Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CIA's Support To The Nazi War Criminal Investigations
CIA's Support To The Nazi War Criminal Investigations
CIA's Support To The Nazi War Criminal Investigations
The story of escaped Nazis after the and placed the names
investigations
collapse of the Third Reich in 1945 of some 60,000 individuals on a
has long gripped novelists and Holly watch list that alerts US immigra
wood screenwriters and provided the tion officials to prevent their entry
grist for such box office hits as The into the United States.2
Boys From Brazil and The ODESSA
File. Since the 1970s, the topic has
also provided steady fare for histori
Continuing Suspicions
ans and
journalists anxious to
explore supposed cabals between Despite these efforts, doubts persist
American intelligence agencies and
in some circles as to whether the
such personalities as Josef Mengele,
United States Government has been
Separating fact from fiction the Angel of Death at Auschwitz,
fully honest about this emotion-
about the alleged postwar and former Austrian President Kurt
charged issue. For example, Christo
Waldheim, a German intelligence
in his 1988 book,
relationships between pher Simpson,
officer in the Balkans during World
Blowback: America ~c Recruitment of
American intelligence and War II.
Nazis and Its Effects on the Cold War,
its former German enemies that US intelligence agencies
asserts
Separating fact from fiction about did knowor had good reason to
and collaborators is both the alleged postwar relationships suspectthat many contract agents
difficult and confusing. between American intelligence and they hired during the Cold War had
its former German enemies and col committed crimes against humanity
State
behalf of the Nazis. The CIA, the
Department, and US Army
Office (GAO), at the request of the intelligence, Simpson states, each
US Congress, has conducted two created special programs for the spe
103
War Criminal
(CIG, 1946-47), employed German CIA covered up its these activities also started its separate investigation
intelligence personnel as sources of from Congressional and other at the same time.
information. Afterward, the CIA Federal investigators.
sponsored the new West German In May 1978, the GAO released its
intelligence service, an organization The extent to which the Agency is formal report, Widespread Conspiracy
under the control of officers of the To Obstruct Probes ofAlleged Nazi
guilty or innocent of these charges is
defunct German general staff The a matter of continuing debate among War Criminals Not Supported by
ranks of the organization sheltered AvailableEvidenceControversy May
historians. Certainly, the Agencys
many officers of the German SS and own secretiveness and its previous
Continue. Regarding CIAs involve
SD whose loyalty to the new West scandals color the debate. For ment, the GAO found that in its
public
German Government remained in search for information on 111
decades, the CIA faced little public
doubt. alleged Nazi war criminals, the
scrutiny of its operations or the iden
Agency had no on 54. Of the
records
tity of its agents. But the Bay of Pigs
remaining 57, CIA had references,
CIA and its predecessor organiza debacle in 1961, highlighting the
such as newspaper articles and gen
tions employed former collaborators CIA-sponsored, ill-fated invasion of
Cuba and the Agencys reliance on eral correspondence with other
of the Third Reich, primarily from
Cuban ØmigrØs, cracked CIAs pic Federal agencies, on 35. That left 22
Eastern and Southern Europe, ini
individuals with whom CIA admit
tially as sources of information and ture-perfect mirror. Controversies in
Vietnam later in the decade only ted to GAO investigators that it had
later as operational assets for activi
increased a more substantial relationship. In an
ties behind the Iron Curtain. concern among Americans
about CIAs unnamed case, CIA sponsored the
accountability. During
the 1 970s, a series of Congressional immigration of a senior official of
the German Foreign Ministry during
CIA, including the Office of Policy investigations pointed to extensive
Coordination (OPC, 1948-52), the Nazi era to the United States.
problems within CIA and presented
Germans and East The remaining 21 had contact with
brought Europe an image of the Agency as a rogue
CIA evacuated Nazi war criminals demanded that the GAO determine employed these individuals after they
and collaborators through rat lines
whether the INS or any other govern had been screened by Federal agen
in southern Europe, allowing them ment agency had conspired to cies and permitted to enter the
obstruct legal action against alleged United States. The Agency denied
to escape justice by relocating them
Nazi war criminals
living in the that itemployed any individual
incognito in South America.
