Chapter 1-5
Chapter 1-5
Chapter 1-5
INTRODUCTION
person's body shape or size. (Oxford Learner’s Dictionary, n.d.). It happens when
someone is made to feel shame for his or her body image and or body size. Usually,
this occurrence is associated with being overweight, or not being pretty and handsome
enough versus the ideal image of a certain individual that has been set and portrayed
by the social media. (Ramirez, n.d.). It also goes by the name of fat-shaming or “the act
of criticizing or drawing attention to someone for being fat, making them feel
body-shaming only happens to overweight or obese people. “But it can also happen
towards people that are thin.” (Dsauza, n.d.). As Jenkins (2015) puts it, “Body shaming,
thin shaming, fat shaming, weight shaming—all of these phrases sum up one idea: that
our body does not fit the ideal standard, and we should feel badly about it.”
1
Media and technology are said to be the main culprit why this culture is being
encouraged and continues to rise. “Magazines constantly offer tips about how to lose
weight ‘in days,’ appear slimmer ‘instantly,’ and hide our ‘imperfections’… without
actually knowing anything about us, much less our appearance.” (Vargas, n.d.). Body
shaming issues are growing; hence most women are being deprived of their body type
and image based on how social media portrays the ideal and perfect body of women.
Andrew (2012). “Sitcoms so frequently use overweight characters’ bodies as the basis
of many of the show’s jokes”. (Ibid). These shows teach people that it is okay to
comment on other people’s weight and shape and give people a narrow standard of
beauty in the society. Messages and comments from social media “often imply that we
should want to change, that we should care about looking slimmer, smaller, and tanner.
And if we do not we worry that we are at risk of being the target of someone else’s
body-shaming comments.” (Ibid). People do not realize the impact of such comments on
whoever is hearing those words because it has become a normal occurrence and has
long been ingrained in the society. "Our culture has this very pro-thin, anti-fat ideal. We
associate having a smaller body size with success, beauty, popularity. With being a
larger size, these individuals are being portrayed as lazy, disgusting and unmotivated."
(Cravens, n.d.). Research shows that much of the social media discussion about
obesity involves fat shaming, which often turns into harassment and cyberbullying,
especially against women. (Chou, et.al, 2014.) “Self-esteem is (also) put into question
when people become the target of body shaming.” (Kazmi, 2017). Self-esteem, as
Feldman (1985) defines it, “is the evaluation of how person value and how he or she
gives importance to himself.” Every person has a self-esteem and it is either high or low
2
self-esteem. (Johanna, 2008.) When a person is subjected to body-shaming, he or she
begins to lose confidence and start to feel insecure. And when one feels insecure or has
low self-esteem, it “can lead to distorted thoughts and emotions about their bodies and
negative thoughts about body image and self-worth.” (“Low self-esteem,” n.d.) Low self-
esteem among adults can are also said to cause eating disorders, early sexual activity,
some as part of the Filipino culture. “Any girl who grew up in a Filipino household knows
a thing or two about being body shamed by family members or relatives. Whether it is
being called names (taba, payatot) (fat, thin) or getting called out for your size or shape
(‘ang laki laki mo na,’ ‘para ka nang toothpick’) (‘you’re so big’, ‘you look like a
toothpick’) our parents, titos and titas, (uncles and aunts) and lolos and lolas
that they hate us or deliberately want us to feel bad about ourselves. It is just that, it is
sadly become part of our culture.” (Agner, 2017.) Filipino-American blogger Erica Dawn
Waters shared in her blog how her relatives barrage her with comments about her body
whenever she comes visit the country. As Waters (2017) put it:
3
ka 'you got fat' as they simultaneously squeeze my 'arm fat.' My
excitement for coming home instantly fades, and I immediately want to
hop on the next America-bound flight—I know that this is just the
beginning of a summer filled with unsolicited commentary pertaining to
my body.”
Award-winning international actress and singer Lea Salonga has been quite
vocal about her experiences of being body-shamed in the past and how body-shaming
is considered bullying. “I say this as someone who, throughout my career, has been
called fat to my face”, Salonga was quoted. (Guno, 2018). She further revealed that
she has had rough comments about her body even at a young age. “I do remember
some of my mom’s friends telling [me] that once I turned 12, I had to start dieting (I was
a chubby kid). I wasn’t a large teenager, but I was already in show business and took it
upon myself to stay in shape and look good. Once I got to college though, I put weight
on. And then when Miss Saigon happened, the pressure to look a certain way was
great. It wasn’t just about looking good, but looking right.” (Waters, 2017). Another
Filipino celebrity and Miss World 2013 Megan Young also added that “Commenting on
someone’s weight as a conversation starter just completely ends it.” (Young, 2017).
These women sharing their experiences about body-shaming despite being on top of
their games is quite alarming. It only proves that despite their successes, “women
one can feel, body shaming comments still cut.” (Guno, Ibid.)
The aforementioned is the same reason why the proponent of this research was
prompted to explore this study. She had an unfortunate share of being bullied during
her adolescent years that drove her self-esteem down. The author recognizes that,
4
although this problem is beginning to gain public’s attention on an international level, it
is still virtually ignored in her chosen locale - Pulilan, Bulacan. Pulilan, Bulacan is a first
class municipality in the province of Bulacan, Philippines. “Many years ago, Pulilan was
primarily a little-known rural town in the northern part of Bulacan where its economy
heavily dependent on farming and poultry raising. Most of the population committed
their entire lives on farming as their livelihood. Today, the town is moving towards
area and center of commerce and industry in the province.” (”Pulilan”, n.d.) However,
the economic growth the town is harnessing does not appear to be evident on the
richness of knowledge its people have about the phenomena of body shaming and its
effect on a woman’s self-esteem. The culture of body-shaming still thrives in this part of
the country. Gab Samson, a 24 year-old resident of Pulilan, shared her story of being
body-shamed by her classmates while doing her report in front of the class. She
added, “Sobrang napahiya ako. mga ilang days ako hindi pumasok. Until one day I
decided not to finish my school na, dahil nagsanga sanga na ung mga pangaasar nila
sa akin below the belt na talaga ayun, hindi ko na kinaya. I choose to stay at home.” (I
was extremely embarrassed. I did not go to school for several days. Until one day, I
decided not to finish school because the problem had fanned out. Their teasing had
become below the belt and I could not take it anymore.) Samson further said that the
incident led to her “depression”, refusal to go out of their house and deactivation of her
social media account. Another native of Pulilan, Camille Santos, 25 years old, also
relayed her body-shaming story saying, “When I was in high school, sobrang taba ko
nuon tapos maitim pa ko kaya lagi talaga ako tinutukso sa school, lalo na din kapag
5
may family reunion kami inaasar ako ng mga pinsan ko na ang laki laki ko daw.” (I was
really fat and dark-skinned when I was in high school that is why I was constantly
teased. My cousins would also tease me during family reunions saying I look huge.)
She continued, “sobrang napapahiya ako lalo na kapag pinupuna nila ung laki ng tyan
at braso ko. minsan naiiyak ako kasi parang ayoko na pumasok ng school or
nahihiya na ako humarap sa tao.” (I felt really embarrassed, especially when they
point out how big my stomach and arms are. Sometimes I get teary-eyed that I do not
want to go to school. More often than not, I do not involve myself in school activities
because I do not like to face people.) Xami Sumulong, 25 years old, also from Pulilan,
flat-chested. Sumulong mentioned that she became self-conscious after the incident.
She became hesitant in posting pictures on the said social media platform because she
is afraid that people might comment something again about her body. These
testimonies prove that this atrocious culture still happens and the researcher, hence,
recognizes that there is a need to raise attention and understanding about the people’s
6
Statement of the Problem
This study was conducted to identify and assess the implications of body
shaming to one’s self-esteem. This study sought to answer the following questions:
a. Age
b. Educational attainment
5. What recommendations may be drawn, based on the results, that will help
against body-shaming.
This study sought to accomplish the following objectives to assess properly the
7
1. To know the demographic profile of the respondents.
5. To draw recommendations based on the results that will help respondents who
Theoretical Framework
antecedent to dejection in youthful young ladies (Grabe, Hyde and Lindberg, 2007).
