A Review On Hydrotropy - A Novel Concept For Solubility Enhancement PDF
A Review On Hydrotropy - A Novel Concept For Solubility Enhancement PDF
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A REVIEW ON HYDROTROPY: A NOVEL CONCEPT FOR SOLUBILITY ENHANCEMENT
1
Department of Quality Assurance, Sigma Institute of Pharmacy, Bakrol, Ajwa-Nimeta road, Vadodara,
Gujarat, India.
ABSTRACT
Solubility is one of the important parameter to achieve desired Correspondence to Author
concentration of drug in systemic circulation for pharmacological
response to be shown. Drug efficacy can be severely limited by
poor aqueous solubility and some drugs also show side effects due
to their poor solubility. There are many techniques which are used
to enhance the aqueous solubility. The ability to increase aqueous
solubility can thus be a valuable aid to increasing efficiency and/or
reducing side effects for certain drugs. This is true for parentrally, Thummar Jayesh M.
topically and orally administered solutions. Use of the solubility
characteristics in bioavailability, pharmacological action and 65/Diwali Nagar, Near Radha Krishna
solubility enhancement of various poorly soluble compounds is a Temple,L.H. Rd., Surat-395010,
challenging task for researchers and pharmaceutical scientists. Gujarat, India
Hydrotropy is one of the solubility enhancement techniques which
enhance solubility to many folds with use of hydrotropes like Email: [email protected]
sodium benzoate, sodium citrate, urea, niacinamide etc. and have
many advantages like, it does not require chemical modification of
hydrophobic drugs, use of organic solvents or preparation of
emulsion system etc.
anionic group and a hydrophobic aromatic ring or solubility in terms of number of milliliters of
ring system. The anionic group is obviously solvent required to dissolve 1g of solute. If exact
involved in bringing about high aqueous solubility, solubilities are not known, the Pharmacopoeia
which is a prerequisite for a hydrotropic provides general terms to describe a given range.
substance. The type of anion or metal ion These descriptive terms are listed in (Table1.1).
appeared to have a minor effect on the
phenomenon[2]. The pharmacopoeia lists
Table 1.1 Expression for approximate solubility[3]
Relative amounts of solvents to
Descriptive terms
dissolve 1 part of solute
Very soluble Less than 1
Freely soluble From 1-10
Soluble From 10-30
Sparingly soluble From 30-100
Slightly soluble From 100-1000
Very slightly soluble From 1000-10,000
nsoluble or practically insoluble More than 10,000
NEED OF SOLUBILITY candidates was due to poor “drug-like” properties.
Therapeutic effectiveness of a drug depends upon It is commonly recognized in the pharmaceutical
the bioavailability and ultimately upon the industry that on average more than 40% of newly
solubility of drug molecules. Solubility is one of the discovered drug candidates are poorly water-
important parameter to achieve desired soluble. Poor “drug like” properties of lead
concentration of drug in systemic circulation for compounds led to ineffective absorption from the
pharmacological response to be shown. Currently site of administration, which has been designated
only 8% of new drug candidates have both high as an important part of the high clinical failure due
solubility and permeability[4]. Due to advanced to poor pharmacokinetics [6]
research & development, there are varieties of new
drugs & their derivatives are available. But more MECHANISM OF HYDROTROPE ACTION [2]
than 40% of lipophilic drug candidates fail to reach A hydrotrope is a compound that solubilises
market due to poor bioavailability, even though hydrophobic compounds in aqueous solutions.
