Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lawsuit Filed by J-1 Visa Students Against WITCC, Area Employers
Lawsuit Filed by J-1 Visa Students Against WITCC, Area Employers
Plaintiffs,
vs.
Defendants.
COME NOW the Plaintiffs, by and through their undersigned counsel, and for their
The Plaintiffs are Chilean international students who arrived in the United States on
student J-1 visas procured at the guidance and direction of Western Iowa Tech Community
College (hereinafter “WITCC”). The Plaintiffs accepted an offer into WITCC’s J-1 visa
program after being promised free tuition, room, board, and food along with an internship
in their selected field of study. Upon arrival, the Defendants, through an organized scheme,
placed the Plaintiffs to work in jobs unrelated to their fields of study, namely processing
plants, forcing them to fulfill an exhausting work and academic schedule using threats of
deportation and legal action. Further, the Defendants used their power to control the
Plaintiffs’ personal, academic, and employment lives by, inter alia, diverting money from
their pay checks to WITCC as repayment for services WITCC previously agreed it would
PARTIES
Chile and Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of herein.
2. Plaintiff Natalia Tapia Leiva is a Chilean citizen and was a resident of Chile
and Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of herein.
of Chile and Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of herein.
4. Plaintiff David Silva Moreno is a Chilean citizen and was a resident of Chile
and Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of herein.
2
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 2 of 95
5. Plaintiff Fernando Vilches Castillo is a Chilean citizen and was a resident of
Chile and Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of herein.
6. Plaintiff Claudio Ramos is a Chilean citizen and was a resident of Chile and
Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of herein.
and Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of herein.
resident of Chile and Sioux City, Iowa at all times relevant to the events complained of
herein.
community college and School Corporation capable of suing and being sued under Iowa
Code § 260C.16, located in Sioux City, Iowa, and registered with the Iowa Secretary of
10. Defendant Terry Yi is a United States citizen and, upon information and
belief, was a resident of Sioux City, Iowa and an employee at WITCC at all times relevant
11. Defendant Rosana Salgado is a United States citizen and, upon information
and belief, was a resident of Sioux City, Iowa and an employee at WITCC at all times
12. Defendant Juline Albert is a United States citizen and, upon information and
belief was a resident of Sioux City, Iowa and an employee at WITCC at all times relevant
3
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 3 of 95
13. Defendant Terry Murell is a United States citizen and, upon information and
belief, was a resident of Sioux City, Iowa and an employee at WITCC at all times relevant
14. Defendant James Zuercher is a United States citizen and, upon information
and belief, was a resident of Sioux City, Iowa and an employee at WITCC at all times
15. Defendant Lilly Castro is a United States citizen and, upon information and
belief, was a resident of Sioux City, Iowa and an employee at WITCC at all times relevant
16. Defendant Premier Services, Inc., d/b/a J&L Staffing and Recruiting Inc. and
d/b/a J&L Enterprises (hereinafter “J&L”) is a corporation organized under the laws of the
State of Iowa, and registered in the State of Iowa. It conducts business in and around Sioux
City, Iowa as a staffing / placement agency. Its “storefront” is located at 219 West 7th
17. Defendant Nancy Albrecht is a United States citizen and, upon information
and belief, was a resident of Sioux City, Iowa and an employee of J&L at all times relevant
18. Defendant Carlos Espinoza is a Chilean and also traveled to Sioux City, Iowa
19. Defendant Soledad Rojas is a Chilean citizen and also traveled to Sioux City,
4
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 4 of 95
20. Defendant Jorge Arcos is a Chilean citizen and also traveled to Sioux City,
21. Defendant Cristian San Martin Matta is a Chilean citizen and also traveled to
organized in accordance with Iowa Code Chapter 490. Its registered agent is located in
Iowa. Its home office is located in South Dakota. It conducts extensive business in and
around Sioux City, Iowa including operating a 185,000 square foot manufacturing facility
employing approximately 700 employees in Sioux City, Iowa processing, inter alia,
Lunchables.1
corporation organized under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its Headquarters in the
State of Missouri, and an agent for service of process in South Dakota. It conducts
extensive business in and around Sioux City, Iowa, and runs a dog food factory in North
24. This court has subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331, 28
U.S.C. § 1337, 18 U.S.C. § 1595, 18 U.S.C. § 1962, and 18 U.S.C. § 1964,. This court has
supplemental jurisdiction to hear and decide the pendent state law claims under 28 U.S.C.
§ 1367.
1
“Lunchables” are a brand-name, individually packaged and ready-to-eat meal that is
typically targeted towards children.
5
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 5 of 95
25. This court has personal jurisdiction over Defendants under Iowa Code §
617.3 and under the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution because:
benefits and protections of its laws, when they entered into an agreement
with the WITCC, J&L, and Corporate defendants to supply Plaintiffs for
trafficking.
b. Defendants Yi, Salgado, Albert, Murrell, Zuerch, and Albrecht are Iowa
residents.
c. Defendants WITCC, J&L, and Tur-Pak are Iowa Corporations that are
registered in the State of Iowa and “at home” in the State of Iowa.
Sioux City, Iowa, including operating a facility in Sioux City, Iowa that
e. Defendant Royal Canin had substantial, intentional contacts with the state
business within Iowa, thus invoking the benefits and protections of its
6
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 6 of 95
J&L), to recruit employees from an Iowa Community College’s
26. The court also has personal jurisdiction pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1965(a) and
(b).
27. Venue is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b) because the events or omissions
described in this complaint took place in Sioux City, Woodbury County, Iowa. Venue is
Human Trafficking
28. Human Trafficking happens in nearly every community in Iowa, but it goes
slavery.3 Such slavery can present itself in a variety of ways, including involuntary labor.4
to the United States, and upon their arrival, they find themselves “in the servitude of the
traffickers.”5 Traffickers take advantage of the fact that these noncitizens are “surrounded
2
https://who13.com/news/hiding-in-plain-sight-a-story-of-human-trafficking-in-iowa/
3
https://www.iowaattorneygeneral.gov/for-crime-victims/fighting-human-trafficking
4
https://www.iowaattorneygeneral.gov/for-crime-victims/fighting-human-trafficking
5
Id.
7
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 7 of 95
by an unfamiliar culture and language” and “without identification documents, fearing for
30. According to the National Human Trafficking Hotline, which “works closely
with service providers, law enforcement, and other professionals in Iowa to serve victims
and survivors of trafficking,” there were 98 human trafficking cases reported in 2019.7
Factories, restaurants and housekeeping were the most common venues for labor
trafficking.8
31. In 2019, several human trafficking complaints were lodged against Iowa pork
processing plant Seaboard Triumph Foods in Sioux City, Iowa (hereinafter “Seaboard”).9
Reportedly, Seaboard recruited nearly 200 Micronesians to work at its plant under promises
to pay them $15.95 an hour, pay for their $1,800 plane tickets to the United States, three
months of room and board, and cash payments to send back to their families in
Micronesia.10 In return, the Micronesians needed to work at Seaboard’s plant and have 11
6
Id.
7
https://humantraffickinghotline.org/state/iowa
8
Id.
9
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/money/business/2019/10/02/seaboard-triumph-foods-
iowa-pork-plant-micronesia-recruits-allege-mistreatment-sioux-city/3843359002/
10
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/13/us/iowa-pork-micronesia-workers.html
11
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/money/business/2019/10/02/seaboard-triumph-
foods-iowa-pork-plant-micronesia-recruits-allege-mistreatment-sioux-city/3843359002/
8
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 8 of 95
32. These works now claim nearly all of these promises were broken. Seaboard
began to deduct 50 percent of the Micronesian workers’ paychecks. When they questioned
the change, Seaboard withheld their passports in order to “threaten and punish” them, and
locked them out of their hotel rooms leaving them with no access to food or shelter.12
Without their passports, the Micronesian workers were unable to cash their checks, open
bank accounts or wire the money they were promised back home. 13 Seaboard allegedly
issued the workers false social security numbers, provided work inconsistent with what
was promised, and failed to provide workers with a translator to ensure they could do their
jobs correctly.14 Seaboard purportedly also threatened workers with deportation if they
33. The State of Iowa promised Seaboard an enticing incentive package for
building its $300 million facility in Sioux City.16 After the embassy of the Federated States
of Micronesia sent the State Department a letter calling for an investigation into Seaboard’s
misconduct, which included claims of physical, emotional and verbal abuse, Governor of
12
Id.
13
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/13/us/iowa-pork-micronesia-workers.html
14
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/2019/03/20/human-trafficking-iowa-massage-
parlor-pimp-sex-crime-craigslist-prostitution-robert-kraft-patriots/3082329002/
15
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/13/us/iowa-pork-micronesia-workers.html
16
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/2019/03/20/human-trafficking-iowa-massage-
parlor-pimp-sex-crime-craigslist-prostitution-robert-kraft-patriots/3082329002/
9
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 9 of 95
Iowa Kim Reynolds said “the state would temporarily block millions of dollars” in those
34. Although Iowa has been identified as a hotspot for human trafficking, very
few of the reported cases involving these operations have been prosecuted. Additionally,
Iowa seemingly has “some of the best laws in the country to combat sex trafficking” and
any conviction is supposed to lead to mandatory jail time.18 However, as of 2019, only one
trafficking ring – the owner of an illicit massage parlor and his wife – had been prosecuted
“for human trafficking under Iowa’s state statute, 710A.2.”19 Considering the sheer number
of trafficking reports each year since 2015, a conservative estimate given that most cases
practices on high profile, “black market” sites, the obvious conclusion is that trafficking
operations in Iowa are going almost entirely unprosecuted and severely under punished. In
2017 alone, there were 174 tips of human trafficking in Iowa reported to the National
Human Trafficking Hotline. Of those 174 tips, only three reports resulted in investigations
35. This is likely for two reasons. According to Representative Marti Anderson,
the previous head of the Crime Victims Assistance Division at the Iowa Attorney General’s
17
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/13/us/iowa-pork-micronesia-workers.html
18
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/2019/03/20/human-trafficking-iowa-massage-
parlor-pimp-sex-crime-craigslist-prostitution-robert-kraft-patriots/3082329002/
19
Id.
20
https://dps.iowa.gov/sites/default/files/intelligence/ht_overview.pdf
10
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 10 of 95
Office, Iowa has been blind to the human trafficking that takes place in the state, both sex
and labor, for a long time.21 Therefore, the prosecutorial structure needed to pursue such
charges is lacking among law enforcement and state attorneys. 22 Another major reason
these cases go unprosecuted is due to the fact that the victims are oftentimes illiterate, come
from other countries and cultures and do not understand the laws of the United States and
the protections it has in place for trafficked workers.23 Additionally, victims are often afraid
to talk to federal agents and investigators, or testify in court, due to their immigration status
37. The J-1 program is grounded in U.S. public diplomacy efforts. Its stated
purpose is:
21
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/2016/11/16/des-moines-identified-top-100-
human-trafficking-site/93952890/
22
Id.
