Designing An Integrated Curriculum For Preschool: Greg Tabios Pawilen, Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
Designing An Integrated Curriculum For Preschool: Greg Tabios Pawilen, Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
Abstract
Integrated curriculum is a popular curriculum design used in organizing preschool
curriculum. This study aims to analyze how teachers design an integrated curriculum.
Specifically, it describes: (1) how do teachers plan an integrated curriculum; (2) what
common themes are used; and (3) what factors are influential or considered in inte-
grating the curriculum. Since the study was conducted in a Christian school, it also
analyzes the influence of the Christian faith in the curriculum. Curriculum analysis
and focus-group discussion with preschool teachers and administrators were done to
gather the necessary data for the study. The results of the study show that the thematic
approach is dominantly used in integrating the curriculum. The themes usually derived
from big ideas or topics related to science, social studies, and some concepts and
activities that are interesting to the learners. Several factors are also found to be in-
fluential in designing the curriculum. The study also found out that Christianity has a
great impact or influence in designing the curriculum. Biblical stories, and Christian
values are always integrated in the selection of sub-topics and activities in the curri-
culum.
Keywords: Integrated curriculum, Christianschool, preschool, thematic approach
Introduction
Throughout the world, especially in industrialized countries, preschool education
is expanding very fast (Boocock, 1991). Consequently, there is an increasing concern
57
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
and a growing demand to provide quality early childhood education for young
children (Clinton, 1996; Curtis and Carter, 1996; Gardner 2000). In pursuit for quality
early childhood education, the curriculum is at the heart of scholastic discussions
among early childhood educators around the globe. The design and implementation
of the curriculum are agreed to be significant contributors to quality in childcare and
kindergartens (NAEYC, 2005). As noted by O’Connell (2006), extensive research has
consistently shown that quality preschool programs improve not only readiness to
learn, but also social skills that will help children for a lifetime.
This study was conceptualized to contribute to the pursuit for excellent curricular
practices for improving and developing the delivery of kindergarten education.
Specifically, this paper aims to analyze how teachers design an integrated curriculum
for kindergarten in a selected Christian school. This paper focuses only to the kinder-
garten level that caters to the needs of young children within the age range of four to
six. The study was conducted in the first kindergarten school in the Philippines which
is one of the first proponents of designing integrated curriculum for preschool in the
country.
The idea of integrating the curriculum is not new, yet it remains to be the most
popular way of designing many preschool curricula. More teachers are becoming
excited about designing an integrated curriculum. The excitement comes from wit-
nessing the learners become more active and interested on the learning process.
Teachers who are trying their best to design an integrated curriculum are committed
to the idea of providing a type of learning that is connected and relevant to the life of
the learners. The increasing number of new knowledge and skills discovered in every
day provides an immense challenge to make the school curriculum relevant and
responsive. There are also specific competencies and content standards that are
important to teach in every subject but with limited time, it is almost impossible to
teach everything. Through curriculum integration, several important concepts and
skills that need to be taught to the learners can be meaningfully and interestingly
58
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
59
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
of education should be on the ability to solve problems and apply them in an ever-
changing context. People interact with parts of the world at various times. Every
activity in man’s life is interrelated and interdependent. Integration recognizes the
interconnectedness of people’s ideas and how such connections make knowledge
more meaningful. It works to facilitate children’s ability to make connections that
represent the world as accurately as possible.
Children need help to bridge the world of the school to the larger community in
which they live. This means that school curriculum includes activities in which
learners gain knowledge that are applicable to real life. It is also important that the
curriculum is relevant and responsive to the needs of the society. Learners must find
themselves part of the process of solving a problem or issue to improve their own
community (Martinello, 1994; Nagel, 1996). Through curriculum integration, all
learners become contributing members of the community and make connections with
their work and the outside world.
Charlesworth (1997) and Lind (1997) observe positive benefits of integrating
Science and Mathematics in the preschool curriculum. Accordingly, through integra-
tion the learners are able to understand important concepts and acquire important
skills in an interdisciplinary perspective. Italso enables young children to see the
connection of science knowledge to different subjects and understand the application
of science in other disciplines. This is because curriculum integration dissolves sub-
ject boundaries to assist students in making connections between disciplines, and to
help them solve problems on their own through research and critical reasoning. It also
addresses the preferences of children with different learning styles and the various
learning conditions that they want (Fogarty, 1993).
