Methaforming Process Description en A4
Methaforming Process Description en A4
Convert
semi-regen CRU
for á profit, Êàáåëüíûå ëîòêè
â emissions
100õ100ìì
Ïîäîãðåâàòåëü Ï-3
à Ñâå÷à ðàññåèâàíèÿ
Ãðàäèðíÿ ÃÐÄ-50Ì
s s .
îãðåâàòåëü Ï-1
e p r o c e
Ïîäîãðåâàòåëü Ï-2
i b l Standalone
Ðàìïà àçîòíàÿ
n e f l e x
O t i o n s .
a p p l i c a mini-refinery
Many
Ìîäóëü ðèôîðìèíãà
Á-1
Process up to
200k tpa FRN
to serve extra
demand
Upgrade
mixed low octane
naphtha streams
Table of Contents
Objective and Limitations. Process Overview ....................................................1
Feedstocks ........................................................................................................2
Types of naphtha
Alcohols and Light Olefin Feeds .......................................................................4
Products ...........................................................................................................5
Process Overview
Methaforming is a catalytic process that makes The key features of the Methaforming process
a motor gasoline or gasoline blendstock by joint that determine its applicability and economics
processing of two components: are:
1. Naphtha: straight-run gasoline, gas • Flexibility with regard to the qualities
condensate and other similar types of of the feedstocks opens up highly profi-
naphtha feedstocks (main feed), and table opportunities to make valuable
2. Ethanol, methanol, other alcohols or products from low value feeds, in some
ethers, light olefins and their mixtures (co- cases amounting to a “waste to energy”
feed). operation. See Feedstocks for more details.
• Superior capital and operating efficiency,
The typical products of Methaforming are: especially at 5 000 bpd (200k tpa) or less.
• Gasoline or gasoline blendstock The smallest profitable Methaformer
(Methaformate) with standard-compliant operates at about 50 bpd (2k tpa), the
sulfur and aromatics content. The yield of largest currently under design is 12k bpd
Methaformate is 75-92% of the naphtha (480k tpa). See Process Description.
feed* with 85-95 RON driven by operator • Reduced carbon footprint and ability to use
economics. The process conditions can ethanol as co-feed for gasoline production,
be tuned to produce a concentrate of giving the operators in certain geographies
aromatics (benzene-toluene-xylene, BTX) additional benefits from carbon credits (see
instead of gasoline blendstock. Process Description).
• Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) and pure • Ability to produce standard-compliant RON
butane, which may be separated from the 90-92 gasoline in a single unit, including
LPG. sulfur and benzene reduction, makes
• Hydrogen rich gas (HRG) or simply fuel gas. it possible to run a Methaformer as a
standalone unit or as a capacity extension
in an existing refinery.
Types of Naphtha
The feed requirements are presented here in This list of possible naphtha feeds is not
a condensed form, for the most frequently exhaustive.
encountered feeds (condensate, virgin naphtha).
If a feed meets the requirements of Table 2,
Methaforming has been successfully used to then it can be a candidate for Methaforming
process the following hydrocarbon feeds: regardless of its origin. A decision regarding non-
• straight-run gasolines (virgin naphthas), conventional hydrocarbon feeds may require
including full range, light, and heavy detailed information on their composition,
naphthas, including various impurities and catalytic poisons.
• gas condensates, The yields and qualities of the products of
• natural gasoline, Methaforming depend on the qualities of the
• pyrolysis gasoline, feeds.