23
https://iowanaht.org/labor-trafficking-iowa/
24
Id.
11
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 11 of 95
sympathetic, and peaceful relations between the United States and other
countries of the world.25
38. There are 15 categories of J-1 Visa programs available to promote these
Visa, or “Exchange Visitor” visa, is “for those who intend to participate in an approved
39. Two categories within the J-1 Visa program are relevant to this case:
25
22 U.S.C. § 2451.
26
For more information on the categories, see 22 C.F.R. § 62.4.
27
U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), USCIS, Exchange Visitors,
https://www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/students-and-exchange-visitors/exchange-
visitors (last accessed Nov. 19, 2020).
12
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 12 of 95
(B) An institute approved by or acceptable to the
post-secondary accredited academic institution, where
the student is to be enrolled upon completion of the non-
degree program;
41. The purpose of the J-1 Visa Program for College and University Students is
to
42. A foreign national can be admitted to the United States through the J-1 Visa
28
22 C.F.R. § 62.4(a).
29
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(a).
30
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(d), (e).
13
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 13 of 95
(ii) Occurs on the premises of the post-secondary accredited academic
institution the visitor is authorized to attend; or
and University, may stay in the United States either (1) as long as it takes to complete the
degree program, if they are in a degree program, or (2) for two years, if they are in a non-
45. Alternatively, foreign nationals may be admitted to the J-1 Visa Program for
the purpose of completing a student internship under the “Student Intern” subcategory.33
academic institution that issued” the authorization for the J-1 Visa.34
46. Student interns must be “a foreign national enrolled in and pursuing a degree
participating in a student internship program in the United States that will fulfill the
educational objectives for his or her current degree program at his or her home
institution.”35
31
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(g)(1).
32
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(h)(1)-(2).
33
See, e.g. 22 C.F.R. § 62.23(h)(3).
34
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(h)(3)(i).
35
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i).
14
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 14 of 95
47. An internship is not a job. The regulations define an internship program as
“[a] structured and guided work-based learning program for an Intern . . . that reinforces
an intern’s academic study; recognizes the need for work-based experience; provides on-
the United States to engage in a student internship program rather than to engage in
upon the participants’ existing knowledge and skills.”38 Student Interns cannot be used to
labor need,” and the “position that the student intern[] fills [must] exist[] solely to assist
the student intern in achieving the objectives of his or her participation in a student
internship program.”39
49. Specific types of “internships” are explicitly precluded for J-1 Visa Student
36
22 C.F.R. § 62.2, Internship Program.
37
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i)(1)(ii).
38
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i)(2)(iii).
39
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i)(3)(ii)(B).
15
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 15 of 95
(iii) Not engage or otherwise cooperate or contract with a
staffing/employment agency to recruit, screen, orient, place, valuate,
or train student interns, or in any other way involve such agencies in
an Exchange Visitor Program student internship program;
(iv) Ensure that the duties of a student intern as outlined in the T/IPP will
not involve more than 20 per cent clerical work, and that all tasks
assigned to a student intern are necessary for the completion of the
student internship program.40
50. Student Interns in the J-1 Visa program can be paid for their time.41
“distinguish between work-based learning for student interns, which is permitted, and
52. Manual labor in particular does not satisfy the J-1 Visa program’s goals of
diplomatic exchange. Other J-1 Visa categories, such as Summer Workers,43 are explicitly
precluded from working in food and agricultural manufacturing jobs such as those provided
40
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i)(8)(i)-(iv).
41
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i)(1)(6).
42
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i)(1)(7).
43
22 C.F.R. § 62.32(b), “The purpose of this program is to provide foreign college and university
students with opportunities to interact with U.S. citizens, experience U.S. culture while sharing
their own cultures with Americans they meet, travel in the United States, and work in jobs that
require minimal training and are seasonal or temporary in order to earn funds to help defray a
portion of their expenses.”
44
22 C.F.R. § 62.32(h)(16), cross referencing “positions in the North American Industry
Classification System’s (NAICS) Goods-Producing Industries occupational categories industry
sectors 11, 21, 23, 31-33 numbers (set forth at http://www.bls.gov/iag/tgs/iag_index_naics.htm).”
This includes jobs in animal food manufacturing and animal slaughtering and processing. See U.S.
Bureau of Labor Statistics, Food Manufacturing, NAICS 311.
https://www.bls.gov/iag/tgs/iag311.htm (last accessed Nov. 19, 2020).
16
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 16 of 95
53. The maximum length of a J-1 Visa Program under the Student Intern
subcategory is 12 months.45
54. The “sponsor must ensure that the student intern has verifiable English
environment.”46
program, regardless of the J-1 Visa category utilized, sponsors like WITCC are required to
make every effort to achieve the fullest possible reciprocity, and send their own students
Common Allegations
56. In this case the Defendants worked in concert to traffic the eight plaintiffs
from their home in Chile into debt bondage at a Sioux City, Iowa area food packaging plant
and dog food factory by offering them a degree with free tuition, room, and board.
Defendants Albert and Murrell, acting on behalf of WITCC, began the process of seeking
authorization from the Department of State for WITCC to host exchange students in the
45
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(h)(3).
46
22 C.F.R. § 62.23(i)(1)(i).
47
See 22 C.F.R. § 62.8(c) (“In conducting its exchange visitor program, sponsors must make a
good faith effort to develop and implement, to the fullest extent possible, reciprocal exchanges of
persons.”).
17
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 17 of 95
58. On February 14, 2019, the Department of State gave notice to Defendant
Albert that Defendant WITCC had been approved as a designated sponsor of the Exchange
Visitor program, and that WITCC had been allotted 50 J-1 Visas for the academic year
59. Around the same time, Defendants Albert, Yi, Burright, and Murell, acting
on behalf of Defendant WITCC, began negotiations with Defendants J&L and Albrecht to
60. The agreed upon plan included WITCC Defendants bringing J-1 Visa
students to the United States, and for the J&L Defendants to find local jobs in the Siouxland
62. Defendants Tur-Pak and Royal Canin are two such business that have a
working relationship with Defendants J&L and Albrecht. Defendant J&L recruits, hires,
and pays hourly workers for Defendants Tur-Pak and Royal Canin, and Defendants Tur-
Pak and Royal Canin pay Defendant J&L for this service.
63. Defendants WITCC, Yi, Burright, Albert, Murell, and Zuerech (collectively,
the “WITCC Defendants”), J&L and Albrecht (Collectively, the “J&L Defendants”), Tur-
Pak, and Royal Canin entered into an agreement wherein J-1 Visa Students would be
48
“Siouxland” refers to Sioux City, Iowa; South Sioux City, Nebraska; and North Sioux City,
South Dakota, as well as the surrounding rural areas and communities.
18
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 18 of 95
recruited to work for Tur-Pak and Royal Canin. The details of the agreement included, at
least:
a. The J&L Defendants would ensure that the J-1 Visa students met the
apartment complex to work and back for the J-1 Visa students.
c. The WITCC Defendants would house the J-1 Visa students on campus
and secure visas for entry into the United States. This included offering
d. Defendants Royal Canin and Tur-Pak would pay $15/hour for the J-1
Defendant WITCC to pay for the student’s housing, tuition, and fees. The
these services.
f. Defendant J&L would also benefit by charging the J-1 Visa students for
64. Around the same time, the WITCC Defendants began their campaign to
19
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 19 of 95
65. These Defendants entered into an agreement with Defendants Espinoza,
Rojas, Actos, and San Martin Matta (collectively, the “Chilean Defendants”) to recruit the
66. By March of 2019, the WITCC Defendants, the J&L Defendants, and the
Chilean Defendants began to recruit students to participate in a J-1 Visa program with
Defendant WITCC.
67. By March 1, 2019, a list of 25 Chilean students had already been generated
communicating with these students using email, Facebook, WhatsApp, and other services
to encourage them to complete the required paperwork for the J-1 Visa Program at WITCC.
69. On March 14, 2019, the Chilean Defendants caused an advertisement for the
WITCC J-1 Visa Program to be published on Facebook, with Defendant WITCC’s logo.
20
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 20 of 95
70. The WITCC Defendants and the J&L Defendants all traveled to Chile to
meet with the Chilean Defendants, as well as meet the Plaintiffs, their targeted recruits, in
April 2019.
71. These Defendants specifically told the Plaintiffs, and others, they would be
able to earn a two-year degree in either a culinary arts or robotics program at WITCC along
with an internship experience that would improve their chances of furthering their careers.
72. The Defendants recruited the Plaintiffs to the U.S. on a promised J-1 visa for
73. During the recruitment phase, Defendant Burright promised the Plaintiffs
room, board, tuition and placement in an internship related to robotics or culinary expertise,
74. All of these promises were reiterated in an “Open Letter” from Defendant
WITCC to its “Brazilian/Chilean friends.” The promised benefits of the program included:
culinary arts.
e. Returning to your home country with a degree from the United States.
75. This letter informed potential J-1 Visa students they would be required to
work as many as 35 hours per week, and attend class for 12 hours per week.
21
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 21 of 95
76. However, this program was being billed as an internship program with
scholarships. Students were not informed they would be working in manufacturing plants
77. Although this letter also informed potential J-1 Visa students they would be
required to pay for their own meals, this information was changed by later communications.
78. On April 24, 2019, Defendant Burright, on behalf of Defendant WITCC, sent
letters to Plaintiffs indicating their acceptance into WITCC as a J-1 Visa Student. The letter
stated:
In this package you will find, other than this acceptance letter, your
DS2019 form, the pre-arrival handbook, your job offer letter, and your proof
of health insurance according to the J1 Visa requirements.
79. The referenced “job offer letter” in the packet was a job offer to work with
Defendant J&L staffing. It did not indicate the rate of pay, the hours, or the location where
49
For those Plaintiffs accepted into the Culinary Arts Program, the letter was identical, with the
exception of inserting the phrase “Culinary Arts program” instead of “Robotics and Automation
program.”
22
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 22 of 95
80. The work was described as a “valuable, resume-enhancing experience for
81. The packet also included a J-1 Student Agreement for the plaintiffs to sign,
outlining the requirements of their program. The J-1 Student Agreement required the
(4) Live in the Western Iowa Tech student housing, Sun Ridge
apartments.
