Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Solapur To Bijapur Exe Summary Draft Eia PDF
Solapur To Bijapur Exe Summary Draft Eia PDF
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
TABLE OF CONTENT
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1-1: Valued Ecosystem Components .................................................................................................. 1-2
Table 1-2: Weightage and Ranking System Adopted ................................................................................... 1-3
Table 1-3: Primary and Secondary Information Sources .............................................................................. 1-5
Table 2-1: Existing Cross Section details ...................................................................................................... 2-1
Table 2-2: Existing Road Inventory ............................................................................................................... 2-1
Table 2-3: Widening Options ......................................................................................................................... 2-2
Table 2-4: Summary of Proposed Horizontal Alignment ............................................................................... 2-4
Table 2-5: Bypass & Realignment Locations ................................................................................................ 2-4
Table 2-6: Details of Service Road ............................................................................................................... 2-5
Table 2-7: Proposed Structures .................................................................................................................... 2-5
Table 2-8: Proposed Structures .................................................................................................................... 2-5
Table 2-9: Details of Underpass .................................................................................................................... 2-5
Table 2-10: Enhancement of Inventories ...................................................................................................... 2-6
Table 2-11: Summary of Civil Cost Estimate ................................................................................................ 2-6
Table 3-1: Country Level Environmental Laws & Regulations ...................................................................... 3-1
Table 3-2: Summary of Clearances & NOCs ............................................................................................... 3-3
Table 4-1: Details of Monitoring Station for Soil ............................................................................................ 4-2
Table 4-2: Physico-chemical Analysis of Soil Quality ................................................................................... 4-3
Table 4-3: Air Pollution Receptors Types Identified along the Project Road ................................................ 4-3
Table 4-4: Details of Monitoring Station for Air Quality Monitoring ............................................................... 4-4
Table 4-5: Ambient Air Quality within Project Corridor .................................................................................. 4-4
Table 4-6: Details of Water Quality Monitoring Station ................................................................................. 4-5
Table 4-7: Physical and Chemical Results of Surface Water Samples ........................................................ 4-5
Table 4-8: Physical and Chemical Results of Ground Water Samples ......................................................... 4-6
Table 4-9: Observed Noise Levels along Road ............................................................................................ 4-7
Table 4-10: Forest Areas along the Project Road ......................................................................................... 4-7
Table 4-11: Census Details ........................................................................................................................... 4-8
Table 4-12: Settlements along Project Road ................................................................................................ 4-8
Table 5-1: Public Consultation held at Different Stages of Project ............................................................... 5-1
Table 5-2: Public Consultations..................................................................................................................... 5-2
Table 5-3: Addressal of General Issues and Concerns under the Project .................................................... 5-3
Table 6-1: Scoring system adopted for the Project ....................................................................................... 6-1
Table 6-2: General Impacts on Environment ................................................................................................ 6-2
Table 6-3: Likely Impacts on Water Resources during the Construction Stage ........................................... 6-6
Table 6-4: Noise Impacts .............................................................................................................................. 6-9
Table 6-5: Forest Area required on Project Road ......................................................................................... 6-9
Table 6-6: Likely Impacts on Flora .............................................................................................................. 6-10
Table 6-7: Proposed Land Requirement in the Project ............................................................................... 6-13
Table 7-1: "With and Without" Project Scenarios - A Comparative Assessment .......................................... 7-1
Table 7-2: Proposed Bypass & Realignment Locations ................................................................................ 7-3
Table 7-3: Analysis of Alternatives for Horti Bypass ..................................................................................... 7-3
Table 7-4: Analysis of Alternatives for Nandani Realignment ....................................................................... 7-5
Table 7-5: Minimisation of Environmental Impacts ...................................................................................... 7-6
Table 8-1: Summary of Mitigation on Impact on Land ................................................................................. 8-1
Table 8-2: Mitigation Measures for Soil Contamination ............................................................................... 8-2
Table 8-3: Details of Stone Aggregates Quarries ......................................................................................... 8-3
Table 8-4: Details of Natural Sand Quarries ................................................................................................. 8-3
Table 8-5: Summary of Mitigations for Impacts on Air Quality ...................................................................... 8-3
Table 8-6: Summary of Mitigations for Impacts on Water ............................................................................. 8-5
Table 8-7: Sources of Noise Pollution, Impacts and Generic Mitigation Measures ...................................... 8-8
Table 8-8: Specific Noise Mitigation Measures ............................................................................................. 8-9
Table 8-9: Summary of Mitigations for Impacts on Biological Environment ................................................ 8-10
Table 8-10: Forest Area Required ............................................................................................................... 8-10
Table 8-11: Species Recommended in Settlement Areas (Within 1 km of Last Dwelling) ......................... 8-12
Table 8-12: Species Recommended in Rural & Semi Urban Areas ........................................................... 8-12
Table 8-13: Species Recommended for Median Plantation ........................................................................ 8-12
Table 9-1: Summary of Reporting of Environmental components and Responsibilities .............................. 9-4
Table 9-2: Modules for Training ................................................................................................................... 9-5
Table 10-1: Environmental Management Plan ............................................................................................ 10-3
Table 10-2: Environmental Budget ............................................................................................................ 10-20
Table 11-1: Details of Borrow area along the Project Road ........................................................................ 11-1
Table 11-2: Probable Borrow Areas data (to be filled by Concessionaire) ............................................... 11-12
Table 11-3: Road Safety Audit Checklist .................................................................................................... 12-1
Table 12-1: Compliance to Additional TOR................................................................................................. 13-1
Table 13-1: Project Team ............................................................................................................................ 14-1
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1-1: Location of Project Road ............................................................................................................ 1-1
Figure 2-1: Proposed Typical Cross Sections ............................................................................................... 2-2
Figure 4-1: Seismic Zones of India ............................................................................................................... 4-2
Figure 5-1: Photographs of Interactions along the project road .................................................................... 5-2
Figure 7-1: Proposed Horti Bypass – Alternatives ........................................................................................ 7-4
Figure 7-2: Proposed Horti Bypass ............................................................................................................... 7-4
Figure 7-3: Proposed Nandani Realignment Alternatives ............................................................................. 7-5
Figure 7-4: Proposed Nandani Realignment ................................................................................................. 7-6
Figure 8-1: Silt Fencing ........................................................................................................................... 8-7
Figure 8-2: Oil interceptor ........................................................................................................................... 8-7
Figure 8-3: Rain Water Harvesting Structure ................................................................................................ 8-8
Figure 8-4: Compound Wall and Trees as Noise Barrier .............................................................................. 8-9
Figure 8-5: Conceptual Landscaping Of Incidental Space .......................................................................... 8-13
Figure 8-6: Thematic landscaping around intersections ............................................................................. 8-13
Figure 8-7: Seating Spaces ......................................................................................................................... 8-18
Figure 9-1: Proposed Organisation Chart ..................................................................................................... 9-6
Figure 11-1: Borrow Area Location Map ..................................................................................................... 11-9
LIST OF BOXES
Box 9-1: Qualification and Responsibilities of Environmental Officer of Concessionaire ............................. 9-2
Box 9-2: Qualification and Responsibilities of Environmental Officer of Contractor ..................................... 9-3
Box 11-1: Earth Quantities required and to be Utilised ............................................................................... 11-1
Box 11-2: Borrow Area Plan Format ......................................................................................................... 11-13
LIST OF ANNEXURE
Annexure 2.1: Details of Bus Bays and Shelters
Annexure 4.1: Water resources along the project road
Annexure 4.2: Cultural Properties along the Project Road
ABBREVIATIONS
0. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
0.1 PROJECT BACKGROUND
National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has been entrusted by GoI to implement the development of
stretches of NH under NHDP Phase-III on BOT Mode / EPC mode. NHAI has decided for Development of
the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of
existing 2 lanes of from proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH
13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka.
0.2 NEED OF THE PROJECT
The demand for the project has emerged from the increase of existing traffic numbers plying on the road.
The total traffic in this stretch has crossed 18000 PCUs in 2010, implying that the capacity of existing 2 lane
road with shoulders has already exceeded its capacity. It is estimated that the traffic will grow at 7.71 %,
7.46 %, 5.00 % and 7.48 % for cars, LCVs, 2-axle trucks and multi axle trucks, respectively. This enormous
growth calls for the development of the road to 4 / 6 lanes standards. Thus to enable that the project road is
able to withstand the pressure of the traffic growth, it has been found that the proposed widening of the
existing road to 4 / 6 lanes standards is needed.
0.3 PROJECT ROAD
The project road starts from existing Km 19.440 of NH 13 near Solapur and ends at Km 102.000 on NH-13
near Bijapur and is 82.560 Km long. The proposed length of the project road is 82.342 Km and the road
shall start at Km 28.200 near Solapur and end at Km 110.542 near Bijapur on NH-13.
0.4 PROJECT INFLUENCE AREA
The project districts are Solapur in Maharashtra and Bijapur in Karnataka. The district of Bijapur is bounded
by Gulbarga & Yadgir in North east, Raichur in South, Bagalkot and Belgaum in west and Maharashtara in
North. Solapur district in Maharashtra is bounded by Latur in East, Osmanabad, Pune & Ahmednagar in
North, Satara and Sangli in west and Karnataka in South. The project road falls under Solapur South
(Maharashtra), Indi & Bijapur (Karnataka) Talukas.
The existing Right of Way (RoW) varies from 13.2m to 45 m, as per the details obtained from NH Divisions
of Bijapur & Solapur on an average. The proposed RoW is 60m all throughout except at toll plaza and rest
areas while the Corridor of Impact (CoI) is 75 m respectively. The project area is 500 m on either side of the
project corridor i.e., a total of 1 Km.
0.5 PROJECT PROPONENT
The project proponent is National Highways Authority of India, Government of India.
0.6 PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS
To cater to the future traffic, the project proposes to:
Develop 4 / 6 lane divided carriageway with paved shoulders
In addition the project would improve the geometric deficiencies through curve improvements and the
improvement of the various intersections
The proposed improvement includes repair / rehabilitation of existing cross-drainage (CD) structures on
the highway and provision of new CD structures at appropriate locations
To minimise the adverse impacts on the various settlements bypass proposed at Horti besides 1 major
realignment at Nandani
Service roads are also provided at 5 locations for a total length of 6.538 Km (both sides length). These
locations were proposed based on the proximity to cultural properties, educational and health units, and
size of settlements.
Slip roads are also proposed for a total length of 22.128 Km of at 17 locations
1 cattle, 8 pedestrian and 6 vehicular underpasses have been proposed to ease access of local traffic
and population
2 Toll plazas near Proposed Km 32.100 & Km 82.550 are proposed
2 Rest Area at proposed Km 57.800 near Zalki Town (RHS) & Km 98.800 Near Arikeri Tanda Village
(RHS) & 2 Truck Lay byes at proposed Km 57.800 & Km 98.800 are proposed
Proper drainage, grade-separators, road furniture, utilities and amenities wherever required shall also
be provided
0.7 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT (EIA) STUDY IN THE PROJECT
The Environmental Impact Assessment study of the project road has been carried out as per terms of
reference of NHAI and guidelines given by the Ministry of Environment & Forests, Govt. of India. The study
methodology for the EIA employs a simplistic approach in which the important environmental receptors were
identified during the Environmental Screening phase. Based on the identification baseline data was
generated and then analysed to predict the impacts and quantify them. Avoidance, Mitigation and
Enhancements measures were then developed and these have been incorporated in the Environmental
Management Plan (EMP), design drawings and / or Bills of Quantities as appropriate. Implementation
arrangements including responsibilities of all the actors have been streamlined and documented for future
guidance.
0.8 POLICY, LEGAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK
0.8.1 Institutional Setting
The project has been initiated and is being carried out by the NHAI. The primary responsibility of the project
rests with the NHAI in providing encumbrance free ROW to the concessionaire who shall implement the
project.
0.8.2 Clearances
As part of the project preparations, the Project Proponent shall take the following clearances and NOCs:
Clearance under the Forest (conservation) Act, 1980 for diversion of 2.665 ha of forestland for the
project. The application for forest diversion has also been processed and submitted to the Nodal Officer
in the Forest Department
Tree felling permission from the respective Divisional Forest Officer
Prior Environmental Clearance from EAC of MoEF as per Environmental Impact Assessment
Notification dated 14th September 2006 and its subsequent amendments as additional right of way
requirement for improvement of the project road is more than 20m
Apart from the clearances that the project requires to be obtained by the Project Proponent, the
concessionaire & contractor shall also obtain the required clearances NOCs & licenses from the various
agencies & authorities prior to his work initiation. These are:
NOC and Consents under Air, Water, EP Acts & Noise rules of SPCB for establishing and operating
plants from SPCB. The NOC shall be made available after the SPCB completes the process of
conducting Public Hearing of the project (which shall be carried out as per the Prior Environmental
Clearance process)
NOC under Hazardous Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 from SPCB
PUC certificate for use of vehicles for construction from Department of Transport
Quarry lease deeds and license and Explosive license from Dept. of Geology and Mines & Chief
controller of explosives
NOC for water extraction for construction and allied works from Ground Water Authority
Apart from the above clearances, the concessionaire also has to comply with the following:
Clearance of Engineer for location and layout of Worker’s Camp, Equipment yard and Storage yard.
Clearance of Engineer for Traffic Management Plan for each section of the route after it has been
handed over for construction.
An Emergency Action Plan should be prepared by the contractor and approved by the Engineer for
accidents responding to involving fuel & lubricants before the construction starts.
Submit a Quarry Management Plan to the Engineer along with the Quarry lease deeds
0.9 BASELINE ENVIRONMENTAL PROFILE
0.9.1 Physical Environment
Climate
The climate of the project district is mainly of semi arid type and major part of the project district experiences
hot and dry summer. There are four seasons:
Geology
Geologically, the project district is possessed of Achaean complex composed of crystalline schist, granite
gneisses and granite. The project district is well endowed with mineral deposits like sand stone, white clay,
and plastic clay of the project corridor.
Soil
The project districts have three types of soils viz. Black soils, Red sandy soils and mixed soils. Formation of
various types of soils is a complex function of chemical weathering of bedrocks, vegetative decay and
circulation of precipitated water. Soils are mostly in-situ in nature. Samples of soil have been collected and
are being tested for the physical and chemical properties
Seismicity
The entire stretch of the project highway traverses through sub category seismic zone II of seismic zoning
classification system which is a zone of stability.
Air Quality
The air quality in the project area is generally pristine. The Ambient air qualities were monitored at six
locations and it is found that the concentration of PM 10 is higher than the standards which can be attributed
to the dryness of the area and the dust present along the project corridor. Concentrations of CO, SO2 & NOX
are well within the standards as per the prescribed National Ambient Air Quality Standards.
Noise Quality
It has been observed that noise levels are within the prescribed limits of CPCB, as normally observed in
other National highways. Noise, though is a major area of concern, at locations of sensitive receptors
(educational establishments like schools and colleges, hospitals) identified quite close to the road especially
within the urban areas.
Water Hydrology and Drainage
A number of manmade water bodies and some seasonal water bodies are found in the project area. To
facilitate the cross-drainage at these water crossings, 140 cross-drainage structures are proposed. The
water quality of the surface water samples are within the standards.
0.9.2 Biological Environment
Forest Resources
The alignment of the proposed project road passes along patches of forest lands at alignment is likely to
directly impact the Reserve Forest area at Nandnani The total forestland required for the project is 2.665 ha.
There are no national park and wildlife sanctuary located within the project area.
Trees within ROW
No endangered flora has been reported along the roadside. The trees that are to be felled have been
marked and jointly verified with forest department and a total of 7684 trees of various species have been
identified for felling. The predominant tree species are Acacia sp., Neem (Azadirchta indica), Siris (Albizia
procera), Eucalyptus sp., Banyan (Ficus bengalensis), Peepal (Ficus religiosa), Babul (Acacia nilotica) &
Subabul (Leucaena leucocephela). There are no endangered trees that are to be felled.
Fauna
Domesticated animals mainly constitute the faunal population within the project area. The forest department
have reported the presence of some wild & endangered animals in the forest areas within the project area,
however no such species were reported during the site reconnaissance and survey.
0.9.3 Social Environment
Census Profile
The project highway passes through the districts of Solapur in Maharashtra and Bijapur in Karnataka. As per
the 2011 census, Karnataka has a total population of 61,130,704 and the total male and female population
in the state is 31,057,742 and 31,057,742 respectively. Maharashtra has a total population of 61,130,704
and the total male and female population in the state is 58,361,397and 54,011,575 respectively. The
population density per sq km is 365 in Maharashtra and 319 in Karnataka. The literacy rate of the
Maharashtra is 82.91 and Karnataka is 75.60 while the sex ratios are 946 & 968 respectively. The
population density, sex ratio & literacy rate of the project districts are less than the state level.
Linguistic Distribution
Marathi & Kannada are the major vernacular language spoken by the majority of the people in the project
corridor.
Settlement
A total of 25 major and minor settlements varying in size and populations are present along the project
corridor.
Educational Institutes
There are a number of educational institutes along the existing project corridor. These sensitive receptors
are exposed to dust and noise from the road. Some of these educational institutions are located on the edge
of the road and is a serious concern from the point of safety and Signage and Safety measures are required.
Signage and Safety measures need to be built in the proposed road design at these locations.
Cultural Properties
The project highway traverses through a number of settlements and there are some religious and cultural
properties which though not of archaeological significance are nevertheless, significant to the community.
Places of Historical Importance / Cultural & Archaeological Heritage
The project area does not have any places of historical importance or cultural & Archaeological heritage.
Highway Amenities
There are number of amenities and utility services located along the highway like dhaba, petrol pumps, bus
stops etc. the location of these amenities along the highway is an issue of concern as the haphazard siting
of these amenities is contributing to congestion of the highway. Traffic aid posts and medical aid posts are
proposed. 21 bus bays and bus shelters are also proposed all along the project corridor.
Truck Parking Lay-bys & Rest Areas
There are no parking lay-byes for commercial vehicles along the project road. Many unorganised truck
parking at certain locations on both sides were found in the project corridor creating bottlenecks. 2 Rest
Area at proposed Km 57.800 near Zalki Town (RHS) & Km 98.800 Near Arikeri Tanda Village (RHS) & 2
Truck Lay byes at proposed Km 57.800 & Km 98.800 are proposed.
Land Use / Acquisition of the Proposed Corridor
A total of 128.1196 hectares of land including private and government will be acquired for the construction of
bypass, ROB, Flyover, junction improvement, service roads and two segregated carriageways.
0.10 PUBLIC INTERACTIONS, CONSULTATION & PUBLIC HEARING
Public Interactions & consultations were conducted during the project preparations. The main purpose of
these consultations was to know the community’s reaction to the perceived impact of proposed project on
the people at individual and settlement level. The issues of the most concern were related to rehabilitation
and resettlements and have been dealt in social assessment report. It was also felt during the public
consultation process that most of the people are aware about the project but they did not appreciate
environmental problems associated with road projects. However, some people were concerned about
environmental issues, mainly air and noise pollution. The other concerns raised at during public consultation
were demand for submergence of project road and safety problems. Public Hearing for the project shall be
conducted and the issues raised by the public shall be duly incorporated in project design.
0.11 POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS
The environmental components are mainly impacted during the construction and operational stages of the
project and have to be mitigated for and incorporated in the engineering design. Environmental mitigation
measures represent the project’s endeavour to reduce its environmental footprint to the minimum possible.
These are conscious efforts from the project to reduce undesirable environmental impacts of the proposed
activities and offset these to the degree practicable. Enhancement measures are project’s efforts to gain
acceptability in its area of influence. They reflect the pro-active approach of the project towards
environmental management.
0.11.1 Impacts on Climate
Impact on the climate conditions from the proposed road project widening will not be significant as no major
deforestation and / or removal of vegetation is involved for the project.
0.11.2 Impact on Air Quality
There will be rise in PM10 & PM2.5 levels during the construction activities, which shall again be within
prescribed limit after the construction activities are over.
0.11.3 Impact on Noise Levels
The impact of noise levels from the proposed project on the neighbouring communities is addressed. It has
been concluded that both day and nighttimes equivalent noise levels are within the permissible limits right
from start of project life. Noise sensitive receptors have been identified along the project road.
0.11.4 Impact on Water Resources and Quality
The construction and operation of the proposed project roads will not have any major impacts on the surface
water and the ground water quality in the area. Contamination to water bodies may result due to spilling of
construction materials, oil, grease, fuel and paint in the equipment yards and asphalt plants. This will be
more prominent in case of locations where the project road crosses rivers, canals distributaries, etc.
Mitigation measures have been planned to avoid contamination of these water bodies.
0.11.5 Impact on Ecological Resources
There is no major loss of vegetation hence adverse impact in terms of availability of nesting sites for the bird
doesn’t arise. Furthermore, there is no sensitive ecological area along the existing project roads, so the
impact will be insignificant during construction period. But on the long run the project shall have a positive
impact due to the compensatory forestation and avenue plantation.
0.11.6 Impact on Land
During the construction of the proposed project, the topography will change due to excavation of borrow
areas, stone quarrying, cuts and fills for project road and construction of project related structures etc.
Provision of construction yard for material handling will also alter the existing topography. The change in
topography will also be due to the probable induced developments of the project. Benefits in the form of land
levelling and tree plantations in the vicinity of the project road shall enhance the local aesthetics.
0.11.7 Impact on Human Use Values
The PAPs shall be compensated as per the RAP. Accidents are bound to increase coupled with ribbon
development. There shall also be some impacts on cultural or religious properties along the corridor.
0.12 ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
Detailed analyses of the alternatives have been conducted taking into account both with and without project
scenario and the available alignment options. The analysis also dealt with the justification of selections of
the proposed alignment and the modifications on it due to environmental considerations, realignment and
bypasses and the minimisation of negative impacts. Based on all these alternative studies the present
alignment was proposed.
0.13 MITIGATION AVOIDANCE AND ENHANCEMENT MEASURES
Both generic and site specific mitigation and enhancement measures have been planned for identified
adverse environmental impacts. The construction workers camp will be located at least 500m away from
habitations. The construction yard, hot mix plants, crushers etc. will be located at 500m away from
habitations and in downwind directions. Adequate cross drainage structures have been planned to maintain
proper cross drainage. In order to compensate negative impacts on flora due to cutting of trees the project
plans compensatory plantation in the ratio of 1:2 i.e. for every tree to be cut, two trees will be planted. The
project shall also witness the plantation of trees for providing aesthetic beauty and shade. Approximately
7684 trees of various species have been identified along the proposed alignment for felling. A total of 15368
trees are to be planted to compensate the loss at a ratio of 1:2. A total of 27420 trees as avenue plantation
and 82342 ornamental, medicinal & flowering plants and shrubs in the median are proposed. In order to
rd
minimise the negative impact of tree felling, it is also proposed to transplant a minimum of 1/3 of trees
proposed for felling. Thus 2562 trees are proposed for transplantation and the cost has been budgeted.
The plantation of trees shall be done subject to availability of space in the proposed ROW . The project will
take an opportunity to provide environmental enhancement measures to improve aesthetics in the project
area. The planned environmental enhancement measures include plantation in available clear space in
ROW, enhancement of water bodies etc. In order to avoid contamination of water bodies during construction
sedimentation chambers, oils and grease separators, oil interceptors at storage areas and at construction
yard have been planned.
0.14 INSTITUTIONAL REQUIREMENTS AND ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PLAN
The responsibility of implementing the mitigation measures and all activities under environmental
management plan (EMP) lies with the concessionaire (selected through International Competitive Bidding)
through the contractor. All construction activities being taken up by the contractor under the concessionaire
shall be scrutinised by the Independent Engineer who in turn shall report to the NHAI. Presently the NHAI is
fully equipped to meet the challenges of implementation of the environmental mitigation measures in the
EMP. The implementation of RAP shall be as per the details given in the RAP report. In the pre-construction
phase of the project the independent Engineer shall review the EMP and RAP to identify environmental and
social issues and arrive at a suitable strategy for implementation.
For effective implementation and management of the EMP, the Concessionaire shall contrive to establish a
Safety, Health and Environment (SHE) Cell headed by an Environment Officer to deal with the
environmental issues of the project. This officer shall interact with the contractor, NHAI, IC and other
departments to ensure that the mitigation and enhancement measures mentioned in the EMP are adhered.
The Environmental officer of the concessionaire shall be the interface between the Environmental Specialist
of IE and the Environmental Officer of the contractor. His prime responsibility shall be to apprise the
Environmental Specialist of the IE about the ground conditions. He shall also procure the requisite
clearances and the NOCs for the project and shall also strictly supervise that the contractor adheres to the
EMP. The officer shall also participate in training programmes and assist the IE in preparing documentation
for good practices in environmental protection.
This Environmental officer of the concessionaire should ideally be a Postgraduate in Environmental Science
/ Environmental Management / Zoology / Botany / Ecology / Environmental Engineer / Environmental
Planning. The EO should have 10 years of total experience with a minimum of 3 years in the implementation
of EMP of highway projects and an understanding of environmental issues. The environmental officer can
also look after the additional charges of safety and health. The Environmental Officer of the contractor
should ideally be a Postgraduate in Environmental Science / Environmental Management / Zoology / Botany
/ Ecology / Environmental Planning / Environmental Engineer. The Environment Officer should have 5 years
of experience with a minimum of 2 years in the implementation of EMP of highway projects and an
understanding of environmental, health and safety issues. The Environmental Officer of the contractor shall
report directly to the Resident Construction Manager / Project Manager so that the pertinent environmental
issues that he raises are promptly dealt with. He shall also have a direct interaction with the Environmental
Expert and the Environmental Officer of the IC and the concessionaire respectively.
