2020 Rwanda Finscope
2020 Rwanda Finscope
Inclusion
Rwanda
2020
1
Acknowledgements
Introduction 9
Background on the Rwanda financial services 9
FinScope Surveys 10
FinScope Rwanda 11
FinScope Rwanda 2020 11
Survey and instrument design 12
Socio-economic profile 13
Money management 18
Knowledge about financial products 18
Access to infrastructure 18
Risk and coping mechanisms 21
Banking account 35
Bank product usage 35
Mobile money penetration 38
Growth in e-money to transact 38
Transactional accounts usage 38
Savings 39
Credit 41
Insurance 44
Mutuelle de Sante 45
Remittances 45
Financial health 47
Financial health indicators include 47
Landscape of access 50
Excluded population 50
Conclusions and
opportunities 52
Priority areas 53
Potential use case: financial services providers (FSPs) 53
Potential use case: policymakers and regulators 53
FinScope footprint 54
KEY FINDINGS
The ultimate aim of policies and strategies for financial inclusion is increased
access to formal financial institutions and increased uptake and usage of
formal financial products and services (i.e. those provided by regulated service
providers). The target of the Government of Rwanda is to increase the proportion
of formally served adults to 100% by 2024.
It is generally agreed that one of the core drivers to an inclusive economy is the
constant fight against poverty and the inclusion of most of the population in the
formal economy. Hence, the importance of a more financially included adult
population is vital as it gives rise to financial stability. As more funds are channelled
and flow in the formal economy, this allows for a more effective monetary stimulus
while helping reduce costs of conducting financial transactions and increase
oversight among other reasons. Given the crucial role of financial inclusion in
the national agenda, priority should be aimed at strategies that increase and
deepen financial inclusion. To do so, it is imperative that these interventions are
specifically targeted, and evidence based. It is in pursuit of this objective that the
Rwandan Government with support from the Access to Finance Rwanda (AFR)
initiated the fourth FinScope 2020 consumer survey.
The first FinScope Rwanda Survey in 2008 was driven by a lack of credible
information to guide policy interventions and financial service providers in their
efforts to expand the reach and depth of the Rwanda financial system. The
decision to implement FinScope Rwanda 2008 was championed by the Ministry
of Finance as the overall custodian of Rwandan’s financial sector.
Similarly, FinScope Rwanda 2020 survey is expected to illustrate how many adult
Rwandans are financially included, specifically aligning the levels of inclusion to the
revised National Financial Inclusion Strategy (NFIS) and also to report any changes
since the last FinScope survey in 2016.
1
Objectives of the FinScope Rwanda 2020 Survey
Methodology
Socio-economic profile
Overview: There are around 7.1 million adults (16 years and older) in Rwanda.
The Rwandan adult population is largely rural based, with 74% (5.2 million)
residing in rural areas. Around 30% of Rwandans are between the age group
of 16 - 30 years. This makes Rwanda a young nation with around 60% of the
2
population younger than 31 years. About 46% of the adults in Rwanda mainly
generate an income from informal sector (including piece work, selling goods) as
well as farming activities (29%) and only about 10% are employed in the formal
sector. Approximately 800 000 adult Rwandans own businesses, recording a
200 000 growth from 2016. Around 53% of these businesses are registered.
The growth in the business owners and the formality of these businesses may
indicate the attention given to developing the micro, small and medium business
(MSMEs). It is widely acknowledged that MSMEs are significant contributors
to job creation, development and economic growth. Given the crucial role of
MSMEs in the national economy, it is in the interest to harness and optimise
on this potential by putting into place strategies to mobilise and enable MSME
growth and development through access to finance and markets.
The business owners (800 thousand) in Rwanda employ a total of 1.2 million
people (excluding the business owners themselves). As such, the sector
contributes significantly to job creation with a total of 2 million people working
in the sector inclusive of business owners. Further it contributes to poverty
alleviation as survivalist businesses play an essential role, especially as a
buffer against slipping into deeper poverty and as such reducing individual and
household vulnerability.
The results also show rapid improvements in access to basic services, such as
the number of households with access to electricity at 42% up from 26% in
2016 and access to pipped water at 54% up from 44% in 2016. Slightly more
households are within the proximity of 30 minutes and less travel distance to
schools and health care facilities. The growth in households accessible to these
amenities (health and schools) are however lagging the population growth of
the country since 2016.
Financial inclusion
In total, 93% (about 7 million adults) in Rwanda are financially included (including
both formal and informal financial products/services). Levels of financial inclusion
vary from 99% in Gasabo district to about 83% in Rusizi district. Gender gap
in financial inclusion is closing with only 8% excluded women compared to 7%
amongst male counterparts. As expected, when comparing seniors and youth,
youth within the age group of 16 – 24 years are financially excluded at 18%
points, significantly higher compared to the national average of 7% exclusion.