82. The agreement did not indicate the cost of tuition, meals, transportation, fees,
or any other part of the program. The agreement did not include a promise to pay WITCC
83. The agreement did not inform students they would be working 35+ hours a
84. The Plaintiffs were not asked to sign anything authorizing Defendants to
23
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 23 of 95
85. During the interview process, Defendant Albrecht, on behalf of J&L, asked
the students whether they could lift 40 pounds to their chest. Defendant Albrecht did not
86. In June of 2019, the Defendants began to change course. Defendant Burright
wrote the plaintiffs, as well as the Chilean Defendants, that Defendant WITCC had “issued
our DS2019’s in a wrong way,” and made some mistakes. Defendant Burright listed those
2. At any moment, we are [not] allowed to mention that the reason for
J1 paid internship is the lack of workers in the area, even when indeed
there is a need for workers. Also, we cannot call you workers, but
student interns, and we cannot use the word salary or wages, but
stipends or compensation.
50
The English version of this document contains some inconsistencies with the Spanish language
version of this document. The Spanish language version also appears to omit some paragraphs that
are included in the English language one. Bracketed insertions in this paragraph are meant to
clarify a sloppy translation job. It is unknown who did the original translation.
24
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 24 of 95
1. In your DS2019 form, you will have a period of 1 year, from August
22, 2019, to August 21, 2020.
87. This letter reassured the Plaintiffs that “nothing had changed for them,” that
they could still stay in the United States and earn their two-year degrees, even though the
88. These changes were made for a clear purpose: initially the Plaintiffs were
offered the chance to earn a two-year degree. But, J-1 Visa students in the subcategory of
Students/College and University cannot work the hours or the type of jobs that all of the
Defendants, collectively, had agreed that the Plaintiffs would work in order to fund
Defendant WITCC’s program. Individuals with a J-1 Visa under the Student/College and
University subcategory cannot work off of campus. J-1 Visa Student Interns can work off
of campus, in an “internship.” This bait and switch allowed was designed to make sure that
25
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 25 of 95
89. This bait and switch was also designed to hide from the Department of State
that the planned “internship program” violated the rules for the J-1 Visa Student Intern
category. As noted in the letter, Defendant J&L staffing was not permitted to participate in
a J-1 Visa internship program, and the purpose of the internship program could not be used
to fill a labor shortage in the United States. However, as noted in the letter, Defendant J&L
was going to continue to be involved, and the students were intended to fill a labor need.
90. Once recruited, the Plaintiffs had to travel to the U.S. Consulate in Santiago,
Chile. Prior to the interview, Defendant coached Plaintiffs as to what to say and not to say
during the consular interview, which included demeanor, emotions and instructions as to
91. The Plaintiffs were coached on how to pass the English language portion of
the interview.
92. The June 2019 email communication from Defendant Burright also
instructed the Plaintiffs to destroy evidence that Defendant J&L was involved and had
Nothing changed for you, only the way we have to approach and describe
this program. This is the main reason for the delay in this process because I
was adjusting it following the instructions of the Department of Education
that so kindly helped us to be on the right track and be successful in this
beautiful project.
94. Formally, the documents initiating Plaintiffs into the J-1 Visa Student Intern
26
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 26 of 95
95. Plaintiffs received Accommodation Information Letters informing them that
they would be living in the Sun Ridge Court apartment complex owned by Defendant
WITCC, in two-apartments, with four people to an apartment. The letter did not state that
96. Plaintiffs also received new acceptance letters dated June 3, 2019, as
program. “Culinary Arts” became “Food Services,” “Robotics and Automation” became
“Electromechanical Technician.”
customized to meet your need for a specific vocabulary and professional terminology for
[Y]ou are NOT responsible for the cost of your tuition, fees, housing, or
supplies. Meals will be provided at the College. The necessary materials for
your classes and training will be supplied by the college and will have to be
returned right after your conclusion of your program.
100. For the rebranded Culinary Arts program (now “Food Service Diploma
27
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 27 of 95
The Food Service Diploma emphasizes fundamental and intermediate
techniques of food preparation, production and baking skills. This program
prepares students for intermediate level positions in the industry more
specifically first-line supervisors of food preparation and serving workers.
This program provides students with hands-on training to prepare them for
an entry level position as an industrial mechanic or maintenance position.
Electromechanical technicians utilize knowledge and skills developed from
learning various topics including electrical, mechanical, fluid power to
maintain and repair industrial equipment and systems. Once you graduate,
you will be ready to operate, test, maintain, or calibrate unamend, automated,
servo-mechanical, or electromechanical equipment and you may assist
engineers in testing and designing robotics equipment, and, in our J1 project,
directly related to automated food production industries, for humans or pets’
consumption.
The most common tasks that electromechanical technicians perform are: test
performance of electromechanical assemblies, using test instruments such as
oscilloscopes, electronic voltmeters, or bridges; read blueprints, schematics,
diagrams, or technical orders to determine methods and sequences of
assembly; inspect parts for surface defects, install electrical or electronic
parts and hardware in housing or assemblies, using soldering equipment and
28
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 28 of 95
hand tools; and verify part dimensions or clearances to ensure conformance
to specifications, using precision measuring instruments.
102. Plaintiffs received an “invitation letter” to their programs with the same date.
Like the acceptance letters, the invitation letters made promises about the costs to students:
Western Iowa Tech will be responsible for your international flight to our
campus in Sioux City, Iowa. You are NOT responsible for the cost of your
tuition, fees, housing, or supplies. Meals will be provided by the college.
and Royal Canin, made these false promises in order to induce the Plaintiffs to travel to the
104. Meanwhile, Defendants Burright and Albert were working to smooth out the
105. Defendant Albert wrote the U.S. Embassy in Chile that it was not necessary
for the Plaintiffs to be fluent in English to participate in WITCC’s J-1 Visa Program,
because “The College runs a strong English as a Second Language Program (ESL) for
international students and will provide the exchange student with Intensive English
language instruction in order for the student to participate in his or her chosen program of
study/training.”
Department of State that the Plaintiffs would be participating in Food Services and
Electromechanical training programs, using the required form DS-2019. This form
29
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 29 of 95
b. Plaintiffs in both programs would take intensive English courses;
c. For the Plaintiffs in the “Food Services” program, Defendants Albert and
student will be under the guidance of a local and qualified employee and
d. The defendants certified that the “Food Services” “student will lend
assist in ongoing workflows. With this, the student will get substantial
knowledge in the Food Service field that will prepare him/her for
restaurants.”
30
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 30 of 95
f. The defendants further certified that “[t]he [Electromechanical program]
technician field.”
107. The Defendants knew this was not an accurate description of the work that
the Plaintiffs would be performing. The Defendants knew Plaintiffs would be working on
exchange student and experience American culture. There were no opportunities for them
110. Defendant Yi also dictated the women’s personal lives; Yi advised them that,
if they got pregnant, he would deport them back to their country of origin.
112. Defendant WITCC did not offer Plaintiffs free room and board.
114. Instead, Plaintiffs were placed by staffing agency Defendant J&L, and at the
processing plant in Sioux City, Iowa and at Defendant Royal Canin’s dog food factory in
31
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 31 of 95
North Sioux City, South Dakota.
115. Defendant J&L organized transport for the Plaintiffs to and from the WITCC
116. The Plaintiffs were required to work as line workers, in positions that
required no skills at all and were not related to the Plaintiffs’ fields of study and reported
internship.
118. In addition, the Plaintiffs were forced to work 40 hours or more per week.
119. When Plaintiffs received their paycheck, several withdrawals were made for
things like employee badges and transportation. These withdrawals included taxes that are
120. Further withdrawals happened behind the scenes, so that they were not
recorded on the Plaintiffs’ pay stubs. Specifically, Tur-Pak and Royal Canin typically pay
between $12 and $15/hour for line work.52 Plaintiffs’ were paid $7.25/hour, while $7.75
an hour went to Defendant WITCC as payment for Plaintiffs’ tuition, fees, room and board.
121. Defendant J&L was paid as a recruiter for the work done by the student.
51
Typically, nonresident aliens working on a J-1 Visa must pay federal, state, and local taxes.
However, nonresident aliens on a J-1 Visa are exempt from paying Social Security and Medicare
taxes on wages. See IRS, Taxation of Alien Individuals by Immigration Status – J-1,
https://www.irs.gov/individuals/taxation-of-alien-individuals-by-immigration-status-j-
1#:~:text=Generally%2C%20wages%20earned%20by%20a,of%20the%20Internal%20Revenue
%20Code. (last accessed Nov. 23, 2020).
52
https://www.indeed.com/career/factory-worker/salaries/IA.
32
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 32 of 95
122. During the week before Plaintiffs’ employment started, Plaintiffs were given
123. After Plaintiffs started working, WITCC ceased providing gift cards for
meals, telling Plaintiffs they had to purchase food using their minimum wage earnings from
124. An attorney for J&L told the press that the “company assisted in lining up
[the student intern’s] internships and that they complied with the law . . . the students signed
a contract where they agreed to have a portion of their $15 per hour wages taken to help
125. The Plaintiffs were encouraged, under duress and coercion, to make
126. Defendant WITCC also encouraged the Plaintiffs to work, outside the scope
127. Collectively, the Plaintiffs began to complain that the long hours of hard
work made it impossible to attend to their classes. Plaintiffs also began to complain that
their work was not an “internship” – they were not using skills pertinent to their classes,
nor were they gaining any particular experience that would further their careers on tehri
128. Plaintiffs complained that they were not provided with the free meals that
they were promised – they had to pay for their food out of their minimum wage earnings
33
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 33 of 95
termination from the education program, termination from employment, and even
deportation.
130. The WITCC Defendants threatened Plaintiffs that they would withhold food
and daily needs. In fact, Defendant WITCC did withhold food from Plaintiffs.
131. Plaintiffs were required to work 8-12 hours daily at Defendant Tur-Pak or
Defendant Royal Canin. Defendant WITCC also held classes for the Plaintiffs six hours
daily.
132. Around November of 2019, the U.S. State Department began an investigation
133. Upon information and belief, the Department of State informed WITCC of
what the WITCC defendants already knew: the jobs at Tur-Pak and Royal Canin were not
“internships,” and the students working there were in violation of their J-1 Visa status.
134. In response, the WITCC Defendants told the J-1 Visa students, including
plaintiffs, that they had to quit their jobs at Defendant Tur-Pak and Royal Canin.
135. Some Plaintiffs had already quit their jobs. Defendant WITCC told those
students that they owed the college $250.00 a week for room, board, tuition, and fees.
136. Once all of the Plaintiffs ceased working at Defendants Royal Canin and Tur-
Pak, Defendant WITCC began attempting to charge all students $250/week for room,
137. The WITCC Defendants informed the Plaintiffs that they were working with
Defendant J&L in an attempt to secure compliant internships for the program so that the
Plaintiffs would not lose their J-1 Visas (and the Defendants could resume earning money
34
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 34 of 95
off of the Plaintiffs’ labor). These internships never materialized.