Shame is a solid and socially determined passionate express that could prompt a
negative attribution style and accordingly may foresee the beginning of sadness
Roberts 1997) was utilized to shape the plan of the present investigation, which
inspected this relationship over the grown-up life expectancy for the two ladies and men
stoutness (Darby et al. 2007; Stice 2002; Wiederman and Pryor 2000). Hence, we
8
the heading of the connection between body dissatisfaction and worldwide assessments
of self-esteem decays with age for either or the two sexes, in the wake of representing
encounter for some female teenagers and ladies, and all the more as of late, male
young people and men (McCabe and Ricciardelli 2004a; Tiggemann and Lynch 2001).
For sure, emergency clinic inaction for body disappointment and dietary issues, and the
requirement for proceeded with long haul mental and physical consideration for eating
the general wellbeing framework (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare 2007; Pratt
of body disappointment over both sexual orientation and age, and the Australian
Federal Government has made body dissatisfy-group and related issues a need territory
for research (Ellis 2009; Roxon 2008). It is inside this setting the present venture was
embraced. In this paper, the researcher aims to find out the Impact of body-shaming to
Objectification Theory
In this study the researcher used Objectification theory to clarify how a culture
may add to ladies and young ladies having a troublesome association with their body, in
this manner promoting psychological well-being issues. This theory can help to
9
understanding how living in a society that places an unjustifiable emphasis on physical
attractiveness for women and relentlessly objectifies them, can lead to body
This theory gives a structure to see how living in a general public that places an
unnecessary focus on physical engaging quality for ladies and externalizes them, can
Related research has also provided some support for the contention that middle-aged
women report fewer body image-related concerns than do college age women, which
may suggest less self-objectification (Cash, Winstead, & Janda, 1986; Pliner, Chaiken,
&Flett, 1990). As women become aware that external evaluation of their appearance is
how others will judge their appearance and subsequently treat them (Grabe, Hyde &
Lindberg, 2007).
Self-Esteem Theory
A few analyses (Webster and Tiggemann 2003) have indicated the decrease in
the significance one credits to appearance over the grown-up life expectancy,
contending this may fill in as a cushion against the evil impacts of appearance
concerns. Such a clarification may likewise represent the decrease in the pervasiveness
of dietary problems with age (Heatherton et al. 1997; Tiggemann and Lynch 2001).
Then again, there is proof to recommend that the impact of body disappointment on
For example, Tiggemann and Stevens (1999) analyzed the quality of relationship
10
between confidence and body disappointment crosswise over various age bunches in
Australia and found that the relationship was more grounded in ladies matured 30 to 49
years than in more youthful ladies. In another Australian investigation, Webster and
Tiggemann (2003) found that the connection between confidence and body
disappointment was more grounded for ladies matured 35 to 49 (the 'middle age'
disappointment were equivalent for ladies in the youthful adulthood and middle age
gatherings, and that this relationship was not-huge in the more seasoned grown-up
significance and confidence in people in the US, each assembled in age by decades
(20– 29, 30– 39, and so forth up to the age of 79). She found that dimension of body
disappointment and size of the connection between body demeanors and confidence
did not shift as a component of age or sexual orientation. Strangely, Wilcox likewise
discovered that self-perception significance in this example did not change over the
grown-up life expectancy, proposing that self-perception significance may not really
decay with age. These discoveries are steady with Fredrickson and Roberts' (1997)
attestation that age-related changes in body disappointment (and its effect on emotional
In spite of the fact that most of concentrates that have assessed the connection
scientists have executed longitudinal plans so as to explore the directional idea of this
11
relationship. Tiggemann (2005) assessed dimensions of body disappointment and
isolated by 2 years. She found that body disappointment at Time 1 anticipated change
disappointment. Discoveries from Paxton (2006) ponder, which was likewise inside an
may change over the distinctive periods of life. In spite of a steady negative relationship
between confidence and body disappointment crosswise over sexual orientation and
age gathering, Paxton and partners found that underlying body disappointment was
prescient of subsequent low confidence 5 years after the fact in early-immature young
ladies and mid-juvenile young men, yet not in mid-youthful young ladies or early-pre-
Conceptual Framework
based on the results that may help the respondents who experienced body shaming
and to raise awareness and campaign against body shaming. In order to realize its goal,
the researcher made use of the Input-Process-Output (IPO) framework. An IPO diagram
is useful when trying to get a result or output as it gives details of the input i.e. the
materials and information required, instructions of the process, and the by-products
resulting from the process. Box 1 is the Input where the researcher established the
respondents and the self-esteem level of the respondents. Box 2, on the other hand,
12
discusses how to researcher gathered data which is by distributing questionnaires to
adolescent women in Pulilan, Bulacan. Finally, Box 3 presents the output of the whole
study which is structuring recommendations and guidelines that will help those who
Research Paradigm
c. Personal
income/
Family Income
13
body shaming of
respondents
4. Is there a significant
relationship between the
level of body-shaming
and the level of self-
esteem of the
respondents?
14
Significance of the Study
The result of the study is beneficial to the following because it will help these
groups or individuals to assess the impact of body shaming on one’s self-esteem better;
The Respondents. The findings of the study will serve as an additional source of
information for various individuals, particularly women who are experiencing body
shaming; as such, the findings of the study will also give them useful insights on how to
one committed in giving health services to the community. They can use the results of
this study to design information drives as to the effects of body-shaming; thus helping
The Students and Future Researchers. The study will serve as an additional
The general purpose of this study is to find out the impact of body-shaming on
decided to choose adolescent women for the study since adulthood is “a period that
15
method, a non-probability sampling technique which is used in choosing participants
who are accessible to the researcher. The researcher believed that this type of
sampling was appropriate for the study since the selected respondents were the ones
available at the time the survey was conducted. The survey was done in different public
places in Pulilan such as schools, barangay halls and public markets. A total number of
250 participants were chosen for this study. Based on the estimated data released by
20,300 registered voters in the area and 0.2 %, or 40.6, of them women who are aged
18 to 25. (See Annex 1.) The researcher decided to have a larger sample size of 250
participants, to have a more statistically significant data and less probability that the
results will happen by mere coincidence. (“Sample size,” n.d.) The study was conducted
16
Definition of terms:
and their thoughts about what they look and how the society can accept them and can
Body Shaming – happens when someone is made to feel shame for his/her
bachelor’s degree.
Undergraduate - a person who has reached college but did not finish or
17
Chapter II
Body image
Developing and nurturing a positive body image is considered part of a healthy mental
combination of how we perceive ourselves about basic looks and how we react
emotionally in certain situations (Sloan 2006). Many studies of the US in 2016 that
factors, fewer have specifically examined body size satisfaction. Most of the research
has focused on women and found that lower body mass index (BMI), increasing age,
and better health are generally positively associated with body size satisfaction. Women
typically view themselves as heavier than they actually are and desire a thinner figure,
with more reporting dissatisfaction with their bodies than men in the same BMI category.
A person's body image is influenced by their beliefs and attitudes. One's body
image does not remain the same, but changes in response to lifestyle events (Women's
interpersonal skills and positive relations with other boys and girls". For instance,
"physical attractiveness has been found to impact on peer relationships all the way back
from elementary school, with attractive girls engaging in more positive social
18
They found a strong association between body image concerns and low self-esteem
among adolescent girls, which has led to constructions of body image as an important
aspect of female self-esteem (Davidson & McCabe, 2006). Having a negative body
image may be a contributing factor to poor self-esteem (Perez et al. 2003) and this will
result in Body dissatisfaction that tends to center around body size, weight, and shape
through body shame relates to these and to different parts of ladies' typified selves
(Schooler, Ward, Merriwether and Caruthers, 2005). People “are trained early on to
which then leads to shame. And as Miceli, et. al (2018) puts it, “shame is an unpleasant
self.” also Brown (n.d.) plausibly meant when he said that “Shame is that warm feeling
that washes over us making us feel small, flawed and never good.” For a person,
especially a woman, being told that a piece of clothing looks strangely on her is
decidedly shameful as “women’s shame generally centers on appearance and the need
According to Pesa, Syre, and Jones (2000), females may first experience the
well-being may be negatively impacted (Pesa et al., 2000). And this will result in the
adolescent women to feel shame about their body, wherein according to Bartky (1988)
Shame is an involuntary reaction to the belief that the self is inherently flawed and
19
impetus behind intense body shame. It is correlated with puberty (Stice, 2003) and
predicts depression in women and girls (Stice, Cameron, Killen & Taylor, 2000) and as
a result, likely play a powerful role in understanding the increase in female depression
connection between the impact of the media (social, advanced, and so on.) and the self-
reasoned that the web is the most often utilized media by the respondents. Related
research has also provided some support for the contention that middle-aged women
report fewer body image-related concerns than do college-age women, which may
suggest less self-objectification (Cash, Winstead, & Janda, 1986; Pliner, Chaiken, &
Flett, 1990). Further, the effects of body dissatisfaction does not appear limited to
behaviors in adolescents and young adult women (Barker & Galmbos, 2007; Clark et al,
2005; Johnson & Wardle, 2005; Neumark-Sztainer, Paxton, Hannan, Haines, & Story,
2006). The years from 18 – 25 years old are the time where internal and external
changes, including brain changes, propel young adults from adolescence toward full
Body Shaming
Shame is an emotion that occurs when individuals evaluate themselves relative to some
internalized or cultural ideal but do not measure up (Lewis, 1992). Individuals who
20
experience shame tend to attribute their shortcomings to global aspects of the self
(Tagney, Miller, Flicker & Barlow, 1996). It is a believable indicator of what Kite et. al.