The reporting system will operate linearly – contractor who is at the lowest rung of the implementation
system reporting to the Concessionaire, who in turn shall report to IC and the NHAI. All reporting by the
concessionaire shall be on a quarterly basis, while the reporting time of the contractor shall be decided upon
by the concessionaire. The NHAI Site Office will be responsible for setting the targets for the various
activities anticipated during construction phase in consultation with the IC and obtaining agreement from the
Contractor after mobilisation but before beginning of works on site. The contractor will report from then on
regarding the status on each of these. The NHAI Site Office will monitor the activities through its own staff or
the consultant’s Environmental Specialist after it has obtained the Contractor’s report with the Consultant’s
remarks on it during the construction phase. During the operation phase, the supervision as well as reporting
1. INTRODUCTORY BACKGROUND
1.1 INTRODUCTION
National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has been entrusted by GoI to implement the development of
stretches of NH under NHDP Phase-III on BOT Mode / EPC mode. NHAI has decided for Development of
the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of
existing 2 lanes of from proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH
13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka.
1.2 NEED OF THE PROJECT
The demand for the project has emerged from the increase of existing traffic numbers plying on the road.
The total traffic in this stretch has crossed 18000 PCUs in 2010, implying that the capacity of existing 2 lane
road with shoulders has already exceeded its capacity. It is estimated that the traffic will grow at 7.71 %,
7.46 %, 5.00 % and 7.48 % for cars, LCVs, 2-axle trucks and multi axle trucks, respectively. This enormous
growth calls for the development of the road to 4 / 6 lanes standards. Thus to enable that the project road is
able to withstand the pressure of the traffic growth, it has been found that the proposed widening of the
existing road to 4 / 6 lanes standards is needed.
1.3 PROJECT ROAD
The project road starts from existing Km 19.440 of NH 13 near Solapur and ends at Km 102.000 on NH-13
near Bijapur and is 82.560 Km long. The proposed length of the project road is 82.342 Km and the road
shall start at Km 28.200 near Solapur and end at Km 110.542 near Bijapur on NH-13. The location of the
project road is presented in Figure 1.1.
Figure 1-1: Location of Project Road
Environmental
Sl. No. Valued Ecosystem Components
Attributes
Total number of drinking water sources (wells, hand pumps, community water points / taps
7 Drinking water sources
etc.) within COI
8 Religious Structures Temples, shrines, mosque, church, gurudwara etc. within COI
Number (total) of cultural properties (protected / unprotected archaeological monuments)
10 Cultural Properties
within 500m from the road
Number (total) of weekly market places / haats; grain / fruit / vegetable / fish market; cattle
11 Market Places
market within COI
CPRs such as pastures / grazing lands; seating areas of the community; cremation/burial
Common Property
12 grounds etc. within / along the RoW (All CPRs other than religious structures, drinking water
Resources
sources and bus stops) within COI
13 Other features Flood Plains; Soil Erosion; stone quarries etc.
After identification and compilation of VEC list, assessment to what extent proposed total road construction
would affect each VEC has been made. To arrive at the nature and significant impacts, numerical values
were assigned for each VEC and combined them all in a single overall measure of the impact as per details
in the table below:
Table 1-2: Weightage and Ranking System Adopted
Total
Environmental Attribute Scoring Criteria Score
Weight
Natural Environment
Plains 1
Rolling terrain 2
Topography 4
Flood plains/coastal belt 3
Hilly/mountainous terrain 4
Vulnerability to natural hazards (such Not prone at all 1
as floods, cyclones, cloud burst, Rare occurrence 2
4
landslide, subsidence, earthquake Prone to natural disasters/risks 3
etc.) Highly prone to natural disasters (regular occurrence) 4
5 or less 1
Number (average) of water bodies per km 6 to 10 2
Surface water resources 5 crossings as well as water bodies within 11 to 15 3
100m on either side of the road 16 to 20 4
21 or more 5
2 or less 1
Over-topping and / or water logging within 3 to 4 2
Drainage Conditions 5 100m on either side of the existing Centre 5 to 6 3
line 6 to 7 4
7 or more 5
Yes (if the project falls
partially or fully within
Is ground water availability / extraction an 4
Ground water resources 4 ‘dark’ or ‘over-exploited’
issue in project? blocks )
No 0
Within 50 km 1
50 to 100 km 2
Materials Availability 4 Availability of stone quarries
100 to 200 km 3
More than 200 km 4
Not at all 1
Is soil erosion an issue in / along the sub- To some extent 2
Soil Erosion 4
project road? Critical 3
Very critical 4
Sub Total 30 - - -
Biological Environment
Presence of designated protected areas Yes 10
Designated Protected Areas 10 within 15 Km from the proposed project
location boundary No 0
Occurrences outside designated protected Within 5 Km 6
Wildlife habitats 6 areas from the proposed sub-project 5 To 10 Km 4
location boundary 10 km or more 2
Migratory route / crossing of wild Crossing project road or within 500 m from Yes 6
6
animals and birds the proposed project location boundary No 0
Presence of RF within 100m from either side Yes 5
Reserved Forests 5
of the existing Centre line No 0
Protected or Other Forests 5 Length of forests along the road within 100m Less than 5 Km 1
Total
Environmental Attribute Scoring Criteria Score
Weight
from either side of the existing Centre line 5 To 10 Km 2
10 To 15 Km 3
15 To 20 Km 4
20 Km or more 5
2 Km or less 1
Length of green tunnel/s within 30m (on 2 Km To 5 Km 2
Green tunnels 4
either side) along the road 5 Km To 10 Km 3
10 Km or more 4
Up to 1000 1
Road side trees (broad estimate, 1000 to 2000 2
specific numbers, girth and species 4 Number of trees likely to be affected
details etc. shall be presented) 2000 to 4000 3
More than 4000 4
Total 40 - - -
Social Environment
10 Km or less 1
Total length of settlement sections (both 10 to 20 Km 2
Settlements 5 towns and villages) abutting the road 20 to 30 Km 3
corridor 30 to 40 Km 4
40 Km or more 5
10 or less 1
Number (total) of sensitive receptors within 11 to 20 2
Sensitive Receptors 5 50m on either side of the road (such as 21 to 30 3
educational and health facilities) 31 to 40 4
41 or more 5
10 or less 1
Total number of drinking water sources 11 to 20 2
Drinking water sources 4 (wells, hand pumps, community water
points/taps etc.) within COI 21 to 30 3
31 or more 4
10 or less 1
Number (total) of religious structures 11 to 20 2
Religious Structures 4 (temples, shrines, mosque, church,
gurudwara) within COI 21 to 30 3
31 or more 4
2 or less 1
Number (total) of cultural properties 3 to 5 2
Cultural Properties 4 (protected / unprotected archaeological
monuments) within 500m from the road 6 to 8 3
More than 8 4
5 or less 1
Number (total) of weekly market places / 6 to 10 2
Market Places 4 haats; grain / fruit / vegetable / fish market;
cattle market within COI 11 to 15 3
15 or more 4
Common Property Resources (All Number (total) of CPRs (such as pastures / 5 or less 1
CPRs other than religious structures, grazing lands; seating areas of the 6 to 10 2
4
drinking water sources and bus community; cremation / burial grounds etc.) 11 to 15 3
stops) within / along the COI 15 or more 4
Total 30 - - -
Grand Total 100 - - -
than 30cm that are falling within the proposed ROW shall be marked on the ground. Based on the survey a
tree schedule has been prepared for submission to the authorities.
In order to quantify the impacts of the project road on various receptors a survey was carried out. The
receptors included educational institutes, hospitals, cultural & religious properties and community properties.
Table 1-3: Primary and Secondary Information Sources
Environmental Parameters Information Sources
Project objectives, Technical information on
ToR, Design Report
existing road features
Inventory of road features like water Bodies,
Community structures, environmentally
Ground Physical surveys
sensitive locations areas, congested locations
etc.
Status of Environment report on Karnataka by SPCB, Envis and other Websites
(www.envfor.nic.in, http://www.bijapur.nic.in, http://solapur.gov.in, http://mpcb.gov.in,
Climatic Condition
http://parisaramahiti.kar.nic.in, http://kspcb.gov.in, etc.), Feasibility report, primary
data collection
State of Environment report published by SPCB, government websites and
Geology, Seismicity, Soil and Topography feasibility report, primary data collection (http://raitamitra.kar.nic.in),
http://parisaramahiti.kar.nic.in etc.)
Land Use / Land Cover Survey of India (SoI) Toposheets, Satellite imagery and Observation during surveys
Drainage Pattern Survey of India Toposheet, water resources, field observation and local people
Status of forest areas, Compensatory
Divisional Forest Office
afforestation norms etc.
Air quality Noise, Soil and Water Onsite monitoring and Analysis of Field samples
Borrow Areas, Quarries and other construction
Material Surveys and public consultations
material source
River geo-morphology, hydrology, drainage,
Feasibility report and information from local people, field observations
flood patterns
Different Govt. agencies/civic bodies, Official websites maintained by state Govt.,
Socioeconomic Environment
census of India 2001 / 2011 and Public Consultation during the Field survey
1.8.4 Consultations
Consultations with community members, PAPs Focus Group Discussions with teachers, women groups and
others and stakeholder meeting with the NHAI were carried out. The feedback generated through these
meetings has been incorporated as far as possible in the design and construction of the road. The
consultation process shall continue even during the implementation stage to gauge the general opinion. The
details are elaborated in chapter 5.
1.8.5 Assessment of Impacts
Assessments of general potential impacts were done based on the baseline data. Assessment of the
environmental impacts was carried out to ascertain that the direct and indirect impacts likely to be induced
due to the project are being adequately identified and addressed. The general impacts are land acquisition
and allied impacts on society, dust and air pollution due to removal of structures, trees and vegetation,
quarrying and other construction activities; noise pollution due to construction, loss of flora and its impacts
on the ecology and impacts on water resources. The chapter on Impacts assessment details out the
impacts.
1.8.6 Assessment of Alternatives
Various project alternatives including with and without scenarios have been assessed during the project.
The assessment of alternatives included that of realignments, widening options, service roads, noise barriers
in sensitive areas etc. The chapter on Analysis of Alternatives elaborates the process.
1.8.7 Mitigations and Enhancement Measures
All affirmative actions not only to avoid and deter but also to capitalise on the opportunities provided by the
project in order to improve the environmental conditions have been deliberated. The various mitigation and
enhancement measures proposed have been included in the environmental budget and also in the technical
specifications for the aid of the concessionaire. Based on their applicability, both general and case specific
measures were incorporated as follows:
Generic measures: To avoid or mitigate impacts on environmental components, general mitigation
measures were identified based on the characteristic features.
Site Specific: At representative sensitive locations, site-specific mitigation measures and
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
1-5
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
This Chapter describes the project road and discusses the various improvement measures proposed as part
of the project. The project description includes details of existing condition of project road, existing and
proposed traffic, pavement conditions, road inventory, safety and community facilities.
2.1 EXISTING ROAD FEATURES
2.1.1 Alignment
The project highway is a 2 Lane undivided carriageway
Earthen (unpaved) shoulders exist for almost entire length of the highway with width varying from 1 to
1.5 m
78% of the pavement condition is good (68.900 Km) followed by 15% fair (13.300 Km) & 7% poor
(6.300 Km )
A total of about 146 horizontal curves (which include 74 left hand curves and 72 right hand curves) and
about 514 vertical curves (254 summit curves and 260 valley curves) exist along the alignment.
The existing pavement for the entire stretch is of bituminous surface
Submergence isn’t reported. Road side drains are present in urban parts but they are either non-
functional or partially functioning
Table 2-1: Existing Cross Section details
Carriageway Width (m) Paved Shoulder Width (m) Earthen Shoulder Width (m) Embankment Height ( m)
7 0-1.5 1-1.5 0-3
11 Typical Cross Sections for widening of the project road in urban, semi urban and rural areas has
been developed based on guidelines of IRC and are depicted in Figure 2.1.
As this is a PPP project, only the horizontal alignment has been fixed and the concessionaire shall
develop cross sections at every 25m.
Table 2-3: Widening Options
Sl. No. Widening Option Total Length Remarks
1 Eccentric 67.043 Due to curve improvement or parallel addition of Structure
2 Concentric 8.484 To remove disparity and to negate more LA
3 Bypass / Realignment 6.815 To reduce social impacts & provide better geometrics
Total 82.342
2.2.3 Pavement
Flexible pavements are proposed for all throughout the road except at the toll plazas where rigid
pavement is proposed. This is due to the high cost of construction involved for rigid pavements.
2.2.4 Geometric Design Aspects
All geometric design aspects have been carried out as per the IRC and MoRT&H standards and
specifications. Adequate warnings have been provided for maintaining continuity has been emphasised
in the design.
The existing profile has been maintained all as far as possible
The design speed has been kept quite consistent, and speed difference between two consecutive
curves is not exceeded. All horizontal curves are designed for 100kmph as detailed in table 2.4
Table 2-4: Summary of Proposed Horizontal Alignment
Radius of Curve (m) Design Speed (Kmph)
Total No of Curves
0-199 200-499 500-899 900-1999 >2000 15-35 50-65 80 100
121 0 7 27 35 32 0 0 0 121
This chapter reviews the existing institutional and legislative set-up pertaining to the project at the National
and state levels. The chapter also elaborates on the various clearances and permissions required for the
project from Government of Karnataka, Ministry of Environment and forests, Government of India.
3.1 INSTITUTIONAL SETTING
The project has been initiated and is being carried out by the NHAI. The primary responsibility of the project
rests with the NHAI in providing encumbrance free ROW to the concessionaire who shall implement the
project. The main government agencies who uphold the implementation of the various environmental
legislations are:
Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India (MoEF), New Delhi formulates and regulates
all country level legislations besides giving prior environmental clearances through a committee for
category A projects, wild life clearances and forest diversion clearances.
State Level Environmental Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA), in the states gives prior
environmental clearances to category B projects.
Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) monitors and implements pollution related legislations
State Pollution Control Board monitors and implements pollution related legislations in the state
besides giving NOC for establishing and operating plants under air and water acts
State Department of Forests gives permission for forest diversion and felling of trees
3.2 THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK
The Government of India and the Governments of Maharashtra & Karnataka have formulated a host policy
guidelines; acts and regulations aimed at protection and enhancement of environmental resources. The
following sections discuss the various legal issues associated with the project.
3.2.1 Country Level Environmental Legislations
Table 3-1 provides the legislations pertaining to the project that has been framed by the Govt. of India.
Table 3-1: Country Level Environmental Laws & Regulations
Implementing /
Sl. Law / Regulation / Applicable
Relevance Reason for application Responsible
No. Guidelines Yes / No
Agency
The Environmental
(Protection) Act. MoEF, State
Umbrella Act. Protection and All environmental
1986, and the Department of
improvement of the environment. notifications, rules and
1 Environmental Yes Environment,
Establishes the standards for schedules are issued
(Protection) Rules, CPCB and
emission of noise in the atmosphere. under the act
1987-2002 (various KSPCB
amendments)
Identifies “(i) New National The project Highway is a
Highways; and (ii) Expansion of National Highway which is
The EIA Notification, National Highways greater than 30 more than 30 Km and
14th September 2006 Km involving additional right of way involves additional right of
2 Yes MoEF
and subsequent greater than 20m involving land way greater than 20m
amendments acquisition" under (item 7 (f) of involving land acquisition
schedule) as one of the projects and hence is a Category
requiring prior clearance A project
Reuse fly ash discharged from
Thermal Power Station to minimise
Notification for use of land use for dispersal and minimise No Thermal Power station
3 Fly ash, 3rd borrow area material. The onus shall No located in 100 Km radius MoEF, SPCB
November 2009 lie with the implementing authority to of road
use fly ash unless it is not feasible as
per IRC
Central and State Pollution Control
Board to establish/enforce water
The Water Consent required for not Karnataka &
quality and effluent standards,
(Prevention and polluting ground and Maharashtra
4 monitor water quality, prosecute Yes
Control of Pollution) surface water during Pollution Control
offenders, and issue licenses for
Act, 1974 construction Boards
construction/operation of certain
facilities.
The Air (Prevention Empowers SPCB to set and monitor Consent required for Karnataka &
5 Yes
and Control of air quality standards and to prosecute establishing and operation Maharashtra
Implementing /
Sl. Law / Regulation / Applicable
Relevance Reason for application Responsible
No. Guidelines Yes / No
Agency
Pollution) Act. 1981 offenders, excluding vehicular air and of plants and crushers Pollution Control
noise emission. Boards
construction machineries Karnataka &
Noise Pollution
Standards for noise emission for and vehicles to conform to Maharashtra
6 (Regulation And Yes
various land uses the standards for Pollution Control
Control) Act, 1990
construction Boards
Conservation and definition of forest State Forest
Forest (Conservation) Forest land diversion for
7 areas. Diversion of forest land follows Yes Department,
Act, 1980 the project
the process as laid by the act MoEF
Coastal Regulatory The project area is not MoEF, State
8 Zone Notification, Protect and manage coastal areas No within designated coastal Department of
2011 zone Environment
State Forest
Wild Life Protection Protection of wild life in sanctuaries No sanctuaries / national
9 No Department,
Act, 1972 and National Park park in the project area
MoEF
Ancient Monuments Archaeological
No Archaeological
and Archaeological To protect and conserve cultural and Survey of India,
10 No monument area in the
sites and Remains historical remains found. Dept. of
project area
Act 1958 Archaeology
Empowers State Transport Authority
All vehicles used for
to enforce standards for vehicular State Motor
The Motor Vehicle construction will need to
11 pollution. From August 1997 the Yes Vehicles
Act. 1988 comply with the provisions
"Pollution Under Control Certificate is Department
of this act.
issued to reduce vehicular emissions.
Sets out the regulations as to regards If new quarrying operation
The Explosives Act
the use of explosives and is started by the Chief Controller
12 (& Rules) 1884 Yes
precautionary measures while concessionaire / of Explosives
(1983)
blasting & quarrying. contractor
Hazardous materials shall
Public Liability And Protection to the general public from
13 Yes be used for road
Insurance Act,1991 accidents due to hazardous materials
construction
Hazardous wastes shall
Hazardous Wastes Karnataka &
Protection to the general public be generated due to
(Management and Maharashtra
14 against improper handling and Yes activities like of
Handling) Rules, Pollution Control
disposal of hazardous wastes maintenance and repair
1989 Boards
work on vehicles
Chemical Accidents
(Emergency Handling of hazardous District & Local
Protection against chemical accident
Planning, (flammable, toxic and Crisis Group
15 while handling any hazardous Yes
Preparedness and explosive) chemicals headed by the
chemicals resulting
Response) Rules, during road construction DM and SDM
1996
Mines and Minerals
(Regulation and Permission of Sand Department of
Permission of Mining of aggregates
16 Development) Act, Yes Mining from river bed & Mining Govt. of
and sand
1957 as amended in aggregates Karnataka
1972
The Building and
Other Construction
Workers (Regulation Employing Labour / District Labour
17 Employing Labour / workers Yes
of Employment and workers Commissioner
Conditions of
Service) Act, 1996
3.4 CONCLUSION
The project requires prior environmental clearance, clearance for the diversion of forest land and permission
for cutting the trees within the proposed ROW. In addition to the above, the concessionaire would require
the following NOCs & licenses from the authorities during construction:
NOC & Consents under Air, Water, EP Acts & Noise rules for establishing & operating plants from
SPCB
NOC under Hazardous Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 from SPCB
PUC certificate for use of vehicles for construction from Department of Transport
Quarry lease deeds and license and Explosive license from Dept. of Geology and Mines & Chief
controller of explosives
NOC for water extraction for construction and allied works from Ground Water Authority
Apart from the above clearances, the concessionaire also has to comply with the following:
Clearance of Engineer for location and layout of Worker’s Camp, Equipment yard and Storage yard
Clearance of Engineer for Traffic Management Plan for each section of the route after it has been
handed over for construction
An Emergency Action Plan should be prepared by the contractor and approved by the Engineer for
accidents responding to involving fuel & lubricants before the construction starts
Submit a Quarry Management Plan to the Engineer along with the Quarry lease deeds
This chapter assess the nature, type and dimensions of the study area and describes the physical,
biological, culture components along the Road. The baseline data on the environmental components was
generated by primary surveys conducted during project preparation, interactions at various levels with local
people and other stakeholders. The socio-economic profile has been distilled from the RAP Report.
4.1 PROJECT AREA
The project districts are Solapur in Maharashtra and Bijapur in Karnataka State. The district of Bijapur is
bounded by Gulbarga & Yadgir in North east, Raichur in South, Bagalkot and Belgaum in west and
Maharashtara in North. Solapur district in Maharashtra is bounded by Latur in East, Osmanabad, Pune &
Ahmednagar in North, Satara and Sangli in west and Karnataka in South. The project road falls under
Solapur South (Maharashtra), Indi & Bijapur (Karnataka) Talukas.
The existing Right of Way (RoW) varies from 13.2m to 45 m, as per the details obtained from NH Divisions
of Bijapur & Solapur on an average. The proposed RoW is 60m all throughout except at toll plaza and rest
areas while the Corridor of Impact (CoI) is 75 m respectively. The project area is 500 m on either side of the
project corridor i.e., a total of 1 Km.
4.2 PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT
4.2.1 Meteorology
The study of Meteorological and micro meteorological parameters is significant in a road project as these
parameters regulate transport and diffusion of pollutants released into the atmosphere. The following
sections describe the key elements of the climate, viz., temperature, wind, rainfall and relative humidity and
evaporation.
Climate
The climate of the project district is mainly of semi arid type and major part of the project district experiences
hot and dry summer. The weather of the project district is influenced by the Southwest and Northeast
monsoon. The summer season is from March to the end of May and remains under the influence of
Southwest monsoon during June to September, while in October and November, the retreating monsoon
prevails. The climate is distinguished by four seasons:
Hot Summer (from March to May),
South west monsoon season (from June to September)
Post monsoon season (October and November)
Cold winter (from December to February)
Temperature
o
May is the hottest month with a mean max of 43C. Mean (Min) and daily temperature is 25.5 C and the
o
mean (max) is 38.1 C. With the advance of south west monsoon into the area, by the middle of June, day
temperature drop is observed. By about the first week of October the monsoon, the temperature drops to
about 18C. The monthly temperature range is smallest in August because of overcast conditions and
largest in March on the contrary.
Rainfall
About 60% of the annual rainfall is received during June to September, while 24% is received in October
and November during the period of retreating monsoon. Average annual rainfall recorded is 553 mm.
4.2.2 Land
Seismicity
The southern part of India in which the project road lies comes under the stable seismic zone. The entire
stretch of the project highway traverses through sub category seismic zone II of seismic zoning classification
1
system as defined by the Seismic Zoning Committee . Zone II is most stable and zone V is considered to be
1
IS 1893(Part 1):2002 ‘Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures: Part 1 General provisions and
Buildings’
least stable. In the revision of the seismic zones in year 2000, the seismic Zone I has been merged in Zone
II by BIS. The project corridor thus is in a zone of stability.
Figure 4-1: Seismic Zones of India
Sl.
Location of Receptor Criteria for Selection
No
institutes, hospitals, forest areas, etc. existing pollution levels
In rural areas that present a pristine As a representative sample for obtaining the concentrations in rural areas and
2
environment to benchmark existing pollution levels
As a representative for concentrations in industrial areas and also to check the
3 Near Industrial areas
available concentrations and to benchmark existing pollution levels
zone, then the ground waters occurs in it. The massive basalt showing spheroidal weathering and exfoliation
have more groundwater carrying capacity than the unweathered massive trap. However, the water carrying
capacity of the massive trap is not homogenous as it is completely depends upon the presence of fractures
and joints, their nature, distribution and interconnection. All along the project road, there exist a large
number of hand pumps and wells within the ROW. These community owned resources are the major
sources of potable water. As per CGWB there are no notified blocks in Bijapur District. 30% of Bijapur Taluk
& 29% of Indi Taluk falls in critical area. The Post-monsoon Depth to water level range in Bijapur District
during 2006 was 0.78 – 13.20 m. No information on Solapur has been available from CGWB
Water Quality
Selection of Sampling Location
6 representative surface water and ground water monitoring stations were selected based on their
importance as source of irrigation and water supply, size, future impacts and quantum of water available.
The physical and chemical parameters of the collected samples were tested as per established standard
methods and procedures. The samples were collected on by Envirotech East Pvt. Ltd for testing on behalf of
Feedback Infra. The locations selected for water sampling are presented in table below. The monitoring has
been carried out with the following objectives:
To establish the baseline water quality at critical locations to be impacted; and
To work out the extent of enhancement of water resources along the corridor in terms of improvement
of water quality.
Table 4-6: Details of Water Quality Monitoring Station
Sl. No. Location Code Chainage (Km) Location
1 SWQMS 1 30.340 Bhima River
2 SWQMS 2 42.500 Canal near Yelgi
3 SWQMS 3 55.000 Gundavana
4 SWQMS 4 90.240 Bhutnal
5 GWQMS 1 25.000 Nandani Village
6 GWQMS 2 49.000 Zalki
GWQMS 3 65.000 Horti
GWQMS 4 85.000 Arakari Tunda
2
Source: Indian Standard Drinking Water Specification – IS 10500, 1994
Sl. No. Parameter Unit SWQMS 1 SWQMS 2 SWQMS 3 SWQMS 4 Max Desirable Limit2
19. Lead mg/l BDL BDL BDL BDL 0.05
20. Manganese mg/l BDL BDL BDL BDL 0.1
21. Zinc mg/l BDL BDL BDL BDL 5
22. Dissolve Oxygen mg/l 2.6 2 4.0 5.1 4
23. BOD(3days) at 270c mg/l 4.2 5.3 3.5 2.9 -
24. COD mg/l 18 20 11.2 8.2 -
marginally higher than the noise standards. This may be due to mix activities as well as vehicular movement
on the road. Noise, though is a major area of concern, at locations of sensitive receptors (educational
establishments like schools and colleges, health units etc.) identified quite close to the road.
Table 4-9: Observed Noise Levels along Road
Monitoring Observed Noise Levels Noise Quality Standards
Station Location Area Category in dB (A) in dB (A)
Code Leq Day Leq Night Leq Day Leq Night
N1 SH 149 & NH 13 Crossing Residential / Rural 49.2 42.8 55 45
N2 M. New Check Post Commercial 49.7 44.1 65 55
N3 Zalki Residential 48.8 42.6 55 45
N4 Horti Commercial / Residential 48.95 42.35 65 / 55 55 / 45
N5 Domonal Residential 46.23 42.34 55 45
N6 Arakri Tunda Residential 40.51 35.63 55 45
Source: Field Monitoring; Note: The area categorisation has been done by the consultants based on the
sensitive features and not by the authorities.
