: is yet another
important aspect to allow free movement of water, and reduce the chances
of pollution.
Seed Certification and accreditation programme is being implemented in
few countries in the SAARC region, but it is necessary for developing BMPs.
6
Expansion of coastal aquaculture: Expansion has been given priority and the
area near the coast which is hitherto lying fallow and assigned DKT lands
are given Certificate of Cultivation in Andhra Pradesh state for a period of
one year and which can be renewed. This will help many small and
marginal farmers to take up shrimp/crab culture and teke out their
livelihoods.
Infrastructure Development: Poor infrastructure development for post-
harvest care and value chain maintenance in aquaculture hiders the huge
demand of exports.
7
New Indian Express, October 25, 2017). Of the total fish exports of
11,34,948 MT from India in 2016-17 fiscal, 9,34,484 MT are shrimps and 60
per cent of it was from Andhra Pradesh, especially the Vannamei variety
which is high in demand in the US, the EU and Japan. There is increasing
Rapid Alert System for Food & Feed (RASFF) alerts from the European
Union on the aquaculture exports from India and Andhra Pradesh. The
recent spate of rejections has prompted the EU to increase their sampling
percentage of farmed shrimp from India for border inspection from 10 to
50% since October 2016. The maximum permissible limits for antibiotic
residues are different for different products in EU, USA, Japan and other
countries. Therefore, there is need to process aqua products as per Standard
Operating Procedures (SOPs) of importing countries to promote exports and
also need for a mechanism for preventing usage of banned antibiotics in the
aquaculture sector and strengthening the traceability in aqua products
exports.
In the late 1970s the US Food and Drug Administration placed seafood
imports from Bangladesh under automatic detention due to lack of sanitary
facilities, technology adaptation and inadequate training to handle the
products. In 1997, the fourth leading export item in Bangladesh was frozen
shrimp and fish, with a 7.3 percent share of the total export market. The
major importers at the time were the European Union (EU) accounting for
34–50 percent of Bangladesh’s exports, the United States at 23–38 percent,
and Japan at 15–26 percent. At that time the value per kilogram of
Bangladesh’s frozen shrimp was lower than average for the Asian region.
Furthermore, Bangladesh had a reputation for producing seafood that
sometimes did not meet minimum international standards as specified by
the Codex Alimentarius Commission. With a low percentage of the world
market, a lower-valued product, and a negative reputation in quality,
Bangladesh had been a price taker, rather than a price-setter. Similarly, on
July 30, 1997, the EU banned imports of fishery products from Bangladesh
following to the EU inspections of Bangladesh’s seafood processing plants.
Inspections found serious deficiencies in the infrastructure and hygiene in
processing establishments and insufficient guarantees of quality control by
Bangladeshi government inspectors (Cato and Subasinge, 2003). The ban
was estimated to cost the Bangladesh shrimp-processing sector nearly
US$15 million in lost revenues from August to December 1997, the impact
on both the industry and the economy of Bangladesh was substantial.
Pakistan’s fisheries trade with European Commission (EC) came to a halt in
April 2007 after the EU inspectors found systemic enforcement failure and
serious deficiencies in the sanitary qualities of the fish, and the EU de-listed
8
11 seafood exporting companies. The ban cost Pakistan about US$ 50 million
worth seafood products annually to the EU when the ban hit its trade.
Pakistan’s share of fisheries export to the EU markets was 26 percent of its
global seafood trade in 2007 (Pak Tribune, 28 February 2013 report).
Sri Lanka’s fish export to the EU was banned for 15 months, starting from
February 2015, which the EU noted was due to a long standing failure to
address serious shortcomings in the implementation of control measures, a
lack of deterrent sanctions, as well as the failure to comply with
international and regional fisheries rules. The ban was lifted in April, 2016
after the island nation changed its laws to fight against illegal, unreported
and unregulated fishing. The ban weighed heavily on exports from Sri
Lanka which used to be the second largest exporter of fresh and chilled
swordfish and tuna to the EU with exports worth 74 million euros in 2013
(Asian Tribune, 22 April, 2016).
It is believed that the consumer would appreciate assurance about three
major issues: (1) Is the product safe? (2) Is the product the result of
environmentally-responsible production methods? (3) Is the producer
socially aware? In addition, many consumers would be interested in the
origin of the product, e.g., captured or fished by which nation.
India
Responsible aquaculture practices are being adopted in all the states of India
with effective management for sustainable aquaculture development. The
following management practices are being followed in the country:
Registration of Aquaculture
The states where aquaculture is in progress have stipulated strinngent
measures to register the aquaculture ponds and regulate the activity. The
9
Departments of Fisheries in the states are responsible for registration of
freshwater fish culture. The Coastal Aquaculture Authority, under the
Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare, Government of India is
responsible for regulating aqua-farming activities in coastal areas.
Disease surveillance
Fish and shrimp diseases are constantly monitored by Disease Surveillance
programme implemented under National Surveillance Programme on
Aquatic Animal Diseases (NSPAAD) with the aegis of National Bureau of
Fish Genetic Resources (NBFGR), Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh state. Some
states have already established many aqua-labs for disease diagnosis and
new aqua-labs are also being established in public sector in different states
of India. There are also mobile aqua-labs are in operation in the country.
Quarantine measures
The introduction of exotic organisms for aquaculture carries a risk of
introduction of exotic pathogens. Aquatic quarantine facilities established
10
for the purpose of the import of L. vannamei and operating at Rajiv Gandhi
Centre for Aquaculture (RGCA) under the overall control of the Animal
Quarantine Officer of the Department of Animal Quarantine and
Certification Services, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare. Based
on guidelines developed by CAA only the registered shrimp hatcheries are
permitted to import the exotic shrimp and to use the quarantine facility for
obtaining import clearance.
11
aquaculture facilities and operations, monitoring, and worker training. The
CAA, BIS and MPEDA are involved in setting guidelines and for
implementation of seafood safety regulations. From 2003-2006 ICAR
conducted an evaluation of seafood safety through its implementation of a
‘National Risk Assessment Program for Fish and Fish Products for Domestic
and International Markets’. In 2003, the Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare issued Gazette notifications on permissible limits of chemicals and
enteropathogenic microbes, which serve as benchmark in assessing seafood
quality in the country. The Ministry of Commerce and Industry has also
issued notifications, setting maximum residue limits for antibiotics, heavy
metals and pesticides in fresh, frozen and processed fish and fishery
products and issued a list of prohibited antimicrobials and chemicals in
aquaculture in 2001. Moreover, MPEDA implements a national program on
residue control planning, which includes monitoring and control of residues
such as antibacterial substances, dyes, aflatoxins, pesticides, and heavy
metals at all stages of seafood production (FAO-RAP PUBLICATION
2013/11).
Application of HACCP
In 1995 the Ministry of Commerce issued Gazette notifications adopting
HACCP principles in order to maintain the highest quality standards for
fish and fishery products as required by importing countries such as USA,
EU member states and Japan. The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of India under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules in
2003 issued notifications on permissible levels of chemicals and microbes in
fish and fishery products, which largely conform to EU standards.
12
special provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 as the most appropriate
institutional form around which to mobilize farmers and build their
capacity to collectively leverage their production and marketing strength.
FPO is created with a vision to build a prosperous and sustainable
agriculture sector by promoting and supporting member-owned producer
organisations, that enable farmers to enhance productivity through efficient,
cost-effective and sustainable resource use and realize higher returns for
their produce, through collective action supported by the government, and
fruitful collaboration with academia, research agencies, civil society and the
private sector.
13
introduction of nursery pond management, water treatment for reservoir,
aerators, aerator pipeline at the bottom of nursery pond and effluent
treatment of pond etc. The inlet water is filtered through 150 micron mesh
before entering in to the reservoirs. The water in the reservoir is allowed to
settle for 2-4 days. The suspended matter, silt etc. are settled at the reservoir
bottom. There after water is treated with bleaching powder at 25 ppm
followed by potassium permanganate treatment at 5 ppm to kill the animals
and parasites which might carry virus and bacteria. After 3-4 days of
treatments the water from reservoir is pumped into the Nursery pond
through 60 and 40 microns mesh to prevent entry of finer particles into the
Nursery ponds for the rearing of post larvae (PL). The culture ponds are
fitted with a Central Drain System to let out the organic wastes accumulated
at the centre of the pond (Shrimp Toilet) into ETP through underground
pipe lines. The water quality of the nursery ponds are tested before stocking
the PL. The stocking density varied from 25-40 PL per m2. Farmers are using
only pellet feeds to the growing shrimp as per the standard charts. Weekly
sampling is done to check the health and growth of shrimp. Aqua farmers
are maintaining the data recorded in the registers. The average Production
is 8-10 MT/ha/crop. Two crops are being harvested per year. Total
production from the farm per year is ranging from 16-20 MT/ha.
c. Capacity Building
With the rapid advancements in aquaculture technologies, the educational
and knowledge status of most of the extension workers are inadequate and
needs up gradation. Universities, colleges and training centres are playing
important roles for developing a sustainable aquaculture and fisheries
sector. A number of training programmes are organized in all the states to
develop skills and competencies to foster sustainable aquaculture
14
development. Exposure visits, orientation courses, training programmes,
refresher courses are already in existence. Several Fisheries Colleges,
Polytechnic colleges are established in India for the development of skilled
manpower for aquaculture.
Bangladesh
The Codes have been developed by the Bangladesh Shrimp and Fish
Foundation (BSFF) reflects five key areas viz. social responsibility, human
rights and labour rights, environmental sustainability, food and feed safety,
and traceability.The Codes are intended to promote aquaculture production
which meets international food safety standards, is sustainable, ecologically
sound and socially responsible.
BSFF, in collaboration with DoF, has prepared Codes of Conduct for the
various segments of the shrimp industry:
• Black tiger or Bagda shrimp (Penaeus monodon) hatchery
• Galda shrimp (Macrobrachium) hatchery
• Black tiger or Bagda shrimp (Penaeus monodon) farm
• Galda shrimp (Macrobrachium) farm
• Shrimp / Fish feed mill
• Shrimp collection and service centre or depot
• Ice plants
• Fishing boats
• Shrimp or fish carrier transport van / vessel
Maldives
The following measures are already practiced in the Maldives’ aquaculture
development policy:
Aquaculture development focusing on locally available species: in order to
manage biosecurity issues associated with transboundary movement of live
aquatic animals, the aquaculture development shall focus mainly on locally
available and sourced species.
15
Import allowed only for approved species: a pre-approval process is already
in place for import of live organisms for aquaculture process. Only two
species are included in the approved list at present. Although the sea
cucumber, sandfish (H. scabra) is the only approved non-native aquaculture
species as yet, this species has been introduced to the Maldives over two
decades back and is now considered naturalized. The stringency in the
conditions imposed for the import of live aquaculture organisms vary based
on the results of a risk assessment.
Bhutan
The NRDCA has produced best management practices for carp farming best
suited for Bhutan’s conditions and has been making efforts to disseminate
them among fish farmers. In this regard, not much has been achieved due
to, among other things, shortage of competent extension workers, lack of
adequate funds, and inefficient institutional set up and stakeholders
management mechanisms.
16
Sri Lanka
After the disease outbreak of white spot syndrome condition in the shrimp
culture, many management practices came out. BMPs have been introduced
in shrimp culture practice by NAQDA. Various activities were implemented
during last few years and the main activities undertaken were dredging of
Dutch canal; introduction of a crop calendar and zoning; formation of
relevant rules and regulations and implementation; regulation of shrimp
hatcheries and screening of post larvae of shrimp and broodstock. In
addition, services are being provided at the shrimp disease diagnosis and
health management laboratory at Battuluoya for shrimp farmers to detect
shrimp diseases. Moreover, inter-calibration of PCR laboratories which
engage in WSSV which is the main virus detected in Sri Lanka carried out
by initiation of NARA with the expert consultation under the FAO.
With regard to ornamental sector, health certifications such as bacterial
types and counts, especially for Vibrio cholerae, is requested by certain
buyers prior to export of ornamental fish. This is to prevent the spread of
disease through trans-boundary movements of live aquatic animals. The
health certification for export of live fish is issued by the Department of
Animal Health and Production in compliance with the infectious pathogens
and diseases listed by the Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia-Pacific
(NACA) and the Office International des Epizooties (OIE)
17
quarters at Kochi, under Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Export
Inspection Council for India, Coastal Aquaculture Authority of India,
Bureau of Indian Standards and NFDB are competent authorities to
prescribe codes and standards for aquaculture and products.
The Ministry of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources Development (MFARD)
the Central government, Sri Lanka is entrusted with the responsibility of
development and management of the fisheries sector. National Aquatic
Resources Research and Development Agency (NAQDA) and National
Aquatic Resources Research and Development Agency (NARA) are the two
main institutions functioning under the MFARD, Sri Lanka pertaining to
aquaculture research and development, and Department of Fisheries
involved in issuing permits.
In Nepal nine Fish Research Stations under the Nepal Agriculture Research
Council (NARC), Fish Development Centers of Department of Agriculture,
Tribhuwan University, and Agriculture and Forestry University are
working for the development of aquaculture in the country.
In Pakistan 13 Federal Government Institutes, 10 provincial fisheries
departments, 11 fisheries education departments and 6 others fisheries
organizations/association are involved in the aquaculture development.
Marine Fisheries Department (MFD) is the competent authority for sea food
safety in Pakistan.
In Bangladesh, Department of Fisheries (DoF), Agricultual universities,
BFRI and BARC are working for the fisheries and aquaculture development
in the country. Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institution (BSTI) and
Bangladesh Food Safety Authority (BFSA) are the competent authorities to
handle food safety and quality control issues.
The Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture (MoFA), Maldives is the main
regulator of aquaculture activities in the country. MoFA is mandated with
the responsibility to formulate and implement all legislatures related to
aquaculture, and planning out its development in the country. The Marine
Research Centre (MRC) of MoFA is responsible for research and
development efforts as well as awareness building, information
dissemination and demonstration of successful aquaculture models. All
environmental issues are regulated by the Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA), the national environmental regulatory body. Maldives Food and
Drug Authority (MFDA) is responsible for ensuring the all public health
and food safety criteria for aquacultured products. Maldives Customs
Services is mandated with the responsibility of regulating all imports and
exports to and from the country.
18
There is no national standards organization in Afghanistan to handle the
aquaculture food safety and quality measures.
The National Research and Development Center for Aquaculture (NRDCA),
Bhutan has produced best management practices for carp farming best
suited for Bhutan’s conditions and has been making efforts to disseminate
them among fish farmers.
Conclusion
Aquaculture affects different stakeholders viz., producers, input suppliers,
fish processors, seafood buyers, consumers, government agencies, members
of affected communities, and environmental, social, and consumer
advocates. The Aquaculture BMPs consist of general and specific
instructions and guidance that address construction, operation,
management, species selection and product sales for commercial
aquaculture facilities. Farm owners and managers adopt BMPs that are
appropriate for the size, production system design, location and species for
their farm. BMPs are promoted as a way to reduce costs and waste, increase
income, reduce pollution, produce higher quality products, gain or maintain
access to new markets, and obtain regulatory relief. Therefore,
representatives of all the stakeholders must be involved in formulating
BMPs. South Asian countries can very well compete with the developed
countries in world food commodity markets because of the lower
production cost of export commodities. However, the products from
developing countries must meet minimum safety and quality standards.
Being the pioneers in aquaculture production the South Asian countries can
achieve this goal through adapting latest technology, trained workers to use
technology and conform to world food-handling, sanitation, and personal
hygiene standards. The SAARC Regional consultation on ‘Best Management
Practices in Aquaculture: capacity building and policy development’ is the
unique and first SAARC initiative to bring all the member countries to a
discussion forum for initiating policy framing and capacity development in
BMP for the region.
References
Asian Tribune, 22 April, 2016
Boyd, C.E., Lim, C., Queiroz, J, Salie, ., K., Wet, L. de., McNevin, A. 2008.
Best Management Practices for Responsible Aquaculture (in English &
Thai). ACRSP, Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon. 47pp.
Cato, J., Subasinghe, S. 2003. Food safety in food security and food trade: the
shrimp export industry in Bangladesh. Focus, 10 (9 of 17).
19
Clay, J.W. 2009. The Role of Better Management Practices in Environmental
Management. In: Tucker, C.S., Hargreaves, J.A. 2008. Environmental best
management practices for aquaculture / edited by Craig S. Tucker, with
18 contributing authors. 1st ed. Blackwell Publishing Ltd, 9600 Garsington
Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK
DAHDF 2016-17. Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying & Fisheries,
Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare, Government of India.
De Silva, D.A.M. and Yamao, M. 2008. Compliance on HACCP and export
penetration: An empirical analysis of the seafood processing firms in Sri
Lanka. Sabaramuwa University Journal, 8(1): 61-77.
FAO 1997. Code of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries. FAO, Rome.
FAO 2013. Adoption of aquaculture assessment tools for improving the
planning and management of aquaculture in Asia and the Pacific RAP
Publication 2013/11 PDF, 2013.
FAO 2017. The Global Aquaculture Summit 2017.
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Division of
Aquaculture
Jong, J. D. Aquaculture in India. 2017. https://www.rvo.nl/sites/default/files/
2017/04/aquaculture-in-india-report-2017.pdf
Klinger, D., Naylor, R. 2012. Searching for solutions in aquaculture:
charting a sustainable course. Annual Review of Environment and
Resources, 37:247-276.
Miao, W., Mohan C.V., Ellis, W., Brian, D. eds. 2013. Adoption of Aquaculture
Assessment Tools for Improving the Planning and Management of
Aquaculture in Asia and the Pacific. FAO Regional Office for Asia and the
Pacific, Bangkok, Thailand. RAP Publication 2013/11, 136 pp.
Pak Tribune, 28 February, 2013.
Shalini, A. Neeliah, S.A., Neeliah, H., Goburdhun, D. 2011. Sanitary and
phytosanitary issues for fishery exports to the European Union: A
Mauritian insight. Journal of Development and Agricultural Economics,
3(2): 56-68.
The Daily Star, 2 February, 2018 Report
The New Indian Express, October 25, 2017
Tucker, C.S., Hargreaves, J.A. 2008. Environmental best management practices
for aquaculture / edited by Craig S. Tucker with 18 contributing authors.
1st ed. Blackwell Publishing Ltd, 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ,
UK
World Bank, 2013. FISH to 2030, Prospects for Fisheries and Aquaculture. World
Bank Report Number 83177-GLB
20
Chapter 2
Aquaculture Scenario
The burgeoning human population has an adverse impact on the standard
of living for many people particularly in developing and under developed
countries. This begets a major challenge to meet nutritional security to
increased population. To meet this challenge, great improvement in food
security is needed. Aquaculture has provided this not only as food for local
consumption but also for export to other countries and year-round
availability in the market. Aquaculture is the chief source for production of
relatively cheap protein food, livelihood for rural folk and foreign currency
earner. In India more than 70-75% of Aquaculture is owned by small and
marginal farmers.
Aquaculture is the fastest growing food-producing sector in the world. It is
developing, expanding and intensifying in almost all regions of the world
(Subasighe et al, 2009). Aquaculture, on a global scale and in comparison to
animal husbandry, became a significant contributor to the human food
basket relatively recently. The aquaculture sector has experienced very
strong growth over the last two decades, making it the fastest growing
primary production industry (FAO, 2007). There is tremendous potential for
aquaculture development in India, as it is endowed with highly diversified
and potential water resources. The country has a coastline of 8,118 km,
continental shelf area of 0.53 million sq.kms, Exclusive Economic Zone of
2.02 million sq. kms. India’s inland water resources consist of rivers and
canals (197,024 kms), reservoirs (3.15 million ha), ponds and tanks (235
million ha), oxbow lakes and derelict waters (1.3 million ha), brackish
waters (1.24 million ha) and estuaries (0.29 million ha). According to CMFRI
Census 2010, there are 3,288 marine fishing villages and 1511 marine fish
landing centres in 9 maritime states and 2 union territories. Global total
capture fishery production in 2014 was 93.4 million tonnes, of which 81.5
million tonnes from marine waters and 11.9 million tonnes from inland
waters whereas aquaculture amounted to 73.8 million tones with 44% share
in the total global production of 167.20 million tones (FAO 2016). In India,
the annual fisheries and aquaculture production increased from 0.75 million
tonnes in 1950-51 to 10.79 million tonnes in 2013-2014 (DAHDF, 2016-17).
21
Though cultured fish has no export market, shrimp has a huge international
market demand. This sector contributes to domestic food security and self-
sufficiency. The infrastructure development in the rural areas can be
attributed to the large scale expansion of coastal aquaculture. More
important is the contribution of aquaculture sector towards employment
generation. Aquaculture has shown immense opportunities to many
unemployed youth to take up their livelihoods. Further aquaculture offered
excellent economic growth, opportunities and entrepreneur development
with ample investments. The dwindling production from agriculture sector
has paved the way towards investments in aquaculture as this sector has
generated more income, reduced poverty and thereby improved human
health as well. The Indian shrimp aquaculture industry has rapidly
transitioned from giant tiger shrimp to white leg shrimp because of
increased production efficiency and huge profits.
Prospects of Aquaculture
The development of aquaculture mainly depends on the availability of
brood stock of fish and shrimp. Indian Major Carp brooders are available in
different rivers in the country whereas in terms of shrimp brood stock, Tiger
shrimp brood stock is sourced entirely from wild (sea) and White legged
shrimp is entirely outsourced from different countries. Government has
recently started a domestication program for giant tiger shrimp and also
establishing Aquatic Quarantine Facility (AQF) and Brooder Multiplication
Centres (BMC) for vannamei. The phenomenal growth in aquaculture
occurred in the country because of the rapid expansion, substantial
investment in capacity, improved production techniques and the ability of
the industry to compete in international markets where demand has also
grown substantially. Aquaculture contributes over 47% of world fish
supplies for human consumption and over 500 million people in developing
countries depend directly or indirectly on fisheries and aquaculture for their
livelihoods (FAO, 2009). The pace of development of aquaculture from
1980s to 2017 is phenomenal from traditional farming to intensive culture
and new technologies like cage culture, Recirculation Aquaculture Systems
(RAS), nursery and grow-out systems in shrimp farming, Biosecurity
measures with latest aspects viz., pond lining, shrimp toilets, pond
automation, aqua mimicry and biofloc technology. There has been a gradual
shift in tilapia culture from traditional, semi-intensive to intensive farm
systems. Farmed tilapia production increased dramatically in recent years,
increasing from 383,654 MT in 1990 to 2,326,413 MT in 2006 (Chakraborty
and Banerjee, 2009).