Curriculum integration helps learners in developing skills to retrieve faster
information by organizing related concepts into themes. It helps children perceive
learning as a whole by figuring out how various ideas, issues, and skills are all can be
connected to enrich depth and breadth in learning. In a study done by Kellough
60
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
61
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
allow teachers to do team-teaching and conduct outdoor activities and other learning
experiences that are required for the implementation of the integrated curriculum. The
type of evaluation and assessment tools to be use is important in designing an inte-
grated curriculum. It is necessary for teachers to have a shared philosophy and under-
standing on how to assess and evaluate the learning progress of the students.
Any curriculum innovation requires the support of parents and school admini-
strators being part of the stakeholders of the school. The parents need to know what
type of curriculum is taught to their children and they can be of help in implementing
the curriculum. Support from parents and school administrators are needed to imple-
ment successfully the integrated curriculum. Hence it is important to consider it in
designing an integrated curriculum.
62
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
63
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
Methodology
This study was conducted in a church-related preschool which is the first kinder-
garten school in the Philippines. This school is the training ground of many kinder-
garten teachers in various church-related preschools in the Philippines. The partici-
pants of the study include three school administrators, two former teachers, and two
teachers who are teaching in the school for more than five years. The teachers are
graduates of Bachelor’s degree in Kindergarten Education while the administrators
hold graduate degrees in Family Life and Child Development and Educational
Administration.
The study uses document or curriculum analysis to examine the curriculum plans
in order to know what type of themes are develop and how Christianity affects or
influences in the design of the curriculum especially in selecting the content and
learning experiences. Documents that were analyzed include curriculum plan of the
kindergarten and preparatory level for the whole school year. The available old curri-
culum guide for the past 10 years was also analyzed. Kindergarten includes children
with three to four years old and preparatory includes children from five to six years
old. In analyzing the curriculum documents, curriculum themes, topics, and activities
were noted.
To supplement the result of the analysis, two schedules of interview with the
teachers and school administrators were done. The first interview focuses on how
teachers plan an integrated curriculum, what common themes were used, and what
factors are considered in designing the integrated curriculum. Problems related to
their tasks of designing an integrated curriculum were also noted to support and
answer the problems of the study. The second interview focuses on the discussion of
64
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
the results of the first interview. This allows other teachers and administrators to
validate their comments and provide additional information to what were shared by
other teachers. The interview was conducted through a round-table type discussion
using the three major research questions as guide.
-
(1) Selecting or deciding a theme or a thematic unit the first thing that teachers
do is to select the theme of the curriculum. Themes are selected from con-
cepts or topics from different subject areas that are interesting to young
children. The theme serves as the focus of teaching and learning for certain
period of time. It is also the organizing center of the thematic web.
(2) Selecting topics from different subjects that are related to the theme -
teachers will develop a curriculum web where different concepts and skills
related to the theme are selected. Topics in the curriculum web are selected
from Social Studies, Science, Mathematics, Language, and Christian Values.
It is important that topics selected should be relevant and connected to the
65
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
theme.
-
(3) Planning different activities that are related to the theme different activi-
ties are planned for each topic in the curriculum web. It is important that the
activities should be interesting and appropriate to the level of the learners.
Free-guided play, music activities, simple experiments and observations,
outdoor activities, group discussion, storytelling, and individual activities are
examples of learning experiences provided to the learners. Chapel services
and prayer time are also included in the list for activities.
-
(4) Selecting instructional materials to be used materials that are used for
actual teaching are selected. The used of authentic or real objects is en-
couraged. The school has adequate instructional materials such as print,
audio-video materials, toys, and other equipments are provided for the
children.
(5) Planning the schedule -teachers will then divide the lesson into smaller
units of study. Each topic is usually scheduled on a daily or weekly basis
depending on the scope of the topic.
-
(6) Designing assessment and evaluation tools narrative reports that include
teachers’observation on the performance and behaviour of each child in the
classroom are used in evaluating the learners. Currently, the teachers are
starting to introduce portfolios and rubrics for evaluating children’s port-
folio.
66
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
handling the classes collaboratively design the integrated curriculum to ensure uni-
formity and standard in the lesson. This requires cooperation and creativity from
teachers. The challenge is always to design an integrated curriculum that is interesting
and meaningful to the learners. The final copy of the integrated curriculum plan is
submitted to the school principal for checking. After the final checking, the curri-
culum plan is implemented by the teachers. Teachers and young children consume
one month or more to study one curriculum theme. Since the preschool program is
structured, teachers allot specific period of time for implementing the integrated
curriculum plan.