138. Some of the Plaintiffs found alternative employment on their own. The
WITCC defendants threatened these Plaintiffs that they were out of compliance with their
139. After the Plaintiffs took their complaints to the press, the WITCC Defendants
attempted to placate Plaintiffs by offering them access to WITCC’s food pantry, and by
140. The WITCC defendants then agreed to offer two meals per day – breakfast
141. In the last week of January – January 23, through January 31, 2019 – was the
first time Plaintiffs were given meal tickets so that they could eat in WITCC’s cafeteria.
But the Plaintiffs noticed that other students did not have to use “meal tickets,” they were
allowed to purchase meal plans. WITCC treated Plaintiffs differently from its regularly
enrolled students.
142. The cafeteria meals were limited to $5.00 for breakfast and $7.50 for lunch.
Students were also given a $75.00 gift card to HyVee to cover their food needs for the
week.
143. For Plaintiffs who were concerned about their food coverage going forward,
the college recommended that the student interns rely on the food pantry, stating:
Some people are reluctant to go to the WIT Comet Cupboard (Food Pantry).
But please we are not insulting you by offering this food. We do this because
we care about you. Before Christmas, employees provided lots and lots and
lots of food. People made sacrifices to provide food for ALL students.
35
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 35 of 95
Donations are provided because people care about people. Not because they
look down on people. If you ever need something, you can go there as well.
144. On March 13, 2020, Defendant WITCC, under investigation by the State
Department, cancelled the Plaintiffs’ J-1 visas. Defendant WITCC blamed the termination
of the visas on the COVID-19 crisis, and bought tickets for students to return home.
145. Defendant Murrell communicated the decision to terminate the J-1 Visa
program to the students via email on March 13, 2020, at 6:21 p.m.
146. Defendant WITCC, through Albert, informed all of the J-1 Visa students,
including Plaintiffs, on March 15, 2020, that they would have to check out of their housing
148. The return tickets were booked for March 18, 2020.
149. This was an attempt to get the plaintiffs out of the country and terminate the
150. However, Defendant WITCC did not terminate the visas of non-J-1 students
151. Defendant WITCC informed Plaintiffs and their families that their presence
Specific Allegations
152. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
153. In addition to the common experiences each plaintiff endured, the following
36
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 36 of 95
A. Karla O’Nell Norambuena
154. Karla is a Chilean national, born in 1991. She is the oldest of four children.
155. Karla’s family suffered financially. She spent the early years of her life
moving from town-to-town while her parents looked for work, and eventually her parents
156. Karla’s mother became ill with cancer, so Karla had to work to raise money
to support her family. At 16 years old, she worked through the summer and the holidays.
However, Karla could not raise sufficient funds to support her family and attend university.
157. Karla deferred applying to many universities since she was financially
158. In March of 2019, Karla began exploring options to study outside of Chile.
She received an opportunity to study at the University of Beunos Aires in Argentina and at
160. Like the other plaintiffs, Karla learned about the program through the
161. Karla called the Chilean Defendants gather information about the program.
162. In April 2019, Karla participated in a series of interviews with the WITCC
37
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 37 of 95
163. She was advised she would be allowed to enter in to one of two degree
164. While in Chile, Karla was only required to pay for her passport. The Chilean
Defendants arranged the costs of attending the in-person interviews in April of 2019.
165. Once Karla reached the in-person interview phase, Karla received breakfast
and attended a brief presentation given by Defendants Albert, Salgado, Murrell, and
Albrecht.
presenters informed the prospective students they would reside on college premises with
three other students (who could be either Brazilian or Chilean) of the same gender.
Additionally, the presenters emphasized student work schedules would not interfere with
academic studies.
and several documents which would be presented to the embassy for the visa application.
168. After executing the documents, Karla was then required to lift and carry
twenty-five (25) pound weights. The presenters informed Karla she was approved pending
169. Like the other plaintiffs, Karla received a packet of letters from Defendants
WITCC, Burright and Zuercher, including the acceptance letter, invitation letter, and
accommodation letter. In that letter, Karla was promised that she would not be responsible
38
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 38 of 95
170. Karla was informed that she could not “get paid internship [sic] off campus
without our permission. You will have your training in an external environment provided
by industries/partners that are served by our Corporate College, a division of Western Iowa
Tech Community College. These companies send their employees to our Corporate
College to acquire knowledge and training when and if it is necessary, and they are willing
to participate in this cultural interchange by allowing us to use their facilities and plants,
171. Like the other Plaintiffs, on June 12, 2019, Karla received an informal email
from Defendant Burright, indicating that the program had been changed to comply with
the Department of Education’s and the J-1 Visa Program’s requirements, and had been re-
172. Before arriving, WITCC told Karla she only needed to bring enough money
to cover food for a few weeks since WITCC indicated it would pay all other expenses.
173. Karla traveled from Chile to the United States once her visa was approved.
174. After arriving, Defendant Alberts and Castro greeted her with the college’s
bus. Albert and Castro drove Karla and other Chileans directly to Sioux City, Iowa. Once
Defendant Yi.
39
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 39 of 95
176. Following dinner, the students were taken on a tour of the college, given
178. Everyone was taken to the companies where the students would be working.
Prior to this, Karla had not been told the names or locations of the companies. She had no
179. The program finally announced to students who selected the Culinary
program they would be working for a slaughterhouse owned and operated by Seaboard
Triumph Foods53 and students in the robotics program would be working at a plant owned
180. These announcements came as a total surprise to Karla and the other students.
Many students became emotional and began to cry. The emotional impact to the
announcement continued, with many students crying daily, feeling devastated by the shock
181. Karla was assigned to work at Royal Canin. While there, Karla complained
that the work she performed did not correspond to the robotics field.
182. Karla was in charge of line production to ensure all “cans” passed inspection.
She was also directed to pack and carry large, heavy boxes and inventory cans of dog and
53
Plaintiffs named in this complaint did not end up working for Seaboard Triumph. However,
upon information and belief, other students who were defrauded and trafficked by Defendants’ J-
1 Visa program did work for Seaboard Triumph.
40
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 40 of 95
cat food. This work did not relate to what she was learning in her classes, indeed there was
183. The program required Karla to work long hours. Initially, she worked six to
12 hours a day, four days per week. Her weekly schedule often totaled 54 hours. In addition
to work, she also needed to attend class every day. She found herself working at the plant,
immediately going to class, and then returning to work with no time for proper rest.
184. Eventually, exhaustion began to take its toll on Karla. She experienced
186. The rigorous work and class schedule caused riffs between the WITCC
Defendants and Karla. When Karla was unable to attend class because of work, WITCC
simply blamed J&L for the problems. WITCC consistently evaded questions and, when it
187. When Karla continued to miss classes, the WITCC Defendants, the J&L
Defendants, and Royal Canine began to threaten Karla. They told her if she did not go to
188. Karla was also told they would be in legal breach of contract if she did not
continue to work.
189. On one particular day, Karla was simply too exhausted from her work and
academic rigors to work at the plant. She advised WITCC staff, who directed her to get
some rest.
41
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 41 of 95
190. The following day, Karla went to the supermarket to purchase essentials and,
unfamiliar with the bus schedule, missed her bus. Consequently, she was late for work.
191. J&L Staffing terminated her and she was forced to work for Tur-Pak, starting
192. Once Karla began at Tur-Pak, she was assigned to the task of accepting
orders. Like her previous job at Royal Canin, this job had nothing to do with Karla’s
electromechanical technician classes, and did not involve an educational aspect. It was pure
193. Karla was told that if she was not compliant with Tur-Pak’s instructions and
194. Karla constantly felt unsafe at Tur-Pak because she was assigned to work
with and around drug addicts, alcoholics, and criminals. In fact, Karla received a piece of
advice her first day – be careful and watch herself at all times. She was told some of the
men working in the plant were prone to sexual assault and harassment.
195. Karla was also required to stand at her job for many hours and only allowed
196. Karla developed severe sinusitis and a stomach infection. When she sought
medical treatment, the college denied any aid since she was required to pay her own health
care.
197. Karla paid for her own medications and spent approximately three weeks
vomiting after every meal due to the vile, fetid smell of Tur-Pak.
42
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 42 of 95
198. Eventually, an American co-worker contacted the United States government
199. In response, WITCC required Karla, and others, to break all ties and
communications with J&L Staffing. WITCC also gave Karla, and others, the opportunity
to search for jobs, even outside their areas of study. However, WITCC requested a weekly
200. Initially, WITCC requested that Karla pay “what she could afford.” WITCC
eventually required Karla and other international students to pay approximately $250.00
per week.
201. To keep up with these payments, Karla had to get a job with a cleaning crew
202. The WITCC Defendants informed Karla she could no longer be enrolled
since she failed to fulfill the terms of her contract by failing to work, as required, and attend
class, as required.
203. The WITCC Defendants compelled Karla to sign a document attesting she
204. Shortly thereafter, another person advised Karla about the fraudulent and
illegal acts of the program. Karla spoke to an advisor and also learned WITCC began to
205. The WITCC Defendants responded to Karla when pressed and explained that
an “error” occurred in its system and she would be allowed to remain in the program.
43
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 43 of 95
206. Once the media began to report on the trafficking, the WITCC Defendants
scheduled a meeting with all of its J-1 students. During the meeting, Defendant Albert
informed Karla and others that the culinary arts students were assured internships, but the
207. The belated efforts by Defendant WITCC to salvage its illegitimate programs
resulted in Karla losing her job as an employment coordinator in Brazil and academic
scholarships with other institutions. The program also alienated her from her family and
social relationships.
208. In March of 2020, Karla received notice that, due to COVID-19, Defendant
WITCC was ending its J-1 Visa program. She was requested to leave the country.
209. Karla declined to do so. On March 16, 2019, Karla contacted Iowa Legal Aid
210. Iowa Legal Aid quickly screened the case and assigned it to Attorney Lauren
Camp. Attorney Camp’s position with Iowa Legal Aid is funded, in part, by a special grant
from the United State Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Office of Victims Crimes
(OVC) to provide legal assistance to victims of human trafficking as defined by the TVPA.
211. On or about March 18, 2019, Attorney Camp contacted Karla with a Spanish
interpreter. During that call, Karla expressed concern about being removed from student
212. Karla was ultimate able to retain an immigration attorney to assist with her
44
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 44 of 95
213. Natalia is a Chilean national, born in 1989. She is the oldest of three children.
214. Since she was a girl, Natalia has dreamed of being a professional chef.
Natalia began working at 11 years old to help support her family. Even though both of her
parents worked, they were unable to earn enough money to meet the needs of the family.