22
Environmental Issues
Aquaculture development brought significant environmental issues and
management problems to share access to the coastal resources. The
following are some of the environmental issues results due to aquaculture
activities:
23
Social Issues
Many social issues arise due to aquaculture activity as detailed below:
• Land owner ship disputes
• Multi-user conflicts: Social unrest is bound to result if high investors
enter in the field and disturb the traditional and improved traditional
system of farming that are being practiced by the small farmers
• Land, water and associated conflicts
• Pollution to the neighbouring agricultural farms due to conversion of
fertile lands into farms
• Drinking water pollution due to pond effluents and salinization.
• Farm regularization issues
24
25
26
such as USA, European Union and Japan in 2016 with USA being the major
rejecting market with 28 rejected consignments. There is increasing Rapid
Alert System for Food & Feed (RASFF) alerts from the European Union on
the aquaculture exports from India and Andhra Pradesh. The recent spate of
rejections has prompted the EU to increase their sampling percentage of
farmed shrimp from India for border inspection from 10 to 50% since
October 2016. The maximum permissible limits for antibiotic residues are
different for different products in EU, USA, Japan and other countries.
Therefore, there is need to process aqua products as per Standard Operating
Procedures (SOPs) of importing countries and promote our exports and also
need for a mechanism for preventing usage of banned antibiotics in the
aquaculture sector and strengthening the traceability in shrimp exports. The
concept of Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) is already
in vogue in most of the processing units and in future it is being practiced in
hatcheries and culture systems. Once this HACCP concept is implemented,
there is greater consciousness in the quality of the shrimp production and
India will continue its dominance in international market. To regulate the
usage of banned antibiotics in aquaculture, the Governments has
constituted task force teams to create awareness among the farmers and to
penalize the violators.
27
28
such as offal, sludge, dead or diseased fish, excess veterinary drugs and
other unwanted chemical inputs into the environment.
BMPs in shrimp culture: The shrimp farmers are adopting better
management practices which include biosecurity, three stage water
filtering mechanism is followed to prevent the entry of egg, larvae of
predators and any other particulate matter into the farm, screening of
seed for various pathogens through PCR, introduction of nursery pond
management, water treatment for reservoir, aerators, aerator pipeline at
the bottom of nursery pond and effluent treatment pond etc. The inlet
water is filtered through 150 micron mesh before entering in to the
reservoirs. The water in the reservoir is allowed to settle for 2-4 days.
The suspended matter, silt etc. are settle at the reservoir bottom. Then
water is treated with bleaching powder at 25 ppm followed by
potassium permanganate at 5 ppm to kill the animals and parasites
which might carry virus and bacteria.
After 3-4 days, the water from reservoir is pumped into the Nursery
Pond through 60 and 40 microns mesh to prevent entry of finer particles
into the Nursery where the shrimp post-larvae (PLs) will be reared. The
Culture pond is fitted with a Central Drain System to let out the organic
wastes accumulated at the Centre of the Pond (Shrimp Toilet) into ETP
through underground pipe line system. The water quality is tested
before stocking the juveniles from the Nursery pond. The stocking
density varied from 25-40 pieces per m2 area. Farmers are using only
pellet feeds to the growing shrimp as per the standard charts. Weekly
sampling is done to check the health and growth of shrimp. Aqua
farmers are maintaining the data recorded in the registers. The average
production is 8-10 MT/ha/crop. Two crops are being harvested per year.
Total Production from the farm per year is ranging from 16-20 MT/ha.
BMPs in Fish Culture: Fish Farmers are also adopting best management
practices which include nursery pond management, water quality
management, stocking of quality fish seed of 50-100 gm size and usage
of pelletised feed viz., sinking pellets and floating pellets for achieving
higher production of fish. The fingerlings (60-80 mm size) are
transferred into another pond (1 Ac) for rearing into advanced
fingerlings to attain 50 g body weight in 60-90 days. The size of culture
ponds ranges from 1 ha to 40 ha. Proper pond preparation is done
carefully such as drying, liming, manuring and stocking density ranges
from 5,000-8,000 per ha. The production ranges from 5-8 MT/ha.
29
30
Recommendations
• Carrying Capacity measurement i.e., the number of fish/shrimp that
can be supported in a pond within natural resource limit or the
number of ponds that can be dug abutting a creek/drain is an
important aspect that has to be taken up as it provides a more practical
approach to determine the sustainability of aquaculture.
• Policy development for proper approaches on minimizing water
pollution, fish/shrimp diseases and escapees into the natural
environment.
• Policy making regarding regulation and setting standards, zoning,
fiscal incentives and capacity building of extension staff and
technicians.
• Harmonization and simplification of existing policies in order to
enable better coordination with aqua farmers.
• R&D efforts for diversification of new aquaculture species as well as
streamlining of seed production and culture technologies of new
species with proper policy frame work.
• Educating extension workers, aqua farmers and other relevant
stakeholders on food safety and the rational use of antibiotics and
chemicals under skill development program.
• Preparation of extension material on best practice guidelines and
associated regulations for fish/shrimp seed production, culture
operations with particular focus upon proper water and soil
management, as well as disease prevention.
• Encourage formation of aqua clusters and thorough monitoring of the
clusters with proper extension and financial assistance wherever
possible.
• Framing implementable guidelines, rules, and regulations and enforce
them so as to reduce the hazards of chemical abuse.
• Strict implementation of HACCP concept as part of food safety
management system will fillip quality shrimp production.
• More Disease diagnostic laboratories should be established in strategic
areas to assist farmers in the identification, prevention and cure of
diseases. Supply of drugs and chemicals should be affected with
proper prescription from such laboratories.
• Education and training on the use of chemicals, their dosages and side
effects should be imparted to the farmers and state government
extension officers.
31
Conclusion
Indeed aquaculture will continue to be an increasingly important food
production sector in India and sustainable aquaculture will ensure many
dividends to the aqua farmers. Aqua industry is the only industry which
can complete and surpass IT industry. Focused attention on aquaculture at
stocking densities that suit the carrying capacity of the ponds, minimising
the risk of disease outbreaks and thereby minimizing the usage of
therapeutic drugs and chemicals is the need of the hour. What is more
required for sustainable aquaculture production is the gaining confidence of
the consumers who take immaculate care of their health and choose their
food item. Awareness creation and promotion of better farm management
practices are essential and state governments are geared up to tap the
domestic market access to make aquaculture more sustainable.
Implementation of Best Management Practices, Capacity building of
extension officers and other stakeholders, domestic market development
and research-extension linkage programmes are the priority items. Time is
ripe to conduct frequent stake holder’s meetings to prepare a roadmap to
make India a sustainable shrimp production country in the world. All
support is needed from stakeholders and research institutes in order to
extend cooperation in a coordinated way to the Blue Revolution in the
country.
References
Arthur, J.R., Subasinge, R.P. 2002. Potential adverse socio-economic and biological
impacts of aquatic animal pathogens due to hatchery-based enhancement of
inland open-water systems, and possibilities for their minimisation. p. 113-
126. In: J.R. Arthur, M.J. Phillips, R.P. Subasinghe, M.B. Reantaso and I.H.
MacRae. (eds.) Primary Aquatic Animal Health Care in Rural, Small-scale,
Aquaculture Development. FAO Fish. Tech. Pap. No. 406.
Chakraborty, S.B., Banerjee, S. 2009. Culture of Monosex Nile Tilapia under Different
Traditional and Non-Traditional Methods in India. World Journal of Fish and
Marine Sciences 1 (3): 212-217.
32
33
Soto, D., Aguilar-Manjarrez, J., Brugère, C., Angel, D., Bailey, C., Black, K., Edwards,
P., Costa Pierce, B., Chopin, T., Deudero, S., Freeman, S., Hambrey, J.,
Hishamunda, N., Knowler, D., Silver, W., Marba, N., Mathe, S.,
Norambuena, R., Simard, F., Tett, P., Troell, M., Wainberg, A. 2008.
Applying an ecosystem-based approach to aquaculture: principles, scales
and some management measures. In D. Soto, J. Aguilar-Manjarrez & N.
Hishamunda, eds. Building an ecosystem approach to aquaculture. FAO/
Universitat de les Illes Balears Expert Workshop, 7–11 May 2007, Spain,
Mallorca. Rome. FAO. FAO Fisheries Proceedings. No. 14: 15–35.
Waite, R., Beveridge, M., Brummett, R. 2014. “Improving Productivity and
Environmental Performance of Aquaculture.” Working Paper, Installment 5
of Creating a Sustainable Food Future. Washington, DC: World Resources
Institute. Accessible at http://www.worldresourcesreport.org.
34
Chapter 3
Vasantha Pahalawattaararchchi
National Aquatic Resources Research and Development Agency (NARA), Sri Lanka
[email protected]
Aquaculture Scenario
With stagnating global capture fishery production and an increasing
population, aquaculture is perceived as having the greatest potential to
produce more fish in the future to meet the growing demand for safe and
quality aquatic food. According to FAO (2004-2017), Asian region have the
highest average food fish consumption rate - estimated at 29 kg per person
per year and the highest contribution (80%) to global aquaculture. In order
to maintain at least the current level of consumption, and taking into
consideration the growing world population, Asia will require an additional
20 million tons of fish per year by 2030 (FAO,2004-2017), which will have to
come from aquaculture This is a major task for the region and there will be
hurdles on the road to success It is acknowledged that, with growth in
volume and value of aquaculture production in the past decade,
aquaculture has made a positive contribution to national, regional and
global economies, poverty reduction and food security.
35
industry was commercialised by a few entrepreneurs about 50 years ago
and it has now developed into a thriving industry affording profits and
employment for many. Ornamental fish culture is carried out mainly in
cement tanks (FAO 2004-2017).
The main Sri Lankan export market for farmed shrimps is Japan followed by
the United States of America and the European Union countries. The
European Union market takes mainly small shrimps in both head-on and
tail only products. The Fish Product (Export) Regulations of 1998 and
Aquaculture (Monitoring of Residues) Regulations of 2000 require
inspection and certification of compliance to these regulations by the
licensee for each export consignment. A special emphasis has been placed
on monitoring to ensure there are no residues of antibiotics as per European
Union's guidelines and requirements. The competent authority for issuing
residue free certificates is the Director General of the Department of Aquatic
Resources.
With the discontinuation of government support for inland fisheries and
aquaculture in 1990, inland fish and freshwater aquaculture production
39,720 Mt in 1989 dropped to 12,000 Mt by the year 1994. With the
reinstatement of government patronage to inland fisheries in 1995, the
former activities recommenced. In 1998, the National Aquaculture
Development Authority (NAQDA) was established under an Act No.53 of
1998 to continue with the programs implemented by the former Inland
Fisheries Division of the Ministry of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources
(MFARD). According to the past statistics aquaculture contributed by less
than 3% to the total fish production of Sri Lanka (MFARD 2016).
36
Figure 2. Fresh water fisheries and aquaculture production
Source: MFARD 2016, Note: Other wild fish includes wild fish, oyster and crabs
37
Seacucumber trade was mainly based on the wild caught juveniles while the
first seacucumber breeding was conducted in Regional Research Centre,
NARA and the technology was transferred to the private sector.
Consequently, one private sector hatchery has been established under the
Vietnam expertise under a MOU signed by National Aquaculture
Development Authority (NAQDA).
Seabass industry is another developing aquaculture industry in Sri Lanka
and cage culture has been practised in lagoons and Bay areas while some
pond culture of seabass also exists. Private sector entrepreneur has started
Sri Lanka’s first ever commercial scale oceanic farm for seabass at the
eastern province.
Few decades ago Sri Lanka entered the World ornamental fish trade as a
supplier of wild caught varieties, mainly marine fish. By 2015, Sri Lanka has
earned, total export revenue (marine and fresh water) of Sl Rs. 2392 million
through export of ornamental fish for 18 destinations, of which main
contributor is cultured / reared freshwater ornamental fish varieties. The
ornamental fish culture industry is wide spread in the island, while the
breeders and exporters are mainly confined to Colombo and suburbs. Grow-
out systems in the ornamental fish culture industry are wide spread
throughout the country. Rapid growth of the industry started since 2012
(fig 3).
38
Development of new ornamental fish strains, development of technology for
induced breeding; providing brood fish, fish disease diagnosis, providing
training and technical assistance are mainly conducted by the government
sector in order to support development of ornamental fish and aquatic plant
culture and exports. Aquaculture Development Centres at Rambodagalla
and Ginigathena under NAQDA and the Panapitiya centre and the Inland
Aquatic Resources and Aquaculture division at NARA are dedicating for
development of ornamental fish and plant industries. Aquatic ornamental
plant production is lower compared to the fish production. Very few
entrepreneurs are engaged in aquatic plant production activities while few
tissue culture laboratories work on micro propagation development and
research.
There are more than 18 destinations where ornamental fish are exported
while countries viz. Germany, France, United Kingdom, Belgium,
Netherlands, Spain, Switzerland, Japan, United States of America and Italy
are the 10 main export markets. According to the statistics of the Customs
department of Sri Lanka, there are 66 large and small-scale ornamental fish
exporters in the country, of which 10 exporters export ornamental fish,
valued over SLR 10 million per annum.
Freshwater prawn production has shown a gradual increase in the country
and the recorded freshwater prawn production was in 2015, about 374 t.
Freshwater prawn created a new fishery in the inland waters and export of
freshwater prawn is at emerging trend. Today, there are mainly two
companies engaged in exporting the freshwater prawn and 21.36 Mt, 20.68
Mt, 141 Mt and 144 Mt were exported in the year 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015,
respectively.
Crab, Scylla serrata farming is confined to fattening and breeding has been
initiated recently. Oyster farming is also in developing stage and the
community based farming has been stated in Puttalam lagoon in the North-
Western province of Sri Lanka.
Prospects of Aquaculture
As an island nation Sri Lanka is endowed with rich fisheries and aquatic
resources in the seas around the country, including 200 nautical miles
Exclusive Economic Zone consisting 517,000. The country is also blessed
with inland water bodies and brackish water ecosystems that are favourable
for fisheries and aquaculture. The lagoons and estuaries cover about 158,000
hectares and mangrove zones, mudflats and salt marshes cover more than
71,000 hectares of the coastal zone. In addition, there is more than 260,000
39
hectares fresh water bodies. These ecosystems provide excellent
opportunities for aquaculture development.
The aquaculture species with high export potentials are shrimp, seaweed,
sea cucumber and freshwater prawn (Macrobrachium).
Sea cumber and bivalve species have a good potential for industrialization
with increasing farming practises with suitable techniques and suitable
sites. Promfret, sea bream and milk fish are the other prospective species for
aquaculture.
40
The marine ornamental fish export sector is totally dependent on the wild
stocks hence there is much scope in breeding and culture of marine
ornamental fish.
The seaweed, K.alvarezii is not of adequate demand for exporting. Species
diversification also has become a current need for expansion of seaweed
culture in sustainable manner. Also, the country is repository of more than
400 seaweed species along its coastal line. At present all the primary
processing seaweed products are exported in the form of dried seaweed in
bales. The major export markets are the Philippines, China, Hong Kong and
France. Sri Lanka has a huge potential for seaweed culture.
Wild collected 13 species of sea cucumber has the export potential but only
Holothuria scabra is cultured in the country. There is a high demand for
freshwater prawn Macrobrachium rosenbergii in the international markets and
the whole prawn is exported in chilled form. The production of freshwater
prawn is not adequate to meet the market demand. Thailand is the major
importer of Sri Lankan freshwater prawn.
41
Figure 5. Shrimp production statistics (source: MFARD 2016)
42
yet and currently over 200 marine species belonging to 40 families are
exported. Increasing pressure on marine ornamental wild fish stocks has
consequently led to the depletion of several wild fish populations; as a
result government has prohibited or restricted export of certain marine and
freshwater fish. As such it is recognized the need of research and
development in marine fish breeding and rearing.
Seaweed farming
Seaweed farming concept was developed in 2008. The industry has picked
up with the public - private partnership. 1.25, 22.5, 25, 70 and 165 of MT of
sea weed are exported during 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 and2015, respectively.
Initiatives for the species diversification and upgrade seed stock
maintenance have been taken in place which is much needed for the
sustainability of the industry. Expansion of the industry is under
consideration to North and South coastal areas with introduction of suitable
methods. While Raft culture and monoline culture practised in the shallow
sheltered coastal areas special structures to be maintained in the areas
where exposed to rough sea conditions.
Other commodities
Live rock export is a new addition to our product range and as at November
2015 live rocks to the values of Rs. 13.5Mn has been exported.
Commercial scale seacucumber fattening is being conduction at
Thewanpitti, Mannar south bay, Ambupuram, Kilinochchi, Valaipadu,
Kilinochchi, and Nachchikuda, Kilinochchi and the production recorded 53
MT. (wet weight) were harvested in 2015 (NAQDA report). Pilot scale
farming with hatchery produced larvae has been stated in Puttalam and
Mannar districts.
The marine ornamental fish export sector is totally dependent on the wild
stocks and currently over 200 marine species belonging to 40 families are
being exported. Several species of wild marine fish populations have
declined due to increased harvesting pressure on marine ornamental fish.
As a result, the government of Sri Lanka has prohibited or restricted export
of certain marine as well as wild caught freshwater fish species.
Other export commodities in smaller quantities are comprised with some
bivalve species, oysters, mussels and sea cucumber,
43
Eighty farmers are engaged in seabass cage/pond culture and the
production was36.5MT in 2015. During 2015 total 250,000 fingerlings were
produced in a hatchery, established through private-public partnership.
Environmental management
The most advanced level of environmental management is the development
and enforcement of rules and regulations regarding how activities should be
conducted in order to provide environmental protection.
In pond aquaculture, contamination of natural waters with nutrients,
organic matter, and suspended solids in effluents usually are the major
environmental concerns. Pond aquaculture normally cannot be conducted
without effluents. So the most advanced regulation requires aquaculture
44
operations to reduce the concentrations and loads of pollutants in effluents
to levels that would not cause deterioration of water quality in receiving
waters. Although Central Environmental Authority has laid down the safe
limits of substances in discharges. However, many farmers do not follow
environmental regulations in aquaculture. Thus, it is necessary to encourage
the farmers to adapt environmentally and socially responsible practices in
aquaculture.
There has been some effort to develop systems approaches to aquacultural
production to improve efficiency and enhance environmental and social
performance. The systems would vary depending upon location, species,
type of grow-out (ponds, cages, raceways, etc.), intensity of production, and
other factors. For shrimp culture Code of Best Management practices have
been introduces for shrimp culture to promote efficient, environmentally
and socially responsible farming.
Destruction of Natural Ecosystems such as mangrove areas which provide
valuable ecosystem services that benefit coastal communities, including
coastal land stabilization and storm protection was recorded in the North-
Western Province for shrimp culture development
It is regulatory to keep a buffer zone when construction of aquaculture
ponds. Mangrove management policy has been documented by the
Environmental Ministry to be implemented.
Eutrophication
The eutrophication or organic enrichment of water column has been
reported in some areas of open waters which is mainly due to unconsumed
feeds,, decomposition of died organisms and overfertilization causing
phytoplankton blooms, burring, and death of benthic organisms. This leads
to undesirable odors and the presence of pathogens in the discharges. It is
proposed to discharge water in shrimp farms through sedimentation tanks
which will help to remove excess nutrients. Moreover, it has to be met the
effluent standards recommended by the Central Environmental
Organization.
45
Introduction of invasive alien species
The negative impacts of the “biological contamination” through
introduction of exotic species in to the native populations. The main
problems anticipated are the displacement of native species, competition for
space and food, and disease spread. Introduction of tank cleaner species has
been become invasive and highly impacted the inland fisheries in Sri Lanka.
Social issues
Social factors are affecting the brackish water shrimp farming and
mariculture, sea cucumber, seaweed and seabass farming, which include;
• Natural character, landscape, and amenity values
• Loss of access/alienation of public space
• Navigational/anchorage interference
• Interference with recreational use
visual pollution Conflicts with other development activities and user conflicts of
different fishing activities are caused when social carrying capacity is not considered
when designating areas for aquaculture,
46
A legal constraint for using some of the lagoons may exist if they already are
part of national parks and wild life sanctuaries or protected wetland
(Marine Protected Areas, RAMSAR convention) areas.
Lack of aquaculture planning and understanding of carrying capacities of
each species also are the major drawbacks in development of aquaculture
Seed certification
Lack or inadequacy of quality seeds in aquaculture is another problem of
aquaculture growth. At present apart from the government no other private
sector involved with the fresh water fish fingerling production. Although
adequate and regulated seed production is prevailed in the shrimp farming
sector all other brackish water and marine sectors face the problem of
inadequate seed supply. Deterioration of quality of the seeds with long term
usage can be observed in some commodities eg. Seaweed farming hence
needs to have proper programmes to have high standard certified seeds.
The use of non-native species and improved strains of native species may
provide better seed for farming, but policies are necessary to ensure
protection of native biodiversity.
47
Investments
Generally, there is low participation of private investors in the sub-sector
due to various constraints in the procedures, lack of incentives, short term
licences with lengthy procedure for application dealing with several line
agencies which cause he investigators discouraged.
Market
The main problem seen in the marketing is that the producer is getting very
low price while middle men get higher profits in the export commodities.
The low selling prices are not able to give profit margin to the producers
resulting less enthusiasm for farming. Priority should be given to make a
more detailed analysis of the value chain to see if it would be possible to
make interventions which could bring about higher profit margin at the
producer level.
Freshwater fish raised in rural areas are sold at the local fairs by the farmers
themselves or sold to an intermediate to sell at local markets. This vital for
house hold level for food security, improving nutrition and income. On the
contrary more than 90 percent of the farmed shrimps are exported and sold
directly from the producer to the processor / exporter, the balance of
production is sold at the local market outlets.