(2013) discussed that shame is a cruel and powerful motivator as well as a demotivator.
A person only needs to be aware of what shaming is. “Once we identify and learn to
recognize what shame looks like and sounds like in our own lives, we can work to reject
Shame is also laced with moral and social judgments that both the self and
others make. Those who do not conform to conventional beauty and weight ideals are
seen as violating a social standard and are perceived as lacking in self-control and
moral discipline (Crandall, 1994). It is also driven by one’s feelings toward their body is
a similar yet distinct situation from body dissatisfaction. Kaufman (1996) discussed that
“to feel shame is to feel seen, acutely diminished—which is also supported by the
person’s typical wish to disappear and tendency to hide.” (Ausubel, 1955; Calhoun,
2004; Wollheim, 1999) say that shame “coincides with a mere fear of others’
Engeln (2017) discussed, is the “normal” feeling for women to struggle with body
shame. It is the feeling of women that even though other people do not necessarily do
anything to them, they feel ashamed even by a mere glance, and that feeling of despair
is just a part of being a woman. While both body shame and body dissatisfaction
encompass an individual’s negative thoughts and emotions toward their body, shame
has a wider meaning. Body dissatisfaction tends to focus on body size, weight, and
21
shape whereas body shame pertains to these and to other aspects of women’s
Tangney et al. (1996) further added that shame is characterized by the desire to
hide and escape because nothing can be done immediately to repair the damage to
one's image and relational value. But apart from this, It is also important to note that
body-shaming does not affect all women equally. The observer's perspective can
become internalized to varying degrees, and variables such as class, ethnicity, age,
sexuality, personal history, and physical attributes make each woman different
(Fredrickson & Harrison, 2005; Quinn, Kallen, Twenge, et al, 2006). Women find ways
from revealing their bodies so that It would be prevented from being noticed
(Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997), or by having a high awareness of their bodies potential
outward appearance she will notice if it does not match her ideal, and awareness of this
discrepancy is a precursor for feeling body shame (Bessenhoff & Snow, 2006)
However, when traditional standards of thinness are internalized, instead of, or possibly
in addition to, strength and power, many women experience a greater amount of body
shame. Shame is especially strong when there is a large discrepancy between what a
person looks like and what she wants to look like (McKinley & Hyde, 1996).
Self Esteem
22
peers, family members, teachers and society and general (Huang et al,2007). Every
person has self-esteem and it is either high and low self-esteem and one can also
maintain and choose what esteem that they can have for themselves, according to
Johanna (2008). Crocker and Wolfe (2001) agreed that we can have higher self-esteem
if we have a positive view and outlook for ourselves. If we always feel that we have
worth, we can also live in a more productive way and we can be a more effective person
in a society we live because we are confident and we believe of our worth. While Frost
and McKelvie (2005), define self-esteem "as the level of global regard one has for the
self". It does contribute to poorer body image and eating disorder symptoms and studies
are still trying to figure out how to hinder adolescent girls' beliefs that they need to be
extremely skinny to look attractive. Adolescent girls can also have low self-esteem
appearance has consistently been found to be the number one predictor of self-esteem
at many ages" (Ata, Ludden, & Lally, 2006). According to Rosenberg (1965), "self-
esteem is defined as a "positive or negative attitude toward the self". When a person is
insecure. And when one feels insecure or has low self-esteem, it can lead to distorted
thoughts and emotions about their bodies and negative thoughts about body image and
self-worth.” (“Low self-esteem,” n.d.) Low self-esteem among adults can are also said to
cause eating disorders, early sexual activity, substance use and suicidal thoughts.”
(Kazmi, Ibid.)
23
In some cases, there is a kind of self-esteem that can be seen as positive but
about how good you feel about yourself as a person (Leary, M. R, 2004). This happens
when a person lacks a sense of competence but do have a sense of worth, which
causes them to rely on feeling worthy for their self-esteem. The result of such
psychological lop-sidedness means they need others to approve them. If such approval
is withdrawn, or if they are criticized because of poor performance, they may feel inferior
superior (Mruk, 2018). Dr. Kristin Neff argues that there is a problem with society’s
focus on high self-esteem. The problem is that this focus involves measuring oneself
against others, rather than paying attention to one’s intrinsic value. “Our competitive
culture tells us we need to be special and above average to feel good about ourselves,
but we can’t all be above average at the same time,”. In this sense, searching for self-
Women nowadays feel empowered and more accepting of their body image.
Many celebrities, both local and international, advocate self-acceptance and denounce
setting standards on how one should look. These “group of actresses and public figures
have taken another road, one that is significant and that leads to acceptance of our own
bodies rather than follow a “beauty standard” without questioning it.” (Chavarria, 2017)
In fact, Filipino celebrities like Lea Salonga, Bela Padilla, and Jessy Mendiola advocate
actress Iza Calzado was shamed after posting a photo of her wearing a swimsuit where
24
internet users commented on her “big thighs” and “cellulite”. Instead of feeling ashamed
quipped, “However, the point is not about comparing your body to mine just to make you
feel better but for us to accept that we are who we are and as long as we are spreading
love and light, we will get that in return,” she added. “Wear what you want! Be free and
happy because you are worthy of that!” (“6 stars who,” 2018.)
Frost and McKelvie (2005) said that there was a positive relationship between
qualities and the dependent variables considered together, but that it was only
significant for self-esteem and body build, not for body image or weight satisfaction.
Also, the study suggested "that a higher level of positiveness awareness about their
good qualities is associated with a higher level of self-esteem, and this relationship
occurs for female elementary school, high school, and university students" (Frost &
McKelvie, 2005). With all the definition and domains available, self-esteem can be
deemed as high when one feels good about the domains he believes is important for
himself. It is even considered that people with high self-esteem are satisfied with the
type of person they are (Shaffer D.R et al.2008). Various factors affect the self-esteem
of adolescents, but there are good reasons to propose that changes in body image may
be crucial for understanding this trend. In this study, the researcher also relates the
on social comparisons. (Chip, et.al. 2011). The more that a person compares herself
with others based on appearance, the more that that person feels diminished (Heather,
et.al,2004) especially if she falls short or inferior with the comparison. Appearance-
related social comparison, on the negative side, can cause the decline of an individual's
25
self-worth and value. Heather et.al (Ibid) further discussed that women who measure
Henderson-King (1997) found out that women who had lower self-perceptions of
images of women in the media. It indicates that women’s importance according to her
beauty might be one of the reasons that women feel more pressure to look physically
socialized to believe that appearance is an important basis for self-evaluation and for
individuals make evaluations about their appearance through comparisons with similar
others. Those women who suffer body dissatisfaction often associate their failure to
reach their ideal body with their self-concept and as a result of this often suffer from a
Fredrickson and Roberts (1997) stated that many women begin to feel emotions
such as shame towards themselves because they are unable to achieve the desired
body image they want. This failure to meet society's perception of normal often leads to
shame and a decrease in self-esteem. Body dissatisfaction can occur if the target of
Crowther, 2009). It was also noted that the impact of society, parents, and friends,
improved the prediction of body dissatisfaction, low self-esteem, and the importance of
appearance (Griffiths & McCabe, 2000). Also, Davidson and McCabe (2006) concluded
26
that their study showed evidence for the association between psychosocial difficulties
and poor body image. Dr. Mulgrew (2013) also said that most women generally had a
good idea that images in fashion magazines were somewhat artificial, they’re been
and self-worth are inextricably linked, such that perceived appearance consistently
emerges as the strongest single predictor of self-esteem among both male and female
adolescents (Huang et al,2007). The people around us are also a great factor that can
affect our self-esteem, how they treat us on how they see us and how they accept us
according to Johanna (2008). This image develops through the things that they can or
cannot do and by how other people see them (Hogan & Strasburger, 2008).
