Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Codex Whitepaper Draft A&C - Master
Codex Whitepaper Draft A&C - Master
Table of Contents
Table of Contents 2
01. Preface 4
02. Introduction 5
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 2
Nothing herein constitutes an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, in any jurisdiction in
which it is unlawful to make such an offer or solicitation. Neither the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission nor any other federal, state, or foreign regulatory authority has approved an
investment in the matters contemplated herein.
This white paper is subject to change from time to time.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 3
01. Preface
It is my privilege to introduce the Codex Registry for Unique Assets (“Codex”) and the protocol that defines it. The white paper
that follows will provide an overview of Codex Protocol and the problems it endeavors to solve. In the long-run, we foresee Codex
benefiting many different categories of unique assets, from luxury goods to agricultural, industrial and commercial equipment, to
emerging digital assets like in-game items. Initially, we are focused on the $2 trillion Art & Collectibles (“A&C”) asset class. As a
preface, I will explain why we’ve started with A&C and why I believe Codex Protocol is of particular interest to the
crypto-community.
First, A&C provides an experience for newly wealthy holders of crypto-assets; driving a classic car on a wide open road,
appreciating the work of a master artist in your home, owning a rare crypto-kitty, or drinking your finest vintage wine on a special
occasion. Codex will make it possible to purchase these experiences directly from existing auction houses with cryptocurrency.
Second, A&C is a financial asset into which cryptowealth should immediately diversify. While today cryptowealth is diversifying
into ICOs, altcoins as an asset class are highly correlated with Bitcoin. A&C, in comparison, provides an uncorrelated, appreciating
and private store of value. Indeed, high-net-worth individuals currently allocate an average of 6% of their portfolios to A&C as a
financial product. It seems logical that cryptowealth will do the same.
Third and finally, A&C has a strong need for a decentralized registry, a long-touted application of the blockchain. Unlike every
other asset class, no central title registry for A&C exists. To solve this problem, we have brought together a consortium from the
A&C community that ensures Codex will be integrated into the systems of over 5,000 auction houses in over 50 countries, which
makes its successful adoption as a standard highly likely. This presents a unique opportunity to prove the effectiveness of a
blockchain-based asset registry to the public.
This is a fascinating market and the white paper that follows will expand on the above issues in depth. I appreciate your interest in
Codex Protocol and look forward to developing Codex.
Sincerely,
Mark Lurie
www.linkedin.com/in/mlurie
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 4
02. Introduction
Codex Protocol is a decentralized registry for unique assets backed by an industry consortium representing 5,000 auction houses.
Codex is initially focused on the $2 trillion Art & Collectibles asset class (art, wine, jewelry, watches, collectible cars, etc.), where
the need for a registry is greatest because no centralized title registry exists. For unique assets, provenance (the identity, chain of
ownership, and other metadata about an item) is fundamental to value. Verifying this critical information is a constant challenge
that creates costly friction in the ecosystem.
The Codex Protocol registry solves this problem by recording, verifying, and securely storing important information about each
item. With this information, Codex users can easily access a variety of applications and services like asset-backed lending,
insurance, fractional ownership, bidding, escrow and more. The first application lets you use cryptocurrency to buy over $6 Billion
of merchandise from auction houses. Many other applications have already been announced including a bidding application,
through which the first purchase was of a CryptoKitty for the highest price ever achieved.
With a widely adopted registry, we expect lower transaction costs and less fraud could grow annual transaction value by
hundreds of billions of dollars and simplified financial products like lending and fractionalization could increase the value of the
asset class by over $1 trillion. In doing so, it will benefit existing market stakeholders and intermediaries, not disrupt them.
The A&C industry is eager for a registry, and the consortium believes one is finally possible because it can be decentralized.
Centralized efforts have failed in the past because collectors are unwilling to trust a central entity with information about their
valuable possessions and intermediaries are unwilling to risk disintermediation. The advent of the blockchain enables a
decentralized solution that stakeholders will accept.
Of course, a registry only works insofar as it is adopted as a standard. To that end, we have established a consortium of leading
online marketplaces, software providers and auction houses with operations spanning over 50 countries who have agreed to
support Codex. They support Codex as an open and decentralized protocol that anyone can integrate with. The consortium will
help to accelerate the adoption of the registry and ease its path to acceptance as the standard.
Finally, we introduce a native token, CodexCoin (CODX). Codex uses a native token for several purposes. First, to access and pay
fees to the registry to create, amend and transfer records. The token is further used to align incentives within the Codex
ecosystem: First, the token enables rewards to validators like auction houses and appraisers who vouch for items in Codex.
Second, it gives applications discounts for holding CodexCoin over a period of time, which ensures affordability and ensures
applications will engage in governance. Third, it ensures enforcement of proper behavior by validators and applications by
requiring them to stake. Finally, it provides a mechanism for the devolution of governance to end-users over time.