• raffinates from aromatics extraction units,
• light FCC naphthas (with 20-25% wt. of Olefins in the feed increase gasoline yield and
olefins), octane. Caution needs to be exercised with dienes
• benzene-rich naphthas (up to 10% vol. of that may cause coking. Thanks to the inhibitory
benzene in the feed), action of water formed during the conversion
• narrow fractions of C6-C7 hydrocarbons of alcohol co-feed, the presence of olefins has
(boiling range 60-85оC), a lesser effect on the regeneration cycle of the
• light naphthas and solvents (up to 30% catalyst than would be expected otherwise.
vol. of C5 components), including those of
synthetic origin (e.g. the products of Fischer- The presence of sulfur compounds up to
Tropsch process, known as GTL naphtha). 1000 ppm in the feed can be tolerated by the
2
Methaforming catalyst while reducing the cycle If present in the feed, CO and CO2 do not affect
length from 30 to about 20 days. The presence of the process.
nitrogen compounds (amines and basic nitrogen
compounds like pyridine), fluorine, and organic As an illustration, we discuss the processing of
aldehydes and ketones may lead to temporary full range naphtha (FRN) as the primary feed for a
poisoning of the catalyst. In general, the feedstock Methaforming unit, jointly with ethanol.
should not have more than trace quantities of
alkali or amines. The catalyst activity is recovered Typical qualities of popular naphtha feeds are
by routine in situ regeneration. shown in Table 3.
Methanol and ethanol are typical oxygenates for An oxygenate feed may be replaced or combined
the Methaforming process (hence the name). with light olefins e.g. ethylene, propylene,
However, the process can also accept mixtures of butylene (Aroforming process). Ethylene
these and other alcohols, simple ethers, including contained in the FCC dry gas is a very low cost
dimethyl ether, and alcohol-water mixtures as the replacement for purchased alcohols. The FCC dry
co-feed. The process can accept methanol and gas would need to be cleaned up as is typically
ethanol solutions with up to 50% wt. of water done before it enters the fuel gas system. If
(Table 4). We can also assess the possibility of this gas mix is used as a feed, the ethylene and
using industrial byproducts with high methanol propylene will be reactively extracted in the unit
or ethanol content as co-feeds to Methaforming while the other hydrocarbon components of the
process. gas (e.g. hydrogen, methane, ethane) would pass
through the unit unreacted.
Examples of such byproducts that were
successfully used in the Methaforming process
include the output fractions of the alcohol- Table 4. Alcohol co-feed specifications
making process that are lighter or heavier than Dimethyl ether, wt% Not limited
the intended product (e.g. ethanol or butanol). Water, wt % < 50
Such byproduct co-feeds have the dual advantage Alkali content calculated as ammonia, < 30
of low alternative value and the “waste to energy” ppm wt
aspect which may allow the operator to claim Sulfur content, ppm wt max < 100
additional environmental credits.
4
Products
Methaforming product streams:
1. The primary product is Methaformate, a gasoline blendstock. Its typical qualities are shown in
Table 5 below. The Methaformate is stabilized for required RVP.
2. The second product is hydrogen-rich gas (HRG), shown in Table 6. HRG is separated in the
3-phase separator. Due to the low concentration of C1-C2 and carbon oxides of
<5% wt, H2 purity of 95-97% vol can be obtained. The HRG can be routed to the existing refinery
gas sweetening system.
3. The third product obtained upon stabilization of Methaformate is LPG (also showin inTable 6). If
needed, it could be routed to an existing Merox treater.
Table 5. Typical Qualities of Methaformate from Full Range Naphtha.
Indicator Naphtha Feed Methaformate
Boiling range, % vol. evaporated °С (oF)
5 50 (122) 43 (109)
10 59 (138) 51 (124)
50 103 (217) 109 (228)
70 118 (244) 128 (262)
95 146 (295) 171 (340)
Final boiling point,°С (oF) 180 (356) 215 (419)
Saturated vapor pressure SVP, kPA 89.6 62
same, psi 13.0 9.0**
Relative Density (Specific Gravity), kg/L 0.73 0.75
RON 70 89.6
n-paraffins, % vol. 25.8 11.9
iso-paraffins, % vol. 29.9 33.1
naphthenes, % vol. 36.3 22.2
olefins, % vol. 1.2 5.2
aromatics, % vol. 6.8 27.0
incl. benzene, % vol. 0.5 0.8
Total sulfur, ppm wt.* 100 10
Table 6. Sample composition of LPG and fuel gas (with 100 ppmw of sulfur in the feed).