This review of the related literature of this kind may contribute to a better
among Adolescent Filipina women in Pulilan, Bulacan. from this study, the researcher
was able to provide important information about the description of Body Image, Body
Shaming, and Self-esteem all about. These studies guided the researcher to
women in Pulilan, Bulacan for better understanding of the study. This related literature
provided vital information about the background of the main topic discussed in this
27
appropriate programs and awareness to alleviate conditions associated with Body
28
Chapter III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Introduction
details with regards to the method that was used in undertaking this research as well as
Research Design
("Convenience Sampling", 20019). The researcher believed that this type of sampling
was deemed suitable for the study since the respondents selected were the ones
representative to conduct the study in the chosen locale. The representative went to
several barangay halls, schools and other public places look for respondents who were
willing to partake in the study. The representative gave a brief explanation as to how
and what the survey will be about and sought for the consent of the participants. Using
29
Google forms, the respondents were asked to answer survey questions about body-
shaming and self-esteem. Their answers were then collected for data treatment and
interpretation.
Research Instrument
The researcher utilized two sets of questionnaire in conducting this study. The first was
developed by Weingarden et al. (2016). It contains situations that people may encounter
in day-to-day life followed by three situations that correspond to the three subscales:
body-shame, body guilt and externalization blame. However, since the researcher’s
goal is to get the body-shaming level of the respondents, only the answers pertaining to
body-shame scale were collated and interpreted. The respondents’ answers to the other
two subscales were disregarded. The complete questionnaire can be read in Annex 2.
widely used in social-science research. It is a 10-item scale that measures global self-
worth by measuring both positive and negative feelings about the self. All items are
answered using a 4-point Likert scale format ranging from strongly agree to strongly
disagree. Higher scores indicate higher self-esteem. (“Self Report Measures,” n.d.)
30
Population and Sampling
Women who are within the range of 18 to 25 years old were chosen to take part
in the study. The researcher chose adolescent women for the study since adulthood is
“a period that brings sometimes tumultuous physical, social, and emotional changes” on
the questionnaire discreetly so as to protect their privacy. A total of 250 women were
tapped for this study. Based on the estimated data released by Commission on
registered voters in the area and women who are aged 18 to 25 comprises 0.2% of the
total registered voters or 40.6. (See Annex 1.) The researcher decided to cast a larger
sample size of 250 participants, to have a more statistically significant data and less
probability that the results will happen by mere coincidence. (“Sample size,” n.d.)
Treatment of Data
respondents were tabulated and analyzed using the following statistical methods.
2. Weighted Mean. This statistical tool was used to determine the overall
31
3. Likert Scale. This statistical tool was used in measuring the respondents’
and its effect on their self-esteem. Likert (1932) developed the principle of measuring
32
Chapter IV
Introduction
This chapter presents the results of the data gathering conducted for the study.
The researcher used a quantitative design in finding out the impact of body-shaming on
the self-esteem of young women in Pulilan, Bulacan. The researcher used two sets of
questionnaire for her data gathering. The first was an adapted questionnaire called
(2016). It contains situational questions that people may come across in their daily life.
The questions are followed by three scenarios that correspond to three subscales
namely: body-shame, body guilt and externalization blame. Since this study targets
solely the body-shaming level of the respondents, the researcher focused and
questionnaire to gain information about the self-esteem level of the respondents. Using
Convenience Sampling as the data gathering procedure, 250 Filipino women were
questionnaires in different public places such as schools and barangay halls. The
33
Methods of Data Analysis and Presentation of Data
data gathered. The data were presented by showing the frequency as well as the
Discussion of Findings
Table 1
18 30 12
19 31 12.4
20 36 14.4
21 37 14.8
22 22 8.8
23 36 14.4
34
24 23 9.2
25 35 14
The researcher tapped women who are emerging adulthood or those who are
aged 18 to 25 (Shaman, n.d.). The three biggest age groups among the participants
were 21, 20 and 23 which has a percentage of 14.8%, 14.4% and 14.4% respectively.
On the other hand, the least age group was 24 which comprises 9.2% of the
respondents. The figure substantiates the report presented by Yahoo health survey
saying that women do not hit body positivity until they reach the age of 35 to 54. (Miller,
2016). Hence, from age 13 when young girls receive their first body critique (Ortiz,
2017) and as they go through their adult lives, women experience a fairly consistent
body negativity as a result of body shaming. The said survey, which was conducted
among 2,000 participants in the US, further showed that 94% of teenage girls admitted
Table 2
College Graduate 80 32
35
The data gathering further shows that majority of the respondents, or 101
participants, have reached college but have not finished their degree with a percentage
achievement. Body shaming has been said as a foremost cause of low body image.
And the lower or more negative one’s body image is, the lower his or her self-esteem
becomes (Jung and Lee, 2006.). Low self-esteem then leads to poor academic
behavior, poor grades, school absenteeism and even dropping out of school. As Shore
(n.d.) puts it, “Low self-esteem can lessen a student's desire to learn, her ability to
focus, and her willingness to take risks. Positive self-esteem, on the other hand, is one
of the building blocks of school success; it provides a firm foundation for learning."
Table 3
PHP 10,000-19,999 70 28
36
The information collected by the proponent also shows that 35.2% or 88
respondents have a meager monthly income of Php 1,000 to Php 9,999. This is
followed by participants, 70 of them, who receive Php 10,000 to Php 19,999 or 28%.
This is followed closely by respondents who receive Php 20,000 - 29,999 and those
who get Php 30,001 and Up with a percentage of 27.2% and 9.6% respectively. Low
condition which inflicts physical problem on people. Having a minimal amount of money
means skipping meals and eating cheap but unhealthy foods. Poverty also becomes a
stressor that triggers people to develop dangerous vices such as smoking and drinking
which can cause obesity and other health problems which then can lead to experiencing
body shaming. With majority of the respondents earning a mere Php1,000 to Php 9,999,
which is below what National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) claims to
be what a Filipino family needs to live (Malasig, 2018.), it is safe to say their economic
determinant of health; as a general rule, wealthy people tend to be in better health than
people of poorer status.” “Some might find the comparison between getting out of
poverty and losing weight absurd. And it is—because losing weight is even harder than
getting out of poverty.” (Winters-Miner, Miner, 2015). As Goldberg (n.d.) puts it, poverty
The succeeding tables show the answers of the respondents gathered from
(2016). It presents situations that people may encounter in their daily life. The original
37
questionnaire contained three scenarios that correspond to three subscales which are
body-shame, body guilt and externalization blame. However, since this study’s focal
point is on the body-shaming level of the respondents, the researcher only interpreted
the answers pertaining to body-shaming. This is to ensure that the presentation of the
results is clear and organized. The complete questionnaire can be reviewed in Annex 2.
total of 111 respondents answered that they would “somewhat likely” feel diminished in
their image of themselves. 59 of them chose “somewhat unlikely” feel a dwindled self-
image. The rest of the participants, 51 and 29, answered “very unlikely” and “very likely”
The high turnout of respondents saying that they would “somewhat likely” feel
(1996) discussed that “to feel shame is to feel seen, acutely diminished—which is also
38
supported by the person’s typical wish to disappear and tendency to hide.” The
Calhoun, 2004; Wollheim, 1999) say that shame “coincides with a mere fear of others’
You go to the mall, and everybody seems better looking than you.
question “You go to the mall, and everybody seems to better looking than you.” A total
of 101 respondents said that they would “somewhat likely” feel awful that they would
want to hide. 76 of them said that they would “somewhat unlikely” feel terrible of the
situation. The rest of the participants, 53 and 20, answered “very unlikely” and “very
likely” respectively as to wanting to hide because of feeling terrible due to the given
situation.