these drugs might exhibit potential Typically, hydrotropes consist of a hydrophilic part
pharmacodynamic activities. The lipophilic drug and a hydrophobic part (like surfactants) but the
that reaches market requires a high dose to attain hydrophobic part is generally too small to cause
proper pharmacological action. The basic aim of spontaneous self-aggregation. Hydrotropes do not
the further formulation & development section is have a critical concentration above which
to make that drug available at proper site of action selfaggregation 'suddenly' starts to occur. Instead,
within optimum dose[5]. As a matter of fact, more some hydrotropes aggregate in a step-wise self-
than one-third of the drugs listed in the U.S. aggregation process, gradually increasing
Pharmacopoeia fall into the poorly water-soluble aggregation size. However, many hydrotropes do
or water-insoluble categories. It was reported a not seem to selfaggregate at all, unless a
couple of decades ago that more than 41% of the solubilisate has been added.
failures in new drug development have been Maheshwari et al[7]; enhanced the aqueous
attributed to poor biopharmaceutical properties, solubility of paracetamol, a poorly water-soluble
including water insolubility, while it was still drug by use of concentrated solution of urea (a
indicated recently that about 50% failure of drug hydrotropic agent).
104
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research & Development ISSN: 0974 – 9446
This hydrotropic phenomenon was employed to nicotine[10], ionic surfactants like diacids[11], SDS
prepare solid dispersion (SD) and syrup of (sodium dodecyl sulphate)[12] and dodecylated
paracetamol. SD was evaluated for dissolution rate oxidibenzene[13]. The aromatic hydrotropes with
and a marked increase in dissolution rate was anionic head groups are mostly studied
observed with SD. IR analysis revealed that there compounds. They are large in number because of
was no complexation/interaction between isomerism and their effective hydrotrope action
paracetamol and urea. Paracetamol syrups may be due to the availability of interactive pi-
prepared with urea showed good chemical orbitals. Hydrotropes with cationic hydrophilic
stabilities. group are rare, e.g. salts of aromatic amines, such
as procaine hydrochloride[14]. Besides enhancing
COMMONLY USED HYDROTROPES the solubilization of compounds in water, they are
The hydrotropes are known to self-assemble in known to exhibit influences on surfactant
solution[8]. The classification of hydrotropes on the aggregation leading to micelle formation, phase
basis of molecular structure is difficult, since a wide manifestation of multicomponent systems with
variety of compounds have been reported to reference to nanodispersions and conductance
exhibit hydrotropic behaviour. Specific examples percolation, clouding of surfactants and polymers,
may include ethanol[9], aromatic alcohols like etc.[8,14].
resorcinol, pyrogallol, catechol, a- and b-naphthols
and salicylates, alkaloids like caffeine and
Table 1.2: Hydrotropic solubilization study of various poorly water-soluble drugs[15-35]
Drug Hydrotropic agent
Riboflavin ProcaineHCl, PABAHCl,
CinchocaineHCl, Resorcinol,
Pyrogallol
Chartreusin Sodium benzoate, Sodium p-
hydroxybenzoate, Sodium m-
hydroxybenzoate, Sodium o-
hydroxybenzoate, Sodium 2,4-
dihydroxybenzoate, Sodium 2,5-
dihydroxybenzoate, Sodium 2,6-
dihydroxybenzoate, Sodium 2,4, 6-
trihydroxybenzoate
Diazepam, Medazepam, Oxazepam, Sodium salicylate
Nitrazepam, Clonazepam
Theophylline, Hydrocortisone, Sodium benzoate, Sodium o-
Prednisolone, Phenacetin hydroxybenzoate, Sodium m-
hydroxybenzoate, Sodium p-
hydroxybenzoate, Sodium 2,4-
dihydroxy benzoate, Sodium 2,5-
dihydroxybenzoate, Sodium 2,6-
dihydroxybenzoate, Sodium 3,4-
dihydroxybenzoate, Sodium 3,5-
dihydroxybenzoate, Sodium 3,4,5 –
trihydroxybenzoate
Paracetamol Sodium salicylate, Sodium glycinate,
105
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research & Development ISSN: 0974 – 9446
106
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research & Development ISSN: 0974 – 9446
dosage forms of water insoluble drugs and to 2. Quantitative estimations of poorly watersoluble
reduce concentration of individual hydrotropic drugs by titrimetric analysis.such as ibuprofen,
agent to minimize the side effects in place of using flurbiprofen and naproxen using sodium
a large concentration of one hydrotrope a blend of, benzoate[42] .