Content, % wt.
Component
LPG Hydrogen-Rich Gas
H2 0.4 10.0
H2O 0.2 1.3
C1-C2 2.1 6.4
C3 51.8 34.3
C4 42.9 29.6
C5+ 2.6 18.3
H2S 0.02 (200 ppm) 0.09 (900 ppm)
Total 100.0 100.0
* Indicative values typical for this feed and for the resulting products.
** Data from a specific sample test. Like RON, product RVP is an operator-driven design parameter,
set to meet the local regulations and operator priorities.
5
Process Description
Process Chemistry
Naphthas from different sources vary greatly in The content of fused-ring aromatics (e.g.
their hydrocarbon composition and therefore naphthalene) in the product remains below 0.5%.
in the ease of conversion in isomerization
and reforming, as well as, in Methaforming. The occurrence of the endo- and exothermic
Methaforming will convert most of the normal reactions in the same vessel translates into
paraffins, naphthenes and olefins to isoparaffins, a significant economic and environmental
and aromatics. advantage of Methaforming over the traditional
methods of naphtha processing due to the
There are numerous chemical reactions that reduced reheat duty. For example, with the
occur during the Methaforming process. Some of FRN+ethanol feed combination, the need for fuel
these reactions are highlighted here. gas in Methaforming is 0.58 gCO2/MJ, or about 1/5
of the corresponding number for the traditional
Upon contact with the catalyst, alcohol yields a reforming and isomerization suite (3.2 gCO2/MJ).
corresponding alkyl radical in a highly exothermic
reaction of alcohol dehydration. The heat of this The water formed in the alcohol dehydration
reaction supports the subsequent endothermic becomes steam that reduces coke formation on
dehydrogenation of naphthenes (see diagram the catalyst, ensuring a longer catalyst cycle.
below; for simplicity, shown with methanol co-
feed). Every step in the pathways is an equilibrium
reaction and hence the products of the conversion
The alkyl radical from alcohol dehydration can process will depend on process parameters.
alkylate aromatic groups, e.g. converting most Table 7. Example of The Aromatics Shift.
of benzene to toluene, xylene and C9 aromatics % wt. Naphtha feed Methaformate
(see Table 7), or react with itself to make longer- Benzene 0.5 0.9
chain radicals, further converted to higher olefins Toluene 1.5 5.7
and aromatics.
C8 aromatics 2.5 10.7
Olefins in the feedstock follow a conversion C9 aromatics 1.5 5.8
pathway similar to the alcohol. Newly formed C10 aromatics 0.5 2.0
aromatics can be further alkylated; paraffins C11 aromatics 0.2 1.1
and naphthenes can be further converted to C12 aromatics 0.0 0.7
isoparaffins and aromatics. Total 6.7 26.9
CH3
Dehydration:
H releases 135 kJ per kg
H C O H + + H O H (283 BTU per lb)
H of naphtha*
Methanol Benzene Toluene Water
H3C H H Dehydrogenation:
H H
CH3 + absorbs 129 kJ per kg
H H
H H (269 BTU per lb)
of naphtha
N-hexane Cyclohexane Benzene Hydrogen
* Assuming 28.3%wt. share of alcohol co-feed.
16
Illustrative Process Flow Diagram and Description
Fuel Gas
AC-2
ST S-3 LPG
To GFU
GC-1
Water
HE-4
AC-1
S-1
P-4
P-3
Water
Steam
Е
F-1
Naphtha HE-1 AC-3 Condensate water
T Methaformate
P-1
P-2
Process operating conditions
Air • Temрerature, reactor inlet: 350-420oC (662-788°F).
F-2 • Catalyst bed temperature: 330-400oC (626-752°F).
Nitrogen HE-3 • Reactor pressure: 0.3-0.9 MPa (44-130 psia).