The interview also shows several problems that teachers encountered while
planning the integrated curriculum. For example, some parents would pressure the
teachers to put emphasis on academic skills such as reading, writing and mathe-
matical skills that will prepare young children for Grade I. Another problem is with
the administrators. Several administrators would like to put emphasis on topics
related to science, reading, or activities as themes. The school requires textbooks for
teaching therefore, teachers should align their themes with the textbook topics.
67
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
68
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
a. Children’s Interests -Most of the time, young children’s interest is the main
source of curriculum themes, contents, and activities. Topics of their interest
such as: insects, cars, toys, food, heavenly bodies, animals, sea creatures or
how their body works are included in the curriculum web or sometimes they
serve as themes for the integrated curriculum. Children’s activities like play
and art activities are also included thus making play as outstanding instruc-
tional means to capture children’s interest.
b. Children’s Textbooks -textbooks are the source of many exercises and acti-
vities for young children. The school develops textbooks for preschool. These
textbooks are recommended to be used by more than 100 church-related
schools. Thus, teachers have the strong tendency to choose the curriculum
theme and organize their lessons based on the topics from the textbooks. The
unit titles of the textbook they are using are used as curriculum themes.
Examples are the units in Science such as plants, animals, non-living things,
or Social Studies units such as family, communities, beautiful places, and
country.
-
c. Children’s Story Books Their favorite story books sometimes serve as a
springboard for the whole lesson or theme. This is similar to the literature-
based approach in integrating the curriculum. Teachers who were trained in
using this approach apply it in designing an integrated curriculum. For
example, when the story of “Creation” in the Bible is used, teachers will inte-
grate themes on land formations, bodies of water, heavenly bodies, plants, and
animals.
d. Availability of instructional materials -this delimits the teachers in designing
the curriculum. Before the start of the school year, teachers are required to
submit a list of instructional materials to be use in the school. However, there
is not enough money to purchase the materials. Sometimes the materials
needed are not readily available. However, the teachers are very creative in
69
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
70
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
young children in school. The children are taught that there is a God that
created everything in the universe and God wants all human beings to be good
stewards of His creation. This message is always emphasized whenever teachers
plan integrated themes in science especially when they teach topics related to
the environment (like plants, animals and non-living things) and topics related
to the human body.
According to the teachers, the parents of young children sent their kids to a
Christian school because they want their children to learn in a Christian atmosphere
and they want their children to know more about the Christian teachings. Hence it is
expected that teachers should include topics about God, the Bible, and the Christian
doctrines to the learners. Having prayers is also one of the major activities that
teachers include when planning activities for the themes. Aside from these, Christian
kindergarten schools have their own mandate from the church to teach Christianity to
the learners. This is well included in the schools’ philosophy, vision and mission and
in the school curriculum.
These influential factors that were mentioned show that the persons involved in
designing the integrated curriculum have a crucial role. This is somehow related to
the idea of Print (1993) of a curriculum presage whereby the personalities, back-
ground, philosophy, and conceptions of all the curriculum workers involved influence
the process of curriculum development. Although students’ interest are considered in
designing the curriculum, the teachers and administrators who will plan and translate
these children’s needs and interests into curriculum content and learning experiences
-
play an important role. Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi (1746 1872) earlier recognized
the important roles of teachers in creating experiences and opportunities to fit in the
nature of the child.
Children’s interests are somehow considered in all the aspects of planning the
integrated curriculum. This practice is very important when designing a curriculum
71
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
-
for young children. Rousseau’s (1712 1778) idea in early childhood education as
mentioned by Brubacher and Seiler (1947) considers the child as the center of the
curriculum. Therefore looking at the interests and needs of the children are very
important in designing the integrated curriculum. A good preschool curriculum should
reflect the nature of the child as a learner who is naturally curious to discover and
explore the environment that surrounds him or her. On the part of the school, the use
of play as a method of instruction and the emphasis on designing a suitable learning
environment or classroom for the learners are very important.