Formally served: About 77% (5.5 million adults) in Rwanda have/use formal
financial products/ services, including banking sector and other formal (non-
bank) financial products/services from insurance firms, mobile network
operators, etc. Again, levels vary from 99% in Gasabo district to only 56%
in Burera district. There is clear gender gap in accessing and using formal
financial services, women (74%) are lagging with 7% gap compared to male
counterparts at 81%.
3
Banked: About 36% (2.6 million individuals) of adults in Rwanda are banked
or are using banking services. The proportion of adults that are banked ranges
from 80% in Gasabo district to only 8% in Ngororero district. Women lag
behind men in the usage of bank services, 34% of female adults in Rwanda
use bank services or products versus 39% of their male counterparts. Banked
population growth has increased by 1.1 million since 2016. Bank uptake and
usage seems to be driven by transactional products, as more people (around
900 000) are receiving their income through banking accounts. About 25%
(1.7 million) banked adults use digital payments, this is up from 6% or around
400,000 in 2016. Digital payments have a direct impact on the increased
usage, 68% of bank clients use their accounts on a monthly basis, and this is
up by 16 percentage points since 2016.
Mobile money: About 87% (6.2 million adults) in Rwanda have access to
a mobile phone with females (84%) having lower access compared to men
(90%). Around 3 in 5 (61%) adults use mobile money and more males (68%)
have mobile money accounts as compared to women (56%). Key barriers to
the uptake of mobile money relate to lack of product knowledge and lack of
interest in the product.
Excluded: Only 7% of adults in Rwanda (0.5 million) do not use any financial
products or services (neither formal nor informal) to manage their financial lives,
i.e. they are financially excluded. Levels of exclusion vary considerably across
the country from zero% in Gasabo district to 17% in Gatsibo and Rusizi districts.
As shown here, traditionally vulnerable groups such as the poor, those residing
in remote rural areas, youth, women, and the adult (senior citizen) population
are more likely to be financially excluded.
4
Savings and investments: About 86% (6 million individuals) of adults in Rwanda
save, including all forms of savings. Saving through formal institutions, grew from
49% in 2016 to 54% in 2020. Informal savings grew significantly, reducing high
number of adults saving money at home. People in Rwanda mainly save for living
expenses. Women and young youth (16-24 years) are less likely to save money
through formal financial service providers. Both women and young youth (49%
respectively) are below national formal savings of 54%.
Borrowing and credit: About 76% (5.4 million) of adults in Rwanda borrow
money, including all forms of borrowing. Slightly more females (77%) have
borrowed in the past 12 months compared to their male counterparts (76%).
Same as saving uptake, there has been an impressive increase in formal credit
consumption, however, formal credit remains low at 22%. Formal borrowings
in Rwanda are driven by borrowing from mobile money and SACCO, each with
9% penetration.
Overall, Rwandans show good signs of financial health in four of the six indicators:
that is balancing income and expenses; building and maintaining reserves;
managing existing debts and using effective range of financial tools to manage
financial lives. About 71% adults in Rwanda have strategies to balance their
income and expenses. Strategies Rwandans used include saving excess cash
and borrowing when there is an income gap. Around 63% of adults build and
5
maintain reserves through saving money and investing in assets and businesses.
Amongst the credit active consumers, only 33% showed signs of credit stress
or over-indebtedness. More financially served adults (88%) have 2 or more
financial products portfolio, allowing them to use effective range of financial
tools to manage their financial lives.
The financial health indicator however shows some gaps on planning and
prioritising (time horizon for planning, types of goals, action steps towards
goals) and recovering from financial shocks indicators. The data shows that
Rwandans’ goals and aspirations revolved around improving economic well-
being whether through starting a business, improving shelter, or investment
on education. The steps or devices used towards goals do not show financial
health confidence as majority of adults use informal and non-financial
methods. Minimum usage of formal financial devises may suggest that the
available formal products do not meet consumers’ needs.
The findings of the FinScope Rwanda 2020 survey indicated that the financial
landscape in Rwanda continues to change due to sector interventions. Both
banking and other formal non-bank sectors recorded significant growth
in the number of financially included population, in line to the population
growth and effort to reduce population who previously relied only on informal
financial mechanisms.
The informal sector continues to play a significant role in financial inclusion and
increasing product portfolio choices. Mobile money continues to be an enabler
for financial inclusion and it is used by both banked and unbanked population.