The majority of the respondents, 101, who answered that they would "somewhat
likely" feel diminished in their image of themselves if someone close to them expresses
39
(Chip, et.al. 2011). The more that a person compares herself with others based on
appearance, the more that that person feels diminished (Heather, et.al,2004) especially
if she falls short or inferior with the comparison. Appearance related social comparison,
on the negative side, can cause the decline of an individual's self-worth and value.
Heather et.al (Ibid) further discussed that women who measure their self-worth based
You are walking down the street and notice that people are glancing in your
direction. You feel certain that they are judging your appearance.
Table 6 shows the compiled answers of the respondents to the question, “You
are walking down the street and notice that people are glancing in your direction.” 142
of the respondents answered that they would think that they are hideous and should
duck inside and hide. On the other hand, 61 participants chose that they would
“somewhat likely” think they are abominable. The other participants, 37 and 10,
answered “very unlikely” and “very likely” respectively as to the possibility of feeling
hideous if people would glance at her while walking down the street.
40
The high number of turnout of participants who answered that they would
“somewhat unlikely” think that they are hideous and that they would duck inside and
hide should people glance their direction, is an unexpected result that contradicts most
studies about body-shaming and self-esteem. It is a believable indicator of what Kite et.
al. (2013) discussed that shame is a cruel and powerful motivator as well as
demotivator. A person only needs to be aware of what shaming is. “Once we identify
and learn to recognize what shame looks like and sounds like in our own lives, we can
work to reject its harmful motivating/demotivating influence.” Kite (Ibid) added. Hence,
some respondents of this study chose to stand up and stand out instead of ducking
You are at the beach, and you notice that everyone looks better than you.
question “You are the beach, and you notice that everyone looks better than you.” 97
participants said that they would “somewhat likely” feel totally inadequate and stay
covered. 71 of them said it is very “unlikely” that would feel insufficient. The rest of
them, 59 and 23, chose “somewhat unlikely” and “very likely” respectively as to feeling
41
inadequate and wanting to stay covered if they notice that everyone looks better than
Majority of this study’s respondents said that they would “somewhat likely” feel
inadequate and stay covered up should they be in a situation being at the beach and
noticing that everyone looks better than they are. This attests that people “are trained
inadequate which then leads to shame. And as Miceli, et. al (2018) puts it, “shame is an
question “At a family reunion, a relative asks about a blemish on your face.” 103 of the
respondents said that they would “somewhat likely” feel inferior and would decide to
leave the reunion immediately. 82 of them felt that they would “somewhat unlikely”
second-rate because of their imperfect skin. The rest of the participants, 63 and 2 of
42
them, answered “very unlikely” and “very likely” respectively as to feeling inferior and
wherein most theorists have traced shame to violations of one's personal standards.
“When they think that others' judgments of them as what they look like as a person,
further added that shame is characterized by the desire to hide and escape, because
nothing can be done immediately to repair the damage to one's image and relational
value.
“Someone makes a negative comment about one of your body parts”. A total of 91
respondents answered that they would “Very Unlikely” to feel bad about themselves that
would wish they could become invisible. 65 women chose “somewhat unlikely “feel so
badly about their looks. And the rest of the participants, 76 and 18, answered
43
“somewhat likely” and “very likely” respectively as to feeling bad about themselves if
Majority of the respondents said that they would “very unlikely” feel so badly
about themselves that they would wish they could be invisible if someone makes a
negative comment about one of their body parts. This shows unanticipated result as
opposed to the other questions in the survey. This result could be a manifestation of
how women nowadays feel empowered and more accepting of their body image. Many
celebrities, both local and international, advocate self-acceptance and denounce setting
standards on how one should look. These “group of actresses and public figures have
taken another road, one that is significant and that leads to acceptance of our own
bodies rather than follow a “beauty standard” without questioning it.” (Chavarria, 2017)
In fact, Filipino celebrities like Lea Salonga, Bela Padilla, and Jessy Mendiola advocate
actress Iza Calzado was shamed after posting a photo of her wearing a swimsuit where
internet users commented on her “big thighs” and “cellulites”. Instead of feeling
She quipped, “However, the point is not about comparing your body to mine just to
make you feel better but for us to accept that we are who we are and as long as we are
spreading love and light, we will get that in return,” she added. “Wear what you want! Be
free and happy because you are worthy of that!” (“6 stars who,” 2018.)
44
Table 10. Level of Body-Shaming:
“While looking at pictures of models in a magazine.” 76 participants said that they would
“somewhat likely” feel inadequate. 87 of them said it is very “unlikely” that would feel it.
The rest of them, 74 and 13, says that “somewhat unlikely” and “very likely” respectively
Most of the respondents said it is very “unlikely” that would feel inadequate while
looking at pictures of models in magazines, is an indication that it does not always result
individuals make evaluations about their appearance through comparisons with similar
others. Body dissatisfaction can occur if the target of comparison is perceived as more
also said that most women generally had a good idea that images in fashion magazines
were somewhat artificial, they’re been retouched and improved with professional
lighting.
45
Table 11. Level of Body-Shaming:
You are trying on clothes in a store and the assistant states that the clothes fit
strangely on your body.
Table 11 shows the compiled answers of the respondents to the question, “You
are trying on clothes in a store and the assistant states that the clothes fit strangely on
your body.” 14 of the respondents answered that they would “very likely” feel as though
they wanted the ground to open up and swallow them. On the other hand, 103
participants chose that they would “somewhat likely” think in the manner mentioned.
The other participants, 50 and 83, answered “very unlikely” and “somewhat unlikely”
they would feel to just wanting to disappear when someone told them that the clothes fit
The total number of respondents who answered that they would rather wish the
ground would open up and swallow them if they hear an unfavourable comments from
store assistants when trying on clothes is what Brown (n.d.) plausibly meant when he
said that “Shame is that warm feeling that washes over us making us feel small, flawed
and never good.” For a person, especially a woman, being told that a piece of clothing
46
Table 12. Level of Body-Shaming:
You are watching a television show and notice that all the actors look perfect.
Table 12 shows the tabulated answers of the respondents to the question “You
are watching a television show and notice that all the actors look perfect.” A total of 84
respondents answered that they would “somewhat likely” would feel worthless in
comparison to these actors. 66 of them chose “somewhat unlikely” feel a dwindled self-
image. The rest of the participants, 89 and 11, answered “very unlikely” and “very likely”
This result is but an indication of what several researches show as the link
between media images and body dissatisfaction. Henderson-King (1997) found out that
in body satisfaction after viewing “ideal” images of women in the media. It indicates that
women’s importance according to her beauty might be one of the reasons that women
47
Table 13. Level of Body-Shaming:
After working out at the gym you go to the locker room to change. Others come
into the locker room and you get the sense that they are staring at you.
Table13 shows the answers of the respondents to the situational question “After
working out at the gym you go to the locker room to change. Others come into the
locker room and you get the sense that they are staring at you.” A total of 108
respondents said that they would “somewhat likely” feel inferior and rush to the
bathroom stalls to hide. 83 of them said that they would “somewhat unlikely” feel inferior
because of the situation. The rest of the participants, 58 and 1, answered “very unlikely”
This result shows that almost half of the respondents still feel being shamed just
by other people’s stare. This is another attestation of what researchers call “normative
content”. Normative content, as Engeln (2017) discussed, is the “normal” feeling for
women to struggle with body shame. It is the feeling of women that even though other
people do not necessarily do anything to them, they feel shamed even by a mere
48
Table 14
MEAN Interpretation
2. You would feel so awful that you’d want to 2.35 Somewhat Likely
hide.
3. You would think, “I should have taken more 2.48 Somewhat Likely
time on my appearance today.”
4. You would feel totally inadequate and stay 2.29 Somewhat Likely
covered up.
5. You would feel inferior and decide to leave 2.18 Somewhat Likely
the reunion as soon as possible.
6. You would feel so badly about yourself that 2.08 Somewhat Likely
you would wish you could become invisible.
8. You would feel as though you wanted the 2.32 Somewhat Likely
ground to open up and swallow you.
10.You would feel inferior and rush to the 2.21 Somewhat Likely
bathroom stalls to hide.
49
Table 14 shows the general mean of body-shaming level of the respondents
which is 2.25 with a “somewhat likely” interpretation. This indicates that the body-
shaming level of the respondents is normal or neutral, i.e. neither high nor low.