Conclusion
Designing an integrated curriculum as mentioned in the first part of this paper is
an exciting journey in preschool education. This type of curriculum design is based
on the findings of several studies that the human brain processes information in an
integrated way. Several ways to integrate the curriculum are offered by different
authors as mention in the review of related literature in this paper. These different
ways to integrate the curriculum are united in one common purpose that is to provide
an education that is holistic, meaningful, responsive, interesting and relevant for the
young learners.
This study found out that the use of the thematic approach is the dominant
approach that is used in the school. This approach enables the teachers to select
themes are relevant and interesting to the learners. Most of the selected themes are
topics that are related to the different disciplines. These themes are carefully selected
by the teachers and administrators. However, since there are other approaches in
curriculum integration, it would also be nice to try other approaches that will provide
more learning experiences to young children.
In the process of planning the integrated curriculum, several factors like the
interest of the learners, the teachers and administrators, the availability of instruc-
tional materials and children’s textbooks are very influential. The study also found
72
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
out that Christian teachings are also very influential in designing an integrated curri-
culum. The thematic approach provides an opportunity for teachers to integrate the
Christian faith and values to young children. Thus it includes biblical stories and
verses, and other activities that are related to different Christian practices like pray-
ing.
Finally, an integrated curriculum design is important especially in preschool.
This type of education is related in the way children learn and construct knowledge.
This design of curriculum also allows the integration of different concepts and skills
that are interesting and important for young children. In connection with church-
related kindergarten schools, an integrated curriculum design provides an excellent
opportunity for Christian values and concepts to be integrated and taught naturally in
the curriculum.
References
Beane, J. (1997). Curriculum integration: designing the core of democratic edu-
cation. New York: Teachers College Press.
Boocock, S. S. (1991). The Japanese Preschool System. In E. R. Beauchamp (Eds.):
Windows on Japanese education. Westport: Greenwood Press.
Brubacher, J. S. (1947). A history of the problems of education. New York and
London: McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc.
Charlesworth, R. (1997). Mathematics in the Developmentally Appropriate Integrated
Curriculum. In Craig H. Hart, Diane C. Burts, and Rosalind Charlesworth
(Eds.) Integrated curriculum and developmentally appropriate practice: Birth
to age eight. N. Y.: State University of New York Press.
Clinton, H. R. (1996). It takes a village and other lessons that children teach us. New
York: Simon and Schuster Paperbacks.
Curtis, D., & Carter, M. (1996). Reflecting children’s lives: A handbook for planning
73
Greg Tabios Pawilen
Jaeson P. Arre, Eloida F. Lindo
-
child centered curriculum. Saint Paul, MN: Redleaf Press.
Drake,S.M. (1998). Creating integrated curriculum: Proven ways to increase learn-
ing. California, Corwin Press Inc.
Erickson, H.L. (2001). Stirring the head, heart, and soul: Redefining curriculum and
instruction. 2nd. Ed. Thousand Oaks, California: Corwin Press Inc.
Erickson, H.L. (1998). Concept-based curriculum and instruction. Teaching beyond
the facts. Thousand Oaks, California: Corwin Press, INC.
Fogarty,R. (1993). Integrating the curricula: A collection. Illinois: IRI/Sky Light
Training Publishing, Inc.
Gardner, H. (2000). The disciplined mind: Beyond facts and standardized tests, the K
-12 education that every child deserves. Cambridge, MA: Penguin Books.
Kellough, R.D. (1996). Integrating mathematics and science for kindergarten and
primary children. N.J. Prentice-Hall.
Lind,K. A. (1997). Science in the Developmentally Appropriate Integrated Curri-
culum. In Craig H. Hart, Diane C. Burts, and Rosalind Charlesworth (Eds.)
Integrated curriculum and developmentally appropriate practice: Birth to age
eight. N. Y.: State University of New York Press.
Martinello, M., Cook, G.E. (1994). Interdisciplinary inquiry in teaching and
learning. New York: Macmillan.
Nagel N. G. (1996) Learning through real world problem solving: the power of
integrative teaching, California, Corwin Press Inc.
NAEYC (2005). Curriculum: A guide to the NAEYC early childhood program
standard and related accreditation criteria. Washington D.C.: National
Association for the Education of Young Children.
O’Connell, J. (2006). Why quality preschool matters. Retrieved February 14, 2006,
from http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2006/02/13/EDGTHH6IF21.
DTL
Print, M. (1993). Curriculum development and design. 2nd.
Ed
. New South Wales:
74
Designing an Integrated Curriculum for Preschool
75