Priority areas
The priorities of financial inclusion in Rwanda continue to ensure that the lives
of Rwandans are improved. To this end, the following areas could be prioritised
in the financial inclusion agenda:
• Adopt Financial Inclusion 2.0 (FI2.0) and embrace a focus towards addressing
real economy needs through better financial solutions. Identify and facilitate
the implementation of the financial interventions that will improve the
resilience and sustainable livelihoods for the target groups (informal sector,
women and youth), as well as enhance the contribution to the macro-
economic indicators for the country
• Develop and expand the roadmaps that will support the implementation of the
emerging thematic areas within the financial inclusion agenda. This includes
expanding the gender and youth financial inclusion pillars within the National
Financial Inclusion Strategy (NFIS) through establishing specific interventions
7
for implementation as well as the inclusion of vulnerable groups, e.g. refugees
and people living with disabilities
• Emphasise the focus on the financial health indicators, quality and impact of
the financial services and come up with specific indicators to monitor these.
The use of digital financial services and economic platforms have the potential
to unlock the opportunities and contribute positively to financial inclusion.
8
INTRODUCTION
Background on the Rwanda financial services
4. Expansion of digital finances - The broad goal envisaged by the NST 1, RNPS
and the SRMP is for a cashless society by encouraging the use of electronic
payments by all residents of Rwanda. Rwanda can be a country in which citizens
use DFS well beyond the currently prevalent person-to-person (P2P) and cash
in and out transactions, by encompassing ecosystems where citizens receive
income digitally, and spend it digitally including at merchant points, schools,
health providers and government payments, as well as eventually e-commerce;
FINSCOPE SURVEYS
FinScope Rwanda
The first implementation of the FinScope survey Rwanda in 2008 was driven by
a lack of credible information to guide policy interventions and financial service
providers in their efforts to expand the reach and depth of the Rwandan financial
system. This decision to implement FinScope Rwanda 2008 was urged by the
BNR as the overall custodian of Rwanda’s financial sector.
In partnership the with Government of Rwanda, AFR initiated the fourth FinScope
survey with an intention to continue measuring progress in the financial inclusion.
FinScope 2020 is expected to illustrate how many adults Rwandan were linked
to financial inclusion specifically formal accounts through different sector
interventions.
After a competitive tender process, the Centre for Economic and Social Studies
(CESS) was selected to conduct the FinScope Rwanda 2020 survey under the
supervision of the steering committee members and with technical support
from FinMark Trust (FMT).
The main objective of the FinScope Rwanda 2020 survey was to:
3 AFR was launched in March 2010 at the request the Government of Rwanda and with support from DFID
and the World Bank. The core objective of AFR is to remove systemic barriers to financial services by putting
the poor at the centre of its interventions.
11
products and services – both formal and informal)
• Describe the landscape of access (i.e. the type of products and services used
by financially included individuals)
• Identify the drivers of, and barriers to, financial access
• Assess trends/changes over time (from 2016)
• Stimulate evidence-based dialogue that will lead to effective public and private
sector interventions in order to increase and deepen financial inclusion
• Provide information on new opportunities for increased financial inclusion
and the extent to which financial services are meeting Rwandans’ needs.
Like the FinScope Rwanda 2016 survey, the current wave (FinScope 2020) was
expanded (with reporting domains at national, regional, urban/rural and districts
levels) to allow for greater data interrogation:
1. Respondent profile
• Universe: adult population in Rwanda
• Rwandan residents 16 years and older
2. Coverage and methodology
• Fieldwork conducted September 2019 to November 2019
• Computer Aided Personal Interviews (CAPI) conducted face-to-face
• Questionnaire reviews included reordering of some questions and the addition
of new questions based on feedback from stakeholders
• Questionnaire in Kinyarwanda and translated into English
• Total of 12 480 interviews conducted
3. Sample and fieldwork validation
• Nationally representative sample
• Sample drawn systematically using Probability Proportional to
Size (PPS) sampling
• Enumerator Area (Villages)-based, 780 Villages (up from 615 villages in 2012)
and 16 interviews per Village were conducted
• Comprehensive Listing in 780 villages – listing 158 386 households
• To identify respondents, two further levels of random sampling:
» Households randomly selected within each sampled village
» Individual respondents randomly selected from sampled households using
the automated Kish grid
• The data was weighted and benchmarked to the 2016/17 Integrated
Household Survey (EICV5)
• The FinScope Rwanda 2020 survey findings were validated and
approved by the NISR
• Data analysis was conducted by the members of the steering committee
and FinMark Trust
12
SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE
Uganda
Eastern province
23%
NORTHERN Kigali city
PROVINCE
22%
EASTERN Southern province
PROVINCE
WESTERN KIGALI 21%
PROVINCE
Western province
20%
SOUTHERN Northern province
PROVINCE 15%
Tanzania
Burundi
with the smallest population of adults being in the Northern Province and the