4.3 BIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENT
4.3.1 Forest Areas
As per DCF, Solapur Division and the Forest Plans available with the division, the forest in the project area
in Solapur division fall under 6A/C1 – Southern Tropical Thorn Forest. The alignment of the proposed project
road shall divert forest lands from RF in Nandani under Solapur Forest Division in Solapur district of
Maharashtra. There are no forest lands involved in Karnataka. There are no national park and wildlife
sanctuary located within 10 Km radius of the project.
Table 4-10: Forest Areas along the Project Road
Proposed
Sl. Chainage (Km) Length Forest Survey Gat
Side Village Compartment Division Remark
No. (Km) Details No. No.
From To
Nandani
1 33.275 33.810 1.535 Both Nandani RF 138 104 3 Solapur
Realignment
5. PUBLIC INTERACTIONS
As a part of the project preparation and to ensure that the community support is obtained and the project
supports the felt needs of the people; public consultations were carried out as an integral component. A
continuous involvement of the stakeholders and the affected community was obtained. The feedback in the
consultation sessions has led to substantial inputs for the project preparation – including, influencing
designs. Consultations involve soliciting people’s views on proposed actions and engaging them in a
dialogue. It is a two-way information flow, from project authorities to people and, from people to project
authorities. While decision making authority would be retained by the project authority, interaction with
people and eliciting feedback allows affected populations to influence the decision making process by
raising issues that should be considered in designing, mitigation, monitoring and management plans and the
analysis of alternatives.
This chapter documents the issues that are close to the community, their aspirations and their addressal by
the project. Information source for the chapter has been the similar documentation as part of the RAP, with
the social team conducting these sessions. The objectives of consultation sessions, the procedure adopted
and the outputs of the consultation conducted have been briefly described in the following sections.
5.1 OBJECTIVES
The main objective of the consultation process is to minimise negative impacts of the project and to
maximise the benefits from the project to the local populace. The objectives of public consultation as part of
this project are:
Promote public awareness and improve understanding of the potential impacts of proposed projects;
Identify alternative sites or designs, and mitigation measures;
Solicit the views of affected communities / individuals on environmental and social problems;
Improve environmental and social soundness;
Clarify values and trade-offs associated with the different alternatives;
Identify contentious local issues which might jeopardise the implementation of the project;
Establish transparent procedures for carrying out proposed works;
Inform the affected populace about the entitlement framework and to settle problems with mutual
consent; and
Create accountability and sense of local ownership during project implementation.
5.2 CONSULTATION SESSIONS
Consultations were done using various tools including, interviews with government officials, questionnaire-
based information with stakeholders etc. The public consultation carried out during the Environment impact
Assessment stages of the project has been summarised.
The extent or the likely level of adverse impacts was one of the major criteria in deciding locations for public
consultation sessions. A listing of the various consultation sessions conducted at different locations along
the entire project corridor is presented in Table 5-1. These community consultations were held during
various times of the design period and were attended by the NHAI staffs, Consultant’s Environmental and
Social experts.
Table 5-1: Public Consultation held at Different Stages of Project
Level Type Key Participants
Individual Local level Consultation People along the project corridor
Village Focus Group Discussion Women, truckers, weaker sections, agriculturist, School teachers
Institutional Stake holder Discussion Line departments
Sl.
Settlement Place Issues / Concern Mitigation measures
No.
Lack of traffic signal and Provision of traffic signs
Hattur
signs Provision of Service / slip roads
Impact on the structures Provision of bypass & realignments
Congestion and traffic jam R&R as per NPRR and NHAI policies
Road Side
1
Eatery LA and R&R issues Safety measures to be strictly followed by
Safety during construction concessionaire and contractor
Health issues during Labour camps to be located away from settlements
construction Provision of PUP & VUP
Location of labour camps Employment opportunities during construction and
Issues in street crossing operation stage
Start of Project
2 Solapur Employment opportunities Concessionaire & contractor shall follow the measures
Road
Other General Issues given in EMP
Safety issues
Involvement of PAPs in Rehabilitation and Resettlement Plans & Resettlement Options
Impact on property and land acquisition
Enhancement of common property resources
Extension of Government Welfare schemes
5.4 CONTINUED CONSULTATION
As part of the continued consultation program, the following actions are proposed:
Conduct Public Hearing for the project at all the districts through which the project road is passing
Implement the suggestions / recommendations and address those grievances that are technically
feasible without compromising on the quality and safety
Continue consultations with the public and stake holders during the various stages of the construction
and operation for smooth implementation of the project
Table 5-3: Addressal of General Issues and Concerns under the Project
Issue / Concern Addressal under the project
Plantation of trees and shrubs along the highway and on median
Dust and Air Pollution Turfing on earthen slopes and earthen shoulders
Water spraying to be adopted near the crushers during construction stage.
Provision of Noise attenuating wall near sensitive receptors
No-horns signage near schools, colleges and hospitals
Increased noise levels
Tree plantation and development of green belts along the project corridor abutting settlements to
attenuate traffic noise
Improvement of intersections
Traffic Congestion Provision of Flyovers, bypasses, underpasses and service lanes etc at suitable locations
Road widening itself will be a major factor to avoid traffic jams
Provision of Service lane to separate local traffic from through traffic
Proper highway signals provided
Road safety Widening of bridges to avoid accidents
Grade level pedestrian crossing
Proper lighting at accident prone locations
Care has been taken to preserve sites of cultural heritage as far as possible.
Cultural properties Where unavoidable the religious structures within ROW to be relocated only after consultation
with local community.
Tree clearing within ROW has been avoided beyond what is directly required for construction
activities and or to reduce accidents
Fauna and flora
Compensatory afforestation would be done as per the directives of the forest department.
Fruit bearing trees and shade trees, to be planted on the roadside.
Rising of road sections and cross drainage structures in areas facing overtopping problems.
Roadside Drainage Location of structures based on hydrological study
Provision of proper drainage scheme for the settlements
In unavoidable cases provision for increasing depth of water bodies to increase its capacity is
Water bodies
made.
Provision of facilities like Rest Areas, Truck stoppage site (lay bye) and bus stops along the
Road side amenities
highway
Loss of Livelihood and income The PAPs will be compensated as per National R&R policy
restoration option RAP to detail out the assistance programme to the needy
Assistance to vulnerable Special provisions have been made in the entitlement framework for assisting vulnerable groups
groups to improve their quality of life.
Employment of locals during
Locals will be given preference for employment during the project implementation
construction
option
They requested for facilities and amenities like underpasses, bus stand and safer accessibility at points
of habitant’s area
Affected population wanted to know about the exact period when the work will start. Sufficient time
should be given before the acquisition in order to avoid any inconvenience
People requested about creation of employment opportunities during road construction and later
phases of the project
Some of them asked about the tender process for the construction, as they were willing to be part of it
People suggested that adequate safety measures should be provided such as speed breakers,
signage’s etc. near the In brief, it was felt during consultation that regular meeting with the local
population / community could easily resolve any dispute between the community people and
implementing agency settlements
The RAP shall address the social issues brought to the fore during the public consultations
The EMP – both generic and specific has been designed to address environmental related issues
5.6 PUBLIC HEARING
5.6.1 Introduction
As per the guidelines of New EIA Notification 2009, “Public Consultation” refers to the process by which the
concerns host population and others who have plausible stake in the environmental impacts of the project or
activity are ascertained with a view to taking into account all the material concerns in the project or activity
design as appropriate. Public consultation process comprises of two parts, viz Public Hearing and written
response from stakeholders. The EIA Notification has arranged the Public Hearing procedure in a
systematic, time bound and transparent manner ensuring widest possible public participation at the project
site(s) or in its close proximity District wise, by the concerned State Pollution Control Board (SPCB).The EIA
report there after submitted to the State Pollution Control Board along with other relevant documents and
additional studies. The SPCB shall process the application for Public Hearing and conduct the hearing within
45 days of the application.
5.6.2 Public Hearing for the Project
As per EIA Notification, Public Hearing shall be conducted by the MPCB and KPCB for Solapur and Bijapur
districts at locations and dates that shall be advertised in the newspapers as per guidelines laid in the EIA
Notification of 2009 and its amendments. The summary of the important points in terms of opinions,
comments, suggestions and objections and the reply of the queries raised by the general public and their
answer / compliance by the project management officials shall be summarized in tabular form in the Final
EIA and the detailed MoM shall be attached
6. IMPACT ASSESSMENT
This chapter assesses the nature, type and magnitude of the potential impacts likely on the various relevant
physical, biological and cultural environmental components along the project corridor. For the assessment of
impacts, the baseline information based on the field visits and the primary surveys of the various
environmental components carried out. The description of the impacts on the individual components has
been structured as per the discussion in Chapter 4: Baseline Environmental profile of this report.
The impacts of the project are expected to be mostly direct and confined to the ROW. Only at critical
locations where the engineering, environmental and social aspects have warranted a shift from the existing
alignment, realignments have been proposed. The impacts on the various environmental components can
occur at any of the following stages of the project planning and implementation:
Planning and design stage;
Construction stage; and
Operation stage
6.1 WEIGHTAGE / RANKING OF VALUED ECO-SYSTEM
A weigtage and ranking system has been developed so as to rank / weigh the various VECs identified during
the reconnaissance survey. Based on the VEC identified during the screening stage within 75m of Corridor
of Influence, the VEC were weighed and ranked as per the table below.
Table 6-1: Scoring system adopted for the Project
S. No. Environmental Attribute Total Weight Score
1 Natural Environment
1.1 Topography 4 1
1.2 Vulnerability to natural hazards 4 1
1.3 Surface water resources 5 1
1.4 Drainage Conditions 5 1
1.5 Ground water resources 4 0
1.6 Materials Availability 4 1
1.7 Soil Erosion 4 1
Sub Total 30 6
2 Biological Environment
2.1 Designated Protected Areas 10 10
2.2 Wildlife habitat/s (outside designated PAs) 6 2
2.3 Migratory route/crossing of wild animals and birds (outside designated PAs) 6 0
2.4 Reserved Forests (RFs) 5 5
2.5 Protected or Other Forest/s 5 1
2.6 Green tunnels 4 2
2.7 Road side trees 4 4
Sub Total 40 24
3 Social Environment
3.1 Settlements 5 2
3.2 Sensitive Receptors 5 2
3.3 Drinking water sources 4 3
3.4 Religious Structures 4 3
3.5 Cultural Properties 4 2
3.6 Market Places 4 1
3.7 Common Property Resources 4 2
Sub Total 30 15
Grand Total 100 45
The total score of the project is 45 against a total of 100 and it can be safely deduced that the project scores
medium on the sensitivity scale and hence there shall be some impacts on the project.
The Table 6.2 presents the general environmental impacts expected due to the proposed up gradation of the
project road. Impacts have been assessed based on the information collected from the screening & scoping
of environmental attributes at feasibility stage. The quanta of all the impacts on Natural Environment are
discussed in details in subsequent paragraphs. The description and magnitude of impacts for the various
environmental components as visualised for the project are presented in the following sections.
A major source of dust during the construction stage is from stone crushing operations from the crusher and
the vibrating screen. The dust, in addition to being a health concern also reduces visibility thereby increasing
safety concerns. As no new quarry needs to be opened for this project (majority of the material shall be from
cut operations, reuse of old materials and existing quarries within the site itself), therefore, no new impacts
are likely to arise due to quarrying operations. A properly enforced EMP could improve the working
conditions of workers in the existing quarry areas selected for the project.
Though the quarry materials are to be transported over long distances to the construction sites, almost all
the quarries identified have proper access roads, therefore, no major impacts during the hauling of materials
is envisaged. The issue of dust generation etc along the haul roads needs to be addressed through proper
enforcement of dust suppression measures.
Soil Erosion
Pre Construction Stage
The removal of roadside vegetation will cause erosion, and increased run-off would in turn lead to erosion of
productive soil. The direct impact of erosion is the loss of embankment soil and danger of stability loss for
the road itself. This impact is generally restricted to the ROW. The project has taken care of this issue at the
engineering design stage itself, as at design gradients of 1:2, the slopes of the embankments are perceived
to be stable for all stretches of road. These sections of the road embankment would need stone pitching or
any other suitable turfing.
Construction Stage
Elevated sections of road in all sections, particularly all high embankments along the bridges, ROBs and the
bridge approaches would be vulnerable to erosion and need to be provided proper slope protection
measures to prevent erosion. Construction of new bridges involves excavation of riverbed and banks for the
construction of the foundations and piers. If the residual spoil is not properly disposed off, increased
sedimentation downstream of the bridge is likely. Though during construction period, drainage alteration and
downstream erosion / siltation is anticipated, due to the improved design and added capacity of the cross-
drainage structures, there should be an improvement in the drainage characteristics of the surrounding area.
Adequate slope protection measures are proposed as part of engineering design. Removal of trees to
facilitate construction will cause erosion problems until the proposed compensatory afforestation plantation
is established. Silt fencing to be provided to prevent eroded material from entering watercourses. The
regular cleaning of the drains by the concessionaire will ensure that these structures will not be overloaded
or rendered Ineffective due to overload.
Operation Stage
No soil erosion is envisaged when the road is in operation as all the slopes and embankments of the project
road shall be stabilised through sound engineering techniques. The issue has been addressed at the design
stage itself and all slopes have been 1:2, which shall ensure stability of the embankment. Appropriate
landscaping measures such as pitching of slopes and turfing shall prevent soil erosion taking place.
Compaction of Soil
Pre-Construction Stage
Compaction of Soil will occur in the pre-construction stage (particularly during site clearance stage) due to
movement of heavy machinery and vehicles. Transplantation of trees if carried out shall involve very heavy
machinery to uproot trees and haul them to the site of transplantation. Similarly, compaction will take place
during setting up of construction camps and stockyards. However, this is a short duration impact.
Appropriate measures need to be specified in the Environment Management Plan to minimise the area of
soil compaction.
Construction Stage
Compaction shall occur beyond the carriageway and within the vegetated area of the ROW by the
movement of vehicles and heavy machinery. Movement of vehicles during road construction is the major
cause of soil compactions. This impact is direct and will be the maximum in the ROW. It is necessary to
ensure that there is no adverse impact of soil compaction in areas other than the ROW, where vegetation
can grow and rain infiltration will take place.
Operation Stage
During the operation period compaction will be restricted to the CW itself. Compaction cannot be said to be
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
6-4
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
an impact of the operation stage as the pavement itself is a function of compacted base and sub base.
Contamination of Soil
Pre-Construction Stage
Contamination of oil in the pre-construction stage may be considered a short-term residual negative impact.
Soil contamination may take place due to solid waste contamination from the labour camp set up during pre-
construction stage. This impact is significant at locations of construction camps; stockyards, hot mix plants
etc. will come up in this stage.
Construction Stage
Contamination of soil during construction stage is primarily due to construction and allied activities. The sites
where construction vehicles are parked and serviced are likely to be contaminated because of leakage or
spillage of fuel and lubricants. Pollution of soil can also occur in hot-mix plants from leakage or spillage of
asphalt or bitumen. Refuse and solid waste from labour camps can also contaminate the soil. Contamination
of soil during construction might be a major long-term residual negative impact. Unwarranted disposal of
construction spoil and debris will add to soil contamination. This contamination is likely to be carried over to
water bodies in case of dumping being done near water body locations.
Operation Stage
During the operation stage, soil pollution due to accidental vehicle spills or leaks is a low probability as one
of the main objective of the project is to reduce accidents, but potentially disastrous to the receiving
environment should they occur. These impacts can be long term and irreversible depending upon the extent
of spill. There should be a disaster management plan in case of such major spills occurring.
6.2.3 Air
Air quality along the project corridor will be impacted both during the construction and operation stages
of the project.
Construction stage impacts will be of short term and have adverse impacts on the construction workers
as well as the settlements adjacent to the road, especially those in the down wind direction.
Operation stage impacts will not be as severe as the construction stage impacts and will be confined
generally to a band of width ranging from 50 to 75m from the edge of the last lane on either side of the
corridor.
Both the construction and operation stage impacts can be effectively mitigated if the impacts have been
assessed with reasonable accuracy in the design stage.
Generation of Dust
Pre Construction Stage
Generation of dust is the most likely impact during this stage due to:
Site clearance and use of heavy vehicles and machinery etc.;
Procurement and transport of raw materials and quarries to construction sites;
The impacts will mostly be concentrated in the ROW. If adequate measures such as sprinkling of water
on haul roads around sites where clearance activities are on, covering material trucks especially those
carrying sand and fly ash, then the impacts can be reduced to a great extent. It is likely that impacts
due to dust generation are felt downwind of the site rather than on the site itself.
Construction Stage
As the entire project corridor has a soil type with high silt content and the construction activities to be carried
out during the dry season when the moisture content would be less, dust generation, particularly due to
earthworks will be significant. Dust is likely to be generated due to the various construction activities
including:
Stone crushing operations in the crushers;
Handling and storage of aggregates in the asphalt plants;
Concrete batching plants;
Asphalt mix plants due to mixing of aggregates with bitumen; and
Construction and allied activities.
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
6-5
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Generation of dust is a critical issue and is likely to have adverse impact on health of workers in quarries,
borrow areas and stone crushing units. This is a direct adverse impact, which will last almost throughout the
construction period. The Environmental Action Plan prepared by the concessionaire should lay emphasis on
enforcement of measures such as provision of pollution masks, regular sprinkling of water to suppress dust
along haul roads at quarries, crushers and borrow areas to mitigate this impact.
Operation Stage
The negative impacts on air quality during operation stage shall not be significant as that of
construction stage. This is due to the reduction of dust particles.
No dust generation is envisaged during the operation stage as the all road shoulders are proposed to
be paved and all slopes and embankments shall be turfed as per best engineering practices.
The air quality shall also improve due to the plantation activity carried out in the ROW during the end of
construction phase.
Generation of Exhaust Gases
Pre Construction Stage
Generation of exhaust gases is likely during the pre construction stage during movement of heavy
machinery, oil tankers etc. This impact is envisaged to be insignificant during the pre construction stage.
Construction Stage
High levels of SO2, HC and hydrocarbons are likely from hot mix plant operations. Volatile toxic gases are
released through the heating process during bitumen production. Although the impact is much localised, it
can spread downwind depending on the wind speeds. The Environment Management Action Plan prepared
by the concessionaire needs to ensure adequate measures are taken especially for health safety of workers
such as providing them with pollution masks during working hours. Also, the contractor should ensure that
hot mix plants, stockyards, etc. are away from residential areas and residential quarters of all workers.
Contractors also should be asked to provide regularly Pollution under Control certificate for their equipments
and machinery as per prevalent norms. If adequate measures are taken, then impacts from generated gases
can be negligible.
Operation Stage
The major impact on air quality will be due to plying of vehicles. The impacts on air quality will at any given
time depend upon traffic volume / rate of vehicular emission within a given stretch and prevailing
meteorological conditions. Air pollution impacts arise from two sources: (i) inadequate vehicle maintenance;
and (ii) use of adulterated fuel in vehicles. Enforcement standards to meet better vehicle performance in
emissions and the improvement of fuel constituents can assist in improving regional air quality.
6.2.4 Water Resources
To facilitate the cross-drainage at water crossings, 140 cross-drainage structures including minor bridges,
slab, box and pipe culverts are proposed. The surface water bodies along the project road might be subject
to adverse impacts due to the various construction activities as well as during the operation stage of the
project. The impacts on water resources have been summarised in Table 6-3.
Table 6-3: Likely Impacts on Water Resources during the Construction Stage
Impacts due to Construction Indicators
Loss of water bodies Area of water bodies affected
Loss of other water supply sources Hand pumps, wells etc. affected
Alteration of drainage, run off, flooding No. of cross drainage channels
Depletion of ground water recharge Groundwater in Area rendered inaccessible & impervious
Use of water supply for construction Quantum of water used
Contamination from fuel and lubricants Nature and quantum of contaminators
Contamination from improper sanitation and waste disposal in Area of camp / disposal site and proximity to water bodies /
construction camps channels
Alteration of Drainage
Impacts of road construction, which lead to alteration of drainage, are generally widening at culvert or bridge
locations. This requires river and or gully training for the period during which the bridge is to be constructed.
Alteration of drainage can lead to soil erosion of adjacent areas, disturb local vegetation and impair local
ecology.
groundwater recharge areas may be reduced due to an increase in impervious layers due to the
construction. The contamination of the groundwater resources due to the project is likely at the following
locations:
Along construction sites, camps involving moving of construction equipments and machinery.
At the various community water bodies and sources of water supply such as hand pumps etc
Along the entire length of the corridor especially around urban areas and productive lands.
The impact of contamination of water sources such as wells can be avoided if these sources are covered
while site clearance is going on at the site. The Management Plan needs to ensure that proper precautions
are taken to prevent / minimise contamination of all water sources. Construction camps or stockyards are
not to be set up near water bodies to prevent oil spills.
Construction Stage
The impacts on water quality will be of greater concern during the construction stage. Increased sediment
load during preparation of the site is the most likely adverse impact. The contamination by fuel and oil from
construction vehicles or bitumen from hot-mix plants is less likely and in any case expected to be localised.
Discharge from labour camps and vehicle parking areas will have to be treated before discharge into any
watercourse. It is during the operation stage that the leakage or spillage from vehicles damaged, overturned
or just badly maintained is more likely.
The construction activities around the surface bodies can affect the water quality due to the disposal of solid
and liquid wastes from labour camps, fuel and lubricant spills or leaks from construction vehicles, fuel
storage and distribution sites and from bitumen or asphalt storage at hot-mix plants.
Also, the raising of the road shall mean that more embankment surface is prone to erosion. However, the
engineering design shall ensure protection of embankment slopes. The spoil heaps around the construction
sites are also prone to erosion and contribute to the increased sediment load in the near-by water bodies.
The major parameter of concern would be the sediment load from the spoils. The major pollutants of
concern are suspended solids, oil and grease, lead and other heavy metals.
Concentration of suspended solids is likely to be highest during the construction stage and immediately
after the construction when vegetation has not been fully established on the embankment slopes.
Oil and grease form a film on the water surface and hinder the transfer of oxygen into water.
Though the compounds of lead are suspected to be carcinogenic, it is unlikely that leads pollution to
have significant effects as 90-95% of lead in run-off is inert, and will be further diluted in the receiving
water bodies, where the lead concentrations are minimal.
Discharge from labour camps and vehicle parking areas will have to be treated before discharge into any
watercourse. It is during the operation stage that the leakage or spillage from vehicles damaged, overturned
or just badly maintained is more likely. The existing levels of contaminants, which can trace their origin to
road run-off, indicate that water quality degradation is not a significant impact. Normally groundwater is
shielded from the effects of such degradation, but if the discharges from construction camps were disposed
off using soak-pits / septic-tanks that were not adequately designed, the consequences would be disastrous
since restoration of groundwater quality is a much slower process.
The impacts of run-off laden with sediment may be felt in villages that depend on the fish living in the water-
body. Increased sediment load, lesser sunlight, difficulty to settle, etc will make the water more turbid. If the
concentrations are higher, smaller fish may be harmed. Large, heavy sediment, particularly with slow moving
water may smother algae and eventually alter the nature of the sub-stratum. Excessive sediment loads may
also mean disruption to areas where fish lay their eggs. However, it must be noted that these effects are
probable only during construction stage. The water quality of surface drainage channels is likely to be
impaired as long as the construction period continues. However, measures to divert the passage of
pollutants into the river can be adopted to minimise the impact.
Operation Stage
No contamination of any water source is envisaged during the operation period.
Impact on other Water Supply Sources
The impact on the local water supply sources like hand pumps, natural and manmade water bodies, wells
and concrete tanks will be significant as many are directly impacted. These though shall be replaced with
new sources at locations near to the existing ones. The project alignment affects some water resources.
Besides these cross drainage structures are built over the canal, river & nalla crossings. As part of the
project preparation, the alignment has been carefully routed to avoid any direct impact on these water
bodies, however, at some locations; the encroachment onto these water resources has been unavoidable. In
such locations the relocations of all these water supply sources has been recommended and the cost of the
relocation has been included as part of the project cost.
6.2.5 Noise levels
Though the level of discomfort caused by noise is subjective, there is a definite increase in discomfort with
an increase in noise levels. Road noise depends on factors such as traffic intensity, the type and condition of
the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration / deceleration / gear changes by the vehicles depending on the
level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRC: 104-1988).
The baseline noise levels monitored at various locations along the project packages indicate the baseline
levels is within the permissible limits for residential and rural areas and exceeds in some commercial areas.
Even the night levels recorded at the various locations are close to or higher than the noise levels allowed
during daytime. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive receptors
(schools, colleges and hospitals) have been identified to be quite close to the road. The impacts on noise
due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the operation stages.
Table 6-4: Noise Impacts
Sl.
Phase Source Impact
No.
Man, material and machinery movement Short duration
Pre
1 Establishment of camps, site office, stock yards, construction plants Localised impact
Construction
etc. Negligible
Plant site
Plant site: significant impact
Crushing, hot mix plants, machineries, batching plants, excavation,
within 500m
2 Construction grading, paving activities
Work zones Work zones: temporary and
negligible
Community residing near the work zones
3 Operation Increase in traffic Negligible impact
Though the noise levels are within the stipulated standard, the noise levels are a concern due to the number
of sensitive receptors located along the project road. The impacts on the receptors shall basically relate to
increase in noise levels, access and physical damage to the structure. There are some schools & health
units that are partially impacted. Even though complaints of noise and vibration are common, most of the
receptors are quite far away from the road and hence the noise is dissipated.
6.3 Biological Environment
6.3.1 Forest Areas
The proposed alignment is likely to directly impact the forest at Nandani Village along which realignment is
proposed. Though the alignment has been routed to minimise forestland acquisition, the acquisition of 2.665
ha of forestland has been unavoidable. The acquisition of forestland is being taken up in accordance to the
Forest (Conservation) Act.
