Carol Ann Duffy Poem Notes (Themes and Tone)
Carol Ann Duffy Poem Notes (Themes and Tone)
- It is not a specific title and just talks about a hectic concept (war)
- The identity of the persona is unknown and no context is given
Tone
● Stanza 1: Near spiritual experience of developing photos; element of unknown because he hasn’t seen
what’s been clicked so far
● Stanza 2: Comparison, a sense of nostalgia coupled with horror and enforcement of a routine
○ ‘Job to do’
○ ‘Home again’
○ ‘Ordinary pain which simple weather can dispel’
● Stanza 3: Photos start developing; recollection of terrible events and their occurrences near him. Guilt is
observed, hinting at ethical concerns of war photography
○ ‘Something is happening’: Dramatic lead-in, something out of the routine, serves as a volta
○ ‘What someone must’
● Stanza 4: Actual publishing of the photos and the casual reactions of the people and him leaving again;
‘Carousel keeps turning’
○ ‘Black or white’
○ ‘Earns his living’
● Overall there is a tone of bitterness by the persona towards those who do not realise the struggles of a war
photographer and the war
● There is a tone of anger as well as sorrow
Standing female nude
- The title describes what the persona in the poem is doing, and this is her job
- This is also a work of art/painting
Tone
● Indifference
● Cynicism, satirically sarcastic
○ Six hours like this for a few francs: Poem starts off with a complaint, automatically highlights the
need for money especially because it’s mentioned
○ They tell me he’s a genius
■ Ironic because the poem then talks about them having sex
■ She had no interest in his kind of art and he doesn’t actually possess her
○ These artists take themselves too seriously
● Scornful towards the artist
Education for leisure
- The title talks about how education is only something one does in their free time
- Shows a sense of resentment or dislike towards education
- While education is a need, the title contrasts that idea and makes it seem like something one does to kill
time or in their free time
- Education only during boredom
Tone
● Egoistical, maniacal, sadistic, chilling, enigmatic, suspense, overwrought
● Personality is slowly uncovered as tone goes from chillingly light/sociopathic to eerily psychopathic,
allowing for a gradual introduction into an intense personality
● “I touch your arm.” acts a cliffhanger for the poem, leaving it on a suspenseful tone. The first time usage of
“your” directly addresses the reader and elucidates the impression that the persona will come for them.
Similar to one of Robert Browning’s poems
● The desire to be noticed and paid attention to; childish
○ “I have had enough of being ignored”
○ “write my name”: Even though he knows it’s transitory, he writes his name because he wants to be
remembered, like Shakespeare
○ “I dial the radio” can be seen as a hunt for seconds of public fame or a call for help
○ Reinforced through delusions of grandeur
■ “I breathe out talent”
■ “I am a genius”
○ Imposing delusions onto others as a way to generate self-importance and self-relevance
■ “They don’t appreciate my autograph.”
■ “The cat knows I am a genius, and has hidden itself.” is actually self-preservation by the
cat
○ Murderous tendencies come from a lack of attention, and is a way of restoring power
Head of English
- The title makes a generalised statement (Unidentified persona)
- Mysterious and not precise
- Makes the reader think, what the poem might be about due to a simple title
Tone:
● Brusque
● Overly confident
● Pompous
● Switches between amusing and commanding as to be controlling but not noticeably so
● Controlling:
● Partly jealous
● Pedagogical
● Patronizing
● Dismissive
● Didactic
● Dismissive: Trying not to praise the person while bragging about their own achievements
● Impossibly archaic
Selling Manhattan
- A commentary on the colonisation
- The purchase of Manhattan
Tone
● Accusatory
● Emotional and guilting
● Contrast between the coloniser and colonised, between the defeated-yet-wise way of life and the brutal,
harsh way of the coloniser
● Bitter
● Derogatory
● Switches halfway through the poem from semi-doubtful to assured; Soft sentences → Imperatives →
Rhetorical questioning
● Becomes more and more saddened throughout
Deportation
- The title has negative connotations because deportation is very painful and harsh upon people
- Talks about forceful abandonment by a country to a civilian
- Tries to draw empathy to the immigrant’s struggles of hopelessness
- Might not come
Tone
● Curt: Officials
● Hurt: How they were treated as parts of a routine/system and not individuals with interests & features of
their own
● Distraught and cold (in tone) towards the end by using brief, simple sentences
● Hypothetical tense to imply a possible future, one that did not occur: This further adds to the impact of a