largest population in the Eastern Province. Other FinScope Rwanda facts include:
• The Rwandan adult population is largely rural based, with 74% (5.3million)
residing in rural areas
• 30% are young adults aged between 16 to 30 years
• The gender distribution of the adult population is skewed in favour
of females (56%)
• A slight decline in the proportion of adults with no formal education or those
who have attained some primary school education. 19% (from 21% in 2016)
of adults have no formal education and about 52% (54% in 2016) have
achieved some level of primary school education but with no secondary school
education. Encouragingly, the proportion of adults with tertiary education has
risen from 2% in 2016 to 6% in 2020
• The percentage of adults with access to piped water in their homes or yards or
access to electricity that could be used for cooking and lighting purposes has
increased, although the majority still have limited access. Fetching drinking
13
water and firewood for cooking purposes is a daily reality in these households
• 80% of adults are from households that are involved in farming activities
• Approximately 42% of the adults in Rwanda generate an income from farming
activities and 12% from farm work wages; 34% earn an income from piece
work. This makes farming and piece work leading sources of income (these
livelihoods are often related to irregular and low levels of income)
• 44% of adults have more than one source of income
• About 10% of adults generate an income from government institutions and
private businesses/companies (5% mention per source)
• 11% of adults are self-employed, meaning that they own businesses. 36% of
them employ 1.2 million people thus creating 2 million employment including
0.8 million owners
26% URBAN
MALE
56% 44%
FEMALE
74%
RURAL
14
• The Ubudehe programme categorises Rwandan households into 4 categories
according to the socio-economic status of the household, with Category 4
households being the most affluent, and households in Category 1 the least.
Based on their self-reported Ubudehe status, only 14% of adults are from
households that fall into Category 1 (these are families who do not own a
house and can hardly afford basic needs). 41% reported that they are from
households that fall into Category 2 meaning that they are families who have
a dwelling of their own or are able to rent one but rarely get full time jobs.
No formal education
19%
Primary education
52%
EDUCATION (%)
Secondary education
22%
Vocational education
1%
Tertiary
6%
Farming Piece work Salary/ Self-employed Salary from Salary from Salary/
wages from (have own Government private wages from
a farmer business) institution business an individual
15
Figure 7: Size, scope & challenges of business owners
64%
Employing 1.2 million people
0.8 million
MSME owners 511,369
individual
entrepreneurs
36%
Creating about 2 million jobs
292,011 including owners
business-owners
with employees
16
17
MONEY MANAGEMENT
As financial products and services are always in constant evolution, it is imperative to offer
financial education among adults. The knowledge level of adults regarding financial products
significantly influences their decisions. Encouragingly, adult Rwandans display high levels of
knowledge for financial products with the most known products being U_SACCO and savings
account with a bank.
U_SACCOs 89%
Saving account with a bank 82%
Medical insurance 77%
Mobile money 72%
Loan account from a bank 64%
MFIs 56%
Bank card 43%
Life insurance 43%
Credit card/bank card 40%
Women banking account 38%
Agriculture insurance 32% Figure 8: % of adults with
Third party insurance 32% knowledge of financial products
Internet banking 26%
Deposit guarantee fund 12%
Credit reference bureau 9%
Access to infrastructure
Proximity to financial services usually gives an indication of how close services are to the
people, and even highlights areas where geographical access is limited. Urban areas usually
have developed infrastructure that supports the access and availability of financial services.
Rural
99% 93% 92%
85% 84% 84% 81% 79% 79% 77%
69% 71%
59%
41%
30% 30%
24% 23% 22%
12% 14% 9% 10% 7%
Mobile School Cell Market Health Umurenge Bank Sector Mobile ATM MFI Insurance
money office care SACCO branch office van branch
agent facility
18
From Figure 9, it can be clearly seen that most access these amenities with reduction from
of the adults in the urban areas travel less 46:46 minutes to 38.86 (SACCO); 52:07 to
than 30mins to get to their destinations with 41.16 (MFI); 53:30 to 42.85 (bank branch);
the closest facility to most being the mobile 53:37 to 41:21 (ATM) and 31:00 to 18:78
money agent, school and cell office. For the (mobile money agent).
majority of the Rwandans who live in the rural
areas, only a few take 30mins on average Notable differences amongst the districts
to get to their desired place with the school with Nyarugenge district having lowest
premises and the cell offices being the closest average time to get to financial institutions
ones. The financial service facility closest (see table 3). Adults in Ngororero on average
to most of the rural population are mobile takes more than 50 mins to get to any financial
money agents and only 1 in every 10 adults in institutions. Targeted interventions per district
the rural areas takes on average less than 30 can yield much resulting in more adults being
mins to get to a bank branch or ATM or MFI. financially included. In all districts, adults
The availability of access points determines generally have access to mobile money agents
whether people will have access or not. ranging between 8 minutes to 34 minutes.