GC-2 • High-pressure separator: 0.5-1.2 MPa (72.5 - 174
To atmosphere
psia).
• Space velocity, volume: 0.7-2 h-1.
AC-4
S-2 • Pressure drop over the catalyst: <0.1 MPa (<15
psia).
Water
• Octane number of the Methaformate is regulated
with either co-feed fraction or reactor temperature.
The design provides for the joint processing of fied and decanted in S-1. The aqueous layer is
feedstock supplied by pump P-1 (naphtha) and sent to water treating and hydrocarbons go to
by pump P-2 (alcohol). pump P-3. From there, the hydrocarbon product
is preheated in heat exchanger HE-4 and directed
Heating and vaporization of naphtha and alcohol to stabilizer ST.
are performed sequentially in the recuperative
heat exchanger HE-1 and furnace F-1. The stabilized Methaformate is withdrawn from
the bottom of stabilizer ST. The Methaformate,
After heating to 360-430°C (680-806°F), the after cooling in HE-4 and air cooler AC-3 to 45°C
gaseous feed mixture is fed into reactor R-1 or (113°F) is routed off-site via product tank T.
R-2 which operate alternately (~800 hr on feed
and ~50 hours of regeneration). The catalytic The overheads of stabilizer ST are cooled in air
process occurs in the reactor converting alcohol cooler AC-2 and fed into the reflux drum S-3,
and naphtha into Methaformate (gasoline which is a three-phase separator. Uncondensed
blendstock). vapors from the S-3 are routed to the fuel system,
and the water is discharged to wastewater
The reaction products at a temperature of 360- treating. The liquid hydrocarbon product is a
430°C (680-806°F) go to the tube side of the propane-butane fraction, which goes to pump
alcohol heat exchanger HE-2 and then are cooled P-4 and is returned to stabilizer ST as reflux with
further in heat exchanger HE-1, followed by air the balance off-site as LPG.
cooler AC-1. The reaction products cooled to
35oC (95°F) are then separated in a three phase The diagram and description above are simplified
separator S-1. Gas (HRG) from S-1 is fed to the off for the ease of comprehension. The actual
gas compressor GC-1, then sent offsite. process flow and equipment for a specific case
may differ and include significantly more than is
The liquid phase of the product stream is strati- shown above.
7
Applications and Economics
The flexibility of Methaforming with respect to For example, a new 5k bpd Methaformer
the acceptable feeds and operating capacity would cost $25m in USGC prices (ISBL, 2019)
translates into a wide range of situations where to build, and can be expected to generate
the process can be the optimal choice for an $21m of annual gross profit under USGC
operator. Examples of such applications include: long range prices. The use of a modular
build of a Methaformer in such situation can
• Conversion of a semi-regenerative catalytic make its deployment easier to the refiner.
reformer or a hydrotreater in front of it
into a methaformer. Such conversion can • Upgrading assorted low-octane naphtha
improve the product yield and – depending streams. Many refiners have assorted low-
on the source of co-feed and local regulations octane naphtha streams that are too small
– may allow the operator to claim a to justify further processing via conventional
financial credit for reducing CO2 emissions. means. Such streams are either blended
For example, a conversion of a 860k tpa into the gasoline pool or sold as low value
(20k bpd) semi-regenerative reformer solvents or petrochemical feeds. Raffinate
that processes heavy virgin naphtha with from the aromatics extraction unit is a classic
ethanol, operates in a jurisdiction where example of such stream. Methaforming
carbon credits can be traded and where the with its tolerance to mixed-molecule feeds
management makes economic decisions can be a very profitable and capital-efficient
based on the US Gulf Coast (USGC) long way of increasing the octane number of
range prices, would translate into a $17m such feeds by ~30+ units (e.g. from 60 to 90)
additional annual gross profit ($15m/year with the corresponding step-up in value.