forgotten future and overcome dreams
Stealing
- The title creates a sense of mystery and thought into the reader's mind
- Unemployment in the UK and why people end up stealing
- One word makes it seem like the rest of the words got stolen and isolated
- There is no importance given to the title because it's just one adjective by itself which does not give any
context to the readers
- Creates a universal effect (everyone does it, and it happens it to everyone)
- We might associate it with men, but it’s a woman in this case. She lets us decide for ourselves
Tone
● Questioning
● Reflective of his actions
● Frustrated
● Psychotic and with a distorted psyche
Warming her pearls
- The title does not give much away
- Sexual relationship between a maid and her mistress
- In the Victorian times, the maids would warm the pearls for their mistresses so thats its not very cold when
they wear them
Tone
● Implied purity and femininity of the mistress
● Sensual, erotic, enigmatic, intriguing, longing
● Impassioned and erotically explicit
● Lascivious; laced with undertones of love for the woman
● Submissive tendencies; Stockholm syndrome
● Over-exaggeration and over-dramatization of every simple action because of the obsession
● Maid glamorizing and idolizing the mistress and her every move, her lifestyle
● Romantic undertone:
○ Red
○ Blush
○ Lips
○ Fans herself
○ Undressing
○ Naked
Little Red Cap
- Reminds the reader of little red riding hood
- Makes it seem like its a poem for a naive baby because of the word “little”
Tone
● Childlike and naive
● Moving onto deceiving a man and becoming intellectual
● Intimate and sexual (animalistic)
● Violent love making
● Peaceful and tranquil
Mrs.Lazarus
- The fact that the title only associates the woman with her husband’s last name
- The woman does not have an identity of her own
- Women are only recognised by their husbands, and this evokes the elements of a patriarchal society
Tone
● Regretful
● Reminiscent
● Grieving and sorrowful
● Bitterness towards society
● Harsh
● Inner peace and tranquility
● Erotic
Mrs.Midas
- This title suggests that the identity of the lady is only because of her husband
- She is the wife of a greedy man from Greek mythology
Tone
● Comical undertones
● Emotional
● Wit
● Longing, regret on his behalf
○ “the woman who married the fool / who wished for gold”; third-person tone suggests that this is
what people might say, reflecting the derision and mockery of gossip mongers
○ “I miss most, even now, his hands, his warm hands on my skin, his touch”; lexical field is related
to human contact, which is exactly where the whole issue even stems from
○ “I think of him in certain lights”
● Tenderness
● Greed/materialism
● Borderline anger + fear
○ “What gets me now is not the idiocy or greed but lack of thought for me.”
○ Leaves her belongings away from him for security
○ “Separate beds. in fact, I put a chair against my door, near petrified.”
○ “now I feared his honeyed embrace, the kiss that would turn my lips to a work of art.”
Anne Hathaway
- She was the wife of Shakespeare who never really got a voice and not many people knew about her
- No one really knows her, but it’s that she has her own personality and identity too
- Tells us who the poem is about, Shakespeare’s wife
Tone
● Soft
● Romantic
● Dramatic
● Exaggerating
● Fondness
● Sensual
● Nostalgic
● Passionate
Salome
- This persona is insignificant in the Bible, and this is the first time that a female's name is in the title
- It shows a dominant woman
- Naive and without an opinion because she is a weak character
Tone
● Slightly humorous, but in a dark sense
● Cavalier
● Sense of revenge; the woman is getting back at men who have murdered, or punished woman for their
excessive sexuality
● Crude, graphic and violent which make her unlikable not only due to basic human nature but also because
these were not female-related traits and characteristics to process so she angered people more by stepping
out of the box of female stereotypes than by murdering people
● Menacing satisfaction
Havisham
- This is another title with a female name, which reveals the name of the persona
- She is a character in Charles Dickens; Great expectations
- This is a stand alone name, without a surname which suggests either isolation or she has an identiy of her
own
Tone
● Bittersweet tone
● Resentment and scornful tone
● Painful and hurt
● Betrayed
● Seeks sympathy
● Angry and frustrated
● Lonely and isolated
Originally
- Importance of origin
- Talks about Duffy’s move to from Scotland to England at the age of 6
- Defines her identity and origin
Tone
● Sorrow
● Irritated
● Fearful and intimidated
● Lost and unfamiliar
● Suffering and scared
● Envious of her brother
● Hesitant due to fear of not fitting