Table 6-5: Forest Area required on Project Road
Proposed Forest Area
Sl. Chainage (Km) Length Forest Survey Gat To Be
Side Compartment Division Remark
No. (Km) Details No. No. Acquired
From To (Ha.)
Nandani
1 33.275 33.810 1.535 Both RF 138 104 3 Solapur 2.665
Realignment
adequate roadside drainage structure, trees located within the area between the pavement and the
daylight line needs to be removed.
Trees need to be cleared to facilitate construction of traffic detours. As the present project road is
mainly two lanes, there shall be need for diversions especially except for construction of bridges.
The stage wise impact on roadside trees and plantation has been described in the following sections.
Pre Construction Stage
The project has a significant, direct and long-term impact on Roadside trees in the Pre construction stage.
The cutting of trees shall have manifold impact. Most visible impact is the loss of shade. Also, there is a
possibility of the local people being deprived of tree products, such as wood, fruits, leaves etc. Removal of
roadside tress will reduce comfort levels for slow moving traffic and pedestrians. This is the only impact
considered important after the effect on the embankment stability has been considered. It may be pointed
out that this may be marginal in case of a full fledge National Highway, where the segregation of through
(fast-moving) and local (slow moving and pedestrian) becomes a major consideration. This negative
implication needs to be taken into consideration by compensating with new plantation along the ROW of the
project highway. The felling of trees need to be compensated for by compensatory afforestation, and
wherever possible, the options of transplantation of significant trees need to be worked out and adequate
provisions for the monitoring of the same need to be worked out.
A far less contentious issue, which normally takes the back seat, is the importance of the ecosystems
supported by the roadside trees. Not only would the removal of trees lead to erosion, it would also mean that
the micro-ecosystems developed on the roadside with the birds, animals and insects using the plantation
over the years would be lost too. The only mitigation would be to ensure that the compensatory afforestation
required as per the MoEF guidelines for the project is carried out with native species and proper care of the
saplings is taken to ensure that the roadside plantation returns to its previous state as quickly as possible.
Co-operation of locals to ensure that local cattle do not damage the saplings during the early stages of
growth will be required.
The roadside plantations will need to be cleared for the project. Though the loss of these trees is an
irreversible and long-term impact, the loss of the roadside plantations shall have to be compensated in
accordance to the principles of the Forest (Conservation) Act.
Construction Stage
The construction of new road shall involve removal of topsoil and clearing of vegetation cover and felling of
trees. These activities will exert wide-ranging impacts on the surroundings as summarised in Table below.
Table 6-6: Likely Impacts on Flora
Activity Impact
Loss of vegetation cover (shrubs & grasses) canopies;
Cutting and removal of earth/rock Felling of trees of girth more than 30 cm and in forest areas;
Road Construction Reduced shade and shelter for roadside fauna
Reduction in soil fertility, moisture and humidity
Workers Camps Use of plants and trees as fuel wood
6.3.3 Fauna
Domesticated animals dominate fauna species. The forest department has reported some endangered
species within the study area. There is likelihood of slight impact to local domestic animals, which graze in
the area especially after the road is constructed. Increased vehicle movement in the area might lead to
accidents involving animals. In areas with high traffic volumes, road kill can be a considerable or even the
predominant cause of mortality. To avoid such accidental kill, the project shall provide underpasses as part
of the project.
More over there shall be positive impact on the faunal species during the operational phase. The plantation
activity carried out, as part of the project component shall provide shelter and food for the smaller avian and
mammalian species, which in turn shall improve the overall food chain and food web and ultimately the
ecology of the area.
6.3.4 Aquatic Ecology
The construction of new bridges will cause some contamination of the river water due to spillage of
construction material, sediment loading & increased turbidity downstream of the bridge location. This change
shall have some impact on the flora and faunal species and change the nature of the substratum resulting in
decline in the number and diversity of plants and thus the food web. No negative impacts are envisaged on
the aquatic ecology during the operational phase.
6.4 SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT
6.4.1 Human Use Values
Amenities and Facilities
Some of the infrastructures built to facilitate the basic needs of the communities in these areas are affected
by the project, the details of which are given in the RAP. Most of the bus shelters shall be affected and these
shall be relocated.
Change in Land Use
The development that the improved road will bring with it will induce a chain reaction towards change in land
use. Change In land use will be sparked off as a result of land speculation. The road, which is flanked by
agricultural fields, will witness overnight selling of these lands for the prices that they will fetch.
Industrialisation of fringe areas of cities is also a possible impact of a road development scheme. The
availability of cheap labour and easy access to markets in the city will make roadside areas quite an
incentive for the industrialist. Reduced transportation costs and availability of high-class transportation
facilities for raw materials and products will be the most important advantage of the improved road. The
mushrooming of industrial areas on roadside will mean that the use of whatever infrastructure facilities that
may be available will preferentially go to the 'deep pockets' of the industry. This will further strain these
almost non-existent services.
Land Speculation
Better connectivity will also mean that the value of roadside properties will rise almost overnight. The
encroachment onto the ROW for the road to cash in on this opportunity is an almost universal occurrence, to
varying degrees. Encroachment will mean that the future expansion / widening of the road scheme will be
problematic and the issues related with easement and eviction will become a real challenge for the NHAI
that is already stretched to the limit. However, the damage to encroaching structure, whatever its status, in
case of an accident will be far more visible and potentially dangerous impact of such activity. Strict planning
laws in conjunction with continuous unbiased monitoring of the development are the only proven strategies
against such illegal activities.
Cropping Pattern and Crop Productivity
The proposed project is likely to bring in its wake industrialisation and change in land use. This translates
into change of land currently under agriculture to more commercial use. It is envisaged that due to this
proposed change the crop productivity in the agricultural belt immediately adjoining the ROW shall
decrease. This impact is envisaged only to be valid for the agricultural land immediate to the ROW. Although
the spatial impact is likely to be insignificant the impact will be irreversible in nature.
Exploitation of Resource base
Development of a road in areas previously not easily accessible can work like a double-edged sword for the
environmental resources in the area. While the road would unlock potential value in the area, stimulate
growth and make the environment hospitable, the rapid depletion of natural resources, by means with which
these areas cannot cope is a distinct possibility. Development of such vital Infrastructure will lead to over
exploitation of the environmental resources (e.g. too much groundwater pumping, indiscriminate wastewater
disposal, etc.). While the medium term impacts may not be large enough to be noticed, the long-term
implications of such depletion are potentially disastrous. The severe depletion of ground water resources in
certain areas and threats of saltwater ingress into aquifers in areas near the coast are likely if the expanded
urban areas continue to use bore wells for their domestic water supply.
Road Safety
The improvement of the project road will entail doubling the existing carriageway to a two-lane section and
improve its condition to allow vehicles at design speeds of 100 km/hr. Increased vehicular speed mean that
the fringe areas of the road are at increased risk from speeding vehicles. The existing facilities and
amenities along the road shall be subjected to adverse impacts of road operation. The possibility of
accidents is likely to increase. The possibility of this happening is a cause of concern as there are many
educational, cultural and health institutes along the road.
Induced Ribbon Development
The development of a road scheme will lead to extension of urban areas especially at the ends of cities and
towns through which the road passes. The improved transportation facility provides the linkages that will
allow much better access to previously difficult to reach markets (for buyers and sellers). This would mean
not only the people from congested areas in cities will want to move to the fringe, but also, people from
nearby rural areas would migrate to the city. Urban services are seldom able to keep pace with the growth of
a city. The growth of a city beyond the established spread network will mean piecemeal arrangements for
services like water supply, wastewater treatment and disposal, and transportation. All the settlements along
the project corridor will experience a sudden boom in activity and population around the start of operation of
the project corridor. Thus, a ribbon development is envisaged all along the project road.
6.4.2 Cultural Properties
Relocation of Cultural Assets
Cultural properties (shrines, sacred and archaeological structures) lying near the ROW are most susceptible
to impacts due to pre construction and construction activities. Clearing of the site during movement of road
construction machinery is likely to require a belt of about 4-5m from the edge of the carriageway, which is
likely to adversely impact cultural properties. Cultural properties will be subjected to varying degree of impact
depending upon their placement in the ROW. Structures, which are close to the proposed CW, are likely to
need relocation. The project shall directly impact some temples which have to be relocated. The construction
shall also partially impact some cultural assets which shall be rehabilitated. The access of some of these
cultural properties shall also be compromised.
6.4.3 Quality Of Life Values
Socio-Economic Profile
The detailed socio-economic analysis of people, structures and property likely to be impacted by the
proposed project has been presented in the Resettlement Action Plan.
Public health and safety
Impacts on public health and safety may arise during the phases of pre-construction, construction and
operation phases. During the pre-construction and construction phases, dismantling of the structures for
ROW clearance and road construction activities may result in the following health hazards:
Breaking and dismantling of properties during pre-construction has psychological impacts on their
owners and others associated with them.
Debris generated on account of the above-mentioned activities if not properly disposed might give rise
to health problems in the area. However, the structures to be dismantled during pre-construction phase
will mainly be of semi-permanent and temporary nature and much of the waste shall be salvageable.
Dismantling of first row of structures (generally commercial) along the highway shall lead to exposure of
second row of properties (generally residential) to higher dust, air and noise pollution levels. This is a
long-term effect (might extend into the operation phase) and may increase the effected households'
medical expenditure.
In case of non-local labour (If so is arranged by the contractor), labour camps are set up at one or more
sites adjacent to the alignment, and at some ancillary sites, like aggregate quarries. These labourers
hired from outside can have clashes with the local population on account of cultural and religious
differences. The influx of a large work force to an area, already hard pressed for basic services
(medical services, power, water supply, etc.), can impose additional stress on these facilities.
In and around forest areas if alternative fuels are not made available to the workforce, there is a
likelihood that trees / branches will be cut down for cooking or heating purposes.
Unsanitary conditions in the labour camps might also result in impact on health of labourers as well as
the local population. Transmission of diseases is also facilitated by the migration of people. During the
construction phase work, crews and their dependents may bring with them a multitude of
communicable diseases including Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STDs) like AIDS. This is more so if
the nature of the project requires more male-workers, who have migrated from other parts of the state
or country.
During road construction allied activities like quarrying and crushing operations, traffic diversions, etc.,
may cause disruption of social and economic life of the local population of the nearby areas. Dust and
noise generated in crushing and blasting operations may cause nuisance to the nearby communities.
Other problems perceived during construction period is inconvenience to the local people as well as the
highway passengers due to traffic jams and congestion, loss of access and other road accident risks,
7. ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
The chapter tries to compare feasible alternative to the proposed project with respect to site, technology,
design etc. The alternatives examined take into account all possible and feasible options and includes both
with and without project scenarios in terms of the potential environmental impacts for the justification of the
project. The chapter discusses how environmental parameters were assigned due importance and were
carefully considered in the analysis of alternatives.
7.1 WITH AND WITHOUT PROJECT ALTERNATIVES
7.1.1 Without Project Scenario
The existing project road is a two lane national highway with pavement width of 7m. With present and
projected high traffic volumes, the capacity of the present highway is insufficient for handling the high
volume of traffic and calls in for improvements to a four lane carriageway. The road has many roadside
settlements and the traffic flow is seriously impacted by severe conflicts between the local and the through
traffic. This is further compounded by the various land use conflicts, in terms of uncontrolled development
along the highway and the encroachments onto the ROW. The population growth, increase in traffic volumes
and the economic development along the corridor would continue to occur and will worsen the already
critical situation. The existing unsafe conditions and the adverse environmental consequences in terms of
the environmental quality along the highway would continue to worsen in the absence of the proposed
improvements. Moreover, if it is decided not to proceed with the project, then the attendant reduced socio-
economic development of this remote, relatively poorly connected area cannot be justified. Therefore, the
no-action alternative is neither a reasonable nor a prudent course of action for the proposed project, as it
would amount to failure to initiate any further improvements and impede economic development.
7.1.2 With Project Scenario
The ‘with project scenario’ is found to have a positive impact in the long run on social, environmental,
economic and financial issues. This scenario includes the widening to four lanes of the existing two lanes
stretch as envisaged in the project objectives. The scenario is economically viable and will improve the
existing conditions. It, would thereby, contribute to the development goals envisaged by the Government of
Karnataka and India, and enhance the growth potential of the area.
To avoid the large-scale acquisition of land and properties, the project envisages the four-laning of the
highway within the existing ROW, but for critical locations like where toll plaza and other amenities have
been proposed.
In spite of the various development benefits likely to accrue due to the project, as is the case of every road
development project, the project would be accompanied by certain impacts on the natural, social and
environmental components. The potential impacts on the various environmental components can be avoided
through good environmental practices. Wherever avoidance of negative impact has not been possible,
appropriate mitigation and enhancement actions will be worked out to effectively offset the environmental
damages inflicted due to the project. A detailed Resettlement and Rehabilitation (R&R) Action Plan is also
being worked out to improve the well-being and livelihood of the people to be impacted. Comparative
assessments of the “with and without” project scenarios are presented in the following Table 7-1.
Table 7-1: "With and Without" Project Scenarios - A Comparative Assessment
Component "With" Project Scenario 'Without" Project Scenario
Highway Divided four lane carriageway with geometric
Existing two lane carriageway with poor geometrics
Geometrics improvements
50-60 Kmph in rural Sections, 30-40 Kmph in Urban
Design Speed 100 Kmph
Sections
Segregation of local and through traffic by the provision of
Congestion in Congestion In urban areas due to mixing of local,
service roads or realignment will greatly relieve
Settlements pedestrian and through traffic.
congestion.
Felling of both old and young trees. Old and weak trees
No felling of trees. The old trees may become a
Felling of road side near the road edge shall be a road hazard and shall be
safety hazard to the road users with passage of
trees felled. Double the number of new young and healthy trees
time.
to be planted in compensation.
Provision of cattle underpasses to provide safety to both Accidents involving cattle and livestock shall be a
Cattle safety
road users and cattle from accidents. concern.
Pedestrian safety Along the settlement stretches with significant pedestrian Pedestrian safety an issue of major concern
Impact on sensitive receptors and sensitive land uses, as schools, hospitals etc.
Loss of community facilities and utilities
Loss of water bodies, other water resources, and
Loss of cultural properties
7.3.2 Urban Sections
Bypasses are being provided in the existing road at important urban sections like Horti & Bijapur. Other
urban areas which do not necessitate a bypass, but would involve considerable acquisition of properties and
result in large-scale displacement of both squatters and property holders, have been identified. However,
though none of these settlements are large enough to generate a significant local traffic, with the
introduction of such a high-speed facility, the safety of the pedestrians and the local traffic will be of great
significance. In these sections, the design team has proposed service lanes along with covered drains which
shall also act as pedestrian sidewalks based on the magnitude and nature of environmental and social
impacts. The decision on the proposal has been reached after discussions with the NHAI and also the social
experts, who wanted to reduce the land acquisition and utilise the existing ROW to the maximum.
7.3.3 Bypass and Realignment Locations
Bypass
A bypass at Horti has been proposed. The bypass candidates, based on the social conditions were
subjected to financial and economic viability. A pragmatic approach has been adopted, with minimum
subjectivity, uncertainty in evaluating the alignment to avoid social impacts that are likely to arise due to
type, nature and magnitude of alignment. Public consultation with stakeholders, client and general public
were undertaken in deciding the alignment. The project attributes considered for the bypasses are length,
terrain, geometrics, embankment, structures, land availability, land acquisition, terrestrial ecology, safety
consideration and alteration of drainage.
Table 7-2: Proposed Bypass & Realignment Locations
Existing Chainage (Km) Proposed Chainage (Km)
Sl. No Nearest Settlement Type Length (Km)
From To From To
1 Horti Bypass 63.600 65.700 72.200 74.200 2.000
3 Nandani Realignment 24.200 25.250 32.940 34.000 1.060
Total Length (Km) 3.060
Horti Bypass
The town is an urban settlement where the existing ROW is insufficient for further widening and shall lead to
huge loss of private, government and cultural properties. To avoid the large scale social impact and to
upgrade the geometrics a bypass has been proposed. Alternative Analysis was carried out for both the
Bypass and upgrading the existing road considering Environmental impacts, engineering and economics
aspects.
Table 7-3: Analysis of Alternatives for Horti Bypass
Sl.
Description Alternate 1 Alternate 3
No.
1 Take off Chainage on NH 13 Km 63.600 Km 63.400
2 End Chainage on NH 13 Km 65.700 Km 66.100
3 Route Alignment RHS LHS
4 Length of bypass 2.0 km 2.9 km
5 Terrain Plain Terrain Plain Terrain
6 Speed 100 km/hr 100 km/hr
Smooth horizontal and vertical Smooth horizontal and vertical geometrics is possible
7 Geometrics
geometrics is possible
Village Road Crossing Village Road Crossing
8
Obligatory Points
9 No of Structures VUP – 1, Minor Bridge – 2 VUP – 1, Minor Bridge - 2
10 Land Acquisition 60m width land required 60m width land required
11 Area Required, Hectares 125.88 133.68
12 Resettlement & Rehabilitation Light impact Light impact
13 Recommendation Recommended Not recommended
Realignment
Realignment has been proposed at one location:
Nandani
The proposed realignment near Nandani village is 1.060 Km long while the existing road in the section is
1.050 Km long. The proposed realignment is on the RHS of the existing road. The realignment was made
necessary since exiting alignment is technically and from safety angle is unsuitable for widening from 2
lanes. The existing road also passes through settlement area making widening of the exiting road more
difficult due to social conditions. Upon deliberations only 1 alternative to the existing road was derived. Since
the widening of the existing alignment would have serious repercussions on safety and technical grounds
and also on the local populace it wasn’t recommended. Any alternative on the LHS was not feasible since
the entire village is situated on the LHS. The proposed alignment chosen is the best alternative available
and suits the existing topography and forest land diversion is the minimum required. Any other alternative
chosen for the project shall involve acquisition of more private, government and forestland. Based on
environmental, social, technical and financial analysis the best alternative was chosen. The realignment is
proposed due to the following reasons.
The existing road has a sharp vertical & horizontal curve and geometric improvements are required
Concentric or eccentric widening isn’t possible in order to improve the curve and also widen the road
Sight distances are poor and safety shall be compromised if realignment isn’t proposed
Criteria Means
Adequate drainage Provision of drains
Reduction of Air and Noise
Intersection improvements; site specific attenuation measures; aggressive tree plantations
Pollution
Displacement of Local Provision of Bypasses and realignments to reduce displacement; Provision of up gradation of skills
Population of PAPs, financial assistance
Minimisation of Direct impact on
Provision of Bypasses and realignments
adjoining settlements
Minimisation of Direct Impact on
Public consultations, Realignment Service roads and underpasses provided at site specific
Sensitive Receptors, cultural
locations; Good EMP measures
and religious properties
Minimisation of Property
Realignments; Concentric widening
acquisition
Displacement of Commercial
Concentric widening
Properties
Minimisation of Loss of Utility
Centre line alterations
Lines
Stabilisation of Slope Turfing / Pitching
Sl.
Particular Impact Reason Mitigation / Enhancement
No
maintenance
Measures will be revised & improved to
Soil quality Effectiveness / shortfall (if any)
mitigate / enhance environment due to any
monitoring Any unforeseen impact
unforeseen impact.
Change in Seismology
No negative impact on the seismological setting of the region is anticipated. Rather, as part of the project all
the existing structures will be checked and constructed as per the seismological requirements of the region
in conformity to the IS 1893(Part 1):2002.
Erosion
Incorporating appropriate type of treatments of slopes has reduced the potential for erosion of high
embankments and bridge fills. The soil is assumed to have an angle of repose corresponding to 1V: 2H.
Slope protection is normally required only for slopes steeper than this. The side slopes gentler than this will
be turfed with shrubs and grasses as per IRC: 56-1974: Recommended Practices for Treatment of
Embankment Slopes for Erosion Control.
Contamination of Soil
Contamination of soil can spoil the soil and can also contaminate the surface as well as ground water
sources. Details of the activities from which the contamination can occur are presented below:
Table 8-2: Mitigation Measures for Soil Contamination
Potential impact Mitigation
No scarification involved.
In case concessionaire decides to scarify then the material to be reused in the GSB layer.
Scarified Bituminous
Wastes Non reusable Bituminous wastes to be dumped in 30cm thick clay lined pits with the top 30cm layer
covered with good earth for supporting vegetation growth over a period only after obtaining permission
of Independent Engineer.
Scarified Non Bituminous
Used in the normal GSB layer (not the drainage layer)
Material
Reused as embankment, median & shoulder fill materials
Cut material Excess material to be used for filling up of borrow areas identified by the concessionaire and approved
by the Independent Engineer
Construction debris
Annexure 8.1 : Guidelines for Identification of Debris Disposal Sites & Precautions needed
generated from
dismantling of structures Annexure 8.2: Guideline for Rehabilitation of Dumpsites, Quarries and Borrow Areas will be applicable
An emergency response team to be created. The team shall contain members of the district and police
administration and also have specialist in remediation. Responsibility of Concessionaire to inform the
Soil Contamination due to team to take actions. The roles and responsibility of the members of the ram shall be framed in
accident spills conjunction with all the parties to address the situation arising out of the accidental spills resulting in
situation like water and soil contamination, health hazards in the vicinity of the accident spot, fire and
explosions etc.
Improvements of design shall lead to less accidents and hence less spillage of oil and grease
Fuel storage will be in proper bunded areas.
Soil contamination due to
Highway run off All spills and collected petroleum products to be disposed off in accordance with MoEF and SPCB
guidelines and as per the directions of the Emergency Response team.
Fuel storage and fuelling areas will be located at least 300m from all cross drainage structures and
significant water bodies.
Operation of residential Vehicle parking area will be made impervious using 75 mm thick P.C.C. bed over 150 mm thick rammed
facilities for labour camps, brick bats. The ground will be uniformly sloped towards to adjacent edges towards the road. A drain will
Vehicle parking areas take all the spilled material to the oil interceptor (Fig 8-2)
height of the pile be restricted to 2m. To retain soil and to allow percolation of water, silt fencing shall
protect the edges of the pile.
The stockpiles shall be covered with gunny bags or tarpaulin.
Such stockpiled topsoil will be returned to cover the disturbed area and cut slopes. Residual topsoil will
be distributed on a areas as identified by concessionaire and approved by the Independent Engineer in
a layer of thickness of 75mm - 150mm. Top soil shall also be utilised for redevelopment of borrow
areas, landscaping along slopes, medians, incidental spaces etc,
During construction, some land will be temporarily needed to create detours, store equipment and material,
site construction workers' camp and other amenities. The top 150 mm of soil from these areas will be
stripped off and stored in heaps of less than 2 m height. The slope of the pile will be maintained to lesser
than 1:4 to reduce removal of sediment with runoff and to enhance percolation through stored soil. The
stored soil will be used for:
Covering all disturbed areas including for the rehabilitation of borrow areas
Top dressing of the road embankments and fill slopes
Distribution over barren / unproductive areas, for a depth of 75-100mm, to make these lands
productive.
Quarries
Existing quarries that are already in operation with the required environmental clearances have been
recommended for this project, and no new quarries have been proposed. The existing quarries are suitable
for the requirement of coarse and fine aggregate required for the road works.
In case the concessionaire decides in opening up of new quarries for the project, he shall follow the
instructions / procedures as laid out in Annexure 8.3: Guidelines for New Quarry Management. For all
existing quarries from where the concessionaire may source his supply of aggregates, Annexure 8.4:
Guidelines for Existing Quarry Management shall be followed.
Similarly natural sand quarries have also been identified for the project road. It has been found that the bed
of the rivers flowing in the vicinity of the project road contains good quality coarse sand in sufficient
quantities Table 8-3 & 4 shows details of quarry areas identified and recommended for the project. It needs
however, to be noted that recommendation on use of quarries is a guideline only and has been done to only
establish the feasibility of construction. Annexure 8.5 provides the Quarry chart.
Table 8-3: Details of Stone Aggregates Quarries
Sl. No Chainage Side Details Distance to Quarry Km) Approx Quantity
1 60.700 RHS Quarry (Hill) 3.2 600,000.00
2 97.850 LHS Crusher, Sanglikar Stone Crusher, Gunnapur Road 1 -
3 97.850 LHS Crusher, Gunnapur Road 1.8 -
4 97.850 LHS Crusher, Sree Shidheswar Crusher, Gunnapur Road 2 -
5 97.850 LHS Quarry 3 1,800,000.00
Sl.
Item Impact Reason Mitigation / Enhancement
No.
Comprehensive afforestation
Meteorological Marginal Due to production and laying of hot Avenue plantation
1.
factors and climate impact bituminous mix Shrub plantation in the median /
island
Sprinkling of Water
Fine materials to be completely
Temporary and
Shifting of utilities, removal of trees & covered, during transport and
2. Dust generation location
vegetation, transportation of material stocking.
specific
Plant to be installed in down wind
direction from nearby settlement.
Air pollution Norms will be enforced.
Clearing and grubbing materials dumping Labourers will be provided mask.
3.
Gaseous Moderate brushing of the surface access roads to Local people will be educated on
pollutants impact borrow area hot mix plants, Crushers paving safety and precaution on access
of asphalt layers, Labour Camps roads, newly constructed
embankment etc.
Air quality Moderate Compliance with future statuary
4. Air pollutants from traffic
emissions impact regulatory requirements
Air quality Effectiveness shortfall of any unforeseen Measures will be revised &
5.
monitoring impact improved to mitigate enhance
provided in the event of the emissions exceeding the SPCB norms. Other potential measures include
plantation around periphery of the hot-mix plants.
To ensure the efficacy of the mitigation measures suggested, air quality monitoring shall be carried out
at least once a month during the period the plant is in operation.
All vehicles, equipment and machinery used for construction will be regularly maintained to ensure that
the pollution emission levels conform to the SPCB norms. A vehicle maintenance schedule prepared by
the contractor and the concessionaire and approved by the Engineer shall be adhered to.