United States. Congress made this against whom allegations of war
request in January 1977, marking crimes were well-founded. The
CIA abused its legal authority to the beginning of the first GAO inves report reiterated CIAs contention
bring Soviet and Soviet Bloc defec tigation. The Special Litigation Unit, that these people were all strongly
torsand other persons of interest to a new office within INS and the anti-Communist and their willing
the United States. immediate predecessor to the OSI, ness to cooperate and their
104
War Criminal
The 1978 GAO unleashed full decades primary offices that respond to OSI
Report a
storm of criticism about the use of requests for information. While the
alleged Nazi war criminals by the Agency and OSI experienced some
United States. Congressman Eilberg teething problems during the early
blasted the Federal Government years of the investigations, a routine
because this report makes clear that Formation of Os! procedure has evolved. OGCs
the CIA and FBI were more inter attorneys undertake close consulta
ested in using these people and As result of frustration tion with OSI to protect legitimate
a continuing
getting information from them than with the of the Nazi war crim national interests if it
course
security
in conducting any background inves inal
investigations, Congresswoman is involved
appears that a CIA asset
tigation as to their wartime activities Holtzman strengthened US immigra
in The CIA has
an investigation.
or pursuing allegations that they tion laws to exclude from admission
never deflected OSI from any investi
were war criminals.6 The GAOs into the United States aliens who
investigation, however, denied that have persecuted any person on the gation or prosecution of any
individual for concealing illegal war
there was any evidence ofconspir a basis of race, religion, national ori
time activities.
acy to obstruct justice, although it gin, or political opinion, and to
claimed that it did not enjoy full facilitate the deportation of such
access to governmental records. aliens who have been admitted into
The agencies achieved a major
two
GAOs investigation, the report the United States. 0 Holtzman also
called for the formation of the Office
breakthrough in 1981, when a Fed
stated, was hindered by the effect of
the passage of time on the availabil of Special Investigations in the Crim
eral stripped Otto Albrecht
court
investigators to validate their time to establish its working proce Jewish residents of Bucharest.
conclusions.8 Despite Carluccis dures and to resolve the problems of Bolschwing also concealed from his
contention, Congress felt that the its predecessors, the Department of CIA case officers the fact that he had
GAO report had been a disappoint Justice and CIA reached agreements worked in the same office with Adolf
ment. Congressman Eilberg, in open in 1980 concerning name-trace pro Eichmann in the 1930s. CIA learned
hearings later in the summer of cedures. After that, CIA and OSI
about Bolshwings close relationship
1978, exclaimed that it is just regret instituted a regular reporting sys
with Eichmann after the latters
table that so much time and man tema process that continues.
abduction by Israel in 1960. Several
hours and money was expended and
we have so little to show for it.9 The The Nazi criminal years before that event, CIA brought
war investigation
GAOs failure, in large part, was is now the longest running investiga Bolschwing to the United States, and
blamed on CIAs restrictions on tion in CIAs history, extending for he received American citizenship in
105
War Criminal
Another GAO Investigation In the spring of 1983, OSI Director resources that had immediate intelli
Allan A. Ryan, Jr. assumed the lead gence potential. These resources
in the Barbie investigation. Several included former Nazi intelligence
The Nazi war criminal
investigations months later Ryan issued a report personnel and collaborators. The
took an unexpected turn in May
that clearly demonstrated that the GAO investigated some 114 individ
1982, when John Loftus, a former
US Army had employed Barbie as an uals and provided detailed
OSI attorney, announced on CBS
agent in Germany and had spon summaries on 12. Of this latter num
TVs 60 Minutes that numerous
sored his escape from Europe. The ber, CIA was involved with five with
branches of the US Government,
Ryan report absolved the CIA of any undesirable or questionable back
including the Army, the FBI, the
wrongdoing, but it highlighted the grounds who had received aid to
CIA, and the State Department, had the United States. The
Nazis and
entangled webs of the Allied intelli move to
employed brought them GAO found no specific program to
America after the Further gence services in Austria, Germany,
to war.
and unearthed thousands of docu nals. No sooner had the ink dried on
gence agencies often assign projects
ments from numerous agencies. This the pages of the Ryan report than innocuous names which do not
time, the Agency granted the GAO OSI undertook the examination of reflect the projects purposes and,
investigators full access to its records Robert Jan Verbelen, a member of a therefore, we cannot assure that we
public attention as the Barbie investi pletely sure that we have obtained all
of Cases
gation, it confirmed that American relevant information or that we have
A Surge intelligence, especially the Counter identified all Nazis and Axis collabo
Intelligence Corps, had been slip- rators assisted by US agencies to
mountains of records, new events With this statement, the GAO has
raised further questions about US left room for further speculation
intelligence activities during the early GAOs Findings about the US Governments actions
port him in South America remained GAO concluded that US intelli the discovery of Mengeles remains in
unclear. gence used anti-Communist July of that year in Brazil, questions
106
War Criminal
ties. Once again, American Solarz that we believe that Wald criminal investigations.
intelligence, especially CIA, came heim was not a member of the Nazi
under close scrutiny. Another OSI Youth Movement, nor was he
The end of the Cold War also
investigation cleared the Agency and involved in anti-Jewish activities. In
addition, the CIA provided a brief spurreddemands that the CIA open
all other American intelligence organs
of any connection with Mengele.8 of Waldheims military to the public. Former Con
its fIles
synopsis
record and said there were no indica gresswoman Holtzman, New Yorks
tions that Waldheim had comptroller and then candidate for
The sensitive of the Nazi war
nature
trated by the Kurt Waldheim case in antiJewish activities. 20 1992 and asked for complete disclo
sure of records concerning Klaus
1986-87, in which an international
Barbie and Otto von Bolschwing.