48
by NAQDA. Various activities were implemented during last few years and
the main activities undertaken were dredging of Dutch canal; introduction
of a crop calendar and zoning; formation of relevant rules and regulations
and implementation; regulation of shrimp hatcheries and screening of post
larvae of shrimp and broodstock. In addition, services are being provided at
the shrimp disease diagnosis and health management laboratory at
Battuluoya for shrimp farmers to detect shrimp diseases.Moreover, inter-
calibration of PCR laboratories which engage in WSSV which is the main
virus detected in Sri Lanka carried out by initiation of NARA with the
expert consultation under the FAO.
With regard to ornamental sector, health certifications such as bacterial
types and counts, especially for Vibrio cholerae, is requested by certain
buyers prior to export of ornamental fish, this is to prevent the spread of
disease through trans-boundary movements of live aquatic animals. The
health certification for export of live fish is issued by the Department of
Animal Health and Production in compliance with the infectious pathogens
and diseases listed by the Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia-Pacific
(NACA) and the Office International des Epizooties (OIE)
49
research and development while Department of Fisheries involved in
issuing permits.
National Aquatic Resources Research and Development Agency (NARA)
was established in 1982 under the National Aquatic Resources Research and
Development Agency Act, No. 54 of 1981 for the purpose of conducting
research and providing advisory and consultancy services on scientific,
technological and legal matters relating to exploitation, management,
conservation and development of aquatic resources. Its scope covers marine
biological resources, inland aquatic resources and aquaculture, fishing
technology, post-harvest technology, environmental studies, oceanography,
information technology and hydrography. Apart from its main research
centre located in Colombo, it runs three regional research centres at
Kadolkele (Negombo), Kalpitiya, and Rekawa.
National Aquatic Resources Research and Development Agency (NAQDA)
was established in 1998 under the National Aquaculture Development
Authority of Sri Lanka Act, No. 53 of 1998. NAQDA’s functions include
development and management of the aquaculture industry, and inland
fisheries, which are generally culture-based. It operates nine regional
aquaculture development centres that provide seed-fish and extension
services required for culture-based inland fisheries and aquaculture, a
shrimp-farm monitoring unit, and a central aquaculture training facility
located at Kalawewa.
Recommendations
On the other hand, stringent regulatory measures have been imposed by the
authority to obtain permission for operation of shrimp farm industry
throughout the country. In this regard shrimp farm operation is allowed
only within the zonal plan prepared by National Aquatic Resources
Research and Development Agency.
50
Capacity building
Capacity building is a cross-cutting theme which is one of the major
elements for sustainable development. The trainings for aquaculture are
getting from many Asian and South Asian countries. The FAO Fisheries and
Aquaculture Department undertakes capacity building activities for marine
and inland fisheries as well as aquaculture. These include provision of
training courses within Technical Cooperation Projects (TCPs), preparation
of training materials (e.g. simple methods in aquaculture series, disease
diagnostic guides, surveillance methods, extension manuals, technical
manuals, etc.), awareness raising through training/workshops, financial and
technical support to existing training programs carried out by partner
institutions and custom training courses on specific topics.
Community is trained for various aquaculture practices under NARA and
NAQDA. Ornamental sector trainings are carried out regularly in breeding
and rearing of ornamental fish, disease management, feed production and
management and aquatic plant culture.
Government sector provides technical information, advice and training to
stakeholders. Outputs are then used by fishers and fish farmers, resource
managers and policy-makers to improve production, conservation and
policy-making in the fisheries and aquaculture sector. The results obtained
through these programs are improved food supply and rural livelihoods
through responsible production, better management practices and
improved environmental sustainability.
51
facilities including, hatcheries, access roads, internal roads, etc. and
conduct environmental impact assessments.
• Prepare zonal plans for aquaculture development areas and block-out
plans for different aquaculture systems and units in such areas, and
declare them as areas designated for aquaculture by order published in
the government gazette.
52
• Involve households in rural areas in fish culture in backyard ponds as
a means of food security.
Conclusion
The future development of aquaculture is strongly linked to the possibility
of providing sustainable aquafeed ingredients. If the aquaculture of
carnivorous species is mooted to continue further growth and
improvements must be achieved through feeding of these animals and
alternative feed ingredients for aquafeeds must be found. As a matter of
principle the production of aquafeeds should be a sustainable activity. The
sourcing of these raw materials should be environmentally acceptable, and
should not have negative impacts on the ecosystems. Thereby feed
management, feed production technologies and feed quality should be
improved. Farming of lowtrophic level species, as well as the integration of
aquaculture with other agricultural farming activities should be promoted.
Confirmation of social carrying capacity is a major factor and the expansion
will depend on perceptions of how much marine farming interferes with or
detract from social values.
References
FAO 2004-2017. National Aquaculture Sector Overview. National aquaculture sector
overview - Sri Lanka. National Aquaculture Sector Overview Fact Sheets. Text
by Siriwardena, P.P.G.S.N. In: FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Department
53
[online]. Rome. Updated 1 January 2004. http://www.fao.org/fishery/
countrysector/naso_sri-lanka/en
MFARD 2005 Sri Lanka Fishereis Year Book
MFARD 2016. Fisheries statistics 2016. Ministry of fisheries and Aquatic Resources
Development. Maligawatta, Colombo 10. 55p.
Siriwardena, P.G.S.N., Willman, R. 2003. Code of Better Management Practices for
Shrimp Aquaculture in Sri Lanka. Report prepared under the World Bank,
NACA, WWF and FAO Consortium Program on Shrimp Farming and the
Environment. Work in Progress for Public Discussion. Published by the
Consortium. 46 pages
National Aquaculture Legislation Overview Sri Lanka; FAO Fisheries and
Aquaculture Department
54
Chapter 4
Aquaculture Scenario
Nepal is situated between latitudes of 26°22' to 30°27' north and between
longitudes of 80°4' to 88°12' east. Within the 147,181 km2 area of the country,
physiographic regions range from tropical forests in the south to the snow
and ice covered Himalayas in the north and in-between that there are three
geographic zones from east to west - plane (terai), mountain (hills ) and the
Himalayas. According to the topographic zones, there are three major
climatic zones- tropical , sub- tropical and temperate.
The fisheries and aquaculture have emerged as potentially an important
sector of Nepalese agriculture. It is among the fastest growing sectors in
agriculture. Started in the early 1950s with the introduction of exotic carps,
the aquaculture developed to a potential enterprise in the country. The
current fish production in the country has reached to 83,000 MT. The most
common aquaculture practices in Nepal are carp polyculture in ponds and
in lake enclosures. Over the years, carp polyculture has been developed as
the most viable and popular aquaculture production system in Nepal. It is
becoming popular among professionals and especially the farmers due to
different feeding behaviour of different fish species which gives low cost
efficient production and are cultured in semi intensively managed earthen
ponds. Basically two types of aquaculture are practiced in the country- cold
water aquaculture in hilly and himalayan areas and warm water
aquaculture in plane areas. In warm water aquaculture, it mainly includes
the fish species that could adapt the wide range of temperature and are
practiced with different species in polyculture. The species that are used in
carp polyculture are mostly common carp (Cyprinus carpio), grass carp
(Ctenopharyngodon idella), Silver carp (Hypophthalmicthys molitrix), bighead
carp (Aristhicthys nobilis), as well as Rahu (Labeo rohita), Mrigala(Cirrhinus
mrigala ) and Bhakur (Catla catla ). There are some exotic fish (eg. Pangas and
Tilapia) also which are used in monoculture practice. Rainbow trout
(Oncorynchus mykiss) is aquacultured in intensive coldwater monoculture
system. in The mixed effect of complex geographic and edaphic factors with
thermal variables, the fish production from upland region is still at very low
55
pace. Except some development in trout farming in recent years, the cold
water aquaculture is still in infancy.
Table 1. Import and export status of table fish in Nepal
Prospects of Aquaculture
Nepal has huge diverse water resources in the form of rivers, rivulets,
streams, streamlets, lakes, swamps, reservoirs and irrigated paddy fields
which have a total area about 8,23,160 ha. Rivers are the most important
fresh water resources of Nepaland constitute 48.57 % of the total water
bodies in the country. Lakes and swamps (Ghole) also play the significant
role of water resources availability and got potential of future aquaculture
in Nepal.
Table 2. Aquaculture and fisheries resources
Resources Area (ha)
Aquaculture pond 11,160
River 3,95,000
Lake 5,000
Ghole(swamps) 12,500
Reservoirs 1,500
Paddy field 39,8000
Total 8,23,160
Source: Progress Report 20162017 by Directorate of Fisheries, Balaju Kathmandu
There are four major river basins in the country, namely, River Sapta Koshi,
River Sapta Gandaki, River Karnali and River Mahakali. These four river
systems are located respectively from eastern to western Nepal. The first
56
three of the major river systems cover nearly 60 percent of the total area of
the rivers in Nepal and some of their tributaries originate from Tibetan
region while the River Mahakali originates from the Himalaya within Nepal
and flows as the western bordering river between Nepal and India. There
are also seven medium rivers, namely, Mechi, Kankai, Kamala, Bagmati,
Tinau, Rapti-west and Babai, which originate from the high mountaineous
regions of the Himalayan or Mahabharat. The third categories of rivers
originate from the Churia (Siwalik) range. These rivers are rain fed, short in
length and have little or no flow during dry season.
Figure 1. Major rivers of Nepal from east to west, Koshi or Saptakoshi, Gandak or
Saptagandaki, Karnali, and Mahakali.
57
Table 3. Fish culture technologies and inputs recommended to farmers
58
Recommended technologies for carp polyculture in pond: For best
management practices
• Pond: Rectangular, 1.5 m depth
• Soil: loam, clay loam
• Slope: 1:2
• Species: 7 ( common carp 25%, Silver carp 35%, Bigheah carp 5%,Grass
carp 5%, rohu 10%, Naini 15%, bhakur 5%)
• Stock time: February - March
• Stock rate: 12,000 fingerling/ha
• Stock size: Fingerling 10-25 gm
• Feed: 3% bw/day, contain 25-30% protein, normally use rice brain and
oil seed cake, if possible pellet feeds are suitable.
• Manure: 3000kg/year
• Nitrogen: 220kg
• Phosphorus:345kg
• Culture period: 300 days
• Multiple stocking and multiple harvesting
• Regular water quality checking: pH 6.5-9, temp. 18- 32* c, turbidity 40
cm, DO above 5ppm,
• Lime: 500kg/ha
• Aerator
• Production: above 5mt/ha
59
Recommended technologies for Integrated fish farming: For best
management practices
• Integration with Vegetable: Brinjal, chilly & cucurbits:- In this type of fish
farming grass carp is main species, where 40-50% grass carps are
needed to stock for the proper utilization of vegetative part of
vegetable.
• Integration with Fruits: Banana:- In this type of fish farming also grass
carp is main species, where 40-50% grass carps are needed to stock for
the proper utilization of leafy part of banana.
• Integration with Piggery: 30-40piglet /ha:- In this type of fish farming
common carp is main species, where 40-50% common carps are needed
to stock for the proper utilization of pig dung.
• Integration with Poultry: 700 poultry/ha:- In this type of fish farming
carp polyculture system are recommended mainly focused in the
production of planktons, which is natural foods of fish.
• Integration with Duck: 500 duck/ha.:- In this type of fish farming carp
polyculture system are recommended mainly focused in the
production of planktons, which is natural foods of fish. Ducks are
suitable for increase the oxygen label in the pond.
• Integration in Paddy field: In the paddy field 8000 fingerling/ha are
recommended for fish culture . Verities of paddy required tall and
strong . 10% of total paddy field are required to make pit for the fish
and fingerlings are release 15 days after paddy transplant. The pit size
are varies according to soil type. Generally 1-2 m with, 60 cm depth
and40-50m length is suitable. The fish cultured period of this
integration is only 90 days and productivity near 500 kg/ha.
• Integration with Livestock: 4cows/ha:- In this type of fish farming, carp
polyculture system are recommended mainly focused in the
production of planktons, which is natural foods of fish.
60
Raceway Aquaculture
There is only one species of cold water aquaculture mainly Rainbow trout
(Oncorynchus mykiss) is cultured in monoculture system with the practice of
intensive farming.
The recommended technologies of Rainbow trout culture are as follows:
Pond: raceway 10 m length, 1.5 m with and 1 m depth
Stock time: March to February
Stock rate: 40-50 fingerlings/ m3
Feed: 5% bw/day as 40-50% protein contain, pellet feed according to fish
size
Culture period: 14-15 month
Water qualities: water color clear, temp.8-18oC, water flow1 lit/se
Production: 100 MT/ha
61
Figure 4. Ghole (Koilae ghole in Kailali)
Environmental issues
• Conservation of fish biodiversity: Most of the rivers and other natural
water resources are having low catch per unit area of local indigenous
species(eg. Sahar Tor tor, Tor putitora, Asala Schizothorax spp, katle
Neolissocheilus hexagonolepis etc) year after year due to illegal and
unmanaged way of fishing.
• Protection of natural habitat of fish from human activities:
Construction of Dam and Hydro-power electricity station are also
found the root cause of low catch of indigenous fish, as such
construction destruct the natural habitat and not have the proper
construction of fish ladder, fish sanctuary and breeding center.
62
Social issues
• Use of natural water bodies in aquaculture/Ranching: Very few natural
water bodies are stocked with fish seeds. Ranching of fish seeds to the
natural water bodies increases production as well as natural stocks.
• Industrial as well as domestic pollution: Industrial as well as domestic
wastes are directly released in to the rivers and water bodies which
causes which pollute the water bodies and harm the fish and fish
habitats.
• Aqua-Tourism and Live fish markets: Now a days people wants to
spend their times in recreation that helps by fishing, boating in fish
pond and fish restaurants. Similarly due to the health concern people
wants to take fresh fish from the market, But there in mostly available
of only dead table fish in the market. So there is a space for supply live
fish in to the markets.
63
• Monitoring and Evaluation by FDC
• Technical discussion among Nursery man, District Agriculture
Development Office and Fisheries Development Centre
64
Fish seed
There are 11 Government Fisheries Development Center all over the Nepal
and they meet the fish seed requirement at different part of Nepal. These
centres also coordinate with District Agriculture Development Offices for
transfer of technology of seed production and fish rearing.
65
Figure 10. Water quality checking
Demonstration kits
The District Agriculture Development Office distribute the demonstration
kits such as fingerlings, feed, fertilizer etc. and provide training to the
farmer with the co-ordination of Fisheries Development Centres.
66
Figure 12. Fingerling distribution as demonstration kits
Institutional Setup
Organization structure
67
Fisheries Extension Program (District Agriculture Development Office) –
(Fisheries officers in 26 district and Fisheries Extension Workers in 33
districts)
• Tribhuwan University
• Agriculture and Forestry University
Recommendations
It is needed to make up one technical forum for technology transfer between
member countries, which will help in capacity building of persons involved
in aquaculture as well as in policies development within the SAARC
countries.
Conclusion
Based on the scenario discussed above, Nepalese aquaculture product and
productivity is found to be low. This program will help to share the ideas on
best management practices of different member countries, which can be
incorporated in the new policies that will ultimately help to increase
productivity of aquaculture in the country.
Reference
Annual book 2015/016 by Directorate of Fisheries, Balaju Kathmandu.
Progress Report 2016/017 by Directorate of Fisheries, Balaju Kathmandu.
Annual book 2015/016 by Fisheries Development Centre. Kailali
www.dofd.gov.np
68
Chapter 5
Rehana Kausar
Aquaculture and Fisheries Program, National Agriculture Research Centre
Islamabad, Pakistan
[email protected]
Aquaculture Scenario
The population of the world is increasing at a fabulous rate. As a
consequence of rapid population explosion, the problem of food shortage,
particularly good quality protein is critical. Therefore without a
corresponding increase in food production; this situation may lead to a risk
of severe malnutrition in developing countries including Pakistan. It is
unfortunate to mention that one or more nutrient is deficit in the food of a
considerable population of the world (FAO, 2012) and this situation is
adversely affecting the health and vitality of the people. Aquaculture
provides aquatic animals including fish that are rich source of vitamins,
minerals, protein, and essential fatty acids (FAO, 2012) and can play an
important role in eliminating hunger and malnutrition.
Pakistan, despite of being an agricultural country and maintaining millions
of people on its land, is facing an acute shortage of proteins. It is therefore,
the need of the time to increase the animal protein production to solve the
problem of protein shortage. Aquatic resources are among the major
alternatives for the production of animal protein. With the declaration of an
exclusive economic zone (EEZ) in 1976, Pakistan’s fishing limits were
extended to 200 nautical miles from the shore, providing the country with a
fishing area of approximately 196,600 square kilometers, with shoreline
areas of less than 200 m in depth estimated at around 50,000 square km. The
entire coastline, of about 1,100 km bordering the Arabian Sea, lies within the
subtropical zone and is divided into the coasts of Sindh and Makran in
Balochistan. The continental shelf of the Makran coast is steep, rough and
very narrow, i.e., between 12-32 km wide. The Sindh coast, on the other
hand, has an extended 40-120 km shelf area. Mostly flat, it forms good
trawlable ground. The coast protrudes into the sea in the form of capes and
peninsulas and is, at a few sites, cut off into several small and large bays.
There are only a few islands along the coast. The large estuarine delta of the
river Indus provides good nurseries for fin-fish, shrimp and other marine
life.
69
Pakistan possesses an extensive lake, river and canal system. Natural lakes
cover an area of 109,780 ha. Some are high- altitude lakes suitable for cold
water fish e.g., Saif-ul-Mulook in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK), Satpara
in the Gilgit Biltistan Areas and Hanna in Balochistan. Warm water lakes
are mostly located in Sindh, and two such lakes are Manchar and Keenjhar.
There are several small lakes also, mostly in the Thatta and Sanghar districts
of Sindh. The Indus and its tributaries are the major freshwater fisheries of
the country. The Indus flows from the GB Areas through the KPK and the
Punjab, where it is joined by five large rivers; Kabul, Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi,
and Sutlaj before passing through Sindh and finally draining into the
Arabian Sea. Along the course of the Indus are a number of dams and
reservoirs which provide water to an extensive irrigation network in the
Punjab and upper Sindh regions, representing one of the world’s largest
canal systems. These running and still waters cover about 4.57 million
hectares, while water logging covers about 2.225 million hectares. Of the
reservoirs, six; Mangla, Tarbela, Chashma, Hab, Khanpur and Warsak cover
an area of 80, 613 hectares and play an important role in freshwater
fisheries. Besides these, more than a hundred small and minidams (in the
baran (rain-fed) tract of the country, particularly in the Potwar Plateau) built
for the storage of water, hold an immense potential for aquaculture. At
present only a few of these water resources are being used to raise fish.
Although aquaculture is a fairly new activity in the country, dug-out ponds
for fish farming have been constructed in the private sector. There are
approximately 120,000 hectare fish farming in the country. However,
aquaculture is characterized by low production per unit area, mainly
because of low inputs.
In Pakistan, according to the latest estimates, the total area covered by fish
ponds across all provinces is about 60 470 ha, with Sindh having 49 170 ha,
Punjab 10 500 ha, KP 560 ha and the other provinces (Balochistan, Azad
Jammu Kashmir [AJK] and Northern Area [NA]) 240 ha. About 13 000 fish
farms have so far been established across Pakistan, the size of these farms
varies considerably; however, the average farm size ranges form 5-10 ha. No
direct data on the number of fish farmers employed in this sector is
available as fish farming in most parts of the country is carried out as an
integral part of crop farming. According to a best estimates, about 50 000
people are either directly or indirectly employed in the sector (FAO, 2017).
Pakistan has about 198 freshwater fish species, among those at least 31
species are economically important.
The aquaculture system in Pakistan mainly gyrates around carp fishes
including both indigenous major carps and exotic Chinese carps
70
(Basavaraga et al., 1999). Indigenous major carps namely Catla catla, Labeo
rohita, and Cirrhinus mrigala are the fish for culture. In order to improve
aquaculture system Chinese carps i.e. Hypophthalmichthys molitrix (Silver
carp), Ctenopharyngodon idella (Grass carp), Aristichthys nobilis (Bighead carp)
and Cyprinus carpio (Common carp) were introduced to the culture system
of Pakistan. These fishes have gained popularity in fish farming due to their
number of traits, such as culture suitability in captive conditions and good
growth in ponds (Mirza and Bhatti, 1999). Two species of trout namely
brown trout (Salmo trutta ) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss ) are
cultured in KP, AJK and NA.
Carp are cultured in earthen ponds utilising extensive polyculture farming
systems with very little inputs; in some farms semi-intensive culture has
also been adopted. A combination of five or six of the three indigenous
species of Indian major carps as well as 3 exotic species of Chinese carps are
grown in the ponds. On a typical farm in Pakistan, the ratio of the warm
water species stocked on the farm is as follows: catla (10-20 percent), rohu
(30-35 percent), mrigal (15-20 percent), grass carp (15-20 percent) and silver
carp (15-20 percent). The intensive culture of these species has not yet been
adopted so far, the major impediment to this development being the non-
availability of low cost feed and to some extent the non-availability of
intensive fish farming technology.
The productivity of carp farms show marked differences across the
provinces with Punjab having the highest per unit production followed by
Sindh and KP. Presently two species, brown trout and rainbow trout are
being produced and cultured successfully for use in sport fishing activities.
The intensive rearing of trout is practiced in commercial raceways in Swat,
Dir, Chitral and Hazara in KP and in AJK and NA. With the exception of
trout culture in KP and the northern region, virtually all aquaculture
currently carried out in Pakistan is pond culture of various carp species.
Freshwater fish culture in earthen ponds, both small and large reservoirs as
well as community ponds was initiated in late 1960s by the provincial
fisheries departments. From 1980 onwards the polyculture of Indian major
carps and Chinese carps has been carried out in Punjab, Sindh and to some
extent in NWFP.
Prospects of Aquaculture
The potential for fish farming particularly in developing countries is great.
It offers as economical source of protein rich food. It also offers that the land
which is unsuitable for cultivation, can be used for fish farming. According
71
to the UN survey, that fish production from aquaculture in 1985 stood 10
million tons, closed behind beef, pork and poultry. According to the FAO
estimates at present world aquaculture provides 12 per cent of global fish
production, but it will be more than double by the end of the century. FAO
figures suggest the demand for aquatic foods will reach 100 million MT
annually by the year 2000 creating a 20 million MT gap between supply and
demand. Aquaculture is the major hope for providing animal protein at a
reasonable price to meet the nutritional requirements of Pakistani People for
the year 2010 AD.