Soon after Codex is launched, we expect widespread utility and usage. As the A&C market passes through auction, the asset
registry will increasingly become a standard on which further applications and financial products are built.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 5
1
Deloitte Art and Finance Report 2017.
2
Deloitte / Wealth-X.
3
The two parties can be two collectors, a collector and a professional dealer or gallery, two dealers, institutions, groups, etc.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 6
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 7
4.1.1 Provenance
In A&C, the provenance (the history of ownership of an item and associated documentation) accounts for almost the entire
monetary value of an item because it is the most important indicator of authenticity.
To understand the importance of provenance, just look at authentic Picasso paintings, Chateau Margaux wine, and Rolex
watches. They are all highly desirable and valuable, whereas fake paintings, wine, and watches are essentially worthless.
Unfortunately, there are many impressive forgeries. For instance, the now infamous New York Knoedler Gallery was forced to
close after the sales of a fake Mark Rothko painting for $8.3 million and fake Jackson Pollock painting for $17 million were
4
uncovered. A 2016 Netflix documentary, Sour Grapes, tells the story of Rudy Kurniawan’s conviction for selling thousands of
5
bottles of fake wine totaling over $35 million. In A&C, over $6 billion is lost annually due to fakes and forgeries. Some estimates
suggest that up to 40%6 of items circulating may be compromised. The risk of fakes, forgeries, and bad title is the greatest risk to a
collector which makes provenance the most important attribute of any A&C item.
The ideal provenance is a well-documented history of ownership in an unbroken chain of transmission since creation or at least
since sold by a trusted intermediary, along with other important information like dates of restorations, liens, insurance status,
etc. Unfortunately, provenance documentation can also be subject to forgery. The most prominent example of this is Wolfgang
Beltracchi, infamous for multiple forgeries of original works, who went to great lengths to forge provenance documentation,
including having his wife pose in photographs as a fictional great-aunt, and alleged prominent art collector.
Today, verifying provenance is an ad hoc and unreliable practice. This is because there is no central title registry for A&C to track
ownership and possession like there is in the real estate market. But, the idea of a registry isn’t novel. Quite the opposite — the
benefits of a title registry are obvious to almost everyone in the A&C market. However, neither collectors nor intermediaries will
trust a centralized registry that could compromise their privacy or that of their clients. Fortunately, tracking and verifying
ownership and possession history is a perfect application for blockchain technologies.
4
Deloitte. Art & Finance Report, 2014, p. 127,https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/at/Documents/Tax/art-finance-report.pdf.
5
Bosker, Bianca. “A True Crime Documentary About the Con That Shook the World of Wine .”The New Yorker, 14 Oct. 2016,
www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/a-true-crime-documentary-about-the-con-that-shook-the-world-of-wine.
6
i2M (2015).
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 8
7
This and other information on the Codex Record may be stored elsewhere and a reference hashed into the smart contract.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 9
The story of this item begins at the artist (O1) who sold the piece to a collector (O2). The collector later decided to consign the
piece to an auction house (AH), perhaps Christie's. A new owner (O3) purchased it from the auction house and flipped it to a
collector (O4) who currently owns it.
Now, O4 is trying to sell the piece to a new buyer. Codex allows
O4 to delegate view permissions to the prospective buyer to view
the information attached to the Record. While the buyer cannot
see the identity of owners who elect to remain private, the buyer
can see when ownership transfers have taken place and the
identity of owners who have elected to be public (in this case,
Christie’s, but in other cases, it could be the artist). This gives the
buyer peace of mind that they are buying an item with good
provenance which supports the value of the item. The buyer is
willing to pay as much as if they had purchased the item directly
from Christie's or the artist.
Of course, O4 and the buyer both need an incentive to pass along
the Codex Record to ensure the registry stays in sync with reality.
We’ll address this question below in section 4.5 (“Challenges”).
To preserve collector privacy, the off-chain metadata associated
with each Codex Record is private by default. Whoever has ownership rights to the Record (either the current holder or anyone
they delegate permissions to) can share this metadata with other users.
While it’s true that anyone can instantiate a Codex
Record, most will likely be created by intermediaries such
as auction houses and then passed on to buyers. Since
many items pass through auction at some point in their
lives, most items should eventually have corresponding
Codex Records. The consortium has already contractually
agreed to instantiate a Codex Record for the items they
sell, which includes over 10 million items sold each year
in tens of thousands of auctions with over 20 million
bidders.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 10
commissions or fees. The consortium has years of experience working with experts to validate items. For example, one of the
consortium members offered an Authenticity Guarantee based on feedback sourced from a network of hundreds of distributed
experts which achieved industry-leading accuracy rates.