215. When Natalia turned 18 years old, she had saved enough money to attend the
University of Chile. While in school, she continued to work. However, when she learned
her father had an advanced stage of cancer, her family became her priority and delayed her
academic pursuits.
216. Eventually, Natalia’s focus returned to her education. Like the other
WITCC. According to a public Facebook advertisement, the program offered students the
internship program.
217. Natalia completed the application and interview process in April 2019, with
the other plaintiffs. During the interview, J&L administered a strength test to Natalia,
requiring her to perform physical tasks such as lifting and moving boxes.
218. During this process, WITCC provided Natalia with prepared answers for her
219. Natalia believed she was applying for a two-year Culinary Arts degree
45
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 45 of 95
220. After the interview process, Natalia was accepted to and agreed to enroll in
221. Like the other plaintiffs, Natalia received a packet of information dated June
3, 2019, from Defendant WITCC and Defendant Burright, including an acceptance letter,
assured Natalia that tuition, costs, supplies, housing, and meals would be provided by the
Defendants.
222. The June 3, 2019 letter also explained Natalia would be prohibited from
223. Also in June 2019, Natalia received the same email received by the other
Plaintiffs explaining that changes were being made to the program in order to comply with
with the program and changing the name and length of the program. Nevertheless, Natalia
224. Natalia completed her state department interview in Las Condes, Santiago,
225. Natalia sold her computer, telephone, and bicycle to raise just under
226. Natalia also quit her job in import/export thereby relinquishing a contract
46
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 46 of 95
228. WITCC and the J-1 program promised Natalia covered health insurance,
food, and housing. In reality, Natalia paid for her own medical insurance, food, and
housing.
229. J&L placed Natalia at Tur-Pak as a food handler for her internship. She
received $7.25 per hour in wages after WITCC deducted $7.25 per hour. Upon information
230. Natalia’s job was not related to her field of study at WITCC.
231. WITCC told Natalia if she missed work or allowed her grades to drop, she
would be removed from the program, her visa would be revoked, and she would be
deported.
232. The WITCC program required her to work overnight, often from 4:30 p.m.
to 4:30 a.m. Her work schedule rigors afforded very little, if any, time for rest and hygiene.
233. On one particular frigid winter day, Natalia did not have money for
transportation from her job to her residence since Tur-Pak and WITCC withheld most of
her paycheck. She had no option but to walk two hours in freezing temperatures. Once she
arrived at her residence, she had to shower and attend class at 8:00 a.m.
234. The struggles the Defendants forced Natalia to endure led to her begging for
money, becoming alienated from her family, and deeply depressed and dehumanized.
235. Like the other Plaintiffs, Natalia was forced to quit her job when the
47
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 47 of 95
236. With no money coming in, Natalia could not afford food. In response, the
WITCC Defendants first offered access to a charity food pantry. Eventually, the defendants
relented and offered gift cards and meal tickets to the campus cafeteria.
237. In March of 2020, Natalia received notice from Defendant WITCC that the
J-1 Visa program was being cancelled, and that she had days to leave the country on a flight
238. Natalia declined to leave the country, and was able to retain an immigration
240. In the spring of 2019, Almendra was studying for a degree in tourism and
hospitality. She had worked as a bartender for two years in restaurants and discotheques.
She had also worked for one year as a tour guide in Zapallar, Chile.
241. Almendra was hoping to study Culinary Arts to compliment her previous
242. The Chilean Defendant recruiters sold the WITCC program as an initiative
Defendant J&L.
48
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 48 of 95
245. Almendra left her last year at the university to come to the US for the
program at WITCC.
246. Like the other plaintiffs, Almendra received a packet of letters from
Defendants WITCC, Burright and Zuercher, including the acceptance letter, invitation
letter, and accommodation letter. In that letter, Almendra was promised that she would not
247. Almendra was informed that she could not “get paid internship [sic] off
campus without our permission. You will have your training in an external environment
Western Iowa Tech Community College. These companies send their employees to our
Corporate College to acquire knowledge and training when and if it is necessary, and they
are willing to participate in this cultural interchange by allowing us to use their facilities
and plants, and by providing us an experienced and qualified employee to oversee your
248. On June 12, 2019, Almendra received the same informal email from
Defendant Burright received by the other plaintiffs, indicating that the program had been
changed to comply with the Department of Education’s and the J-1 Visa program’s
requirements.
249. Despite these changes, Almendra, along with the other plaintiffs, was told
that “Nothing changed for you, only the way we have to approach and describe this
program. This is the main reason for the delay in this process because I was adjusting it
49
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 49 of 95
following the instructions of the Department of Education that so kindly helped us to be on
251. Before Almendra began her internship, she was given a $50/week gift card
252. Almendra was provided with an employee handbook from J&L , and asked
to electronically sign acknowledging her receipt of that handbook on September 13, 2019.
253. Also on September 13, 2019, Almendra was asked to sign a form in Spanish
indicating that she understood J&L required perfect attendance during the first two weeks
254. Almendra began her job at Tur-Pak and received paychecks from J&L
staffing.
255. Almendra was paid $7.25/hour, for 45-50 hours per week.
256. Once her employment began, Defendant WITCC stopped distributing the
Walmart gift cards, stating students would have to pay for their food with their income
257. When Almendra and other student interns complained they could not afford
food, and that they were promised food, WITCC took the student interns to local churches
for donations.
258. Almendra thought she would be working in a job related to the career that
she had come to the United States to study, such as cooking. Instead, she was told she
50
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 50 of 95
259. Although Almendra was technically working with food at Tur-Pak, she did
260. This job involved no skill at all, and she did not receive any training relevant
261. Defendant J&L provided transportation to the job, at a cost of $4.00 per ride,
262. Other deductions, including taxes that are not permissible on a J-1 Visa, were
Tur-Pak and suffering several on-the-job injuries. Alemndra was told that if she missed
work for any reason, even including injury, she would be out of compliance with the
264. J&L and Tur-Pak did not care if Almendra or other workers were sick, or if
they missed classes because they were tired. For J&L and Tur-Pak, work was more
important.
265. Almendra felt she could not quit or stop working, because she was threatened
with deportation. Defendant Albert explained that if she quit her job, she would be out of
compliance her his visa and would be deported, with no return to the United States
available.
266. After one group of students made complaints to the Department of State
about the program, Almendra received notice that all students would have to stop working
at Tur-Pak, and that WITCC would assist the students in finding new jobs.
51
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 51 of 95
267. WITCC never found Almendra a new job, or any suitable internship for the
268. In March of 2020, WITCC terminated Alemndra’s J-1 Visa, claiming that it
could not continue the program due to the ongoing Coronavirus Pandemic. Almendra was
269. Despite this, Almendra did not leave the country, and retained an
271. David has had a difficult childhood. He never met his biological father. His
mother encountered legal trouble as a result of her husband, and so David was frequently
in his grandmother’s care. David and his mother also lived with his aunt for a time, but
became homeless because David’s aunt was abusive. David was diagnosed with Leukemia
as a teenager.
272. Because of the immense difficulties in his past, when David came across the
opportunity to study in the United States, he jumped for the opportunity for a fresh start.
273. David was recruited for the WITCC J-1 Visa program by the Chilean
274. David had a video conference with Defendants Albert and Burright to answer
his questions about the program. During this video conference, Defendants Albert and
Burright explained that, to participate in the program, the applicant had to know basic
52
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 52 of 95
275. David attended the April 2019 interviews with the WITCC Defendants and
J&L Defendants.
276. Bizarrely, during the presentation, Defendant Albrecht took out a $100 bill,
showed it to David and the other students, and stated “You want to have money. You want
278. Like the other Plaintiffs, David received a packet of information dated June
3, 2020, including the acceptance letter, invitation letter, and housing accommodation
letters. These letters assured David that he had been accepted into the rebranded Food
Services Diploma program, that his tuition, housing, supplies, and meals would be
provided by the college, and that he would participate in an internship that was relevant to
279. David was also notified that he could not obtain an internship or job outside
280. Like the other Plaintiffs, David also received the informal email from
Defendant Burright, describing the changes that had been made to the program since the
April 2019 interviews, and instructing him to destroy the documents from Defendant J&L
281. David decided not to destroy the documents from Defendant J&L.
282. The WITCC Defendants prepped David for his interview, explaining he had
to tell the consular office that he was only coming to the United States for one year, and
53
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 53 of 95
283. David came to the United States in August with the rest of the Plaintiffs.
284. Once he arrived, the WITCC defendants provided some gift cards for food.
286. David’s job at Tur-Pak was pure menial labor. He did not use any of the skills
he was learning in classes at this job, and there was no educational component to it.
287. David’s schedule at Tur-Pak was from 3:30 p.m. to 12:00 a.m., Monday
through Friday. If he missed a day of work, the J&L Defendants and WITCC Defendants
would tell him that he would have to work a Saturday, or he would be deported.
288. Defendant Yi in particular repeatedly told David, “If you don’t work, you go.
If you don’t study, you go. If you don’t comply, you go.”
289. This schedule, combined with David’s class load, was exhausting.
290. Because of exhaustion, David suffered an injury at work, leaving him with a
291. David was encouraged not to go to a doctor for these injuries, because it
292. To this day, his ankle hurts. He has learned to live with the pain.
293. Defendant WITCC did not care if David was tired or stressed. He was always
threatened with being deported to Chile if he did not comply with the Defendants’
demands.
294. David was eventually given the option of quitting at Tur-Pak and finding
work elsewhere. However, he was told that if he was not working at Tur-Pak, he would
54
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 54 of 95
owe the college $250/week.
State. A Department of State investigator made an appointment to talk with David. Prior
to the appointment, the WITCC Defendants attempted to coach David on how to answer
interview questions.
296. David went two months without a job and with no financial assistance from
the WITCC Defendants. He had to beg his parents for money, but they could not afford to
help him.
297. During a meeting with all of the J-1 Visa students, David was told that he
excuse to terminate the J-1 Visa program. David received notice that his program had ended
and his Visa was terminated, and was asked to leave the country within a few days.
299. Instead of leaving, David was able to retain an immigration attorney to help
301. Fernando has a high school diploma, and studied Social Work for two years
at Andres Bello University in Vina del Mar in Chile. He also has a diploma from a cocktail
302. Fernando was hoping to study Culinary Arts to compliment his cocktail
55
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 55 of 95
303. The Chilean defendants sold the WITCC program as an initiative to help
304. Fernando quit his job, left university, and sold all of his belongings to come
up with the money he needed to come to the United States for this program. His parents
305. Fernando received a letter from Defendant Burright dated April 24, 2019,
stating that he was accepted into WITCC’s J-1 Visa, Culinary Arts Program and to start his
306. Fernando believed, based on the WITCC Defendants’ promises, that this
307. Fernando signed a contract of employment with Defendant J&L on April 27,
2019.