The fisheries sector plays an important role in the alleviation of poverty and
the achievement of food security in many parts of the world. In many
economies, fisheries exports generate more foreign exchange than the
revenues earned from any other traded food commodity (FAO 2004).
According to the Economic Survey of Pakistan 2006-2007 (ESP 2006-2007),
fisheries are the principal source of livelihoods for many rural communities
inhabiting the long coastline of Sindh and Balochistan, as well as inland
along the major rivers, and in the vicinity of lakes and dams. The fisheries
sector is estimated to provide direct employment to about 379,000 fishermen
and 400,000 people in ancillary industries (State Bank of Pakistan).
With the exception of trout culture in KP and the northern region, virtually
all aquaculture currently carried out in Pakistan is pond culture of various
carp species. Pakistan has not yet begun any coastal aquaculture operations
although there is good potential all along Pakistan's 1100 km coastline.
Efforts have been made in the past to start shrimp farming along Sindh
coast (Yaqoob, 1994) which did not succeed, the main constraints being the
non-availability of hatchery produced seed and lack of expertise.
Freshwater fish culture in earthen ponds, both small and large reservoirs as
well as community ponds was initiated in late 1960s by the provincial
fisheries departments. From 1980 onwards the polyculture of Indian major
carps and Chinese carps has been carried out in Punjab, Sindh and to some
extent in KP and Balochistan.
According to the old estimates, the total area covered by fish ponds across
all provinces is about 60470 ha, with Sindh having 49170 ha, Punjab 10500
ha, KP 560 ha and the other provinces (Balochistan, Azad Jammu Kashmir
and Northern Area [Gilgit-Biltistan or GB]) 240 ha (Akhter), current data of
total number of fish farming is not available, however, a recent survey
conducted by Fisheries Development Board reveals that in three Tehsil one
each of Gujranwala, Hafizabad and Mandi Bahuddin, about 10000 ha of area
72
is under fish farming. Projecting based on this data, it could safely be said
that total fish farming area of Pakistan is about 120,000 ha.
Marine fisheries exclusively depend upon capture fisheries. Some
development work for shrimp farming was initiated under two
development projects namely Aquaculture1 and Aquaculture 2 during
1980s and 90s, which established among other a big coastal aquaculture
farm at Gharro area district Thatha. The farm consists of about 28hectare of
pond area along with offices, labs and residential buildings. At the same
time the Sindh government allocated 6800hectare of land in the area to
about 80 prospective shrimp farmers. However, because there was no local
production of seed in Pakistan, all those involved had to import seed from
Sri Lanka and Malaysia resulting to high mortalities experienced. Due to the
lack of expertise, none of the pilot farms managed to continue in operation
and all shrimp farming activities ceased by 1990. The government, however,
took note of the potential importance of shrimp farming and again initiated
efforts to establish a shrimp hatchery complex at Hawks Bay which started
operation in 2001. Successful rearing of post-larvae (PL) was achieved at this
hatchery in 2002. A privately run enterprise has successfully cultured the
seed from this hatchery and subsequently produced about 3.0 tons of
shrimp that were later exported. Fisheries Development Board has
supported to enhance the capacity of the said hatchery upto 32 million
PL/year (Personal communications).
The federal government has also taken a number of additional steps aimed
at supporting the development of commercial scale shrimp farming in
Pakistan. In this context, the Marine Fisheries Department (MFD) conducted
two stock assessment surveys of the coastal areas of Sindh and Balochistan
provinces, established a hatchery for shrimp and fish species. Fisheries
Development Board under aquaculture and shrimp farming project selected
11 potential sites along Balochistan Coast and established a shrimp hatchery
at Jiwani. But all these efforts remained unsuccessful due to one reason or
other (personal communications).
Pakistan has many marine and inland fishery resources. The potential was
estimated at 1 million tonnes/year from the marine subsector alone. The
commercially important resources include near 250 demersal fish species, 50
small pelagic fishspecies, 15 medium-sized pelagic species and 20 large
pelagic fish species. In addition, there are also 15 commercial species
of shrimp, 12 of cephalopods and 5 of lobster. The effect of the Indus River
Delta on the marine resources of the coastline of Sindh is substantial, as this
river system has been transporting enormous quantities of nutrients and
73
sediment to the continental shelf for centuries. Pakistan has an extensive
inland water areas system, which is mainly dominated by the Indus River.
These water bodies, depending on their type, possess varying potential for
development of the inland and aquaculture subsectors.
The commercialization of fisheries in Pakistan is fairly a recent
phenomenon. On Fisheries side, Pakistan has opened up its deep-sea waters
to commercial fishing relatively recently when compare to regional
countries. This practice (with no scientific data in hand) has resulted in over
exploitation of natural stocks and hence considered a main reason in
depletion of fish stocks in Pakistani waters. The local fishermen are
harvesting fisheries resources mostly in traditional manners but some
fishermen are also using destructive fishing gears in greed of more fish and
they also has contributed in stock depletion. The fish handling practices on
boats and at harbors are so poor that it spoils fish during transportation and
handling at harbors and in processing plants. The fish and its product
produced under this supply chain are not at par with international
standards and hence largely considered unhygienic for the export markets.
The gaps identified in the supply chain are in respect to food safety
standards, and sustainability standards. Further future prospects of
aquaculture in Pakistan may include:
• Further intensification of fishing pressure in the shelf and deep seas is
possible in the next few decades, due to addition of fishing units and
enhancement of fishing efficiency in terms of vessel capacities, fishing
power of gear systems and acoustic and satellite based fish detection
systems and electronic navigation systems. This may raise issues of
long term sustainability and impact on biodiversity and may result in
diminishing returns in terms of landings and catch per unit effort.
• There will be increasing demand for development and implementation
of conservation technologies for minimising negative impacts of
fishing on resources, biodiversity and environment. These may include
technologies for bycatch reduction, protection of vulnerable species,
minimising energy use in harvest and post-harvest operations and
minimising environmental impacts and materials protection
technologies.
• Problems of scarcity and cost of timber resources for boat building,
biodegradation and corrosion may further aggravate and may require
intensive work on alternate boat building materials.
• Climate change is likely to show its impacts causing regime shifts of
certain commercial species which may affect their regional availability
74
and abundance, which in turn may impact on the fish harvesting and
processing sectors, either negatively or positively.
• Requirement for the regionalisation and implementation of the FAO
Code of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries, adoption and
implementation of Ecosystem based Fisheries Management (EFM) and
effective control of illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing
to management of fisheries may come to the forefront.
• Fishery certification, ecolabelling and traceability may become
important issues influencing international seafood trade from India, in
the next few years and expertise and infrastructure may have to be
developed to address these issues on national and international level.
• Reservoir fisheries may get a boost, due to its high potential in
enhancement of national fish production. Cluster based integration in
harvest and post harvest operations, value addition and marketing,
under value chain concept may have to be evolved.
• Factors affecting riverine fish production such as pollution, destructive
fishing and overfishing may aggravate in the next few decades and
may need management redressel.
• Unconventional resources such as oceanic cephalopods and
myctophids may become significant sources of seafood supply in the
next few decades, in the context of stagnation and shortfall in the
availability of traditional fishery resources, and these developments
may demand appropriate technology interventions for their
sustainable harvesting, value addition and utilisation.
• Further enhancement in India-based tuna fishing effort may take place
in Indian Ocean region and accompanying effort in improving
harvesting and processing of high value tuna products may be
required.
• Advanced techniques for seafood preservation such as non-thermal
processing may become available and widely applied in seafood
processing and preservation. Value addition will be the key principle
in guiding product development. A zero-waste approach will be
warranted with fishery waste also converted to economical products.
Packaging will play an important role in determining consumer
acceptability with respect to perceptions on safety as well as
maintenance of quality.
• Newer products that have wide ranging applications may be available
from the large aquatic resources, including microbes. These can be
exploited for human good.
75
• There is need to mainstream fish in the food habits of the Indian
population with better understanding of the role of fish in decreasing
malnutrition and improving health and creation of awareness about its
significance.
• Seafood safety issues may bring in newer challenges with the
emergence of new forms and variants of pathogens. The issue will also
come into focus with increasing stress on the domestic market for
promotion of seafood products.
• Increased awareness of consumer regarding the usefulness of fish as a
source of nutrition and the changing demands for newer and
convenient products that are easy to cook or consume will call for
intensified efforts in this area.
• The national and international policy regimes vis-à-vis trade, climate
change, conservation and environment are changing rapidly and these
will continue to have an impact on the fisheries sector of the country.
• The traditional systems of technology transfer will undergo changes
and innovative models including public-private partnerships will
evolve making the process of technology commercialization more
dynamic and a truly two way process.Intellectual Property protection
will see new challenges in the face of the need for judicious
commercialization and responding to societal needs.
76
available feed ingredients. Stocking density is very low from 1250 to 3000
fish babies per hectare. Use of aeration is very limited to cluster of
Muzafargarh where semi intensive farming practices have become popular
(NFS&R Yearbook, 2013-14). With the promotion of tilapia farming one
tilapia hatchery has been established and two commercial feed plants.
Tilapia farming has promoted the use of water aeration in some parts of
Punjab. Cage farming is being conducted at experimental stages by Fisheries
Development Board in Mangla dam and some other water bodies. The
concept of hygienic methods of fish handling and marketing is yet to be
popularized among various players of the sector (FDB, personal
communication). Pakistan has not yet begun any coastal aquaculture
operations although there is good potential all along Pakistan's 1 100 km
coastline. Efforts have been made in the past to start shrimp farming along
Sindh coast, (Yaqoob, 1994.) which did not succeed, the main constraints
being the non-availability of hatchery produced seed and lack of expertise.
About 50 % of the total production is consumed locally, 22% is exported
whereas 28% is converted into fish meal for poultry industry. There are
more than 50 fish processing plants in Pakistan with the capacity to process
586 metric tons of fish and shrimp daily. Out of these, 27 plants are involved
in production of frozen products, 2 in canning, and 8 for fishmeal
processing. The export of sea food products increased from US$ 213 in year
2007-08 to US$ 317 in year 2012-13 thus registered a marked increase in term
of values (MFD, 2014).
Despite a lack of formal training, fishers in Pakistan are experienced and
accustomed to coastal and offshore operations, which has resulted in
successful fishing techniques, based on simple technology and fishing gear
(Khan and Khan, 2011). Thus, the small-scale fishing communities have
maintained their traditional methods of fishing, production and marketing
(Siddiqi, 1992). Fishers engage in traditional fishing practices within the 12
nm coastal zone (no deeper than 50 meters), from small wooden-vessels,
using cast nets, gillnets, stake nets and line gears (Khan, 2006). Many of the
local gears used are non selective and unsustainable, with trammel nest and
fine mesh gillnets used widely in coastal areas.
These fishing activities are managed by the provincial fisheries departments
of Sindh and Balochistan (FAO, 2003). Fishermen use nylon gillnet for this
purpose. Benthic variety includes Jew fish, Croakers, Grunters, Shaper,
Groupers, Ribbonfish, and Pomfret. Pelagic fishing is used in Sindh on small
scale by special nets using wooden sailboats. Fishing by this method is done
especially in Ibrahim Hydari and Chashma Goth villages. Two types of
77
vessels are used for fishing in Pakistan firstly, Mechanized Docked Boats
which are 6000, and secondly Mechanized Sailboats made of wood which
are 2000 in Pakistan (Sidiqui, 2012).
It is difficult to estimate the total artisanal and subsistence fishery
production in Pakistan, as there is no routine registration required for
village fishers. Still, it is estimated that artisanal fishing contributes
approximately 40% to total annual marine catch (Siddiqi, 1992).
As with most trawl fisheries, Pakistan’s shrimp fishery produces a large
portion of by-catch and discards. Substantial quantities of non-target fish
are caught, which consist of a mixture of fish species, including fish of
commercial importance, and a significant portion of small, unmarketable
fish. The trawl feet can be at sea for approximately 7-15 days and the by-
catch can be retained each day depending on the capacity of the vessel and
is usually caught in the last few hauls (Shakir and Bano, 1999).
Approximately 60-90% of all by-catch is retained for the purpose of fish
meal production. Discard rates have been estimated by region for the trawl
fishery (Davies et al. 2009).
Tuna supports some of the more important fisheries in Pakistan. There are
eight known species of tuna landed in Pakistan. However, only five species
contribute significantly to commercial catches (Khan 2012b): longtail tuna
(Thunnus tonggol), yellowfin (Thunnus albacares), skipjack (Katsuwanus
pelamis), frigate tuna (Auxis thazard), and Kawakawa (Euthynnus affinis). The
official reported data does not include any landings of bigeye tuna (Thunnus
obesus). According to Fonteneau (2009), vessels of Pakistan and Iran’s
oceanic gill net fisheries operating in Central Western Indian Ocean waters
may have greatly under reported catches of bigeye tuna. It has been
predicted that in some cases, bigeye catches have been misclassified as
yellowfin tuna catches, something that has also been documented in Iran
and the Maldives. However, as bigeye tuna are rare in northern parts of the
Western Indian Ocean, this does not apply to Pakistan’s tuna catches in EEZ
waters or near-EEZ high seas waters (i.e., northwest Indian Ocean). The
fishery operates as both an artisanal and industrial activity, using locally
made wooden-hulled gillnet vessels. It is estimated that more than 500
gillnet fishing vessels are engaged in the inshore and offshore fishery for
tuna (Khan 2012c), with most vessels ranging from 10-20 m. Only about 30
vessels are between 20 to 30 m LOA and have on board freezing
compartments and dual registration to fish in Pakistan and Iran’s EEZ
(Khan, 2012c).
78
The elasmobranch fisheries of Pakistan, which target sharks, sawfish,
guitarfish and rays, are in declining state. Pakistan’s landings, in the early
1990s, contributed 5% of the world’s elasmobranch production (Bonfil,
1994), and Pakistan became one of the 30 top shark fin exporters to Hong
Kong in 2008 (Maslam, 2010).
A sizable recreational fishery exists in Pakistan that targets fish in three
different zones of the EEZ: billfish and tuna fishing out of Karachi, sport
fishing in coastal waters, and hand-line (bottom) fishing in near-shore
waters (FAO, 2009). The only available information on this sector evaluated
the fishery at about 900 participants, catching approximately 130 MT in 2002
in all activities, and by 2009 it was estimated that 1000 participants were
involved in the sector, operating approximately 120-150 non-licensed
vessels (Khan, 2006; FAO, 2009). Despite this information the total
contribution from this sector remains unknown and no official records of
catch can be found.
79
countries, although some substances continue to cause concern (Hall, 2002;
Mason, 2002). This includes pollutants whose ecological effects have been
geographically extensive and long standing despite large management
efforts. After first becoming apparent as a major problem in the 1960s,
eutrophication continues to have major effects on some lake systems
(Verschuren et al. 2002).
Water pollution from oil spills at the ports and harbours; household and
industrial waste; and effluents and agricultural run-off. Karachi and the
surrounding industrial estates (Korangi, Landhi and SITE) are the main
source of household and industrial wastes and effluents. Untreated waste
flows into the sea at Kemari and Minora in violation of regulations.
Agricultural run-off, which used to spill into inland lakes (Manchar, Haleji,
Dhabeji), is now being diverted to the lower Sindh coast through the donor-
funded Left Bank Outfall Drain (LBOD), with a parallel drain on the right
bank of the Indus on the anvil (Aftab et al. 2000). Industrial policy and
environment in Pakistan, Islamabad, UNIDO has quantified the magnitude
of the pollution and estimated that 70 per cent of Karachi's waste water
flows into the marine environment.
Population of some of the species is declining due to habitat loss and
degradation, water abstraction, drainage of wetlands, dam construction,
pollution and eutrophication. These factors have caused substantial declines
and/or changes in inland fish species. Consequently distributional ranges of
some of the species have shrunk tremendously over the last three decades
and are restricted to localised areas. The species Danio rerio, Megarasbora
elonga, Rita rita, Nandus nandus, Badis badis, Monopterus cuchia, and
Macrognathus aral have been severely affected by the environmental
deterioration and habitat loss.
Although intensification of aquaculture can potentially generate high levels
of environmental problems, capital-intensive production systems often give
producers more control over problems like effluent pollution and the spread
of disease. Technology may in fact present economies of scale in the control
of environmental problems. Intensification can raise the risk of disease.
Management techniques such as rotation of cultured species and lower-
density stocking of organisms can partially address this risk, but antibiotics
and water control technologies like aerators and water recirculation systems
can also mitigate the stress caused by high concentrations of organisms.
Technologies based on local knowledge systems and different political and
cultural contexts can also help develop aquaculture in underexploited water
bodies, such as rice paddies, irrigation canals, reservoirs, and seasonal or
80
perennial ponds in developing countries. Some technologies long employed
in traditional aquaculture systems can also be useful in addressing concerns
raised by water management, effluent control, disease control, and land use
in intensified aquaculture. Most of the culture practices in Pakistan are still
based on extensive culture, but with the establishment of few feed mills, the
semi intensive farming practices have been started on limited scale, to
boosts this process substantial investment is required in raising awareness
and extending financing to fish farmers.
The Indus River with its tributaries is the lifeline of agriculture in Pakistan.
The Indus delta ecosystem is degrading from a combination of salt-water
intrusion up to 30 kilometers inland and reduced silt and nutrient flows due
to upstream dam construction. The ravages to the ecosystem have been
exceptionally severe to the mangroves and this is likely to be one of the
major causes of the reduction in fish stock. International Union for the
Conservation of Nature-Canadian International Development Agency-
Ministry of Environment and Pakistan National Conservation strategy,
Islamabad claim that the mangroves sustain fisheries through their role as
breeding grounds. The National Commission on Agriculture observed that
mangrove forests were more seriously threatened than any other forests in
the country. Pakistan has lost 1,700 square km its mangrove forest area in
the past 50 years. The report noted that the Indus delta originally had eight
different species of mangroves, most of which are not found in Pakistan
today.
Coastal development and tourism are other major torments to marine life
caused by human activities as 80% of the world tourism occurs in coastal
areas and world’s 60% population lives within 60 km of coastal sphere.
Mangrove forests and sea grasses, meadows and other marine ecosystem
have been removed to create open beaches, hotels, airports, marinas, resorts,
and golf courses. As the Mediterranean Sea, one of the world’s leading
tourist destinations has lost its ecological assets due to massive tourism so
ecosystem or ecological assets of Gwadar will face the same jeopardy and
the ecological assets may lose their jewellery due to coastal development
and tourism.
81
tremendous potential to improve the quality and quantity of fish reared in
aquaculture, although not without significant controversy and risk.
Biotechnology has the potential to enhance reproduction and the early
developmental success of cultured organisms. The possible environmental
effects of genetically modified aquatic organisms are not well understood,
however, and concerns exist over possible human health risks. The
documented escapes of farmed salmon and their threat to native wild
populations demonstrate that caution should be employed when
considering the introduction of a new species into an ecosystem. Pakistan is
successfully breeding freshwater carp and trout species, but for others
investment and training is required.
The main managerial issues of the aquaculture sector further includes Lack
of Brackish water aquaculture, lack of diversification in species and systems,
only limited number of finfish species are under cultivation since very long
time. High input cost is another issue which need policy and research
support. Loss due to diseases is an emerging issue with the intensification of
the farming system, but there is no strategy to address this issue. Potential
for salinity and temperature increase over present levels during grow-out
period are the most easily perceived climate changes in the future. Export
markets are becoming more and more competitive due to introduction of
quality standards. No research backup will lead us to no market for export
of our seafood products. Growing domestic demand for fish and shell fish
may support the production system of aquaculture.
No commercial fish feeds are currently being produced in Pakistan,
however, some experimental feeds have been prepared and utilised very
effectively. Small pelagics caught as a by-catch from shrimp trawlers as well
as fish offal are used for the production of fish meal on an industrial scale.
About 189134 MT of small pelagic were landed, yielding 42230 MT of fish
meal according to the latest reports. Some progressive fish farmers are using
fish meal and or trash fish in aquaculture operations but it is not a common
practice.
Aquaculture began in Pakistan as a small-scale side line of crop farmers,
however, with the emergence of fish hatcheries operated by the public
sector, there is a movement towards larger fish farms particularly with the
entry of business men into this sector. This effect, however, is area specific
and confined to areas close to big cities such as Lahore and Multan as well
as in Sindh where people have large land holdings, the management of
large water bodies and the construction of large farms are now common
here.
82
In Pakistan, the participation of women in fisheries is common among the
fishing communities but among fish farmers women usually do not
participate in the business when it is an independent company. However,
women are engaged in aquaculture activities when it is part of a family
enterprise and help is required in feeding, planting grasses in the ponds and
guarding the ponds when the farm is close to the house.
83
aquaculture system. Fishing is an important source of Foreign exchange
earnings. The fish supply/production shows an increasing trend and supply
improved from 645000 ton in 2007 to 745,000 ton in 2014.
The worldwide export in the fish and fisheries products was roughly
US$129.2 billion during the year 2012. Despite having very rich natural
resources, the share of Pakistan in the world export is very limited (Kumar,
2006). The main reason behind this is that our exporters are exporting raw
fish and are not focusing on value added products. In addition, lackluster
marketing, untimely exports and variable export quality have all
contributed to poor global market share, despite the richness of natural
resource available.
Fish and shrimp are processed in Pakistan as chilled, frozen, cured, and
canned before they are exported. Fish was being exported in different forms
such as dried, salted, brine, smoked, fresh, chilled, frozen and canned but
export of some forms have been abandoned. In addition, fishmeal is also
produced from small pelagic and also from by-catch. Shrimp is the main
export item both by weight and value. It is exported mostly fresh; frozen
either as shell on tails or as peeled and divined. The USA, Japan, and the EU
are the main importer. Also, Pakistan exports fish meal, fish maws and
shark fins, as well as growing quantities of chilled fish, for which the main
markets are Singapore and the Gulf. Although shrimp has occupied a
predominant position among the items of seafood exported from Pakistan,
very little efforts have been made to harvest shrimp through aqua farming.