say, 5 hydrotropes can be employed in 1/5th 3.Preparation of hydrotropic solid dispersions of
concentrations reducing their individual poorly water-soluble drugs precluding the use of
[41]
toxicities . Maheshwari observed miraculous organic solvents. Such as felodipine[43] using
synergistic effect on enhancement in solubility of a poly-ethylene glycol 6000 and poly-vinyl alcohol.
poorly water-soluble drug (aceclofenac) by mixing 4. Preparation of dry syrups (for reconstitution) of
two hydrotropic agents (urea and sodium citrate) poorly water-soluble drugs.
and mixed hydrotropic blend was employed to 5. Preparation of topical solutions of poorly water-
solubilize a poorly water-soluble drug, aceclofenac soluble drugs, precluding the use of organic
from fine powder of its tablets to carryout solvents. Such as tinidazole, metronidazole and
spectrophotometric analysis precluding the use of salicylic acid using sodium benzoate and sodium
organic solvents. citrate.
6. Preparation of injection of poorly water soluble
ADVANTAGES OF MIXED HYDROTROPIC drugs.
SOLUBILIZATION 7. The use of hydrotropic solubilizers as
1. It may reduce the large total concentration of permeation enhancers.
hydrotropic agents necessary to produce 8. The use of hydrotropy to give fast release of
modest increase in solubility by employing poorly water-soluble drugs from the
combination of agents in lower concentration. suppositories.
2. It is new, simple, cost-effective, safe, accurate, 9. Application of mixed- hydrotropy to develop
precise and environmental friendly method for injection dosage forms of poorly water soluble
the analysis (titrimetric and spectrophotometric) drugs.
of poorly water-soluble drugs titrimetric and 10.Application of hydrotropic solubilization in
spectrophotometric precluding the use of nanotechnology (by controlled precipitation).
organic solvents. 11. Application of hydrotropic solubilization in
3. It precludes the use of organic solvents and thus extraction of active constituents from crude
avoids the problem of residual toxicity, error drugs (in pharmacognosy field).
due to volatility, pollution, cost etc. 12.Hydrotropic solutions can also be tried to
Maheshwari[41], investigated the application of develop the dissolution fluids to carry out the
mixed hydrotropy. There was miraculous dissolution studies of dosage forms of poorly
synergistic effect on enhancement in solubility water-soluble drugs.
of a poorly water-soluble drug by mixing two
hydrotropic agents. Solubility of aceclofenac in CONCLUSION
blends of two hydrotropic agents was much Drugs and solubility is also the basic requirement
larger than the sum of the solubilities of for the formulation and development of different
aceclofenac in individual hydrotropic solutions. dosage form of different drugs. Solubility can be
NOVEL PHARMACEUTICAL APPLICATIONS OF enhanced by many techniques and number of folds
HYDROTROPIC SOLUBILIZATION IN VARIOUS increase in solubility is reported too. Because of
FIELDS OF PHARMACY[02] solubility problem of many drugs the bioavailability
1.Quantitative estimations of poorly watersoluble of them gets affected and hence solubility
drugs by UV-Visible spectrophotometric analysis enhancement becomes necessary. It is now
precluding the use of organic solvents. possible By this article we conclude that, Solubility
is a most important parameter for the oral
108
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research & Development ISSN: 0974 – 9446
bioavailability of poorly soluble drugs. Dissolution 15. Poochikian G.K. et al, “Enhanced chartreusin
of drug is the rate determining step for oral solubility by hydroxybenzoate hydrotropy”,
absorption of the poorly water soluble that to Journal of pharmaceutical science , 1979, 68,
increase the solubility of poorly soluble drugs with 728-729.
the help of various techniques as mentioned above 16. Badwan A.A. et al, “The solubility of
benzodiazepines in sodium salicylate solution
REFERENCES and a proposed mechanism for hydrotropic
1. Neuberg, C. Hydrotropy. Biochemistry Z. 1916; solubilization”, Internantional journal of
76: 107- 109. pharmaceutics, 1983, 13, 67-73.