308. Like the other Plaintiffs, Fernando received the June 3, 2019 packet of letters,
including the acceptance letter, invitation letter, and accommodation letter. These letters
promised Fernando free tuition, housing, fees, and supplies, and that meals would be
309. Like the other Plaintiffs, Fernando received the informal email from Burright
indicating that the program had been changed from a two-year J-1 Student Visa program,
311. Before Fernando began his internship, he was given a $50/week gift card to
56
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 56 of 95
312. Fernando was provided with an employee handbook from J&L, and asked to
electronically sign acknowledging his receipt of that handbook on September 13, 2019.
313. Also on September 13, 2019, Fernando was asked to sign a form in Spanish
indicating that he understood J&L Staffing required perfect attendance during the first two
314. Fernando began his job at Tur-Pak and received paychecks from J&L
staffing.
315. Fernando was paid $7.25/hour, for 32+ hours per week.
316. Once his employment began, WITCC stopped distributing the Walmart gift
cards, stating students would have to pay for their food with their income from their job.
317. When Fernando and other student interns complained they could not afford
food, and that they were promised food, WITCC took the student interns to local churches
for donations.
318. Fernando thought that he would be working in a job related to the career that
he had come to the United States to study, such as cooking. Instead, he was told he would
3:30 p.m. to 12:00 a.m., Monday through Friday. Although he was technically working
with food, he did not apply anything that he learned in his classes.
320. This job involved no skill at all, and he did not receive any training relevant
57
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 57 of 95
321. J&L Staffing provided transportation to the job, at a cost of $4.00 per ride,
322. Other deductions, including taxes that are not permissible on a J-1 Visa, were
position every day for eight hours, doing repetitive work, watching his coworkers fight,
324. On October 10, 2019, Fernando emailed Albrecht at J&L and asked to be
325. Albrecht replied, one minute later: “[P]lease report to work and if they send
you home we will deal with it then but you must go to work.”
326. Fernando worked at Tur-Pak for two months when he began experiencing
back pain and muscle spasms. Fernando suffers from scoliosis. During these two months,
he had to go to the doctor on three occasions, and the doctor told him that this was not an
327. Fernando was temporarily restricted to light work duty for three days, with
328. Fernando had to be prescribed Tizanidine to treat his muscle spasms, and
58
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 58 of 95
329. J&L and Tur-Pak did not care if Fernando or other workers were sick, or if
they missed classes because they were tired. For J&L and Tur-Pak, work was more
important.
330. Fernando felt that he could not quit or stop working, because he was
threatened with deportation. Albert explained that if Fernando quit his job, he would be out
of compliance with his visa and would be deported, with no return to the United States
available.
331. Fernando had a meeting about his back pain with Defendant Yi. Yi was a
chiropractor. Because Fernando did not have money to go to a chiropractor on his own, Yi
made Fernando take off his shirt in front of other students for a chiropractic adjustment.
332. Next, Fernando had a meeting with Albert. Albert told Fernando that he
could leave the job at Tur-Pak, but that he had to find another job and could not delay in
doing so.
333. Fernando found another job at The Don’s Sports Bar & Grill in Sioux City,
334. Notably, without the connection between The Don’s Sports Bar and J&L,
WITCC was no longer receiving a cut of Fernando’s pay from his work.
335. After two weeks of this, Albert contacted Fernando and the other student
interns who were no longer working at Tur-Pak and informed them that they would have
59
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 59 of 95
336. At first, Albert informed the students that they would owe $100/week for
housing. Then, Albert informed the students they would have to pay $250/week to cover
337. When Fernando stopped working for Tur-Pak, WITCC stopped providing
338. Fernando’s job at Don’s Bar earned him approximately $500 every two
weeks, meaning that $250/week fees to WITCC would be the entirety of his earnings, with
339. After one group of students made complaints to the Department of State
about the program, Fernando received notice that all students would have to stop working
at Tur-Pak, and that WITCC would assist the students in finding new jobs.
340. At one point, WITCC issued one round of gift cards for the students that were
341. Fernando was threatened that if there were any problems, if he did not
perform his job adequately or missed too many classes, that he would be deported and
342. WITCC never found Fernando a new job. WITCC never provided Fernando
343. Albert stated to Fernando that she doesn’t care if he goes to class or not. All
WITCC cared about was that the student interns were working.
344. In March of 2020, WITCC terminated Fernando’s J-1 Visa, claiming that it
could not continue the program due to the ongoing Coronavirus Pandemic. Fernando was
60
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 60 of 95
asked to vacate WITCC immediately and go back to his home country on a few days’
notice.
345. Fernando has not vacated the country. Fernando retained an immigration
346. Since coming to the United States, Fernando has married a U.S. Citizen.
Fernando still hopes to pursue a career in Culinary Arts, although the Defendants’ actions
F. Claudio Ramos
348. Claudio has a high school diploma, and he was attending college at the
Universidad Santa Maria studying engineering when he came across the WITCC Culinary
Arts Program.
349. Claudio jumped at the opportunity to earn a free degree in Culinary Arts,
because baking had long been his passion and his dream.
350. Claudio had a difficult childhood. His mother had him at age 16, and his
biological father was never in the picture. His stepfather struggled to be an adequate parent
and connect to Claudio, and the family dealt with extreme poverty.
351. Despite their struggles, Claudio and his stepfather worked together in a
bakery, selling bread and cakes throughout their neighborhood. Claudio was able to put
352. Claudio hoped that the culinary arts program at WITCC would give him the
skills he needed to open his own bakery and follow in his stepfather’s footsteps.
61
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 61 of 95
353. Claudio was excited to participate in cultural exchange – he was going to
learn English and be able to speak it while educating himself to have his own business.
354. Claudio contacted the Chilean Defendants to learn more about the WITCC
Culinary Arts Program. Defendant Espinoza contacted Claudio every day to tell him about
355. Claudio was interviewed for the WITCC Culinary Arts program by the
356. During the interview with Defendant Albrecht, on behalf of J & L, Claudio
was asked simple questions, such as if he had any health issues, and whether he could lift
30 kilograms.
357. Defendant Burright had warned Claudio and others that they would be asked
about how much they could lift, but explained that “questions like that are usual here” in
358. During the interview with the WITCC Defendants, Claudio was assisted with
filling out the application paperwork for the WITCC Culinary Arts program.
359. Claudio was informed that he was accepted and made plans to come to the
United States.
360. Then, Claudio learned, like the other students, that the program was
undergoing some changes. Claudio received the email from Defendant Burright explaining
that WITCC had made some mistakes in creating the program, and that the Culinary Arts
62
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 62 of 95
361. Claudio received the same packet of June 3, 2019 letters as the other
These letters described the program, and assured Claudio that he would not be paying for
362. Claudio quit his job, and stopped his education in Chile for the opportunity
363. Claudio was concerned to leave his parents behind because his mother was
364. Claudio arrived on August 17, 2020 and settled into the apartment that
365. In September, Claudio received his social security number and began work
The work was physically demanding. He would rotate within the same line, but couldn’t
move from his line. His job was to make sure that the Lunchables were not missing any
items.
367. Making sure that the cheese was not missing from the Lunchables packets
was not an educational internship. Claudio did not learn anything about the Culinary Arts
in this internship.
368. Claudio had classes from 7:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m., then he would work form
63
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 63 of 95
369. The work environment was also frightening for Claudio, and not suitable for
a student. His co-workers were former convicts and drug addicts, and there was workplace
370. This schedule was physically draining on Claudio. He would wake up with
cooking. He couldn’t keep up with the routine because his body was not getting the rest it
371. Claudio began to miss classes due to exhaustion and psychological stress.
hospital, but he was told that he would not be taken to the hospital because he had to go to
373. Claudio was told that if he missed work or missed classes to go to the
hospital, that his J-1 Visa would be revoked and he would be deported back to Chile for
374. Defendant Yi yelled at Claudio and the other students that they could not
miss work because they owed Defendant WITCC so much money. Yi told Claudio and the
other students that if they missed even a day of work, their J-1 Visas would be cancelled
375. After this occasion, a co-worker volunteered to take Claudio to Walmart for
376. Claudio also began to suffer back pain as a result of his work on the
64
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 64 of 95
Claudio and Defendant Burright that Claudio had a fever. Defendant Burright told Claudio
377. On one occasion, a co-worker hit Claudio out of nowhere. Claudio told a
378. Claudio observed co-workers laying on the floor, and co-workers using drugs
379. Claudio realized during this time that there were many deductions from his
pay stub to cover living expenses, transportation. He complained about this but nothing
happened.
Claudio was told to quit his job at Tur-Pak. He did so because he felt he had to comply
381. Without any income, Claudio had to write his family for money for his basic
needs.
382. In November and December, Claudio was among the students interviewed
by the government as it was investigating the allegations against WITCC. After these
384. Claudio had no more income as he had been ordered to quit his job at Tur-
Pak. Defendant WITCC was no longer providing any money for food, and Claudio had to
spend all the money his parents sent him just to survive.
65
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 65 of 95
385. In January, Claudio was called to a meeting with officials at WITCC and the
other student interns. The student interns were told they had two options: return to Chile at
right away with a paid ticket and no certificate, or stay at WITCC, but work at a job of
WITCC’s choosing, and continue to have money deducted from their paychecks.
386. Students who did not comply – because they quit their jobs and worked
outside of the jobs that were approved by WITCC – were excluded from receiving Walmart
387. Defendants Burright, Yi, and other WITCC employees constantly addressed
Claudio as a debtor, stating that they had done a lot for him, and that he had to pay all of
388. Defendants Burright and Yi scheduled a second meeting with Claudio after
because his grades were below the average expected by the school. However, these
390. When Claudio returned to his apartment, he logged into WITCC’s portal to
check his grades: they were in line with what was expected. Defendants Burright and Yi
391. Shortly after this meeting, Claudio was informed that he no longer would be
deported, and he could work for Chik-Fil-A in food prep. Although this was also paid labor,
and still not a real internship, Claudio was at least out of the environment at Tur-Pak.
66
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 66 of 95
392. Claudio has experienced real harm from his time in the United States, being
trafficked by WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and their employees. He has a hard time sleeping and
has nightmares that the recruiters will do something to his family, or deport him to keep
him from testifying. He has severe anxiety due to his treatment and exploitation. This
makes it hard for him to complete daily tasks. He has also lost a significant amount of
cancelling his J-1 Visa (allegedly due to COVID-19) and he had a few days to leave the
country.
G. Alejandro Pizarro
397. Alejandro had an incredibly difficult childhood. His mother was an alcoholic,
and abusive. This caused Alejandro to seek comfort in food, leaving him overweight as a
child.