Fresh/chilled fish exports from Pakistan have not recorded marked growth
and expansion, despite the attractive markets with growing demand,
available in the Gulf States. Internal demand for fresh fish and supply
constraints are the main reasons for the decline in fresh/chilled fish exports
from Pakistan. In addition, with global stocks of marine shrimp is declining,
it is becoming more and more imperative to move towards aquaculture. The
country has about 6.8 million hectares of freshwater bodies in the form of
lakes, reservoirs, rivers and water logged areas, which is ideal for
aquaculture, this resource is not utilized at present.
Pakistan has more than 50 fish processing plants, which mostly clean and
freeze fish for international buyers out of these only 2 plants have
permission to export their fish to EU countries. The certified Pakistani plants
maintain HACCP standards, which are accepted by European countries.
The certification process is thorough and the SociétéGénérale de
Surveillance (SGS) is the sole accredited certifying agency for marine
products in Pakistan. The processing plants have made large investments in
84
the requisite safety equipment and procedures, and have also installed in-
house laboratories to check fish toxicity. The drivers of compliance at the
processing stage are markets and the underlying unpredictability of the
business. The first is self-evident; if exporters fail to comply with standards
they lose export markets. Second, processing is both high-risk and costly.
Contamination in a single container means the entire consignment has to be
destroyed. Finally, catches fluctuate daily. The high risks, high capital and
processing costs involve owners closely in plant management. The EU
inspectors have noted high awareness levels with regard to HACCP among
plant workers, comparing it with conditions in India and Thailand.
HACCP standards are both plant specific and apply to all stages of pre-
processing. The three stages of pre-processing are: 1) on board fishing
vessels; 2) docks/auction halls; and 3) transport to processing plants.
The EU requirements also include traceability which include first, fishing
vessels are registered with a name and identification number. Second, the
vessel owners are required to install radio systems so they can be
monitored. Third, processors are required to test each batch and, if found
contaminated, to backtrack through the vessel owners to the source of the
catch. The processors are also required to prepare regular reports. The
system in Pakistan has been found to have flaws and contamination levels
on board the fishing vessels, landing docks and auction halls are high and
have been pointed out by the EU inspectors. On-shore handling also falls
below the basic sanitary and health standards, the auction halls are equally
unsanitary. Storages constructed near the auction halls for storing unsold
fish exhibit similar unsanitary conditions. The transportation of fish from
the auction halls to the processing plants meets acceptable cleanliness
criteria if the processors use their own mobile vans. Other forms of
transport, including open mode, tend to be sub-standard.
Compliance failure has institutional roots. Three potential players in
compliance are the Fishermen’s Cooperative Society (FCS), the Marine
Fisheries Department (MFD) and the Karachi Fish Harbor Authority
(KFHA). Overlapping responsibilities are a source of tension among them
and none of the three are technically, financially or administratively
equipped to cope with the various aspects of compliance.
85
therefore be conducted in a responsible manner. National and international
fisheries policies and management practices that better reflect the principles
of the Code of Conduct will lead to an improved and sustainable economic,
social and environmental contribution of the fisheries sector. The
optimization of the contribution of fisheries to achieving benefits in terms of
food, employment, recreation and trade as well as ecosystem and socio-
economic well-being will benefit populations throughout the world.
To promote long-term conservation and sustainable use of fisheries
resources, following a call from the International Conference on Responsible
Fishing (1992) to strengthen the international legal framework for more
effective conservation, management and sustainable exploitation and
production of living aquatic resources, the 1995 FAO Conference adopted
the FAO Code of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries. The Code provides
principles and standards applicable to the conservation, management and
development of all fisheries. It also covers the capture, processing and trade
of fish and fishery products, fishing operations, aquaculture, fisheries
research and the integration of fisheries into coastal area management.
• States and users of living aquatic resources should conserve aquatic
ecosystems. The right to fish carries with it the obligation to do so in a
responsible manner so as to ensure effective conservation and
management of the living aquatic resources. Fisheries management
should promote the maintenance of the quality, diversity and
availability of fishery resources in sufficient quantities for present and
future generations in the context of food security, poverty alleviation
and sustainable development. Management measures should not only
ensure the conservation of target species but also of species belonging
to the same ecosystem or associated with or dependent upon the target
species.
• States should prevent overfishing and excess fishing capacity and
should implement management measures to ensure that fishing effort
is commensurate with the productive capacity of the fishery resources
and their sustainable utilization. States should take measures to
rehabilitate populations as far as possible and when appropriate.
Conservation and management decisions for fisheries should be based
on the best scientific evidence available, also taking into account
traditional knowledge of the resources and their habitat, as well as
relevant environmental, economic and social factors. States should
assign priority to undertake research and data collection in order to
improve scientific and technical knowledge of fisheries including their
interaction with the ecosystem. In recognizing the transboundary
86
nature of many aquatic ecosystems, States should encourage bilateral
and multilateral cooperation in research, as appropriate.
• States and sub regional and regional fisheries management
organizations should apply a precautionary approach widely to
conservation, management and exploitation of living aquatic resources
in order to protect them and preserve the aquatic environment, taking
account of the best scientific evidence available. The absence of
adequate scientific information should not be used as a reason for
postponing or failing to take measures to conserve target species,
associated or dependent species and non-target species and their
environment.
• Selective and environmentally safe fishing gear and practices should be
further developed and applied, to the extent practicable, in order to
maintain biodiversity and to conserve the population structure and
aquatic ecosystems and protect fish quality. Where proper selective
and environmentally safe fishing gear and practices exist, they should
be recognized and accorded a priority in establishing conservation and
management measures for fisheries. States and users of aquatic
ecosystems should minimize waste, catch of non-target species, both
fish and non-fish species, and impacts on associated or dependent
species.
• The harvesting, handling, processing and distribution of fish and
fishery products should be carried out in a manner which will
maintain the nutritional value, quality and safety of the products,
reduce waste and minimize negative impacts on the environment. All
critical fisheries habitats in marine and fresh water ecosystems, such as
wetlands, mangroves, reefs, lagoons, nursery and spawning areas,
should be protected and rehabilitated as far as possible and where
necessary. Particular effort should be made to protect such habitats
from destruction, degradation, pollution and other significant impacts
resulting from human activities that threaten the health and viability of
the fishery resources.
• States should ensure that their fisheries interests, including the need
for conservation of the resources, are taken into account in the multiple
uses of the coastal zone and are integrated into coastal area
management, planning and development. Within their respective
competences and in accordance with international law, including
within the framework of subregional or regional fisheries conservation
and management organizations or arrangements, States should ensure
compliance with and enforcement of conservation and management
measures and establish effective mechanisms, as appropriate, to
87
monitor and control the activities of fishing vessels and fishing support
vessels.
• States authorizing fishing and fishing support vessels to fly their flags
should exercise effective control over those vessels so as to ensure the
proper application of this Code. They should ensure that the activities
of such vessels do not undermine the effectiveness of conservation and
management measures taken in accordance with international law and
adopted at the national, subregional, regional or global levels. States
should also ensure that vessels flying their flags fulfill their obligations
concerning the collection and provision of data relating to their fishing
activities. States should, within their respective competences and in
accordance with international law, cooperate at subregional, regional
and global levels through fisheries management organizations, other
international agreements or other arrangements to promote
conservation and management, ensure responsible fishing and ensure
effective conservation and protection of living aquatic resources
throughout their range of distribution, taking into account the need for
compatible measures in areas within and beyond national jurisdiction.
• States should, to the extent permitted by national laws and regulations,
ensure that decision making processes are transparent and achieve
timely solutions to urgent matters. States, in accordance with
appropriate procedures, should facilitate consultation and the effective
participation of industry, fish workers, environmental and other
interested organizations in decision making with respect to the
development of laws and policies related to fisheries management,
development, international lending and aid. International trade in fish
and fishery products should be conducted in accordance with the
principles, rights and obligations established in the World Trade
Organization (WTO) Agreement and other relevant international
agreements. States should ensure that their policies, programmes and
practices related to trade in fish and fishery products do not result in
obstacles to this trade, environmental degradation or negative social,
including nutritional, impacts.
• States should cooperate in order to prevent disputes. All disputes
relating to fishing activities and practices should be resolved in a
timely, peaceful and cooperative manner, in accordance with
applicable international agreements or as may otherwise be agreed
between the parties. Pending settlement of a dispute, the States
concerned should make every effort to enter into provisional
arrangements of a practical nature which should be without prejudice
to the final outcome of any dispute settlement procedure. States,
88
recognizing the paramount importance to fishers and fish farmers of
understanding the conservation and management of the fishery
resources on which they depend, should promote awareness of
responsible fisheries through education and training. They should
ensure that fishers and fish farmers are involved in the policy
formulation and implementation process, also with a view to
facilitating the implementation of the Code.
• States should ensure that fishing facilities and equipment as well as all
fisheries activities allow for safe, healthy and fair working and living
conditions and meet internationally agreed standards adopted by
relevant international organizations. Recognizing the important
contributions of artisanal and small- scale fisheries to employment,
income and food security, States should appropriately protect the
rights of fishers and fish workers, particularly those engaged in
subsistence, small-scale and artisanal fisheries, to a secure and just
livelihood, as well as preferential access, where appropriate, to
traditional fishing grounds and resources in the waters under their
national jurisdiction. States should consider aquaculture, including
culture-based fisheries, as a means to promote diversification of
income and diet. In so doing, States should ensure that resources are
used responsibly and adverse impacts on the environment and on local
communities are minimized.
• States and all those engaged in fisheries management should, through
an appropriate policy, legal and institutional framework, adopt
measures for the long-term conservation and sustainable use of
fisheries resources. Conservation and management measures, whether
at local, national, subregional or regional levels, should be based on the
best scientific evidence available and be designed to ensure the long-
term sustainability of fishery resources at levels which promote the
objective of their optimum utilization and maintain their availability
for present and future generations; short term considerations should
not compromise these objectives.
• Within areas under national jurisdiction, States should seek to identify
relevant domestic parties having a legitimate interest in the use and
management of fisheries resources and establish arrangements for
consulting them to gain their collaboration in achieving responsible
fisheries. For transboundary fish stocks, straddling fish stocks, highly
migratory fish stocks and high seas fish stocks, where these are
exploited by two or more States, the States concerned, including the
relevant coastal States in the case of straddling and highly migratory
stocks, should cooperate to ensure effective conservation and
89
management of the resources. This should be achieved, where
appropriate, through the establishment of a bilateral, subregional or
regional fisheries organization or arrangement.
• A subregional or regional fisheries management organization or
arrangement should include representatives of States in whose
jurisdictions the resources occur, as well as representatives from States
which have a real interest in the fisheries on the resources outside
national jurisdictions. Where a subregional or regional fisheries
management organization or arrangement exists and has the
competence to establish conservation and management measures,
those States should cooperate by becoming a member of such
organization or a participant in such arrangement, and actively
participate in its work. A State which is not a member of a subregional
or regional fisheries management organization or is not a participant in
a subregional or regional fisheries management arrangement should
nevertheless cooperate, in accordance with relevant international
agreements and international law, in the conservation and
management of the relevant fisheries resources by giving effect to any
conservation and management measures adopted by such organization
or arrangement.
• Representatives from relevant organizations, both governmental and
non-governmental, concerned with fisheries should be afforded the
opportunity to take part in meetings of subregional and regional
fisheries management organizations and arrangements as observers or
otherwise, as appropriate, in accordance with the procedures of the
organization or arrangement concerned. Such representatives should
be given timely access to the records and reports of such meetings,
subject to the procedural rules on access to them. States should
establish, within their respective competences and capacities, effective
mechanisms for fisheries monitoring, surveillance, control and
enforcement to ensure compliance with their conservation and
management measures, as well as those adopted by subregional or
regional organizations or arrangements.
• States should take measures to prevent or eliminate excess fishing
capacity and should ensure that levels of fishing effort are
commensurate with the sustainable use of fishery resources as a means
of ensuring the effectiveness of conservation and management
measures. States and subregional or regional fisheries management
organizations and arrangements should ensure transparency in the
mechanisms for fisheries management and in the related decision-
making process.
90
• States and subregional or regional fisheries management organizations
and arrangements should give due publicity to conservation and
management measures and ensure that laws, regulations and other
legal rules governing their implementation are effectively
disseminated. The bases and purposes of such measures should be
explained to users of the resource in order to facilitate their application
and thus gain increased support in the implementation of such
measures.
• Recognizing that long-term sustainable use of fisheries resources is the
overriding objective of conservation and management, States and
subregional or regional fisheries management organizations and
arrangements should, inter alia, adopt appropriate measures, based on
the best scientific evidence available, which are designed to maintain
or restore stocks at levels capable of producing maximum sustainable
yield, as qualified by relevant environmental and economic factors,
including the special requirements of developing countries.
• States should assess the impacts of environmental factors on target
stocks and species belonging to the same ecosystem or associated with
or dependent upon the target stocks, and assess the relationship
among the populations in the ecosystem.
• To be effective, fisheries management should be concerned with the
whole stock unit over its entire area of distribution and take into
account previously agreed management measures established and
applied in the same region, all removals and the biological unity and
other biological characteristics of the stock. The best scientific evidence
available should be used to determine, inter alia, the area of
distribution of the resource and the area through which it migrates
during its life cycle. In order to conserve and manage transboundary
fish stocks, straddling fish stocks, highly migratory fish stocks and
high seas fish stocks throughout their range, conservation and
management measures established for such stocks in accordance with
the respective competences of relevant States or, where appropriate,
through subregional and regional fisheries management organizations
and arrangements, should be compatible. Compatibility should be
achieved in a manner consistent with the rights, competences and
interests of the States concerned.
• Long-term management objectives should be translated into
management actions, formulated as a fishery management plan or
other management framework. States and, where appropriate,
subregional or regional fisheries management organizations and
arrangements should foster and promote international cooperation and
91
coordination in all matters related to fisheries, including information
gathering and exchange, fisheries research, management and
development.
• States should ensure that the level of fishing permitted is
commensurate with the state of fisheries resources. States should adopt
measures to ensure that no vessel be allowed to fish unless so
authorized, in a manner consistent with international law for the high
seas or in conformity with national legislation within areas of national
jurisdiction. Where excess fishing capacity exists, mechanisms should
be established to reduce capacity to levels commensurate with the
sustainable use of fisheries resources so as to ensure that fishers
operate under economic conditions that promote responsible fisheries.
Such mechanisms should include monitoring the capacity of fishing
fleets.
• The performance of all existing fishing gear, methods and practices
should be examined and measures taken to ensure that fishing gear,
methods and practices which are not consistent with responsible
fishing are phased out and replaced with more acceptable alternatives.
In this process, particular attention should be given to the impact of
such measures on fishing communities, including their ability to
exploit the resource. States should require that fishing gear, methods
and practices, to the extent practicable, are sufficiently selective so as to
minimize waste, discards, catch of non-target species, both fish and
non-fish species, and impacts on associated or dependent species and
that the intent of related regulations is not circumvented by technical
devices. In this regard, fishers should cooperate in the development of
selective fishing gear and methods. States should ensure that
information on new developments and requirements is made available
to all fishers.
• States and fisheries management organizations and arrangements
should regulate fishing in such a way as to avoid the risk of conflict
among fishers using different vessels, gear and fishing methods. When
deciding on the use, conservation and management of fisheries
resources, due recognition should be given, as appropriate, in
accordance with national laws and regulations, to the traditional
practices, needs and interests of indigenous people and local fishing
communities which are highly dependent on fishery resources for their
livelihood.
• States and sub-regional and regional fisheries management
organizations and arrangements, in the framework of their respective
competences, should introduce measures for depleted resources and
92
those resources threatened with depletion that facilitate the sustained
recovery of such stocks. They should make every effort to ensure that
resources and habitats critical to the well-being of such resources
which have been adversely affected by fishing or other human
activities are restored. States, in conformity with their national laws,
should implement effective fisheries monitoring, control, surveillance
and law enforcement measures including, where appropriate, observer
programmes, inspection schemes and vessel monitoring systems. Such
measures should be promoted and, where appropriate, implemented
by sub-regional or regional fisheries management organizations and
arrangements in accordance with procedures agreed by such
organizations or arrangements.
• States should ensure that fishing is conducted with due regard to the
safety of human life and the International Maritime Organization
International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea, as well as
International Maritime Organization requirements relating to the
organization of marine traffic, protection of the marine environment
and the prevention of damage to or loss of fishing gear. States should
prohibit dynamiting, poisoning and other comparable destructive
fishing practices.
• States should make every effort to ensure that documentation with
regard to fishing operations, retained catch of fish and non-fish species
and, as regards discards, the information required for stock assessment
as decided by relevant management bodies, is collected and forwarded
systematically to those bodies. States should, as far as possible,
establish programmes, such as observer and inspection schemes, in
order to promote compliance with applicable measures. States should
promote the adoption of appropriate technology, taking into account
economic conditions, for the best use and care of the retained catch.
• States, with relevant groups from industry, should encourage the
development and implementation of technologies and operational
methods that reduce discards. The use of fishing gear and practices
that lead to the discarding of catch should be discouraged and the use
of fishing gear and practices that increase survival rates of escaping
fish should be promoted.
• States should cooperate to develop and apply technologies, materials
and operational methods that minimize the loss of fishing gear and the
ghost fishing effects of lost or abandoned fishing gear. States should
ensure that assessments of the implications of habitat disturbance are
carried out prior to the introduction on a commercial scale of new
fishing gear, methods and operations to an area. Research on the
93
environmental and social impacts of fishing gear and, in particular, on
the impact of such gear on biodiversity and coastal fishing
communities should be promoted.
• States should promote the development of appropriate standards and
guidelines which would lead to the more efficient use of energy in
harvesting and post-harvest activities within the fisheries sector. States
should promote the development and transfer of technology in relation
to energy optimization within the fisheries sector and, in particular,
encourage owners, charterers and managers of fishing vessels to fit
energy optimization devices to their vessels.
• States should introduce and enforce laws and regulations based on the
International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships
States should adopt relevant standards and guidelines which would
include provisions for the reduction of dangerous substances in
exhaust gas emissions. Owners, charterers and managers of fishing
vessels should ensure that their vessels are fitted with equipment to
reduce emissions of ozone depleting substances.
• The responsible crew members of fishing vessels should be conversant
with the proper running and maintenance of machinery on
board. Owners, charterers and managers of fishing vessels should
ensure that their vessels are fitted with appropriate equipment as
required by MARPOL 73/78 and should consider fitting a shipboard
compactor or incinerator to relevant classes of vessels in order to treat
garbage and other shipboard wastes generated during the vessel's
normal service. Owners, charterers and managers of fishing vessels
should minimize the taking aboard of potential garbage through
proper provisioning practices. The crew of fishing vessels should be
conversant with proper shipboard procedures in order to ensure
discharges do not exceed the levels set by MARPOL 73/78. Such
procedures should, as a minimum, include the disposal of oily waste
and the handling and storage of shipboard garbage.
94
FATA, NA and AJK are relatively small and mainly aimed at the
management of the trout fisheries.
At the central level, fisheries is overseen by the office of the Fisheries
Development Commissioner (FDC) working under the Ministry of Food
Security & Research. The office of the FDC is responsible for policy making,
planning and coordination with the provincial fisheries departments as well
as other national and international agencies. The Marine Fisheries
Department (MFD), Karachi, an attached department of MnFS&R, is
responsible for the implementation of Deep Sea Fishing Policy and the
regulation of exports of fish and fishery products.
The Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA) working under
the Ministry of Water and Power also has a fisheries department responsible
for the regulation and auction of fisheries rights in the large reservoirs
found in Pakistan. There is a fisheries research unit at the National
Agricultural Research Center (NARC) of PARC, the country's biggest
research organizations established under the MnFS&R. Some universities in
the country are also involved in basic fisheries research.
95
lack of expertise, none of the pilot farms managed to continue in operation
and all shrimp farming activities ceased by 1990.
The government, however, took note of the potential importance of shrimp
farming and again initiated efforts to establish a shrimp hatchery complex at
Hawks Bay which started operation in 2001. Successful rearing of post-
larvae was achieved at this hatchery in 2002. A privately run enterprise has
successfully cultured the seed from this hatchery and subsequently
produced about 3.0 MT of shrimp that were later exported. The government
of Sindh and the National Institute of Oceanography have since taken over
operation of the hatcheries established at Hawks Bay and another at Clifton
near Karachi and very recently seed has been produced which is now being
reared at the Sindh government's facilities located in the Garho area. With
the success in seed production using indigenous species, it is expected that
commercial scale shrimp farming will begin in the near future.
The national government has also taken a number of additional steps aimed
at supporting the development of commercial scale shrimp farming in
Pakistan. In this context, the MFD conducted a survey of the coastal areas of
Makran and identified potential areas where shrimp farming could be
established. The Government of Sindh has also proposed potential areas for
the development of shrimp farming.
96
2. Fishermen Cooperative Society (FCS)
3. Pasni Fish Harbour
4. Gawadar Fish Harbour
5. Fisheries Department Government of Punjab
6. Fisheries Department Government of Sindh
7. Fisheries Department Government of Balochistan
8. Fisheries Department Government of KPK
9. Fisheries Department Government of GB
10. Fisheries Department Government of AJK
11. Coastal Development Authorities in Sindh and in Balochistan
97
Northern Areas continue to retain most features of the 1961 and 1965 laws.
The detail is given in table 1.
Table 1: Laws related to fisheries sector in Pakistan
Federal
The constitution of Pakistan, Fourth Schedule, Article 36
The Territorial waters and Maritime Zone Act, 1976; Act No. LXXXII of 1976
Exclusive Fishing Zone (Regulation of Fishing) Act, 1975 as amended 1993
The Exclusive Fishing Zone (Regulation of Fishing) Rules 1976, promulgated
under section 16 of the Exclusive Fishing Zone (Regulation of Fishing) Act 1975
Exclusive Fishery Zone (Regulation of Fishing)(Amendment)Ordinance,
1983(Ordinance No. XXIX of 1983)
Exclusive Fishery Zone (Regulation of Fishing) (Amendment) Act, 1993 (Act No.
V of 1993)
Conservation of fisheries resources S. R. O. 329(1)/79
Notification No.DD-75/98/3342-48 dated 24-07-1999
Port Qasim Authority Act, 1973 (Act No. XLIII of 1973)
West Pakistan Fisheries Ordinance, 1961
Fisheries Act (No. 4 of 1897)
Deep Sea Fishing Policy.1995
The Pakistan Fish Inspection & Quality Control Act, 1997
Pakistan Fish Inspection and Quality Control (Amendment) Ordinance, 1998 (No.