2. Jain P, Goel A, Sharma S, Parmar M. Solubility 17. Saleh A.M. et al, “Hydrotropic agents: a new
Enhancement Techniques with Special definition”, International journal of
Emphasis On Hydrotrophy. International pharmaceutics, 1985, 24, 231-238.
Journal of Pharma Professional’s Research ,1(1); 18. Winsor P.A. et al, “Hydrotropic solubilization
July 2010; 34-45. and related emulsification process”, Trans
3. Indian Pharmacopoeia, Goverment of India Faraday Society , 1950, 54, 762-772.
ministry of health and family Welfare, 4th ed., 19. Kennth, C. J., Aqueous solubilities, In: Kennth,
The Controller of Publication, Delhi, 1996, 332. C. J., (Ed.), Solubility & Related Properties,
4. Shinde A.J. et al, “Solubilization of poorly Published by Informa health care, Inc., New
soluble drugs: A Review”, Pharmainfo.net, York, 1986, 355.
2007, 5, 6. 20. Higuchi T. et al, “Complexation of organic
5. Shiv M. Solubility Enhancement: Need. substances in aqueous solution by
Pharmainfo.net.2009 hydroxyaromatic acids and their salts”, Journal
6. Liu, R., Introduction, In: Liu, R., (Ed.), Water- of pharmaceutical science, 1961, 50, 905-909.
Insoluble Drug Formulation, 2nd ed., CRS 21. Rasool A.A. et al, “Solubility enhacement of
press, New York, 2008, 1. some water-insoluble drugs in presence of
7. Maheshwari RK. Solid dispersion and syrup nicotinamide and related compounds”, Journal
formulation of poorly water-soluble drug by of pharmaceutical science, 1991, 80, 387-394.
hydrotropy. Indian Pharmacist 2006; 5: 87-90. 22. Hamza Y.E. et al, “Enhanced solubility of
8. Balasubramanian D. and Friberg, S. E., in paracetamol by various hydrotropic agents”,
Surface and Colloid Science (ed. Matijevic, E.), Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy,
volume 15 , Plenum Press, New York, 1993. 1985, 11, 1577-1580.
9. Friberg S.E. et al, “Colloids Surf. A: 23. Nahar M. et al, “Formulation and evaluation of
Physicochemistry”, Engineering Aspects, 1999, saquinavir injection”, 2006, 68, 608-614.
156, 145–156. 24. Feldman S. et al, “ Effect of urea on solubility”,
10. R. C. daSilva. et al, Thermochimica Acta, 1999, Journal of pharmaceutical science. 1967, 56,
328, 161–167. 370-375.
11. Robinson P.L. , Journal of the American oil 25. Rawat S. et al, “Hydrotropic solubilization of
chemists’society , 1992, 69, 52–59. some cox-2 inhibitors”, Indian Drugs., 2006, 43,
12. Guo R. et al., Journal of Dispersion science and 565-573.
technology, 1996, 17, 493–507. 26. Coffman R.E. et al, “Effect of urea on the
13. Lomax, E. G. (ed.), Amphoteric Surfactants, solubility of riboflavin in various solvents”,
Marcel Dekker,2nd edition, Inc.New York, 1996. Journal of pharmaceutical science., 1996, 85,
14. Roy, B. K. and Moulik, S. P., Colloids Surf. A: 951-954.
Physicochemical and Engineering .Aspects, 27. Woolfson A.D. et al, “Stabilization of
2002, 203, 155–166. hydrotropic temazepam parenteral formulation
109
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research & Development ISSN: 0974 – 9446
*****
110