yield improvement, and $2m/year carbon The profitability of such upgrade will be
credits*). The value of the carbon credits even higher if olefins from dry FCC gas are
in this example assumes that the co-feed used as co-feed (Aroforming process).
is carbon-neutral and has no impact on
the overall CO2 emissions of the process**. • Standalone mini-refinery. An energy
Given the similarity of process conditions of entrepreneur with access to economically
Methaforming to hydrotreatment, the cost priced naphtha and/or an appropriate
of such a conversion can be estimated at inexpensive co-feed can operate a
$15m, translating into a payback period of Methaformer very profitably. For example,
just under a year. processing a condensate or full range
naphtha with 100 ppm sulfur content will
• Serving incremental demand for gasoline result in a gasoline product with ~10 ppm
at 100-5000 bpd (40-200k tpa). When a sulfur and will require – depending on local
refiner sees an opportunity to sell up to 5k conditions and regulations – a relatively
bpd (200k tpa) additional gasoline after all inexpensive OSBL setup. We have seen an
debottlenecking opportunities have been example where an entrepreneur was able
exhausted, they should consider using to locate the feeds with such prices that
Methaforming. Reforming and isomerization resulted in a gross processing profit from
have much higher capital cost per ton or Methaforming of $400 per ton (~$45/bbl).
barrell of feed or product and typically Modular Methaformers can be successfully
require higher operating capacities to justify used in such applications; two models can
the investment. Adding a Methaformer in be ordered from us at this time, of 20k tpa
such situation is a capital-efficient solution (500 bpd) and 6k tpa (150 bpd) naphtha
with a much quicker payback period. processing capacity.
General features of the Methaforming process: The reaction of converting the naphtha together
with alcohol and/or olefins to produce high
• Share of co-feed (alcohols, ethers, olefins) octane gasoline is carried out in a fixed bed, gas
can range from 15 to 50% of the naphtha phase reactor.
feed;
• RON of Methaformate: 85-95, can be Overall enthalpy change of the reaction mixture
managed by changing the reactor inlet during the reaction is small i.e. inlet and outlet
temperature and/or the ratio of co-feed to temperature are comparable. This is because the
naphtha; dehydration of alcohol is highly exothermic, while
• Long cycle length (up to 33 days) and the dehydrogenation of naphthenes is highly
operational life of the catalyst (3-5 years); endothermic.
• Inexpensive non-precious metal catalyst;
• Similarity to hydrotreatment process, with In general, throughout the catalyst bed, it is
similar equipment costs, and a possibility for desirable for the temperature to remain within
a low-cost revamp of an existing hydrotreater ±15°C (27oF) of the design value.
or reformer into a methaformer;
• When feed requirements are observed, the A multi-bed reactor with divided input of alcohol
products do not contain components that to the beds is used to maintain a satisfactory
may lead to gumming; temperature profile.
• Produces hydrogen-rich gas (HRG) for use in
other refinery units.
Service Factor
9
Catalyst Regeneration of the Catalyst
The Methaforming process uses a zeolite catalyst The regeneration of the catalyst is carried out with
designed for producing high-octane hydrocarbon nitrogen-air mixture. The nitrogen-air mixture is
fractions (gasolines, their components, aromatic compressed by compressor GC-2 and heated to
hydrocarbon concentrates), from low-octane 350-550°C (662-1,022°F) in heat exchanger HE-3
hydrocarbon fractions, with a co-feed of oxygen- and furnace VH-2, and then fed to the reactor
containing compounds (alcohols, ethers), and/or R-1 or 2. Exhaust regeneration gas containing
olefins. nitrogen, carbon dioxide and water is cooled in
exchanger HE-3 and air cooler AC-4, wherein a
The catalyst is in pellet form consisting of a high- portion of the water condenses and is removed
silica zeolite of the pentasil group and a binder in separator S-2 with the gases discharged into
containing silica and/or alumina. The zeolite the atmosphere or scrubbed.
is promoted using salts of zinc and rare earth
elements. The expected cycle time is from 33 days (800
hours) to 17 days (400 hours) minimum,
Table 8. Properties of the Catalyst. depending on the feed qualities and operating
conditions. The amount of coke on the surface of
Type of catalyst proprietary,
the catalyst at the beginning of the working cycle
zeolite-based
is 0.3-0.5%wt., and at the end of the cycle, up to
Loss during calcination at < 5.0 10%.