XI of 1998)
The Pakistan Fish Inspection & Quality Control Rules, 1998
The Pakistan Environmental Protection Act, 1997
The Agriculture Produce (Grading & Marketing) Act 1937
The Pakistan Animal Quarantine (Import and Exports of Animal and Animal
Products) Ordinance, 1979
Punjab
Punjab Fisheries Ordinance, 1961 (W.P. Ordinance No. XXX of 1961
Fisheries Ordinance 1961 (amended up to 2001)
Fisheries Rules, 1965 (amended up to 2001)
Punjab Fisheries (Amendment) Rules 1996
Punjab Fisheries (Amendment) Act 1999
Punjab Fisheries (Amendment) Ordinance 2001
Punjab Fisheries (Amendment) Rules 2001
Sindh
Sind Fisheries Ordinance, 1980 (Sind Ordinance No. III of 1980)Part I.
Sindh Fisheries (Amendment) Act, 2003 (Act No. VI of 2004)
Karachi Fisheries Harbour Authority Ordinance, 1984 (No. II of 1984)
98
There is a need to formulate research programs with stakeholder
participation and prioritization of research programs to be undertaken at
organization levels including:
• Continued development of responsible fishing systems for inland and
marine capture fisheries incorporating principles of bycatch reduction,
protection of biodiversity, minimization of environmental impacts and
energy conservation.
• Standardisation of craft-gear combinations in terms of fishing power
and capacities.
• Development and standardisation of processing technologies for
emerging species from aquaculture and less utilized species from
inland and marine capture fisheries.
• Continued development of processes for utilization of processing
waste and low value bycatch for isolation of novel potentially
commercial products.
• Continued development of appropriate packaging technologies for
improvement of consumer appeal and better storage.
• Developing food safety standards for the domestic market along the
value chain and standards for processes and products.
• Rapid techniques for identification of hazards and surveillance of
aquatic systems.
• Extraction and characterization of bio-molecules and genes for
therapeutically and industrially significant biological activities,
including anti-inflammatory, antiviral, anti-bacterial, anti-oxidant and
anticoagulant activities.
• Use of bio-molecules for bioremediation of polluted aquatic
ecosystems
99
There shall be focus on efficient technology transfer and policy analysis for:
• Developing innovative models for technology transfer based on need
evaluation and impact assessment.
• Technology incubation
• IP management
• Sectoral level analysis of impacts of policies
Recommendations
Focus areas of development for aquaculture sector are given below:
• Environment friendly and cost effective technologies
• Diversification of species and systems
• Comprehensive health management plans and infrastrucutre
• Faster growth and increased disease resistance
• Utilization of brackishwater resources
• Socio-economic analysis and support to policy and planning
100
c) Increase awareness of farmers and aquaculture industry about
environment, food safety and social equity issues and at the same
time educate public about the positive aspects of aquaculture and
fish as health food
2. Carry out strategic research to tackle emerging problems of brackish
water aquaculture and to strengthen the capacity of key stakeholders to
address the various issues that are likely to be confronted.
a) Preparedness on emerging diseases and advice the development
and regulatory departments to address risks
b) Assess the climate change impacts and increase the capacity of
farmers to adapt to climate change and develop policy initiatives
which help in adaptation and mitigation of negative impacts
c) Evaluate risks due to intensification of culture practices and
develop an action plan to be implemented by the state
3. Invest in areas of research to utilize emerging opportunities and
develop linkages for effective utilization of the research outputs.
a) Carry out research on genomics of candidate species and ensure
that these results are used in captive breeding, increased growth,
enhanced disease resistance and better utilization of feed nutrients
b) Enhance capacity to use biotechnology tools to address difficult to
solve problems of captive maturation and disease threats
c) Develop linkages with universities and industry partners for
promoting work on basic and strategic aspects to fill knowledge
gaps
4. Partnership with other institutions, large integrated brackishwater
aquaculture projects in private and public sector, entrepreneurs and
innovative farmers to augment the existing capacity for broodstock and
farm testing facilities, scaling up and for commercialization of products.
a) Carry out on-farm research under a project mode with other
institutions, large integrated brackishwater aquaculture projects in
private and public sector, entrepreneurs and innovative farmers
b) Commercialize products in partnership with entrepreneurs
c) Develop a consultative mechanism with stakeholders for tracking
and responding to recent developments in hatcheries and farmer
ponds
5. Ensure that stakeholder needs and impact assessment set the agenda for
research and awareness building.
101
a) Strengthen Priority Setting Process, Evaluation and Monitoring
process to undertake multi disciplinary and multi institutional
research projects
b) Increase our capacity for carrying out risk and impact assessment
c) Increase awareness levels among stakeholders on research outputs.
Conclusion
• Pakistan is endowed with considerable quantity of resources i.e. 0.29
million sq km of marine with 1120 km long coastline and
approximately 8.6 million ha of inland waters.
• Pakistan possesses seafood industry of worth about $1.2 billion of
which exports alone are worth nearly $315 million per annum. About
one million people are associated with the industry for their livelihood
directly or indirectly.
102
• With the exception of trout culture in KPK and the northern region,
virtually all aquaculture currently carried out in Pakistan is pond
culture of various carp species. Carp are cultured in earthen ponds,
using mostly extensive farming practices with very little inputs.
• Marine fisheries exclusively depend upon capture fisheries.
• About 50 % of the total production is consumed locally, 22% is
exported whereas 28% is converted into fish meal for poultry industry.
• Human resource is single most critical area of concern in the fisheries
sector of Pakistan. Only research program of PARC exists for
aquaculture sector and that too is limited by human resources. The
worst part of the scenario is that there is almost no research system
either at the institutional level or at the enterprise level which could
cater the needs of the fisheries industry.
• Global fish production was around 184 million tons of which 49%
comes from Aquaculture (2012).
• Unrestricted access to fisheries resources has resulted in over
exploitation of natural stocks. Fishermen are using destructive fishing
gears in greed of more fish and they have contributed in stock
depletion.
• Pakistan has more than 50 fish processing plants, which mostly clean
and freeze fish for international buyers, out of these only 2 plants have
permission to export their fish to EU countries.
• The maintenance of quality system in Pakistan has been found to have
flaws and contamination levels are high on board the fishing vessels,
landing docks and auction halls. On-shore handling also falls below
the basic sanitary and health standards, the auction halls are equally
unsanitary. Storages constructed near the auction halls for storing
unsold fish exhibit similar unsanitary conditions.
• Technological advances that improve information and management
methods are now required. Satellite remote sensing and other
information technologies can help provide better information about
wild fish stocks as well as help monitor fishing activity and improve
consumer information about the condition and origin of fish products.
Technology is also crucial to avoiding the environmental damage and
waste caused by certain fishing practices.
• Genetic modification and biotechnology also hold tremendous
potential to improve the quality and quantity of fish reared in
aquaculture.
103
• Most of the culture practices in Pakistan are still based on extensive
culture, but with the establishment of few feed mills, the semi intensive
farming practices have been started on limited scale, to boosts this
process substantial investment is required in raising awareness and
extending financing to fish farmers.
• The main issues of the Fisheries sector includes Weak institutional
management and capacities for strategic planning and implementation,
unknown fisheries stock carrying capacity, high post-harvest losses,
low quality of fish/fisheries products etc.
• The main issues of the aquaculture sector includes lack of
diversification in species and systems, high input cost, low technology
adoption, weak institutional support etc.
• Strategy to develop fisheries sector includes development of
responsible fishing systems for inland and marine capture fisheries
incorporating principles of bycatch reduction, protection of
biodiversity, minimization of environmental impacts and energy
conservation. Developing food safety standards for the domestic
market along the value chain and standards for processes and
products. Development of ‘green fishing vessels’ with built-in energy
saving design features, fuel saving technologies and practices for
existing fleet and alternate sources of energy for propulsion of fishing
vessels and onboard fish processing. There shall be need for capacity
building of stakeholders in public and private sector.
• Strategy to develop aquaculture sector includes environment friendly
and cost effective technologies, ddiversification of species and systems,
utilization of brackish-water resources. Increase awareness of farmers
and aquaculture industry about environment, food safety and social
equity issues and at the same time educate public about the positive
aspects of aquaculture and fish as health food.
References
Aftab, Z., Ali, C.L., Khan, A.M., Robinson, A., Irsad, I.A. 2000. Industrial policy and
environment in Pakistan. Industrial Policy and Environment
(NC/PAK/97/018). United Nations Industrial Development Organisation
(UNIDO).
Agricultural Development Bank, 2005. Agricultural Growth and Rural Poverty: A
Review of the Evidence. Islamabad: Asian Development Bank, Pakistan
Resident Mission.
Akhtar, N. 2001. Strategic Planning for inland fisheries and aquaculture sector in
Pakistan. In proceeding of National Seminar on strategic planning for
104
Fisheries and Aquaculture to face the challenges of new Millennium. May 28,
2001 Karachi.
Anderson, J. L. 2003. The International Seafood Trade. Cambridge, U.K., Woodhead
Publishing Ltd.
Arnason, R., Kelleher, K., Willmann, R. 2009. The Sunken Billions: The Economic
Justifi cation for Fisheries Reform. Washington, DC: World Bank.
Asche, F. 2011. Green Growth in Fisheries and Aquaculture Production and Trade.
Department of Industrial Economics, University of Stavenger, Norway.
Ayyappan, S. 2012. Indian Fisheries on a Fast Tract. The Economic Times (New
Delhi, India), September 28.
Badjeck, M., Katikiro, R.E., Flitner, M., Diop, N., Schwerdtner, M. K. 2011.
Envisioning 2050: Climate Change, Aquaculture and Fisheries in West Africa.
Dakar, Senegal 14-16th April 2010. Workshop Report No. 2011-09.
Penang/Bremen: WorldFish/ZMT.
Bhatti, Z. 2012. The fisheries and aquaculture sector of Pakistan. INFOFISH
International 5/2012.
Blinch, J., McCarron, E., Yewdall, K. 2011. The future of fish in Asia. Responsible
Research 2011, Issues for Responsible Investors. Responsible Research Pte ltd,
Como House 4th Floor, 6B Orange Grove Road, Singapore 258332.
Bostock, J. C., McAndrew, B., Richards, R., Jauncey, K., Telfer, T. C., Lorenzen, K.,
Little, D. C., Ross, L. G., Handisyde, N., Gatward, I. and Corner, R. 2010.
Aquaculture: global status and trends. Philosophical transactions of the royal
society B 365: 2897-2912.
Brown, L. 2000. Fish farming may soon overtake cattle ranching as a food source.
Worldwatch Issue Alerts. Washington, D.C.
Brugère, C., Ridler, N. 2004. Global aquaculture outlook in the next decades: an
analysis of national aquaculture production forecast to 2030. FAO Fisheries
Circular No. 1001. FAO: 47 pp.
Cao, L, Diana J.S, Keoleian, G,A, Lai, Q. 2011. Life cycle assessment of Chinese
shrimp farming systems targeted for export and domestic sales.
Environmental Science and Technology 45: 6531–6538.
Cao, L., Wang, W., Yang, Y., Yang, C., Yuan, Z., Xiong, S. and Diana, J. 2007.
Environmental impact of aquaculure and contermeasures to aquaculture
pollution in China. Environmental Science and Pollution Resource 14(7): 452-
462.
Cheung, W., Lam, V., Sarmineto, J., Kearney, K., Watson, R., Pauly, D. 2009.
Projecting global marine biodiversity impacts under climate change scenarios.
Fish and Fisheries 10: 235-251.
Christensen, V., Walters, C.J. 2004b. Trade-Off s in Ecosystem-Scale Optimization of
Fisheries Management Policies. Bulletin of Marine Science 74 (3): 549–62.
105
Costa-Pierce, B.A., Henry, L., Doherty, G. 2002. Ecological Aquaculture: The
Evolution of the Blue Revolution. A Shared Vision for Marine
Programs.University of New England, Marine Centre.
Costello, C., Ovando, D., Hilborn, R., Gaines, S.D., Deschenes, O., Lester, S.E. 2012.
Status and Solutions for the World’s Unassessed Fisheries. Science 338 (6106):
517–20.
Delgado, C.L., Wada, N., Rosegrant, M.W., Meijer, S., Ahmed, M. 2003. Outlook for
Fish to 2020 Meeting Global Demand. International Food Policy Research
Institute; WorldFish Center. Washington, D.C.; Penang, Malaysia.
FAO 2003. Investment potential on inland fisheries and freshwater aquaculture
project (UTF/PAK/ 092). Report No. 03/063 CP-PAK.
FAO 2005. Aquaculture production, 2004. Year book of Fishery Statistics - Vol.96/2.
Food and Agriculture organization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy.
Government of Pakistan 2005. Overview: Medium Term Development Framework
2005-10.
Hall, M. A., Alverson, D.I., Metuzals, K.I. 2000. By-catch: problems and solutions.
Marine Pollution Bulletin, 41, 204– 219.
Khan, S.R., Khan, S.R. 2009. Assessing poverty-deforestation links: evidence from
Swat, Pakistan. Ecological economics, 68 (10), 2607–2618.
Mason, C.F. 2002. The Biology of Freshwater Pollution. Prentice Hall, New Jersey
Melba, R. 2005. Coastal Areas of Sindh- Assistance for Project Formulation.
Unpublished report.
Sultana, G. 2004. Strengthening of fish handling, processing and quality assurance.
FAO, TCP/PAK/ 2904-A.
Verschuren, D., Johnson, T.C., Kling, H.J., Edgington, D.N., Leavitt, P.R., Brown,
E.T., Talbot, M.R., Hecky, R.E. 2002. History and timing of human impact on
Lake Victoria, East Africa. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series
B – Biological Sciences, 269, 289–294.
106
Chapter 6
Shafiya Naeem
Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture, The Maldives
[email protected]
Aquaculture Scenario
The Maldives’ aquaculture industry is still in its infancy. At present, only
one commercial aquaculture venture is in operation, with a total annual
aquaculture production of approximately 144 MT of sandfish (Holothuria
scabra) targeted at the export market. This amounts to approximately 7 MT
of dried sandfish exported mainly to China, and an additional 250,000
pieces of live juveniles exported to Sri Lanka biannually (Barakathul Bakhr
Pvt. Ltd., Pers. Comm).
The Government of Maldives recognizes potential for the country to
develop a thriving aquaculture industry, mainly based on high-valued
marine food fish targeting export markets. To this end, a 5-year mariculture
enterprise development project, with financial assistance from the
International Fund for Agriculture Development (IFAD), has been working
with 150 beneficiaries selected from the south of Maldives in piloting
commercial sandfish grow out businesses at the community level (Republic
of Malives: Mariculture Enterprise Development Project (MEDeP) Design
completion report, 2012). In addition, a World Bank funded project is
underway, with a major mariculture component focusing on the
establishment of a multi-species hatchery and the development of research
and extension capacity within the Government of Maldives (The World
Bank, 2017) Maldivian Government is also investing in establishing capacity
to produce milkfish (Chanos chanos) as live bait for the Maldivian pole-and-
line tuna fishery.
Prospects of Aquaculture
Maldives has immense potential for the development of marine aquaculture
activities. The geographic expanse of the country provides marine areas
with a variety of features upon which aquaculture of some high valued
marine species could be developed.
While the development of land-based aquaculture facilities is possible, such
development may be hindered by the limited availability of land. It is
107
expected that the establishment of land-based facilities will be limited,
mainly, to hatcheries and nurseries, while the grow-out phases will be
focused more on marine waters with desirable features for the species of
interest.
The key species of aquaculture interest at the moment include the high-
valued sea cucumber species, sandfish (Holothuria scabra), brown marbled
grouper (Epinephelus fuscoguttatus) and milkfish (Chanos chanos). While
locally fished groupers and sea cucumbers have an existing export market,
milkfish is a new product of which the production is targeted at
supplementing live bait for local pole-and-line tuna fishery. It is expected
that most aquaculture development will be of export-market oriented, high-
valued food fish species.
108
Issues and Challenges in Aquaculture
As the aquaculture industry is still in its infancy in the Maldives, and not
many commercial aquaculture ventures are in operation at present, the
country is faced with investor reluctance to enter into this undemonstrated
business. In addition, as a country that has relied extensively on wild
fisheries for which the investment returns are very quick, a business such
like aquaculture for which the return on investment is usually longer is not
an attractive business option for the smaller scale operators. However, there
is emerging interest among larger investors to enter into this business at
present.
One other major challenge in aquaculture development in the Maldives is
the lack of availability of seed stock for starting up an aquaculture venture.
There is interest among local communities to engage in the grow out
process of high-valued marine species, but to date, only one commercial
hatchery is in operation. Recognising this gap, the Maldivian Government,
with assistance from the World Bank is in the process of developing a multi-
species hatchery, initially focusing on the brown marbled grouper and
milkfish production. In addition, the Mariculture Enterprise Development
Project is working on linking locals with the existing hatchery operation to
source seed stock for their grow-out production.
Further, the lack of human capacity is also an issue with developing an
aquaculture sector in the Maldives. Apart from a few, the Maldives lacks
trained, technically capable individuals in this field. If responsible
aquaculture was to develop in the Maldives, human resource development
in this field is necessary.
Environmental issues
Maldives has a global reputation for its serene marine environments. The
development of marine aquaculture in the country may result in negatively
impacting this reputation, if not carried out in an environmentally
responsible manner. Marine based aquaculture activities may contribute to
increasing nutrient load in the waters as well as alteration of the cage-
bottom diversity resulting from increased feed inputs. In addition,
mariculture development will also carry the risk of disease spread within
the cultured populations as well as transmitting those to wild populations.
In order to reduce the concerning environmental issues arising from
mariculture development, the country chooses to adopt a precautionary
approach to aquaculture development. Measures are taken to reduce
impacts on the environment include but are not limited to restrictions in
sourcing initial stock used and mandatory submission of environmental
impact assessments for aquaculture operations.
109
Figure 1. Sandfish (Holothuria scabra) production facility in Maldives. A & B: Inland
production systems. C: Pen within a saltwater pond for initial stocking in grow-out
ponds
110
Social issues
It is likely that social issues will arise as a result of the geographic spread of
the country, especially in relation to the distribution of seed stock from a
single central hatchery. However, the magnitude of social issues arising
from aquaculture development may be difficult to be estimated at this point.
As aquaculture development will result in the creation of new employment
opportunities, this development is at present seen as a positive change.
111
Issues related to export of aquaculture products
It is expected that aquaculture, at least during the initial stages, will be
developed exclusively targeting the high-value export markets. Thus, issues
relating to export of aquaculture products are likely to arise, although the
magnitude of these issues are difficult to estimate.
The grouper production will target the live reef fish trade in the Far Eastern
countries, and as such, there will be a requirement for establishing basic
testing capacity for aquacultured food organisms. The Ministry of Fisheries
is in the process of establishing an Aquatic Animal Health Laboratory
facility to address the requirement for diagnosis of aquatic animal diseases.
An unrelated issue, but one which is equally as important is the fact that
operating an aquaculture venture in the Maldives will be more expensive
than a similar operation in other countries within the region. As a result,
Maldivian aquaculture production may be sensitive to price fluctuations
and economic situations in the major importers of Maldivian products.
112
the import of live aquaculture organisms vary based on the results of
a risk assessment.
• Regular monitoring and reporting of effects on the natural
environment will be made mandatory when the aquaculture
regulation comes into effect.
• Feeding and feed management: feeding practices and feed
management measures shall be monitored to ensure adequate feeds
are provided to the culture animals both in terms of quantity and
quality of feed.
Further, new farmers need to be educated on best aquaculture practices for
the sustainability of this new sector in the Maldives.
113
MoFA is responsible for monitoring and evaluation of all licensed
aquaculture projects, and decisions on the licenses issued based on the
performance of the projects. Import of live organisms for aquaculture is also
regulated by MoFA. MoFA is in the process of establishing an aquatic
animal quarantine facility at the airport to provide quarantine services for
importers of live aquatics. An aquatic animal disease diagnostics facility
that will provide basic diagnostic services for farmers, is also to be
established.
Maldives Food and Drug Authority (MFDA) is responsible for ensuring the
all public health and food safety criteria for aquacultured products. MFDA
also issues the necessary certification ensuring food safety and hygienic
production, which is required for exportation of aquaculture products.
Recommendations
The major reasons, amongst others, for the lack of development of
aquaculture are lack of demonstration of successful aquaculture businesses,
investor reluctance to invest in aquaculture, lack of a reliable supply of seed
and a general limitation in technical expertise in the field. In order for an
aquaculture industry to be developed in the Maldives, it is recommended
that the Government invests in a hatchery as well as human resources
required for a sector at the initial phase of development. Financing options
for aquaculture ventures is expected to increase as the investor confidence
in the sector is increased through demonstration of viable aquaculture
businesses and development of human resource capacity required for sector
development. In addition, research and development followed by effective
extension of technology is required for target aquaculture species.
Conclusion
Aquaculture development in the Maldives is still at its infancy, despite
efforts to develop a striving aquaculture industry in the Maldives. To date,
only one commercial aquaculture venture is in operation in the Maldives,
producing approximately 7 MT of dried sea cucumbers annually, targeting
export markets. In addition, the Government of Maldives is investing in
developing aquaculture, particularly of high-valued food fish for export
markets as well as live bait for the local pole-and-line tuna fishery. The
major reasons, amongst others, for the lack of development of the sector are
lack of demonstration of successful aquaculture businesses, investor
114
reluctance to invest in aquaculture, lack of a reliable supply of seed and a
general limitation in technical expertise in the field. In order for an
aquaculture industry to be developed in the Maldives, it is recommended
that the Government invests in a hatchery as well as human resources
required for a sector at the initial phase of development. Financing options
for aquaculture ventures is expected to increase as the investor confidence
in the sector is increased through demonstration of viable aquaculture
businesses and development of human resource capacity required for sector
development.
References
Republic of Malives, 2012. Mariculture Enterprise Development Project (MEDeP)
Design completion report.
The World Bank, 2017. Sustainable Fisheries Resources Development Project (Fourth
South West Indian Ocean Fisheries Governance and Shared Growth Project),
Projects and Operations. Available at: http://projects.worldbank.org/
P157801?lang=en (Accessed: 1 September 2017).