Operation Stage
During the operation stage, the mitigation that the project can carry out is related more to facilities for
checking levels of pollution. Additional measures proposed are as below:
Broad-leaved pollution resistant species, which can grow in high pollutant concentrations or even
absorb pollutants, shall be planted as they help settle particulates with their higher surface areas along
with thick foliage, which can reduce the distance for which particulates are carried from the road itself.
Cassia fistula (Amaltas), Ficus religiosa (Peepal), Ficus bengalensis (Banyan), Tamarindus indica (Imli)
and Azadirachta indica (Neem) are recommended.
Other measures such as the reduction of vehicular emissions, ensuring vehicular maintenance and
upkeep, educating drivers about driving behaviour I methods that will reduce emissions are beyond the
scope of the project but will be far more effective in reducing the pollutant levels. The concessionaire
together with the Motor vehicles Department and the SPCB can arrange for provision for inspection for
the Pollution under Control (PUC) certificates at all the three toll plazas proposed.
Air Quality Monitoring
Apart from provision of the mitigation measures, ambient air quality shall be monitored. The monitoring plan
shall be functional in construction as well as in operation stages. The frequency, duration and responsibility
will be as per the Environmental Monitoring Plan. The air quality shall be monitored at all the locations as
given in Table 4.4 beside the plant sites. The maximum desirable limits as per the national ambient air
quality standards are given in Annexure 10-1 and the monitored values should correspond with the table. All
deviated results shall be reported to engineer, for remedial measures.
8.2.4 Water – Mitigation
The table below presents the adverse impacts on the water resources due to the project and the mitigation
measures that are proposed.
Table 8-6: Summary of Mitigations for Impacts on Water
Sl.
Item Impact Impact (Reason) Mitigation / Enhancement
No.
Land acquisition to be minimized with provision
Loss of water Major, direct Part or complete acquisition of
1. of Retaining walls.
bodies impact source of water
Relocation of ground / surface water sources.
Major bridge constructions Widening & construction of bridges, there will
Alteration of Cross Very Low
2. Widening of minor bridges and be an improvement in the drainage
Drainage Impact
culverts. characteristics of the project area.
Silt fencing to be provided.
Siltation of water bodies Recharge well to be provided to compensate
Runoff and Direct
3. Reduction in ground recharge the loss of pervious surface.
drainage Impact
Increased drainage discharge Continuous drain is provided, unlined in rural
area and lined in urban area.
Contractor needs to obtain approvals for taking
adequate quantities of water from surface and
Water requirement for construction
Water requirement Direct ground water sources.
4. activity.
for project impact This is required to avoid depletion of water
Water requirement for labour
sources.
Water harvesting structures to be provided.
Increased sediment laden run-off Silt fencing to be provided
Increased Direct
5.
sedimentation impact
after the nature and capacity of the Instructions given in Annexure 8.6 Guidelines
watercourse for Sediment Control to be enforced.
Scarified bitumen wastes Hazardous wastes (Management and Handling)
Direct Oil and diesel spills Rules, 1989 to be enforced.
Contamination of
6. adverse Emulsion sprayer and laying of hot Oil Interceptor will be provided for accidental
Water
impact mix spill of oil and diesel.
Production facilities for the labour Rejected material will be laid as directed by IC.
Sl.
Item Impact Impact (Reason) Mitigation / Enhancement
No.
and officers. Septic tank will be construction for waste
Routine and periodical maintenance disposal.
Effectiveness / shortfall (if any) Measures will be revised and improved to
Water quality
7. mitigate / enhance environment due to any
monitoring Any unforeseen impact
unforeseen impact.
To reduce noise and vibrations, noise barriers in the form of compound wall is proposed. In case of space
crunch, the use of concrete screens is also suggested. However the concessionaire shall identify such areas
where concrete screens shall be used. The noise barrier wall shall be constructed by excavation of
foundation, laying of brick masonry wall up to a height of 2m above ground, plastering and coping as per the
direction of the engineer and as laid in the specification. Creepers and paints shall be used in consultation
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
8-9
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
with the affected community to give an aesthetic look. Shade and flowering trees shall be planted within the
boundary of the sensitive receptor, between the building line and the compound wall, wherever space shall
be available, 5m centre to centre. Figure 8.4 shows the combination of compound wall and trees which shall
be used as noise barrier. The measures adopted for noise attenuation for receptors (schools and hospitals
for all type of land use) identified above are as below:
Plantation within the premises if space available for plantation
Rising of existing boundary wall / construction of new wall up to 2m height
Planting creepers to provide aesthetic view
In urban areas the boundary wall can be painted with posters to provide aesthetic views. The option of
posters or creepers shall be agreed by the school / hospital administrator.
Noise Pollution Monitoring – Mitigation
The effectiveness of mitigation measures and further improvement in designs to reduce the noise level due
to construction and operational activity shall be monitored. The frequency, duration and monitoring plan shall
be functional in construction as well as in operation stages as per the Environmental Monitoring Plan. Noise
shall be monitored at all locations identified in Table 4-9 beside the plant sites & other locations identified by
the engineer. The country standards are given in National Ambient Noise Standards in Annexure 10-1. Any
value / result not within acceptable limits shall be reported to engineer, for remedial measures.
8.2.6 Biological Environment
Flora
The major adverse impacts on flora shall involve the removal of trees, shrub and ground cover from within
the Corridor of Impact. As part of the project preparation, to minimise the loss of trees, clearance of only
those trees identified from the design will be removed.
Table 8-9: Summary of Mitigations for Impacts on Biological Environment
Sl.
Item Impact Reason Mitigation / Enhancement
No.
Direct Diversion of forest land as per Forest Act
1. Forest area Diversion of forest area
Impact Plantation of trees as per Forest Department
No
2. Wild Life No wild life habitat Nil
Impact
Compulsory tree plantation in the ratio of 1:2.
Option of compensatory afforestation through
Increase in soil erosion, silting of water Forest Department.
Direct bodies. Avenue plantation along corridor, where ever
3. Trees Cutting
Impact Dust and noise pollution possible.
Loss of shade and loss of tree products Identification of incidental spaces (ox bow areas)
for group plantation.
Transplantation of trees also explored.
Clearing and grubbing will be minimised, and
sprinkled with water to reduce dust pollution.
Direct Increase in soil erosion, silting of water
4. Vegetation Exposed surface like embankment slopes will be
Impact bodies, noise pollution, dust pollution
protected with stone pitching and turfing.
Open land in and around plant will be vegetated.
Cattle No
5. No cattle grazing found Nil
Grazing impact
For stretches of the corridor through the forest areas, the contractor and the concessionaire shall ensure
that the construction activities shall be limited to the proposed ROW, so as to avoid any impacts on the
vegetation within the forest areas. The measures for avoiding / mitigating adverse impacts on the reserve
forest stretches are given below:
No construction camp shall be allowed within the designate limits of the forest areas and within 1km
from their boundaries.
No earthworks or surfacing permitted along stretches of road within these areas after sundown. No
workmen allowed shall be allowed to stay within the areas after sundown except with adequate
supervision.
As far as possible, concreting along the stretch of road within the areas to be planned such that work
after sundown is avoided or kept to the absolute minimum. Wherever this is unavoidable, the
Engineer’s Environmental staff shall remain present at site.
No disposal of debris shall be allowed within these areas except at locations identified during project
preparation.
Compensatory Afforestation
Compensatory afforestation for trees affected in forest areas will be taken up as per the Forest
(Conservation) Act, 1980.
The directions of the Forest Department on the issue of compensatory afforestation shall be binding.
Efforts though shall be to convince the department to plant trees in the affected project area to
compensate the ecological loss due to felling of the trees.
A total of 15368 trees are to be planted to compensate the loss of 7684 trees in non forest areas at a
ratio of 1:2. The raising and maintenance cost for three years of the rest shall be given to the forest
department who shall raise the trees. The cost for the same has been included in the EMP budget.
Transplantation
rd
In order to minimise the negative impact of tree felling, it is proposed to transplant a minimum of 1/3 of
trees proposed for felling.
Thus a minimum of 2562 trees are proposed for transplantation and the cost has been budgeted.
However, a budget for 15368 trees (twice the number of 7684 trees) have been considered for
compensatory afforestation purpose
The concessionaire to identify trees that can be transplanted and adopt methodology for
transplantation. The methodology shall be approved by the IE and NHAI
Avenue and Block Plantation
Avenue plantation along corridor, where ever possible given to compensate the loss of trees due to
felling.
The plantation scheme shall involve a plantation contractor who shall supply and maintain the
plantation as per details given in Annexure 8.7: Tree Plantation Strategy.
Native indigenous trees species shall be used as far as practicable, strictly avoiding any exotic (but
popular) species like Eucalyptus sp. that can have far-reaching adverse effects on the ecology and
water regime of the area.
Endeavour to initiate plantations before the construction is complete so that the trees are at least a year
or two old when the project is completed.
The concessionaire shall work out the number of trees to be planted around junctions and for
enhancement purposes.
Cost for a total of 27420 flowering, shade, medicinal, ornamental & fruit bearing trees in suitable area
including plantation and maintenance for the entire duration of the contract period has been budgeted.
This number of trees are excluding the trees to be planted for compensatory plantation
Pure avenue plantation with single species like Terminalia arjuna (arjuna), Magnifera indica (mango),
Azadirachta indica (neem) only to be planted for a few kilometres (or, the stretch between two market
places for example) to provide harmonious and pleasing look, and a regular and wavelike skyline. This
row of trees forms the first and innermost line.
Selection of tree species in outer rows (where multiple rows can be accommodated) has been
considered from economic point of view. Therefore, trees that provide fuel and fruit as well as small
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
8-11
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Protection of Species
Activities during the construction period are likely to have adverse impact on the plant species located along
the carriageway. A total of 22279 tree guards are proposed to protect the young trees in the median.
Landscaping Strategy
The locations for landscaping shall be identified by the concessionaire.
The Figures 8.5 & 8.6 shows thematic landscape sketches.
Plantation along medians shall screen headlights glare from approaching vehicles and prevent
distraction to the driver. Species like Bauhinia purpurea, Thespesia populnea, Thevetia nerifolia etc. as
given in Table 8-13 are recommended prevent glare from the headlights.
Proper landscaping of the traffic islands and the surrounding areas shall integrate these features with
the surrounding landscape. Junctions of relatively low importance shall be planted with flowering
shrubs in the first row of planting in the curves and shade trees in the next rows. If the traffic islands are
spacious enough small shrubs or ground cover shall be planted on them.
The floral species that shall be used for landscaping along river and canals are Ficus bengalensis,
Azadirachta indica etc. The landscape treatment shall involve stepped access to the waterfront, seating
beneath tree groves facing the river side and stone pitching, gabion structures on road and other
embankments.
Due to the realignment of the project road within the ROW to improve the geometries, many small
incidental or irregular spaces have been formed. These micro spaces have potential to add to the
visual quality of the road landscape and have been considered form the point of enhancement.
Figure 8-5: Conceptual Landscaping Of Incidental Space
Fauna
As the entire corridor is subject to intense human habitation, there are no significant fauna species along the
highway. The following measures need to be taken up during the construction stage by the contractor and
the concessionaire.
All works are to be carried out such that minimum damage and disruption to fauna is caused.
Construction workers shall be instructed to protect natural resources and fauna, including wild animals
and aquatic life.
Hunting and unauthorised fishing shall be prohibited.
During construction, at any point of time, if a rare / endangered / threatened fauna species is spotted,
the contractor and the concessionaire shall make all arrangements to intimate the wild life authorities
and measures will be taken as for is conservation during the operation period also.
8.2.7 Social Environment
Entire corridor will acquire a pattern of urban and rural stretches. At certain stretches the concentration,
density and level of urbanisation will be much higher due to the overlapping and amalgamation of two to
three settlements over time. All along the corridor length the urban and rural stretches have been identified.
Within the urban settlements the areas with highest, high, medium and low concentrations have been filtered
and accordingly suggested appropriate treatment to avoid further and future ribbon development.
Loss of Land
As far as possible the land acquisition has been kept to the minimum, by restricting the geometric
improvement within the existing right of way. However the land acquisition will be done at sections having
width, insufficient to accommodate the approved cross-sections & geometric Improvements.
Bus Shelters and Bus Bays
The existing design is not suited to the local climate and thus only finds use during the rainy season.
Further, utility of these facilities varies according to the traffic volume, intensity of user groups and visibility of
the moving traffic from the bus stop and comfort conditions within the bus stop. In places where bus stops
already exist, changes should be incorporated to increase the utility of these structures:
Bus shelters are proposed near to residences to minimise walking distance.
It should be positioned in straight and level sections of road and should be visible from a long distance
in both directions.
Bus bays are proposed as per the recommendations of IRC: 80-1981.
Bus bays with bus shelters are being provided at a total of 21 locations. These locations are given in
Annexure 2.1.
New bus stops would be provided with shade, benches and railings.
Interpretative signage would be displayed in Kannada / Marathi and English that could deliver
information about the bus numbers, origin & destination and routes of buses.
Rest areas
Roadside rest areas are intended for rest and relaxation intended for long distance travellers, and may
occasionally provide facilities for overnight stay also. The generic design for rest areas shall take into
account:
Parking facility shall be provided. Vehicle parking lay-by shall be provided at the frontage of these
locations.
Based on the location and availability of space landscaping shall comprise of walkways and soft
landscaped areas and outdoor seating spaces. Shade and fruit trees as well as flowering shrubs are
proposed in the rest areas.
The project proposes to provide the minimum required public conveniences such as toilets and drinking
water facilities at each of the rest areas.
Restaurant with outdoor and indoor seating spaces, Fast food joints, General stores, Chemists /
medicine shops, STD / PCO and Vehicle repairing shops shall be proposed
The locations of rest areas shall be advertised through signboards and overhead signs in advance.
Truck lay byes
The lay-byes have been proposed where congestion of heavy commercial vehicles was observed. An
additional pavement on both sides (but alternating with each other) shall be developed so that the flow of
traffic in carriageway is not obstructed. The generic enhancement outlines for truck parking lay-byes facilities
provided for supporting the functioning of the lay-byes shall be as per design in the Concession Agreement:
Landscaping shall comprise primarily of shade trees. Ornamental trees, shade trees and shrubs shall
be planted in order to develop the area aesthetically. Trees shall be planted to define the length of the
lay-by on its outer side as also depending on availability of space
The minimum required public conveniences such as toilets, bathing spaces and drinking water facility
shall be proposed at these locations.
Chemists / medicine shops, STD / PCO and Vehicle repairing shops shall be proposed
The locations of rest areas shall be advertised through signboards and overhead signs in advance.
Community / Cultural Resources
The project proposes the relocation I replacement of all community resources likely to be impacted. Apart
from replacing these community resources along the highway generic enhancement measures have been
worked out for the enhancement of these resources.
Disruption to the Community
Loss of Access
The contractor shall provide safe and convenient passage for vehicles, pedestrians and livestock to and
from side roads and property access connecting the project road. The construction activities that shall affect
the use of side roads and existing access to individual properties shall not be undertaken without providing
adequate provisions. The construction works will not interfere with the convenience of the public or the
access to, use and occupation of public or private roads whether public or private. Service roads are
proposed along with underpasses to ease access at locations where land acquisition shall impact access.
The locations of service road are provided in table 2-6 of this report.
Traffic Control during Construction
Detailed Traffic Control Plans will be prepared prior to commencement of works on any section of the
project road by the concessionaire. These plans shall be approved by the IC and or the site office of the
NHAI prior to execution. The traffic control plans will contain details of temporary diversions details of
arrangements for construction under traffic and details of traffic arrangement after cessation of work
each day.
Temporary diversion (including scheme of temporary and acquisition) will be constructed with the
approval of the Engineer. Special consideration will be given in the preparation of the traffic control plan
to the safety of pedestrians and workers at night.
The Contractor and the concessionaire will ensure that the running surface is always properly
maintained, particularly during the monsoon so that no disruption to the traffic flow occurs. The
temporary traffic detours will be kept free of dust by frequent application of water, if necessary.
The Contractor and the concessionaire will take all necessary measures for the safety of traffic during
construction and provide, erect and maintain such barricades, including signs, markings, flags, lights
and flagmen as may be required by the Engineer for the information and protection of traffic
approaching or passing through the section of the highway under improvement. Annexure 8.8: Traffic
Control and Safety during Construction gives the details of the road safety measured to be adopted
during construction.
Risks Associated - Mitigation
The Contractor and the concessionaire is required to comply with all the precautions as required for the
safety of the workmen as per the International Labour Organisation (ILO) Convention No.62 as far as those
are applicable to this contract. The contractor and the concessionaire will supply all necessary safety
appliances such as safety goggles, helmets, masks, etc., to the workers and staff. The contractor and the
concessionaire has to comply with all regulation regarding sage scaffolding, ladders, working platforms,
gangway, stairwells, excavations, trenches and safe means of entry and egress.
then, storage tanks will be provided. All water supply storage will be at a distance of not less than 15m from
any latrine, drain or other source of pollution. Where water has to be drawn from an existing well, which is
within such proximity of any latrine, drain or any other source of pollution, the well will be properly
chlorinated before water is drawn from it for drinking water. All such wells will be entirely closed in and be
provided with a trap door, which will be dust proof and waterproof. A reliable pump will be fitted to each
covered well. The trap door will be kept locked and opened only for cleaning or inspection, which will be
done at least once a month.
Hygiene
The Contractor and the concessionaire during the progress of work will provide, erect and maintain
necessary (temporary) living accommodation and ancillary facilities for labour to standards and scales
approved by the resident engineer. Refer Annexure 8.9: Guidelines For Sitting And Layout Of Construction
Camp.
There will be provided within the precincts of every workplace, latrines and urinals in an accessible place,
and the accommodation, separately for each for these, as per standards set by the Building and other
Construction Workers (regulation of Employment and Conditions of service) Act, 1996. Except in workplaces
provided with water-flushed latrines connected with a water borne sewage system, all latrines will be
provided with dry-earth system (receptacles) which will be cleaned at least four times daily and at least twice
during working hours and kept in a strict sanitary condition. Receptacles will be tarred inside and outside at
least once a year. If women are employed, separate latrines and urinals, screened from those for men and
marked Woman in vernacular will be provided. There will be adequate supply of water, close to latrines and
urinals.
All temporary accommodation must be constructed and maintained in such a fashion that uncontaminated
water is available for drinking, cooking and washing. The sewage system for the camp must be properly
designed, built and operated so that no health hazard occurs and no pollution to the air, ground or adjacent
watercourses take place. Compliance with the relevant legislation must be strictly adhered to. Garbage bins
must be provided in the camp and regularly emptied and the garbage disposed off in a hygienic manner.
Construction camps are to be sited away from vulnerable people and adequate health care is to be provided
for the work force. Unless otherwise arranged for by the local sanitary authority, arrangement for proper
disposal of excreta by incineration at the workplace will be made by means of a suitable incinerator
approved by the local medical health or municipal authorities. Alternatively, excreta may be disposed off by
putting a layer of night soils at the bottom of a permanent tank prepared for the purpose and covering it with
15 cm layer of waste or refuse and then covering it with a layer of earth for a fortnight (by then it will turn into
manure). On completion of the works, the whole of such temporary structures will be cleared away, all
rubbish burnt, excreta or other disposal pits or trenches filled in and effectively scaled off and the whole of
the site left clean and tidy, at the contractor and the concessionaire’s expense, to the entire satisfaction of
the Engineer.
8.3 ENHANCEMENT FOR CULTURAL PROPERTIES
The project strives to improve the experience of highway travelling by strengthening the physical link
between the corridor and the cultural properties falling along the road. Depending upon site-specific
situations the project strives to improve the access to these properties by providing walkway to the property
from the highway. Locally available materials like stone and bricks have been preferred for paving. CC
flooring also shall be adopted for ground treatment. At places plantation shall be used in addition to hard
landscaping measures to define precinct boundaries.
8.3.1 Plantation
Trees not only enrich the visual quality of a space but also act as functional buffer screens to counter
pollution, define areas and provide shade. Plantation of trees has been a prime enhancement as well as
mitigation measure in the project. Tree bases have been proposed around existing as well as proposed
shade trees to form informal seating spaces, which are evidently preferred to the formal seating spaces. At
cultural and religious properties locations, trees with religious significance like Ficus religiosa (Pipal) Emblica
officinalis (Amla), F. bengalensis (Banyan), Azadirachta indica (Neem), Magnifera indica (mango) etc. shall
be planted. Seating arrangement as given below shall be adopted depending upon site conditions.
8.3.2 Seating Spaces
Creating formal and / or informal seating spaces and rest areas where feasible and as per the scale of the
property in question were tried. In the case of availability of space, cultural properties if coupled with rest
areas will prove to be beneficial not only to the highway travellers but also the users of the religious
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
8-17
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
9. IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT
9.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter provides an assessment of the existing institutional arrangement within NHAI and, reflects on
capacity building / training issues that need to be addressed to ensure timely implementation of EMP. The
institutional arrangement proposed for this project has been presented here with newly defined roles and
responsibilities. The responsibility of implementing the mitigation measures lies with the NHAI. All
construction activities being taken up by the concessionaire selected through International Competitive
Bidding. The Independent Engineer shall monitor the implementation of the work on behalf of NHAI. The
concessionaire will be responsible for planning all Environmental Management Plan (EMP) activities. In the
pre-construction phase of the project the concessionaire shall study the EMP to identify environmental
issues and arrive at a suitable strategy for implementation.
9.2 EXISTING ENVIRONMENTAL CELL, NHAI
NHAI already has an organisational and institutional capacity at the headquarters created to meet the
requirements for implementation of the environmental mitigation measures in the EMP. At present, the
Environmental cell within the NHAI is headed by an Environmental Officer of the rank of DGM and reports to
CGM, LA at the headquarters. The incumbent officer is only entrusted with the proceedings of the
environmental issues of all NHAI projects. He is supported by the field staff of the Project Implementation
Units for all administrative purposes. As part of the PPP project it is envisaged that the Environmental Cell
will continue to:
Monitor progress of the implementation of the EMP measures in consonance with the timeline for the
project within the allotted budget;
Maintain interaction with the various other statutory bodies like State Pollution Control Board and the
MoEF;
Interact with the Environmental Expert of the Independent Engineer on the state of the environment
and mitigation and enhancement measures adopted;
Occasionally inspect the environmental measures being implemented by the Contractor;
Report progress of works, both in terms of physical progress and quality for transmission to statutory
authorities such as the Ministry of Environment and Forests;
Document and disseminate good practices, bottlenecks and their resolution during the implementation
of environmental measures.
9.3 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS
The NHAI is responsible for the implementation of the provisions made within the EMP through its site
offices. The services of Independent Engineer will be procured to assist the site offices for monitoring the
environmental aspects of the project during implementation. The organisation chart for implementation
arrangements is shown in Figure – 9.1.
9.3.1 Independent Engineer (IE)
The Independent Engineer, to be procured through ICB shall assist the NHAI with the implementation of
project, once the project documents are ready. The Environmental Expert of the IC shall be the key
personnel to ensure the successful implementation of EMP provisions. Since ICB procurement is envisaged,
the selected consultants are expected to have the necessary professional(s) to tackle the issues that the
project is likely to bring up. The Environmental Specialist of the IE will be a key position, which can be
leveraged to ensure that the contractor complies with the various EMP requirements.
The EMP prepared for the Project road under PPP, needs to be followed during the implementation of the
civil works. The EMP is integrated in the technical specification and contract documents. The key
responsibility of the Environmental Specialist will be the successful implementation of the EMP. In addition,
he / she will update NHAI on the progress of environmental protection and / or enhancement works as
envisaged in the EMP. It is envisaged that the responsibilities of the Environmental specialist of the IE will
include:
Supervise and monitor the implementation of EMP by the Contractor and the concessionaire
Review and approve site-specific environmental mitigation / enhancement designs worked out by the
contractor and the concessionaire based on the EMP prepared during project preparation
Review and recommend the contractors’ and concessionaire’s Implementation Plans for approval (with
any changes that may be necessary) to ensure compliance with the environmental provisions of the
Contract
Monitor tree plantation programs and the periodic Environmental Monitoring (Air, Noise, Water, etc.)
Programs to ensure compliance with the State requirements and the EMP.
Hold regular meetings with NHAI and keep it updated on the progress of site works
Prepare and submit Environmental progress report to NHAI
Develop and organise environmental training programmes to upgrade the skills within the staff of the
environmental cell, contractors and the concessionaire
Document and develop good practices during project implementation for wider dissemination
The project will require continuous environmental supervision from the IE’s side. Since the Environmental
Specialist for IE projects are deployed on intermittent basis, it is desirable to have the field engineers
supervising construction can be trained on environmental aspects, who then shall apprise the Team Leader
and the Environmental Specialist of any significant development on environment.
9.3.2 Concessionaire
For effective implementation and management of the EMP, The BOT / Annuity concessionaire shall contrive
to establish a Safety, Health and Environment (SHE) Cell headed by an Environment Officer to deal with the
environmental issues of the project. This officer shall interact with the contractor, NHAI, IC and other line
departments to ensure that the mitigation and enhancement measures mentioned in the EMP are adhered.
The Environmental officer of the concessionaire shall be the interface between the Environmental Specialist
of IC and the Environmental Officer of the contractor. His prime responsibility shall be to apprise the
Environmental Specialist of the IE about the ground conditions. He shall also procure the requisite
clearances and the NOCs for the project and shall also strictly supervise that the contractor adheres to the
EMP. The environmental officer can also look after the additional charges of safety and health.
Box 9-1: Qualification and Responsibilities of Environmental Officer of Concessionaire
Qualifications & Experience
Postgraduate in Environmental Science / Environmental Management / Zoology / Botany / Ecology /
Environmental Planning / degree in Civil Engineering with specialisation in environment.
10 years of total experience with a minimum of 3 years in the implementation of EMP of highway projects and an
understanding of environmental, health and safety issues.
Prior practical experience in State and National Highways would be an advantage.