The Codex Protocol’s validation network relies on the same validators to ensure the integrity of the protocol. It incentivizes them
through rewards. At first, the validators themselves and the rewards they receive for their activities will be decided on a
discretionary basis. Over time, we anticipate rewards will be algorithmically distributed along with a reputation system that
scores end-users who have expertise. (See sections on “The Codex Economy” and “Organization and Governance”)
As validators verify information, the provenance of the underlying asset is strengthened, which in turn helps to maximize its value.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 11
4.5 Challenges
There are several key challenges associated with a decentralized registry for A&C:
Pre-existing items
First, many A&C items are already in existence. Of course, items created in the past will only have an immutable history since their
instantiation on the blockchain. That’s why auction houses are a great way to onboard existing items to the registry—as part of
the auction process, auction houses already research the provenance, compile documentation (e.g., sales receipts or written
appraisals), analyze the item’s physical attributes, and vouch for items with their reputation. This information will be loaded onto
Codex and future owners will know which auction house instantiated that information. The best evidence of authenticity will thus
be the reputation of the auction houses or dealers who previously owned and sold a given piece. We intend to reward users for
vouching for items on the registry to further address this issue.
Linking digital records to physical items
Second, we are linking physical items to digital records. We are often asked how we prevent malicious owners from swapping out
a real piece with a fake one that could then be transferred along with a Record that has good provenance. Fortunately, there are
multiple physical tagging technologies which can solve this problem. These include RFID tags and synthetic DNA, among others.
For example, one company provides an inexpensive aerosol canister that sprays industrial diamond dust on physical items, and
the resulting 4-d crystalline pattern is invisible to the naked eye but scannable with an iPhone. Several companies and developers
have already engaged in designing applications that will register this data in Codex.
It is also important to emphasize that even without physical tagging technology, the registry will be a massive improvement to
the status quo. We don’t think the initial threshold for innovation needs to be perfection, but rather significant improvement.
Today, provenance is recorded on paper and verbally, which is easy to copy and difficult to verify. With provably unique Records,
the existence of a Record with good provenance makes it hard for a malicious actor to sell a forged replica because a prospective
buyer could reverse search for the Record with superior provenance and quickly determine that the replica’s title is
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 12
compromised.8 The Art Loss register works similarly today, where stolen art (including Nazi art) is registered, preventing its resale.
9
Finally, the value of a piece is in its provenance, so transferring a good title along with a replica would only serve to decrease the
value of the authentic piece as much as it increases the value of the fake piece, leaving the seller no better off. Codex is designed
to provide a significant improvement over the status quo, which is why the consortium is eager to adopt it.
Ensuring the registry is in sync with physical items
The most important mechanism that keeps the registry in sync with physical items is behavioral incentives. Buyers will likely
demand a Codex Record to preserve resale value by being able to prove provenance. Another reason a buyer might demand it is
to ensure the seller doesn’t intend to resell the proven record of ownership along with a duplicate piece to another buyer.
Perhaps most importantly is so the buyer can easily access the applications and services available in the Codex Ecosystem that
can unlock additional value from the asset. The larger the Codex ecosystem becomes, the more incentive there will be for buyers
to demand Codex Records with their purchases.
Of course, the registry won’t be perfectly in sync. There will be plenty of occasions when a Codex Record is lost. That’s ok. When a
Codex Record is lost, an owner can restart a new provenance by uploading information and rewarding a high-reputation validator
(e.g. a well-known appraiser or auction house specialist) for verifying and attesting that the new title is an extension of the old,
lost Record. Of course, this requires trusting the validator, but we expect that’s sufficient in 99% of cases).
Widespread adoption
Adoption is a challenge that many blockchain companies
face and is not unique to Codex. However, people often
question whether the A&C industry is more conservative
towards adopting new technologies, so it’s important to call
this out as a challenge here. To address this, we focus a
significant amount of research & development time towards
architecting solutions that make the technology more
accessible to users that are unfamiliar with blockchain.
Additionally, we’re planning on building out educational
materials and community outreach to existing members of
the A&C space.
The strongest evidence that this industry will adopt Codex is
the adoption we’ve already secured. There is substantial
interest from companies already in the A&C space today in
integrating blockchain technology to their existing
workflows. In the “Ecosystem & Adoption” section we
outline a number of companies that we have already
partnered with that are planning on building on top of
Codex Protocol.
8
Note that this does not compromise privacy beyond the status quo. Today, past auction sales are public and a comprehensive list of artists’ known works is
typically compiled in a Catalogue Raisonné. It isn’t the existence of items that compromises privacy, but rather personal information about owners.
9
The Art Loss Register (http://www.artloss.com/en) is the world’s largest database of stolen art, enabling experts to “check the provenance of items before they
buy.” Codex will provide a similar capability for authenticity and ownership.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 13
https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/blob/master/EIPS/eip-721.md
10
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 14
The implementation of each of these components is available on GitHub11 under an open-source license. The mechanics of the
ecosystem is being tested on the Rinkeby test network in a public beta that is accessible via https://beta.codex-viewer.com.