115
Chapter 7
117
Bangladesh has diversified fisheries resources with 0.794 million hector
inland closed water body (Pond, Baor, Dighi etc.) and 3.92 million hector
inland open water body (rivers, haor, beel, flood plain, kaptai lake etc.).
It has the vast 710 km long coast line with 12 nautical miles territorial
marine water-body from the shore while 1,18,813 square kilometer maritime
boundary and 710 kilometer coastline.
In the inland water bodies there are about 260 fresh water indigenous fish
species, 12 exotic fish species and 24 species of fresh water shrimp species.
The country has diversified marine fisheries resources viz., finfish 475
species, sharks, rays/skates, dolphin 21 species, shrimp 36 species, lobster 6
species, crabs 16species, sea turtle 3 species, crocodiles 3 species, squid &
others fish 7 species, shellfish (univalves & bivalves) 350species and
seaweeds 165 species.
Since last two and half decades, significant growth rates in fisheries
production have been achieved by expansion of closed water aquaculture
through the intervention of production technologies and adoption of
community based fisheries management for conservation and sustainable
exploration of open water fisheries resources. During 1990s and 2000s along
with National Fisheries Policy and Strategy framework, lots of efforts were
made to increase the fish production for ensuring the nutritional security of
ever increasing population. Recently, emphasis is also being given on food
safety and quality standards of fish production in line with environmental
sustainability in compliance to the national requirement and increase access
to global market, addressing the traceability and health hazards related
issues.
Aquaculture in Bangladesh is mainly confined to the freshwater closed
water bodies viz., ponds, lakes, baor, creeks etc. Freshwater aquaculture
involves pond aquaculture especially the poly-culture of native and exotic
species. Intensification of aquaculture during last two decades has greatly
contributed to the country’s fish production. At the same time care was also
taken for food safety and quality issues across the aquaculture fish value
chain to comply the food safety standards giving priority of public health
issues for the domestic as well as international consumers.
118
Figure 6. Resource wise fisheries production of Bangladesh from 1997-2006 (DoF
2006).
Attempts are also made to utilize the vast seasonal water bodies viz. flood
plains, fellow rice fields, beels, canals and natural depressions for extensive
aquaculture involving community based fisheries management by CBOs. To
take care of biodiversity and natural resources conservations many
biological management interventions are introduced in inland open water
by habitat restoration, creating fish sanctuaries, beel nursery and continuing
regular stocking of selected major and minor fish species (SIS) to ensure
availability of small indigenous species along with increased productivity.
Such improve/extensive aquaculture efforts ultimately compensated the
gradual declining catch from the open water fisheries and also motivated
peoples to switch over in to semi-intensive farm practices with attractive
economic return and benefit-cost ratio than that of other agricultural sub-
sectors.
Prospects of Aquaculture
Inland water resources
Inland fresh water fisheries resources include a number of rivers, estuaries,
beels, haors, lakes, reservoirs and seasonal flood-plains covering over 3.918
million ha. Besides, about 8.0 million ha of inundated rice fields around the
country where 3.0 million ha remain under water for 4-6 month having
unique ecological suitability for fish and shrimp aquaculture with
concurrent or rotational cropping (DoF 2016). These open, semi-closed or
seasonal fresh water resources provide suitable natural habitats for
numerous wild fish and shellfish species. Aquaculture is now practiced in
more than 372405 ha freshwater ponds and 2,75,509 ha coastal shrimp farm
119
areas (DoF 2016). Aquaculture production has increased about 8 times
during the last two decades. Large areas suitable for aquaculture still
remain underutilized and have a good potential of increasing aquaculture
production further in a cost effective way. Open fresh water resources also
have potential for increasing fisheries production, employment generation,
export promotion and maintaining biodiversity.
The Community Based Fisheries Management (CBFM) project was founded
with an ambition to promote sustainable use of inland capture fisheries by
empowering fisher's communities to manage their own aquatic resources.
Most fishers in rural Bangladesh operate on a small-scale basis. Poor fishers
suffer disadvantaged situations due policies that favor powerful players in
the sector. The CBFM initiative has developed a series of fisheries
management approaches for ensuring equitable access to fisheries resources
for community-based organisations (CBOs). Founded in 1994, the project
supported by Department for International Development (DFID) and
implemented by Bangladesh's Department of Fisheries (DoF) in partnership
with the WorldFish Center and 11 NGOs adopted a research-based
approach to promote equitable access and sustainable management of
inland fisheries resources and to be run by the CBOs. So far, a total of 164
fish sanctuaries have been established in over 80 water bodies under the
CBFM approach. The project involved 14,000 CBO group members and a
further 9,000 direct beneficiaries. The majority of CBOs reported increases in
total production despite a 30 per cent increase in the number of fishers by
then. Thus it appears that community-based fisheries management can offer
significantly better utilization of the public water bodies covering over 4
million ha of floodplain wetlands in the country.
120
Bangladesh is considered one of the most suitable countries in the world for
prawn and shrimp farming, Because of its vast resources of shallow water
bodies which provide a unique opportunity for prawn and shrimp
production. Prawn farming has brought about dramatic improvements in
the livelihoods of the coastal poor, including women. During the 1990s, the
rapid development of prawn farming in southwest Bangladesh has been
likened to a "Blue revolution”. The migration of poor communities form the
coastal region to the urban areas has reduced thanks to improved livelihood
opportunities brought about by prawn and shrimp culture.
Fisheries in Bangladesh are diverse and there are about 795 native species of
fish and shrimp in the fresh and marine waters. Besides that, there are 10
species of pearl bearing bivalves, 12 species of edible tortoise and turtle, 15
species of crab and 3 species of lobster. Most of the prawn and shrimp farms
(~75% ) are located in southwest part of the country, mainly Bagerhat,
Khulna and Satkhira districts, with the remainders in the southeast region
including Cox's Bazar and Noakhali district. In 2003, more than 0.6 m
people are engaged in shrimp farming activities.
121
Scope of Marine Aquaculture and future intervention policy
There is enormous scope in Bangladesh for horizontal as well as vertical
expansion of aquaculture at coastal belt. Extensive shrimp culture is
traditionally practiced in the country and recently few shrimp hatcheries are
established. Since last 3 decades very limited initiatives are taken on coastal
aquaculture either by the private sector or by the government bodies like
Department of Fisheries (DoF) and Bangladesh Fisheries Research Institute
(BFRI). Recently Government in collaboration with development partners
and private entrepreneurs planned to undertake larger programs
introducing coastal aquaculture with selective finfishes, mollusks, seaweeds
and some other important species to generate employment opportunity. The
main objectives of the coastal aquaculture initiatives are,
• Research and demonstration project to develop breeding techniques,
culture practice, safety and quality assurance of some selective
species Vetki (sea bass), mullet, persa, tengara, tilapia etc)
• AIG for the coastal fisher community/other stakeholders to
support/improve their livelihood, food security and social safety
• Generate investment and employment opportunity for private sector
enterprises
• Reduce/control artisanal fishing particularly, over fishing pressure in
the shoreline to protect/conserve important species to ensure
sustainable yields
• Motivate, aware poor fishers and other stakeholders to involve in
aquaculture value chain from harvest/catch to market/industry
• Prevent IUU, illegal shrimp seed collection and biodiversity
destruction,
• increase per capita fish protein intake by the poor groups,
• promote aquaculture of commercially important species as raw
materials for and feed export industry
• Organize environmentally sound, socially appreciated and cost
effective aquaculture production for home and abroad.
122
popularly referred to as "Mache Bhate Bangali" or "fish and rice makes a
Bengali".
The country also has a coastal area of 2.30 million ha and a coastline of 714
km along the Bay of Bengal, which supports a large artisanal and coastal
fisheries. Bangladesh is considered one of the most suitable countries in the
world for farming of freshwater prawn (Macrobrachium rosenbergii)
Bangladesh is one of the resourceful countries with its wide range of marine
aquatic bio-diversities. There are about 1093 marine aquatic organisms
where 44.35% are finfish, 32.23% shellfish, 15.10% seaweeds and only 8.32%
are other organisms including shrimps. Bangladesh has so far realized only
a fraction of its production potential.
Bangladesh has some 130 deep-sea fishing trawlers, 22000 mechanized
fishing boats, and 25000 non mechanized fishing boats. Currently there are
133 fish processing plants in Bangladesh which are mostly located in port
cities (Khulna and Chittagong) of which 74 processing plants are EU
approved.
Though the country is endowed with enormous fishery resources which are
vital to the livelihood of millions of people and national food and nutrition
security, the sector is facing major constraints including climate change,
poor fisheries infrastructure, resource mismanagement, water and
environmental population, natural disasters such as recurrent flood and
cyclones, and lack of knowledge among farmers. Bangladesh is working
with close collaboration with World Bank, USAID, ADB, Department for
International Development (DFID), World Fish Center and other
international organization to develop the sector by building research
partnerships and increasing investment.
123
Role of fish in diet
Fish is the primary source of animal protein for Bangladeshi population,
especially poor rural households. Fishes are the major source of animal
protein providing 60% of the animal protein intake and 7% of total protein
supplies. Rice and fish constitute such an important part of Bangladeshi
food culture that it has become a popular proverb- "mache bhate bangali,"
which means "fish and rice make a Bengali. In terms of weight, fish is the
third most widely consumed food nationwide. But consumption pattern
tends to vary among urban and rural areas and is shown to be lower among
female members. Per capita annual fish consumption in Bangladesh is about
14 kg against a recommended minimum requirement of 18 kg/year. From
the last national survey in rural Bangladesh, the mean total protein intake
was 48 g/person/d, of which fish contributed 3 g.
124
degradation, and extensive use of agrochemicals, all of which have had
serious negative impacts on fisheries production, there is an imperative felt
by agriculturists to find more sustainable strategies to reduce these negative
impacts. Bangladesh has seen a dramatic rise in national rice production.
Many watery areas have been brought under staple crop production to meet
the demand of the huge population. Though fish production has also
increased, but the its still far below the real potential of the country. Rice-
fish farming can boost the production of both items which will help the
country to improve food and nutrition security. The demand for rice and
fish is constantly rising in Bangladesh with nearly three million people
being added each year to its population. Integrated rice-fish farming can
help Bangladesh keep pace with the current demand for food through rice
and fish production.
Increasing population translates to increasing demand for food and more
pressure on land and water. If sustainable policies are not taken, rice
demand may continue to compromise fisheries output in Bangladesh.
Although official figures show that the number of floodplain fisheries
increased in the 1990s, after decreasing in the 1980s, it is widely held that
floodplain catches have been falling. Agricultural intensification has been
proposed by researchers to meet the rising food demand for the huge
population in Bangladesh. While rice production is still likely to increase, its
also possible that it'll come at the expense of diminishing resources for fish
production.
125
the absence of adaptation, increased frequency and intensity of cyclones and
floods would result in greater damage to fishing materials and loss of fish.
Mariculture is also at risk of increasing salinity and over-fishing. According
to FAO, globally, around a quarter of all fish stocks are overexploited and
half of them are fully exploited. In Bangladesh, marine capture represents
about 20% of total fish production. The floodplain and marine fisheries are
under serious threat from overfishing. Overexploitation in the coastal region
poses significant challenges on marine living resources and increases the
dependency on distant water fishing in the long run.
Besides these natural and chemical events, inadequate financial capacities,
poor resources management and lack of research facilities are also
responsible for underperformance of the fisheries sector and environmental
degradation. Researchers have shown that poor management of prawn and
shrimp culture is having devastating effects on the Sundarbans (the largest
mangrove forest in the world) where an estimated 9700 ha of the forest-
mass has been lost as a result of intense shrimp farming. Conversion of
many natural wetlands to prawn farms has resulted in impediment of water
flows and also decreased the scope of migration for many fish species.
The fisheries sector of Bangladesh is vulnerable to numerous natural and
anthropogenic causes such as,
Climate Change
It is an emerging issue for Bangladesh like other countries. Fish production
and breeding season duration is decreasing gradually in inland open
waters. To adapt to the climate change impacts different mitigation
strategies are followed in aquaculture viz. stocking of fast growing fish,
fishes which have market value even they are small in size, stocking of
larger size fingerlings and lowering stocking density, supplying safe quality
and cost-effctive supplementary feeds (floating feed) and adopting GAqP as
much as possible.
Imbalanced Urbanization
Unplanned and imbalanced urbanization is going fast in Bangladesh. Huge
area of water bodies are converted in to residential area, canals and others
fish migratory routes are embarked and obstructed in many cases which
ultimately affect fish production. Poor urban and industrial management
and lack of enforcement of environmental laws are contributing to this
pollution spree.
126
Industrialization versus environmental degradation causing fish habitat
destructions
Water pollution is another growing threat for the future of fisheries sector in
Bangladesh and is fast becoming a serious public health issue and a
constraint for food production. Industrial (especially textile and tannery)
effluent, fertilizer and pesticide run-off, poor sewerage infrastructure and
improper disposal of household waste are the major causes of water
pollution in Bangladesh. Rivers and canals near the urban areas are
threatened by sedimentation and siltation due mainly to soil erosion, and
compounded by industrial expansion, most of these water bodies have
already become to polluted to support biological system. The Buriganga
river that flows through the capital city is the most polluted river in the
country, many parts of which have already turned coal black. Industrial
wastes are directly discharged to the river and different open or semi closed
water bodies without any pre-treatment. Waters bodies are getting heavily
polluted which directly plays negative role on fish production.
127
and technology is not advanced enough to produce good quality fish fillets
or other diversified fish products for export in the competitive international
market. Therefore, they could not able to utilize the available carp or catfish
raw materials for producing quality export products. As fish handling and
processing activities are quite limited in the industry, the workers could not
increase their skills, efficiency and experience. On the other hand, the
dependence of all processing plants on shrimp results in a shortage of raw
materials and finally limits the utilisation of the processing factories. This
situation also enhances competition for raw materials and to some extent
the processing plant owners collect shrimp ignoring quality aspects and
finally fail to get the expected price in the competitive market. Even such
quality compromises may create future image problem in the strictly
regulated export market for Bangladesh. About 50% of the leading
processing industries have good technical, management capabilities and
regulatory compliance to the export market but they are now not running
well due to lack of raw materials (Pichler 2007). Out of 133 shrimp/fish
processing plants 73 are maintaining International Food Standard (IFS)
graded (>90% QM Score) and have EU licenses for the export of shrimp and
fish (DoF 2007). To sustain the small and large factories, their economically
feasible utilisation must be ensured. There are no other alternatives but for
them to develop technological and management efficiency for handling and
processing available carps, catfish and other fishes as raw materials to
utilise the existing processing facilities. The supply of these fish to the
factories can be easily increased in Bangladesh, which might not be equally
possible for shrimps in a cost effective way.
Illegal Fishing
There are some illegal nets used for fishing in Bangladesh. Such nets are
locally called Current net (monofilament nets) and behundi net (set bag net)
etc. The mono-filamentous, transparent synthetic nets of different mesh size
seriously destructive to the juvenile Hilsha (Jatka) and other important open
water species directly by gilling during their movement. The set bag net is
destroying the SIS species in flowing waters i.e. rivers and coastal areas. The
uses of such nets are strictly prohibited by the laws and regulations.
Government is giving maximum efforts to control the production, storage or
uses of such nets. However, due to lack of implementation of rules,
regulations and other associated socio political problems, still some illegal
fishing happening in open water resources.
128
Open water management policy
In Bangladesh all the open water belong to the Ministry of Land but the
beneficiaries or users of these water bodies belong to the Ministry of
Fisheries and Livestock. Open water bodies are administratively controlled
and leased by the Land Ministry and they are mostly emphasized on
revenue earning rather than biological management system which is the
mandate of DoF.
Innovations in shrimp Aquaculture
The modern techniques viz., cluster farming, increasing the water depth in
ghers (at least 1 meter depth), nursery rising with PCR tested PL and use of
GAqP/GHP/GMP are introduced in shrimp aquaculture recently.
129
Social issues and resource use conflicts
• Obstruction of common property wetlands and flowing rivers and
canals for aquaculture.
• Salt water intrusion in agricultural lands affecting agricultural crops.
• Unauthorized use of others’ land.
• Using child labour.
Traceability
Lack of proper documentation of all aspects of the value chain.
In the context of Bangladesh, the points that are more frequently raised in
connection with coastal aquaculture of the shrimp are the following:
• Legal ownership of the farm – Regulatory
• Social conflicts on the use of common properties viz., water usage
conflicts and agricultural land use conflicts
• Conflicts between the rice farmers and shrimp farmers
• Environmental degradation
• Labour law violations
• Use of hazardous chemicals in aquaculture risking food and feed
safety
130
The Codes are intended to promote aquaculture production which meets
international food safety standards, is sustainable, ecologically sound and
socially responsible.
BSFF, in collaboration with DoF, has prepared Codes of Conduct for the
following segments of the shrimp industry:
• Black tiger or Bagda shrimp (Penaeus monodon) hatchery
• Galda shrimp (Macrobrachium) hatchery
• Black tiger or Bagda shrimp (Penaeus monodon) farm
• Galda shrimp (Macrobrachium) farm
• Shrimp / Fish feed mill
• Shrimp collection and service centre or depot
• Ice plants
• Fishing boats
• Shrimp or fish carrier transport van / vessel
Preparations of the above Codes have been based on the review of the
following documents:
131
g) Regulation (EC) No 1334/2008 on flavoring and certain food
ingredients with flavoring properties
h) Regulation (EC) 854/2004 laying down specific rules for the
organization of official controls on products of animal origin
intended for human consumption
i) Commission Regulation (EC) 1251/2008 implementing Council
Directive 2006/88/EC as regards conditions and certification
requirements for the placing on the market and the import into the
Community of aquaculture animals and products thereof and laying
down a list of vector species
j) Commission Regulation (EC) 2074/2005 laying down implementing
measures for certain products under Regulation (EC) 853/2004 of the
European Parliament and of the Council and for the organisation of
official controls under Regulation (EC) 854/2004 of the European
Parliament and of the Council and Regulation (EC) 882/2004 of the
European Parliament and of the Council, derogating from Regulation
(EC) 852/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council and
amending Regulations (EC) 853/2004 and (EC) 854/2004
k) Council Directive 97/78/EC laying down the principles governing the
organization of veterinary checks on products entering the
Community from third countries
l) Council Regulation (EC) 1005/2008 establishing a Community system
to prevent, deter and eliminate illegal, unreported and unregulated
fishing
m) Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 concerning the Registration,
Evaluation, Authorization and Restriction of Chemicals
132
12. Thailand Department of Fisheries Code of Conduct (COC) and Good
Aquaculture Practices (GAP) Program.
There are several Acts, rules, regulations, directives and Codes of Conducts
(CoC) in Bangladesh for the development of Aquaculture. The summarize
features of some important Fish Acts and Regulations are as follows:
133
• Immediate after breeding season, during parental care period of
natural species, it is strictly prohibited to catch any parents or
spawn/juveniles.
4. Codes of Conduct for Shrimp sector involved in the shrimp value chain
• For selected 10 segments of the shrimp Aquaculture industry in
Bangladesh
• Black Tiger or Bagda Shrimp (Penaeusmonodon) Hatchery
• Galda Shrimp (Macrobrachium) Hatchery
• Black Tiger or Bagda Shrimp (Penaeusmonodon) Farm
• Galda Shrimp (Macrobrachium) Farms
• Feed Mill
• Shrimp Collection and Service Centre / Depot
• Ice Plants
• Fishing Boats and Vessels
• Shrimp or Fish Carrier Transport Van
• Code of Conduct for Fish / Shrimp Processing Plant
5. Fish and Fish Product Inspection and Quality Control Act 1985, 2008 and
proposed 2013
• Any fish and fish products which quality and safety parameters are
not fulfilling the standard criteria settled in law and may affect
public health should/ must not be produce, transport, storage,
handling or marketing for human consumption or any intentional
use that have risk of health hazards.
• Input suppliers, producers, handlers and marketing stakeholders
must follow the Codes of Conduct and implement GAqP, GHP and
GMP through the fish value chain to ensure safe food production
and consumption.
• Violation of any instructed CoC, or legal procedure may impose
punishment of any stakeholders in the Fish/Shrimp value chain
134
fisheries sector in the country. Bangladesh is working in close collaboration
with Department for International Development (DFID), FAO-UN, USAID,
USFDA, EU, World Bank, OIC, JICA, World Fish, SAARC and other
international organization to develop the sector by building research
partnerships and increasing investment for resources utilization.
Mandate of DoF
The Department of Fisheries serves through its following wings-
1. Inland Fisheries
2. Marine Fisheries
3. Fisheries Resource Survey System
4. Fish Inspection and Quality Control ,
5. and Training
Extension Service
• Provide technical know-how to the farmers through training and
advice on aquaculture and management.
• Dissemination of modern technology on aquaculture, fisheries
management, hatchery operation, etc.
• Render advisory services to provide credit on fisheries.
• Implementation of development projects to support farmers &
fishers.
135
• Enforcement of Fish and Fish Products (Inspection and Quality
Control) Rules
Policy Framework
• Advising the Government in formulating policies related to
aquaculture and aquatic resource management.
• Collection of data on fisheries and its compilation, editing and
publication.
• Planning, Formulation, Implementation, Monitoring and Evaluation
of Development projects.
Recommendations
• Resource identification and utilization of blue Bangladesh.
• Minimization of Fish feed and seed cost.
• Collaborative research and management protocol on emerging
issues, such as- marine fisheries resources management and
136
expansion of coastal aquaculture as well as on climate change
impacts on fisheries resources.
• Infrastructure development to promote sustainable aquaculture
practices (viz., Fish landing center, market development etc.)
• Hatchery development for potential coastal/marine finfish (for ex.,
Lates calcarifer)
• Dissemination of adaptive technologies (especially shrimp, prawn,
tilapia and pangus) in ecologically constrained/ coastal areas.
• Popularization cage culture technology in coastal areas
• Stock assessment of marine resources
• Ensure adequate safety measures and early warning system for
fishers
• Increase utilization of fisheries resources, development of
diversified fisheries products for promotion of national and
international market.