These results demonstrate how women share their feelings about the situation
given and their concerns related to how others view them. Finally, women find ways to
from revealing their bodies so that It would be prevented from being noticed
(Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997), or by having a high awareness of their bodies potential
outward appearance she will notice if it does not match her ideal, and awareness of this
discrepancy is a precursor for feeling body shame (Bessenhoff & Snow, 2006)
However, when traditional standards of thinness are internalized, instead of, or possibly
in addition to, strength and power, many women experience a greater amount of body
shame. Shame is especially strong when there is a large discrepancy between what a
person looks like and what she wants to look like (McKinley & Hyde, 1996).
It is also important to note that body-shaming does not affect all women equally.
The observer's perspective can become internalized to varying degrees, and variables
such as class, ethnicity, age, sexuality, personal history and physical attributes make
each woman different (Fredrickson & Harrison, 2005; Quinn, Kallen, Twenge, et al,
2006).
50
Table 15.
Table 15 shows the answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self- Esteem
Scale Question, “On the whole, I am satisfied with myself.” A total of 96 respondents
said that they “agree” on being satisfied with themselves, while 51 choose "strongly
agree". The rest of the participants 43, and 60 answered "disagree" and "strongly
disagree" respectively.
Most of the respondents said that they “agree” on being satisfied with themselves
this relates to fewer studies that have examined body size satisfaction among men.
Research suggests that women tend to be more satisfied with their body size or weight,
even if they are overweight. While height or other body areas may influence women
body size satisfaction available studies have focused on weight. For some women, body
size does not appear to affect their self-perceptions or body image as much as it does
for women, which may account for discrepancies between the sexes in weight-control
51
Table 16.
Table16 shows the compiled answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self-
Esteem Scale Question 2, “At times I think I am not good at all.” 136 respondents said
that they “agree” that sometimes they think they are not good at all, while 33 choose
"strongly agree". The rest of the participants 75 and 6 answered "disagree" and
"strongly disagree".
The most number of participants said that they “agree” that there were times that
they don't feel good at all. While many studies of US in 2016 that adults have assessed
specifically examined body size satisfaction. Most of the research has focused on
women and found that lower body mass index (BMI), increasing age, and better health
are generally positively associated with body size satisfaction. Women typically view
themselves as heavier than they actually are and desire a thinner figure, with more
reporting dissatisfaction with their bodies than men in the same BMI category. While
Khan (2013) some report acceptance or satisfaction with their body size.
52
Table 17.
Table17 shows the answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self- Esteem
Scale Question 3, “I feel that I have a number of good qualities.” 106 of the
respondents said that they “agree” that they feel that they have a number of good
qualities, while 44 choose "strongly agree". The rest of the participants 100 and 0
In this result, most of the respondents said that they “agree” that they have a
number of good qualities, Base on the study of Frost and McKelvie (2005) it is found
that there was a positive relationship between qualities and the dependent variables
considered together, but that it was only significant for self-esteem and body build, not
for body image or weight satisfaction. Also, the study suggested "that a higher level of
positiveness awareness about their good qualities is associated with a higher level of
self-esteem, and this relationship occurs for female elementary school, high school, and
53
Table 18.
Table18 shows the compiled answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self-
Esteem Scale Question 4, “I am able to do things as well as most other people.” 120 of
the respondents said that they “agree” that they are able to do things as well as most
other people, while 35 choose "strongly agree". The rest of the participants 66 and 29
Majority of the participants chose “agree” that they were able to do things as well
who we think that are worse than us (Morse and Gergen, 1970). Like in other cases,
people who are suffering from serious diseases prefer to compare their condition with
other individuals whose current condition and likely prognosis is worse than their own
54
Table 19.
Table 19 shows the answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self- Esteem
Scale Question 5, “I feel I do not have much to be proud of.” 58 of the respondents
chose “agree” that they do not have much to be proud of, while 29 choose "strongly
agree". The rest of the participants 127 and 36 answered "disagree" and "strongly
disagree".
Almost half of the participants chose “disagree” that they do not have much to be
proud of, Self-esteem is so intrinsically linked to thoughts about one's body that physical
appearance has consistently been found to be the number one predictor of self-esteem
at many ages" (Ata, Ludden, & Lally, 2006). According to Rosenberg (1965) , "self-
esteem is defined as a "positive or negative attitude toward the self". While Frost and
McKelvie (2005), define self-esteem "as the level of global regard one has for the self".
It does contribute to poorer body image and eating disorder symptoms and studies are
still trying to figure out how to hinder adolescent girls' beliefs that they need to be
extremely skinny to look attractive. Adolescent girls can also have low self-esteem
55
Table 20.
Table 20 shows the compiled answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self-
chose “agree” that they do not have much to be proud of, while 34 choose "strongly
agree". The other participants, 50 and 125 answered "disagree" and "strongly disagree".
Most of the respondents said that they "strongly disagree" on feeling useless at
times is an indication of one of the two varieties of Defensive Self-Esteem that is the
Worthiness-based self-esteem. An internal feeling about how good you feel about
yourself as a person (Leary, M. R, 2004). This happens when a person lack a sense of
competence but do have a sense of worth, which causes them to rely on feeling worthy
for their self-esteem. The result of such psychological lop-sidedness means they need
others to approve them. If such approval is withdrawn, or if they are criticized because
56
Table 21.
Table 21 shows the answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self- Esteem
Scale Question 7 “I feel that I'm a person of worth, at least on an equal plane with
others.” 26 of the respondents chose “agree” that they do not have much to be proud
of, while 41 choose "strongly agree". The rest of the participants 183 and 0 answered
Most answers we get is the participants “disagree” on the question, “I feel that I'm
a person of worth, at least on an equal plane with others.” Dr. Kristin Neff argues that
there is a problem with society’s focus on high self-esteem. The problem is that this
focus involves measuring oneself against others, rather than paying attention to one’s
intrinsic value. “Our competitive culture tells us we need to be special and above
average to feel good about ourselves, but we can’t all be above average at the same
57
Table 22.
Table 22 shows the compiled answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self-
Esteem Scale Question 8 “I wish I could have more respect for myself.” 168 of the
respondents chose “agree” that they wish they could have more respect for themselves,
while 9 choose "strongly agree". The other participants, 41 and 32 answered "disagree"
Most of the respondents said that they "agree" on they wish they could have
more respect for themselves. It was said that "self-esteem was the most important
predictor of body dissatisfaction, with females with low self-esteem experience more
body dissatisfaction than those with high self-esteem" (Griffiths & McCabe, 2000). It was
also noted that the impact of society, parents, and friends, improved the prediction of
body dissatisfaction, low self-esteem, and the importance of appearance (Griffiths &
McCabe, 2000). Also, Davidson and McCabe (2006) concluded that their study showed
evidence for the association between psychosocial difficulties and poor body image.
58
Table 23.
Table 23 shows the answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self- Esteem Scale
Question 9, “All in all, I am inclined to feel that I am a failure.” 157 of the respondents chose
“agree” from being inclined to feel that they are a failure, while 3 chose "strongly agree". The
Most answers we get is the participants is they "agree" that as a whole they were inclined to
feel that they are a failure. Those women who suffer bodydissatisfaction often associate their
failure to reach their ideal body with their self-conceptand as a result of this often suffer with a
decrease in self-esteem (Bessenoff, 2006). Fredrickson and Roberts (1997) state that many
women begin to feel emotions such as shame towards themselves because they are unable to
achieve a desired body image they want. This failure to meet society's perception of normal
59
Table 24
Table 24 shows the compiled answers of the respondents to the Rosenberg Self-
Esteem Scale Question 10 “I take a positive attitude toward myself.” 123 of the respondents
chose “agree” that they take a positive attitude towards themselves, while 50 choose "strongly
agree". The other participants, 48 and 29 answered "disagree" and "strongly disagree".
Most of the respondents said that they "agree" on taking a positive attitude towards
themselves. A person's body image is influenced by their beliefs and attitudes. One's body
image does not remain the same, but changes in response to lifestyle events (Women's
Health, 2007). A poor body image may hamper adolescents' development of interpersonal
skills and positive relations with other boys and girls". For instance, "physical attractiveness
has been found to impact on peer relationships all the way back from elementary school, with
attractive girls engaging in more positive social interactions than less-attractive girls. The
researchers addressed that there is a relationship between body image and psychological
functioning during adolescence. Lastly, they found a strong association between body image
concerns and low self-esteem among adolescent girls, which has led to constructions of body
60
Table 25
Mean Interpretation
61
Table 25 shows that the respondents answered “Agree” in almost all questions except
question 6 where they replied “Disagree” to the question about “certainly feeling useless at
times.” The table further shows that the respondents’ self-esteem level is 2.53. This indicates
that the participants in this study have a normal or average self-esteem level.