Roles & Responsibilities
He / She shall be reporting directly to the Chief Project Manager of the Concessionaire.
Primarily responsible for implementation of the EMP on site and ensuing that the environmental quality is meeting
the standards laid down by Central Pollution Control Board and other related authority.
The EO shall implement the EMP by assigning the necessary resources (manpower, money and machinery) and
attend such meetings as are required for the effective implementation of the EMP on site.
He shall maintain a “Complain Register” to record any grievances from members of public.
He shall maintain a register of all road side trees planted and present within ROW.
The EO shall be the interface of the concessionaire with the client and the IC.
9.3.3 Contractor
Execution of works will be the responsibility of the contractor. The concessionaire may himself be the
executioner of the project or might decide to outsource or hire contractor for highways and structures, who
may in turn sublet some part of their work to petty contractors. In case the concessionaire decides to
execute the work by himself then the responsibilities of the EO as given in Box 9.2 shall also be performed
by the EO of the concessionaire.
If the concessionaire decides to outsource the work then the contractors shall employ an Environmental
Officer whose qualification and responsibilities shall be as per Box 9.2. The contractor shall be responsible
for both the jobs done by the petty contactor (if Sublet) as well by him. In both the cases the concessionaire
will implement the environmental measures (either through the contractors or themselves). This has been
done with a view to ensure that road construction and environmental management go together.
The environmental officer shall have a small environmental, health and safety team to help him in
implementing the EMP. These team members may / may not report to him / her directly but shall apprise him
of all the incidents and mark a formal report of any incident having an impact on the Health, Environment
and Safety issues.
Duty Officers (DO)
The Duty Officers shall, on day to day basis, monitor the Project Facilities and report to the EO on activities
that adversely affect the environment in the vicinity.
Supervisors
They shall take the necessary mitigation measures.
Plant Engineer
The Plant Engineer has the responsibility of managing and controlling the hot mix plant, crusher unit and
fleet of vehicles shall ensure that the environment is not degraded at his plant site. Even though the
Environmental Officer shall routinely monitor to detect any negative issues due to operations and bring it to
the knowledge of Plant manager for taking rectification works. In case of emergency the Plant Engineer shall
immediately notify the Environmental officer for necessary actions.
9.4 REPORTING SYSTEM
Reporting system provides necessary feedback for project management to ensure quality of the works and
that the program is on schedule. The rationale for a reporting system is based on accountability to ensure
that the measures proposed as part of the Environmental Management Plan get implemented in the project.
Reporting system for the suggested monitoring program operates at two levels as:
Reporting for environmental condition indicators and environmental management indicators
Reporting for operational performance indicators at the NHAI site level.
The reporting system will operate linearly – contractor who is at the lowest rung of the implementation
system reporting to the Concessionaire, who in turn shall report to IE and the NHAI as per figure 9-1. All
reporting by the concessionaire shall be on a quarterly basis, while the reporting time of the contractor shall
be decided upon by the concessionaire.
The NHAI Site Office will be responsible for setting the targets for the various activities anticipated during
construction phase in consultation with the IE and obtaining agreement from the Contractor after
mobilisation but before beginning of works on site. The contractor will report from then on regarding the
status on each of these. The NHAI Site Office will monitor the activities through its own staff or the
consultant’s Environmental Specialist after it has obtained the Contractor’s report with the Consultant’s
remarks on it during the construction phase. During the operation phase, the supervision as well as reporting
responsibilities will lie with the NHAI Site Office.
Table 9-1: Summary of Reporting of Environmental components and Responsibilities
Independent Engineer NHAI PIU
Format No. Item Timing Overseeing /
Supervision Reporting
Compliance
CONTRACTOR MOBILIZATION AND SITE CLEARANCE
Reporting by contractor to IC for dumping Before start of
M1 As required Quarterly As required
locations & construction and labour camp site construction
Reporting by contractor to IC for construction Before start of
M2 As required Quarterly As required
and labour camp site construction
M3 Target sheet for Tree cutting Before start of work As required After cutting As required
Before start of
M4 Reporting for borrow areas As required Quarterly As required
construction
CONSTRUCTION PHASE
After
C1 Target sheet for Pollution Monitoring As per Monitoring Plan As required As required
Monitoring
C2 Top soil Conservation Before start of work As required Quarterly As required
OPERATION PHASE
After
O1 Target sheet for Pollution Monitoring During Operation As required As required
Monitoring
After completion of After
O2 Redevelopment of Borrow Areas As required As required
usage of Borrow Area Monitoring
After
O3 Survival Rate of Trees During Operation As required As required
Monitoring
NHAI
Chief Project Manager
Project Director / CGM (Concessionaire)
(Env)
State Pollution
Control Board /
MoEF
Construction /
Project Manager
Team Leader (Contractor)
(Independent Engineer)
Environmental Expert
(Independent Engineer) Environmental
Officer
(Contractor)
Direct Indirect
The concessionaire shall provide Foot over bridge or other facilities near schools & hospitals beside the
proposed underpasses and service roads (if found necessary during construction)
10.2.3 Community properties
Some community properties like graveyards are impacted. The relocation / rehabilitation shall be as
recommended in the RAP
New bus shelters along with bus bays are proposed in place of the existing bus shelters which are
directly impacted.
Water resources to be impacted shall be relocated prior to construction works
10.3 IMPLEMENTATION OF EMP
The Environmental Officer of the concessionaire should be available for the entire duration of the project.
The Environmental Officer of the concessionaire shall be primarily responsible for compliance of EMP. The
Environmental Specialist of the IC who should ideally be deployed for the entire duration shall monitor the
compliance of the EMP. The key issues that require special attention along with the mitigations and
enhancement measures to be implemented have been detailed in Table 10-1.
3
Some of the mitigation measures are preventive in nature while some others include additional measures in terms of environmental conservation and involve physical and construction work.
4
Unless otherwise stated, the Project Site covers area beyond ROW, such as borrow areas, access roads, service roads and equipment storage sites (MoRT&H: 306.3).
5
Time frame refers to the duration or instant of time when the mitigation measures will be taken.
6
The contract requirements refer to the following:
Ministry of Shipping, Road Transport & Highways, (MoRT&H) Government of India, Specifications for Road and Bridge Works, Specific and general conditions of the contract.
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
10-3
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km
110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
All community underground and overhead utilities will
Resettlement
be shifted as per Utility Shifting Plan, prior R&R Officer,
Post design to Pre- Action Plan (RAP),
Relocation of Utilities permission will be required from regional offices of Concessionaire / IE, NHAI
construction Utility Relocation
Electricity, Telecommunications, OFC, Water works Contractor
Plan
etc.
Private drinking water source replaced according to
Loss of drinking water RAP and public water sources replaced. Post design to Pre- Concessionaire / Resettlement
IE, NHAI
source Temporary arrangements shall be provided, if the construction Contractor Action Plan (RAP)
existing water supply is disrupted accidentally.
Cultural properties affected to be relocated as per
RAP and Public Consultation. Resettlement
Concessionaire /
Cultural Properties Mitigation / enhancement measures have been Pre-construction IE Action Plan (RAP),
Contractor
suggested for each of the cultural property MoRT&H: 301.5
individually.
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
SPCB and submit a copy to the Independent
Engineer (IE).
Location of dumping sites shall be finalized based on
the guidelines given in Annexure 8.1 and the
Independent Engineer (IE) shall certify that :
These are not located within designated forest
Identification of Throughout the During Concessionaire /
areas. IE, NHAI Annexure 8.1
dumping sites corridor mobilisation Contractor
The dumping does not impact natural drainage
courses
Settlements are located at least 1 km away from
the site.
CONSTRUCTION STAGE
Secure the following clearances prior to start of
construction activity:
Type of clearance Applicability
NOC and consents under
For establishment
Air, Water & Environment
of construction
Act and noise rules from
camp.
SPCB
NOC and consents under For operating
Air, Water & Environment construction plant,
Act and noise rules from crusher, batching
SPCB plant etc.
Explosive License from For storing fuel oil,
Chief Controller of lubricants, diesel
NHAI, SPCB, CPCB,
Explosives etc.
Chief Controller of
Manufacture Construction stage
Permission for storage of Explosives, District
storage and Import (Prior to initiation of General Conditions
hazardous chemical from Collector State
Clearances and of Hazardous any work). Concessionaire / of Contract.
CPCB Department of Mines,
approvals Chemicals Time period in Contractor Clause 111.3,
State Ground Water
Borrow Area, approval getting the MoRT&H
Board, State Irrigation
from District Collector, permission varies
Borrow area for Department, Labour
Consent letter, lease Commissioner Officer
excavation of earth
agreement with the Owner
of land.
Quarry Lease Deed and
Quarry operation
Quarry License from State
(for new quarry)
Department of Mines
Permission for extraction
of ground water for use in
Extraction of
road construction activities
ground water
from State Ground Water
Board
Permission for use of Use of surface
water for construction water for
purpose from irrigation construction
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
10-5
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km
110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
department
Labour license from labour Engagement of
commissioner office Labour
Provide a copy of all necessary clearances to the IC
Adhere to all clearance terms and conditions
Obtain written permission from private
landholders to conduct construction activities on
their land prior to commencing works.
Land
Main reason of soil erosion is rains. Concessionaire /
Contractor should plan the activities so that No
naked / loose earth surface is left out before the
onset of monsoon, for minimising the soil erosion
following preventive measures to be taken such as:
Embankment slopes to be covered, soon after
completion.
Next layer / activity to be planted, soon after
completion of clearing and grubbing, laying of
embankment layer, sub-grade layer, sub-base
layer, scarification etc. Upon completion of
Throughout Project MORT&H
construction
Top soil from borrow area, Debris disposal sites; Corridor, Specification
Soil Erosion and activities at these Concessionaire /
borrow area, construction site to be protected / Service roads and IE, NHAI 305.2.2.2, 306, 307,
Sedimentation control sites. Contractor
covered for soil erosion. equipment storage 308
Debris due to excavation of foundation, sites, etc.
During construction
dismantling of existing cross drainage structure
will be removed from the water course
immediately.
Diversions for bridges will be removed from the
water course before the onset of monsoon
Along sections abutting water bodies, stone
pitching needs to be carried out.
At the outfall of each culvert, erosion prevention
measure, such as the following, will be
undertaken,
All areas of cutting and all areas to be permanently
covered will be stripped to a depth of 150 mm and
stored in stockpile.
The stockpile will be designed such that the slope
does not exceed 1:2 (vertical to horizontal), and the All along Project
MoRT&H: 301.3.2,
Loss of agricultural height of the pile is to be restricted to 2m. Stockpiles Corridor, where Concessionaire /
During construction IE, NHAI 301.7, 305.3.3 &
top soil will not be surcharged or otherwise loaded and productive land is Contractor
305.3.9
multiple handling will be kept to a minimum to ensure acquired
that no compaction will occur. The stockpiles will be
covered with gunny bags or tarpaulin. It will be
ensured by the Concessionaire / Contractor that the
topsoil will not be unnecessarily trafficked either
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
10-6
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km
110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
before stripping or when in stockpiles.
Top soil will be safeguard from erosion and will be
reused as follows:
Covering all borrow areas after excavation is
over.
Dressing of slopes of road embankment
Agricultural field, acquired temporarily
Construction vehicles should operate within the
Corridor of Impact avoiding damage to soil and
vegetation.
Diversions, access road used will be redeveloped by
Compaction of Soil Concessionaire / Contractor, to the satisfaction of the Throughout Project MORT&H
Concessionaire /
and Damage to owner / villagers. Corridor and all areas During construction IE, NHAI Specification 112.6,
Contractor
Vegetation Construction vehicle, machinery and equipment shall temporarily acquired. 201.2
move or be stationed in the ROW only. While
operating on temporarily acquired agricultural land
for any construction activities, top soil will be
preserved in stockpiles.
Guidelines of “Hazardous waste (management
and handling) rules, 1989 will be enforced.
Vehicle / machinery and equipment operation,
maintenance and refuelling shall be carried out in
such a fashion that spillage of fuels and lubricants
does not contaminate the ground. An “oil
interceptor” will be provided for wash down and At fuel storage areas
refuelling areas. – usually at
During Concessionaire / Chapter-8 of this
Contamination of soil Fuel storage shall be in proper bunded areas. All construction camps, IE, NHAI
Construction. Contractor Report.
spills and collected petroleum products shall be temporarily acquired
disposed off in accordance with MoEF and SPCB site.
guidelines at designated locations.
Plant to be set up 500 m away from surface water
body.
Oil interceptor will be installed at construction site.
Septic tank will be constructed for safe disposal of
waste.
Quarry material shall be sourced from approved
and licensed aggregate and sand quarries as
given in Table 8.3 & 8.4. Copy of licenses to be
submitted to the IE.
1. Quarrying Annexure 8.3
For operating new quarries, the Concessionaire /
Concessionaire / MORT&H
Contractor shall obtain materials from quarries Table 8.3 & 8.4 During construction IE, NHAI
Contractor Specification 111.3,
only after consent of the DoF or other concerned
2. Material sources 302, 305.2.2.
authorities and only after development of a
comprehensive quarry’ redevelopment plan.
Adequate safety precautions shall be ensured
during transportation of quarry material from
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
10-7
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km
110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
quarries to the construction site. Vehicles
transporting the material shall be covered to
prevent spillage. Operations to be undertaken by
the Concessionaire / Contractor as per the
direction and satisfaction of the IE.
Debris generated due to the dismantling of the
existing pavement structure and the cutting of the
Generation of Debris Throughout Project During Concessionaire / MoRT&H: 112.6 &
hillside for the widening shall be suitably reused in IE, NHAI
Corridor. Construction Contractor 112.2
the proposed construction as fill materials for
embankments
The disposal of debris shall be carried out only at
sites identified for the purpose. The Concessionaire /
Sites identified by the
Contractor shall carry out the disposal as described
Concessionaire /
in Annexure 8.1.
Contractor and
All arrangement for transportation during During Concessionaire /
Disposal of Debris approved by the IE, NHAI Annexure 8.1
construction including provision, maintenance, Construction Contractor, IC / SC
Independent
dismantling and clearing debris, where necessary will
Engineer (IE).
be considered incidental to the work and should be
planned and implemented by the Concessionaire /
Contractor as approved and directed by IE.
Air
Vehicles delivering materials should be covered
to reduce spills and dust blowing off the load.
Clearing and grubbing to be done, just before the
start of next activity on that site.
In laying sub-base, water spraying is needed to
aid compaction of the material. After the
compaction, water spraying should be carried out
at regular intervals to limit the dust to below
Road surface should be cleaned with air
compressor and vacuum cleaners prior to the
Beginning with &
construction works. Manual labour using brooms
Throughout Project throughout MORT&H
should be avoided, if used labour to be provided
Corridor, all access construction until Concessionaire / Specification 111.1,
Dust Generation masks. IE, NHAI
roads, temporarily asphalting is Contractor 111.5, 111.8, 111.9,
Embankment slopes to be covered with turfing / acquired sites. completed and side 111.10 & 118.1
stone pitching immediately after completion. slopes are covered.
The Concessionaire / Contractor shall take every
precaution to reduce the level of dust emission
from the hot mix plants and the batching plants up
to the satisfaction of the IE
All existing highways and roads used by vehicles
of the Concessionaire / Contractor, or any of his
sub-Contractor or suppliers of materials or plant
and similarly roads which are part of the works
shall be kept clean and clear of all dust/mud or
other extraneous materials dropped by such
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
vehicles or their tyres.
Plants, machinery and equipment shall be so
handled (including dismantling) as to minimise
generation of dust.
The discharge standards promulgated under the
Environment Protection Act, 1986 shall be strictly
adhered to. All vehicles, equipment and
machinery used for construction shall conform to Throughout Project
MORT&H Spec 106,
Equipment Selection, the relevant Bureau of Indian Standard (BIS) Corridor, all access
During Concessionaire / IRC: 72-1978, IRC:
Maintenance and norms. roads, sites IE, NHAI
Construction. Contractor 90-1985, 111.5,
Operation All vehicles, equipment and machinery used for temporarily acquired
111.9, 111.10, 2013
construction shall be regularly maintained to and all borrow areas.
ensure that pollution emission levels comply with
the relevant requirements of SPCB and the
Independent Engineer (IE).
All crushers used in construction shall conform to
relevant dust emission control legislations.
Clearance for siting shall be obtained from the
SPCB.
Alternatively, only crushers already licensed by
the SPCB shall be used.
During Erection,
Water will be sprayed during the non-monsoon
Pollution from All Aggregate Testing, Operation Concessionaire /
months, regularly to minimise dust, in the whole IE, NHAI MoRT&H: 111.1
Crusher Crushing Plants. and Dismantling of Contractor
crusher plant area.
Such plants.
The suspended particulate matter contribution
value at a distance of 40m from a controlled
isolated as well as from a unit located in a cluster
should be less than 500g/m3. The monitoring is
to be conducted as envisaged in the monitoring
plan.
Water
No excavation from the bund of the water bodies.
No debris disposal near any water body.
Prior written permission from authorities for use of
water for construction activity will be submitted to
IC.
Construction labours to be restricted from MORT&H
Loss of water bodies/ polluting the source or misusing the source. Concessionaire / Specification 111.4,
Near all water bodies During construction Concessionaire
surface / ground Shifting of source to be completed prior to Contractor 201.2, 301, 304,
disruption of the actual source. 306 & 305.4.1
Alternate measures to be taken / ensured during
disrupted period.
Source to be replaced immediately, in case of
accidental loss.
Construction work shall be restricted to 3m – 4m
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
width from the existing formation near ponds.
The volume of water storage lost shall be
compensated for by excavation of an equal
volume of similar depth at closest possible
location in the direction of flow and shall be done
with the approval of the Independent Engineer
(IE).
Diversions will be constructed during dry season,
with adequate drainage facility, and will be
completely removed before the onset of
monsoon.
Debris generated due to the excavation of Throughout Project
Whenever MORT&H
foundation or due to the dismantling of existing Corridor, all access Concessionaire /
Alteration of drainage encountered during IE, NHAI Specification 201.2,
structure will be removed from the water course. roads, temporarily Contractor
construction 301, 304, 306, 312.
Temporary Silt fencing to be provided on the acquired sites.
mouth of discharge into natural streams.
Continuous drain (lined / unlined) is suggested /
will be provided. Obstruction, if any, will be
removed immediately.
Throughout continuous drain is provided.
Lined drain is provided at built-up locations for
quick drainage.
Concessionaire /
Runoff and drainage Increased runoff due to increased impervious During Construction
Contractor
IE, NHAI
surface is countered through increased pervious
surface area through soak pits and rain water
harvesting structures.
Concessionaire / Contractor will provide a list of
sources (surface / ground) for approval from IE
Prior to use of source Concessionaire / Contractor
will take the written permission from authority, to
use the water in construction activity, and submit Throughout Project
Water requirement for a copy to IE. Corridor, all access Concessionaire /
During Construction IE, NHAI
project During construction only permitted quantity roads, temporarily Contractor
(permission taken) from approved sources will be acquired sites.
used.
Concessionaire / Contractor will ensure optimum
use of water; discourage labour from wastage of
water.
Measures suggested under “Soil Erosion and
Sedimentation control” will be enforced.
MORT&H
Silt fencing is provided around water bodies.
Throughout Concessionaire / Specification 111.4,
Silting / sedimentation Construction activities will be stopped near water construction period Contractor
IE, NHAI
306
bodies during monsoon.
EP Act, 1986
Soil trap are suggested / will be provided in all
ancillary sites and camps.
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
Measures suggested under “Contamination of
soil” will be enforced. Throughout
All areas in MORT&H
construction period,
Construction work close to water bodies will be immediate vicinity of Specification 111.1,
During
Contamination of avoided during monsoon. construction Concessionaire / 111.4, 111.9,
Establishment, IE, NHAI
water Labour camps will be located away from water campsite chosen by
Operation and
Contractor 111.13, 122, 201.2,
bodies. the Concessionaire / 201.4, 301.1.3.10,
Dismantling of
Car washing / workshops near water bodies will Contractor.
Labour Camps.
304.3.3, 306
be avoided.
Noise
Noise standard at processing sites, eg. Aggregate
crushing plants, batching plant, hot mix plant will
be strictly monitored to prevent exceeding of
noise standards.
Workers in vicinity of loud noise, and workers
working with or in crushing, compaction, concrete
mixing operations shall wear earplugs and their
working time should be limited as a safety
measure.
In construction sites within 150 m of sensitive
MORT&H
receptors construction will be stopped from 22:00
Specification No.
to 06:00.
Throughout Project 111, 111.1, 111.13,
Machinery and vehicles will be maintained to 111.5 & 111.6
Corridor, all access
Noise from Vehicles, keep their noise to a minimum. Throughout Concessionaire /
roads, sites IE, NHAI
Plants and Equipment Construction of noise barriers at sensitive temporarily acquired
construction Contractor
Environment
receptors. and all borrow areas. (Protection) Rules,
All vehicles and equipment used in construction 1986.
shall be fitted with exhaust silencers. During
routine servicing operations, the effectiveness of
exhaust silencers shall be checked and if found to
be defective shall be replaced.
Noise limits for construction equipment used in
this project (measured at one metre from the
edge of the equipment in free field) such as
compactors, rollers, front loaders, concrete
mixers, cranes (moveable), vibrators and saws
shall not exceed 75 dB(A), as specified in the
Environment (Protection) Rules, 1986.
Blasting shall be carried out only with permission
of the Independent Engineer (IE). All the statutory
laws, regulations, rules etc., pertaining to During
Noise from Blasting or acquisition, transport, storage, handling and use Preparation,
All Blasting and Pre- Concessionaire / MoRT&H: 302.1 &
Pre-splitting of explosives shall be strictly followed. Operation and IE, NHAI
splitting Sites. Contractor 302.4
Operations Blasting shall be carried out during fixed hours Closure of Such
(preferably during mid-day), as permitted by the Sites.
Independent Engineer (IE). The timing should be
made known to all people within 500m (200m for
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
10-11
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km
110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
pre-splitting) from the blasting site in all directions.
People, except those who actually light the fuse
shall be excluded from the area of 200m (50m for
pre-splitting) from the blasting site in all directions
at least 10 minutes before the blasting.
Flora & Fauna
Plant and maintain 26647 flowering, shade,
medicinal, ornamental & fruit bearing trees in
suitable area for the entire duration of the contract
period
Plant and maintain a minimum 80020 ornamental,
medicinal & flowering plants and shrubs in the
Annexure 8.7
median for the entire duration of the contract
Loss of trees and period After completion of MORT&H
Concessionaire /
Avenue Planting & Annexure 8.7 construction IE, NHAI Specification, 111,
Identify, transplant and maintain 1394 trees of Contractor
transplantation activities 111.5, 201.5, 306,
various girth, height and species for the entire
308
duration of the project period
Cost of plantation included in the EMP Budget.
Concessionaire / Contractor has to make sure
that no trees / branches to be fell by labourer for
fuel & or warmth during winter. Enough provision
of fuel to be ensured.
Clearing and grubbing should be avoided beyond
that which is directly required for construction
activities.
During cleaning
Next activity to be planned / started immediately, Concessionaire / MORT&H
Vegetation clearance operations. IE, NHAI
to avoid dust generation and soil erosion during Contractor Specification 201.2
During construction
monsoon.
Turfing / re-vegetation to be started soon after
completion of embankment.
Construction workers must protect natural
resources and wild animals. MORT&H
Concessionaire /
Fauna Hunting will be prohibited. During construction IE, NHAI Specification 111.1,
Contractor
Nesting grounds & migratory paths will be 111.6.
protected.
Socio – Economic Environment
Debris generated will be disposed to the satisfaction
Public Health and of Independent Engineer (IE). Concessionaire /
During Construction IE, NHAI
Safety Monitoring of air, water, noise and land during Contractor
construction and operational phase.
The Concessionaire / Contractor will provide, erect
and maintain barricades, including signs marking Concessionaire /
Accidents During Construction IE, NHAI
flats, lights and flagmen as required by the Contractor
Independent Engineer (IE).
Resettlement Action A comprehensive resettlement action plan has been During Construction Concessionaire / IE, NHAI
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
of People prepared to improve the standard of living of the Contractor, NHAI
affected population.
Precaution to be taken for any accidental loss to
community and cultural property
Any loss made shall be the responsibility of the
Concessionaire / Contractor and made good by
Sensitive community him at his own cost Concessionaire /
During Construction IE, NHAI RAP
and cultural facilities Through access / identification to be maintained Contractor
Endeavour towards enhancement of community
and cultural property
Community consultations for any relocation,
mitigation measures adopted
The Concessionaire / Contractor shall provide
safe and convenient passage for vehicles,
pedestrians and livestock to and from side roads
and property accesses connecting the project
road. Work that affects the use of side roads and
existing accesses shall not be undertaken without
providing adequate provisions to the prior
satisfaction of the Independent Engineer (IE).
The works shall not interfere with or cause
inconvenience to public or restrict the access to
Temporary Loss of All along the Project During Concessionaire / MoRT&H: 112.7
use and occupation of public or private roads, and IE, NHAI
Access corridor Construction Contractor
any other access footpaths to or of properties
whether public or private.
Access across the work-zone will be provided for
two slots every day during construction (2 hours
in the morning and 2 hours in the afternoon). For
this purpose the Concessionaire / Contractor shall
maintain a strip of pavement across the work
zone of such quality that light motor vehicles
(LMV) can pass without difficulty or danger of
breaking down.
Road Safety And Construction Safety
Detailed Traffic Control Plans shall be prepared
and submitted to the Independent Engineer (IE)
for approval, 5 days prior to commencement of
works on any section of road. The traffic control
plans shall contain details of arrangements for
Traffic Delays and All along the Project During Concessionaire / MoRT&H: 112.1 &
construction under traffic and details of traffic IE, NHAI
Congestion Corridor. Construction Contractor 112.2
arrangement after cessation of work each day.
The Concessionaire / Contractor shall ensure that
the running surface is always maintained in
running condition, particularly during the monsoon
so that no disruption to the traffic flow occurs.