There are major differences among the Overall, this suggests that there are no
provinces and districts worth noting as significant infrastructural barriers to access
presented in Tables 2 and 3. Adults living financial service providers. However,
in Kigali are closer to most of the financial improvements can be made to reduce the
services as compared to other provinces. time taken to reach financial access points
Mobile money agencies are conveniently in areas that exhibit longer distances
located in most of the provinces. Overall, there in order to stimulate ease of access to
has been improvement in reducing time to financial institutions.
UMURENGE
SACCO
21:25 45:38 43:55 41:77 43:42 38:86
BANK
BRANCH
22:78 50:20 49:03 48:06 48:25 42:85
MOBILE
MONEY 8:96 23:62 23:76 22:36 17:49 18:78
AGENT
19
Table 3: Average time taken to destination (in minutes:seconds) by districts
21
Figure 11: Risk or hardship experienced in the past 12 months
22
23
FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK • Formally served: Individuals who have or
use products or services from financial
Financial inclusion: The concept “financial institutions that are regulated through an
inclusion” is core to the FinScope methodology. Act of law (formal financial institutions).
Based on financial product usage, the bankable • Informally served: Individuals who
population is firstly segmented into two groups: have or use products or services from
the ‘financially excluded’ and the ‘financially financial institutions that are not regulated
included’: (informal financial institutions and
Financially excluded: Individuals who manage mechanisms) and/or use community-
their financial lives without the use of any based organisations/mechanisms to save
financial products or mechanisms external to or borrow money.
their personal relationships. If they borrow, • Those individuals who have or use both
they rely on family/friends; and if they save, formal and informal products and services.
they save at home.
Financially included: Individuals who have/ The formally served population can further be
use formal and/or informal financial products segmented into:
and mechanisms. Note: That does not mean • Banked: Individuals who have or use
that these individuals have the products in products or services from licensed
their name. They could also, for example, use commercial banks that are regulated by
someone else’s bank account or be covered by the central/reserve bank.
some else’s insurance. That includes: • Served by other formal financial institutions
24
(non-bank): Those individuals who have The level of financial exclusion has dropped
or use products or services from financial by 4 percentage points:
institutions that are regulated through Acts • In 2020, 7% (0.5 million) adults are excluded
of law but which are not commercial banks. down from 11% (0.7 million) in 2016. About
• Those individuals who have or use products 93% (6.5 million) of Rwandan adults
or services from both commercial banks and have or use formal or informal financial
other formal financial institutions. products or mechanism
Important to note is the fact that there are The reduction in exclusion was caused by a
overlaps in product uptake as one sector might significant increase in the proportion of adults
not fulfil all needs, e.g. a person might have a who are formally served (i.e. who have or use
bank account, an insurance product, and be a product or service from a formal financial
part of a community savings group. Possible institution):
overlaps are illustrated below. • In 2016, 26% of adults were having/using
bank products/services; this proportion
FinScope tools: Main analytical tools used here increased to 36% in 2020. The increase
include the Overview, Financial Access Strand was mainly due to new banking channels
and the Landscape of Access. entering the market resulting in increased
outreach of existing banks
• The uptake of non-bank channel/ services
LEVELS OF FINANCIAL increased from 65% in 2016 to 75% in
INCLUSION IN RWANDA 2020. The increase was caused by an
uptake of products offered by non-bank
formal financial institutions (such as
Mobile money, Umurenge SACCOs and
Figure 13: Overview of financial products/services insurance companies)
uptake by years (%)
Despite the increase in the uptake of formal
financial products, many Rwandans still use
2020
informal mechanisms to manage their money:
2016
• Informal inclusion increased from 72% in
Banked 2016 to 78% in 2020
36% • 81% of individuals who have formal financial
26% products also use informal mechanisms (up
Other formal from 76% in 2016)
(non-bank)
75% Drivers of banking sector
65%
Informal High uptake and usage of banking products
78% has also led to formal financial inclusion. The
72% growth in the banking products or services
Excluded was driven by both savings account and as
7% well transactional products including credit
11% facility products such as credit and overdraft.
25
Figure 14: What drives banking?
Current/cheque 61%
account* 72%
Savings account 60%
at a bank 48%
46%
ATM/debit card 26%
Mobile banking 40%
(M-Banking) 22%
Internet banking 32%
2%
Credit from a bank 29%
(loan from a bank) 13% 2020
2016
Bank USSD codes 24%
Fixed deposit
13% * Please note there has been an
account
increase in absolute numbers from
Overdraft 9% 594 000 in 2016 to 1 045 875 in 2020
facilities 2%
7%
Credit card 1%
About 5.6 million or 78% adults use informal mechanism to manage their finances.