This links particularly in individualistic cultures, report having relatively high self-esteem,
an interesting question is why this might be. Other cultures place more importance on
developing high self-esteem than others, and people correspondingly feel oppressed on saying
their feelings about themselves (Held, 2002). Self-esteem tends to fluctuate over time,
depending on your circumstances. It's normal to go through times when you feel down about
yourself and times when you feel good about yourself (Mayoclinic, 2017). A problem with
measures such as the Rosenberg scale is that they can be influenced by the desire to portray
the self positively. The observed scores on the Rosenberg scale may be somewhat inflated
because people naturally try to make themselves look as if they have very high self-esteem,
maybe they lie a bit to the experimenters to make themselves look better than they really are
and perhaps to make themselves feel better. If this is the case, then we might expect to find
average levels of reported self-esteem to be lower in cultures where having high self-worth is
62
Table 26
Pearson r Correlation Analysis of the Relationship Between the Respondents’ Level of Body-
Shaming and Self–Esteem
respondents’ body-shaming level and self-esteem level. This further shows that the
relationship. This means that there is a tendency for high level of body-shaming
associated with high level of self-esteem and vice versa. In other words, although this
study shows normal or neutral level of both body-shaming and self-esteem of the
respondents, there is an inclination that as the level of body-shaming arises, the level of
This study may suggest that women are more confident and happy within
themselves and their appearance. However, these results show that self-esteem tends
Rosenberg scale is that they can be influenced by the desire to portray the self
positively. The observed scores on the Rosenberg scale may be somewhat inflated
because people naturally try to make themselves look as if they have very high self-
63
esteem maybe they lie a bit to the experimenters to make themselves look better than
they really are and perhaps to make themselves feel better. If this is the case, then we
might expect to find average levels of reported self-esteem to be lower in cultures where
Robles (2011) stated that female adolescents are particularly manipulated by this
idea of having a good body image is perfection as they see it as a means of measuring
perspective of their body which leads to an increase in body shame. Much of the
amount of evidence that is also suffering from body shame and the desire to look
beautiful. Thus, the feeling of body shame remains stable across the lifespan (Webster
64
Chapter V
Introduction
This chapter summarizes the findings of the study based on the results and data
Summary of Findings
This research study aimed to identify the impact of body-shaming on the self-
study were:
A total of 250 women from Pulilan, Bulacan was chosen for this study. The
respondents tapped are aged 18 to 25. The three biggest age groups among the
participants are 21, 20 and 23 while the least age group is 24. Almost half of the
participants or 40.4% have reached college but have not finished their degree.
65
35.2% listed a meager monthly income of Php 1,000 to Php 9,999 followed by
the respondents is 2.25. This indicates that the level of body-shaming of the
Based on the analysis of the researcher on the data gathered, the overall
average of the self-esteem level of the respondents is 2.53. This indicates that
through the use of Pearson r, showed that the level of body-shaming and the
that there is a tendency for high level of body-shaming associated with high level
of self-esteem and vice versa. To wit, although this study shows normal or
66
an inclination that as the level of body-shaming arises, the level of self-esteem of
shaming.
the past should try to focus on their unique and admirable qualities.
other people say about their body, they can show or improve their abilities
that will help them enrich self-love and positive body image.
67
messages that promote body-acceptance instead of posts about weight
against body-shaming.
shaming.
68
Conclusions
The researcher concluded that the participants in this study show that they have
an average self-esteem level and a neutral level of body-shaming. This study further
shows that instead of being discouraged, the respondents have a tendency of gaining
respondents are already aware of how to handle body shaming by taking it as a positive
Overall, this study can still be used in structuring recommendations that will help
those who have experienced body-shaming. The results of this study can also be used
effects of body-shaming; thus helping and educating the community about the ill-effects
of such act.
1. Since the researcher used Convenience Sampling as the research method, only
participants available at the time the survey was conducted were asked. As such,
2. The study did not consider the impact of body-shaming on the self-esteem of the
3. The limited responses gathered by the researcher since the study is mainly
69
get a more in-depth analysis on the psychological effect of body-shaming on the
respondents.
Recommendations
This study which aimed to analyse the impact of body-shaming on the self-
esteem of adolescent women in Pulilan, Bulacan has introduced possible future studies
to expand the analysis and examination of the effects of body-shaming. As such, the
13 years old receive body critique from other people, hence, the
instrument that relates to physical activity to be used with females who are
physically active and females who are not physically active. This is to
70
BIBLIOGRAPHY
significant others on disordered eating and body dissatisfaction among early adolescent
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/264620563_The_influence_of_significant_oth
ers_on_disordered_eating_and_body_dissatisfaction_among_early_adolescent_girls.
not-work-poverty-is-worse-for-health-than-obesity.html.
Allison Abrams (October 10, 2017). Shutting Down Body Shaming Retrieved
compassion/201710/shutting-down-body-shaming
compulsive personality traits in adult women with eating disorders: defining a broader
Arooba Kazmi (October 10, 2017). "Body shaming can lead to long-term effects"
ae3d-11e7-a353-0bcc5f915c7a.html.
Ata, Rheanna N.; Ludden, Alison Bryant; Lally, Megan. Journal of Youth and
Adolescence, v36 n8 p1024-1037 Nov 2007. The Effects of Gender and Family, Friend,
and Media Influences on Eating Behaviors and Body Image during Adolescence.
71
Barrett KC. A functionalist approach to shame and guilt. In: Tangney JP, Fischer,
Bearman, S.K., Presnell, K. Martinez, E & Stice, E. (2006). The skinny on body
dissatisfaction: A longitudinal study of adolescent girls and boys. Journal of Youth and
Bessenoff, G. R., & Snow, D. (2006). Absorbing society's influence: Body image
Bish CL, Blanck HM, Serdula MK, Marcus M, Kohl HW, 3rd, Khan LK. Diet and
physical activity behaviors among Americans trying to lose weight: 2000 Behavioral
Brandy Hanson. Body Shaming, Self-Image, and Social Media, "“OMG! You’re
:https://www.lake.k12.fl.us/cms/lib/FL01000799/Centricity/Domain/9156/Photo%20Essa
y%20Example.pdf
Brinkman, D. J., Tichelaar, J., Van, M. A., De, T. P., & Richir, M. C. (2015, July).
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25650568
Women's Lived Experiences and Mental Health Risks". (n.d.). Retrieved January 24,
72
2018, from http://scalar.usc.edu/works/bodies/fredrickson-and-roberts-objectification-
theory-toward-understanding-womens-lived-experiences-and.
Buunk, B. P., Gibbons, F. X., & Visser, A. (2002). The relevance of social
comparison processes for prevention and health care. Patient Education and
Crandall, C.S. (1994). Prejudice against fat people: Ideology and self-interest.
Colby, K., Lerman, J. B., & Morley, E. (1981). The current status of suicide and
Chou Wy, Prestin A, Kunath S. (2014). Obesity in social media: a mixed methods
Christopher Mruk (July 28, 2018), Authentic Self-Esteem and Well-Being: Part III
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/authentic-self-esteem-and-well-
being/201807/authentic-self-esteem-and-well-being-part-iii.
nervosa and bulimia nervosa: implications for DSM-V. American Journal of Psychiatry,
165(2), 245-250.
Davison, T. E., & McCabe, M.P. (2005). Relationships between men's and
women's body image and their psychological, social, and sexual functioning. Sex Roles,
52(7/8), 463-475.
73
Downs, D.M., James, S. & Cowan, G. (2006). Body objectification, self-esteem,
and relationship satisfaction: A comparison of exotic dancers and college women. Sex
do-we-do-it/
Erica Waters (May 19, 2017) "Let’s Talk About Body Shaming in the Philippines"
predicts motor performance. Journal of Sport and Social Issues, 29(1), 79-101.
Frost, J., & McKelvie, S. (2005). The relationship of self-esteem and body
satisfaction to exercise activity for male and female elementary school, high school, and
74
Gapinski, K.D., Brownell, K.D. & LaFrance, M. (2003). Body objectification and
“fat talk”: Effects on emotion, motivation, and cognitive performance. Sex Roles, 48,
377-388.