Traffic Control and The Concessionaire / Contractor shall take all Entire Project site. During Concessionaire / IE, NHAI MoRT&H: 112.1 &
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
10-13
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km
110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
Safety necessary measures for the safety of traffic during Construction Contractor 112.4
construction and provide, erect and maintain such Annexure 8.9
barricades, including signs, markings, flags, lights
and flagmen as may be required by the
Independent Engineer for the information and
protection of traffic approaching or passing
through the section of the highway under
improvement.
All signs, barricades, pavement markings shall be
as per the MoRT&H specification. Before taking
up construction on any section of the highway, a
traffic control plan shall be devised to the
satisfaction of the Independent Engineer.
The Concessionaire / Contractor is required to
comply with all the precautions as required for the
safety of the workmen as per the International
Labour Organisation (ILO) Convention No. 62 as
far as those are applicable to this contract.
The Concessionaire / Contractor shall supply all
necessary safety appliances such as safety
During Concessionaire /
Risk from Operations goggles, helmets, masks, etc., to the workers and Entire Project site. IE, NHAI Factory Act
Construction Contractor
staff.
The Concessionaire / Contractor has to comply
with all regulation regarding safe scaffolding,
ladders, working platforms, gangway, stairwells,
excavations, trenches and safe means of entry
and egress.
No child labour shall be utilized in the project
Adequate precautions will be taken to prevent
danger from electrical equipment.
No material or any of the sites will be so stacked
or placed as to cause danger or inconvenience to
any person or the public.
All necessary fencing and lights will be provided
Risk from Electrical to protect the public. During Concessionaire /
Entire Project site. IE, NHAI MoRT&H: 106
Equipment All machines to be used in the construction will Construction Contractor
conform to the relevant Indian Standards (IS)
codes, will be free from defect, will be kept in
good working order, will be regularly inspected
and properly maintained as per IS provisions and
to the satisfaction of the Independent Engineer
(IE).
All workers employed on mixing asphaltic
Risk at Hazardous material, cement, lime mortars, concrete etc., will During Concessionaire /
Entire Project site. IE, NHAI
Activity be provided with protective footwear and Construction Contractor MoRT&H: 111.1
protective goggles.
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
Workers, who are engaged in welding works,
would be provided with welder’s protective eye-
shields. Stonebreakers will be provided with
protective goggles and clothing and will be seated
at sufficiently safe intervals.
The use of any toxic chemical shall be strictly in MoRT&H: 111.6
accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions.
The Independent Engineer (IE) shall be given at
least 6 working day’s notice of the proposed use
of toxic chemical. A register of all toxic chemicals
delivered to the site shall be kept and maintained
up to date by the Concessionaire / Contractor.
The register shall include the trade name,
physical properties and characteristics, chemical
ingredients, health and safety hazard information,
safe handling and storage procedures, and
emergency and first aid procedures for the
product.
All reasonable precaution will be taken to prevent
danger of the workers and the public from fire, flood,
Risk caused by Force’ During Concessionaire /
drowning, etc. All necessary steps will be taken for Entire Project site IE, NHAI
Majure Construction Contractor
prompt first aid treatment of all injuries likely to be
sustained during the course of work.
At every workplace, a readily available first aid
unit including an adequate supply of sterilised
dressing material and appliances will be provided
as per the Factory Act.
Workplaces, remote and far away from regular During Concessionaire / MoRT&H: 1207.6,
First Aid hospitals will have indoor heath units with one Entire Project site. IE, NHAI
Construction Contractor Factories Act,
bed for every 250 workers. Suitable transport will 1948
be provided to facilitate take injured or ill
person(s) to the nearest applicable hospital. At
every workplace and construction camp,
equipment and nursing staff shall be provided.
All relevant provisions of the Factories Act, 1948
and The Building and other Construction Workers
(regulation of Employment and Conditions of Factories Act,
Service) Act, 1996 will be adhered to. 1948 and The
Building and other
Adequate safety measures for workers during
Construction
Safety Measures handling of materials at site will be taken up. During Concessionaire /
All construction sites IE, NHAI Workers
During Construction The register will include the trade name, physical construction Contractor
(Regulation Of
properties and characteristics, chemical Employment and
ingredients, health and safety hazard information, Conditions of
safe handling and storage procedures, and Service) Act, 1996
emergency and first aid procedures for the
product.
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
Latrines shall be provided with septic tank. The
effluents can be diverted for horticulture inside the
camps.
The septic tank may be cleaned once in 6 months
and filter cleaned after a year.
All temporary accommodation must be
constructed and maintained in such a fashion that
uncontaminated water is available for drinking,
cooking and washing.
Garbage bins must be provided in the camps and
regularly emptied and the garbage disposed off in During Concessionaire /
Hygiene a hygienic manner. All Worker’s Camps IE, NHAI
construction Contractor
Adequate health care is to be provided for the
work force. Unless otherwise arranged for by the
local sanitary authority, the local medical health or
municipal authorities.
On completion of the works, all such temporary
structures shall be cleared away, all rubbish
burnt, septic tank and other disposal pits filled in
and effectively sealed off and the outline site left
clean and tidy, at the Concessionaire /
Contractor’s expense, to the entire satisfaction of
the Independent Engineer (IE).
Concessionaire / Contractor to prepare site
restoration plans for approval by the Independent
Engineer (IE). The plan is to be implemented by the
Concessionaire / Contractor prior to demobilisation.
On completion of the works, all temporary structures
Clearing of will be cleared away, all rubbish burnt, excreta or
Construction of other disposal pits or trenches filled in and effectively Concessionaire /
All Workers’ Camps IE, NHAI
Camps & sealed off and the site left clean and tidy, at the Contractor
Restoration Concessionaire / Contractor’s expense, to the entire
satisfaction of the Independent Engineer (IE).
Residual topsoil will be distributed on adjoining /
proximate barren / rocky areas as identified by the
Independent Engineer (IE) in a layer of thickness of
75mm - 150mm.
Table 4.1, 4.4, 4.6 &
The monitoring of land, air, water and Noise to be
4.9 of chapter 4;
Monitoring at critical carried out identified critical locations as given in Concessionaire /
IE Table 10.1: EMP
locations Table 4.1, 4.4, 4.6 & 4.9 besides locations identified Contractor
Budget &
by IC along the project corridor.
Annexure 10.1
OPERATION STAGE
Water quality Silt fencing, Oil & Grease traps, etc. shall be At sensitive water As per Monitoring
During Operational
degradation due to provided at sensitive water bodies to ensure that bodies identified. NHAI and / or SPCB NHAI plan in Annexure
Stage
road run-off the water quality is not impaired due to As specified in the 10.1
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
contaminants from road run-off. monitoring plan
Monitoring shall be carried out as specified in the
Monitoring plan
Contingency plans to be in place for cleaning up
of spills of oil, fuel and toxic chemicals.
Spill of oil, fuel and automobile servicing units
without adequate disposal systems in place to be
discouraged.
Contamination of
Accidental spills are potentially disastrous, but its
Soil and Water Entire Project During Operational Concessionaire /
probability is quite low as one of the objectives of IE, NHAI
Resources from corridor. Stage Contractor
this project is to enhance road safety.
Spills Accidents
The Public will be informed about the regulations
on land pollution.
Land pollution monitoring program has been
devised for checking pollution level and
suggesting remedial measures.
Depending on the level of congestion and traffic
hazards, traffic management plans will be
prepared. Concessionaire /
Traffic control measures including speed limits to All along the Project Contractor, Local NHAI /
Traffic and Accident During Operational Through
be enforced strictly. corridor and Government Bodies, Concessionaire /
Safety Stage Operation Stage.
Road control width to be enforced. Local surrounding areas. Development Contractor
government bodies and development authorities Authorities.
will be encouraged to control building
development along the highway.
Compliance with the Hazardous Wastes
(Management and Handling) Rules, 1989
Creation of an Emergency Response team
For delivery of hazardous substances, permit
license, driving license and guidance license will
NHAI, Motor
Accidents involving be required.
All along the Project Vehicles
Hazardous Public security, transportation and fire fighting corridor and
During Operational Concessionaire /
Department,
Materials departments will designate a special route for Stage Contractor
surrounding areas District
vehicles delivering hazardous material. These Administration
vehicles will only be harboured at designated
parking lots.
In case of spill of hazardous materials, the
relevant departments will be intimated at once to
deal with it with the spill contingency plan.
Trees planted along the corridor shall be
maintained for a period of three years.
All along the corridor
Road side tree Maintenance works include, watering of the During Operational Concessionaire /
Immediately from the IE, NHAI
plantation saplings, and all necessary measures for survival Stage Contractor
planting of sapling
of the sapling.
The avenue plantation should be completed,
Environmental Responsibility
Mitigation Measures3 Location4 Time Frame5 Cross reference6
Impact / Aspect Implementation Supervision
maintained and casualties to be replaced.
Discouraging local peoples from cutting tree /
branches for fuel, cattle food etc.
Educating people about the usefulness of trees.
Table 4.1, 4.4, 4.6 &
The monitoring of land, air, water and noise to be
4.9 of chapter 4;
Monitoring at critical carried out identified critical locations as given in Concessionaire /
IE Table 10.1: EMP
locations Table 4.1, 4.4, 4.6 & 4.9 besides locations identified Contractor
Budget &
by IC along the project corridor.
Annexure 10.1
HORN PROHIBITED sign post will be enforced SPCB, State Police,
After completion of
Maintenance of noise barriers Traffic Police, State
construction IRC 35-1971
Noise Discouraging local people from establishing Throughout and after
During Operational Forest Dept., Transport
IE IRC 79-1981
sensitive receptor near the road. Stage Dept., Concessionaire /
project development IRC 93-1995
The public will be informed about the regulations period
Contractor and Planning
on noise pollution. Authorities
Co-ordinate
Sl. Village/ Lead Survey Qty
Chainage Taluka Side
No Panchayat E N in km Nos. (Lakhs
cum)
581006.00 1896669.00
580937.00 1896637.00
6 60.600 Hadalsang Indi RHS 3.600 102/1 0.364
580781.14 1896885.05
580774.09 1896663.68
581574.00 1896405.00
581707.00 1896407.00
7 60.600 Sonakanahalli Indi RHS 0.500 117 0.486
582102.65 1896393.51
582106.01 1896322.90
589382.00 1919973.00
589468.00 1919772.00
8 36.000 Dhulikhed Indi RHS 0.100 149 0.405
589667.00 1920002.00
589599.08 1919776.94
585532.00 1910356.00
585537.00 1910382.00
9 46.600 Zalaki Indi RHS 0.500 67/1 0.202
585314.00 1910462.00
585311.00 1910352.00
586241.00 1910699.00
585986.00 1910817.00
10 45.800 Arajanal Indi RHS 0.100 173 0.971
586111.00 1911037.00
586398.87 1910995.17
580812.71 1880368.97
580807.66 1880256.83
11 77.700 Tidagundi Bijapur LHS 0.100 - 0.162
580963.04 1880357.35
580961.27 1880256.83
580025.61 1877868.16
580028.14 1877926.29
12 80.250 Tidagundi Bijapur RHS 0.100 111B 0.081
579891.15 1877932.24
579890.36 1877870.75
578897.40 1873063.63 (100 to
578612.94 1872999.14 102) &
13 85.000 Kannal Bijapur RHS 0.100 3.238
578940.03 1873391.37 (103 to
578655.57 1873326.88 107)
578967.38 1873181.69
578967.38 1873148.06
14 85.000 Kannal Bijapur LHS 0.100 0.081
579014.43 1873182.41
579014.69 1873148.78
579196.93 1872855.94
579266.74 1872856.67
579204.08 1872748.64
579303.55 1872857.12
15 85.500 Kannal Bijapur LHS 0.400 91/1 0.121
579270.72 1872747.98
579307.16 1872798.20
579299.09 1872745.96
579200.19 1872802.13
579513.64 1872851.12
579527.81 1872764.46
16 85.500 Kannal Bijapur LHS 0.400 87 & 91/2 0.405
579219.80 1872629.64
579205.63 1872716.30
Co-ordinate
Sl. Village/ Lead Survey Qty
Chainage Taluka Side
No Panchayat E N in km Nos. (Lakhs
cum)
578523.00 1868320.00
578481.00 1868233.00
17 85.500 Kannal Bijapur 578467.00 1868200.00 LHS 0.900 81/2C/1 0.364
578424.00 1868234.00
578480.00 1868354.00
577509.18 1867131.27
577648.98 1867154.87
577615.96 1867186.58
18 91.200 Bhutnal Bijapur 577511.56 1867199.30 LHS 0.000 93 0.162
577517.72 1867230.63
577365.82 1867209.72
577370.71 1867288.23
583561.63 1887161.33
583576.28 1887041.62
583687.35 1887006.17
18/
70.100 Bhutnal Bijapur 583811.58 1886976.20 LHS 0.450 173/1 0.809
A
583983.35 1886934.25
583957.27 1887012.63
583923.29 1887159.01
583458.53 1887461.44
583464.23 1887524.64
583488.11 1887523.62
19 70.100 Basanal Indi LHS 0.000 99/5 0.081
583487.08 1887567.13
583541.53 1887572.48
583542.88 1887447.32
583630.80 1889112.28
583391.31 1889099.87
583363.36 1889318.95
583615.73 1889334.29
20 68.000 Horti Indi LHS 0.000 459 0.162
583705.72 1889159.08
583944.87 1889174.17
583942.74 1888687.94
583767.06 1888694.85
583516.74 1888333.97
583483.03 1888239.01
21 68.900 Horti Indi LHS 0.400 0.121
583632.74 1888294.93
583608.88 1888205.45
583174.66 1886828.05
583167.31 1886904.62
22 70.200 Agasnal Indi 583140.35 1886974.22 RHS 0.200 104/2A 0.162
583077.90 1886963.46
583091.23 1886822.35
583174.66 1886828.05
583053.46 1886821.72
23 70.200 Agasnal Indi 583039.86 1886821.63 RHS 0.200 104/2B 0.162
583040.58 1886719.79
583172.38 1886731.34
24 70.200 Agasnal Indi 583040.58 1886719.79 RHS 0.200 104/2C 0.162
Co-ordinate
Sl. Village/ Lead Survey Qty
Chainage Taluka Side
No Panchayat E N in km Nos. (Lakhs
cum)
583042.71 1886635.56
583169.75 1886651.41
583172.38 1886731.34
583723.64 1889158.39
583943.66 1889176.01
583939.57 1889385.09
25 68.200 Horti Tanda Indi LHS 0.000 459/4 0.243
583887.97 1889382.33
583731.68 1889237.91
583746.43 1889383.69
577615.96 1867186.58
577578.87 1867222.60
26 91.200 Bhutnal Indi 577524.51 1867258.40 LHS 0.300 93.0 0.040
577517.72 1867230.63
577511.56 1867199.30
582132.08 1887624.07
582432.78 1887514.93
582460.53 1887317.68
582476.84 1887171.22
27 72.600 Agasnal Indi 582406.49 1887171.43 RHS 2.000 72 0.809
582387.41 1887322.13
582369.90 1887377.63
582256.60 1887489.56
582107.77 1887499.10
581744.61 1887255.29
581878.94 1886831.02
581760.06 1886823.21
28 72.650 Agasnal Indi RHS 2.000 73 0.809
581709.35 1886994.04
581486.25 1887032.26
581475.93 1887152.48
582482.11 1887165.40
582783.88 1887240.88
29 70.100 Agasnal Indi RHS 0.500 0.607
582730.67 1886936.42
582505.06 1886948.12
582710.97 1888666.46
582481.82 1888648.04
30 68.700 Horti Indi RHS 1.000 440 0.283
582498.27 1888509.82
582481.82 1888648.04
583888.23 1895572.18
583877.02 1895521.51
31 61.600 Savakanalli Indi RHS 0.500 0.040
583817.16 1895595.99
583817.16 1895595.99
584583.12 1894783.24
584558.57 1894915.52
32 63.000 Halagunki indi LHS 1.000 80 0.567
584323.01 1894923.72
584313.47 1894676.84
578206.21 1870222.76
578178.18 1870127.80
33 88.100 Arakeri Tanda Bijapur LHS 0.200 0.202
578390.95 1870177.60
578362.19 1870081.11
Co-ordinate
Sl. Village/ Lead Survey Qty
Chainage Taluka Side
No Panchayat E N in km Nos. (Lakhs
cum)
577688.03 1870396.03
577658.11 1870301.66
34 88.100 Arakeri Tanda Bijapur RHS 0.500 1.202
577614.46 1870313.32
577645.42 1870409.13
578590.37 1872204.16
Barradgi 578244.79 1872217.89
35 86.200 Bijapur RHS 0.100 34 0.728
Tanda LT1 578320.79 1871983.51
578574.04 1872037.19
578803.48 1872287.17
578745.33 1872112.92
36 86.000 barradgi Bijapur LHS 0.100 0.728
579183.79 1872159.94
579131.60 1871992.52
579083.34 1872729.96
579102.43 1872612.08
37 85.000 Kannal Tanda Bijapur RHS 0.300 91/3 0.445
578786.18 1872601.71
578830.53 1872728.86
581571.74 1882645.99
581439.63 1882414.84
38 75.100 Bommanahalli Indi LHS 0.200 0.809
581842.13 1882487.17
581695.13 1882261.57
581138.25 1901440.64
581191.75 1901472.53
581679.06 1902159.80
581479.74 1902122.80
581381.44 1902285.90 184,194
39 56.250 Nandurgi Indi 581209.82 1902059.21 RHS 4.500 1.497
& 188
581366.95 1901935.38
581508.63 1901743.58
581643.50 1901767.20
581609.62 1901977.68
581505.68 1895777.67
581240.44 1895730.42 221/3,
40 60.450 Sankanahalli Indi RHS 3.200 219/B/1, 0.324
581506.88 1895685.10 132
581239.24 1895822.99
585940.83 1892613.17
586051.35 1892610.20
41 65.500 Horti Indi LHS 2.600 20/2 1.052
586158.60 1893022.12
585881.08 1893032.40
581662.00 1902379.76
581788.87 1902991.35
42 56.250 Nandurgi Indi RHS 4.000 221 0.445
582604.78 1903031.13
582495.67 1902512.30
580105.80 1899686.80
580924.80 1900150.47
43 59.100 Hadalsang indi RHS 4.800 0.486
580194.96 1900270.23
580194.96 1900270.23
584300.54 1891744.63
584878.68 1891917.43
44 65.300 Deginal Indi LHS 0.950 0.202
584997.44 1891594.00
584355.62 1891429.50
Co-ordinate
Sl. Village/ Lead Survey Qty
Chainage Taluka Side
No Panchayat E N in km Nos. (Lakhs
cum)
584997.44 1891594.00
584355.62 1891429.50
45 65.300 Deginal Indi LHS 1.200 0.809
585798.53 1890831.44
584827.91 1890690.51
583117.89 1891412.62
582996.74 1891437.46
46 65.700 Deginal Indi RHS 0.300 0.202
582915.50 1891331.90
583046.44 1891258.94
580688.32 1867769.57
580866.32 1867804.01
47 90.750 Bhutnal Indi LHS 4.000 0.081
580928.20 1867878.96
580757.57 1867869.59
581070.10 1867620.10
581454.50 1867783.14
48 90.750 Bhutnal Indi LHS 4.000 0.324
581137.61 1868141.09
580928.20 1867878.96
581070.10 1867620.10
581454.50 1867783.14
49 90.750 Deginal Indi LHS 4.000 0.405
581668.46 1867542.89
581299.06 1867329.24
589085.00 1893118.00
588895.00 1893166.00 226/1,
50 65.500 Nimbalkhed Indi LHS 6.500 226/2 0.971
588773.55 1892685.26 & 226/3
588963.55 1892637.26
582653.80 1896118.09
582665.97 1896200.35
51 60.450 Sankanhalli Indi RHS 1.340 107 0.121
582531.31 1896149.34
582543.49 1896231.63
582531.31 1896149.34
582515.42 1896035.57 106 &
52 60.450 Sankanhalli Indi RHS 1.700 0.121
582605.06 1896132.76 106/2
582589.17 1896018.99
581734.62 1898069.20
581812.00 1897973.52
53 60.450 Hadalsang Indi RHS 3.000 47 0.121
581967.40 1898281.42
581890.02 1898377.10
581297.61 1883169.12
581248.74 1882775.30
54 75.000 Dommanal Indi RHS 0.200 1.012
581475.00 1882753.25
581617.12 1883027.78
583205.15 1859860.66
583481.42 1859834.76
55 99.300 Ukamnal Bijapur LHS 4.000 0.486
583434.17 1860096.81
583268.63 1860029.27
579527.81 1872764.46
579312.89 1872670.39
56 85.500 Kannal Indi LHS 0.600 0.324
579320.99 1872559.68
579550.98 1872679.48
Co-ordinate
Sl. Village/ Lead Survey Qty
Chainage Taluka Side
No Panchayat E N in km Nos. (Lakhs
cum)
584913.95 1887632.60
585049.86 1887567.47
57 69.000 Basanal Indi RHS 2.100 197 0.546
585087.70 1887970.51
584943.54 1888018.28
584026.66 1891877.31
584024.76 1892052.14
58 65.200 Horti Indi LHS 0.800 0.436
584279.88 1891928.39
584266.43 1891756.71
584171.02 1894078.14
584125.69 1894091.55
59 63.000 Horti Indi LHS 0.500 0.081
584117.80 1894004.62
584158.27 1893997.98
584220.66 1896398.61
584334.94 1896457.65
60 60.800 Halagunki Indi LHS 0.100 75 0.121
584264.64 1896551.03
584290.96 1896305.23
580672.65 1859213.61
580817.89 1859087.43
61 99.150 Shivgeri Bijapur LHS 1.500 1.214
580768.66 1858864.85
580444.65 1859090.18
581592.65 1895695.32
581623.42 1895690.09
62 60.450 Sankanahalli Indi LHS 2.200 0.040
581602.38 1895798.59
581571.61 1895803.82
587693.00 1916262.00
63 40.000 Yeligi PH Indi 587682.00 1916388.00 RHS 1.100 0.040
587644.00 1916391.00
587741.00 1916190.00
587653.00 1916177.00
64 40.000 Yeligi PH Indi RHS 1.200 0.243
587653.00 1916177.00
587760.00 1916050.00
582397.70 1888857.58
582375.65 1888640.76
65 68.700 Horti Tanda Indi RHS 0.800 0.721
582710.97 1888666.46
582733.02 1888883.28
582481.52 1888648.04
582498.27 1888509.82
66 68.700 Horti Tanda Indi RHS 0.800 0.201
582296.91 1888487.89
582280.46 1888626.11
582117.43 1888610.73
582092.46 1888786.77
67 68.700 Horti Tanda Indi RHS 0.800 0.269
582274.93 1888762.60
582280.46 1888626.11
583449.00 1860107.00
583574.00 1860035.00
583661.26 1859983.66
583706.51 1859957.04
68 99.150 Ukamnal Bijapur LHS 4.100 0.688
583828.58 1860143.36
583778.98 1860172.68
583685.50 1860226.92
583563.17 1860302.92
Co-ordinate
Sl. Village/ Lead Survey Qty
Chainage Taluka Side
No Panchayat E N in km Nos. (Lakhs
cum)
584019.00 1860200.00
584031.00 1860070.00
584040.70 1859964.89
69 99.150 Mahalianapur Bijapur LHS 4.200 0.728
584351.03 1859993.54
584341.33 1860098.65
584329.33 1860228.65
579478.00 1872176.00
579457.00 1871938.00
70 99.150 Baratagi Bijapur LHS 0.800 1.497
579791.00 1872190.00
579812.00 1872428.00
580191.00 1872125.00
580154.00 1872027.00
71 85.300 Baratagi Bijapur LHS 1.700 1.497
580731.00 1872089.00
580787.00 1872265.00
Total 36.035
Residual topsoil will be distributed on adjoining/proximate barren/rocky areas as identified by the Engineer in
a layer of thickness of 75mm-150mm. Top soil shall also be utilized for redevelopment of borrow areas.
Landscaping along slopes, medians, incidental spaces etc.
Extent of Mechanization
No drilling is required to undertake removal of soil
Compressors are not required since only soil shall be excavated
Excavators shall be used for loading the soil into dumpers which shall be used for transportation
Work Force
Depending upon the work load, general shifts working, man power will be proposed. However the work
force shall typically consist of Mining Competent Persons (Foreman), Administrative persons, Supervisors,
Skilled & Unskilled labourers.
Blasting
No blasting operations are required
Infrastructure
No infrastructure facilities like aerial rope way, conveyor belts, power lines, buildings, structures and
treatment plants are required for these processes. Therefore no utilization and their physical stability
and maintenance will be required.
11.2.4 Opening of New Borrow Areas
Siting
Borrow areas identified shall be used by the Concessionaire for the project. In case the contractor or the
concessionaire wants to open any new borrow areas other than mentioned in this report, then the selection
and recommendations for borrow areas will be based on environmental as well as civil engineering
considerations. Location of source of supply of material for embankment or sub-grade and the procedure for
excavation or transport of material shall be in compliance with the environmental requirements of the MoEF,
NHAI and as specified in IRC: 10-1961.
The Concessionaire shall establish a new borrow areas only with the prior consent of the Independent
Engineer (IE) only in cases when:
Lead from existing borrow area & quarries is uneconomical and
Alternative material sources are not available. The Concessionaire shall prepare a Redevelopment
Plan for the borrow area and get it approved by the IE.
Certain precautions have to be taken to restrict unauthorised borrowing by the contractor and the
concessionaire. No borrow area shall be opened without permission of the Engineer. The borrowing shall
not be carried out in cultivable lands, unless and until, it shall be agreed upon by the Engineer that there is
no suitable uncultivable land in the vicinity for borrowing or private landowners are willing to allow borrowing
on their fields.
The construction schedule and operations plans to be submitted to the IE prior to commencement of work
shall contain a detailed work plan for procuring materials that includes procurement; transportation and
storage of borrow earth material. The concessionaire shall provide the following:
Selection Criteria for Evaluation of Potential Borrow Areas
A brief statement as to how the site was chosen.