This uptake is driven by informal savings groups:
• 4.2 million adults in Rwanda reported that they use informal groups such as
Village Savings Loan Association:
» 3.9 million adults save through savings group
» 2.8 million borrow money from these savings groups (overlaps possible)
• 2.3 million adults used credit shop (i.e. took goods in advance from the shop
and paid back later)
Savings 82%
group 79%
Shop 42% 2020
credit 47% 2016
58% 31% 6% 5%
28 Urban
20% 44% 24% 12%
Rural
are financially included compared to 98% of 87% financially included women in 2016
the urban population. The formal inclusion (versus 91% males).
in the urban areas is largely driven by the • There are still differences in the type of
high uptake of banking
22% services14whilst
% in access41women
% and men have, 16% men are
7%
the2020
rural areas its mostly driven by SACCOs more likely to use formal financial services
12%
and mobile money. 14% 42compared
%
21% a -7% gender
to women, creating 11%
• The2016
gender gap continues to narrow down gap in access and uptake of formal financial
in 2020 with 92% of women financially services/products.
Banked
included (versus 93%Banked (OTC)compared
males) Othertoformal (non-bank)
• Figure 25 showsInformal
thatonly
mobile Excluded
money
58% 31% 6% 5%
Urban
20% 44% 24% 12%
Rural
73% 22% 3% 2%
Urban
23% 48% 20% 9%
Rural
29
and Umurenge SACCOs played a more • As displayed in Figure 26, high uptake
significant role in pushing out the boundaries of formal products or services is driving
of formal financial access for adults receiving inclusion among all age groups with the
livelihoods from farming and informal sector. mobile money pushing out the boundaries
• However, there are disparities and levers that for the 16-24 year olds and 25- 30 year olds.
should act to enable a broader inclusion of • Young adults between the ages of 16 –
the population: 24 years remain are more likely to be
» Informal economy unbanked and excluded.
» Dependents from other people (mainly
youth between age of 16 – 24 years
» Incoming from farming
98% 2%
Category 4*
46% 37% 12% 5%
Category 3
28% 45% 19% 8%
Category 2
25% 43% 20% 12%
Category 1
*Kindly note that the banked population figures for category 4 (from 57% in 2016 to 98% in 2020) are not
stable due to small sub-sample sizes.
31
Comparing Rwandan access strand to other countries where FinScope surveys have been
conducted (Figure 27) show that:
• Rwanda is in position 3 when the countries are ranked by financially included adult population
Access strand through the districts’ lenses (Figure 28 and 29) shows that:
Figure 27: % Comparison of the Rwandan Access Strand with that of other countries where FinScope surveys
have been conducted – ranked by financially included
94% 1%2% 3%
1 Seychelles 2017
81%
10 %
2% 7%
2 South Africa 2019
36% 41% 16% 7%
3 Rwanda 2020
85% 3% 2% 10%
4 Mauritius 2014
40 %
43%
6% 11%
5 Kenya 2019
52% 33% 2% 13%
6 Swaziland 2018
38% 23% 20% 19%
7 Lesotho 2011
11% 42% 26% 21%
8 Uganda 2018
68 %
5
%
5%
22%
9 Namibia 2017
30% 39% 8% 23%
10 Zimbabwe 2014
50% 18% 8% 24%
11 Botswana 2014
13% 49% 7% 31%
12 Tanzania 2017
40 %
9 %
15
%
37%
13 Nigeria 2018
25% 13% 21% 41%
14 Zambia 2015
34% 7% 15% 44%
15 Ghana 2010
27 %
7
%
15 %
51 %
16 Malawi 2014
12%
24 %
12 %
52%
17 DRC 2014
20% 4% 16% 60%
18 Mozambique 2014
32
Figure 28: Access Strand by districts above national average of 77% adults formally served
80% 19% 1%
Gasabo
78% 20% 2%
Nyarugenge
78% 17% 2% 3%
Kicukiro
36 %
49 %
13%
2%
Rulindo
36% 47% 15% 2%
Nyanza
40 %
43 %
14 %
3%
Ruhango
33% 49% 11% 7%
Kayonza
36 %
45 %
12 %
8%
Rubavu
17% 63% 14% 7%
Nyabihu
24% 56% 13% 7%
Ngoma
32 %
48 %
13%
7%
Rwamagana
32% 47% 16% 5%
Bugesera
27 %
51 %
14 %
9%
Kirehe
Figure 29: Access Strand by districts below national average of 77% adults formally served
Banked Other formal (non-bank) Informal only Excluded
35
Figure 31: Proportion of adult population that are banked by districts (%)
Gasabo 80%
Nyarugenge 78%
Kicukiro 78%
Ruhango 40%
Nyanza 36%
Rulindo 36%
Rubavu 36%
Kayonza 33%
Rwamagana 32%
Bugesera 32%
Kamonyi 30%
Huye 28%
Nyagatare 28%
Kirehe 27%
Gatsibo 26%
Ngoma 24%
Muhanga 23%
Musanze 23%
Nyamagabe 22%
Nyamasheke 21%
Rusizi 21%
Nyaruguru 19%
Nyabihu 17%
Gicumbi 16%
Rutsiro 16%
Gisagara 15%
Gakenke 15%
Karongi 14%
Burera 13%
Ngororero 8%
90% 6% 2% 1% 1% 1%
Figure 36:
81%
Digital payments
56%
Digital
payment in 30%
the past
12 months: 70% YES
NO
Bank Mobile Money
account account
37
Mobile money penetration digital finance providers, governments and
the economy; notwithstanding a number of
When considering what drives the usage of issues still persist which, if addressed, can
mobile money accounts it is important to do make digital finance work better for individuals,
this by looking through the consumer lens, businesses and governments. The digital
as we seek to understand what the triggers, finance issues discussed in this section are
drivers and barriers to unlock usage are. About relevant for the on-going debate and country-
87% of adults in Rwanda have access to a cell level projects directed at greater financial
phone with females (84%) having slightly less inclusion via digital finance in developing and
access compared to their male counterparts emerging economies.