650°C, wt. %
Bulk density, kg/m³ ~ 640 Regeneration is typically carried out within 2
Strength index, 1.5 days, depending on the circulation rate and the
kgf/mm diameter amount of coke on the catalyst. The temperature
during catalyst regeneration grows from 280
Granule diameter, mm 2.0 – 4.0
to 510 °C as the oxygen concentration in the
Particles <1 mm in < 0.5 circulating nitrogen/air mixture is increased from
diameter, wt%
1.5% to 18%.
Utility Requirements
The operator will need to have access to standard refinery utilities per the diagram on the facing page.
Approximate requirements for such utilities per unit of naphtha feed are shown in Table 9.
10
Nitrogen 99.9% Plant effluents
disposal
Air control
equipment Storm water
drain
Air for Methaforming unit
regeneration Regeneration gas
vent stack
Electricity ISBL
Emergency flare
Fuel gas system
Condensate
Steam HP water
In general, there are two streams of waste gases: The water production is 39% wt. of the ethanol
1. Combustion gases from feed preheater, and co-feed (56% wt. of the methanol co-feed).
2. Gases from catalyst regeneration (produced
in the process of burning coke during The qualities of the effluent water are presented
regeneration). in Table 10 below.
The Methaforming process uses significantly Alcohol content in the produced water is typically
less fuel (1/5 to 1/7) than the traditional suite nil and always <0.5% wt.
of refining units that is used to process naphtha
(hydrotreater and dehexanizer, catalytic reformer This reaction water from the separator can
and isomerization unit, benzene removal unit). be directed to a crude desalter or to offsite
wastewater treating.
Solid waste
Table 10. Quality of Reaction Water Under
Under routine operations, no solid waste is Standard Process Conditions.
generated. Periodically, solid waste is generated Alcohol, ppm <5
when replacing spent catalyst in the reactor.
Benzene, ppm <1
Spent Methaforming catalyst containing traces
Other hydrocarbons, ppm 10-50
of naphtha generally may be sent to industrial
landfill upon neutralization. H2S, mg/L 0.01-0.10*
A typical process to bring Methaforming to your site involves the following steps:
2. Feed testing.
We have an extensive test library which allows us to forecast the product yields that can be
expected from processing a wide variety of possible feeds. However, in many cases we recommend
testing your specific feed(s) in one of our pilot plants to validate our expectations. Should this be
necessary, a typical series of five tests will cost you $10k, plus the cost of delivering the sample
to our lab. If you are interested, you are welcome to witness the testing in person. Duration of
the testing depends on how busy our lab is at the time; we usually suggest budgeting about four
weeks for this stage.
* Note to the back cover: compared to 3.2 gCO2/MJ for traditional naphtha processing.
Simple one stage process
Tolerant to feed qualities
• Straight-run • Light FCC naphtha,
gasoline (virgin • Benzene-rich naphtha,
naphtha), • Narrow fractions of C6-C7,
• Gas condensate, • Light naphthas and
• Natural gasoline, solvents including GTL
• Pyrolysis gasoline, naphtha,
• Raffinate from • Mixes of the above.
aromatics
extraction unit,
0.6 gCO2/MJ*
Naphtha up to 85%
Gasoline
LPG
RON 90-92
Fuel Gas
Alcohol up to 50%
• Ethanol,
• Methanol, • Mixes of these,
• Propanol, butanol including
and heavier byproducts of
alcohols, alcohol production,
• Ethers, with up to 50%
• Light olefins, water content.
NGT Global AG
www.ngt-synthesis.com
Synthesis