Hogan, M.G., & Strasburger, V.C. (2008). Body image, eating disorders, and the
personality disorders among those with eating disorders. Eating Disorders, 13(1), 7-21.
theory analysis of the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale. Personality and Social Psychology
Held, B. S., (2002) The tyranny of the positive attitude in America: Observation
10.1002/jclp.10093refer
doi:10.1177/01461672992511001
Hesse-Biber, S., Leavy, P., Quinn, C.E. & Zoino, J. (2006). The mass marketing
of disordered eating and eating disorders: The social psychology of women, thinness
75
Huang Jeannie, Norman Gregory J, Zabinski Marion. Body Image and Self-
among Adolescents. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences , 1. Retrieved
2014-1-024.pdf
Jen Brass Jenkins (May 11, 2015) BODY SHAMING—A CULTURAL EPIDEMIC
https://healthcare.utah.edu/healthfeed/postings/2015/05/body-shaming-cultural-
epidemic.phphttps://fetzer.org/sites/default/files/images/stories/pdf/selfmeasures/Self_M
easures_for_Self-Esteem_ROSENBERG_SELF-ESTEEM.pdf.
Jessie Sholl (June 6, 2019) "How to Deal With Shame" Retrieved June 08, 2019
from https://experiencelife.com/article/shutting-shame-down/
Kristin Neff, Ph.D April, 2011. "With self-compassion, we give ourselves the
same kindness and care we'd give to a good friend." retrieved June 22, 2019 from
https://www.psychalive.org/self-worth/?fbclid=IwAR0V-uCk9f-
AQehHc6dhWfNrF9116eU5Nw0SNDlYYiIau0l784tmSxrpa6M.
make women look bad: Solo status and body image concerns diminish women’s
76
Korin Miller (September 4, 2016), The Shocking Results of Yahoo Health’s Body-
shocking-results-of-yahoo-1332510105509942.html
Kozee, H. B., Tylka, T. L., Augustus‐Horvath, C. L., & Denchik, A. (2007, May
from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1471-6402.2007.00351.x/abstract
Leary, M. R. (2007). The curse of the self: self-awareness, egotism, and the
regulation: Research, theory, and application (pp. 373–391). New York, NY: Guilford.
Lewis, H.B. (1971). Shame and Guilt in Neurosis. Psychoanalytic Review, 58(3),
419-438.
Marita P. McCabe et al. The Journal of Social Psychology. Volume 143 ...
Mayo Clinic (2017), Self-esteem check: Too low or just right? retrieved June 20,
esteem/art-20047976.
77
McKinley, N. M., & Hyde, J. S. (1996). The objectified body consciousness scale
Moradi, B., Dirks, D. & Matteson, A.V. (2005). Roles of sexual objectification
Morse, S., & Gergen, K. J. (1970). Social comparison, self-consistency, and the
Mulgrew, Kate & Volcevski-Kostas, Diana & Rendell, Peter. (2013). The Effect of
Music Video Clips on Adolescent Boys' Body Image, Mood, and Schema Activation.
698. DOI:10.1037/a0016763
Mukwamu, S. (n.d.). Body shaming and its effect on society. Retrieved from
http://www.perdeby.co.za/sections/features/5774-body-shaming-and-its-effect-on-
society
N., J., & P. (n.d.). MacArthur SES & Health. Retrieved from
http://www.macses.ucsf.edu/research/psychosocial/selfesteem.php
Niña V. Guno (August 30, 2017) "Megan Young, Lea Salonga weigh in on PH
78
https://entertainment.inquirer.net/240407/megan-young-lea-salonga-weigh-ph-culture-
body-shaming#ixzz5pmDLUucL
Paula Chavarria (March 16, 2017). All Women Against “Body Shaming”
sh_b_9468152
23374.htm
Rappler.com (March 9, 2018). "6 stars who DGAF about looking ‘perfect"
celebrities-speak-up-against-body-shaming.
Schooler, D., Ward, L.M., Merriweather, A. & Caruthers, A.S. (2005). Cycles of
shame: Menstrual shame, body shame, and sexual decision-making. Journal of Sex
79
Wood, J. H. (2001). Personality disorders in eating disorder not otherwise
specified and binge eating disorder: a meta-analysis of comorbidity studies. The Journal
Tangney JP, Miller RS, Flicker L, Barlow DHJ Pers Soc Psychol. Are shame,
Yean, C., Benau, E. M., Dakanalis, A., Hormes, J. M., Perone, J., Timko, C. A.
(2013). The relationship of sex and sexual orientation to self-esteem, body shape
doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2013.00887 .
Pesa, J., Syre, T., & Jones, E. (2000). Psychosocial differences associated with
body weight among female adolescents: The importance of body image. Journal of
Robles, D.S. (2011). The thin is in: Am I thin enough? Perfection and self-esteem
SLOAN B. 2000. Body image. Ohio State University Factsheet. Retrieved from
Stice, E., Hayward, C., Cameron, R.P., Killen, J.D. & Taylor, C.B. (2000). Body-
image and eating disturbances predict onset of depression among female adolescents:
80
Annex 1.
81
Annex 2
______________________________________________________________________
Very
Somew Somew Very
Unlik
hat hat Likely
ely
Unlikel Likely
y
1. Someone close to you expresses disappointment over your appearance:
(a) You would attribute this person’s
disapproval to wrong priorities.
(b) You would regret that you didn’t keep up
with your efforts to maintain your appearance.
(c) You would feel diminished in your image of
yourself.
82
Very
Somew Somew Very
Unlikhat hat Likely
ely
Unlikel Likely
y
2. You go to the mall, and everybody seems better looking than you.
(a) You would think, “I should spend more time
trying to improve my appearance.”
(b) You would feel so awful that you’d want to
hide.
(c) You would think, “They don’t lead busy
lives, so they are able to spend more time on
their appearance.”
83
Very Somew Somew Very
Unlik hat hat Likely
ely Unlikel Likely
y
5. At a family reunion, a relative asks about a blemish on your face
(a) You would feel inferior and decide to leave
the reunion as soon as possible.
(b) You would think, “That person has always
been inappropriate!”
(c) You would regret that you had not made an
appointment with the dermatologist.
Very
Somew Somew Very
Unlik
hat hat Likely
ely
Unlikel Likely
y
6. Someone makes a negative comment about one of your body parts
(a) You would feel so badly about yourself that
you would wish you could become invisible.
(b) You would think, “I shouldn’t have worn
clothes that showed this body part.”
(c) You would think, “That person is so
insensitive.”
84
Very Somew Somew Very
Unlik hat hat Likely
ely Unlikel Likely
y
8. You are trying on clothes in a store and the assistant states that the clothes fit
strangely on your body
a) You would feel as though you wanted the
ground to open up and swallow you.
(b) You would think, “I need to work harder so I
fit into these clothes next time.”
(c) You would think, “The assistant is not very
good at her job!”
85
PART II- Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale:
Instructions
Below is a list of statements dealing with your general feelings about yourself. Please
indicate how strongly you agree or disagree with each statement.
86
CURICULUM VITAE
E-Mail : [email protected]
Mobile : +61 412974859
Nationality: Filipino
Address : Sydney, Australia, New South Wales.
Professional Strength
Work Experience
June 2014 – September 2015 – Front Desk Officer – Marriot Courtyard, Green
Community.
-Location: Jebel Ali, Dubai UAE
Job Description: Performs to executive management. Receiving calls,
managing calendars, events, making reservation. Operate telephone switchboard to
answer, screen, or forward calls, providing information, taking messages, or scheduling
appointments.Hear and resolve complaints from customers or the public.
87
and securing speakers or special guests, planning location and room layouts
and the entertainment program.
Education
Tertiary : 2016 (Undergraduate) Bachelor of Arts In Psychology, AMA University
Online Education.
2011-2014 Bachelor of Science in Hotel and Restaurant Management
Bulacan State University, Malolos, Bulacan
Secondary : 2006-2010 St. Dominic Academy Poblacion, Pulilan, Bulacan
Elementary : 2001-2006 Segundo Esguerra Memorial Elementary School
Dampol, Pulilan, Bulacan
Seminars / Training
2012, December - Butler Service, Food and Beverage, House Keeping, Actual Bed
Making and Opera System Seminar- Pan Pacific Manila
88
Manila, Philippines
89