(90%). About 3 in every 5 (60%) adults (see
Figure 34) use mobile money. • Approximately 30% (2.1 million) of
Rwandans transacted or made digital
• Amongst the services available to the users payments in the past 12 months prior to
of mobile money are money transfers, airtime the survey up from 18% (1.1 million) in
purchases and bills payments. Only 23% of 2016. More people transacted through bank
the Rwandan adult population use the mobile accounts (see Figure 36)
money to pay for services including buying • Third party payments and those who
airtime, saving and to borrow money receive their income digitally are the main
• About 2.7 million (38%) of mobile money drivers of e-money.
users use it for remittances ONLY
• Figure 35 shows that of those not using Transactional accounts usage
mobile money, the key barrier to uptake
relate to the lack product knowledge • Mobile money account is widely used, 58%
about mobile money. of the users transact 3 or more times on
a monthly basis
Growth in e-money to transact • Though MM is used more frequently,
encouraging digital payments could
Digital finance and financial inclusion have strengthen the impact.
several benefits to users of financial services,
Mobile Money
account 58% 23% 17% 3%
Savings are the leading product type and one of the main drivers for financial inclusion for the
entire Rwanda and this is encouraging as savings are the doorway to enabling adults to create
wealth, pay for household furniture and equipment and most importantly, enabling adults to
use savings as collateral for accessing credit.
In constructing this strand, the overlaps in savings product/services usage are removed:
The study sought to find out the proportion Figure 42: Credit overall (%)
of adults that borrow money or use credit to
finance capital purchases, daily consumption 2020
or other needs like agricultural inputs. In Banked 2016
8%
Rwanda, 76% of adults have borrowed in the 4%
past 12 months and the credit overall uptake
revealed the following: Other formal (non-bank)
18%
13%
• 8% of adults borrow from the bank (up by
Informal
4 percentage point from 2016) 61%
• 18% of adults have formal credit facilities 61%
from non-bank financial institutions Family & friends
• Credit from the informal groups (such 30%
as savings groups, use shop credit and 32%
moneylenders) remained at 61% Not borrowing
• Slightly fewer adults (30%) claimed to have 23%
borrowed from family and friends. 28%
Bank Other formal (non-bank) Informal Family & friends Not borrowing
In constructing the credit strand, the overlaps in financial products/services usage are removed
Figure 44: Sources for credit and reasons for borrowing (%)
Bank product
8% 2020
4% 2016
MFI
4%
2%
Mobile Money
9%
3%
Umurenge SACCO
9%
5%
Employer
1%
6%
Informal groups
39%
41%
Moneylender
1%
3%
Shop credit
33%
34%
Farmers association
2%
6%
Family and friends
30%
32%
Business/investments 22%
Education/school fees 16%
Building/improving dwelling 14%
Buying land/dwelling 14%
Emergencies (excl. medical) 12%
Living expenses 8%
Medical expenses 4%
Paying off other debt 3%
Farming expenses 3%
42
Figure 46: % of adults who have been refused a loan
NO 80%
NO 26%
YES
20% 74%
YES
Did not have No reason Had too many Did not have Income too Other
security communicated other debts down payment low
/collateral
43
INSURANCE
17% 83%
2020
9% 91%
2016
Medical insurance
41%
66%
Rwanda Social Security Board (CSR/RSSB)
32%
37% 2020
Life insurance 2016
23%
12%
Third party insurance
9%
12%
Private pension
13%
11%
Credit life (insurance linked to a loan)
11%
11%
Household insurance
9%
5%
Agriculture insurance
1%
4%
44
Mutuelle de Sante
REMITTANCES
2% 41% 2% 55%
2020
1% 39% 3% 57%
2016
Bank Other formal (non-bank) Informal Family & friends Not remitting
45
46
FINANCIAL HEALTH can access and use those tools to acquire,
move, and store funds as well as and grow
Financial health is a relatively new term in their assets)
the financial inclusion community, aiming to
provide a model for assessing how well one’s Overall, Rwandans show good signs of financial
daily financial systems enable a person or health in four of the six indicators: that is
household to build resilience to shocks and balancing income and expenses; building and
pursue opportunities and dreams. maintaining reserves; managing existing debts
and using effective range of financial tools to
Financial health indicators include manage financial lives.