398. Alejandro has suffered trauma in his life. He was sexually abused by a tennis
coach. He was in a car accident with his best friend, resulting in that friend’s death.
67
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 67 of 95
399. Alejandro overcame that trauma to pursue a career in construction, where he
400. Alejandro was interested in the Robotics J-1 Visa Program because he
thought it could advance his career if he learned English, and learned skills related to
401. He first came across the program on Facebook in March of 2019. He saw the
402. Alejandro contacted Defendants Espinoza, Actos, and Martin Matta to get
more information about the program. The Chilean Defendants provided dates when
403. Alejandro applied to participate in the Robotics J-1 Visa Program offered by
Defendant WITCC.
404. Initially, Alejandro was told that this would be a two-year program, that the
program would be supported by scholarships, and that he could use the money he earned
405. Alejandro attended interviews with the Chilean Defendants, the WITCC
406. During the interview with Albrecht for J&L, Alejandro had to demonstrate
that he could lift 40 pounds from the floor to the height of his torso.
407. Like the other Plaintiffs, Alejandro received a packet of letters dated June 3,
2019, including the acceptance letter, accommodations letter, and invitation letter for the
68
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 68 of 95
Alejandro would not be responsible for the cost of his tuition, fees, housing, supplies, or
meals.
408. Like the other Plaintiffs, Alejandro received the email from Defendant
Burright explaining that some changes had to be made to the program, including reducing
the program to one year with the option to renew, and instructing the students not to
say to the Department of State during the visa interview, specifically, he was told he could
not tell the embassy he was coming to work, not to mention J&L, and to say that the only
410. Finally, Alejandro was instructed to destroy the documents indicating that
411. To prepare for his time in the United States, Alejandro sold his work tools so
that he could have cash for his expenses. These tools had more than economic value to
Alejandro, they allowed him to be independent because with these tools he could obtain
construction jobs.
412. Alejandro also had to cancel a number of his pending jobs. This severely
415. Alejandro worked in a production line at Royal Canin. His job was to
separate very heavy pieces of meat with a tool that resembled a drill.
69
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 69 of 95
416. Alejandro was not using the skills that he learned in his classes on this job.
He did not learn anything related to his course of study on this job. The job on the
production line at Royal Canin was pure physical labor, for the benefit of Royal Canin, and
417. Somedays, he worked six-hour shifts. Other days, he worked 12-hour shifts.
418. Alejandro’s classes were scheduled from 8 a.m. to 12 p.m. With this
419. However, he could not stop working. The WITCC and J&L Defendants
required him to attend work and class, stating that if he failed to do so he would be kicked
420. The WITCC and J&L Defendants informed Alejandro that “everyone had a
debt to pay.”
421. During one of Alejandro’s 12-hour shifts, he dropped a heavy piece of frozen
422. Alejandro informed Defendant J&L that he would not be returning to work
the following day because of his injury. In response, Defendant Albrecht told him Royal
Canin would give him a different position that day where he would not have to work with
his hands. When he arrived at work, he was not given any assistance and not transferred to
a different position.
concerned his thumb was broken. Although there was no fracture, he was prescribed
70
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 70 of 95
Naproxen for pain management and the use of a splint to protect the injured wrist and
thumb.
424. The following day, he was fired by Defendant Royal Canin because he failed
425. Defendants WITCC and J&L arranged for Alejandro to work for Defendant
Tur-Pak instead. Again, Alejandro was placed on the production line, this time assembling
Lunchables.
426. Defendant Tur-Pak did not provide a healthy or clean work environment.
Alejandro observed several employees and many of his classmates get sick with stomach
427. Several of Defendant Tur-Pak’s employees had criminal records. They used
drugs on the job, and there were verbal and physical altercations every day.
428. At Tur-Pak, Alejandro worked Monday through Friday, from 3:30 in the
429. Defendant Alejandro was provided with food or gift cards for food before he
began working for Royal Canin. However, once he began work, he was told that his
430. Alejandro was given access to the WITCC cafeteria for breakfast and lunch
431. Alejandro did not have the opportunity to learn English as he expected. The
only other students in his classes were Chileans or Brazilians in the same J-1 Visa program.
71
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 71 of 95
432. In November or December, Alejandro was informed that he had to quit the
job at Tur-Pak because it did not comply with the J-1 Visa requirements. He was threatened
with being deported. He was threatened that if he was deported he would be unable to
433. Alejandro always did what the WITCC Defendants told him to, for fear that
they would cause him to be deported and he would be unable to return to the United States.
434. Alejandro was repeatedly told that he was indebted to Defendant WITCC,
435. Instead of finding a replacement internship that would comply with the J-1
Visa program, in February 2020, WITCC put Alejandro to work in maintenance on the
college. His first project was to paint the walls in the college. Like the jobs at Royal Canin
and Tur-Pak, this was pure physical labor for the employer’s benefit, and not an internship.
436. After Alejandro’s J-1 Visa program was terminated by the school in March
2020 (allegedly over COVID-19), his parents began receiving threatening and harassing
messages. They received correspondence from the school stating that Alejandro is
437. Alejandro has suffered physical and psychological harm as a result of being
trafficked.
438. Alejandro struggles to sleep, and often cannot fall asleep until 5 or 6 a.m. He
is only able to sleep for four hours before the anxiety wakes him up again.
72
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 72 of 95
439. Alejandro did not leave the country, despite Defendant WITCC’s attempts to
make him leave in March of 2020. Alejandro retained an immigration attorney to assist
440. Eduardo Antonio Munoz Vargas was born in La Ligua, Chile, in 1988.
441. Like the other Plaintiffs, Eduardo first learned about Defendant WITCC’s J-
442. Eduardo saw this program as an opportunity to change the life he had led in
443. Eduardo applied to participate in the Culinary Arts J-1 Visa Program offered
by Defendant WITCC.
444. Initially, Eduardo was told that this would be a two-year program, that the
program would be supported by scholarships, and that he could use the money he earned
445. Eduardo attended interviews with the Chilean Defendants, the WITCC
446. During the interview with Albrecht for J&L, Eduardo had to demonstrate that
he was physically fit. Defendant Albrecht did not have many other questions during the job
interview.
447. After these interviews, Eduardo signed the contract with Defendant WITCC
for the J-1 Visa program, and the employment contract with Defendant J&L.
73
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 73 of 95
448. Like the other Plaintiffs, Eduardo received a packet of letters dated June 3,
2019, including the acceptance letter, accommodations letter, and invitation letter for the
rebranded, one-year “Food Services Program.” These letters reiterated that Eduardo would
not be responsible for the cost of his tuition, fees, housing, supplies, or meals.
449. Like the other Plaintiffs, Eduardo received the email from Defendant
Burright explaining that some changes had to be made to the program, including reducing
the program to one year with the option to renew, and instructing the students not to
450. Eduardo was instructed by Defendants Burright and Espinoza on what to say
to the Department of State during the visa interview, specifically, he was told he could not
tell the embassy he was coming to work, not to mention J&L, and to say that the only work-
451. Finally, Eduardo was instructed to destroy the documents indicating that
452. Eduardo arrived in the United States in August 2019. While he was gone, his
454. A week later, Defendants Carlos and Soledad visited the student apartment
complex and the factories that the students would be working at to ensure their wellbeing.
455. It took a month for Eduardo’s social security number to arrive so that he
74
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 74 of 95
456. Before starting his job, Eduardo and other Plaintiffs had a meeting with
Defendant Albrect, informing them that they had to work 40 hours/week, that
transportation would be deducted from their paycheck, and if they missed a day of work,
457. During this meeting Defendant Albrecht bizarrely took out a $100 bill and
showed it to Eduardo and the other students, stating “If we wanted that money, we should
458. Eduardo was put to work for Defendant Tur-Pak on September 18, 2019. His
job was to put plastic trays for Lunchables into the machine, so that the trays could be filled
459. This was purely routine, physical labor, for the benefit of Tur-Pak. There
were no educational components, and he did not use any of the skills learned in his program
at this job.
460. Eduardo was paid $7.25/hour for this work. Additional amounts were taken
out of his paycheck for transportation, and for taxes that were not permitted for J-1 Visa
students.
461. Eduardo was informed that more money was being taken out to pay
Defendant WITCC for his contract. Eduardo did not authorize this to happen. This money
462. Eduardo was in class from 8:30 a.m. to 12 p.m. The transportation from
Defendant J&L picked him up at 2:30 p.m., and then he would work until midnight.
75
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 75 of 95
463. Sometimes, the transportation from Defendant J&L back to his apartment
was late. Eduardo recalls waiting until 2:00 a.m. for a ride home from work.
464. Eduardo’s job produced a lot of anxiety for him. If he was too slow, the
machine would err and the whole production line would be shut down. He could not sit or
move from his spot in the line for the entirety of his shift.
465. Eduardo began to be exhausted from the repetitive and strenuous work.
466. Defendants Burright and Yi would interrupt Eduardo’s classes to take out
and talk to students who did not attend work. They would lecture everyone that they had
signed a contract they had to fulfill, and that if they did not work, they would be deported.
467. Because of these threats, Eduardo felt powerless to change his employment.
468. During one two-week period, Eduardo was scheduled to work every single
day. By the 13th day, his legs were giving out and his mental health was in a precarious
state.
469. Eduardo emailed Defendant Albrecht to ask for a day off. Albrecht
encouraged him to go to work, despite his precarious state, stating “You must go to work
or risk losing your job. If you’re truly sick they will send you home.”
470. The constant stress was too much for Eduardo. He lost 20 kilos, became
471. After the investigation into the J-1 Visa program in November, Eduardo was
told that he had to stop working at Tur-Pak. He learned from this investigation that, under
his J-1 Visa, he was not permitted to work more than 32 hours.
76
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 76 of 95
472. The investigators also informed Eduardo that Defendant WITCC was
supposed to be paying for the J-1 Visa Program, not deducting it from Eduardo’s pay.
473. After this, Defendants WITCC did not follow through and provide an
internship for Eduardo that would be compliant with his J-1 Visa Program.
474. In order to have some money to survive, Eduardo began donating plasma,
and got various low-income, part-time jobs. Defendant WITCC then made him quit these
jobs, as they were not compliant with the J-1 Visa program.
475. Eduardo was in a catch-22 – the school would not provide him with the things
he needed to survive, would not provide him with an internship – but he couldn’t get these
476. Despite the promise of free tuition, housing, supplies, room and board,
Eduardo received bills from the University for each of these items.
the cafeteria. Again, this was a low-wage job, and not an educational internship.
478. On March 13, 2020, Eduardo received notice that the program was cancelled
– ostensibly for COVID-19 – and that he would be returned to his country and must vacate
480. Defendant WITCC continued to threaten Eduardo, stating it would tell his
77
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 77 of 95
481. Eduardo continues to suffer mentally and emotionally as a result of the
Defendants’ actions.