Additionally, the smart contracts that make up the protocol are being audited by Hosho12, one of the top blockchain security
firms. Once the initial audit of the smart contracts is complete, we will hold a public bug bounty paid in ETH to members of the
community that find any security issues that weren’t found during the security audit.
11
https://github.com/codex-protocol/contract.codex-registry
12
https://hosho.io/
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 15
The entire A&C market can benefit from a system of record, from auction houses and galleries to collectors and artists to insurers
and shippers. When provenance is easily verifiable, it means it’s easier to transact and provide related services to end-users.
That’s why major stakeholders are supporting Codex, why businesses will integrate with Codex and why application developers
will create useful software for end-users. Already, many businesses have announced their support of Codex. These include online
marketplace and software providers who will help populate the registry with unique assets from over 5,000 auction houses that
sell over 10 million items per year worth over $6 Billion in value. They also include appraisal services, asset-backed lenders,
fractional ownership and securitization firms, and bidding applications. These partners will build applications that do the
technical work of integrating with Codex in the background while providing a seamless user-experience to end-users for specific
use-cases. Collectively, we term these businesses “partners” or “app-developers”.
In this section, we will describe the personas in the ecosystem, the use-cases that can benefit each of them, the businesses who
have already announced integrations, and the first two applications which are being created by Codex Labs, Inc.
Collectors and Investors: Codex empowers collectors and investors to purchase A&C with much
greater confidence in the integrity of works. This will enable faster transactions, easier cross-border
movement, and, over time, a reduction in the costs associated with owning A&C (e.g., insurance). Codex
will provide infrastructure for the development of inventory and wealth management applications.
Having an efficient asset registry will also enable alternative models such as fractional ownership for
investors. Finally, Codex will allow collectors to easily find objects they desire, enabling them to trace
the verifiable record of ownership, with the permission of those owners, from the last known sale (e.g.
at auction) to the current owner.
13
References to any party other than Codex Labs, Inc. and references to any product or service of any third party, are for illustrative purposes only. Such products
and services are subject to applicable law in each jurisdiction and Codex Labs will not make available any products and services in any jurisdiction in
contravention of applicable law, and may not make them available at all. Codex Labs, Inc. does not intend to offer any regulated product or service directly
through the Codex Protocol.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 16
Artists, their Estates and Foundations: Applications built on Codex could provide an efficient means
of cataloguing and archiving work for artists which will deter the creation of fakes and forgeries and
may prevent manipulation of an artist’s market. An artist or their estate would be able to build a
catalogue raisonée on Codex. Applications built on Codex could also enable easier tracking of resale
royalty payments which may be due to artists but frequently remain unpaid.
Asset-backed Lenders: Today, a large market exists in loans secured by A&C. Owners seek out these
loans for many reasons. For example, if they are asset rich but liquidity constrained and need to fulfill a
financial obligation, a loan secured by A&C property may be their only viable option. Codex will support
art lending since it will allow lenders to be more confident that they can confirm valuations and
authenticity. This is likely to mean that lenders will become increasingly comfortable offering more
asset-backed loans with higher loan-to-value ratios. Codex could also enable liens to be added to
Records giving lenders further comfort.
Insurers: A large market currently exists for insuring A&C, both from damage at home and in transit. A
Codex-based application could enable owners to quickly and easily obtain quotes and purchase
insurance on items they own, as well as update premiums based on changing prices of their holdings.
Insurance inspection, administration and underwriting costs could be decreased by using Codex to
track possession during transit, verify insurance valuations and administer claims.
Storage and Logistics: Art storage and logistics is a multi-billion dollar industry which still relies
heavily on paper records and outdated systems. Applications could be built on Codex to allow the easy
management of items for storage and logistics.
Appraisers: Codex could support an application that enables buyers to post bounties for appraisals of a
Codex Record that appraisers can compete for by appraising the authenticity and value of the piece.
Appraisers would build a reputation in the application for their appraisals.
Museums: A&C is often bequeathed to museums for immediate tax deductions. This can be complex
and expensive to structure but could be made simple and accessible if template contracts were used
with a multi-owner Record system on Codex.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 17
LiveAuctioneers.com is the leading online marketplace for auctions of art, antiques and
collectibles. They have announced that their millions of bidders will be able to claim a
pre-populated Codex Record with each purchase from their 5,000 auction houses across 47
countries that sell millions of items annually worth over $5 Billion. Already, they have
integrated a title-escrow application (Biddable) that enables bidders to register, bid and buy at
their auctions with cryptocurrency. This is especially important because auctions provide an
on-ramp of goods onto Codex en masse.
“We are thrilled to be one of the first to partner with Codex and to bring Biddable to our users,”
said Phil Michaelson, President of LiveAuctioneers.com. “LiveAuctioneers has continuously
invested in providing our auction house partners with services and technology solutions, and
Codex and Biddable are the most exciting we’ve seen. Codex and Biddable can securely and
anonymously increase trust among buyers, sellers, and consignors, so we, our bidders, and our
auction house partners eagerly await its launch.”