Balances income and expenses (success in • About 71% adults in Rwanda have strategies
shaping income and expenditure in order to to balance their income and expenses.
meet daily needs and financial obligations) Strategies Rwandans use include saving
Builds and maintains reserves (this indicator excess cash and borrowing when there is
captures the behaviour of intentionally or an income gap (see Figure 51).
habitually putting away assets, as well as the • Figure 52 shows that around 63% of
magnitude of assets immediately available) adults build and maintain reserves through
Manage existing debts goals (this speaks to saving money and investing in assets
how manageable current formal and informal and businesses.
debt are, and what resources a person can call • Figure 53 shows that amongst the credit
upon through formal and informal sources) active consumers, only 33% showed signs
Plan and prioritise (improving and maintaining of credit stress or over-indebtedness
financial health requires active and intentional • More financially served adults (88%) have
engagement, including activities such as 2 or more financial products portfolio,
planning and prioritisation) allowing them to use effective range of
Recover from financial shocks (how well a financial tools to manage their financial lives
person can leverage financial resources to (see Figure 54).
weather and recover from an economic shock)
Effective range of financial products (the • The financial health indicator however shows
indicator assesses how well an individual some gaps on planning and prioritising (time
Figure 51: Balancing income and expenses (%) Figure 52: Build and maintain reserves (%)
INCOME NON-FINANCIAL
/NOTHING
25%
29%
37% NO
47
Figure 53: Managing existing debts (%) Figure 54: Range of financial tools to manage
financial lives
76%
67%
57% Financial product
portfolio
33% 31%
12%
NON-
30%
FINANCIAL
49%
INFORMAL
21%
Figure 56: Main goal (%) FORMAL
50
Figure 60: Landscape of access –
formally served
Transactional
39%
Savings
Remittances -32% points
56% 71%
-53% points
Insurance Credit
22% 28%
Table 6 gives an overview of the characteristics of adults neither using formal nor
informal mechanisms indicating that financially excluded population is most significantly
skewed towards (vulnerable groups):
51
TOTAL
POPULATION (%) EXCLUDED (%)
Marital status
Never married 22 47
Married 60 33
Living together 5 3
Divorced/Separated 3 5
Widowed 10 12
Physically challenged
Have disability 19 25
Source of income
Salaried 8 0
Wages from farmer 10 8
Money from farming 29 26
Piece work 24 37
Level of education
No formal education 19 32
Primary 1-3 12 17
Primary 4-6 40 36
Secondary 1-3 11 10
Secondary 4-6 11 4
University or other higher education 6 1
Vocational training 1 1
Ubudehe category
Category 1 13 21
Category 2 40 45
Category 3 46 33
Category 4 1 0
52
non-bank sectors recorded significant Potential use case: financial services
growth in the number of financially included providers (FSPs)
population, in line to the population growth
and effort to reduce population who previously • Financial health measurement can be a
relied only on informal financial mechanisms. tool for improving product design and
strategy development.
The informal sector continues to play a • Improve financial health through high-
significant role in financial inclusion and quality and consumer-centric products.
increasing product portfolio choices. Mobile • Use research results/indicator to modify
money continues to be an enabler for financial product suites, improve functionality,
inclusion and it is used by both the banked and or adapt distribution methods, all with
the unbanked population. the ultimate goal of better serving their
existing clients, as well as growing
Priority areas their customer base.
Tunisia
Nepal
Pakistan
Egypt India
Myanmar
Laos
Sudan
Burkina Thailand
The Gambia Faso
Cambodia
Nigeria Ethiopia
Benin Cameroon
Uganda
Togo Kenya
Ghana DRC Rwanda
Cote d’Ivoire Burundi
Tanzania
Repeat cycle
Mozambique First cycle
Zambia
Potential first cycle
Zimbabwe Madagascar
Namibia Underway
Botswana
Swaziland
Mauritius
South Lesotho
Africa
Twitter: Linkedln:
54
@AFRwanda https://www.linkedin.com/mwlite/company/afrwanda