• Improvement of supply chain/marketing system
• Institutional Capacity Building through
- community based fish culture;
- stocking of fingerlings;
- establishment of Sanctuaries,
- beel nurseries,
- creek development for hill area;
- smart ID card for real fishers;
- pen culture,
- cage culture;
• Spillway construction etc.
• Recruitment of Field Staff at rural level (Field Assistant);
• Empowerment of DoF Officials towards different act
implementation
Conclusion
Aquaculture and fisheries being the very fast growing sector in Bangladesh
have high potential to contribute to the national economy. Bangladesh is
blessed with water resources, good soil and water, cheap labor force and
lots of culture-worthy fish species. Besides, as a lower middle income
country, Bangladesh has good possibility of investing more resources on it.
137
Proper planning and implementation strategy, logistic support and also
latest technology support from the neighboring countries can boost
aquaculture development of Bangladesh.
Following the self-sufficiency in crop sector, country is hoping to be self-
sufficient in fish very soon to reach the target of being a middle income
country.
Development of Fisheries Sector of Bangladesh depends on a bottom-up
process following on Vision-2021, 7th Five year Plan, SDG goals and targets
and Annual Development Plan ADP. Bangladesh has published its National
Fisheries Policy (1998), National Fisheries Strategy with eight sub-strategies
(2002) to cover different fields.
Reference
Annual Report, 2014. Department of Fisheries, Bangladesh, Ministry of Fisheries and
Livestock.
EU food and feed safety regulations
FAO Fish Stats, 2015
Fisheries Statistics in Bangladesh: Issues, Challenges and Plans – Published by
Department of Fisheries, Bangladesh
International Principles of Responsible Aquaculture UN/FAO/UNEP/World Bank-
Netherland funded WWF- 2003
US Food and Drug Administration food safety regulations
Year book of Fisheries Statistics of Bangladesh, 2015-16. Department of Fisheries,
Bangladesh, Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock.
138
Chapter 8
Namgay Dorji
National Research Centre for Aquacultre (Gelephu). Department of Livestock,
Ministry of Agriculture and Forests, Bhutan
[email protected]
Aquaculture Scenario
The mainstay of Bhutan’s aquaculture is warm-water carps which were
introduced into the country in the early 80s. Six species of carps are
presently cultivated in Bhutan: Common carp, Grass carp, Silver carp, Catla,
Rohu and Mrigal. Bhutan is also making efforts to develop rainbow trout
farming. In connection to this, a government fisheries agency is presently
conducting an adaptive rainbow trout production trial (Tshering, 2017).
Bhutan’s annual output of farmed fish is less than 200 MT, with that in 2016
being 188 MT (Department of Livestock, 2017). In sharp contrast, the
demand for fish in the country is massive, as indicated by an annual
consumption of over 3000 MT: In 2015 alone Bhutan consumed 3752 MT of
fish (wet weight equivalent). Since the domestic production of fish is
meager, the huge demand for it has to be met through import. This causes
huge amounts of foreign currencies to flow out of the country (as presented
in the table below).
Table 1. Fish production and import in Bhutan during 2010-2016.
Year Domestic output Fresh fish import Estimated Foreign Currency
(MT) (MT) Outflow (Million Rupees)
2010 23.12 830 41.50
2011 49.49 915 54.90
2012 64.32 1325.18 92.76
2013 54.661 1412.5 113
2014 119.09 1457.69 131.19
2015 149.10 1346 121.14
2016 187.63 1261 114.3
MT- Million Tonnes
Fish production activities are concentrated in the south where a majority of
the country’s available flatlands are. The rest of the country is mostly sloped
terrain, and so not readily amenable to excavating fish ponds. Also because
the available cultivable species- warm water carps- require warm climate to
139
grow well, fish farming in the country has been literally forced to flourish in
the south, as compared to the other regions, due to the suitable climate
there. Very few warm water farms are located in the higher altitude hilly
regions. These high altitude farmers do not generally cultivate the relatively
slow-growing rohu, mrigal and catla.
Small landholdings and strong wetland conservation laws preclude the
establishment of large commercial carp production systems on private
lands. As a way to work around these limitations, the government
encourages, and supports, the use of Government Reserve Forest (GRF)
land through leasing by farmers for commercial fish production. However,
state owned lands suitable for building large-scale commercial fish
production systems are scanty. Therefore, the likelihood of large
commercial-scale pond based fish production systems developing in Bhutan
in the foreseeable future is low.
With an annual harvest of about 7.8 mt, exploitation of wild fisheries
resources in Bhutan is virtually non-existent (Dorji, Impact of climate
change on coastal fisheries and aquaculture in Bhutan, 2017). Though
Bhutan is severely data deficient with regard to information on wild
fisheries diversity and stock abundance, it is more or less understood these
resources are limited and incapable of sustaining industrial scale
exploitation. Therefore, the likelihood of capture fisheries programs
contributing appreciably to the production of fish protein in the country is
very low.
Except for the exotic carps, aquatic organisms such as crustaceans, mollusks
and aquatic weeds are not cultured in Bhutan. Harvests of these organisms
for food purpose from the wild, if any, are also not reported.
In summary, the following can be said about the aquaculture sector in
Bhutan:
• The annual production of fish, including whatever little is harvested
from the wild, is less than 200 mt;
• Limited flatlands preclude the development of commercial-scale fish
production;
• Given the cultivable species available, short warm seasons preclude
appreciable production of fish in the hilly regions;
• Aquatic organisms such as crustaceans, mollusks and aquatic weeds
are not cultured;
• Farmers prefer to culture the relatively fast growing grass carp and
common carp. Thus, the slower growing rohu, catla and mrigal are
140
effectively rendered redundant. This further limits the options of
species that can be cultured;
• Aquaculture infrastructure is predominated by backyard production
systems which are not “economically” amenable to being managed in a
high-productive high-yielding commercial manner;
• Because of the backyard scale of production and short warm season,
the average Bhutanese fish farmer engages in an “all-in & all-out”
system of production wherein all the fish in a pond is completely
harvested at the end of the warm season. Thereafter, the pond is dried
and prepared to receive an all new stock of fingerlings to commend the
next culture operation at the onset of the next warm season. This
system is also often adopted for fish ponds which are fed with
rainwater which all but dry up shortly after the rains stop. The all-in &
all-out system sharply contrasts with the staggered-harvest system
adopted for large commercial ponds that are fed water from
permanent sources such as a river. Fish ponds in the commercial
staggered-harvest system are rarely completely harvested. Such
culture systems may only partially be harvested now and then for
various reasons (for example, to fulfill an ad-hoc demand for fish), and
the bio-mass gap in the pond created by the harvest is normally offset
by an appropriate quantity of fingerlings restocked into it. In other
words, commercial staggered-harvest type fish ponds retain water and
fish all year round.
141
Prospects of Aquaculture
As has become amply clear by now, the demand for fish in Bhutan is
massive and therefore the likelihood of the marketing of this commodity
becoming difficult in the near future due to surplus production is rather
very low. This prognosis, when coupled with the following few important
facts about Bhutan, unmistakably indicates a successful future for
aquaculture- specifically fish farming- in the country:
• Bhutan’s topography and climate can support both warm water and
cold water fish culture;
• The government of Bhutan strongly supports fish farming with
financial incentives and other forms of support;
• Inputs of fish farming, including land and water, are readily available
within the country;
• The system of governance of aquaculture in Bhutan is well established
with clear mandates assigned to public, corporate and private
stakeholders; and
• Technologies that are capable of sustaining both subsistence and
commercial fish production activities are available in the country.
In the long run, Bhutan could also produce niche products, such as organic
fish, for export. This is a real possibility because factors of fish production,
especially water, in Bhutan are virtually uncontaminated.
Bhutan could also develop aquaponics to enhance domestic fish output in a
climate resilient manner. This fish production technology has a high
likelihood of becoming an attractive livelihood means for the Bhutanese
youth and women.
Culture of other aquatic organisms, such as mollusks and crustaceans,
however appears to have a bleak prospect in Bhutan. This is so for two
important reasons. Firstly, being a landlocked country, Bhutan does not
have saltwater/ marine/ brackishwater aquatic organisms and secondly,
among the freshwater aquatic species available in the country, there is
hardly any with the potential of becoming a commercially important
cultivable species.
142
households producing it. Only rarely are surplus available to sell off for
cash.
More than 90 % of Bhutan’s 500 odd fish producers are farmers who culture
fish in backyard earthen ponds which are in some cases as small as 200
squared meters. These backyard farmers’ primary motive for fish
production is household consumption. Therefore, they hardly employ
intensive husbandry techniques. For the Bhutanese backyard fish farmers,
fish culture is, more or less, all about stocking their ponds with fingerlings
and then leaving them on their own to grow to consumption-size. But for
providing a supplementary feed comprised of farm stuffs such as rice bran,
maize powder and other such things, Bhutanese backyard fish farmers
invest virtually “zero” improved/ intensive inputs, such as nutritious
commercial feed, in their fish production systems.
Only a handful of Bhutan’s fish producers operate what may be termed as
commercial fish production systems. These systems are usually a few
numbers of decent-sized fish ponds built on Government Reserved Forest
(GRF) land which the farmers take on lease from the government.
Commercial fish ponds may each measure about 2500 squared meters, and a
commercial fish farm may be comprised a few numbers of such ponds, often
more than 5 ponds. In terms of production inputs, even the commercial
farms do not use commercial feed, relying more on farm residues as fish
feed. However, such farms invest relatively significantly in other inputs
such as manure to enhance fish pond natural/ primary productivity.
In the north-west of Bhutan, a government fisheries organization named
National Research and Development Centre for Lake and Riverine Fisheries
(NRCLRF) is promoting intensive rainbow trout farming to exploit the
country’s potential to produce cold water fish. This technology however has
a long way to go before it becomes a prominent producer of farmed fish.
The main constraints to the development of rainbow trout farming are an
under-developed capacity to produce fish seed and poor access to nutritious
commercial fish feed (Tshering, 2017).
As Bhutan’s waters are pre-dominantly fast flowing, often torrential, culture
techniques such as cage culture have never been tried in Bhutan. Lately
though, the government has been seriously considering conducting cage-
fish culture in the country’s hydropower reservoirs (Tshering, 2017). Bhutan
is also considering harnessing the potential of Culture Based Capture
Fisheries (CBCF) to contribute to national fish output.
143
Issues and Challenges in Aquaculture
Fish farming in Bhutan is significantly constrained by, among other things,
unfavorable topography, climate, wetland conservation policies,
smallholder farmers and inadequate resources such as flatlands. These
factors effectively preclude the establishment of large-scale commercial
farms by farmers. Of late, climate change induced extreme events have
begun to impact fish farming adversely also.
144
Figure 4. Establishment of a corporate-run commercial fish farm
Environmental issues
Being predominantly subsistent in scale, pond fish farming in Bhutan does
not pose any serious threat to the environment. Farm effluents are not
loaded with nutrients from fish feed, aqua-chemicals and drugs, and other
inputs to the extent capable of causing adverse impacts on natural aquatic
eco-systems due to eutrophication. Production systems such as cage-culture
in natural waters are not yet existent. So environmental impacts associated
with such systems are not encountered. Movement of farmed exotic species
is strictly regulated, and under no circumstances are they permitted to be
introduced into natural waters. Therefore, the likelihood of adverse impacts
on natural aquatic biodiversity arising from the introduction of farmed
exotic species in natural waters is kept to a minimum. Though
establishment of large commercial scale fish farms by individual farmers is
not possible due to reasons already explained, the government of Bhutan
encourages establishment of such farms on Government Reserved Forests
(GRF) land by groups of farmers and corporate entities. Activities
pertaining to the construction and operation of such farms are strictly
monitored to ensure that the environment is not seriously impacted by way
of removal of large tracts of vegetation, dumping of materials in natural
waters and other such activities. In the long run, however, these activities
could become a significant threat to the environment. Environmental issues
associated with mariculture are not applicable to Bhutan.
145
Social issue
The population of Bhutan is approximated at 700000 people. The official
religion of Bhutan is Buddhism and approximately 75 % of the Bhutanese
are Buddhist. The remaining 25 % mainly practise Hinduism. Buddhist
Bhutanese on average are highly religious. This trait prevents a good
number of Bhutanese from taking up livelihood activities that involve
rearing and slaughter of animals including fish. Therefore, besides dairying
for milk and milk products, other livestock husbandry activities such as
poultry, piggery and aquaculture activities for production of chicken, pork
and fish meat respectively are not intensifying commensurate with the
support provided by the government. It is approximated that 657 Bhutanese
people undertake fish (carp) production in earthen ponds. These activities
are concentrated mainly in the south of the country and are undertaken
mainly by people practicing Hinduism. The only social issue in Bhutan that
that has a significant impact on aquaculture is the near-ostracization of
people who undertake fish farming by those who do not. Bhutanese who
are engaged in fish farming are more often than not looked down upon by
those who are not engaged in fish farming. This has caused several farmers
to discontinue their fish farming activities, and also the fear of being thus
treated prevents a good number of Bhutanese from adopting fish farming
despite their having interest to do so.
146
the important details of pond fish production such as stocking density and
stocking rate, feed type and feeding regime, water quality management,
liming, manuring and ensuring optimal natural fish food production etc.
This is thought to be the main reason why the average Bhutanese fish farm’
productivity and output are not incommensurate with scientific
expectations.
Large commercial-scale corporate fish farms however are managed in
accordance with scientific recommendations.
147
Table 2. Aquaculture institutional set up and stakeholders’ involvement in
Bhutan.
Sl.No Stakeholder Main responsibilities
1 MoAF i. Overall governance of aquaculture;
(Government) ii. Promulgation of policies and rules and regulations;
iii. Provision of support for aquaculture development;
2 DoL i. Support the MoAF set aquaculture goals and
(Government) objectives;
ii. Enforcement of policies and rules and regulations;
iii. Provide oversight and resource support to the
NRDCA and the NCRLF;
iv. Reports to the MoAF.
3 NRDCA i. Produce carp seed;
(Government) ii. Conduct research to develop/ improve aquaculture
technologies;
iii. Technically backstop fish farmers and corporate fish
producers;
4 NCRLF i. Customize Rainbow trout culture technology and
(Government) produce rainbow trout seed;
ii. Research other cold water aquaculture technologies.
5 RCA i. Produce carp seed
(Government)
6 RLDC i. Technically backstop fish farmers and corporate fish
(Government) producers;
ii. Facilitate marketing.
7 Fish farmers i. Produce fish and other aqua-commodities
(Fish
producers)
8 Corporate i. Produce fish and other aqua-commodities
entities (Fish
producers)
9 The retailers i. Market fish and other aqua-commodities
MoAF: Ministry of Agriculture and Forests
Recommendations
Aquaculture in Bhutan has a long way to go before it can be said that the
country’s aquaculture potential has been exploited to an appreciable extent.
To enable Bhutan to realize its aquaculture potential, the following
recommendations are made:
• Mainstream fisheries and aquaculture in its policies;
• Improve the efficiency of Bhutan’s aquaculture institutional set up and
stakeholders’ involvement;
• Develop capacity in terms of quantity and quality of technical human
resource;
• Strengthen infrastructure for aquaculture research and production;
• Diversify aquaculture technologies;
148
• Diversify cultured species;
• Improve brood-stock of existing cultured species;
• Strengthen networking with regional and global aquaculture entities;
• Disseminate existing aquaculture technologies aggressively among
farmers; and
• Incentivize aquaculture activities
Conclusion
Despite having the potential to enhance its fish output through both
backyard and commercial-scale production, Bhutan continues to remain
unable to do so mainly because of an inability to back existing political will
with appropriate efforts. This is why while massive quantities of fish are
imported every year, domestic output is growing at a rate which is far
below the rate at which it could grow if things are done correctly. Towards
correcting this defect, among other things, the efficiency of Bhutan’s
aquaculture institutional set up and stakeholders’ involvement to produce
desired results must be improved, pro-aquaculture policies must be built,
network must be forged, and infrastructure and capacity must be
strengthened.
Bhutan today is at a critical juncture with the 11th Five Year Plan coming to
an end and the 12th Five Year Plan (12 FYP) being formulated. Therefore, all
in all, if the recommendations of this paper are acted upon in a non-
negotiable manner, there is a high likelihood that Bhutan’s aquaculture
potential will be significantly realized and fish import will be reduced
greatly by the end of the 12 FYP.
References
Department of Livestock. (2017). Livestock Statistics 2016, MoAF, RGoB.
Dorji, N. 2017. Development of GIFT-strain Oreochromis niloticus (Nile tilapia)
Farming in Bhutan.
Dorji, N. 2017. Impact of climate change on coastal fisheries and aquaculture in
Bhutan.
Dorji, N. 2016. What does it mean for Bhutan to attempt to achieve self- sufficiency
in fish? Gelephu.
National Research and Development Centre for Aquaculture, 2016. NRDCA Fish
Farming Data.
Royal Government of Bhutan,2016. 12th Five Year Plan Guideline.
Royal Government of Bhutan2017. PEOPLE, SOCIETY AND RELIGION. Retrieved
September 3, from http://www.tourism.gov.bt: http://www.tourism.gov.bt/
about-bhutan/people,-society-religion
Tshering, S. 2017. Rainbow trout culture development in Bhutan.
149
REPORT OF THE SAC/NARA REGIONAL EXPERT
CONSULTATION ON “BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES
(BMP) IN AQUACULTURE: CAPACITY BUILDING AND
POLICY DEVELOPMENT”
(19-21 September 2017, Goldi Sands Hotel, Negombo, Sri Lanka)
Papers presented
A total of 7 country papers on ‘Best management practices (BMP) in aquaculture:
capacity building and policy development’ were present at the expert
consultation, covering Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan
and Sri Lanka. Another five technical papers covering crucial aspects of the
management practices in aquaculture and policy development in the SAARC
region were also presented by the acknowledged experts from the SAARC
nations in these special fields.
Recommendations
1. Revisiting the existing codes in aquaculture in SAARC member states,
and framing and harmonizing new codes to tap the global export
market of aquaculture products
2. Establishment of brood banks, seed certification and health certification
facilities
150
3. Development and harmonization of quality standards for fish, fish
products and their handling
4. Development of disease surveillance, antimicrobial resistance (AMR),
disease management and quarantine measures in aquaculture
5. Prevention of use of hormones, drugs, antibiotics and disease control
chemicals in aquaculture and aquaculture products
6. Setting up of accredited fish feeds analytical laboratories in the region
7. Use of Information and Communications Technology (ICT) and smart
technology in aquaculture
8. Proper disposal of wastes generated from aquaculture
9. Framing of policy to lease public water bodies, registration of
Aquaculture, and setting up of Farmer Producer Organizations (FPOs)
10. Security to farmers in case of crop loses
11. Institutional linkages, capacity building and continuous awareness
campaign at primary producer level for sustainable aquaculture
12. Creating more investment in aquaculture and creating market chain for
the produce
13. Freshwater fish germplasm exchange among the member states
14. Creating mechanism for better information sharing among the SAARC
countries on aquaculture development and conducting SAARC
Aquaculture dialogue
15. Recognize nutritive value of small indigenous species and develop
policy towards promoting nutrition sensitive aquaculture
16. Framing of biodiversity and environment compatible stringent
Aquaculture Policy in the SAARC region.
Following this Expert Consultation which has recorded, for the first time,
the importance of capacity building and suitable policy framing for the best
management practices in aquaculture in the SAARC region should
- recognize that the Consultation has only made a first step in gathering
information on the topic;
- collect and collate information on emerging issues and challenges in
aquaculture, the management practices followed in aquaculture,
legislations and framework available to manage aquaculture,
institutional frame work and capacity available in SAARC member
countries; and
- organize further meetings and finally drafting the best management
practices to be followed in aquaculture in the SAARC region to tap the
international export markets and domestic consumption of aquaculture
products.
151
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS
BANGLADESH
Dr. Kazi Iqbal Azam
Deputy Director
Department of Fisheries, Dhaka Division, Dhaka
Bangladesh
E-mail: [email protected]
BHUTAN
Mr. Namgay Dorji
Programme Director
National Research Centre for Aquacultre (Gelephu)
Department of Livestock, Ministry of Agriculture and Forests
Royal Government of Bhutan
Bhutan
E-mail: [email protected]
INDIA
Mr. Rama Sankar Naik
Commissioner Fisheries
Government of Andhra Pradesh
Poranki, Bander Road
Vijayawada
India
Email: [email protected]
MALDIVES
Ms. Shafiya Naeem
Aquatic Pathologist
Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture
The Maldives
E-mail: [email protected]
NEPAL
Mr. Gayatri Raj Wagle
Senior Fisheries Development Officer
Fisheries Development Centre, Geta, Kailali
Nepal
Mail: [email protected]
152
PAKISTAN
Dr. Rehana Kausar
Senior Scientific Officer, ASI
National Agricultural Research Centre
Pakistan
Mail: [email protected]
SRI LANKA
Dr. Vasantha Pahalawattaararchchi
Principal Scientist
Head/Inland Aquatic Resource and Aquaculture Division
National Aquatic Resources Research and Development Agency (NARA)
Sri Lanka
Email: [email protected]
FAO
Dr. Rohana Subasinghe
Retired Chief of the Aquaculture
FAO, Rome, Italy
Managing Director, FUTUREFISH
16 I, ICONIC,
110, Parliament Road,
Rajagiriya 10107,
Sri Lank
Email: [email protected]
153
KING AQUA SERVICES (PVT) LTD, SRI LANKA
Dr. S. Thayaparan
Managing Director
King Aqua Services (pvt) Ltd
53B, Singhapura Road,
Chilaw 61000
Sri Lanka
Email: [email protected]; [email protected]
NAQDA
Mrs. K.B.C. Pushpalatha
Director (Extension)
National Aquaculture Development Authority of Sri Lanka (NAQDA )
No. 41/1, New Parliament Road
Pelawatta, Battaramulla
Sri Lanka
Email: [email protected]
Mr. Jayantha Chandrasoma
Previous Chairman
National Aquaculture Development Authority of Sri Lanka (NAQDA)
153,Horana Road,
Panadura,
Sri Lanka
Email: [email protected]
NARA
Dr. Anil Premaratne
Chairman
National Aquatic Resources Research and Development Agency (NARA)
Craw Island
Nara Rd, Colombo 01500
Sri Lanka
Email: [email protected]
154