Maecenas is a blockchain project that fractionalizes and securitizes artwork so it can be traded
with ERC-20 tokens. They have announced an integration with Codex to create Records for
their works and offer the ability to fractionalize selective works of Record-holders.
Dust uses inexpensive diamond dust to imprint a crystalline fingerprint on physical items that
is invisible to the naked eye but can be scanned with an iPhone to verifiably link physical items
with digital records like Codex Records. Users will be able to log the dust identifier onto their
Record.
With The Clarion List Codex Record holders can expect to get quotes from reviewed service
providers easily and effortlessly.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 18
Valuemystuff allows customers to request a virtual appraisal from the leading network of
experts with prior experience at institutions like Sotheby’s and Christie’s.
Feral Horses allows you to acquire and trade shares of contemporary artworks.
Codex Labs, Inc. Codex Labs, Inc. is a USA company (for-profit) that provides enterprise consulting services and
tools to those integrating with and using Codex Protocol. The business model for Codex Labs,
Inc is similar to that of other companies that have sponsored open-source projects, like Red
Hat and Linux. It has already released two tools, the Codex Viewer and Biddable. Codex Viewer
providers an easy web interface so that end-users can create, manage and modify their
Records with no technical knowledge(see section 6 for a detailed explanation and
screenshots). Biddable is a title-escrow and payment application that integrates into auction
software and enables holders of cryptocurrency to register, bid and buy at auctions (see
section 6 for a detailed explanation). Codex Labs, Inc plans to donate the profits from these
activities to the community fund. Initially, 100% of these profits will be donated, decreasing
over time no faster than the same rate at which the company’s tokens are unlocked. See
section 8 on organization and governance for more information about Codex Labs, Inc.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 19
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 20
6.2. Biddable
Biddable enables cryptoholders to purchase A&C instantly, privately and easily.
A critical problem in the auction industry is the phenomenon of bidders who bid and win, but never pay (“Non-performing bidder”
or "NPB”). A unique item can have only one winner, so NPBs directly result in loss of sales and auction revenue. NPBs plague
auction houses, costing billions of dollars each year. Biddable is a dapp intended to drive adoption of the Codex Protocol by
solving this critical problem.
Currently, many auction houses try to reduce the number of NPBs by
requiring bidders to register for auctions in advance, disclose their
identities, financial ability to pay with bank statements, and even wire
funds into pre-auction escrow. These disclosure requirements are
burdensome, compromise privacy, and deter many bidders. Moreover,
many bidders don’t want to disclose information regarding their wealth
that may inform shill bidding, which is when a dishonest auctioneer or
seller submits false bids to drive up the winning price. While illegal, most
buyers believe that shill bidding is widespread in the industry. Indeed,
research indicates a “price premium of between 16% and 44% can be
achieved by shill bidding.”14
This conflict between bidders’ demands for both privacy and convenience
and sellers’ demands for identification and disclosure creates an impasse
that lowers auction participation and revenue. While exact figures are
confidential, the magnitude is large and data from the Consortium
indicates that over one million bidders are excluded from participating in
auctions each year. In particular, bidders from Asia are excluded from US
14
Nikitkov & Bay (2015), http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1467089515000044
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 21
15
prove their intention to pay while maintaining privacy and keeps sellers acting appropriately as well.
This dapp will not be a standalone consumer-facing application, but rather will be embedded in existing auction house bidding
software. Initially, this will include LiveAuctioneers.com and the applications developed by AuctionMobility.com.
With Biddable, the bidder’s initial deposit will be in a major and highly liquid cryptocurrency like Ether (CodexCoin will also be
accepted). Sellers will leave their stake in CodexCoin, and the maximum amount the auction houses can require as a deposit will
be directly proportional to how much CodexCoin they stake. This will incentivize auction houses to set the lowest possible
deposit requirement that will deter non-performing bidders rather than the maximum possible deposit that will help inform shill
bidding. It will also prevent abusive behavior like offering items to test the market and then pulling them prior to sale.
If a bidder does not win anything, each party’s escrow will be released back. In the case
of a winning bid, the escrow is locked until the bidder pays for their items, either in
cryptocurrency with Biddable, or as normal in fiat. Winning bidders that did not
register via Biddable can still use it to pay for their winnings using cryptocurrency.
Biddable plans to charge a transaction fee, payable in CodexCoin.16 As an aside, we
intend to donate the majority of these fees to the Community Fund for the foreseeable
future to ensure alignment with the community.
If an auction house is unable to get payment from a bidder within a reasonable
interval, they may declare them an NPB. In this case, we plan for the seller’s stake to be
returned in full and the bidder’s deposit to be indefinitely locked. We orphan the
deposit rather than transfer it to the seller so that there is no incentive for sellers to
falsely declare NPBs.