Alternative sites that were considered to be mentioned.
Record any public consultations involved while choosing and what the public concerns were, if any.
Existing land use (Agricultural / Barren / Scrub / grazing / any other type)
Vegetation / trees to be removed
Erosion/degradation potential
Distance and name of the nearest settlement
Distance from the nearest surface water body
Drainage pattern of the area
Available Surrounding
Name of Material Nearest Offset from
Sample no. Left / Length Breadth Depth Total Land / Land / Remarks
Village type Chainage nearest
Right (m) (m) (m) (Cum) Terrain Terrain
(Km.) Chainage (m)
Signature Signature
Name Name
Designation Designation
Concessionaire Independent Engineer
project area, no stations were selected specially to monitor the baseline quality of the borrow area. The air
quality in the project area is pristine, by and large, the water quality is satisfactory and the major physical
and chemical parameters are within limits set by the Bureau of Indian Standards for drinking water and
surface water quality for bathing except for total hardness, Calcium & Magnesium. No heavy metals are
presented in the ground water. The noise monitoring survey shows that noise levels are marginally higher
than the noise standards which may be due to mix activities as well as vehicular movement on the road. The
borrow areas are not located within 10 Km of any wild life Sanctuary or national park. The borrow areas also
do not require any diversion of forest areas. No endangered flora has also been reported. The details are
given in chapter 4.
11.4 IMPACT
Significant borrowing of earth is required for the embankment fill material, and for the construction of the
pavement.
Pre Construction Stage
As the borrowing is to be carried out in accordance to the guidelines laid out in IRC-10-1961, no major
adverse impacts are anticipated. Also, productive agricultural areas have been avoided for borrowing.
However, the borrow area pits, if not treated properly after the borrowing is complete, can form stagnant
pools and pose health hazards to prevent which redevelopment of borrow areas need to be worked out.
Additionally, they can also act as breeding ground for vectors like mosquitoes just after monsoon. It is
expected that the implementation of the mitigation measures for borrow area redevelopment proposed as
part of the project will reduce these impacts to acceptable levels.
Construction Stage
Cartage of the borrow materials to the construction sites can be of significance, as almost all such areas are
accessible through dirt tracks only and therefore, spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Proper protections measures need to be worked out for the minimising of such impacts
during the haulage of borrow materials. Rehabilitation of borrow areas from which earth has been excavated
can be a major potential problem. In addition to visual blight, the other problems more down-to-earth are the
safety issues. At borrow area locations where the owners are willing to create ponds for fisheries etc, proper
protection measures for the drainage of the surrounding land and slope protection measures need to be
worked out.
The soils along the corridor are in general capable to produce high yielding agricultural produce and may be
negatively impacted if unduly borrowed. The loss of productive topsoil due to road construction is a direct
adverse long-term impact. The concessionaire should ensure that in all such locations topsoil must be
stacked aside and replaced after the borrowing activity is over. The soil heaps should be periodically
compacted and sprinkled with water to avoid loss. Emphasis should be laid on maximum use of the stripped
topsoil in medians, road junctions, redevelopment of borrow areas and additional landscaping works in the
road project. The project shall take enforcement measures to prevent / minimise the use of topsoil from other
locations such as borrow areas, stockyards, lands for diversions.
The impact on air, water & noise has been documented in the chapter 6 under the relevant sections.
As far as possible borrow area selected for enhancement shall be on government / community land in the
vicinity of settlement. The Concessionaire must ensure that any enhancement design proposed should be
workable, maintenance free and preferably worked out in consultation with the community and proposed
enhancement materials should be locally available. The borrow area can be developed either of the
following:
Vegetative Cover
Vegetative cover must be established on all affected land.
Topsoil must be placed, seeded, and mulched within 30 days of final grading if it is within a current
growing season or within 30 days of the start of the next growing season.
Vegetative material used in reclamation must consist of grasses, legumes, herbaceous, or woody
plants or a mixture thereof.
Plant material must be planted during the first growing season following the reclamation phase.
Selection and use of vegetative cover must take into account soil and site characteristics such as
drainage, pH, nutrient availability, and climate to ensure permanent growth.
The vegetative cover is acceptable if within one growing season of seeding:
The planting of trees and shrubs results in a permanent stand, or regeneration and succession rate,
sufficient to assure a 75% survival rate;
The planting results in 90% ground coverage.
The site shall be inspected when the planting is completed and again at one year to ensure compliance
with the reclamation plan.
Certificate of Completion of Reclamation
Concessionaires have to obtained certificate of satisfaction from the landowner and submit it to the
Engineer before final payment is to done.
Working Plan
The Concessionaire must prepare a working plan before enhancing the identified borrow areas. Following
are the inputs that provide the guidelines to the Concessionaire to formulate the working plan:
Access of Property / width of access / material
Orientation of property with respect to the road
Site Slope
Local Drainage / water logging etc if any
Location of nearest culvert etc if any to drain water if required
Any other community resources such as tube well/well etc in vicinity
Location of trees including Species / girth / foliage spread and afternoon shaded area on ground
Surrounding land use; nearby settlements (name of structure/pattern of settlement)
Mark on plan part of the borrow area, most suitable for storing and staking topsoil.
Drawings to be Prepared
The Concessionaire have to prepared the drawings showing both cross-section as well as plan of the
identified borrow areas incorporating following inputs:
Contours if any, depth if any
Location of trees, height, foliage spread and afternoon shaded area on ground
Any other existing details at the road / property interface such as signage/railing/etc.
Details of immediate surrounding for at least 5m on either sides
Photographs to Include
The Concessionaire must ensure that photographs are to be taken before and after the excavation of borrow
materials and also after the implementation of redevelopment plan, incorporating the following:
Overall View from access side
Any other community resource in the vicinity
All spots to be detailed such as access to borrow pit /cluster of existing trees etc.
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
11-16
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Sl.
Item to be checked Remarks
No.
considerable length of the highway?
Typical intersection designs / layouts are
9. Junctions, interchanges and their design: provided conforming to all geometric and
safety requirements.
Will road users coming from all directions (including
side roads) be able to see that they are approaching Recommended and provided in typical
(a)
a conflict area? Are give-way lines, stop lines, turning designs.
lanes and ramps clearly visible?
Recommended.
Are existing conjoining and intersecting roads
Junctions are listed as major and minor
(b) appropriately adjusted and matched to the new road
separately with recommendations for
(without sharp bends and gradients)?
interventions.
Do the routes of road users through the junction seem
(c) Recommended.
clear for all directions and manoeuvres?
Is there sufficient space for all types of vehicles to
(d) Recommended.
undertake all manoeuvres?
Are the crossing facilities for pedestrians and non- Yes, typical drawings feature proper signs
(e)
motorised traffic adequate and safe? and markings.
Likely to cause problems and need to be
avoided. However, the design does not
(f) Can parking cause problems?
recommend any parking provisions near
junctions.
Have roundabouts been considered?
In urban areas, ghost markings and left-turning lanes
(g) with islands are safest; they prevent overtaking and No.
assist pedestrians and cyclists who are crossing the
road.
Decide whether or not old, unremoved section of road
10. Checked and found no obstruction.
can give undesired optical directions.
No roundabouts proposed in the present
11. Special points at roundabouts:
project.
Are all entrance lanes curved and is speed
(a) NA
adequately reduced?
(b) Will the central island be visible? NA
Are the measures taken for the benefit of pedestrians
(c) from a safe stopping distance and cycle traffic NA
adequate?
At the junction/transition to existing roads (especially Typical intersection designs / layouts are
12. from multi-lane to two-lane, dual to single provided conforming to all geometric and
carriageway): safety requirements.
(a) Are there sudden changes of alignment? Checked and didn’t find any.
Does the road standard change too rapidly, or can
(b) road users clearly see and recognize the transition in Checked and didn’t find any such location.
good time?
Would a roundabout be able to mitigate any sudden
(c) No.
changes in standards and alignment?
Are existing junctions and intersections adjusted and
13. matched to the new road appropriately (without sharp Yes.
bends and gradients)?
Are there any constructions that will be difficult to
14. drain and are the cross-fall and any gutter gradient Checked and found no.
adequate at the critical spots?
Are there places where there is a risk of flooding? No.
Will overtaking be prevented at critical places (not
15. Yes
simply by restrictions, but also by making it quite
Sl.
Item to be checked Remarks
No.
apparent that overtaking is prohibited)?
16. If signs and road markings have been proposed: Yes
(a) Are the markings consistent and are they adequate? Yes
Has the quantity of information been kept at a
(b) Verified and found yes
reasonable level?
If markings have not been proposed: will special
17. NA
markings be necessary?
Is there any risk that cannot be “marked out of
18. No.
existence”?
Will there be any large sign constructions? Is so; will
19. NA
guardrails or breakaway safety devices protect them?
Has it been proposed that lighting be located on the
20. No sharp curves in the design.
outside or inside of bends?
Will it be possible to carry out maintenance work (on
21. lighting, gantries, plantations, etc.) safely and without Yes
using the carriageway or cycle path?
Is the landscaping design or planting likely to lead to The proposed landscaping plantation is such
22. a lowering of safety with mature or seasonal growth? that it will not cause any safety issues.
Is frangible vegetation appropriate? No
Are there arrangements for safe access by Median openings are found to be wide
emergency vehicles? Check the design of medians enough to allow emergency vehicles. Also
23.
and barriers, and the ability of emergency vehicles to they are placed at standard intervals.
stop without necessarily disrupting traffic?
24. Pedestrians
(a) Have pedestrian needs been considered? Yes
If footpaths are not specifically provided, is the road
The blind corners are eliminated. Footpaths
(b) layout safe for use by pedestrians, particularly at blind
are provided on all new bridges.
corners and on bridges?
Are pedestrian subways or footbridges sited to
(c) Yes
provide maximum use?
Footbridges / subways are provided at
Is the avoidance of footbridges or subways possible specific locations where they are warranted
(d)
by crossing the road at grade? based on site requirements ensured by
surveys and studies.
Yes. Pedestrian underpass, Road signs and
Has specific provision been made for pedestrian markings are provided.
(e)
crossings, school crossings or pedestrian signals? No pedestrian signals are recommended for
present project.
(f) Are pedestrian refuges/ kerb extensions needed? Provided wherever required.
(g) Whether needs of disabled road users taken care of? Yes
Have the needs of public transport users been
Yes
25. considered?
Yes
Are bus stops positioned for safety?
Is lighting envisaged in specified locations of the
project? Are the difficulties of illuminating sections of
At major junctions, on approaches and on
the road caused by trees or over bridges, for
flyovers, major bridges, VUPs and PUPs, and
26. example?
urban locations highway lighting is proposed.
Are there any aspects of the provision of the lighting
No
poles, which would require consideration from the
safety point of view in their being struck by vehicles?
27. Is adequate safe access to the work site available? Yes
Are there any factors requiring specific road safety
28. No
provision, including maintenance?
Are there any traffic management features, which Yes. During construction to be taken care by
29.
would require special attention during construction or the concessionaire.
Proponent: National Highways Authority of India Draft EIA Report
12-3
Consultant: Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd January 2013
UNCONTROLLED IF PRINTED
Development of the existing 2 lanes carriageway to 4 / 6 lanes dual carriageway configurations including strengthening
of existing 2 lanes from Proposed Km 28.200 to Proposed Km 110.542 of Solapur to Bijapur Section of NH 13 in the
states of Maharashtra & Karnataka
Sl.
Item to be checked Remarks
No.
during the transition from construction to full
operation?
30. Other checks made at discretion of auditor or client. NA
Sl.
ToR Points Compliance
No.
NH 13, thus improving connectivity between Pune
& Hyderabad with Bijapur
Faster and safe connectivity;
Decongestion of traffic on road;
Saving in travel time, fuel, transportation cost
The water tanks along the project road shall not be
8 The condition shall be complied with
disturbed.
Any litigation(s) pending against the proposed
project and / or any direction or orders passed by
9 No litigations are pending against the project road.
any court of law/ any statutory authority against the
project is to be detailed out.
Submit detailed alignment plan, with details such as Detailed Alignment Plan shall be attached
nature of terrain (plain, rolling, hilly), land use Terrain along the project road is plain
pattern, habitation, cropping pattern, forest area,
2.665 Ha of forest land will be diverted for the project.
environmentally sensitive places, mangroves,
notified industrial areas, sand dunes, sea, river, The project does not involve any mangroves,
10 ecologically sensitive areas, sand dunes, sea, lake etc.
lake, details of villages, teshils, districts and states,
latitude and longitude for important locations falling Project Districts: Solapur (Maharashtra) & Bijapur
on the alignment by employing remote sensing (Karnataka)
techniques followed by ground truthing and also Tehsils: South Solapur (Maharashtra), Indi & Bijapur
through secondary data sources. (Karnataka)
The project road is an existing NH and connects
Solapur in Maharashtra with Bijapur in Karnataka.
Hence question of various alternatives for the project
road does not arise.
However to decongest built up areas along the project
Describe various alternatives considered, route bypass proposed at Horti besides a major
11 procedures and criteria adopted for selection of the realignment at Nandani. Different alternate route were
final alternative with reasons compared considering the factors like road length,
available ROW, land acquisition, structures to be
demolished, project affected families, forest area
diversion, tree cutting and construction cost.
The details of analysis of alternative are given in
Chapter 7.
Submit Land use map of the study area to a scale of
1:25,000 based on recent satellite imagery
delineating the crop lands (both single and double The land use map based upon recent satellite imagery
crop), agricultural plantations, fallow lands, waste and on desired scale shall be enclosed
lands, water bodies, built-up areas, forest area and The land use of the study area (10km on either side of
12 other surface features such as railway tracks, ports, project road) comprise of agricultural land, built up
airports, roads, and major industries etc. and submit area, forest, rivers, canals & barren areas
a detailed ground surveyed map on 1:2000 scale Strip plan (1:2000 scale) has also been prepared &
showing the existing features falling within the right shall be enclosed
of way namely trees, structures including
archaeological & religious, monuments etc. if any.
If the proposed route is passing through any hilly
area examine and submit the stability of slopes, if
13 the proposed road is to pass through cutting or The proposed route is not passing through hilly area
embankment / control of soil erosion from
embankment
If the proposed route involves tunnelling, the details
of the tunnel and locations of tunnelling with
geological structural fraction should be provided. In
14 case the road passes through a flood plain of the The proposed route does not involves tunnelling
rover, the details of micro drainage, flood passages
and information on flood periodicity at least of last
50 years in the area should be examined
The project is passing through an Elephant Corridor
a map duly authenticated by Chief Wildlife Warden
showing these features vis-à-vis the project location The proposed route does not passes through any
15
and the recommendations or comments of the chief elephant corridors
Wildlife Warden thereon should be furnished at the
stage of EC. An underpass in Elephant Corridor
Sl.
ToR Points Compliance
No.
shall be provided.
All underpasses have been provided based on traffic
studies and IRC 103 which states that pedestrian
Study regarding the Animal bypasses / underpasses
grade separators / underpasses are to be provided if
etc. across the habitation areas shall be carried out.
the PV^2 value (p: pedestrian count, v : vehicles in
16 Adequate cattle passes for the movement of
peak hour) exceed 1 X 10^8. At both locations, PV^2
agriculture material shall be provided at the
values are (1.2 X 10^8 and 1.6 X 10^8)
stretches passing through habitation areas.
Adequate cattle passes have been provided based on
IRC guidelines
If the proposed route is passing through a city / Bypass at Horti & a major realignment at Nandani have
town, with houses and human habitation on the been proposed for smoother movement of traffic in
either side of the road; the necessity for provision of densely populated areas.
bypasses / diversions / under passes shall be
17 Chainage wise locations of bypass locations are given
examined and submitted. The proposal should also
in table 2.5, chapter-2 of EIA report.
indicate the location of wayside amenities, which
should include petrol station/service centre, rest Details of wayside amenities, service roads &
areas including public conveyance etc. underpasses are provided in chapter 2
6.538 Km service road proposed at 5 locations
21bus bays with bus shelters proposed along with 2
truck lay bays
15 underpasses (8 PUP, 1 CUP, 6 VUP) proposed
Submit details about measures taken for the 2 toll plaza, highway patrol, trauma centre and
pedestrian safety and construction of underpasses ambulance facilities are proposed.
18
and foot-over bridges along with flyovers and Underpasses & flyovers shall take care of pedestrian’s
interchanges. needs & safety. Apart from these, provisions are
proposed for pedestrian safety, in Schedule C (Project
Facilities) and Schedule D (Standards &
Specifications) of the Concession Agreement signed
between the Concessionaire and project Proponent.
During construction period, appropriate traffic
management will be adopted to minimize congestion.
During Operation period, the proposed project would
smooth the traffic jams and congestion and would
minimize traffic accidents.
Assess whether there is a possibility that the Detailed traffic management plan enclosed as
proposed project will adversely affect road traffic in Annexure 8.8
19
the surrounding areas (e.g. by causing increases in The project shall improve connectivity in the region,
traffic congestion and traffic accidents). enhancing the inter-urban, inter-district and inter-state
mobility, and it will attract more traffic in the form of
diverted and generated traffic from the influencing
areas. Development of project road will not lead to any
congestion on other roads in the areas, the measures
for traffic control / diversion while construction is
proposed.
Clearly indicate / provide details regarding the
location, date (along with site photographs with the
background of monitoring equipments and/or
20 Refer Section 4.2.3 of chapter 4
sample collection in process) and protocol adopted
for sampling and analysis of various environmental
parameters as a part of the baseline data collection.
Details of quarry areas identified for the project is given
Examine and submit the details of sand quarry,
21 in Tables 8-3, 8-4 & 8-5. Quarry chart enclosed as
borrow area and rehabilitation.
Annexure 8.5. Borrow Area details given in table 11.1
Climate and meteorology (max and min
temperature, relative humidity, rainfall, frequency of For climate and meteorology data kindly refer Section
22 tropical cyclone and snow fall); the nearest IMD 4.2.1 of Chapter 4 of EIA. Secondary meteorological
meteorological station from which climatological data are procured
data have been obtained to be indicated.
The air quality monitoring should be carried out as
th Air quality monitoring has been carried out as per new
23 per the new notification issued on 16 November,
notification for the period October - December, 2012.
2009.
24 Identify project activities during construction and Impact evaluation and results and proposed mitigation
Sl.
ToR Points Compliance
No.
operation phases, which will affect the noise levels measures are given in Chapter 6 & 8 of EIA report
and the potential for increased noise resulting from
this project. Discuss the effect of noise levels on
nearby habitation during the construction and
operational phases of the proposed highway.
Identify noise reduction measures and traffic
management strategies to be deployed for reducing
the negative impact if any. Prediction of noise levels
should be done by using mathematical modelling at
different representative locations.
Examine the impact during construction activities
due to generation of fugitive dust from crusher units, Regular water sprinkling system will be adopted to
air emissions from hot mix plants and vehicles used minimize the dust emission.
for transportation of materials and prediction of
Raw materials with covered vehicles to avoid fugitive
25 impact on ambient air quality using appropriate
emission;
mathematical model, description of model, input
requirement and reference of derivation, distribution Impacts on Ambient air quality and its mitigation
of major pollutants and presentation in tabular form measures are assessed & shall be provided
for easy interpretation shall be carried out.
An environment management plan has been proposed
Also examine and submit the details about the
to minimize the impact on habitation from dust, noise
26 protection to existing habitations from dust, noise,
etc. during construction stage. Please refer Table 10.1
odour etc. during construction stage.
of Chapter 10 of EIA report.
If the proposed route involves cutting of earth, the The borrow materials will be withdrawn as per IRC: 10-
details of area to be cut, depth of cut, locations, soil 1961. The aggregate and sand will be procured from
27 type, volume and quantity of earth and other the Govt. approved licensed quarries by paying the
materials to be removed with location of disposal / cost of material as well as cost for rehabilitation.
dump site along with necessary permission. The locations of borrow areas are given in Chapter 11
If the proposed route is passing through low lying
areas, details of fill materials and initial and final
28 No low lying areas exist along the project road
levels after filling above MSL, should be examined
and submit.
Examine and submit the water bodies including the
seasonal ones within the corridor of impacts along
29 Inventory of water bodies attached in Annexure 4.2.
with their status, volumetric capacity, quality likely
impacts on them due to the project.
Total water required for the project will be 442 KLD,
Examine and submit details of water quantity
this will be sourced from both surface & ground water
required and source of water including water
during construction phase.
30 requirement during the construction stage with
supporting data and also classification of ground As per CGWB there are no notified blocks in Bijapur
water based on the CGWA classification. District. No information on Solapur has been available
from CGWB
The schedule for construction of piles will be done, so
Examine and submit the details of measures taken that the existing volumetric flow of the river will not
during constructions of bridges across river / canal / affect.
major or minor drains keeping in view the flooding of Coffer dam will be used.
the rivers and the life span of the existing bridges.
31 No excavated material will be dumped on river bed /
Provision of speed breakers, safety signals, service
bank even though 500 m from the river bank.
lanes and foot paths should be examined at
appropriate locations throughout the proposed road Silt fencing will be provided to protect surface run-off.
to avoid the accidents. Speed breakers, safety signals and service lanes will
be provided as per IRC guidelines and codes.
If there will be any change in the drainage pattern 108 culverts & 30 minor & 2 major bridges are
32 after the proposed activity, details of changes shall proposed based on hydrological studies. Therefore,
be examined and submitted. change in drainage pattern may not be happen.
Rain water harvesting pit should be at least 3 - 5 m.
Rain water harvesting structures at 500m distance in
above the highest ground water table. Provision
33 staggered pattern proposed.
shall be made for oil and grease removal from
surface runoff. Refer Rain Water Harvesting chapter 8
If there is a possibility that the construction / 2.665 Ha of forest land adjoining the existing
widening of road will cause impact such as carriageway shall be diverted and the proposal has
34
destruction of forest, poaching reductions in wetland been submitted to the forest department, hence the
areas, if so, examine the impact and submit details. project shall not lead to increase in poaching. The
Sl.
ToR Points Compliance
No.
forest land is required to upgrade the road to required
specifications without which there shall be a
compromise in road safety issues. Thus the acquisition
of 2.665 Ha. of forest area is unavoidable
All safety provisions are being considered during
design, construction and operation phases.
Improvements of geometry have been proposed as per
IRC guidelines and codes
Submit the details of road safety, signage, service
35 roads, vehicular under passes, accident prone zone Bus shelters, truck lay bays, traffic signage will be
and the mitigation measures. provided. The details are given in chapter 2
The provisions are as per Schedule C & D of the
Concession agreement and IRC: SP 84 – 2009,
‘Manual of Specifications & Standards for Four-laning
of Highways through Public Private Partnership.
IRC guidelines shall be followed for widening & up IRC guidelines have been followed for widening and
36
gradation of road up-gradation of project road
Submit details of social impact assessment due to Social Impact Assessment is provided in Impact
37
the proposed construction of road. Assessment chapter
The entire project road is designed by maintaining the
IRC codes, MoRT&H manual and other applicable
Examine road design standards, safety equipment
guidelines for safety standards. Provision of road
specifications and Management System training to
38 safety has been kept as per IRC: SP-44-1996 and IRC:
ensure that design details take account of safety
SP-32-1998.
concerns and submit the traffic management plan
A traffic management plan is proposed as part of the
project. Road safety audit carried out.
With the project the traffic congestion will reduce along
with reduction in accidents. Further densely habitat
areas are bypassed. HTMS and highway patrolling,
ambulance facility, computerised highway monitoring
Accident data and geographic distribution should be and Emergency call box system will be there.
reviewed and analyzed to predict and identify trends Attempts were made to review accident data and their
39 - in case of expansion of the existing highway and distribution and cause as part of feasibility study. The
provide Post accident emergency assistance and design of new 4-lane facility is taking care of accident
medical care to accident victims. black spots. The facility minimizes accident possibilities
with superior design and safety features. Necessary
measures have proposed to take care post accident
emergency / trauma care; they are listed in the
Schedules of the concession agreement.
If the proposed project involves any land
40 reclamation, details to be provided for which activity No land reclamation involved in this project.
land to reclaim and the area of land to be reclaimed.
Details of the properties, houses, businesses etc. A total of 7316 PAPs & 1329 PAFs are to be impacted.
41 activities likely to be effected by land acquisition and A total of 528 properties are being affected which
their financial loses annually. includes 228 residential & 118 commercial properties.
Detailed R&R plan with data on the existing socio-
economic status of the population in the study area
and broad plan for resettlement of the displaced
population, site for the resettlement colony, Compensation to the project affected families (PAFs)
42 alternative livelihood concerns/ employment and will be as per NPRR 2007 and NHAI policy. Separate
rehabilitation of the displaced people, civil and R&R budget kept.
housing amenities being offered, etc and the
schedule of the implementation of the project
specific
The project is a Government of India project which
aims at providing better connectivity and also providing
better economic development in the region. Hence
Submit details of Corporate Social Responsibility.
43 CSR details is not applicable for the project
Necessary provisions should be made in the budget.
However the Concessionaire shall make necessary
provisions for Corporate Social responsibility in their
budgetary provisions
Estimated cost of the project including The project will be on DBFO basis. Civil cost for the
44
environmental monitoring cost and funding project is INR 605.659 while the Total Project cost is
Sl.
ToR Points Compliance
No.
agencies, whether governmental or on the basis of INR 757.074 Crores
BOT etc and provide details of budget provisions EMP budget for INR 43.088 crores is presented in
(capital & recurring) for the project specific R&R Table 10-2
Plan. The R&R cost is budgeted at INR 25.37 Crores
Submit environmental management and monitoring
Kindly refer Chapter 10 for Environment Management
45 plan for all phases of the project viz. construction
Plan of EIA report.
and operation.
FISPL has been approved by QCI NABET for sector 34 (Highways, railways, transport terminals, mass rapid
th
transport systems) vide MoM of 87 Accreditation Committee Meeting of QCI NABET held on September
11, 2012. The EIA report prepared has complied with the prescribed ToR and the data submitted is factually
correct