CAUSES OF ACTION
“…[T]he Declaration of Independence[] recognizes the inherent dignity and worth of all
people. It states that all men are created equal and that they are endowed by their Creator
with certain unalienable rights. The right to be free from slavery and involuntary
servitude is among those unalienable rights. Acknowledging this fact, the United States
outlawed slavery and involuntary servitude in 1865, recognizing them as evil institutions
that must be abolished.” 22 U.S.C. § 7101(b)(22).
COUNT 1
Trafficking with Respect to Peonage and Forced Labor
TVPRA, 18 U.S.C. § 1590, § 1595
(Against All Defendants)
482. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
obtained Plaintiffs for labor in violation of the TVPRA, by one or by any combination, of
United States.
transportation.
78
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 78 of 95
d. Defendants Royal Canin and Tur-Pak paid the WITCC Defendants and
484. The purpose of these actions was to obtain Plaintiffs’ labor by force and by
peonage.
485. The defendants actually did obtain Plaintiffs’ labor by these means.
486. Defendants knew or were in reckless disregard of the fact that their venture
Defendants as follows:
COUNT 2
TVPRA, 18 U.S.C. § 1589, § 1595
(Against All Defendants)
488. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
489. Defendants obtained the labor and/or services of the Plaintiffs by one or by
79
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 79 of 95
a. By means of serious harm or threats of serious harm to that person or
of value, specifically:
the program.
workers, who could not quit or leave their jobs without fear of retaliation,
and who could not even have a sick day without fear of retaliation.
profited, despite the fact that they did provide some classes to the
Plaintiffs.
could not quit or even have a sick day for fear of legal repercussions (e.g.,
housing).
491. Defendants knew or were in reckless disregard to the fact that the venture
80
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 80 of 95
492. Defendants actually obtained forced labor as a result of these actions.
Defendants as follows:
COUNT 3
Peonage/Debt Bondage
TVPRA, 18 U.S.C. § 1581 and § 1595
(Against All Defendants)
494. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
covering tuition, fees, costs, housing, and food while completing their
b. Defendants did not inform Plaintiffs that they would be required to pay
for this “scholarship” with their labor until after Plaintiffs had been
81
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 81 of 95
c. Defendants required Plaintiffs to work 35+ hours/week in menial and,
d. Defendants told Plaintiffs they could not miss work or change jobs
e. Defendants told Plaintiffs that even if they were deported and were unable
school money.
f. When some Plaintiffs did quit their jobs, they were presented with bills
g. Food was withheld from Plaintiffs who were not working for Tur-Pak and
Royal Canin.
496. The Defendants knew or were in reckless disregard of the fact that the
bondage.
Defendants as follows:
82
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 82 of 95
c. Punitive damages and,
COUNT 4
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act
18 U.S.C. § 1961-1967
Conducting the Affairs of an Enterprise through a Pattern of Racketeering
18 U.S.C. § 1962(c)
(Against Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin)
499. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
500. Plaintiffs are all “persons” as defined in the RICO statute. 18 U.S.C. §
1961(3).
501. Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin are all “persons” as
1961(4), by associating in fact for the purpose of trafficking Plaintiffs to the United States
503. Defendants J&L, Tur-Pak, and WITCC also formed an enterprise as defined
in 18 U.S.C. § 1961(4), by associating in fact for the purpose of obtaining the labor of
504. Defendants J&L, Royal Canin, and WITCC also formed an enterprise as
defined in 18 U.S.C. § 1961(4) by associating in fact for the purpose of obtaining the labor
83
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 83 of 95
505. Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin engaged in
racketeering activity, including, but not limited to, violations of 18 U.S.C. § 1581–1592
(relating to peonage, slavery, and trafficking in persons). See 18 U.S. Code § 1961.
506. Defendants WITCC and J&L engaged in racketeering activity including, but
not limited to, violations of 18 U.S.C. § 1546 (relating to fraud and misuse of visas, permits,
507. Defendants WITCC and J&L attempted to prevent the investigation into
these actions by evicting the Plaintiffs and forcing them out of the country in March of
2020.
508. Defendants WITCC and J&L engaged in a campaign to prevent the Plaintiffs
from testifying or otherwise seeking recourse by making their presence in the United States
509. Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin engaged in those
510. Alternatively, Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin had a
reckless disregard of the fact that they were engaging in illegal acts amounting to predicate
acts of racketeering.
511. Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin engaged in a pattern of
racketeering activity. In fact, the allegations made by these eight Plaintiffs in and of
84
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 84 of 95
themselves show a pattern. Furthermore, the Defendants have also engaged in this same
512. The Defendants’ illegal acts are both closed-ended and open-ended. The
Defendant’s illegal acts are closed-ended in so much as the nearly 60 student victims from
Brazil and Chile show repeated predicate offense under the RICO statute.
513. The Defendants’ illegal acts are also open-ended, in so much as the
Defendants can continue their racketeering enterprise into the future, continuing to import
forced labor into the United States from the developing world through fraud and deceit.
514. One of the instances of racketeering occurred after the effective date of 18
U.S. Code § 1961, and the last of which occurred within 10 years of the prior act of
racketeering activity. The instances of racketeering are believed to have begun in 2018 and
515. The Defendants activities, both legal and illegal, had an effect on interstate
516. The Plaintiffs have suffered injury to their business and property by reason
Defendants as follows:
54
Upon information and belief, the students from Brazil were also invited to attend the
same two-year Culinary Arts or Robotics programs, and the programs underwent the same
re-branding bait and switch for the Brazilians that occurred with the Chilean Plaintiffs.
85
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 85 of 95
a. Actual, compensatory, consequential, and all other allowable damages
COUNT 5
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act
18 U.S.C. § 1961-1967
Conspiracy to Engage in Racketeering
18 U.S.C. § 1962(d)
(Against Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin)
517. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
518. Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin each agreed to commit
racketeering acts.
519. At a minimum, Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin each
520. Defendants WITCC, J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin each knew the general
86
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 86 of 95
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs request Judgment against the aforementioned
Defendants as follows:
COUNT 6
Violation of the 13th Amendment
Right to be Free from Involuntary Servitude
(Against All Defendants)
521. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
a. Threatening to revoke their J-1 Visas and deport them if they missed a
shift of work.
87
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 87 of 95
b. Threatening them with large amounts of debt owed if they missed a shift
of work.
including:
b. Plaintiffs did not have vehicles to leave, or money for a flight to leave the
country.
525. Defendants also took advantage of the natural isolation that occurred because
526. As a result of these actions, Plaintiffs had no real choice but to work for the
527. Once Plaintiffs were brought to the United States and indebted to
Defendants, they had no real choice but to do the work demanded of them.
Defendants as follows:
88
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 88 of 95
b. Plaintiffs’ cost in this action, including reasonable attorneys’ fees and
costs;
COUNT 7
Fraud
(Against the WITCC Defendants and J&L Defendants)
528. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
including:
Culinary Arts.
530. These representations were false. The Plaintiffs did not receive free tuition,
room and board, or meals, nor did they participate in internships relevant to their fields of
study. Plaintiffs were not offered a two-year degree program in Culinary Arts or Robotics.
531. These representations were material. They induced the Plaintiffs to act by
coming to the United States to pursue their promised degrees through the J-1 visa program.
532. Defendants knew that the representations were false, and that upon arrival in
the United States, Plaintiffs would be placed in low-wage jobs through J&L with Royal
89
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 89 of 95
Canin and Tur-Pak, in a one-year program that would not result in a degree. Defendants
knew that this scheme was not consistent with the requirements of the J-1 visa program.
533. Defendants intended to deceive the Plaintiffs so that they could obtain the
Defendants as follows:
costs;
COUNT 8
Breach of Contract
(Against Defendant WITCC)
536. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
538. The terms of that contract included, but were not limited to:
Arts or Robotics.
90
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 90 of 95
b. Plaintiffs would be provided a scholarship that covered tuition, costs,
539. Plaintiffs fulfilled the terms of the contract. They abided by Defendant
WITCC’s rules for conduct, attended classes, and generally followed Defendant WITCC’s
instructions regarding the interview and application process, in getting their Visas, and
menial, physically demanded jobs, where their labor was entirely to the
91
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 91 of 95
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs request judgment against the aforementioned
Defendants as follows:
costs;
COUNT 9
Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress
(Against All Defendants)
542. Plaintiffs replead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
come to the United States with free tuition, free food, and free room and board, and instead
Plaintiffs.
546. Defendants’ actions were the actual and proximate cause of the emotional
distress.
Defendants as follows:
92
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 92 of 95
a. Actual, compensatory, consequential, and all other allowable damages
costs;
COUNT 10
Violations of Iowa Wage Payment Statute – Deductions from Pay, Iowa Code § 91A
et seq.
(Against Defendants J&L, Tur-Pak, and Royal Canin)
547. Plaintiffs re-plead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
549. There was no valid court order requiring Defendants to deduct wages for
Plaintiffs’ alleged “debt.” Upon information and belief, Plaintiffs did not agree to such a
550. Further, the deduction was not to the Plaintiffs’ benefit, as the purpose of the
551. The effect of the deduction was to hold Plaintiffs in debt bondage/peonage.
552. As a result of Defendants’ practices and policies, Plaintiffs have not received
defendants, to include:
93
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 93 of 95
a. Wages owed;
91A.8;
COUNT 11
Respondeat Superior
(Against Defendants WITCC and J&L)
553. Plaintiffs re-plead the preceding paragraphs as if fully set forth herein.
555. Defendant J&L employed Defendant Albrecht at all times referenced within
the complaint.
556. Under the doctrine of respondeat superior, an employer is liable for the
negligence of an employee committed while the employee is acting within the scope of his
or her employment.
557. Defendants Albert, Yi, Burright, Murrell, Zuerech, and Castro were acting
within the scope of their employment with Defendant WITCC with respect to each of their
558. Defendants Albert, Yi, Burright, Murrell, Zuerich, and Castro were
advancing the interests of Defendant WITCC with respect to each of the actions herein
described.
94
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 94 of 95
559. Defendants Albert, Yi, Burright, Murrell, Zuerech, and Castro used
Defendant WITCC’s resources, facilities, name, and logo with respect to each of the
560. Defendant Albrecht was acting within the scope of her employment with
562. Defendant Albrecht used Defendant J&L’s resources, facilities, name, and
563. Defendants WITCC and J&L are vicariously liable for the actions of their
JURY DEMAND
COME NOW the Plaintiffs and demand a jury trial for all counts pled herein.
Respectfully submitted,
95
Case 5:20-cv-04054 Document 1 Filed 11/25/20 Page 95 of 95