For example, an auction house auctions a $10,000 item and stakes $500 of CodexCoin
so that any bidder who leaves a $500 deposit is instantly approved. If the buyer wins
and settles, Biddable earns a 1% fee of $100 (payable in CodexCoin) and the Record is
transferred to the buyer.
In the view of the consortium, Biddable will have a major impact on the market. In
addition to enabling the expansion of East-West trade, auctioneers have indicated that
they may give a discount of as much as 5% to Biddable bidders because they leave
17
deposits - yet another compelling reason for prospective bidders to adopt CodexCoin.
15
Technically, it may be possible for an auction house to trace a wallet address to a specific individual. However, this is very difficult and is unlikely in the context
of a real-time auction where a deposit can be made from any existing or newly created wallet address at the last minute.
16
Biddable intends to charge this transaction fee in exchange for providing the decentralized smart escrow contract software. Biddable is not party to the
transaction itself, is not in the flow of funds, and cannot adjust the smart escrow contracts once funds have been deposited, although it may occasionally update
new versions of the smart contract software to auction houses for future auctions.
17
Consortium Survey Results
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 22
Modifying Codex Records requires fees payable in CodexCoin. This is analogous to gas in Ethereum. It’s also similar to the 0x
protocol where makers and takers pay fees in ZRX (the 0x token) to relayers to exchange tokens.18 Operations to read data are
completely free, but operations to create, update, and transfer Codex Records have an associated fee depending on the type of
modification. For example, adding a lien on a registered item may cost more than a transfer of title operation. Fees will be used to
replenish a community pool that is used for rewards (discussed further below).
We do not intend that these fees should be burdensome for any one individual. Rather, they will be relevant for stakeholders who
use the protocol in volume for commercial use, like app developers and auction houses.
18
Warren, Will. “Governance in 0x protocol”. https://blog.0xproject.com/governance-in-0x-protocol-86779ae5809e
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 23
In most cases, we anticipate applications to charge fees to end-users in the form of fiat or ETH for usability, while invisibly
converting to CodexCoin to pay for protocol fees. Meanwhile, technically savvy users are more than welcome to interact directly
with the protocol.
7.3 Discounts
Stakeholders will receive discounts on registry fees based on the size of their stake and the amount of time the stake has been
active.
Token holders will not receive these benefits for simply
holding tokens: staking is an explicit operation that
requires token holders to deposit their CodexCoin stake
into a smart contract. Additionally, it allows application
owners to provide another layer of incentives to their
users for staking to the application’s contract. Stakes can
be withdrawn at any time, but the longer a stake is held
the greater the discounts.
In other words, the price (P) to make modifications will be
inversely proportional to the average amount of
CodexCoin held over a certain time period H(t). P and H(t)
may differ for various modification types to encourage
usage and network effects.
This discount and staking mechanism has several desired outcomes. First, it ensures that those who use the protocol most will
have affordable rates. Second, it incentivizes commercial users to evangelize the protocol to their users, advocate it as a
standard, and engage in governance. Third, it gives applications an incentive to transition their users into CodexCoin holders as
users become comfortable so that the application can save on conversion fees and token purchases. Finally, it gives the most
frequent users an elevated say in the governance of the Codex Protocol.
7.4 Rewards
Those who create value for the network should be rewarded for doing so. In particular, validators and application developers.
Validators create value by contributing and verifying provenance information. They include appraisers, auction houses and their
specialists, dealers, gallerists and creators/artists (see section 5). Examples of behaviors we’ll reward include creating new
Records, providing well-researched historical provenance, and attesting to Records created by end-users. Initially, Validators will
be whitelisted and rewards will be distributed on a discretionary basis (see section 8 on governance).
Application developers who increase adoption or provide special value to the network should also be rewarded. For example, we
intend to reward application developers in proportion to the downstream modification activity on Records (e.g., number of wallet
addresses modifying) they created in the past, which is a proxy for actual usage of Records by end-users. These rewards will also
initially be distributed on a discretionary basis.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 24
Over time, we intend for rewards will be algorithmically distributed. The consortium will guide this algorithm along with the help
of reputation applications built by developers. Examples of reputation applications will soon be posted on the Codex Protocol
blog.
Whenever tokens are rewarded, they will be subject to vesting such that recipients have a continually refreshing incentive to
maintain the network by evangelizing Codex to their clients.
7.5 Penalties
Those who participate in the network must behave appropriately. To deter inappropriate behavior, participants may be required
to stake CodexCoin for various purposes.
For example, validators may be required to stake CodexCoin that can be penalized if they spam the network or are deemed by
other validators to be contributing false information intentionally. Similarly, application developers may be required to stake
CodexCoin that can be penalized if they don’t adhere to privacy and data portability policies of the protocol.