figure, a former secretary general of The Agencys response to Solarz
the UN and soon-to-be Austrian resulted in great embarrassment in In the process of employing these
president, stood accused of hiding both Congressional hearings and dur people and bringing them to safe
his role in World War II. While haven in the United States and else
ing OSIs examination into
Waldheim had long admitted his ser Waldheims wartime activities. As a where, laws were broken, lies were
vice in the German Army, he had result of OSIs 1987 report, the US told, and the President, Congress,
never fully described the extent of his
and other government agencies and
Attorney General placed Waldheims
activities in the Balkans, a region the watch list the public were deceived, Holtzman
name on to prevent
marked Nazi atrocities. his entry into the United States. OSI asserted, but we still dont know the
by numerous
The fact that Waldheim rose to such concluded that Waldheim had partic whole story. Forty-seven years afrer
in the transfer of civilians the end of World War II, it is time
high levels after the war led many ipated to
observers to question whether he the SS for slave labor; the mass for the American people to find out
the truth.24
enjoyed a special relationship with deportation of civilians to death
107
War Criminal
abandoned a number of projects as justice. The media and self-pro Quiet Neighbors: Prosecuting Nazi
War Criminals in America (San
failures, including the recruitment claimed Nazi hunters quickly link
and of hot war contin the Agency to any new rumors of Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich,
training 1984); and Christopher Simpson,
gency forces. A new organization in one Nazi fugitive or another.
Blowback: Americas Recruitment of
an old game, CIA needed to learn
Nazis and Its Effects on the Cold War
the ropes, and it made mistakes in This controversy will outlive its par (New York: Weidenfeld and Nichol
the process. ticipantsthe accused war criminals son,1988).
108
War Criminal
2. Rick Atkinson, Nazi Hunters are OToo!e and Morton Mimi, US Mengele: A Report to the Attorney
Still at War, Fighting a Losing Bat Probes Report Nazi Collaborators General of the United States (Wash
tle, The Washington Post, 27 August Were Helped to Immigrate, The
ington, DC: Department ofJustice,
1995, pp. Al and A22. Washington Post, 18 May 1982, p. 1992).
A3; Thomas OToole, Nazis
3. Simpson, Blowback, p. xiv.
Brought to US to Work against Sovi
ets in Cold War, The Washington 19. A.M. Rosenthal, The Waldheim
Post, 20 May 1982, pp. Al and A20; File, The New York Times, 24
4. United States General Accounting
and Thomas OToole, The Secret
Office, Comptroller General of the November 1989, p. A35.
Under the Little Cemetery, The
United States, Widespread Conspir Rosenthals columns about Wald
Washington Post, 23 May 1982, pp.
acy to Obstruct Probes ofAlleged Nazi Al andA5.
heim helped persuade a member of
War Criminals Not Supported by
Congress to introduce a bill to open
Available EvidenceControversy
the Agencys records on all Nazi war
13. Ralph Blumenthal, Ex-Chief of
May Continue, GGD-78-73 (Wash criminals.
DC: General Gestapo in Lyon is Linked to US
ington, Accounting
Office, 1978), pp. 33-34. Intelligence, The New York Times,
8 February 1983, pp. A-i andA-9.
20. Frederick P. Hitz, Office of Legisla
5. Ibid. tiveCounsel, to Congressman
14. US Department of Justice, Criminal
Division, Klaus Barbie and the
Stephen J. Solarz, 31 December
6. Press Release, Report to Ei!berg 1980.
United States Government: A Report
Charges Ties with CIA, FBI, 17 to the Assistant Attorney General,
May 1978.
Criminal Division, US Department of 21. US Department of Justice, Criminal
Justice (Washington, DC: US
7. Cover statement, 1978 GAO Division, In the Matter of Kurt Wald
Department of Justice, 1983). For a
Report. For further details, see the heim (Washington, DC: US
retrospective look at the CICs role
Reports Scope of Review, pp. 4-6. this time, see Department ofJustice, 1987).
in Austria during
James V. Milano and Patrick Bro
8. Frank C. Carlucci to J. K. Fasick, gan, Soldiers, Spies, and the Rat Line:
22. For example, see Robert Edwin
International Division, GAO, 18 Americas Undeclared War against the
May 1978. Soviets (Washington, DC: Brasseys, Herzstein, Waldheim.~ The Missing
1995). (New York: Arbor House! Will
Years
109
War Criminal
110