Since we want to minimize frictions to joining the network, we plan that rewards will be used to preload staking contracts for
validators and application developers with locked-up CodexCoin who have just joined the network.
7.6 Governance
Although early governance of the protocol will be at the discretion of the consortium and Codex Labs, Inc, we believe in creating
an open community that governs a decentralized system. To that end, we plan to put the entire governance structure in the
hands of token holders and contributors to the network through an on-chain voting scheme in the future. The staking
mechanisms in the aforementioned sections will thus provide one important basis for the protocol’s most involved actors to
influence the protocol itself. Just as for discounts and penalties, we intend to apply the principle that both the magnitude and the
duration of the stake are important in weighing the influence of the stake on governance. In addition to the stake, we also intend
to consider contributions and other behaviors on the network in the voting mechanics.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 26
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 27
8.4 Governance
The consortium is committed to robust community governance in the long-term and will work with experts in the governance of
token economies to that end. The code itself is open-source and anyone can contribute to improvements.
In the short term, the consortium will ensure that changes to the protocol are aligned with its mission. The consortium’s power
comes from its influence in the A&C market. If the consortium dislikes changes, its members can simply fork the protocol and
their broad user base would likely go with them. Thus, we expect developers, including ourselves at Codex Labs, Inc, to defer to
them as the protocol evolves.
Over time, we aspire to a formal community governance system, which we believe will result in a more robust and lasting
ecosystem that best represents the goals and needs of every stakeholder. We also believe it will provide a foundation that will
enable the protocol to be malleable over time in response to innovation and market maturity. We expect the governance system
to be based on both stake and behaviors on the network, with limits to constrain any individual from exercising majority control.
The CodexCoin token will be critical in enabling this decentralization of governance as a measure of a stake for voting.
19
All incentives and rewards referred to in this White Paper will only be distributed on a fee-for-service and calculated and distributed on a one-to-one basis. No
mutualised and/or passive profit, income or other returns are intended or advertised by this project.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 28
Similarly, educational initiatives will be funded to encourage adoption of the protocol within A&C and familiarity with A&C within
the blockchain community. Examples include symposia and conferences, educational programs for A&C stakeholders on
blockchain and for app developers on A&C, and more.8.5 Creating a Developer Ecosystem
Applications are especially important to the success of Codex, so we want to summarize the activities we believe will foster a
robust developer ecosystem, even if redundant. These include:
1. App developer grants from the Community Fund.
2. Incubation & Acceleration programs, such as hackathons
3. Active community development, both online in social channels and offline in meetups.
4. Tools and support for developers, including SDKs and other packages.
5. Education for app developers about the market and the protocol.
The consortium anticipates directing the community fund resources to encourage a robust ecosystem of applications and
services supported by developers.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 29
09. Roadmap
9.1 Potential Value Creation
We expect that Codex Records will become an authoritative source of information about A&C items, which would create well-over
$1 trillion in value for the ecosystem. For example, if owners could more easily lever their assets 50%, the asset class could grow
by half. If cryptoholders invested as much in A&C as high-net-worth investors do, it would create hundreds of billions in new
transactions. If it were easier to verify items and thus transact, commissions could be cut dramatically, creating hundreds of
billions in value.
In the long-run, the Codex Protocol could be applied to other categories of unique assets. These include Luxury Goods (designer
goods and fashion), Equipment (agricultural, industrial, commercial), vehicles (luxury autos, boats, and airplanes), digital assets
(collectibles and in-game assets), real estate (agricultural, commercial and residential), and more. Once a robust ecosystem of
applications is developed on top of an asset registry, the potential value created is immense.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 30
marketing will likely occur to end-users for the new use-case. Marketing will include working closely with core partners in the art
ecosystem, industry bodies and international organisations as well as art business events and conferences.
We are confident in our strategy and ability to execute the pre-launch and launch plan because the team has extensive experience
launching products and increasing adoption in the art and collectibles market, including:
● Managing multi-million dollar marketing budgets in the A&C market.
● Managing inside sales teams soliciting auction houses and galleries through “predictable revenue” strategies.
● Launching and promoting scaled software products for the art and collectibles space.
Based on this experience, we are confident that our sales and marketing strategy and campaigns will be effective in driving
adoption of the protocol at launch. Proceeds from the ICO will be used as follows: 25% taxes; 15% sales and business
development; 20% marketing; 25% engineering and 15% operational expenses.
Goal A B Events
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
Jun
Beyond Post-Launch
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 31
10.1 Founders
Mark Lurie previously founded Lofty.com, an expert-reviewed A&C marketplace that was acquired in
2016. Prior to Lofty, he worked in venture capital as an investor at FJLabs and Bessemer Venture Partners,
early investors in many leading businesses like Pinterest, Yelp, Linkedin, and Twilio. Mark has an MBA
from Harvard Business School and a BA from Harvard College in Economics.
Jess Houlgrave previously worked at OPTrust, a large Canadian pension fund, where she executed
several billion dollars of European private equity transactions as part of the Private Markets Group. Prior
to OpTrust, she worked at Credit Suisse in the investment banking group where she was involved in IPOs
that raised over USD$1 Billion. Jess has an M.A. in Art Business from Sotheby’s Institute of Art, where she
wrote her thesis on the applications of blockchain technology in the art ecosystem and later worked in
Sotheby’s bidding department. Jess also has an M.A. in Economics and Management from the University
of Oxford.
John Forrest previously worked at Microsoft as a Senior Software Engineer in the Identity division, which
provides secure authentication for the billions of customers that use Microsoft products every day. Past
projects include leading the convergence of Microsoft’s consumer and enterprise identity systems and
integrating Microsoft’s consumer identity systems into the Xbox One. John was consistently rated in the
top percentiles of his organization at Microsoft and has a BS in Computer Science from Southern
Methodist University where he graduated summa cum laude with a minor in Mathematics. At SMU he was
awarded the Departmental Award for Computer Science and holds multiple undergraduate research
awards for his work in data-stream clustering.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 32
10.2 Advisors
Joey Krug, Co-Chief Investment Officer at Pantera Capital & Cofounder of Augur. Joey brings deep
technical expertise and guidance to Codex. He has been at the forefront of developing best practices in
the token ecosystem and a strong voice in the developer community. At Pantera, Joey is the Co-Chief
Investment Officer of a $100 million ICO fund. At Augur, Joey developed the technology for prediction
markets with the vision of creating a decentralized financial system. Joey is also an advisor or Numerai,
Urbit, 0x, Bloom, and doc.ai.
Nader Al-Naji, Cofounder & CEO of Basecoin. Nader has a background in finance and software
engineering. He has worked at DE Shaw & Co in equities high-frequency trading, as well as at Google as a
software engineer in the Search and Ads teams. He graduated summa cum laude in Computer Science
from Princeton.
Dr. Abe Othman has a PhD in Computer Science from Carnegie Mellon and is a visiting scholar at the
Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. He earned his BS in Applied Math from Harvard. He was
named to the Forbes 30 under 30 list and is an advisor to Augur and Stox.
Brook Hazelton, Christie’s President of the Americas. Brook Hazelton is the current President of the
Americas for Christie’s, one of the two largest auction houses in the world with over $7 Billion in annual
sales. Previously, he was the CEO of Phillips de Pury & Co, one of the largest A&C auction houses in the
world (www.phillips.com), where he grew sales 400% in four years. Before Phillips, Brook worked in
Private Equity at the Carlyle Group and Goldman Sachs. He is a graduate of Harvard Business School
(MBA) and Princeton University (BA). https://www.linkedin.com/in/brook-hazelton-421a1/
Sarah Shinn Pratt is an experienced auctioneer and appraiser. For 13 years, she was an auctioneer at
Sotheby’s as well as the Director of Appraisals for the Americas. She has appeared on multiple seasons of
the Antiques Roadshow and, after Sotheby’s, ran an art & collectibles dealer and advisory firm with her
husband. Sarah has an MBA from UCLA and a BA in Economics & Philosophy from Mount Holyoke College,
Phi Beta Kappa.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 33
Consumer Internet
Fabrice Grinda is among the world’s leading internet entrepreneurs and investors. He has over $300m in
exits and 300+ angel investments. Currently, he is the founder of FJLabs.com, an early stage angel fund.
Previously, he was the cofounder and CEO of OLX, one of the largest websites in the world with over 200
million monthly unique visitors, operations in 40 countries, and more than 1,200 employees. OLX is the
largest classified site in India, Brazil, Pakistan, and many other emerging markets. Before OLX, Fabrice
was co-founder and CEO of Zingy, which he grew to $200 million in sales in four years and exited. He
worked at McKinsey and graduated Summa Cum Laude from Princeton in Economics.
www.fabricegrinda.com. https://www.linkedin.com/in/fabricegrinda/
Bessemer Venture Partners (BVP.com) is a leading venture capital firm with $4.5 Billion under
management and a track record that includes over 121 IPOs. Recent companies include Pinterest, Blue
Apron, Snapdeal, Twilio, Shopify, Box, Linkedin, Yelp, and Twitch.
FJLabs (fjlabs.com) is an angel investment firm specializing in online marketplaces and global
companies, with over 300 investments across 20 companies including Alibaba, Betterment, Letgo,
Palantir, Uber, Viajanet, and more.
Pantera Capital (panteracapital.com) is an investment firm focused exclusively on ventures, tokens, and
projects related to blockchain tech, digital currency, and crypto assets. As the first U.S. Bitcoin investment
firm, Pantera is the leading blockchain investment firm and one of the largest institutional owners of
cryptocurrencies.
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 34
White Paper :: Codex Protocol :: Version 26 July 2018 A cryptocurrency and protocol for unique assets. 35